Catherine McBroom: Exploiting FAMILY For PROFIT...
Vložit
- čas přidán 31. 05. 2024
- Does Catherine McBroom exploit her family and children for her own personal gain? In this second part covering the Ace Family scams, I dive into the life of Catherine McBroom and her many shady business decisions, as well as examine the problematic aspects of family channels on CZcams in general...
Patreon: www.patreon.com/cruelworldhap...
Resources: docs.google.com/document/d/1K...
Shyla Walker's video: • The truth
Chapters:
0:00 Intro
4:30 Who is Catherine McBroom?
8:39 Controversy
14:08 The Problem with Family Channels
19:30 Benefiting from Scams
21:42 the truth about Catherine McBroom
28:12 Backlash Builds
29:44 Skincare Disaster
35:41 The 1212 Lawsuit
40:32 Shady Friendships
43:21 Shyla Walker
45:08 Catherine Responds
48:33 Catherine Goes Solo
52:35 Conclusion
INSTAGRAM: @cruelworldhappymind
I tried my best to blur out all children’s faces in this video to protect their privacy. Sorry if I missed any frames!
Also again, credit to SL04N who has covered the Ace family and their many lawsuits and scams in a ton of detail! 💜
Congrats on having your baby :)
@@Emily-ro7mv thank you! 🥺💜
@@cruelworldhappymind Oh my- how didn't I know?! Congratulations!! ♡
I’m a young mexican stoner tryna make it out the hood by doing reaction videos while im high asf on my CZcams channel 😩..
Pst. The escort thing is cuz of *sparkles* misogyny *sparkles*
Because if she was an escort… it's work. I do question the idea of the age of 16, but thats less something to go after her for and more the society and people around her, who sexualises teenagers and may have lured her into it.
But the idea, not fact. Because there is no evidence as you said! It's just people who want to slap something bad onto her to make their hate more valid.
Misogyny will always seep into any criticism when it concerns women…
i personally think catherine will stay with austin until he’s completely down and out and then make her own channel and speak out against him and play the “things weren’t what they seemed” narrative
In order to truly understand catherine, look at what she has been allowing as a MOTHER and smiling about it. Let that sink in
100 percent agree
yup, I mean if we’re looking at the money aspect here she would be mad stupid for leaving Austin now. there whole brand Is based off of family so she needs him. they need each other to keep this going. no wonder she turns her head about the cheating rumors. greed is strong in some people and they won’t let anything get in the way of that.
Yes if she is bright she still very him to do L the shady stuff and then blame him for everything
Tbh it's not like this is a normal situation I highly doubt any of us in this comment section have any real idea of what their and her life's actually like
I think in 10-15 years we’ll start to see a rise in child exploitation law suits from the children of family vloggers!
Exactly my thoughts lol. Because of ace family, so many other problematic channels go under the radar. Cole and Savannah are a good eg
That's wild 💀. I believe you 💯☝️
@Steph2020 Jane exactly..it’s just open field for predators now a days and people don’t care.. 😑🤦🏻♀️
I /hope/ that's what we see
I'd be interested to see that happening but at the same time be depressed to learn how many people had to go through an exploited childhood like the DaddyoFive kid.
Austin is the face of the Ace Family, Catherine is the brains, and the children are the overworked employees
Austin is the very punchable face of the Ace Family.
It frustrates me when the parents say "the kid wants to do it". Like they're 5, they want to do it because it makes mummy and daddy happy and they get attention when they are filmed. there's no way the children actually understand what they're doing and how constant filming could be harmful in the future.
Like "you want to do it!" "She wants it" is what was always said when I was being trafficked. No I didn't want to do it I wanted you to stop yelling and hitting me because I said no. No I didn't want to do it I just went silent because I was afraid. We don't know how they react if the kids don't want to film if it's anything like anger then the kids will do it because kids are smart enough to understand self-preservation and when to not anger someone whose bigger then you.
@@xxcallmeniaxx3272 I hope things are better for you now, It’s horrible to hear you had to go through that.
Exactly! When I was 5, I really wanted to shove my cousin down the stairs in a sled, because it sounded fun. My parents wouldn't let me, and I didn't accident murder my cousin.
