Microsoft Windows Wants To Record Your Screen...
Vložit
- čas přidán 20. 05. 2024
- Hello guys and gals, it's me Mutahar again! This time we take a look at a new alarming feature that Microsoft wants to implement in upcoming versions of WIndows, a feature named Recall. This feature permits the system to take snapshots of your system to reflect on and becomes another useless feature powered by AI, should you switch to something more respectful? Probably. Thanks for watching!
Like, Comment and Subscribe for more videos! - Hry
“That ain’t artificial intelligence that’s a videotape.”
That’s a valid point actually.
From Microsoft’s own FAQ: "Note that Recall does not perform content moderation. It will not hide information such as passwords or financial account numbers."
This attack vector will be specifically targeted by hackers.
LLM isn't AI, anyways. It's just pattern recognition. My calling it computer collage is generous.
@@galeru and couldnt they have used their "AI" to just hide all that stuff loool.
@@washuai chatgpt is also just pattern recognition. so is that not ai either? it doesnt matter what AI means if it seems like AI its valid for companies to use the term
@@luxemierAI is a term that has come to mean "any time a computer acts intelligently based on input" which covers everything from chatGPT to the behavior trees used in that one Alien game.
Can someone start a class action law suit for invasion of privacy? Sign me up.
It is possible to win in the EU. Idk about America
@@YTDani75 Good luck 😂
@@YTDani75 I mean, they've gotta have an office there _somewhere.._
You might wanna check them ToS you agreed too but didn't read
@@officialnucky ToS are only applicable when they can be enforced, and they can only be enforced when the backlash for doing so doesn't out weight the benefit from doing it.
There's a very clear way to solve this problem: make the cost too high to pay. Make them afraid to.
It's a "locally stored recording", for now. Watch them offer cloud storage for that recording, for "ease of recovery" or some such shit, within 3-5 updates.
Slow boil
I was wondering that too
And it will be compulsry just like edge 😂🤣
each day we are closer to Cyberpunk 2077 but without the cool gadgets
you do realize that windows 11 has one drive enabled by default right? like you have to opt out of your files being stored on someone else's hardware.
Every breath you take
And every move you make
Every bond you break
Every step you take
I'll be watching you
PoLiCe 👮👮👮
Microsoft taking notes from the Diddler, we should've known smh
That's fine my life is boring and probably won't go on for much longer anyways
Saurons eye
@@gladteer873Hello, fellow brother with a really boring life!
Privacy is a human right.
you mean getting it or do you mean someones own Privacy?
desire*
Did you watch the video? It all happens locally, it won't be sent to their servers
@@verybadosuplayer9033 lol ya imagine thinking that, your info is not being stolen, its just being logged
@@EAGLEVISION666 Not even microsoft has enough money to store screencaps of every windows user LOL
2014 Microsoft: Fighting spyware with Microsoft Defender
2024 Microsoft: Installing spyware with Microsoft Recall
"The only spyware allowed is ours"
only took them 10 years
I mentioned that Spyware like this used to be illegal in another CZcams comment… it got deleted
Satya Nadella became CEO in 2014. Coincidence? I think not.
@@SeeJayPlayGames If you're point is "woman CEO = bad", then it really falls apart. You know full well every other rich person is also using "AI" to spy on people. And even before the AI craze, there were other reasons to do so. When it's men doing it, it's blamed on them being rich. If it's women doing it, it's blamed on them being women and is proof "all women are bad".
If this problem is because of Satya being CEO, then all this bs would've happened WAY earlier. It wouldn't have taken A DECADE.
Say goodbye to your password security folks.
My passwords don't appear on screen even once. I don't know what you're doing that they do. I'm much more worried about how much more believable these "I have recordings of you watching porn" scams are now going to be...
@@IdiotamSpielenProblem is they'll also keep track of mouse movement and key inputs.
@@thenonexistinghero password manager ctrl+c, ctrl+v... if you don't do that your passwords were never secure in the first place.
They don't want you to use passwords anymore lol. Maybe this is a part of the plan?
“Implementing retinal scan; please hold still…”
Hey Windows,
are you listening on me right now?
Windows: No.
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Hal9000 , what are you doing Dave?
lol
Windows "No you are not that special"
What a good argument, you talk as smart as a Windows fan, don't you?
Remember when the marketing pitch for win 10 was that it's the final windows
The final windows you'll want to use.
The final one before they turn you into glass
I remember when I called Microsoft and asked them if there was going to be a new release of Windows and they told me no.
They dropped a fat L on my head that day. I pirated Windows from 98 all the way to 8.1. Never paid them a cent, because only clowns pay for zeroes and ones. When I heard Windows 10 was going to be the last I felt a little guilty and didn't want to miss my last chance to "make things right" with Microsoft... so I paid them full price for my copy of Windows 10. Little did I know the one version of Windows I actually paid for would be the worst one yet, and the one to finally drive my pilgrimage to the holy land of Linux.
It will be last legacy x86 os. Win 11 "supports" x86 legacy but only on modern TPM 2 hardware. Windows is going to the Walled Garden and Planned Obsolescence route of Mac in cahoots with the PC big box makers in order to artificially drive sales of newer hardware, even though there's really no need for it. By the time Windows 11 dies, you will need to upgrade your hardware in order to update google chrome to latest version.
So my wife is a counselor, and sees some clients online. This would be a massive HIPPA violation for her and any medical professionals who do online consultations.
This be true, especially for my doctor sis and her husband, whose a doctor. Then my other sis who works as a medical scientist, doing work up on people's lab results and so on. I think Microsoft didn't think that far with this. At least for lawsuits. Thanks, I'll warn my siblings not to even consider updating to w11. :o
ITS OPT IN, YOU DONT HAVE TO USE IT. STOP LISTENING TO THESE SO CALLED TECH EXPERTES WHO ARE ONLY GAMERS
@@alexmiu4070 Yes, ignore this feature that gets installed without your consent, "just turn it off bro".
