Indian Doctors Call for Nationwide Strike on Saturday | Vantage with Palki Sharma

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 11. 09. 2024
  • Indian Doctors Call for Nationwide Strike on Saturday | Vantage with Palki Sharma
    India's largest doctors' group, the IMA, has called for a nationwide strike on Saturday, demanding justice for the Kolkata rape and murder victim. Meanwhile, political parties in West Bengal are busy playing a blame game, with the chief minister demanding death penalty for the suspect in "one week". Palki Sharma asks why parties are willing to discuss anything but real solutions.
    ---
    Doctors | Doctors' Protest | India | Kolkata | Rape | Murder | Sexual Assault | Firstpost | World News | News Live | Vantage | Palki Sharma | News
    #doctorsprotest #kolkata #rape #murdernews #firstpost #vantageonfirstpost #palkisharma #worldnews
    Vantage is a ground-breaking news, opinions, and current affairs show from Firstpost. Catering to a global audience, Vantage covers the biggest news stories from a 360-degree perspective, giving viewers a chance to assess the impact of world events through a uniquely Indian lens.
    The show is anchored by Palki Sharma, Managing Editor, Firstpost.
    By breaking stereotypes, Vantage aims to challenge conventional wisdom and present an alternative view on global affairs, defying the norm and opening the door to new perspectives. The show goes beyond the headlines to uncover the hidden stories - making Vantage a destination for thought-provoking ideas.
    Vantage airs Monday to Friday at 9 PM IST on Firstpost across all leading platforms.

    Subscribe to Firstpost channel and press the bell icon to get notified when we go live.
    / @firstpost
    Follow Firstpost on Instagram:
    / firstpost
    Follow Firstpost on Facebook:
    / firstpostin
    Follow Firstpost on Twitter:
    / firstpost
    Follow Firstpost on WhatsApp:
    www.whatsapp.c...

Komentáře • 686

  • @buhahahaha123
    @buhahahaha123 Před 26 dny +174

    Dear West bengal.... If you don't throw this lady out from politics your fate won't change... she is a drama queen.. she is fooling not only you people... but whole of india... don't fall for it...

    • @malsawmkima6226
      @malsawmkima6226 Před 25 dny +3

      And vote what? BJP? Then women would have the right to walk freely at night?

    • @buhahahaha123
      @buhahahaha123 Před 25 dny +18

      @malsawmkima6226 So ur r saying conditions in West bengal is better than the rest of India... 🤣🤣🤣 Even Russell peters in an interview told WB have not changed. Think even a foreigner can see it... and u people are still blind... It took 35 years to understand communists for you people.... may be it will take more than that.. Meanwhile, things like this will happens again... and CM will protest against CM... u will be clapping 👏...

    • @buhahahaha123
      @buhahahaha123 Před 25 dny +3

      yathā rājā tathā prajā

    • @malsawmkima6226
      @malsawmkima6226 Před 25 dny

      @@buhahahaha123 It has not change I'm not blind but i will not change if under BJP rule.
      Have you ever read the news? A nurse in UP is being graped and killed AGAIN ! But there is the saying " a day without rape is a day wasted". Guess where is that.

    • @adityadubey177
      @adityadubey177 Před 25 dny +1

      @@malsawmkima6226 if you don’t want to vote to BJP vote congress

  • @LifeIsPresent2804
    @LifeIsPresent2804 Před 26 dny +432

    Against whom is she protesting.. CM himself,
    Home Minister himself,
    Health Minister himself
    And she's asking for justice from whom this is called politics 😢😢
    She's making fools of people..

    • @Dewdrops34215
      @Dewdrops34215 Před 26 dny

      Perhaps you haven't heard of the issues in West Bengal
      TMC leaders assaulting women in front of their families. Look up Sandedhkhali.
      Women being punished according to Sharia Law in Bengal
      Goons sent by politicians to destroy evidence in this case.
      Bengal is in a dictatorship situation. Mamta Banerji needs to resign.

    • @MAHIPALKUMAR-b9r
      @MAHIPALKUMAR-b9r Před 26 dny +25

      She has been doing this for 20 years

    • @Mzenith
      @Mzenith Před 26 dny +16

      She is Concern about the state election that's why playing bullshit politics

    • @ashokbrahma2338
      @ashokbrahma2338 Před 26 dny +14

      She is a drama queen.

    • @Awakened_Creator_1283
      @Awakened_Creator_1283 Před 26 dny +6

      She's trying to make another Singur out of this!

  • @gamer22542
    @gamer22542 Před 26 dny +435

    The current cm (Mamata Banerjee) tried to cover up this incident, Mamata Banerjee should be arrested. She has destroyed West Bengal, the capital of WB, Kolkata literally looks like a dystopian city and Kolkata is the hub of scammers (most of the indian scammers reside in kolkata because they get protection from the TMC party). President rule should be imposed in West Bengal.

    • @merrick6484
      @merrick6484 Před 26 dny +3

      Wrong.
      West Bengal should return o Bangladesh.

    • @swapneelbehera260
      @swapneelbehera260 Před 26 dny

      Take it if you can😂​@@merrick6484

    • @sobhajames4563
      @sobhajames4563 Před 26 dny

      ​@@merrick6484what we already gave the country to Muslims. Muslims should go from India

    • @Marshal-hj3kk
      @Marshal-hj3kk Před 26 dny +5

      Couldn't agree more

    • @shahilsaha3645
      @shahilsaha3645 Před 26 dny +16

      @@merrick6484 and bd must become Pakistan again... now you may kindly get lost

  • @bhatnissa4197
    @bhatnissa4197 Před 26 dny +373

    Mamta Banerjee what the hell she thinks she is doing,

    • @BTSARMY-yc7xi
      @BTSARMY-yc7xi Před 26 dny

      She's tripping 😢 she forget that she's also a women

    • @nuranichandra2177
      @nuranichandra2177 Před 26 dny

      WTF are you doing about it?