I actually think Catherine is smarter than Austin, because she always stays quiet and sends him to speak up. Leaving him like a scammer and awful person, and leaving her like an innocent victim.
But everyome who goes with that is kinda an idiot
In 2-5 business years this comment will have aged like fine wine
@@JM-gm1te it already aged like fine wine she was exposed for not paying workers
Oh, she's definitely the "brains" in that relationship which is mind-boggling since I'm sure her IQ is hovering right in the 85-90 range.
@@MsSugar1209 She's actually really smart and used to make a lot more money than Austin.
BAN. FAMILY. CHANNELS.
These children need to be protected from their exploitation hungry parents.
👏 agreed. Or there needs to be restrictions so family channels can’t take advantage of their children
Some are okay. For example one I watch is fathering autism. I don’t think the parents are exploiting their daughter. They are so good with her but then again I find it more information because my kid has autism. But I agree some family channels are disgusting especially the bigger ones.
Yes! Or if CZcams could blur public videos of children/limit allowed screen time of minors in uploads so that the channels become less popular>less profitable>less made. No more using kids to make their videos interesting.
Erika Solorioo Idk the fathering autism guy has done some exploitative videos. He’s filmed her on the toilet and I’ve definitely seen him ignore her when she’s given cues that she doesn’t want to do certain things. Not only that, but the guy is known for lashing out at people and being a bad employer.
Agree one zillion percent!!!
those clips of them ignoring their children because they're trying to say the lines for their vlog are horrifying and heartbreaking
Absolutely!!!
Honestly that fast you can see the real true colors
I don't see how anyone who truly loves their children can do that,I just have cats but almost every time they meow at me I at least say hi or give them a few pets.
When the child started crying and he looked at his own child and said “no one is coming to get you” and then kept trying to film, I got a sinking feeling in my stomach and wanted to vomit.
I see people often time feel bad for Catherine, but she really isn't as innocent as everyone seems to think.
Exactly. I mean, its possible to get away from that family, like Shyla did, but I don't think Catherine wants to.
@@Emily-ro7mv I mean it is possible but it's also hard. Because we've seen the result of what happened when shyla left the family the whole family was bullying her and blackmailed her and then their fans went after Shyla as well. But at the same time Catherine is definitely not innocent as well
@@pauletteblack9140 True, plus Catherine and Austin have two (I think) kids
@@Emily-ro7mv they have three
@@pauletteblack9140 Ohhhh ok. But yea, I think it was easier, not easy tho, for Shyla to get out because her and Landon on have one kid
Catherine isn’t the “lesser of two evils”; She’s just a smarter, more cunning flavour of evil when compared to Austin.
She’s a Virgo, he’s a Taurus
She knows wassup 😌
She said she wants to seem that way
@Maverick Lanzerotti exactly!
@@dmejia6431 shut up 😐
They deserve each other
Catherine benefits from the “women are wonderful” effect so hard. Because she is also a scam artist. But is capable of acting dumb and innocent, and can easily get away with people thinking she’s a bystander instead of a co-conspirator.
Thank you for not escort shaming. Even if she DID do that, so what? Does that make her a bad person? I really hate when people make assumptions about a person based only on something like that!
Are your a former escort?
@@DavidKen878 Does it matter? Because it shouldn't.
@@TheKevlarKitten Umm ok
@@DavidKen878 why even ask? Looking to be a client? ROFL. It really shouldn't matter to you or anyone if someone escorts.
fr!! sex work is work, and there's nothing wrong with working a crappy job to get by.
This reminds me of a time when I asked my friend why she chose to be Vice President instead of president of a club. She said “If stuff doesn’t go right, the VP never gets the heat for it, the president does.”
Ong cause my vice president didn't do absolutely anything and even if the club president was incompetent i didn't blame my vice president (I'm treasurer btw)
that... is actually kinda smart dam
Thats an old saying, and unfortunately true lol
@@skimaskgank9224 It was a gardening and cooking community club.
Well, your friend is definitely smart
The fact that she complains about privacy and other struggles with publicity, BUT STILL DOESNT want to respect her kids privacy, speaks volumes about her mentality as a mother. Along with agreeing to sell posters of Elle, while being WELL AWARE of creeps. Just by looking at decisions that she makes as a mother, makes it hard to believe that she was manipulated by austin. We will see about that overtime though
In addition to the topic PRIVACY, she is UNQUALIFIED to speak on it until she respects her kids privacy. Like how can you complain about something, but at the same time put others(kids) in that same position to face the cons of publicity.