Imagine this as a person who shows up in your home one day to watch all you do (for your benefit, of course), and you are told that the person won't record what you are doing unless you say "yes". Wouldn't you still be creeped out that they're there to begin with?
have her buy a device that doesn't have it .
@@alexmiu4070to be fair Muta actually does detail that you can turn it off and control what data it stores however you like, and that it’s all stored locally on your system and not sent to any servers
I'm the guy who left the reddit comment at the end of this video. I keep using Windows because I rely on a lot of niche software for work (I'm a VFX artist/animator). A lot of the tools I use don't even have a competitor, let alone a Linux version. I've tried running a dual boot of Linux and I constantly found myself returning to Windows for various tasks.
To be honest, manually installing critical updates and running shutup10++ every other week isn't much of a burden - although I'd rather do without it.
Idk if it would solve your problem but I know muta has stated in other videos he'll emulate windows in a virtual machine to run certain games that don't run on linux. Might be able to do the same to run your software.
Not even WINE gets you a working version on Linux? Damn, that's rough. But some things do depend on Nvidia AI integration. Good luck man.
@@jishani1 I'm gonna be real, running editing software in a VM is rarely a fun time.
@@benjamindourney7716 Yeah, any software that has specific and/or requirements runs on Windows 11, for example VR and graphic stuff, that's what i mostly use, and neither VM nor Linux can keep up with the updates and needs i have, so "Windows bad, windows bad" chant is well heard, but there's little to nothing that us creators can do about it, we are already packed with graphic stuff, and this is more like coding and tech savvy stuff, beside this function is for paying users, only with time we shall see how this will end up
Microsoft Recall must at least be an optional feature that the user must activate on their own as it is not only a spyware but also because it consumes a lot of storage as well.
I would go further. It must only be downloadable DLC like the power toys.
They don’t care. It’s not their decision to deploy this surveillance software. The orders are coming from higher places.
@@JadtyI agree with you....we are heading into a 1984 dystopia kind of trash😅 China has clearly set an example with their credits system...and i knew it was only a question of time here too.
they activated one drive local file stealer err i mean "cloud storage" by default on wind 11, its a opt out only "feature". no such luck.
Give it time they’ll use AI as a scape Goat to justify mandatory online verification cause it will be the only way to verify you’re actually talking to a human
"AI, please stop recording my screen and sending my information to Microsoft and third parties."
"I'm sorry, Dave. I can't do that."
Lol yup
Fr
That looks like a Linux Ubuntu distro you downloaded.
What are you doing D A V E?
1 million likes hahaha
@@TKUltra971while (base) Ubuntu is more privacy respecting than windows it is still spyware
Microsoft is trying to speedrun becoming the worst company across all of their business sectors
Don't forget the individuals that go along with this so they can get paid. We can and should blame the company, but remember it's made up of people. Evil people.
microsoft has been doing evil supervillain stuff like this for decades
Wouldn't be surprised if this was their second or third run for it.
All companies are doing this crap Sony is going full minority report with biometric scans and Microsoft is doing this crap cyberpunk is a dystopian fiction genre not a user manual
Microsoft has really never operated in good faith… like ever. There was however a time when I could say I happily enjoyed Windows without much worry… that time died with Windows 7.
If privacy isn't privacy, then privacy isn't privacy.
The first rule of the tautology club is the first rule of the tautology club.
"Most secure Windows computer" and yet they pushed a Windows 10 update that gave me a FULL SCREEN POPUP UNPROMPTED saying how I couldn't update to Windows 11 and telling me how to. Yeah no, lmao, I don't trust that they wouldn't silently patch in an update that sends those screenshots to a server of some sort. The annoying part of their wording is that you "pause" that AI stuff. I don't want to "pause" it, I want it OFF.
I'd love to switch to Linux, but my understanding is that stuff isn't as plug & play as Windows.
Depends. Some stuff is more plug and play than Windows, and some less. You could give it a try for free and see if you like it.
@@Lestibournes I once tried to switch from Windows to Linux. It didn't go well for me. Lol.
@@DepravityWriting It happens.
Linux had more built-in hardware support than Windows, but windows has more drivers available to install.
Linux has lots of software, but there are still certain niches where sime critical piece of software is missing, whether MS Office, Adobe products, or professional CAD software. Alternatives exists, but they're often not good enough for professional use, or aren't sufficiently compatible.
But for regular home users and some professional uses Linux is usually superior. It provides a better user experience, better UI, runs better on older and weaker hardware while looking beautiful and being responsive, is more stable, and lets you have full control and respects your privacy.
@@Lestibournes I'll confess, I installed Linux uh, I forget what it was. One of the more popular distros. I formatted the hard drive for it using that special file system and everything. But I couldn't get the thing to work seamlessly as a bootable device. Every attempt I made to goto Linux has been a spectacular failure. It didn't just 'work' like Windows does. I didn't even get to the point of installing apps and stuff because it simply would not boot after making a partition and blah blah installing etc. So I reinstalled, using a thumb drive iso basically. Same problem. Even though the SSD formatting was correct. Anyway - if I were to successfully get it to work, how many additional hurdles would I face to simply play the video games I want to play on steam, or Star citizen, etc?I have a high end computer.
@@DepravityWriting This is exactly why I'm tired of pc nerds like myself suggesting linux to your average user. Yes, Linux is arguably better in a lot of ways IF and only if you know what you're doing. Your average user doesn't want the hassle and doesn't have the knowledge to do things easily or intuitively that Windows does. Linux users will always point to some new feature that fixes one part of the many problems a normal tech illiterate user will run into, but there's always plenty of more. Unfortunately, on a topic like this you'll run into a lot of normal users who don't understand the context of the situation looking for answers because they saw a headline, vid, or a tech literate friend said something.
TLDR; Stop recommending linux to everyday people. They don't have the niche knowledge to make it work as seamlessly as windows and that really matters.