    • @P.C1999
      @P.C1999 Před 26 dny +15

      Nobody cares
      Keep voting Mumtaz bano after sandeshkhali incident
      Ye to hona hi tha

    • @P.C1999
      @P.C1999 Před 26 dny +15

      @@nuranichandra2177 voting her party again and again to win and keep this type of situation in bengal

    • @sushantgupta9969
      @sushantgupta9969 Před 26 dny

      I am from Kolkata and let me tell you things are going to get much worse from here because of just one lady and that is Mamata Banerjee. She has displaced the native people and made them minorities in their homeland and bringing in illegal immigrants for her vote bank so that she keeps winning elections over and over.

  • @IgaSwiatekFan-ox9rn
    @IgaSwiatekFan-ox9rn Před 26 dny +205

    I am from West Bengal. The constant legal notice to twitter handle, goon attack on RG kar, police inefficiency & suspicious role in both case and gone attack ,the constant arrogance from CM I am literally horrified seeing my state fall apart 😢

    • @IgaSwiatekFan-ox9rn
      @IgaSwiatekFan-ox9rn Před 26 dny +5

      Goon*

    • @ranapratapsingh3416
      @ranapratapsingh3416 Před 26 dny

      Then why your state people shamelessly vote for the Terrorist Mamata .

    • @BhuvneshKumar-lr3hr
      @BhuvneshKumar-lr3hr Před 25 dny

      Everything in the human society is a sham. Don't be afraid of what is going. What's laughable is, each everyone person in our country is responsible for what happened.

    • @srikanthlives
      @srikanthlives Před 23 dny

      But we love Mamata didi and vote for her with thumping majority to do what ever crime she wants.

    • @ranapratapsingh3416
      @ranapratapsingh3416 Před 23 dny

      @@srikanthlives Only criminals will vote for Mamata. She is a criminal.

  • @indiaendless7388
    @indiaendless7388 Před 26 dny +188

    Mamata must resign

  • @reginageorgetownuni
    @reginageorgetownuni Před 26 dny +182

    The main issue is being diverted. This is an issue with RG Kar medical college specifically. Something is very messed up about that college because news about "suicides" or mysterious deaths have been going around since 2000s... that college needs to be shut down and investigated thoroughly.

    • @azurelearningsimplified1349
      @azurelearningsimplified1349 Před 26 dny +20

      Use of expiry medicines, organ traffic, sex and drug racket

    • @xlr8_bs514
      @xlr8_bs514 Před 26 dny +7

      They have to make provisions to shift the students to other colleges and provide them with food and stay for that to happen. Do you really think that any government in India, especially the State Government of my state is worthy enough to do that?

    • @dhven9274
      @dhven9274 Před 26 dny +12

      Nothing will happen. Max some more scapegoats will be arrested. Cover up is too deep & everything already sanitized . Actual photo of the crime scene is already on the net ..
      Its clear the crime *did not* take place in the room they are calling Seminar room. Body was placed there by smbdy involved at some level. .
      & Police staged the rest
      That room is like a small store room with barely enough room for 2 men + victim.
      And the autopsy report suggests there were several men involved in the crime.
      The room has a wooden stand upright against the back door & next to it is a floor standing fan facing the room . Her slippers are neatly kept on the step- up wooden platform thats the floor. Abt 2 steps from her body on the side is a wooden table
      If the crime involved several men , how come everything is so untouched & undisturbed ? Even the slippers are perfecty placed at the start of the platform.
      Her face looks too clean of blood for such a brutal crime . Her eyes are bleeding but her mouth that has bruises has no blood.
      She is covered with a blue cloth / blanket till her neck.. If a person doesn't look carefully at the face then alongwt the undisturbed room . .. this could easily pass off as suicide .
      Exactly as the Police & Principal tried to cover up at the start

    • @reginageorgetownuni
      @reginageorgetownuni Před 25 dny

      @@xlr8_bs514 there aren't that many resident doctors, they can be transferred to other govt hospitals. Mbbs Students can continue studying in the college. The hospital needs cease and desist

    • @harshithanuthala8930
      @harshithanuthala8930 Před 25 dny

      ​@@dhven9274doctors are involved in this crime

  • @rayrwyr
    @rayrwyr Před 26 dny +55

    Mamata: if you can't fight them, join them. So she is now protesting against her government.

  • @RaulVincitaly
    @RaulVincitaly Před 26 dny +74

    Mamtha action is like
    Rapist asking justice for the victim

  • @nandakumar4738
    @nandakumar4738 Před 26 dny +264

    TMC is responsible for the loss

    • @SR-mv2mf
      @SR-mv2mf Před 26 dny +7

      Also ppl voted for her what about them?

    • @AK-wt3jj
      @AK-wt3jj Před 26 dny +4

      ​@@SR-mv2mf they are the real culprits

    • @babahanuman83
      @babahanuman83 Před 26 dny

      primitive politisation. its indian patriarchic mindset + corruption.

    • @sushantgupta9969
      @sushantgupta9969 Před 26 dny

      TMC Party cadres were mobilized from local slum areas to create vandalism.

    • @dhven9274
      @dhven9274 Před 26 dny

      ​@@AK-wt3jj Nothing will happen. Max some more scapegoats will be arrested. Cover up is too deep & everything already sanitized . Actual photo of the crime scene is on the net ..
      Its clear the crime *did not* take place in the room they are calling Seminar room. Body was placed there by smbdy involved at some point . . .
      & Police staged the rest .
      That room is like a small Store room with not even enough room for 2 men to commit such a crime .
      And the autopsy report suggests there were several men involved in the crime.
      The room has a wooden stand upright against the back door & next to it is a floor standing fan facing the room . Her slippers are neatly kept on the step- up wooden platform thats the floor. Abt 2 steps from her body on the side is a wooden table
      If the crime involved several men , how come everything is so untouched & undisturbed ? Even the slippers are perfecty placed at the start of the platform.
      Her face looks too clean of blood for such a brutal crime . Her eyes are bleeding but her mouth that has bruises has no blood.
      She is covered with a blue cloth / blanket till her neck.. If a person doesn't look carefully at the face then alongwt the undisturbed room . .. this could easily pass off as suicide .
      Exactly as the Police & Principal tried to cover up at the start

  • @Esha_Biswas_3008
    @Esha_Biswas_3008 Před 26 dny +103

    Mamta must resign. A very strict action should be taken against rapists. New rules needed.

