Raghuram Rajan: How markets and the state leave the community behind

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 28. 08. 2024
  • Raghuram Rajan, professor of finance at the University of Chicago, a former chief economist at the International Monetary Fund and the former governor of the Reserve Bank of India, outlined the argument of his new book “The Third Pillar: How Markets and the State Leave the Community Behind” at the Hutchins Center on Fiscal & Monetary Policy at Brookings on February 27, 2019.
    www.brookings.... (transcript available)
    Subscribe! www.youtube.com...
    Follow Brookings on social media!
    Facebook: / brookings
    Twitter: / brookingsinst
    Instagram: / brookingsinst
    LinkedIn: / the-brookings-institution

Komentáře • 101

  • @stephaniehale946
    @stephaniehale946 Před 5 lety +108

    *One of the brightest minds in the world economics.*

    • @arjunriddle
      @arjunriddle Před 5 lety +2

      LOL. His knowledge is very limited. He knows nothing about economics

    • @stephaniehale946
      @stephaniehale946 Před 5 lety +40

      @@arjunriddle Of course, his knowledge is very limited. But still he was the Chief Economist at the IMF and current professor at the University of Chicago, one of the best business schools in the world, and was the chief of the central banking authority in India, all this despite having a limited knowledge. Not to mention, he has authored numerous books, so the publishers keep on paying him millions to write books although his knowledge is limited. You are very right, brother! Hopefully, you will be able to achieve 10% of what Dr. Rajan has achieved in his life.

    • @dev9077
      @dev9077 Před 5 lety +4

      William Hale And also among the first economists to predict a forthcoming sub prime crisis in 2005.

    • @vikas426
      @vikas426 Před 5 lety +1

      @@stephaniehale946 Well U answered it very very well

    • @aashitrajopdhya2514
      @aashitrajopdhya2514 Před 5 lety

      Can u explain 5:10 abt free competitive mkts if u r from chicago thats all u need? Didn't get the context. .😓

  • @palaksharma5078
    @palaksharma5078 Před 5 lety +32

    I was at this talk, and was blown away at how humble and kind he is, he spoke to me, made jokes, and was gracious enough to take a picture too. 🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽 1:09:18

    • @Rightlime7923
      @Rightlime7923 Před 5 lety +2

      Try to ask good questions

    • @rinoyinnocent4389
      @rinoyinnocent4389 Před 4 lety

      Good to see u here mam..

    • @SachiMohanty
      @SachiMohanty Před 3 lety

      Where was this discussion? Washington, D.C.?

    • @Ann-ut6jv
      @Ann-ut6jv Před rokem

      It seems he kept fumbling for a pen when you asked your question, and even after he found a pen he didn't answer you?

  • @ManikandanS-zn1qv
    @ManikandanS-zn1qv Před 5 lety +13

    Omg this guy is genius. He understand the middle class problem. He actually speak for people and ask government to deal with fixing people's problem in wayyyyyyyy economic way.... Really like you sir.

  • @abhinav.mishra17
    @abhinav.mishra17 Před 5 lety +12

    He simplifies economics to the level of a commoner very well. India misses you. Thanks Mr. Rajan!

  • @tomthounaojam345
    @tomthounaojam345 Před 5 lety +24

    One of the best RBI governors we had, wish he had longer term.

    • @vikramrazdan5680
      @vikramrazdan5680 Před 5 lety +2

      He was the best among other RBI Governors when he was hired, but the worst when he left the job in 2016; the bloody fool kept on increasing interest rates to control inflation without realising that 80% of India's economy is in the informal sector which is unregulated.

    • @MegaLeoben
      @MegaLeoben Před 3 lety +1

      The bhakts chased him away

    • @MegaLeoben
      @MegaLeoben Před 3 lety

      @@vikramrazdan5680 you don’t understand inflation.

    • @vikramrazdan5680
      @vikramrazdan5680 Před 3 lety

      @@MegaLeoben - Rajan had no previous experience in Central Banking ops, and thus he resorted to 'theoretical analysis' on 'incomplete data' given that only 20% of the India's economy is formal for which data is validated. Hero worshipping and blind faith is a problem with teenagers and half-baked cookies. I know quite a bit about Inflation and Money Supply (M1, M2, M3)/ Central Bank monetary policy in Western Economies as well as Developing Economies.

  • @anupsingh-qv3nw
    @anupsingh-qv3nw Před 5 lety +7

    what a genius prof.raghu is,we indians are so proud of him & i am angry on the political ldrs. who did't allow him to reform & improve things around in our country but hopefully he may come back as soon as we hv a change of gov. on may23- 2019.He has explained everything so clearly in his forewords which makes him the darling of the crowd/intellectuals who benefit from his enlightening discourses.good luck to him & looking forward to his return back to india.jai hind(1947 wala)

    • @gustofzephyr947
      @gustofzephyr947 Před 5 lety +2

      Hahaha there is no way Congress will reinstall him. Unlike Manmohan Singh, Rajan cannot be controlled and that instantly disqualifies him.