I'm sick of my processing power being stolen by legal hackers.
It is amazing how much of a computer's resources get used by windows.
Putting a SSDs in old Pentium 3 computers to run win 98 for old games to run on original hardware, is funny, scary fast load times after bios prompt.
Windows is so full of uh, other stuff, nowadays. Even windows 10 needs tweaking to get a pleasant experience out of using it.
Maybe, just maybe, Microsoft will revert to a windows format like XP, because windows 11 is HOT GARBAGE.
*laughs in linux*
@@clementpoon120🎉😂 so true
@@clementpoon120 linux is not much better nowadays, its just 10 years behind windows
@@monad_tcp In which ways? The main issue I see with Linux today is standardization (such are the woes of open source) and compatibility (which comes down to companies to support it and is not an integral flaw in Linux). But what sets it 10 years behind Windows?
Back in my day we called this "spyware"
Thanks, that was the term I was looking for.
Yes, I remember those times also. Just imagine how people would have reacted if this came with Windows XP? Or if for example Facbook released that same app they have today in 2004? Those companies would have been shut down for doing that. But today we happily run that stuff.
Win10/11 already has been spyware for years. I once did the math based on Microsoft's own bragging in their marketing and the result was around 4-8 datapoints collected per minute and sent to MS on each PC. I guess MS hopes people are just impressed by big numbers without thinking about what they mean.
Back in my day we called this no Vaseline and no reach around
was that yesterday or 20 years ago i am not sure
Ugh this is worse than the Minecraft situation! Why the actual fuck was Microsoft allowed to get away with this in the first place!?
Because the western digital world is slowly turning into the CCP.
no competition
What Minecraft situation, specifically?
Remember back in the day, nortns and the like accused or suspected of having government back-doors
This just another example maybe lol
@@tomsmith8515 I don't know what that is as that probably occurred before I was born
Switched from Windows to Linux few years back already. For the last few years I used Windows, you could see the downhill. More telemetry, more restrictions, more "as-a-service" bullshit.
Now, I am actually the admin of my computer.
Which Linux do you use? Mint? I'm thinking of switching and I need help on how to set it up.
@@blackagent4754 Pop!_OS for now. I have Nvidia GPU, so that's why I chose Pop. It's been developed by System76, a company selling linux PC's, and they are very good at implementing nvidia drivers into their OS.
@@blackagent4754 how comfortable are you with things like the command line and editing bootloader entries? If you're more comfortable and willing to troubleshoot things, fedora or a fedora spin (KDE, probably) isn't a bad way to go. If you want something basic that resembles windows, I'd use mint. The thing about Linux is that there is no perfect OS and different ones are better-suited for different individuals with different use cases.
@@benjamindourney7716 I'm not comfortable with those at the moment. However, for now I'm going back to Windows 10 until then. Thanks for the advice and letting me know!
@@blackagent4754 no problem, one option is installing mint in a virtual machine and just going from there, and switching when you're comfortable. don't be afraid to look things up, good luck.
The first thing I did with AI Copilot was figure out how to disable AI Copilot.
I literally asked co pilot 'how do I turn you off?'
Wait! There's an ability to shut it off? Lay it on me, man! Tell me how you can take off AI.
@@Xero42literally same!!
Same with Cortana and the Windows app store. I hate unnecessary shit I didn't ask for!
Same here.
Really loving how, each and every update, Microsoft loves to just do anything they can *but* fix Windows. That’s too much.
fixing windows, you mean, not installing any of that crap and just letting it be Windows7
@@monad_tcpfixing the theme file that is not updated since 2014 (with old textures, no dark mode, old animations), removing all the new stuff in explorer and build it using the “native” layer (I can send you a picture of what it looks like if you do that, and it looks amazing), make web apps be native ones, make WinUI 3 theme aware with msstyles (or ditch completely WinUI; if they do this, they make the rendering of windows modular, flexible, and very very easy to update for them in the future; all you’d need to do is to change some strings and some bitmaps inside what’s essentially a zip archive), remove many of the new things (web search, since with it, the new search is worse than on Vista; widgets, make them native if you want them at all; reccomended section, make it native; copilot: we don’t need it literally everywhere and in different versions, and if they want it at least make it native; edge, don’t make it so annoying and clean up a lot of the design and the feature set), set a default look for all apps *that all inbox apps should follow* (e.g. now inbox apps have different designs for the most stupid things, they have the same stuff worded or structured differently just for the sake of it, its all useless) etc etc etc. The list of stuff that needs fixing essentially since 2014 is incredibly big.
@@monad_tcpor Linux
Fix it yourself...
@@awwwwhhhyeahhhh Already did with the majority of the stuff, still laughable that isn’t done by Microsoft.
*2007:* Sorry Linux i leave you, we tried, it was nice, but it doesn't work, you're too complicated for me.
*2024:* Hi Linux ... sorry for calling you so late. I've been thinking about you a lot lately. You were right my ex OS is a stalker!
What? Now you are a better OS? I've matured too ... I'm ready to try again ♥
This needs to be a more popular/viral copypasta, I tell you what!
Ending: And so *Person* and Linux were finally happy together, Linux became the best OS in 2025 and Windows 11 falls, eventually Microsoft loses so much money and sales of the Xbox that they go bankrupt, and everyone switches to using Linux, and or Mac, The End.
after hearing this, i just switched from Windows 11 to Ubuntu 24.04LTS, thanks Mutahar!
You did a great job by switching to Linux.
I myself switched to linux just a week ago and my computer doesn't overheat on Minecraft anymore.
Enjoy your new slow computer with SNAPS. Ubuntu sucks with their slow loading SNAPS. SNAPS kills the Linux experience for me. I detest them more than any Windows machine. Have fun with that.
@@riseabove3082 lol its running better than windows 11 so far
lol it runs better than windows 11
@@riseabove3082 such a weird comment dude, stay in ur lane
LOL at the fact the built in screen recorder will record your bank account number but Netflix has managed to make sure it's disabled for their video hosting, very obvious where the priorities lay with this software.
