OK, but this is a m o v i e, they just need to be actors who can also sing. They don't need to be theater actors or have any experience with theater. This movie is its own thin separate from the musical.
@@desflores4463 the issue is they aren’t actors who can sing. Cady is really quite terrible in most of her songs, and that’s with a full recording studio making her sound her best. There’s a reason why Renee Rapp, Jaquel Spivey, and Auli’i Cravalho are all standouts in the film.
@@desflores4463 tell me how this makes sense at all bro. they arent separate at all 😭 the movie is literally based on the musical. they said “oh why dont we turn the mean girls musical into a movie!!” and then they did it and i get that a movie and a theater are different, but if youre going to make a beloved musical into a movie, at least make it,, good,, like, OF COURSE people dont like it. this movie didnt do mean girls the musical justice and people are definitely allowed to be upset about that
It's because that's how a homeschooled would sing. It's captured the soul. The songs in the movie are more enjoyable because it's like pop song. Not your typical Broadway songs.
@@madison.0429 ivy actually listened the Broadway version of I See Stars and I didn't like it much. I love the movie version. I also really Iove all Renee's performance in this.
@@davidariyan7915the Broadway versions are a million times better, even most of the songs they cut. i don’t like Whose House Is This or Do This Thing but even these are better than the dullification of Stupid With Love in the movie. Broadway Cady actually sounds like she’s in love with Aaron compared to 2024 movie Cady who sounds like she thinks Aaron is cute but isn’t filled with calcu-lust like she says she is.
i havent watched the movie out of fear, but im curious how they made the “does this guy work out? he must! all hot and sweaty at the gym” line land with such a,, somber song 😭
poor cady to be honest. she gets tons of hate when she was told to do this, she most likely didn’t have a say. i obviously agree that the broadway version is better
@@notCinnamonrollit’s not that she can’t sing like she has a pretty soft voice but like compare to everyone else yeah I can see why you say she can’t sing
I listed to both versions of stupid with love and apex predator and in both cases the versions from the movie are better than the musical theather versions.
@@yomilala8929WHAAAAAT?? I get having different opinions but there’s a lot of things that make the Broadway better imo (Better singers, instrumentals, and acting)
@@themysticsomeone2089 The acting in broadway is too exaggerated (because, of course, it's theater) The voices in the Broadway musical are too loud and not very pleasing. The rhythm in the movie's songs was better
@@yomilala8929 it’s over exaggerated because it’s infront of an audience who can’t see them closely. And the reason they’re loud is because their vocal technique is REALLY good and allows them to belt. Unlike the movie where Cady can’t even sing a simple melody in Revenge Party without shouting. You don’t seem to even know basic music theory (not to be rude, not everyone’s forfeit)
tbh, the 2024 movie rushed the entire storyline. they left out a ton of bangers (where do you belong., stop, whose house is this, etc.) and as for the songs they did include, they rushed those too. stupid with love had like zero emotion. also it's really sad that they cut kevin g's whole personality :(
Can I just say that having “It Roars” would have been so much better than “What Ifs”. Cady’s character in this is so… cleaned up. Like, what happened to quirky Cady who’s not dumb, just hasn’t been in society. Like… what?!?
@@AlexeBriand2002What ifs IMO detracts from the story. Cady is much more open to adventure and exploration in the musical which It Roars showcases. What ifs feels way too lovey dovey and plays up too much into Cadys naivety, it just makes her look more clueless and dumbbed down
Fr it should have been the song where candy goes “I can’t even watch when she touches his hair and I’ve watched a snake eat a cow” when her face is super close to the camera like running through the halls 😭
I’m gonna agree with you on that, but also listen to the broadway version. That one brings me to tears, maybe that has something to do with the fact that our school just finished with our mean girls musical and I’m fighting the post show blues, but if they made it as close to the broadway version as possible, at least with this song that would be a best case scenario!