  • @sujeettharma565
    @sujeettharma565 Před 5 lety +10

    he is true , speaker

  • @luffy-vv8jp
    @luffy-vv8jp Před 3 lety +1

    🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥wao I m falling in love with india

  • @bijut3035
    @bijut3035 Před 5 lety +1

    Love to hear him. Thinks about in totality.

  • @mohankalagara1074
    @mohankalagara1074 Před 5 lety +6

    Good intro .

  • @gautamkhandelwalgk6690
    @gautamkhandelwalgk6690 Před 5 lety +2

    Will become an important book.

  • @rukminireddy921
    @rukminireddy921 Před 3 lety

    Excellent idea and presentation
    Jmreddy

  • @TTT-uk3cn
    @TTT-uk3cn Před rokem

    Why none of media asking Rajan questions on Congress conspiracy to throw in fake currency in Indian economy via UK and Pakistan? That led to demonetisation. P. Chidambaram is under scrutiny and his finance secretary is already in custody.

  • @pkswain1759
    @pkswain1759 Před 5 lety +4

    Like technological innovations, economics theories is also evolving. Raghu is backing old school of thoughts like Neoclassical and Austrian. Capitalist society creates income disparity; communism and socialist economy discourage economy to grow faster.

    • @rudranarayan6053
      @rudranarayan6053 Před 5 lety +4

      After saying this I wish to know more about ur views

  • @virnamisra1657
    @virnamisra1657 Před 2 lety

    Lock on the Bath pun Room door. Why didn't it occur? No suggesters ? Why?

  • @MrUdayNarainPandeySharadNPande

    The Stone Cuttttttttttttttttttttttttt

  • @anandkapdi4822
    @anandkapdi4822 Před 5 lety

    44:10 Which author he is talking about. I am not able to hear it properly. Plz help.

    • @sabyasachisenapati3619
      @sabyasachisenapati3619 Před 5 lety +1

      Ross Douthat , Reihan Salam Grand New Party: How Republicans Can Win the Working Class and Save the American Dream

  • @charlespatterson8412
    @charlespatterson8412 Před 5 lety +4

    I no longer attempt to communicate on this channel because I have never seen a sign of response. It is for my pleasure alone. I still don't have to pretend I like it...

  • @virnamisra1657
    @virnamisra1657 Před 3 lety

    Whale coastal areas. do they give you a high. a time to remember

  • @virnamisra1657
    @virnamisra1657 Před rokem

    How Ma ( ushabehn Virnabehn 105 )}}}. are left behind by the state sordids as well as the other word Good or Bad you said. You said it

  • @virnamisra1657
    @virnamisra1657 Před 3 lety

    Engine after 2 bogeys disentangles & an engin seeti maarey arrives at seitasitapuram & links one from front one bogey off & engin reinstated 355555. goes as per 7 min past one. ....~~~~~~~~✓

  • @virnamisra1657
    @virnamisra1657 Před 2 lety

    What do you do when diseased civil cements crop up in between some peelpaint but jack stone built buildings and like you remember the country turns both eyes blind. ?

  • @MrUdayNarainPandeySharadNPande

    Why no IIM Delhi found instantly on the web world.

  • @shankarvk922
    @shankarvk922 Před 5 lety +1

    In 1995, S Gurumurthy already wrote a seminal piece on community based developmental model, focusing on industrial clusters..

    • @shankarvk922
      @shankarvk922 Před 5 lety

      @Sourabh Mittal here is an article link. www.thehindubusinessline.com/opinion/caste-as-social-capital/article22995911.ece. Harish Damodaran has wriiten a book on this subject. Check on Amazon

    • @sriwru
      @sriwru Před 5 lety +1

      community based development is far away from industrial clusters ..

    • @kalyaninutopia
      @kalyaninutopia Před 5 lety

      Gurumurthy's piece is not seminal neither did he focus on industrial clusters. Read the link that you have shared thoroughly.

    • @sriwru
      @sriwru Před 5 lety

      Why waste reading something that idot wrote .. Worth illa ..

    • @kalyaninutopia
      @kalyaninutopia Před 5 lety +1

      I asked Mr. Shankar to at least read the article thoroughly before claiming that Gurumurthy wrote about industrial clusters. Neither Gurumurthy nor Mr. Shankar seems to understand what industrial clusters are. Moreover, the article is outdated and hence infactual. According to the NSSO 2011-12 data, relative share of ownership of establishments: ST 0.5, SC 0.6, OBC 0.9, General castes 1.8. So, Gurumurthy's argument falls flat. @@sriwru

  • @virnamisra1657
    @virnamisra1657 Před 3 lety

    Community chest. Delve deeper in that detail

  • @tamilkalavai
    @tamilkalavai Před 3 lety

    A lady who make lemon pickle calls him a worst economist
    Damn it.....

  • @virnamisra1657
    @virnamisra1657 Před rokem

    In 3-20 seconds. Oint 1) look at who all are participating and why who !? Aren't 2) oint oink pink 2 .. you fill in

  • @virnamisra1657
    @virnamisra1657 Před 3 lety

    You who don't prohibit & the country whose people fail to......