I'm going to scream at this point, we can't have shit anymore.
I think it's moreso that Netflix will sue Microsoft if the screen recorder worked on the video player and a giant lawsuit is more costly than whatever forced arbitration that MS would force the affected people into
To be fair that's not really about microsoft's decision it is more about netflix caring more about their profits than banks caring about user's money. Which was always a given.
And here I've been thinking it sounds like a key stroke logger. More so, it sounds like stuff some companies were doing with their office computers. Where they got caught using key stroke loggers and screen recorders under the guise of being for "office security". AKA, Spyware.
It also sounds like a GREAT reason to NEVER use any form of public computer. whether it be in a school, a library, university or TAFE centre.
Scammers would go nuts with joy if they can pull whatever file stores the information from this program. A treasure trove of gold incrusted personal information and secrets.
They want to know that you’re not looking at misinformation during the next plandemic
Microsoft saying your data is yours stored locally. Is like Apple saying your old photos that are deleted from our server and can never be retrieved and we care about user privacy.
I knew from the get go not to trust any company stomping for AI, and I was right. AI in fantasy always ended up being used for evil. Why is reality any different?
Outbound firewall for all of their services on windows.
There are one process called Windows 11 AI Host, if you can find a way to lock this out it should be ok.
@@CarTastic-fv6eo Just make a Tiny11 without all of that crap
Very true
I remember Prism back from the Snowden NSA days. Glad to see Microsoft picked it up and reimplemented the project.
Microsoft is doing everything to make Linux more and more attractive.
From the Title alone:
That seems illegal from a Privacy standpoint alone...
Not when you agree to the terms of service before you use their hardware.
@@jonvon2044You mean "forced to agree"
@@jonvon2044 It still is.
ToS just serves as a bullshit excuse.
You’re not forced to pay for Copilot Pro and a Copilot laptop.
@@goofyahdemoman1134 You're not forced to smoke meth
They aren't even trying to hide it at this point lmao
They literally gaurunteed that this information isnt stored, isnt used to train the models, and its only on when you turn it on...
@@awwwwhhhyeahhhh oh right, who wouldn’t trust Microsoft right? /s
@@awwwwhhhyeahhhh hey did you know when a politician says they really care about *you*, yes you [specific person 10013632475278456138254386294] that they mean it? You are valued, do vote for [Insert] political party, they won't increase taxes or make your life worse.
@@Infelious OK...I work in tech, not politics, that's not how the tech industry works, no matter how much conspiracy CZcams videos may try to convince you otherwise.
@@awwwwhhhyeahhhhboots aren't lollipops. You don't have to lick them.
Muta, talk about the option in MS Edge (which is enabled by default) that literally takes screenshots of websites you visit and uploads to MS's cloud. It's in the browser setting, under Privacy, labelled "Save screenshots of sites for history"
On by default? It's switched off here, and I didn't change that setting ever. So it's off by default, at least in W11 pro
@@Thijs_NL I appreciate you think that way but you're mistaken. If you sign in to Windows with your MS account, it will sync settings between PC's if you sign into two (or more) computers using the same account. I won't reply past this.
there is no mention of uploading them to MS Cloud in the settings, is there proof for this
it says "We will take screenshots of the sites you visit and save them so that you can quickly revisit the sizes you want by hovering over your history results in the history hub."
@@ivanzivkovic7572probably a disinformation
Many sites have already been doing something similar for years, but without AI.
My office wanted me to install a software that would basically record every client session and upload it to our cloud. I tested it by watching my own previous recorded sessions and then I watched some other clients sessions as well. Never felt so icky just for doing my damn work
I feel bad for the fella that has to watch my search history
Lol
God bless the normal Microsoft employees seeing our search history’s
Reminds me of South Park, Toilet Security Administration
@@MrRyukage thanks for reminding me about that one scene lol
Bros not gonna make it past the first entry without putting a hole in his desk.
It's all stored locally... until it's not!
All depends on Microsofts defnition of Local. If they mean on our own machines then look forward to MS eating up your storage space on your drives. If they mean locally as in their own cloud servers then look forward to all your data being sold on to every adverstiser in the world.
It can certainly be stored locally, but that certainly doesn't mean that it doesn't report important keywords or complete fingerprint data back to their servers and sold to advertising, law enforcement, political companies, etc
It doesn't say that microsoft is not allowed to get a sample from it.
@@VirtualTrucker74 Oh yeah thinking about this aren't Microsoft developing a online only OS, forgot the name but it means it won't be stored locally... so by default locally is there server right?
ye coz microsoft can store hundreds of millions of users data every second until the endtime 😭 get a grip bro learn how this works before being paranoid.
I am glad that I listened to Muta and moved over to Linux. Complete side note is that a PSP Go, that is a blast from the past.
Bonzi Buddy wasn’t a monster… He was just ahead of the curb
The scary thing is the companies that will buy these for employees. I bet employee work tracking will be a thing for business version of windows. Same with schools.
They are allowed todo this , many companies use this to record the activity .
Witj ai recording and sending a full rapport to the boss will become a norm and a ligal trojan.
Many trojans/virus programmers are trying to add ai to it.
actually thats legal when it comes to business computers
@@MyVlogTubes Why trojan and not just spyware? Trojan encompasses more than spyware. What spies is just spyware.
Not bappening where proprietary data is handled. Ever. These mofos route CCTV through a firewall 300 miles away because part of the workstations are in the DMZ.
That is the moment when I'll go work in a farm
Businesses should be pushing back on this hard. Because if this is recording anything on a business computer, it’s gonna make business espionage a big issue.
And despite what Muta is claiming, do you really trust Microsoft to not screw this up? Because they do not have a great track record when it comes to the Internet figuring out ways to break their stuff.
EDIT: Just wanted to add that Muta is right about switching to Linux. If you really gave a damn about your privacy, you need to stop whining and just DO IT. If something has a learning curve, it’s usually worth doing.