I think I’d like what ifs if I just heard it completely separate from this. Ngl its a catchy song and Cady’s actor isn’t struggling as much with this one. However, if you know the musical and It Roars, What Ifs is a major let down. Cady’s Broadway actor is an incredibly talented vocalist, which really rubs salt in the wound when hearing this movie’s typical pop song replacement. My guess is they changed the song because Cady’s remake actor just can’t do that (or far less than that tbh. Look how they massacred my boy 😢). It’s just so dull, even if it’s just compared to other songs in the movie that are so much more alive (despite being stripped down for some reason???)
im sorry but i dont like the choice of casting angourie rice as cady. there were better actors imo and she just didnt bring the same energy that lindsey lohan and erika henningsen brought in the og movie and musical
Yeah, I mean she did the whole awkward homeschooled girl thing pretty well but towards the end she wasn’t a very believable “mean girl” her vocals also sounded flat the entire movie
I’m so sad that this is what people think of when they hear Mean Girls the Musical and not the broadway version. I also don’t like how much auto tune they put on Damien
I miss the old I see stars there was so much emotion and impact in it. This one isn’t bad by any means if you don’t know the original. But the thing with the original is the moment “Cheap fake” comes out you know it’s gonna be a good time
I usually don’t comment on stuff, but I felt the need. Cautionary Tale and What’s Wrong With Me are BEAUTIFUL songs. I don’t even mind Angourie as a singer, but I totally understand why she is on this list. Cautionary Tale is only on here because the creator has a clear Renee Rapp bias and Cautionary Tale is the shortest song. Yet Jaquel and Aulii do really well!!! However I have a bone to pick with whoever decided What’s Wrong with Me should be on here. That song is PHENOMENAL and in my opinion the best song of the show. Feel free to disagree but Bebe Wood really put more emotion into the song than Renee did in World Burn and Someone gets Hurt (and I’m a hardcore Renee STAN). Do with this as you will, but how about we just don’t hate on songs for clout?? Just my hot take 🤷🏻♀️
I totally agree with everything you said! However, I don’t think I could ever say “what’s wrong with me” is the best just because of the sheer masterpieces that are “Someone gets hurt” and “World Burn”. They build so perfectly, and the vocal prowess it takes to sing that songs just puts them in a class of their own in my opinion. “What’s wrong with me” is extremely heart felt. However, for me when it comes all the facets of a great song then the icing on the cake being one of the best singers of our generation singing her entire face off on both songs puts in the top for me! I think being a voice teacher makes just appreciate everything Renee does! Also, AULI ATE! I don’t know why the heck she is on here! I agree, there was some bias showing lol.
@@jacobmccain8794 ok but hear me out, I'd rather be me (movie version) deserves to be in this list. I don't know why but it feels sooo plain and boring in the movie
its gut wrenching to see them cut out amazing songs, and butcher the iconic ones. stop, what’s wrong with me reprise, it roars, more is better, where do you belong. i NEEDED those and i was let down 👎👎
The movie sounds like all of the characters are depressed and unexcited. They dulled down Cady especially, but really all of the Mean Girls personalities were more excited and just seemed more like teens in the musical. Also before people say "well the musical wasn't enjoyable, it was too loud/annoying/exaggerated" okay? You don't have to like everything. The Broadway style isn't for everybody. However in the Broadway musical the technique and execution was much better. That is a fact. Another fact is that you don't need to like the one with better technique, just don't deny that it's true. Also all of the is MY OWN OPINION. (Besides of course the technique and execution part)
All the love in the world to her, and her acting was great in the movie, but she’s pretty clearly not a singer. Her songs were by far the weakest, which is a shame considering that both Bebe (Gretchen) and Avantika (Karen) are fantastic singers who lost most of their singing roles in the movie.
@@josephsherby at least she didn't miss a note. That's good. I hate some people who said she can't sing and even compared her performance to Emma Watson's. She clearly did good to those songs. Maybe something's wrong with their ears.
@@goat.cheese_ and you think you can sing better than her? Go make a cover of them and post it. You can't say someone is bad singer unless they missing a note.
