Celebrating Birthday is Permissible in Islam? Dr Zakir Naik, Bilal Philips, Mufti Menk, Shabir Aly
Vložit
- čas přidán 25. 05. 2022
- Everyone wants to celebrate his birthday but as a Muslim, we must consider the commandments of ALLAH.
Is celebrating Birthday Permissible/prohibited in Islam?
Dr Zakir Naik
Bilal Philips
Mufti Ismail Menk
Shabir Aly
Aasim Al Hakeem
Yasir Qadhi
For more updates:
1. Follow us on Facebook: / talaash-haq-ki-1016275...
2. Subscribe our channel: / @talash-haqki2583
Please if you watched the video with all respect don't deny the truth when it doesn't suit you
correct.
czcams.com/video/ctTUUfyK0FU/video.htmlfeature=shared
PROPHET (Peace be upon him) himself PROUDLY celebrate his BIRTHDAY called Milad or Mawlid
I don't understand your comment
Regarding the last scholars explanation, well it is forbidden to celebrate anything annually except for 2 eids. A new house ceremony or graduation, or any form of happiness expressed in celebration is acceptable. But it shouldn't be done yearly like we do in birthday celebration and it also has origin from pagans.
As a Muslim we celebrate our birthdays 5 salah a day and Friday we celebrate our great grandparents Adam and Hawa birthday by coming together to listen to the message.
Subhan'Allah Alhumdulilah Wa li ilahaillilah Wa Allah O Akbar peace and blessings of Allah Swt be upon all the prophets messengers and the companions RA and the Muslim Ummah Ameen yah rabbil Aalameen ♥️☝️
Agreed
جزاک اللہ خیرا . Those who have superficial understanding they think it's incorrect saying birthday is not allowed in Islam. I wish you may be blessed with real understanding of Deen e Islam, Ameen!
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
czcams.com/video/ctTUUfyK0FU/video.htmlfeature=shared
PROPHET (Peace be upon him) himself PROUDLY celebrate his BIRTHDAY called Milad or Mawlid
Are you smarter than Dr Zakir Naik, Bilal Philips, Mufti Menk?
But molid have been used as an opportunity of gathering people to teach the merciful prophet not for worship the prophet during the time when their were no midia
So money people become Muslim
If everything is bida'a midia is bida'a to
It went from "it's haram" to "it's ok". 😂😂😂😂😂 Listen, to be on the safe side: don't imitate the kuffar.
As a former kuffar you could not be more correct. Please brothers and sisters do not do what we do in any way. Do not work to please the people, work to please Allah. 🙏 Honestly, a bit of poison is not okay, stay away.
You should learn English
@@benfoster5387BarakAllahu feek
The main thing we Muslim do follow lunar calendar... So celebrating birthday according to christian calendar doesn't make sense at all 🤷
Besides the birthday celebration of a Muslim is wrong date s well..we follow lunar calendar... simple way to live life is try to ask urselves if the Prophet Muhammad Saw and Sahaba practised those actions then u follow... what they didn't do and didn't encourage it we shouldn't follow
the lunar calender was invented by Umar
I agree with Dr Shabbir ally
Dr Yasir Qadhi almost made it Sunnah , Astaghfirullah.
See this is exactly what is wrong about injecting other culture in the Islamic Tradition. Soon it'll be part of religion to celebrate anniversaries to win your wife's heart.
Let's see what our Prophet ﷺ did and stay close to Allah's message. May Allah Protect and Guide us all. Ameen
I "studied" under him. I say it in quotes because it hardly qualified as study. May Allah forgive me for speaking out of turn, and to Allah is all the knowledge, but I do not have a good impression of the man. I am a white western convert with every reason in the world to be liberal and western minded. After meeting this man many years ago, I would not follow what he says seriously.
Exactly, I felt the same
Exactly, May Allah Guide Dr. Yasir Qadhi
Dr yassir qadhi millions are listening to you...this social media...you making it halal
May ALLAH guide...yassir qadhi
please explain
"And the same peace on me the day I was born and the day I will die and the day I would be raised alive."