Don't worry, all those companies collaborating with M$ will have the version free of all this that is absolutely not available to the public.
"You can turn it off", some are saying. Like windows hasn't been busted multiple times secretly turning stuff back on with updates or doing stuff anyway in the background even if it's Off...
@@Dexter01992 Again, you’re assuming Microsoft is competent enough to ensure that. Which I’m saying, THEY ARENT.
Only a company sucker would think that their data is safe with another corporation with no incentive to protect their assets.
i mean they can claim that stuff is stored locally and deleted properly all they want but we have seen what it is
we have seen how well ios "deletes" photos
there's no trusting these tech companies with your data anymore
"If you really gave a damn about your privacy, you need to stop whining and just DO IT."
-sigh-
Goddamnit, you're fucking right.
🗣🔥
Love the OOSU++ plug. That tool is incredibly helpful.
i didn’t see it mentioned but this could also be used in abuse situations where the abuser could use this to look at their victims web history. and Microsoft if they move forward with recall will literally give them exactly everything the victims don’t want them to see.
any research or correspondence on them trying to leave/get themselves/kids/family or friends to safety or help.
or research into medical/things abusers don’t want them to see or read/watch about that would go against everything the pushed on their victims.
and even if they try to erase that history it be VERY obvious whats missing and when it missing.
Everything is processed locally, phew. Good thing I’ve never heard of a big tech company abusing access to customer data before
Wouldn’t you be able to use a packet sniffer or just look at your internet when idle and figure out if they’re streaming your screen pretty easily? Plus the infrastructure needed for that would be crazy.
It’d be more likely IMO that (when local AI models are efficient and integrated into Windows) the screen is recorded, data is gathered locally based on that and sent to Microsoft. Make the users’ PC do the hard work for you :)
Yeah for 6 months until a TOS update comes out and they can not only access the data, but sell it.
"It's only local ((but fine print: we'll not export your desktop images! Hahaha, Heavens no! ...just some key data points, metrics and meta data... for functionality use ONLY trust me bro"
5 versions later and updates, paraphrased: "Well... we pretty much send everything to NSA and all meta data to advertising companies and they will ofcoz handle your privacy really good... we get a kick back and it will surely improve your life quality! Trust me bro"
And they definitely never lie!
Microsoft really likes the idea of "Year of Linux desktop" huh...
yet, Linux is not "capitalizing" on that.
Windows is losing to MacOS , of all things, a more closed and bullshit thing than it
We have been talking about the "Year of Linux desktop" for decades.
The debate over privacy issues in the current digital age is never ending. Surveillance cam is a perfect example. It's safe to be skeptical about privacy assurance from Microsoft, because as users we are right in demanding transparency in corporations handling our data.
Completely agree with you on pretty much every single point made!! It’s a MASSIVE problem.
Windows 10 really was the last version of Windows
If it weren't for so many good games only being on ten I'd be on a custom version of seven
2025 is the death of 10 😢
Best time to be alive for Linux users, I feel so much more intelligent.
@@MarquisDeSang It's like Valve saw this coming and invested heavily on bringing Linux gaming to get it to the point where almost all games just work with proton.
@@bradmiles1984 They all work as long as you have an AMD gpu. NVIDIA never fix their broken driver so once in a while a game that works on Linux will not work with nvidia. My next gpu is an AMD trust me.
no. windows 8.1 one was. even with its flaws, it didn't have heavy M$ monitoring
Remember when the desktop is just sat by and did what you wanted?
Mine still does. Linux chads eating good.
@@piked86 Yup, it's the only way. Microsoft is evil, only way to deal with them is to refuse to use or purchase their shit. I'm going full Linux
Yeah thx to Steam Deck also Linux User here
I'd use linux, really, but I can't. I use my computer for gaming, and I just can't play many games, as my computer isn't good enough to really handle a virtual machine with more intensive games. For me, it is better to just use shutup and privatezilla etc.
@@k.w.6626 That's the only reason I still have a windows machine at all, the games I've already paid for. I'm shrinking my Windows install to a single old SSD though, dual-booting, so everything else can be Linux and I'll just have the one drive essentially as a gaming console exclusively (at least until companies like Ubisoft decide that I don't own those anymore either)
Recall needs to be RECALLED
FBI spying on us but now woohoo the FBI Windows Professional Edition with XplayStation 6!
It's also a way to fill up a person's hard drive with non-content, thereby forcing people to buy new storage even though they don't actually need more storage.
Yeah im wondering about the performance impact of this AI too. This seems terrible for older devices which are forced to upgrade to win 11 and dont have these AI optimisations.
The storage usage is by default limited to 25GB, and most of these new laptops have 1TB at least. I don't see a problem here.
@@vodkawhisperer3923that's the neat part. You will not get those AI features at all if you do not have the NPU
@@davidpodeszwa7010 well at least that good, but trust me, win 10 is unusable on older devices (2012) and i know from experience
@@davidpodeszwa7010if enabled by default I see an issue with that.
If this becomes mandatory for Windows then I'm absolutely switching to another platform.
same sentiment. ill switch over to linux and figure out VMs if it comes to that point.
@@kazesh9148 same
Would the de-bloating software work to get rid of this?
I’m staying, I have nothing to hide and I support windows.
I've convinced most of my friends to look into Linux, much more customizable and there isn't an evil billionair running the company.
Aight Muta’s linux tutorial is gonna come in handy right about now
As soon as I heard about this "feature" I was looking forward to your take on the subject.
I'm at the verge of half-switching to linux. Sort of having windows on one drive and linux on another, with boot loader set to let me choose which I want to run each time I start the PC up.
I think it's a nice way to ease myself into switching. I'll run what I can on linux and switch back to windows for the odd task, that I don't know how to perform on linux just yet
I played Cyberpunk 2077.
We really don’t want this.
Well, most of us playing Cyberpunk 2024...