You do NOT get to have an opinion on the songs in the new mean girls movie unless you’ve seen/listened to the actual mean girls musical Edit: Ok I phrased this pretty weirdly at first, what I mean is you shouldn’t criticize the songs in the musical overall if you’ve only listened to the songs in the movie
@@serenitysubs933 what? Stop using the term gatekeeping when someone says you don’t get an opinion on the songs in the movie? The songs in the movie are extremely different from the ones in the musical, so it’s valid to “have a say” on them. THAT’S how it’s gatekeeping. It’s gatekeeping people’s opinions to a damn song. Your point makes no sense.
Hear me out, revenge party (THE ORIGINAL broadway song) was king of bad bcz of cady, like she did NOT bring the anger in her voice when it came to getting the revenege.
Okay, people need to understand that they didn't want to make it exactly like the broadway version because I feel like it would be kind of boring if it was just the same thing over and over again they wanted to bring another branch of similarities and differences to the mean girls franchise. Some people talk about Cady and how her range wasn't very big or whatever. First of all she is Australian and second maybe that's how the directors wanted it to be so don't just hate on her if you don't like it. I personally liked it but cause I try not to compare it to the broadway or original movie and just try to think of it as it's own thing. Thank you
Whats wrong with me is fine song in the movie! 😡😡 No comparisons with Broadway, ok? I love the music box effect and the actress's voice is very gentle! She played Gretchen well. Undeservedly included in this top!
@@goat.cheese_ this is a movie remake with elements added from the Broadway show. They have to make changes. Like made the songs more pop or enjoyable and relatable. So regular film audience could enjoy. Because I'm enjoying watching movies but I didn't enjoy the Broadway version of the songs.
I hate what they did with the music. Stupid With Love's beat sounded like diss track, and it sounded so accapella and modernized. It was almost like they were ashamed of it being a musical. Idek how you go so wrong with something.
Basically all the songs wigh cady like the actress was not cut out for the role. I don't really see her emotions or I don't hear them, I mean she may be a great actress, but not for this movie.
“What’s Wrong With Me?” is so deep and just hits on another level. There is no way that it is on this list. You either didn’t get the songs meaning, or ur heartless(not trying to be rude I’m just really upset)
Ok 'a cautionary tale is so amazing because both of their voice blend so well together that makes the song sound incredible- but since you put that song in 5th for worst mean girl songs i cannot live anymore
All I know is Gretchen’s character really ate up those vocals on “what’s wrong with me! Also, why is “A Cautionary Tale” there? That song is such a bop and she sings the heck out of it!
Them using tiktok as a format is gonna make this movie outdated so much more quickly. That was why the original movie didn't use any actual slang and limited the use of cell phones. To make it timeless!
I agree with the top 3, whats wrong with me was lowkey so good and personally I feel like showed how Gretchen truly felt and cautionary tale IS a BANGER
well if they kept them closer to the broadway version it'd be better (ex. stupid with love)
thank you!
No thank you. This is not your regular Broadway show. This how the songs will played in movie. I think they did great with I Seen Stars.
This comment is so real
@@davidariyan7915the song lyrics were great but the singer wasnt
@@madison.0429 she's not an artist/ singer before. I think she nailed it. Cady would sing like this
Villains' Songs>>>Protagonists' Songs
Realest thing I’ve seen today
Agreed
💯
honestly tho
COURTNEY PFP ❤
How dare you, a cautionary tale is a banger
Ikr
Fr. It’s good
Right!
Fr 😭😭
Ik😭😭
Just remember NONE of these guys have theater experience besides Renée Rapp so don't blame them for these songs. That's on the music department
OK, but this is a m o v i e, they just need to be actors who can also sing. They don't need to be theater actors or have any experience with theater. This movie is its own thin separate from the musical.
Can’t forget Thr good actor for Moana. That played Janice as well as the person who played Damian they were both in Brodway / in theater
@@desflores4463 the issue is they aren’t actors who can sing. Cady is really quite terrible in most of her songs, and that’s with a full recording studio making her sound her best. There’s a reason why Renee Rapp, Jaquel Spivey, and Auli’i Cravalho are all standouts in the film.