(Kanzul Iman the translation of Holy Quran, Sura Al Maryam, Verse 33)
I think this is very clear to me, Happiness and Joy on day he born (ESA AS) and it does not negate it in the quran.
It is ok to have mix understanding of birthday celebrations. We are hung up on small issues. People are not praying and fasting that’s a bigger issue.
You have to look at yourself first and we fix ourselves before we can give dawah if these are “small issues” they are still haram
This is not small issue...
This is connected with aqeedhaul islamiyya and EMAN...
If I not fasting inshallah Allah will forgive me.
But If I haven't full of EMAN,... I can't to go jannah ever 😮😢
It’s connected. People are not praying and fasting, but they still celebrate birthdays and stuff
Last one seems controversial and unclear...
People think they are right because it’s personal celebration but just they want to make haram to halal because they do . When i see this type of comment and discussion that this is not haram I remembe’‘ there will be time people make haram thing to halal ‘’
Allah said that in the Quran there will be a time when halal is bad an haram. Is goid
Even jesus or isa alay salam..
Never celebrate his birthday.. If I'm not mistaken..
From my own level of Islamic knowledge, if the Prophet pbuh recommend fasting on the day one was born then that is enough.
Dr Yasir qadhi makes good points . May Allah bless you abundantly Aameen
You like it because it's not against your desire. The 5 strongest scholars said that this is forbidden, but you remain with the last one.
After watching this video. i am confused,,, someone plz clearify whether to celebrate or not?
what i understood from this video, it is disliked/ not encouraged (makhruh). Personally, I call it haram cuz of the origin. (dont emitate the kuffar)
3 candles?
Ahmed deedath celebrating birthday of prophet (s)
Sheikhul Islam Yasir Qadhi 💯
then is easter egg and such festivals halal according to this logic?
Easter is a religious festival, Birthdays are not
There are only 2 eids (celebrations) in Islam as per Prophet Muhammad (s.a.w) ! Dont listen to Dr. Yasir Qadhi on this matter!
Eid is a celebration celebrated by the community and we do it because its a practice in our religion, birthdays are personal not communal. You probably didn't even listen to what Shaykh Yasir said.
Many people are warning against yasir qadhi.....no one from the salaf celebrated birthdays...its not part of islam...and most importantly birthday is from the pagans ...why on earth anyone would celebrate a year lost from his life:)
@layman- You can't dismiss EVERYTHING a person says just because they happen to be wrong about a few, what have people said about Dr Yasir Qadhi in this video. Also nobody ever said birthdays are a part of islam, when a muslim celebrates his/her birthday they don't expect a reward from Allah or anything like that. The pagans had their own demonic rituals, I don't see people nowadays doing that when celebrating birthdays.
@@SoliderBoi_ actually we say not to listen to him at all .. as layman can't differentiate between right or wrong... secondly it doesn't have to be demonic ritual or stuffs, blowing candle and cake itself is a ritual itself..and majority of scholars say it's prohibited to celebrate birthday
@layman- thats the whole point laymen can't differentiate between right and wrong that's why they ask the scholars or else what's the point of listening to ANY scholar for the matter? You seem to be indicating that we should disregard what he's saying for no reason.
Blowing candles and cutting cake is not a ritual its a celebration and not all birthdays have cakes and candles so even if you were right about it being a ritual it doesn't explain how birthdays as a whole are haram.
Again with all due respect to the scholars, nothing indicates it's haram
According to "Satanic Bible" birthday is most important festivals of the stanic worshipers
Yasir qadhi you are genius ignorant non Islamic scholars
I agree with Yasir Al Yadi, the most sensible argument here
Agreed 100%. He is very sound with his explanations and it absolutely makes sense.
🕋🕌
Simple cutting of cake ?
8
Haram.
Lol...people why u guys dont want the highest stage of jannat?? Celebrating birthdays is the culture of the worshipers of satan
@@southsponge3216 not directly make it haram
Vahabisam
Dr. Yasir Qadi, Men Wearing pant and shirt is different topic than celebrating pegan celebration annually. To you Then celebrating Christmas is also ok?!?
Celebrating Christmas is haram.