Such a good point!!!
Yes!! Selling posters of your young child is beyond creepy and wrong seeing as there are predators online and there’s no way the parents don’t know that. 💴 > their child’s safety and well-being.
Nothing to see here same ol lame sh t everybodys already been saying
Omg she sells posters of Elle? Wth
Manipulation or not, a parent protects their child. Even from another parent. Both my partner and I know if the other tries to hurt our kids, we're gonna kill the other before we let anything happen to our kids.
Huge red flag ladies if he makes the reservation for your first date before confirming both that he has a date OR that you like the food… that sets a precedent. This is a dude who will ask for forgiveness but not permission. I’m glad she could make a positive spin on it, but come on. Also, the correct response to someone saying they didn’t like sushi is to ask what they do like, and go from there. Cancel your stupid sushi reservation.
Oh stop with the drama! Someone making a reservation is NOT a red flag. And I'm no Austin fan. He took a leap and booked the restaurant before he asked. So what?
If he booked a hotel room, THAT'S a red flag. You're silly.
@@jog8483 well said 👏 👍
@@jog8483 if a dude insisted on taking me out to a restaurant I didn’t like, I would not be going on that date. But then again I like respectful and gentle men who want my input in decisions. That’s not drama, it’s just looking for a good person.
The fact that you think identifying red flags is “drama”…. Phew child I seriously pray for you and your relationships.
@@maddieb.4282 Yup!! You're a certifiable HIGH MAINTENANCE, drama queen. I see red flags with YOU.
No one said he "insisted on taking her", he just made a damn reservation. I'm sure if she hated the place he wouldn't DRAG her there against her will.
Speaking of drama, you're praying for me for disagreeing that the guy threw up a red flag?? Stop your silliness.
Some women like a take charge man. Not IN CHARGE, but take charge. If you were a more secure woman you wouldn't feel so threatened by that. A guy making a reservation is NOT taking away your free will, OK?
I would go on the date 👩🏫 BUTTT☝ I would be taking notes. Some people just get ahead of themselves trying to be kind👩🏫🙌... And some mother tickets are trying you like these ladies said.
And I am a male. Fight your mama gents.
And ladies yes, make sure you aren't doing the most.
💁🤷🏽♀️❤😌😎👌✍
Okay real talk, that story of her ‘past life’ about her being a mermaid wanting to live on land but her dad was a king is LITERALLY the entire plot of The Little Mermaid.
What a scam. 🤣
Catherine is just as toxic, greedy and messy as Austin if not more, she is just way more quiet with it. I find her to be a very manipulative person.
Austin is just louder. It wouldn't surprise me if she's mainly the brains and he's the mouth.
the bts of the videos seem like it too ngl
Narcassistic* she has NPD clearly lol
And now she seems to be Goopy-fying her brand... very predatory
Yes especially seeing why she’s done to her friend with the business etc
The fact that people even consider the possibility that she's naïve or innocent in all of this when she's been in the industry since she was a teenager is insane. People need to stop acting like women in these family channels are just pawns in their husbands' schemes. She's just as evil as Austin, if not more because at least he addresses the controversies (while making an ass out of himself in the process). Catherine just runs away, pretends she has nothing to do with it, and runs all the way to the bank with the profits. The fact that she feigns ignorance makes her more manipulative than Austin.
Thank you!
I agree 👍
Who thinks that? I knew from the start she is defo in on it too. I do think there is abuse Bjt I don’t think she is 100% in the clear. Ppl just blindly support them. Thank god Shyla got out. But think about it, they build an empire. Bet she doesn’t want to leave it. That’s why so much denial
This is A LOT of women's game.
She’s not dumb at all. Even if she’s hurt by the cheating, she knows she benefits more from their relationship than on her own. Some people are able to forgo certain things like love and loyalty for money and comfort. You could even argue that’s technically the most logical thing to do in that case lol I feel like she knows what she is doing all the time while Austin just makes bad decisions left and right because he’s a sketchy person.