@@desflores4463 bro the musical itself isnt even its own thing, tf you mean 🤣
@@desflores4463 tell me how this makes sense at all bro. they arent separate at all 😭 the movie is literally based on the musical. they said “oh why dont we turn the mean girls musical into a movie!!” and then they did it
and i get that a movie and a theater are different, but if youre going to make a beloved musical into a movie, at least make it,, good,,
like, OF COURSE people dont like it. this movie didnt do mean girls the musical justice and people are definitely allowed to be upset about that
theres no WAY you put cautionary tale on there
AGREED
It’s my favorite song from the album
Yess
There’s WAY
AGREED
I love how the very worst songs are cady's, but A Cautionary Tale does not belong there.
edit: OMG 6K LIKES WTF
Im so confused why they hired this person for Cady… no hate to her but… she should not be in a musical lol
@@simpforsupersoldiers because it is a paramount movie I think. And she acts on most paramount movies. But props bc she australian.
Totally
@@MXGHZIE ohhhh that makes sense
Frrr Auli'i and Jaquel were amazing in this movie, 100x better than Cady, a cautionary tale is great
“Where people *die* 👹
“NO ONE DIES”!
Timestamp?
@@FxiryAddison13you can’t put time stamps on shorts
@@FxiryAddison13 it was at like 14 seconds
A CAUTIONARY TALE IS SOO GOOD THO-
fr
facts
Fr
They absolutely ruined stupid with love in the movie. The broadway musical version of stupid with love is so much better
It's because that's how a homeschooled would sing. It's captured the soul. The songs in the movie are more enjoyable because it's like pop song. Not your typical Broadway songs.
@@davidariyan7915yes…enjoyable. im taking it you havent listened to the broadway songs
@@madison.0429 ivy actually listened the Broadway version of I See Stars and I didn't like it much. I love the movie version. I also really Iove all Renee's performance in this.
@@madison.0429 I even cried during the ending of this movie since where the bridge part came out.
@@davidariyan7915the Broadway versions are a million times better, even most of the songs they cut. i don’t like Whose House Is This or Do This Thing but even these are better than the dullification of Stupid With Love in the movie. Broadway Cady actually sounds like she’s in love with Aaron compared to 2024 movie Cady who sounds like she thinks Aaron is cute but isn’t filled with calcu-lust like she says she is.
there’s no way you put what’s wrong with me on there
I know so rude
I know
There’s way
The song is mid
@@ayasukityeah that’s true
Stupid with love❌
Stoopoo with love✅
I just noticed that😭
stupid with love is so good when you listen to the broadway version, the movie really took away all the energy and things that made it so good.
i havent watched the movie out of fear, but im curious how they made the “does this guy work out? he must! all hot and sweaty at the gym” line land with such a,, somber song 😭
poor cady to be honest. she gets tons of hate when she was told to do this, she most likely didn’t have a say. i obviously agree that the broadway version is better
She can't sing 🤷♂️
@@notCinnamonrollit’s not that she can’t sing like she has a pretty soft voice but like compare to everyone else yeah I can see why you say she can’t sing
i mean yeah vocal wise she's incomparable to renee and aulii, even avantika sounds better than her
@@kenasiafriesonagreed.
@@kenasiafriesonbut no matter what she still can’t sing well enough to be the lead in a musical
The songs were so good in the musical, but they changed them to be more ‘Spotify friendly’. As if my whole playlist isn’t musical theatre.😭😭
I listed to both versions of stupid with love and apex predator and in both cases the versions from the movie are better than the musical theather versions.
@@yomilala8929WHAAAAAT?? I get having different opinions but there’s a lot of things that make the Broadway better imo (Better singers, instrumentals, and acting)
@@themysticsomeone2089 The acting in broadway is too exaggerated (because, of course, it's theater)
The voices in the Broadway musical are too loud and not very pleasing.
The rhythm in the movie's songs was better
@@yomilala8929 it’s over exaggerated because it’s infront of an audience who can’t see them closely. And the reason they’re loud is because their vocal technique is REALLY good and allows them to belt. Unlike the movie where Cady can’t even sing a simple melody in Revenge Party without shouting.
