Why did Khidr kill a child? Surah Kahf
Vložit
- čas přidán 21. 07. 2024
- #ASSIMALHAKEEM #JAL #ASKZAD
00:00 Intro & Ques
00:24 Dhul Khidr Actions with Musa
02:48 Answer
03:50 The Danger of "What if"
__________________________________________
Knowledge Base:
▶️assimalhakeem.freshdesk.com
__________________________________________
Need LIVE Counseling with Sheikh Assim?:
▶️www.assimalhakeem.net/announc...
▶️www.paypal.com/paypalme/assim...
___________________________________________
Do you have a question:
▶️www.assimalhakeem.net/ask-a-q...
___________________________________________
New FB Page:
▶️ / assimalhakeemar
___________________________________________
Ask Zad Zoom Link (Sat after Maghrib & Sun after Asr):
▶️bit.ly/3fqWKKI
___________________________________________
Allah does whatever He wills! So who are we to question why Allah did this why Allah did that?!
If we are to be questioned by Allah for our deeds we would wish that we were dust!!
We really need to realise it is ALLAH we are questioning. Not our parents or siblings!!!! And we dont have that right. Allah says in the Qur'an that He cannot be questioned, but He will question His creation. Sometimes we really do forget our place!
Jazak Allahu khairan sheikh for explaining this.
Sura Al Kahf is one of the most amazing Suras. Read tafseer of it and be amazed
Which tafseer?
Convincing my heart to take a strong grip of belief on predestination sometimes seems to be one of the toughest jobs, sort of a jihad within itself.
Allāh is Al-Hakeem, The Most Wise, The Most Merciful, The Most Just.
Allāh has Decreed that every soul shall taste death. Allāh Took the life of this boy in this manner because of His Divine Wisdom which He Alone Knows the wisdom of it in Perfection.
This is like when the Angels questioned Allāh about the creation of Adam because they didn't grasp the wisdom Placed behind the creation of Adam.
So when we can't comprehend the wisdom Placed behind Allāh, then we're at fault and Allāh is The Most-Wise.
absolutely, raking your brain trying to understand predestination will only take you down a loophole of questions which we ultimately will never know the answer to - there is beauty in not knowing why Allah has chosen to do things, that knowledge is with Him and it is He who knows best. We as humans can only extract information from our biased and subjective point of view. May Allah keep us steadfast in His deen
One may ask, "Allah could have done something else!" Nauzubillah.
Now this is problematic, because that person will ultimately end up asking, "why did Allah create evil in the first place?" SubhanAllah!
See where the problem is?
Allah is the ultimate decider of everything that will ever happen. It is He who decides how they will happen.
Just read surah al kahf. Alhamdulillah.
Also one thing I would like to say is that the kid that was saved by being killed because children go to jannah when dead , other wise if he grew up he would be bad person and be in hell. Allah gave khidr(as) that knowledge about future . we dont have that knowledge , we cant kill/hurt random people because we think they will do bad before they actually do it.
Don't turn off comment section
thank you for clarifying, I had similar thinking
Masshalah it’s a great video
May Allah save us from sins AMEEN and forgive us our sins .
Allah Hu Akbar. Allah knows best.
This is a common thought problem that every human has when it comes to Allah. If you think about the basis of this however you will realise that a human being with severely limited knowledge is questioning the creator of all who has unbound knowledge. There is an ignorance and arrogance to have these thoughts - both of which come from the whispers of shaytan who have these traits. The ignorance is of not knowing your Lord, the arrogance is of thinking you know best when you know nothing. Once you remember again who and what Allah is, it will be easier to understand these stories.
but Allah doesn't judge anyone until they've the wrong deed, then why did he kill the child if he didn't commit the sin yet ? i am confused
Read surah khaf and you will understand allah took the boys life early in his life as he knew that this boy was going to cause a lot of harm in the future even to his parents
What but? Listen to the video properly.
Allah what that boy was gonna do so he ordered him to kill to boy. If ur about to do something bad but u don't allah knew at the end of the day u wouldn't do it so he will let go of u but. In other case
Allah knows best maybe that boy could have been worse than pharo allah knew that boy was up to no good if he wouldn't have been killed he could have done something unimaginable.
It's up to Allah swt these thoughts are from Satan putting dought to question why
Be careful ☝️
Very interesting but I’ve heard of the story before and it’s a very interesting story but I don’t really get with the moral of the story is and what the lesson is behind it can someone please explain thanks
actually for the child, i say he got a better place where he is with Ibrahim pbuh. So I say he is in a better place. و الله اعلم
Submit to Allah
Assalamu alaykum sheikh, I think that you wanted to say "he destroyed the wall" not "fixed the wall", a tongue slip. Baraka allahu fikum
You're wrong brother, Khidr fixed the wall that was about to collapse, and Musa (pbuh) asked him that he could have taken a payment from the villagers for this act (I was reading Sura Kahf with translation just yesterday on a flight so this is still fresh in my mind 😊)
Assalamu alaikum warahmatullaahi wabarakaatuhu,
He fixed the wall not destroyed it,so that the treasur beneath the area of that wall can be found by the children of that mentioned(pious person) later (whenever ALLAH wanted).
Assalamu alaikum warahmatullaahi wabarakaatuhu