  • @HarshSharma-eo3tq
    @HarshSharma-eo3tq Před 26 dny +31

    Mamta Banerjee is a classic example of whats wrong with our politics.
    She's marching against herself or probably forgot she is the CM 😅😅

    • @harshithanuthala8930
      @harshithanuthala8930 Před 25 dny +1

      Doctors are protesting against themselves

    • @Unknown-u6e
      @Unknown-u6e Před 25 dny +1

      ​@@harshithanuthala8930 doctors are protesting against her (CM), they are protesting for justice and safety- Mamata Banerjee just joined them because she couldn't win them, WOW what a smart move- but they won't spare her- She has to resign 😤

  • @VitthalGucci
    @VitthalGucci Před 26 dny +53

    RGKar State run Medical College in WB is possibly at the centre of Drug, sex and smuggling activity ,that funds TMC ,with the State Police and Administration trying to cover up! There is a total collapse of law and order in the State of West Bengal.

    • @yashaswini287
      @yashaswini287 Před 26 dny +2

      May be Organ trafficking too

    • @dhven9274
      @dhven9274 Před 26 dny

      Almost all big Govt hospitals are the same. Badly managed, no checks & even audits , lacking in facilities & amenities for both medical staff & patients and its the place for whitewashing plenty bad happenings esp of local politicians.

    • @harshithanuthala8930
      @harshithanuthala8930 Před 25 dny

      ​@@yashaswini287maybe that's they are dragging

    • @jay1645
      @jay1645 Před 25 dny

      Investigate thoroughly, use this opportunity to shut down or dismantle the system that allowed this to happen sack or vote Mamta B out asap

  • @vijaybaishnab7349
    @vijaybaishnab7349 Před 26 dny +31

    This State has become a Gutter

  • @Marshal-hj3kk
    @Marshal-hj3kk Před 26 dny +71

    Mamata is involved in this. She should be thrown out of this country.

    • @harshithanuthala8930
      @harshithanuthala8930 Před 25 dny +1

      No she is not doctors involved in this because crime took place in hospital

    • @nikitasah6996
      @nikitasah6996 Před 25 dny

      ​@@harshithanuthala8930 Dude tmc goons sent by her to attack on protestors and hospital to destroy evidence because her karyakatas are involved

    • @Dr.SyedSaifAbbasNaqvi
      @Dr.SyedSaifAbbasNaqvi Před 23 dny

      ​@@harshithanuthala8930TMC MLA Nirmal Majhi's son is one of the accused. Who are you !? You are not even bengali. How are you passing comments about Mamata. She sent her goons on the 14th night to sabotage the evidence.

  • @kobitakobita2262
    @kobitakobita2262 Před 26 dny +39

    Mamta Banerjee is a big dramatic personality.. who know how to play when and where ...
    The most badluck For Bengal ..

  • @nirmalafakir3306
    @nirmalafakir3306 Před 26 dny +31

    Please CBI get the results as soon as possible . The world is watching

  • @kevingupta7091
    @kevingupta7091 Před 26 dny +54

    Honestly, I agree with everything Palki is saying. I love her reporting.
    And if the politicians themselves have assault and rape charges against them, then how can the public expect them (the politicians) to make any improvements? Also, education starts from birth. Why are we not teaching our kids to stop treating women (or anyone) like objects? A hardcore criminal becomes from a small crime, like robbery. A rapist becomes from small acts like eve teasing or stalking. Let's stop these people there, before they go any further.
    Everyone needs to play a part.

    • @aloksingh8971
      @aloksingh8971 Před 26 dny +3

      We all know rape happening is a problem but the bigger picture here is how shamelessly momta didi trying hard to save somebody is just not acceptable... rape happens in every state and daily .. that needs to be stopped but can you remember which state govt sides by culprit and save rhem..? That is only patented in west bengal...😢

    • @AnneX59
      @AnneX59 Před 26 dny +1

      Thank You for recognizing the crux n core of the problem. Issue needs a holistic approach....
      It is the whole eco system of patrairchy which is upkeeped often by women only. Women exert patriarchy. Not just in India
      Across the globe women are used as props by other women for social advantage .
      Ek women is complete only after she's an accessory to a man's life. As a bahu qs a wife as a mother. Other than that independent divorced childless women are still looked down upon. The culprit of heinous crime is also product of this social environment. He's a victim of this same sick gaze that he's been brought up in. And the proboem is global....
      Bill in Iraq to legalise Child marriage ... gals marriageable age is proposed at 9.
      All over the world ... females are used as pawns to assert religious beliefs.
      Christian leaders wanna prove they are devote devoted Christian(Catholics) so they will oppose the right of a woman to abort her pregnancy.
      Islamic Hardliners like Khomeini and Talibanis will list 1000s of donts for the womenfolk and also write that men should ensure this so as to prove themselves to be a good Muslim .
      India bhi kuch kam nhi hai...
      Good Hindu gal should wear covered clothes. Ghunghat. In laws ki sewa meaning sacrifice ki murti. No derr raat ghumna. No inheritance. Dowry lana...
      Baap aur Pati ki baat maanna... in short no brain or no opinion of your own. No control of your own life. Seek validation from in laws pati and continue to live like a robot so that you belong to a good Hindu Bahu category.
      Principle all over the world is that limit women's rights to exert your religious beliefs.
      That will make you
      A good Hindu
      A good Muslim
      A good Christian
      Socio- Political respect nhi hai aurton ki. Toh personal respect kaise hogi?
      Issliye Kolkata ka Hospital ki Doctor ho yaaa Dalit worker ki Beti rape ladkiyon k hi hote hain aur hote rahenge.