You don’t seem to even know basic music theory (not to be rude, not everyone’s forfeit)
Hairspray (2007) was more pop inspired versus Broadway, but the music was still pleasant on the ears.
there's absolutely no way whats wrong with me and a cautionary tale is on there
tbh, the 2024 movie rushed the entire storyline. they left out a ton of bangers (where do you belong., stop, whose house is this, etc.) and as for the songs they did include, they rushed those too. stupid with love had like zero emotion. also it's really sad that they cut kevin g's whole personality :(
Can I just say that having “It Roars” would have been so much better than “What Ifs”. Cady’s character in this is so… cleaned up. Like, what happened to quirky Cady who’s not dumb, just hasn’t been in society. Like… what?!?
i honestly prefer What Ifs to It Roars, and It Roars wouldn’t have translated well to movie
“It Roars” is a terrible song. “What Ifs” is better Angourie just can’t sing
@@AlexeBriand2002What ifs IMO detracts from the story. Cady is much more open to adventure and exploration in the musical which It Roars showcases. What ifs feels way too lovey dovey and plays up too much into Cadys naivety, it just makes her look more clueless and dumbbed down
Not fair on Cady is it?
I love cautionary tale
What’s wrong with me is a really beautiful moment for Gretchen
It’s their opinion
@@Campbell0217their
Fr, like Gretchen is discovering herself
Holy crap I forgot she played Gretchen
@@Campbell0217their*
“Where people died!”
“No one died!”😂😂😂
my theatre kid heart breaks 💔
Cautionary Tale and What’s wrong me are too good to be on this list
I totally agree
Fr it should have been the song where candy goes “I can’t even watch when she touches his hair and I’ve watched a snake eat a cow” when her face is super close to the camera like running through the halls 😭
@@AlltooTaylor-lj2ky Revenge Party is ok, but I like cautionary tale so much better
Frrrr
Fr
putting what’s wrong with me on there is a crime
Real
It's quite bad in comparison to the original
Not putting songs of Renée Rapp This a crime
@@karenrayssa2665she arguably did the best in this.
FOR REAL THO-
If any of you reading this haven’t listened to the Broadway soundtrack, please do!! I love it 💖
no way you put what's wrong with me on here 😭
“What’s Wrong With Me?” spoke to me in so many ways.
It feels more emotional on the broadway recording
i know and its so unfair, there's not that many songs in the movie, so if they aren't on the top 5, they will be on the bottom 5.
Same, I literally cried the first time I heard it and music doesn’t make me cry often
The way my jaw dropped on “what’s wrong with Me” that’s prob one of the prettiest songs 😮
I’m gonna agree with you on that, but also listen to the broadway version. That one brings me to tears, maybe that has something to do with the fact that our school just finished with our mean girls musical and I’m fighting the post show blues, but if they made it as close to the broadway version as possible, at least with this song that would be a best case scenario!
@@jd-ks5ct no way! My school just finished our mean girls too!!! Who were you?
@@Harper.Alexis5Oh shoot, I just realized we could be from the same school 😂
I was Aaron Samuels, it was so fun 🔥
@@jd-ks5ct lmao does ur name start with an R?
like it's my favorite song on the musical
The elf in the back: 👁👄👁
“What’s wrong with me” Is here? You can’t tell me that 🎶“it’s probably me”🎶 didn’t hit! 😭😂 that note hit a satisfying nerve
What ifs is actually so good tho. Not better than it roars but deff better for the quiet and nervous yet adventurous cady that was in the 2004 version
cap
It's so good, all of them are but what ifs is just ❤
NAHHH IT WAS ASS, im not gonna lie all of her songs were, i hate cadys voice
I think I’d like what ifs if I just heard it completely separate from this. Ngl its a catchy song and Cady’s actor isn’t struggling as much with this one. However, if you know the musical and It Roars, What Ifs is a major let down. Cady’s Broadway actor is an incredibly talented vocalist, which really rubs salt in the wound when hearing this movie’s typical pop song replacement. My guess is they changed the song because Cady’s remake actor just can’t do that (or far less than that tbh. Look how they massacred my boy 😢). It’s just so dull, even if it’s just compared to other songs in the movie that are so much more alive (despite being stripped down for some reason???)