If Allah has not commanded thee in Quran then it is not Haram, its manipulation of Allah's word which is unpardonable in eyes of our Lord. Follow Quran and forbid yourself with only which is forbidden in Quran. And those which are not forbidden in Quran it is plausible it is not Haram.
@@Uno.Numero If a celebration is going to encourage festivities that are against Islam, like gender mixing, music, dancing or is part of another religious ritual, then it doesn't need to be in Quran to become Haram.
Do what you think is right brother. May Allah Guide and Protect us all. Ameen.
@@FawadBilgrami What's wrong in gender mixing, music and dancing? why does everything we do have to different to other religions and faiths? Why can't we have commonalities?
Keep Islam Simple, what's in Quran be followed and what's not in Quran not be followed.
Allah has said there's no forgiveness to people who manipulate his word by adding or subtracting to suit their narratives. Hence, if Allah has said follow, if Allah has not said don't follow.
In Islam, Allah is One, True & Supreme and None else.
@HALAL MILAN Where is it written in the Quran that Music & Dancing is Haram?
If a celebration is going to encourage festivities that are against Islam, like gender mixing, music, dancing or is part of another religious ritual, then it doesn't need to be in Quran to become Haram.
Do what you think is right brothers but I agree it's makrooh at very best. May Allah Guide and Protect us all. Ameen.
Music dancing and gender mixing isn’t haram either
Simone rule If u doing any thing ask proof for najayaz not ask for proof of whether it is jayaz
@HALAL MILAN music and dancing isn’t haram , allah loves ppl singing and dancing as long they remember allah , Allah won’t care 🙏
@HALAL MILAN thanks! I just know it’s not haram , it’s only haram if the music and dancing is inappropriate and using it to miss ur salah but casual music and dancing is totally halal
@@Cousinbiddy1 Assalamu Alaykum brother. I recommend you to not give any fatwas without proper knowledge, most scholars have given fatwas by looking at the evidences that music is haram. Any kind of musical instrument except the permissible ones are haram
Who is the your leader?
Yes ibnu abdul vahab...
Is Birthday wishes Haram?
no. Celebrating birthdays is haram. Yeah, you want to make due to Allah (SWT) whenever it's your birthday, asking Allah (SWT) to grant you a good life :D
@@southsponge3216 nonsense
@@Uno.Numero nonsense where?? They are saying make wishes to your god, which is good. Who do you pray too?? A cake or a god??
@@southsponge3216o, making a wish is haram, is the cake gonna make your wishes come true? Do you worship the cake? Do you pray to the cake??? No, so you shouldn't make birthday wishes. It's the same purpose as making a wish to Father Christmas (Santa Claus).
@@Bl00dsforbuddies He literally said "asking Allah", not praying to a cake smh. You can make a wish to Allah anytime, not just when it's your birthday 🤦♂
BIRTHDAYS ARE SHIRK. ABSOLUTELY NO OTHER WAY TO LOOK AT IT.
So who follow mr yasir kadi.... celebrate bday and according to him its halal....hmmm may Allah give him andnus all hidayat.
Dr. Yasir Qazi is absulutely right.
So do you follow Yasir Qadhi or our Prophet and the companions and the salaf?
Yasir Qadhi wants to win his wife luv by doung anually anniversary 😢cant u give her other surprises now and then..why wait for the anniversary invented by the mushrik?if Rasulu LLAH was here with us now would he have allowed such celebration?!!! So now it will become a must to all wives bcose Yasir said..and it will go on and on and Subhana ALLAH eventually fitna will occur..definitely..
so independence day celabration is haram?
Yes. Independence celebrations comes annually. Any annual celebration is haram. Listen to Dr.Zakir Naik lecture carefully.
Nationalism is haram to begging with.
@@ishratjahanisha977 why is it a religious event?
@@dan8643It's a religious celebration or annual event but it's not for Islam, Islam forbids any annual events like valentines day, fathers day, mothers day etc.
@@Bl00dsforbuddies valentine day is haram and we have no father's and mothers day because we think all days are father's and mother's days. But the birthday thing is a little different event. I have seen a video in which sheikh tells it was celebrated in pharaoh time and it's a pagan event. Something like that. You can search Sheikh Uthman birthday celebration . So i don't think we should celebrate it.