    • @srujankumarmishra1768
      @srujankumarmishra1768 Před 24 dny

      @@aloksingh8971 congress destroyed the constituion by re writting laws to change the verdict of supreme court where they exposed muslims treating their women as objects... so i hope ur a congress critic too. tbh bjp is the only sane party, even tho they have allegations, thats still lesser evil than other parties

  • @deepika2117
    @deepika2117 Před 26 dny +22

    If mamta can't handle matter she should resign, instead of attending rally 😡
    Stop this blaming politics, mamta can't confuse doctors
    We want immediate justice

  • @musical_0713
    @musical_0713 Před 26 dny +38

    Wow, what a move, phle rape mein shaamil ho, fir saare evidence mita do, uske baad apni glti chupaane ke liye march pe utar jao , taaki aapko sb dudh ka dhula smjhne lge...what a movie by this lady, such a shame...😢

  • @user-ed2nv8pp5m
    @user-ed2nv8pp5m Před 26 dny +35

    Manta should resign as cm were in the hall can prosecute in 1 week ,
    What she trying too hide

    • @merrick6484
      @merrick6484 Před 26 dny +1

      Look, who is protecting the Rapists.

  • @channasuc1726
    @channasuc1726 Před 26 dny +53

    President rule must be imposed!!!

  • @johnwdsouza1
    @johnwdsouza1 Před 26 dny +50

    MAMTA ji, Go to Bangladesh

    • @intisarannafi9015
      @intisarannafi9015 Před 26 dny

      We 🇧🇩 must decline. We are tired of these types of politicians.

    • @P.C1999
      @P.C1999 Před 26 dny +1

      Nobody cares
      Keep voting Mumtaz bano after sandeshkhali incident
      Ye to hona hi tha

    • @xlr8_bs514
      @xlr8_bs514 Před 26 dny

      ​@@P.C1999For the last time, we DO NOT.
      Most true Bengalis did not vote for her. Only illegal immigrants, muslims (because she only works for them, so it's understandable that they vote for her) and poor people blinded by freebies vote for her.

    • @rashidkhalid3970
      @rashidkhalid3970 Před 26 dny

      Kolkata is Bangaldesh

    • @P.C1999
      @P.C1999 Před 26 dny

      @@rashidkhalid3970 yes after few years

  • @subratabhowal7590
    @subratabhowal7590 Před 26 dny +22

    'Safety First is Safety
    Always."
    - Charles Melville Hays.
    "It takes leadership to improve
    safety."
    - Jakie Stewart.

  • @biswarajkarmakar9650
    @biswarajkarmakar9650 Před 26 dny +22

    People of Bengal DEMANDS Mamta free Bengal.

    • @alexgomel5805
      @alexgomel5805 Před 26 dny +1

      Don't be stupid...force he out.

    • @alexgomel5805
      @alexgomel5805 Před 24 dny

      @biswarajkarmakar9650 Do it now people before it's too late.The people of Bangladesh woke up from their deep slumber.U guys still asleep.???!@!

    • @alexgomel5805
      @alexgomel5805 Před 24 dny

      Her.

  • @sompalbaliyan2660
    @sompalbaliyan2660 Před 26 dny +37

    Central government MUST impose Presidents Rule in WB immediately and, hanover it to central forces including Army.

    • @vikasmishra7504
      @vikasmishra7504 Před 26 dny

      The moment president rule is imposed whole opposition will start crying about democracy and constitution and central government will be called as dictatorship.

  • @tkdasgupta123
    @tkdasgupta123 Před 26 dny +39

    Please add in slogan that "#Mamata resignation"

  • @darthvadeth6290
    @darthvadeth6290 Před 24 dny +5

    why isn't Palki comparing India with China now?????? 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

  • @Dancingdoll27
    @Dancingdoll27 Před 26 dny +30

    I don't agree that the law should ONLY be for Doctors! We cant create laws for every profession separately, including home makers or just women sitting at home. This is a problem for any and every woman in the country and I liked what PM Modi proposed, Dont just get justice, but also ensure that the punishment served to such horrific folks, is published and talked about everywhere, so that, a rapist thinks twice before this act!.... In Dubai, the punishment for this act is so severe, that a man thinks twice before even thinking of assaulting a girl!... This is what we need here too!....

    • @dhven9274
      @dhven9274 Před 26 dny +2

      Exactly. But the bigger issue also is that Govt Institutions have little or no checks & staff there have little accountability. If these two are not addressed then such incidents will continue . Next bigger issue is that laws to protect women & children are few and what exists is very porous -- makes it easy to get away or get away with weak penalty .
      There shld be smthing like Rights of Working People & Rights of Students -- a list of must haves thats their basic rights l& which also include facilitites + safety measures in Institutions where they spend so much time ...... Institutions that make money of them.

    • @harshithanuthala8930
      @harshithanuthala8930 Před 25 dny +1

      Right

  • @SlimJim3082
    @SlimJim3082 Před 26 dny +62

    Another nurse met the same fate in India in a separate incident.
    India you never fail to amaze us.

    • @AK-wt3jj
      @AK-wt3jj Před 26 dny +1

      You are talking about nurse Aruna right.

    • @GeoShubh
      @GeoShubh Před 26 dny

      @@AK-wt3jj She was Brahmin and she rejected that person. Brahmin girls get objectify the most. That SC person was from UP. Bihar,UP, West Bengal,Delhi belt is most cruel belt for women.

    • @subhamsingh3097
      @subhamsingh3097 Před 26 dny +2

      This is India my , friend where leaving India and settling abroad is considered success. May God help me to leave this country.