Someone agrees with me!
im sorry but i dont like the choice of casting angourie rice as cady. there were better actors imo and she just didnt bring the same energy that lindsey lohan and erika henningsen brought in the og movie and musical
Yeah, I mean she did the whole awkward homeschooled girl thing pretty well but towards the end she wasn’t a very believable “mean girl” her vocals also sounded flat the entire movie
"🎵It's a cautionary tale were people died🎵🙃" "😧No One died"
I’m so sad that this is what people think of when they hear Mean Girls the Musical and not the broadway version. I also don’t like how much auto tune they put on Damien
I miss the old I see stars there was so much emotion and impact in it. This one isn’t bad by any means if you don’t know the original. But the thing with the original is the moment “Cheap fake” comes out you know it’s gonna be a good time
I usually don’t comment on stuff, but I felt the need. Cautionary Tale and What’s Wrong With Me are BEAUTIFUL songs. I don’t even mind Angourie as a singer, but I totally understand why she is on this list. Cautionary Tale is only on here because the creator has a clear Renee Rapp bias and Cautionary Tale is the shortest song. Yet Jaquel and Aulii do really well!!! However I have a bone to pick with whoever decided What’s Wrong with Me should be on here. That song is PHENOMENAL and in my opinion the best song of the show. Feel free to disagree but Bebe Wood really put more emotion into the song than Renee did in World Burn and Someone gets Hurt (and I’m a hardcore Renee STAN). Do with this as you will, but how about we just don’t hate on songs for clout?? Just my hot take 🤷🏻♀️
I totally agree. What’s wrong with me was well executed and very heart felt to me
I totally agree with everything you said! However, I don’t think I could ever say “what’s wrong with me” is the best just because of the sheer masterpieces that are “Someone gets hurt” and “World Burn”. They build so perfectly, and the vocal prowess it takes to sing that songs just puts them in a class of their own in my opinion. “What’s wrong with me” is extremely heart felt. However, for me when it comes all the facets of a great song then the icing on the cake being one of the best singers of our generation singing her entire face off on both songs puts in the top for me! I think being a voice teacher makes just appreciate everything Renee does! Also, AULI ATE! I don’t know why the heck she is on here! I agree, there was some bias showing lol.
@@jacobmccain8794 ok but hear me out, I'd rather be me (movie version) deserves to be in this list. I don't know why but it feels sooo plain and boring in the movie
its gut wrenching to see them cut out amazing songs, and butcher the iconic ones. stop, what’s wrong with me reprise, it roars, more is better, where do you belong. i NEEDED those and i was let down 👎👎
The movie sounds like all of the characters are depressed and unexcited. They dulled down Cady especially, but really all of the Mean Girls personalities were more excited and just seemed more like teens in the musical. Also before people say "well the musical wasn't enjoyable, it was too loud/annoying/exaggerated" okay? You don't have to like everything. The Broadway style isn't for everybody. However in the Broadway musical the technique and execution was much better. That is a fact. Another fact is that you don't need to like the one with better technique, just don't deny that it's true. Also all of the is MY OWN OPINION. (Besides of course the technique and execution part)
Most of the songs are sung by Angourie Rice
The author just jealous with her
All the love in the world to her, and her acting was great in the movie, but she’s pretty clearly not a singer. Her songs were by far the weakest, which is a shame considering that both Bebe (Gretchen) and Avantika (Karen) are fantastic singers who lost most of their singing roles in the movie.
@@josephsherby at least she didn't miss a note. That's good. I hate some people who said she can't sing and even compared her performance to Emma Watson's. She clearly did good to those songs. Maybe something's wrong with their ears.
That’s because she’s a bad singer
@@goat.cheese_ and you think you can sing better than her? Go make a cover of them and post it. You can't say someone is bad singer unless they missing a note.
Okay but like the original stupid with love is so fire
especially as a duet 🤩
NO WAY "STUPID WITH LOVE" IS ON THERE. SOOOOO GOOD AND CATCHY.