@@TKossiand most of us didn't walk away going" I want this future. Nice neon lights. Hehehe'
Sorry. You had 69 likes and I ruined it.
We still gonna get this. And we will pay for it. You don't use it? Great, you are used. You still HAVE to pay. You are a human cell in their worldwide system. You are a transistor with sensors and a 24/7 connection (your mobile).
There is no coming back from today.
I played Deus Ex.
Yeah, me neither.
Me to Win 10: Perhaps I treated you too harshly
Man I remember being so opposed to updating from win7 to 10... Never thought I'd be clinging to it later
Aside from being unable to easily uninstall basic MS bloat, I can at least run Classic Shell and have the regular control panel back. I still have problems with sample rates competing for command of my audio interface when I run multiple programs, but at least everything works in Windows 10.
But I do sincerely miss how good 7 and XP were.
@@12ealDealOfficial I've got rid off all bloatware and made sure no more can be added. I thought I wanted windows 7. Now I actually kinda like Windows 10
No. Windows 10 and 11 suck.
@@RiruRana Yeah that sounds awfully familiar...
"Clippy"
That bring me back a long time ago.
If it ever runs automatically or without the user's knowledge or its not obvious that it is active that's an absolutely no-go.
Imagine if OBS did that, automatically start up and begin recording in the background, even by accident that'd be a massive deal.
The fact that it's attached to some AI makes everything so much worse. You don't really need an AI to organize a bunch of sequential images. I'm like 80% sure this just exists as a means to generate training data.
i don't know how privacy laws look in the US, but in the EU they are very strict. so haveng these recording features turned on by default alone could allredy raise enough red flags to have this system baned.
Privacy in the us? Hahaha
I hope the EU will ban that BS AI-Crap by MS
Did you watch the video? It all happens locally, it won't be sent to their servers
@@verybadosuplayer9033Surely
@@verybadosuplayer9033 yet
Bruh this is invasion of privacy with extra steps.
Companies who want to micromanage their employees would love this.
you can disable it
No, no there is no extra steps. You must of read that somewhere and thought was cool. Then tried to use it in your own sentence and ya fucked it up
@@absolutelyfookinnobody2843 you used the word "is" when you should have used "are"...
videocalls and convos are gonna be fun now
It's hilarious how next to this video about Windows 11 security, CZcams recommends me a video of how you should never connect Windows XP to the internet for security. Huh, I WONDER IF THERE IS A SIMILARITY.
They're not even good at manipulating us
what no competition does to an os
True
They are consistently loosing users to macOS. But it’s true they still have majority market share so doesn’t say too much.
factaul
@@hanes2mac os will not take off sadly because windows is installable on any garbage ever. Macs don’t. Apple needs to make budget mac to get more users
@@pracalt1051 also, macOS isn’t multi purpose like Windows has been for decades. macOS is designed for personal device. Many Windows computers is not personal item. It may be an office computer doing X. Or just a headless pc that runs something… so that’s a lot of PCs… However Microsoft making it more difficult with win10/11 to make it a useful computer outside a personal item.
Ah yes, Thanks Muta for showing me each time how the world is heading into a cyberpunk dystopia
we're there. one day youll see
I mean that would be pretty dope!! Im gonna go full chrome!! Hopefully i dont go cyberpsychosis.. lol
Except not as cool and hardly tech and we’re slowly becoming a third world nation
There will be no governments. Just big ass corporations that will rule everything.
@@snowleopardd Nah i'd say since the devonian period.
damn that was a good goon session last week, let's run it back
My security cameras point at my doors and windows.
I do not have them in my bedroom and toilet.
Microsoft really needs to learn to differentiate what is good for the CUSTOMER and what is good for THEM.
You seem to confuse who are Microsoft's customer are, if you are thinking you, me or your neighbor you couldn't be more wrong, we are the resource our data is their product and it's the companies that use our data which are their customers.
@@haroldcruz8550 Last I heard windows was commercial software you have to pay for? This is not a "if it's free you are the product" situation, they are double dipping thieves.
They can record me starting one of their exclusive games, playing it for 10 minutes and uninstalling it
Lol
New to your channel and I just had to get a new computer with Windows 11. So with that said, what OS do you recommend that is less invasive than W11 or do you have vids that help to shut down these features, although I know windows is constantly updating to eliminate community workarounds. Advice? Recommendations?
God bless Mutahar, man.
Privacy aside, wouldn't that also quickly eat up bandwidth and/or storage space?
Did you watch the video? It all happens locally, it won't be sent to their servers
it is 200 gigabytes at the moment. and screenshots every time the screen changes. So watching a video it will screenshot at least 100 times.
@@verybadosuplayer9033 Remember unity. Well they changed their fine print to make its users need to give them a percent of money from all downloads. Even on free games. Can you with 100 percent certainty say that microsoft won't do something similar by clouding the information my dude?
so you have to buy cloudspace, which many current phones did when they stopped adding a way to install a SIM for more space (they want You to store Data on Their PCs instead).
@@verybadosuplayer9033THANK YOU! everyone is sensationalising this, and Microsoft literally said, this wont be stored anywhere, wont be visible to them, and wont be used to train future or existing models.
imagine doing taxes, work and other sensitive stuff. not only can some one else come on ur pc and rewind. but once the cloud gets hacked again. everyone's life, secrets info and more is now on a plate. like a giant library of cctv footage of your life. now before people say this happens already. it dose but a huge amount of crime is crime of opportunity. why risk and do hard work when u can just cut out all that and ind it in one spot.
because Microsoft is going crazy with these AI stuff
So don't use it
@@Aylmayomeme And also force all your friends, family, coworkers and every organisation who has your data to not use it? You're digitally intertwined. To be fair though phones are worse than that already.
@@Bozebo It's going to be an optional download/optional to use/optional to sign up to
If you can't read what it does or understand what it's going to do, you shouldn't be on a computer connected to the internet
There’s no AI .. only programmed logic/task management software. It’s only as smart as the programmers instructions.