  • @shoumava1
    @shoumava1 Před 26 dny +18

    I am not able to understand this, if the perpetrators were multiple people, where did they come from? If they were insiders how come no one from the hospital are not aware of it in the hospital. Why is Police not naming the suspects in the case. Are medicos protesting against themselves??

    • @harshithanuthala8930
      @harshithanuthala8930 Před 25 dny

      U r 100% correct

    • @Optimus_Crime_
      @Optimus_Crime_ Před 25 dny

      Yes. It's not that hard to understand. It's about safety precautions that high profile hospitals even in the capital cities don't provide to doctors. And against the blatant corruption and unchecked hooliganism that has tampered/destroyed the investigation of this case.

    • @dr.akshatgange5883
      @dr.akshatgange5883 Před 25 dny +2

      We are protesting against the assailants and the system that cannot provide us with a safe working environment.
      There is a possibility that medical personnel are involved, in that case it’s a strong resistance against them too.

    • @shoumava1
      @shoumava1 Před 25 dny +1

      @@dr.akshatgange5883 condition and safety of Government hospitals need to be improved in the country. Being a Health care professional, even I agree that our HCPs work in the worst conditions and deserve better to serve the society well. We are with you ❤️

  • @bimanjana8806
    @bimanjana8806 Před 26 dny +13

    When Mamata Banerjee protesting for this case.she useing protesting time her party (TMC) Flags🏳️ not use our national Flag 🇮🇳🇮🇳 this is bad for us 😡😞

  • @mihirsharma0987
    @mihirsharma0987 Před 26 dny +32

    Dr Moumita di is a warrior , she was not ready to settle with negativity and illegal things , she had tried helped the nation, ..protest will be continued

  • @nmew6926
    @nmew6926 Před 25 dny +7

    That's one of the many reasons why Elon Musk don't want to send his team of engineers in India.

  • @sompalbaliyan2660
    @sompalbaliyan2660 Před 26 dny +10

    If central government DOESN'T impose president rule, soon it may be a new Bangladesh

  • @Dewdrops34215
    @Dewdrops34215 Před 26 dny +11

    Why is Mamta Banerji going on strike? Why cant she increase funding for government hospitals? More security jobs, CCTV cameras and stop protecting her party members who have committed this crime.

  • @rayrwyr
    @rayrwyr Před 26 dny +9

    Sanjoy Roy, the main suspect, is probably not even involved. Sandeep Ghosh, the ex-principal, is most certainly involved.

    • @spacesight6453
      @spacesight6453 Před 24 dny

      There are high profile intern doctors who have done this horrific act the mamta govt has helped them to destroy evidence by some construction reason and they say they have fled the country

  • @debg89768
    @debg89768 Před 25 dny +4

    the fact is they tried to cover up the incident as suicide, wounds on the victims body suggest multiple perpetrators, they only arrested 1 person and tried to bribe the parents. even after all that they tried to destroy evidence and intimidate protester with mob, . so high possibility of someone from tmc or related tmc is involved in this crime. and guess what mamta Banerjee demanding, death penalty within 1 week? is it for justice ? no people are not stupid it's the fear that if they start investigating deep they will find a link back to them and that's why mamata banarjee trying to get rid of the case by dealing with 1 supposed criminal.

  • @ankddaas6570
    @ankddaas6570 Před 26 dny +29

    When I am watching this... Before the day a nurse is raped and murdered in uttarakhand
    A doctor raped patients in odisha
    What is going on 😞

    • @shida2772
      @shida2772 Před 26 dny +6

      Because hell is empty all the evils are on earth now

    • @GeoShubh
      @GeoShubh Před 26 dny +1

      Don't go to male doctor. Scream if they come to you. Girls can save themselves only by not trusting anyone until they prove themselves trustworthy.

    • @Shiva-nx1tn
      @Shiva-nx1tn Před 26 dny +5

      The One In Uttarakhand The Culprit Is From Up Dont Say my State Name

  • @Kleyana
    @Kleyana Před 26 dny +5

    People of West Bengal, hold the current head of state accountable. Without political help, criminals would not have been able to safely exit the crime scene after committing such a horrible crime.

  • @khanch.6807
    @khanch.6807 Před 26 dny +7

    I am from Bangladesh. We had high rape crimes like India. We changed the law to full life imprisonment and death penalty for rapists. They never get to know when they die. Rape cases dropped to 6000 per year compared to 500000 per year in India.
    India may have a large population but its not 80 time than ours to justify the gap.

    • @subhamsingh3097
      @subhamsingh3097 Před 26 dny +3

      Here also law is strict, some laws are even extremely biased which results in innocent men to go jail, problem is not in law , problem is in execution. Here all politicians are corrupt and Mamta ruined West Bengal and Kolkata. Kolkata was ones know as city of joy but seeing today's situation it's city of hell

    • @alexgomel5805
      @alexgomel5805 Před 26 dny

      Good.

    • @rashidkhalid3970
      @rashidkhalid3970 Před 25 dny

      It happens all over India is mumta to blame for that as well

    • @subhamsingh3097
      @subhamsingh3097 Před 25 dny

      @@rashidkhalid3970 yeah , politician like her , in short all of them are the reason why police department is trash .

  • @SherlockHolmes2606
    @SherlockHolmes2606 Před 26 dny +11

    Mamta must resign immediately!!

    • @harshithanuthala8930
      @harshithanuthala8930 Před 25 dny

      Why nobody enquirying what is happening in hospital......all are obsessed with mamata resignation........if mamatha has to prove guilty investigation must be done inside hospital......why principal are not taking responsibility why doctors in that hospital are clueless about anything for what they protesting outside college

  • @nachsn2213
    @nachsn2213 Před 26 dny +6

    Even after Sandeshkali, people of WB voted for her. Why were the women of WB not react after that? WB had its chance but dropped the ball

    • @poy2182
      @poy2182 Před 24 dny

      Because @nachsn2213 Women in Bengal get lot of benefits so they vote. When there's freebies there is no much development.