There's no way you put stupid with love on there
There is absolutely nothing wrong with, “what’s wrong with me”!!!
Exactly
the full song in the Broadway show is better, but the music box version in the movie was cute
unpopular opinion but i actually liked i see stars
I agree I really love the song!
Off course especially from the bridge onwards. It made me cry
It’s a great song cool lyrics bad singer
cady singing it was only okay
I love that song!! especially from the broadway version!
Not me getting scared that apex predator is on there
Tbh I hate that ppl hate on this movie: I haven’t watched it yet but I love all the songs
You do NOT get to have an opinion on the songs in the new mean girls movie unless you’ve seen/listened to the actual mean girls musical
Edit: Ok I phrased this pretty weirdly at first, what I mean is you shouldn’t criticize the songs in the musical overall if you’ve only listened to the songs in the movie
Yes they do. Stop gatekeeping songs -_-
Plus I’ve listened to both. The ones in the movie are pure trash.
I’m saying they can’t call the songs themselves bad if they haven’t listened to the original versions because the movie ones suck
@@xxxmaysilssss690 it's called logic not gatekeeping. Stop overusing that term for anything u hate
@@serenitysubs933 what? Stop using the term gatekeeping when someone says you don’t get an opinion on the songs in the movie? The songs in the movie are extremely different from the ones in the musical, so it’s valid to “have a say” on them. THAT’S how it’s gatekeeping. It’s gatekeeping people’s opinions to a damn song. Your point makes no sense.
@@xxxmaysilssss690you can’t say a song is bad if you only listened to the meh cover and not the original.
Stop What Ifs is such a cute song
its a cute song but whoever they cast as cady just doesnt do it as well as it wouldve in broadway
Hear me out, revenge party (THE ORIGINAL broadway song) was king of bad bcz of cady, like she did NOT bring the anger in her voice when it came to getting the revenege.
I love musicals version, especially actress what played Cady, she was a lot more alive.
Okay, people need to understand that they didn't want to make it exactly like the broadway version because I feel like it would be kind of boring if it was just the same thing over and over again they wanted to bring another branch of similarities and differences to the mean girls franchise. Some people talk about Cady and how her range wasn't very big or whatever. First of all she is Australian and second maybe that's how the directors wanted it to be so don't just hate on her if you don't like it. I personally liked it but cause I try not to compare it to the broadway or original movie and just try to think of it as it's own thing.
Thank you
THANK YOUUUUU- ppl don’t understand that it’s not a remake of either the 2004 movie or the musical🥺🥺
I never was really into the first movie at first but I love musicals so after watching this I felt more open to the original
Nah you blew this list by adding Cauitonary Tale
justice for “what’s wrong with me?”
They did all the songs so dirty… the broadway version was so much better 😭
Not at all.
The songs are better in the movie.
A cautionary tale and what’s wrong with me are great but I agree with the rest. Cadys singing was horrible😭
i took whats wrong with me personaly. i sang that for a eastman school of music audition and got it.
"WhERe PpL dIED👹👹"
"no one died 😰"
I honestly felt bad for greychen in this
She did Cady dirty
Ps: all the songs are great!!!!! None are bad I don’t get this list, but that’s js my opinion
it’s Cady
@@AlexeBriand2002 sry auto correct js realized
As someone who didn’t see or listen to the Broadway version till AFTER this movie, I actually liked the movie and the songs.
This is like if you put on a high budget high school production of mean girls but tried to make it more “hip for the kids”
best songs
1. Someone gets hurt
2. I’d rather be me
3. What’s wrong with me
4. World Burn
5. Sexy
From the movie or the broadway show?
IMO I like the message of I’d rather be me, but the lyrics make me cringe
No because literally, "Someone gets hurt" is such a insanely good song
“ where people DIE.” , “ NO ONE DIE.” . 😭🤣.
Stupid with love is literally the best song in the movie
Whats wrong with me is fine song in the movie! 😡😡
No comparisons with Broadway, ok? I love the music box effect and the actress's voice is very gentle! She played Gretchen well. Undeservedly included in this top!