Last time Windows added a feature I wanted was going 64bit for memory size and when they finally quit the seeming requirement to reboot after a change of IP number. (LAN event setup was always a pain). I have hated every bloaty update since, I don't care much about a snazzy GUI, I don't play Windows, I do some CAD, Word Excel processing and Gaming.
Multi-monitor was a nice stepping stone... but so is just to buy a larger monitor.
Yeah, why would you have dedicated monitors for things when you could get one really annoyingly large monitor and have to resize EVERYTHING manually to be able to multitask as well as running into constant desync issues playing games that were never designed to operate at the resolution you're pushing? Who would want things to be organized and not annoying?
"Lol they think we aren't already doing this" - MS 2024
Exactly my thoughts. ...the only difference now is they want to let the user play with it.
This sounds like a perfect tool for companies to keep tabs on people who still work remotely from home
Companies that let people work from home usually give work laptops/desktops with a feature that allows them to see your screen in real time and some even have it actually recording
Also for companies that let you use personal computers they also usually have a piece of software you need to download in order to lock down that computer while you are working and usually that also allows them to monitor your screen and everything
They already have SEVERAL methods of doing this, AWS Workspaces is one of them. Every two-bit cloud service has this, they've had it for years now.
@@jacktringoli3299 When my fiance was on work from home, we just needed a secured connection and he accessed his work stuff through a secured portal.
Good thing my company and most others I've worked at effectively ban Windows because it's inherently insecure :)
@@jacktringoli3299 Gotta love making people pay for the company's office space and equipment from their net income and have to pay the full tax on that too...
I only have Windows PC's for gaming, for anything else I use Ubuntu and Debian as my daily, but - this is even making me think its time to start looking at Linux gaming, and going full-Linux for everything.
This combined with the message there would be no updates for Windows 10 after 2025 pulled the trigger for me. I'm hopping to Linux as my main operating system for home use, probably an Arch/Fedora based distro optimized for gaming (Ubuntu ain't much better than windows on the privacy front).
I've been using it for work/coding for a long time and after testing a few games on my work device I expect the experience to be relatively smooth. Hope everyone else thinks about hopping OS too, there has never been a better time and reason.
As they announced this for windows 11 they also quietly pushed an update forward that will cut support from windows 10 in 2025..
Sounds going to Mutahar's video about installing linux distros should be handy.
Are you also gonna complain that they dont support vista anymore? How long do they need to support out dated versions of the software?
@@ZeallustImmortal🤓
@@ZeallustImmortal Windows 10 hasn't been out for long at all. My computer still works perfectly and I got it at the very end of the cycle for windows 10. Meanwhile windows XP had support for many years after its initial release. This support effects security which means that you're being forced to upgrade or even buy an entirely new hardware for your safety. A lot of people HATE windows 11, but since not enough people switched to it, they are forcing it. THIS is a really shitty move that means they don't have to listen to the consumer and what the consumer wants. Instead of listening to the consumer and creating a version of windows that people actually like, they're saying "You have no choice so you'll buy what we give you".
I mean, by that point it'll be 10 years old, doesn't seem all that out of the ordinary. Would be roughly the same life span as 7
when Microsoft gets a data breach people are doomed, that's why i disable every shitty "AI" feature and telemetry
Same. I dispise all this AI crap
I don’t think disabling it stops Microsoft from collecting the data
@@ambiarock590 IKR! And you wanna know what really gets me about all this shit? These people who work in the tech fields or anyone else who speaks out about this stuff (Elon Musk and so on) who complain about this AI crap saying that it’s a threat to civilization, this and that, but yet they keep making this technology and pushing it out to the public 🙄
@@Thatguyfromthecommentsection it probably will, i am also very lucky to live in the EU since the EU is not taking of company bullshit
How do I disable it
The only thing that keeps me from going 100% to Linux is that my classes through WGU state that I “need either windows or macOS for certain classes.”
But it’s so tempting at times to just say “I’ve been using opensuse on one of my laptops for awhile, I’ll just use it in everything.”
The data itself will probably be stored locally. The analytic patterns, the AI learning if you like, are almost certain to be shared with MS.
The question should be, if someone was doing something illegal on their windows computer, would Microsoft contact law enforcement. That should be the question.
No more sailing the high seas with big brother watching you
if vimms is locked im doing something very much bad that will collapse a food stand.
Don't law enforcement already get notified by automated bots if you type in specific illegal searches? Like, searching for ped0 stuff, drugs, etc. Or is this just the US and not other places? Cyber security police task forces are a big deal
They can and they will.
@@ChristoffRevan the dark web is what most 'smart' criminals would use, behind Tor or something similar. It's a lot harder to track, but not impossible. That said, if they start taking people down for watching a movie for free, I am certain that they will be creating more criminals, not getting rid of them.
Each day we get closer to living in a cyberpunk dystopia like those old 80s animes
without the cool things
You are already living it.
We need kami
Names of those animes?
Hey I like your videos I was hoping that one day you might make a video showing us how to duel boot because every time I install Linux on the same hard drive it never gives me the option to choose which one I want to boot into.
Before seeing this video, i was contemplating between switching to windows 11 or remaining on windows 10. But this video has made it much easier for me to decide what i should do.
Ever heard the saying, better to ask forgiveness than for permission. Guaranteed already happening
The straw that broke the camel's back for me. Can't change PCs now for personal reasons, but when I eventually do, I'm switching to Linux.... I've been tolerant towards Microsoft for a very long time, mostly out of convenience as I'm not technically literate and I'm used to how Microsoft products work for day to day life. But this is pure evil and inexcusable.... What also fascinates me is how brazen they've become. No fear from repercussions whatsoever.....
They have become beholden to investors, making these insane bad decisions not for us, but to make money out of investors.
@@WokioWolfy Yep. A lot of this crap is being done because they're trying to please braindead out of touch greedy investors who either have ulterior motives or don't know what the heck they're asking for and only want it because it's the "current trend" right now.