    • @amanchoudhury8135
      @amanchoudhury8135 Před 24 dny

      Money 💰💰

  • @Kc-iu4ru
    @Kc-iu4ru Před 26 dny +4

    The city of joy is turning into the city of chaos where goons with uniform tried to protect wild goons for people who protest for justice

  • @Goldenbirdchirp
    @Goldenbirdchirp Před 25 dny +3

    It shows how collective consciousness of the INDIAN SOCIETY IS ALIVE ❤ Kudos India

  • @Madhukumari-sb4wv
    @Madhukumari-sb4wv Před 26 dny +36

    During elections pappu gang was saying modi is dictator 😂😂😂

    • @merrick6484
      @merrick6484 Před 26 dny +1

      Modi can never be a dictator.
      He is too weak and low IQ for a dictator. Jus compare him to Xi and Putin, Modi is useless.

    • @kaladak
      @kaladak Před 25 dny +1

      😢😢right sis .yogi in up atleast make the state very safe no incidence soon wb will become bangladeah😢

  • @tusharsamanta7997
    @tusharsamanta7997 Před 25 dny +3

    Unfortunately, it seems, few people from same doctor community executed the crime...

  • @reshmanoor7411
    @reshmanoor7411 Před 26 dny +7

    STOP VIOLENCE AGAINST WOMEN IN INDIA
    SAVE MINORITIES IN INDIA

    • @CrazyPanda.000
      @CrazyPanda.000 Před 25 dny

      Save majority as well, also minorities in Bangladesh and other 30-40 islamic state nations

  • @lokeshk4642
    @lokeshk4642 Před 26 dny +4

    Mamata and her party did not make any statements earlier and now she came up with new game. She is the CM so she is asking justice from the her own government?

  • @sandeepraobe
    @sandeepraobe Před 26 dny +4

    very balanced reporting. We are watching from USA and this is one of the best reporting anywhere in the world . no taking sides. no political look alike affiliations. amazing job and amazing reporting keep doing . dont get the stains of like other channels where they already are bruised and tainted with political inclinations.

  • @Blackmanface24
    @Blackmanface24 Před 26 dny +5

    how can a minsiter of state ddumb af that this mamta is rallying with people to fight against whom ? and she is the chief minster of health care and home minster .

  • @ashoksarin2736
    @ashoksarin2736 Před 24 dny +1

    Nothing will come out when the government of W. Bengal is shielding the criminal!
    😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢

  • @user-er7gv1cj6o
    @user-er7gv1cj6o Před 25 dny +3

    This time Janta of Bengal n Doctors shouldnot leave protest intil n unles mamta submit resignation from CM Chair.

  • @ghtwghtw7197
    @ghtwghtw7197 Před 26 dny +4

    Whats wrong with this country....sickening...

  • @BhuvneshKumar-lr3hr
    @BhuvneshKumar-lr3hr Před 25 dny +3

    A very arrogant lady doctor once handled a UTI case of my friend. Not only was she was very rude and egoistical with her own staff, but also she mistreated my friend twice. Now draft this separate bill for doctors so they become even more egoistical and roam freely mistreating whoever they want in their hospitals. GREAT !! Humans think they are better than everyone amongst themselves as well as against others. What a joke. The r*pe was a heinous crime and I cried too, the security necessary must be provided as well but imagine a bill that can allow some egoistical doctor to mistreat your loved ones and humiliate you & on top of that they get shielded by the law, that would just be laughable.

    • @love_cook
      @love_cook Před 25 dny +2

      exactly. Its just another case in the eyes of law.

  • @rohitsharma-mg3yw
    @rohitsharma-mg3yw Před 26 dny +4

    Oscar award for Mamtha Banarjee🐐

  • @sleepyknight7039
    @sleepyknight7039 Před 26 dny +5

    I don't mean to say that doctors don't deserve protection or other rights, but it seems like this fight for justice is slowly turning into a fight for the doctor's own rights. It feels like the reason why these protests started in the first place is being overtaken by something else. ( idk,I maybe wrong, maybe I'm being too insensitive on this )

    • @venom14dark66
      @venom14dark66 Před 26 dny +5

      I agree with you, it's supposed to be about women's safety not only doctor's safety and working conditions(which they should receive too)

    • @harshithanuthala8930
      @harshithanuthala8930 Před 25 dny

      I agree with you u r not insensitive from first onwards they are using this incident to solve their pending demands..... only few fighting for justice majority for their own demands........ only because of media and doctors protests criminals escaping

    • @dr.akshatgange5883
      @dr.akshatgange5883 Před 25 dny +1

      Yes it is about that too. As this incidence has happened with a member of our fraternity, we demand rights for every body but more so for our fraternity as the state of security in government hospitals is very grim and we can work better knowing that we are safe

    • @amanchoudhury8135
      @amanchoudhury8135 Před 24 dny +1

      I mean doctors were the one who raised the issue so they are just following what they started

  • @vikramj1000
    @vikramj1000 Před 26 dny +5

    Didn't get ye mamta cm hai HM bhi hai . Toh yeh kyun justice delay kar rahi hai . Or yeh baat in logo ko samajhne nahi Ti hai kya jo iske sath kadhe hai .

  • @sanfriday6667
    @sanfriday6667 Před 24 dny +1

    Why is rape so rampant in India, a country more religious than no other

  • @user-jl9ku8kj3e
    @user-jl9ku8kj3e Před 25 dny +1

    We want justice 😡😡

  • @ShubhamSingh-et2ze
    @ShubhamSingh-et2ze Před 26 dny +19

    Now they aren't protesting for justice they are protesting for power

  • @dsanjeevkumar
    @dsanjeevkumar Před 25 dny +2

    Bengal people don't Fool again by Mamatha benarji .Fought for Justice

  • @surajkantibag3100
    @surajkantibag3100 Před 26 dny +2

    I am with doctors along with all medical professionals in this heinous incident.. but also at the same time demanding the central act not to be implemented. I hope most of the peple never wants this to be implemented because everday we witness careless doctors in every corners of our country. For them earning is main target. Implemention such act means protection to all..