Dr. Zakir seems to be more christian than Muslim. So celebrating Birthday of Prophet Mohammed is against Islam as per Dr. Zakir. It's just Hypocrisy.
The 2 Eids and Jummah are general celebrations, I personally think we should be thanking and praising Allah every 2nd for keeping us alive, however for some people that's the only time they say Alhamdulillah, Dr. Yasir Qadhi's argument makes a lot of sense to me, we should not make everything in Islam haram especially when hadiths and Quran did not say anything about it. Let Personal happiness be the halal way. Salam
But our niyyat is not like moon worship.
But our prophets never celebrated birthdays, so you can't do it.
@@southsponge3216 Thay didn't even know when they were born, I personally don't throw a party or anything, but I do go with my mom to eat or shopping. I don't agree with this logic because a lot of things that are in this modern world were not in the times of our prophet sws. You tube, internet, cars, etc. Are all of this haram? no, can they be haram if we use it in certain ways. yes.
Zakir Naik and all those who call a birthday celebration 'Haram' should have their heads examined.
Firstly, Both of the Eids and Friday are celebrations of the Religion as in whole, while a birthday of an individual is a personal celebration wherein well wishes from his well wishers and families are blessed and bestowed upon him. They are two very different type of celebrations and a birthday celebration can also be looked upon as a celebration of the day when Allah gifted this individual a life.
Secondly, Islam is a free flowing religion, free flowing of thoughts and ideas, free flowing of exchange of blessings, free flowing of compassion, free flowing of goodness, free flowing of happiness and it should be kept that way and not get constricted which these dumb minded preachers intend on doing.
All I have to say is Celebrate every breath you take and offer your deepest gratitude to Allah for it. Islam does not constrict goodness and happiness. Celebrate your Birthdays and always dedicate a moment on your birthday to express your gratitude to Allah for gifting you this life this day.
Amen.
Eid can be celebrated but making wishes on birthdays are deprived from Pagan traditions. As the prophet (SAW) said, " Whoever imitates a people is one of them".
I agree with you, Islam is a free flowing religion allowing for happiness, however, remember that EVERY religion has restrictions. Allah has allowed you to be free, to be this and that, but does that mean you go against his rules?? The Quran?? No. Read the Quran, read the hadith. Allah knows best. Follow his words.
Once again I agree!! Wish for deepest gratitude to Allah and Inshallah we will all find happiness. But It's best to do it the way Allah has said so.
@@tozak196 no one is imitating the Eid Celebrations. I understand our Prophet's perspective that nothing can be celebrated as Eid as the Kings would be inclined to. I'm no king, so it is not for me, as long as I'm celebrating my birthday as a personal celebration and thank Allah on that day for giving me life and blessing me of being born in Islam, so why does it become Haram?
No human can determine what is Haram except Allah and the word of Allah is Quran, so if it is not in the Quran then it is not Haram.
@@Uno.Numero I wasn't talking about Eid imitations but of birthdays. You celebrating your birthday to give thanks to Allah is good! I said nothing against that, my point was on wishes you make during your birthday. Generally, that would be on candles and throwing party etc. Those act are deprived from traditions where we Muslims are not associated with. Only Allah and the Quran knows what is haram or not, that is a strong point I agree on, absolutely!! But this is where interpretation comes. Experts, like Muslim scholars will spend years reading, memorizing, and interpreting the Quran so it makes sense. We have no choice by to rely on those for now, until Allah reveals.
Astagfrullah you’re went too far….
@@benjaminsiba6161 how?
Mombatti nikaalo
Please tell this to Indian Actors
Salman Khan
Fardeen Khan
Aamir Khan
Saif Ali Khan
So many are there , dance on the floor with underwear and bikinis
They celebrate birthday and they were bokinis etc
Birthdays are not public they’re private events and have NOTHING to do with religion in our times please don’t make everything haraam.
In private or in public, glory is to Allah (swt). Birthday celebrations are haram.
Filthy
What's your evidence for your argument?