  • @virnamisra1657
    @virnamisra1657 Před rokem

    Angle of inclusion. Between removal of the portrait at odeon and the obtuse a la asterisk

  • @virnamisra1657
    @virnamisra1657 Před 3 lety

    These are for the rajdhani newpicnic come along

  • @virnamisra1657
    @virnamisra1657 Před 3 lety

    Comment 65.. affirmation de royale..de Parisian. Sermon e amigos

  • @virnamisra1657
    @virnamisra1657 Před 3 lety

    Lowly doesn't require you to diagnose. our country & profession is tendential .... however didn't fight on that

  • @virnamisra1657
    @virnamisra1657 Před 3 lety

    32?

  • @tarang926
    @tarang926 Před 5 lety

    1:06:15

  • @MrUdayNarainPandeySharadNPande

    Call 📞 edge. Did ya say ?

  • @lively196
    @lively196 Před 5 lety

    Whenever we distract from our way ,simple way to get on your way again ,just back to basic ......every one need to use you. but no body wants you get benefited from it...only decentralize will be the way to make each one on single platform and with each other engagement we all grow ,not only the human but also our surrounding community.

  • @virnamisra1657
    @virnamisra1657 Před 2 lety

    Revival of histories and geographies like crossing the T s ( la Espania. & Dotting ( Kim s Empire. Pun the I s

  • @EDmobile
    @EDmobile Před 5 lety +2

    Sorry, Raju. Too old school theoretical and simplistic and prescriptive. That’s not how the world evolves. It’s even disobedient to everything you said. Most important of all, you completely missed the impact of the networked economy.

  • @MrUdayNarainPandeySharadNPande

    The entire ....

  • @virnamisra1657
    @virnamisra1657 Před 3 lety

    How bout sharing/ sorting a few venues like this your place & / or sweedish house & lots few more & bring in fed exchange chief & you guys & few many others out of their circles & keep going on. but first graph extrapolating the sultry circulars. if you know what I err

  • @virnamisra1657
    @virnamisra1657 Před 3 lety

    BOB 2 15 2. Robert"""""" Robert """"". Milan

  • @MrUdayNarainPandeySharadNPande

    Swiss or Otherwise Conspiracy. Smile

  • @Geopoliticus
    @Geopoliticus Před 5 lety +1

    I’m sorry but this book is intellectually lazy. Rajan’s analysis of the interaction between state-society-markets is inherently problematic: the historical analysis is limited to Western Europe, completely ignores the mercantilism, commercial interactions btw European, Asian and African communities from the 16th century onward.
    The three pillars operate differently in different regions in different times. You cannot generalise for the entire world on the basis of a limited reading of history. It’s surprising that an Asian scholar is so blindly Eurocentric.

    • @Geopoliticus
      @Geopoliticus Před 5 lety

      SheStillRuns Did you watch the talk? His three pillars thesis is based on the analysis of middle age Europe. No issue with that. But, the 16th century is the beginning of the modern international system - which persists till, well, contemporary times.

  • @nandakumar1780
    @nandakumar1780 Před 3 lety

    Oold culture was manually maintain of domestic every day's " Naw skills with electrical powers.

  • @virnamisra1657
    @virnamisra1657 Před 3 lety

    Baden Baden English. &. Some delicacies. in. Fondue

  • @charlespatterson8412
    @charlespatterson8412 Před 5 lety +6

    Vapid. Is this the best you can do? No need to answer...

  • @virnamisra1657
    @virnamisra1657 Před 3 lety

    Chameleon tracks o train

  • @gomachanLovely
    @gomachanLovely Před 2 lety

    全然オーダー来ねえーじゃん

  • @MrUdayNarainPandeySharadNPande

    When we shall entertain the Captains Guests with the education scholarships cottages studies dollars purse 👛 from all then we shall re allow with hyphens Raghuram s this above lecture without his it of course

  • @virnamisra1657
    @virnamisra1657 Před 3 lety

    Dzire & self selection denied yet carrying on Alzheimer's except if X is Max. & Ex f fact. correct or

  • @virnamisra1657
    @virnamisra1657 Před 2 lety

    Party 21/10/06 punjabbbi bagh club o what? Nag 🐍 family non ppearance reason non edu wife. KVK

  • @MrUdayNarainPandeySharadNPande

    No female questioners esp here

  • @virnamisra1657
    @virnamisra1657 Před 2 lety

    Bath pun room dues. Expand & Reimburse dear. 🦌

  • @virnamisra1657
    @virnamisra1657 Před 3 lety

    Main kyon Mar Gaya?????

  • @virnamisra1657
    @virnamisra1657 Před 2 lety

    ४८

  • @jayasundar7882
    @jayasundar7882 Před 4 lety

    P8j

  • @virnamisra1657
    @virnamisra1657 Před 3 lety

    F T L 25

  • @vikramrazdan5680
    @vikramrazdan5680 Před 5 lety +1

    Raghuram Rajan is living in the past, just like Gurumurthy whose theory applies to the informal sector in India where money supply and credit are unregulated; in the West the community theory is not longer valid, where the growth of new virtual communities and their influence on the monetary system needs to be studied and discussed.