    • @harshithanuthala8930
      @harshithanuthala8930 Před 25 dny

      Yes

    • @dr.akshatgange5883
      @dr.akshatgange5883 Před 25 dny

      So you want to hit a doctor and deliver the law by yourself rather than seek compensation in a court?
      Sure there might be some negligence or mistakes but that doesn’t entitle you people to punch/kick/stab and kill us.

    • @harshithanuthala8930
      @harshithanuthala8930 Před 25 dny +1

      ​@@dr.akshatgange5883not only doctors so many also getting kick punch or killed by them......why that only doctors are prioritise it

    • @harshithanuthala8930
      @harshithanuthala8930 Před 25 dny

      ​@@dr.akshatgange5883do doctors want safety against normal people or doctors in hospital?

  • @user-fy8hm2px4t
    @user-fy8hm2px4t Před 25 dny +2

    Who is responsible for this crime?
    The state Authority.
    Who should ensure that no tempering should be done to the evidence?
    The State Authority.
    Who should ensure no mob violence should happen to cause further unrest?
    The state authority.
    Who should ensure the fair investigation should happen and the perpetrators should be put behind the bars?
    The state authority.
    And the state authority after failing in every single duty is doing what?
    Protesting 🤦

    • @harshithanuthala8930
      @harshithanuthala8930 Před 25 dny

      Hospital staff doctors management police security are responsible for this crime who are inside hospital

    • @user-fy8hm2px4t
      @user-fy8hm2px4t Před 25 dny +2

      @@harshithanuthala8930 who controls police and staff of WB and what action has been taken against them?
      The Principal was suspended and was appointed in some other location within 9 hours of suspension.

  • @channasuc1726
    @channasuc1726 Před 26 dny +5

    They should match Mamta’s residence!!!

  • @myonlystar456
    @myonlystar456 Před 25 dny +2

    If female doctors are not safe, then what about patients?

  • @iddrisuzurikanen7435
    @iddrisuzurikanen7435 Před 26 dny +3

    I am surprised the Muslims have not been blamed for this

    • @alexgomel5805
      @alexgomel5805 Před 26 dny +1

      All in good time....they will also be blamed. When options run out.

    • @sharathshivashankar2419
      @sharathshivashankar2419 Před 26 dny

      It is the Muslims who vote for Mamata Banerjee repeatedly. Also, wait until the names of the other rapists come out.

  • @user-eh8qy1rs5b
    @user-eh8qy1rs5b Před 26 dny +4

    The victim's parents say colleagues may be involved .IMA MUST STOP PROTESTS .CBI INVESTIGATION IS ON GOING WHY PROTEST CALLED BY IMA.
    UNWANTED PROTEST CAUSING INCONVENIENCE TO PATIENTS .

    • @PriyanshuShee10F31-ee7iv
      @PriyanshuShee10F31-ee7iv Před 26 dny +6

      if you were a doctor now, would you like to work???? IN SUCH CONDITION???

    • @user-eh8qy1rs5b
      @user-eh8qy1rs5b Před 26 dny

      @@PriyanshuShee10F31-ee7iv was the condition only now will protest solve the issues. politics is involved.Was it rape or much more CBI is investigating.

    • @geetakurhade7867
      @geetakurhade7867 Před 26 dny +3

      @@user-eh8qy1rs5bso you mean keeping quiet will help?

    • @SaumadeepMukherjee
      @SaumadeepMukherjee Před 26 dny +2

      Unless mamata resigns the protest will continue period

    • @harshithanuthala8930
      @harshithanuthala8930 Před 25 dny

      ​@@SaumadeepMukherjeeshe won't resign because this incident took place inside hospital....... Hospital staff doctors working 24hrs are responsible for this crime...... doctors are protesting against themselves........ solving their unmet demands using this case and diverting main issue

  • @MonglemTanaok-qk9vl
    @MonglemTanaok-qk9vl Před 26 dny +2

    That's why I don't like indian constituency always opposite reply instead of justice..until modi govt...justice is no chance in india

  • @loneranger114
    @loneranger114 Před 25 dny +1

    Indeed very india

  • @naiwangkonyak7522
    @naiwangkonyak7522 Před 25 dny +1

    Thankyou mam palki sharma up dates News govt Action immrdietely😊😅😮

  • @mercyninan9659
    @mercyninan9659 Před 26 dny +2

    If an on futy doctor is raped and murdered in a hospital , what about vulnerable patients ?

  • @tanzilatani
    @tanzilatani Před 26 dny +2

    The criminals should be punished by the law and enforcement at all...
    India can create an example all over the world...
    So that each country's people raise their voice against brutal rape and give an example that...if Indian Govt. Take action against criminals why my country couldn't able to do that...
    We want Justice for Momita...
    As well as every girl who suffered this kinda situation at all...
    Please stand for Justice as a women...we all should stay with Indian girls...

  • @nagendarbabu111
    @nagendarbabu111 Před 23 dny +1

    Home minister against chief / health minister same way heath minister is against chief / health minister and this joke continues

  • @freddygovender3879
    @freddygovender3879 Před 25 dny

    Government must get involved solving this issue.

  • @jyotirajput4920
    @jyotirajput4920 Před 25 dny +2

    😐Doing Politics after any incidents is easy & politician choose the easy path.
    Instant justice can only bring down the anger but it can't not prevent further incidents .
    Proactive , long term safety should be ensured .
    A widespread campaign like swachh bharat should be started for ensuring the safety of women at workplace .
    this incident happen in hospital but the question is is there other places safe ? Big No .😐
    Sharm Karo neta log 😢🙁🫤😕

  • @dibyenduroy5097
    @dibyenduroy5097 Před 26 dny +1

    AMI is earnestly requested not to do any compromise in this issue

  • @tkdasgupta123
    @tkdasgupta123 Před 26 dny +5

    #Mamata resignation

  • @madhurimabiswas7473
    @madhurimabiswas7473 Před 26 dny +9

    No use blaming each other and play politics. The police should interrogate the fellow interns and the seniors of the victim. The perpetrators are most probably some of them.