It has nothing to do with our religion but it has something to do with the pagans religion as they used to celebrate birthday as an act of worship
Dr. Yasir Qadhi is a fitnah in our religion of this time in doing this. It is scary to listen to this guy and he has more philosophical approach. 😮
Well that’s your opinion but as for me, he is one of the best scholars of our time and may Allah bless him with more knowledge.
You are the fitna
Just give more proof of why he considered fitnah brother that’s all!
Masha Allah, sheikh Yasir , Jazakallah khair. You speak the truth sincerely, may we be guided to more important issues facing our community.
It’s fitna because we are not supposed to copy the traditions of the nonbelievers! We’re not supposed to imitate them! Drink grape juice in a glass one glass is imitating drinking alcohol! That should feel wrong in your stomach. Not knowing that something is pagan worship isn’t an excuse to say to Allah swt “oh I didn’t know!” So I guess by his reasoning Halloween and Christmas would be acceptable too!
Birthday is 100% a pagan festival so don't know what you talking about Yasir & again anniversaries is also another western thing so are mothers, father's day, for us Muslims everyday is a blessing & if 1 by 1 will copy the non Muslims especially in rituals as birthday then in future we will accept anything so you are definitely WRONG because the Hadith of don't copy the non Muslims does apply to birthdays
Every country celebrates birthdays, it's not a Pagen festival. What God is being worshipped on a Birthday?
@@alexojideagu good question 😊 birthday was first celebrate by the phoroah for when a phoroah was born they would worship the phoroahs & then by the Roman pagans so on to Christian's who started idol worshipping with the cross & birth of God's son another God,,, now everyone wants to follow the trend even some Muslims are doing the same thing...
@@husnaimaan7006Just because the Pharaoh did it doesn't mean we're doing it because he did it. And aren't you supposed to make your kids happy in Islam? And besides, Milad-un-nabi was prophet Muhammad (SAW) birthday, and we Muslims still celebrate it. I think at it's worst, it's place is neutral. And if you sing happy birthday to someone, it's still okay. Singing isn't haram in itself, the instruments are, so you can sing without any music, as long as all the lyrics are not haram (swearing, sexual words etc). But I think buying something really unnecessarily expensive like expensive watches and expensive phones is haram because you're wasting far too much money. I think making a wish while blowing the candles is haram and you should make wishes (duas in this case) instead. And cake cutting is in no way at all haram. We all cut regular everyday things like pizza and pies all the time, so how is this any different??
But at the end of the day, Allah knows best.
@@king_mononykus if we start making exceptions then we can do whatever we want, prophet Muhammad pbuh said; do not copy other ppls religions not the pagans & birthday clearly is a pagan tradition done by the worst of ppl phoroah so muslims celebrating birthdays who's sunnah are they following? Their is a very good reason music is haram, not only it is a tool of the iblees but it will also be used by Dajjal,
Prophet Muhammad pbuh said do not mix haraam with halal...
It's not okay to make ur children happy by doing things you shouldn't like celebrating Christmas, Devali, vasaki ect like what many have started doing but they don't even follow their own religion..
When my birthday comes I just celebrate my mom I say it's here day. She the one who brought me in the world so celebrate her.
He is wrong
Crap logic
Yasir kadi you are out of control we don't believe you you are not a scholar
DR Shabeer Ali needs to look more deeper. This was pagant ritual and pharaoh practiced it.
Do not speak like a enemy of the prophet
Dr yassir qadhi check your words u ar misleading ummah
Where is the evidence that he's wrong?
Why would you stick the last video to waste the whole argument of kuffar celebration ? The last guy is untrustworthy
YASIR QADHI WRONG NUMBER 👎
Yasir is gone, his brain is in a state of hibernation. This man is realy fitnah
I dont agree with Yasir Qadhi. I will not learn from him at all.
There is another reason why birthdays are Haraam. chocolate cakes were not eaten during the time of our prophet. All cool cakes are new inventions. They are Bidah and that's why haraam. Because Bidah is haraam.
Whats the link between eating chocolate cakes and Bidah ?
Kkkkkkk hhhhhhh there were no car during prophet so stop driving car