NAH… PLS DONT TELL ME YOU PUT BEBE ON THERE
What ifs is one of my favourites, I’m not the biggest fan of cady’s voice but I love the song
The audacity of putting a cautionary tale in here when it's an amazing opening song
Humm who cast that girl for Cady ? Her dad worked on production or something ?
give credit to cady guys..she isn't even a real artist still she give her best
Yeah the author is the real mean girl
Yeah, why the heck was she casted get someone who can sing? It’s not her fault it’s the directors and casters
@@goat.cheese_ so you saying you are the better caster
@@davidariyan7915 yes i am saying that
@@goat.cheese_ this is a movie remake with elements added from the Broadway show. They have to make changes. Like made the songs more pop or enjoyable and relatable. So regular film audience could enjoy. Because I'm enjoying watching movies but I didn't enjoy the Broadway version of the songs.
I hate what they did with the music. Stupid With Love's beat sounded like diss track, and it sounded so accapella and modernized. It was almost like they were ashamed of it being a musical. Idek how you go so wrong with something.
As a theatre kid I hated how they changed almost all the songs I was so mad with what if I was waiting to listen to roar 😭😭😭😭😭😭
To be honest stupid with love + what ifs are honestly kinda good…
I think what ifs is good specifically because of the context and the choreo. It works super well for the opening
If only they casted Cady as someone who could sing
They did.
@@yomilala8929stop lying lmao
@@riabee. I'm not.
They should’ve casted Sabrina carpenter.
tbh she has the potential, but the directors did her wrong. this happens to a ton of live action remakes today
thats crazy bc those are some of the best songs in the musical.
WHATS WRONG WITH ME SONG REALLY GETS ON MY FUCKING NERVS
idk why everybody is hating on stupid with love like she has such a good voice and the lyrics are so relatable like I be vibing to this in my room
We are hating because it’s so bad compared to the broadway version they pop-songified it. Listen to the original
CONRAD that u!! 😂😂😂
Ngl “what ifs” has been stuck in my head
Basically all the songs wigh cady like the actress was not cut out for the role. I don't really see her emotions or I don't hear them, I mean she may be a great actress, but not for this movie.
'I See Stars' and 'Stupid with Love' are absolutely marvelous on Broadway. 'It Roars' shouldn't have been replaced. Freakin' shame.
“What’s Wrong With Me?” is so deep and just hits on another level. There is no way that it is on this list. You either didn’t get the songs meaning, or ur heartless(not trying to be rude I’m just really upset)
Ok 'a cautionary tale is so amazing because both of their voice blend so well together that makes the song sound incredible- but since you put that song in 5th for worst mean girl songs i cannot live anymore
All the songs were great on Broadway just not in the movie
Top 5 worst songs in mean girls :So every single song in the whole move
"smart with math but stupid with love" WHAT WAS THAT DISNEY CHANNEL ASS HAND MOVEMENTT
not the what was i made for dupe😭😭😭
Broadway >>>>> whatever this is
All I know is Gretchen’s character really ate up those vocals on “what’s wrong with me! Also, why is “A Cautionary Tale” there? That song is such a bop and she sings the heck out of it!
I see stars always gave me chills idk about this version tho
Cady's actress was the real tragedy here. Something 3 of these songs have in common.
WHAT IS A CAUTIONARY TALE DOING HERE YALL WHAT THE HECK
Them using tiktok as a format is gonna make this movie outdated so much more quickly. That was why the original movie didn't use any actual slang and limited the use of cell phones. To make it timeless!
I agree with the top 3, whats wrong with me was lowkey so good and personally I feel like showed how Gretchen truly felt and cautionary tale IS a BANGER
The autotune on what ifs and stupid with love 😂😂😂
I.. Im dead 💀
I honestly forgot about the last song🥱
Missing erikas voice for cady
A cautionary tale does not deserve this...
i loved their version of A Cautionary Tale
It’s giving high school musical on SHEIN
What’s wrong with me made me cry, it’s relatable and the main reason why I resonate with Gretchen. It’s also sooo good