  • @user-cl6ei8op6s
    @user-cl6ei8op6s Před 26 dny +1

    No one is calling for overhaul in West Bengal Police Force and Hime Ministry ? This was Sachin Vaze version of WB Govt where they are hand in glove with the criminal.

  • @rishabhpant4158
    @rishabhpant4158 Před 25 dny

    Such a horrific case should get justice within a week, how can a court cant give justice in a week.

  • @AshishGeorge-kd8zu
    @AshishGeorge-kd8zu Před 25 dny +1

    A Question please ,
    If there are two Criminals one carries out a henious murder and all the native citizens cry out for justice for the victim ,
    while another does everything to ensure the Criminal never gets punished for the Crime commited.
    Who of the above two Criminals is responsible for eroding the faith in Lawenforcement and Judiciary.
    Is it both the Criminals ?
    If so, How come the second criminal walks away scot free everytime without being punished for obstructing and Suppresing the flow of justice for the Victims whoever, wherever they were.

  • @sabprogroup8623
    @sabprogroup8623 Před 26 dny +1

    yes, it doesn't help anyone except those folks outside India that's coordinating all this.

  • @ronnie5329
    @ronnie5329 Před 23 dny +1

    Wow, Palki talks about a problem in India. No finger pointing at "west" in this segment😅

  • @SuranjanaVlogsUSA
    @SuranjanaVlogsUSA Před 26 dny +2

    Mamata should resign WB is ashamed of her

  • @bankimdebbarma5529
    @bankimdebbarma5529 Před 24 dny

    It is best work for us 👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍

  • @ZtlauVantawl-xy1cw
    @ZtlauVantawl-xy1cw Před 26 dny +1

    JUSTICE for Dr Miss.

  • @jaimahakaljainepal9391

    Hope you get justice. praying for you. 🇳🇵🙏💓🇮🇳

  • @Update350test
    @Update350test Před 24 dny

    We Want Justice ⚖️

  • @alexgomel5805
    @alexgomel5805 Před 26 dny +1

    Blame game... !!!!!

  • @rakeshdurgam8906
    @rakeshdurgam8906 Před 26 dny +3

    No one is responsible for this case.... The one who is responsible is our system... The system of education should be changed... The value education should be enlighted ...
    People becoming more materialistic than spiritual...
    Todays society if any One talk about spirituality they are considered as mentally disabled... But they are living in a virtuous life.
    Education should be included self defencive education especially for girls.

    • @merrick6484
      @merrick6484 Před 26 dny

      Education itself can not change the DNA of a nation.

    • @harshithanuthala8930
      @harshithanuthala8930 Před 25 dny +2

      The hospital is responsible for this case staff management doctors police security are responsible for this crime

    • @poy2182
      @poy2182 Před 24 dny

      @merrick6484 education is a first step.

  • @profnesamony
    @profnesamony Před 24 dny

    Thank you for your concern😊

  • @tanzimatuntun4101
    @tanzimatuntun4101 Před 25 dny

    India is more concerned about what is happening in their neighbouring countries rather than looking into the issues in their own.

  • @jamesmadison4834
    @jamesmadison4834 Před 26 dny +1

    I'm not sure Palki is giving this event the attention it deserves but I am glad she's drawing attention to it. I hope for swift and strong justice for the victims.

  • @amitsarkar3019
    @amitsarkar3019 Před 26 dny +2

    President rule is the 1st demand to get full justice.

    • @harshithanuthala8930
      @harshithanuthala8930 Před 25 dny

      No justice will come because culprits involved were doctors itself I think they are protesting against themselves

  • @YouCantHandleTheTruth.
    @YouCantHandleTheTruth. Před 26 dny +1

    _Blame-game_ is nothing new with India.

  • @umachikkaraddi5773
    @umachikkaraddi5773 Před 25 dny

    Good cover. Well done first post.
    Being a lady doctor myself i m feeling heared when Palki covers our story. Hope the poor soul gets justice 🙏

  • @Explorer_cities
    @Explorer_cities Před 23 dny

    SAME THING HAPPENED IN ETHIOPIA AND HEAVEN WAS ONLY 7 YEARS OLD💔💔 MEN ARE CRUEL CRUEL 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

  • @NiveshanNayager
    @NiveshanNayager Před 26 dny +1

    The devil comes to steal, kill, and destroy, but Jesus came to give life abundantly, offering a life filled with purpose, joy, and eternal hope. While the enemy seeks to diminish and deceive, Jesus brings fullness and freedom, inviting us to experience the richness of life in Him.
    In the same spirit, we pray for India to be a land of safety and protection, especially for all female Indians and female tourists who live and visit this great nation. May the authorities and citizens work together to shield them from evil men who are influenced by the devil's destructive intentions. May India be a beacon of hope, justice, and empowerment for all women, where they can thrive without fear of harm or oppression.

  • @amitb4367
    @amitb4367 Před 26 dny +3

    WTF … bandh on a Saturday.. so doctors can take a long weekend and take a break! Show some real respect!

    • @harshithanuthala8930
      @harshithanuthala8930 Před 25 dny +1

      Every Saturday Sunday hospitals are not crowded in the evening time they are literally empty ......now a days doctors are getting plenty of time...... especially in govt hospital nowadays tight security is there .....they are not allowing anybody in to hospital

    • @dr.akshatgange5883
      @dr.akshatgange5883 Před 25 dny

      @@harshithanuthala8930you are out of touch with the ground reality my friend

    • @harshithanuthala8930
      @harshithanuthala8930 Před 25 dny

      ​@@dr.akshatgange5883no we know