Same. I'm more lazy and get frustrated by programing to learn Linux but this has made me reconsider a lot. I"ll stick to my Win10 PC for now but I'm going to take time to learn how to transfer over to Linux when I eventually have to get a new PC.
I'm in the middle of taking cs classes online and quite honestly switching over to Linux would be too much for me right now, but after I get this degree and take some time off, its time to make the switch.
I liked win 10 but this is too far. After "upgrade" to win 11 i am considering to switch to linux.
Will keep windows just for gaming and everything else should be linux.
If linux could run PUBG i would be all linux
Like he said 'Who will use this?'. I'm still using Windows but definitely plan to switch in the future to Arch Linux or something. Furthermore this replay stuff already exists in windows with the XBOX game bar replay function. Well that's just a 30 seconds replay but I think this is enough. I've used this feature for quite a while now and it is really useful sometimes while playing a game or not paying attention in homeschooling xD. But I can control when a replay is made and where the data goes, nobody needs this AI replay thing if you ask me. Thx for the video!
Everyday I get a little closer to finally jumping ship over to Linux completely. It's just hard how some of the games (mostly just DCS) and programs I use will likely never have dedicated Linux versions.
Ubisoft - You need to get comfortable not owning your games.
Apple - You need to get comfortable not owning your data in the cloud.
M$oft - You need to get comfortable not owning your screen.
The Customer: You better get comfortable making significantly less money.
Corporations need us more than we need them.
For Apple it's - You need to get comfortable not owning your own Hardware.
Copilot: get comfortable while I warm up the neurotoxin emitters
All together - You need to get comfortable not owning your personality in real life any longer. (Copy pasted by some criminal organisations and to be sold on Marketplaces in the DarkNet)...... **Crinch***
@@martinpalm5 I’m actually talking about a recent now deleted(censored) post where users are finding out their old data deleted years ago it coming back during a recent update. Isolated it that it was stored in the cloud and Apple doesn’t delete stuff when you tell them to on their remote servers.
But you aren’t wrong as well!!! Apple be like you, you don’t own anything and have planned failures obsolescence within every few years. :-) lmao
Well if there is an easy way to get me into Linux...
Mint is a good first stop to adjust
@@KatKat32 Mint (among others, Zorin goes out of its way to look much like W7 or XP) was designed to be familiar to Windows operators.
Pick a distro, any distro (well not any, but any beginner/friendly one) throw it on a USB, and boot off of that just to try it out. If you just want to see what the general look and feel is, do some light browsing, thats all you need. No permanent system changes, no need to go hackerman on the console. If you dont like how plain Ubuntu looks/feels you dont need to go though the effort of swapping desktop environments, you can try Ubuntu Cinnamon (Cinnamon desktop enviroment) or Kubuntu (KDE Plasma desktop enviroment) till you find one you like. A thumb drive, a bit of time, and being smart enough to not click Yes to "Install linux now, this will erase your drive" prompts and you can have a poke.
Ubuntu all the way
@@peterwatkins671 never could wrap my head around GNOME.
What we need is some kind of an easy to use firewall, where we can select specifically what connections we allow. Windows can work offline right? so basically it doesnt need to send anything, not a single byte of information to whoever. So... as I said - we need an easy to use firewall, just put it between PC and router and let them add whatever they want.
I feel sorry for the AI that will be watching my screen... especially at night 👀
This is Number 139573 of reason why I'm glad that I still haven't "upgraded" to Win 11
I don't plan to do it till I absoultly have to, or until people figure out a way to remove the ads, the Ai and all that other crap we don't want.
@@scyris99 what ads are you referring to? most stuff on windows 11 is still pretty removable via third party debloaters, but we shouldn't have to resort to that.
This is the sole reason why I stay on Windows 10.
win 10 is terrible too and has spyware stuff like this.
@@Ralphunreal that is true unless you got windows 10 osint debloated like I have
@Infisrael fun fact youll have far more privacy with Linux
So many privacy concerns with this. Surely this is a breach of most data protection and confidentiality laws
the one thing I'm worried about moving to linux are some of my EAC games (I really like hunt showdown), and moving all of my stuff to that new drive. I only have a HDD to use as a moving tool.
WE GETTING SILENCED BY THE ALGORITHM WITH THIS ONE 🔥🔥🗣🔊🗣🔊🗣🔊🔥🔥🔥
WE GETTING MONITORED 24/7 WITH THIS ONE🗣‼️‼️
yo whys it called Prism 5:06 that's the NSA internet spying program
WE GETTING MONITORED BY BIG BROTHER WITH THIS ONE 🗣🗣🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥‼️⚠️⚠️🔊🔊😳
You're not, because all of this is patently false.
@@awwwwhhhyeahhhh small hat spotted
Just 2 days ago I saw a popup saying support for 10 (which isn't that bloody old) losing support October of next year. NEXT YEAR!
I was wondering why the rush. Now I understand why.
Windows 10 was introduced in 2015... it IS that bloody old...
...and still better than 11.
@@Windowsfan100 XP got at least around 15 years. This will mean 10 get half a decade less.
That's still quick in my opinion.
They end service quicker than they can release/develop games.
@@DemonicAkumi 10 years is the average and targeted life cycle for any Windows product. XP getting 12½ years of support was an exception, not a rule. Would've been great if they did that to Win10 as well, but the advertiser dough is too sweet it seems.
2:16 ah yes we all love this game
These corporations need to be boycotted into insolvency!
This has to be illegal
TOS is you selling your life to MS.
Did you watch the video? It all happens locally, it won't be sent to their servers
@@iyeetsecurity922 TOS is just a piece of toilet paper in the court of law.
@@verybadosuplayer9033 stepping stones man
@iyeetsecurity922 TOS does not work that way. Allot of TOS stuff gets turned over in courts often. Just like signing a contract it can be broken.