Beyond everything touched on here...imagine being ten, or six, or three. You want your parents to love you, and you're a kid, just exploring and figuring stuff out. Except your entire family's livelihood depends on you being on camera. Except your parents are also your bosses. Except their praise and approval only comes when you act like they want. Except when something bad happens, you never know if it's a prank or not. Except that millions of people know your face and have opinions about you before you even know yourself.
I didn't even like putting up pictures of my sons on FB, and only did a small handful of times to get my mom off of my back about that. I couldn't imagine doing what family vloggers do to their kids.
be careful. facebook is the king of mining data and stealing ur info. stick to your instinct feeling and don’t let anyone pressure you into posting your children online if you don’t want to. x 💕
@@draculena real true
I set up a private album for my family only to see. It works great!
@@jowiens32 I didn't think of that!
I put up a private album for friends and family
Omg the possible dynamic you brought up of Catherine being way smarter than she lets on and Austin just being the figure head reminds me SO much of the founders/couple from the LulaRich documentary. She was the real brains of the operation but played dumb for the camera while her husband did most of the talking.
Absolutely!!
How interesting was that?! Seeing her talk so confidently on the radio show about strategy was an eye opener.
This is totally the dynamic. When the shit hits the fan she will play dumb and say it was all Austin's idea.
This reminds me so much of the quote that says behind every great man is a women. I don’t think Austin is a great man, but you get what I’m saying
That's a good take. Completely agree
Catherine is an adult, a grown woman, a mother. So being naive does not excuse doing wrongs. She knows what she’s doing.
I think she’s as bad and as manipulative as that dingleberry she let father her kids!
@@laffytaffy2916 yup
Exactly 💯💯
Probably she is the puppet master austin is to idiotic to get that far
The sad part is Catherine could have been extremely successful with 1212 gateway if she didn’t lock them out of the accounts n stuff and let them do what they needed to do.
I can't imagine the burnout their kids will face at such a young age, not to mention just their reputation. Burnout being: they felt drained and dragged out at such a young age and pushed constantly by their parents, so maybe later in life they just won't care about certain things, I hope not because these kids really have been used by their parents :/
Imagine dating Michael B. Jordan and ending up with Austin…
She left him because he didn’t want kids so she turn to someone who did: Austin McAsshole
Great win for MBJ
Sometimes life just doesn't work out 🤣
Maybe he is too smart for her to manipulate
I don’t think they were dating. It’s a rumor that has never been confirmed but people say that chantel jeffreys and cathrine were escorts for famous people before they became famous. If you search online you can find pictures of them in clubs with a lot of rappers and chantel became famous bc she was rumored to be dating Justin Bieber when in reality she was an high level escort. I think Cathrine did the same with Micheal B. Jordan
I respect your choice to censor the kid's identities as much as possible. I wonder how they will feel as adults looking back on their childhood through the lense of CZcams.
Censor*
@@zealot246 oh damn, you right 😅
Not to mention how it might feel to see that total strangers cared more about privacy and consent more than their own parents 😔
i hope it doesn’t take a child of these vlog families suing in 15 yes for some laws to be put in place to protect exploited children
Everyone's criticizing the Ace Family for exploiting their kids, but they praise other people such as Colleen Ballinger for exploiting hers. Do we only hold people accountable if we don't like them as people? Are people generally okay with child exploitation as long as they aren't seen as shady.
Thank you for bringing up the respect needed for those in the sex work industry. I really hate when people get offended by that. Like why be mad at them and not those buying their services
because their providing the service for people to buy. nothing to buy if you aren’t offering it 😂 they don’t need respect. they are prostitutes.
Why should i be mad at drug addicts for buying drugs and not the drug sellers?
That's a dumb argument tbh
Why be mad at either? Dumb take
It's shameful to be a sex worker just because "they were poor" like no, these type of people were just lazy to get an actual job so selling your body is easier than cleaning some office. Why should anyone respect someone who lost his/her dignity?
I like that you don’t indulge or criticize her “personal life” . You talk about the legitimate scam issues they are doing. I’m loving your videos! Thank You 😊
Catherine seems to be much smarter than she wants us to believe. She seems to be very calculated, but is still vulnerable to being potentially manipulated emotionally by Austin. This relationship is so uncomfortable to watch, their kids are living such a crazy reality. Their parents aren't just aggressive stage parents; these are shifty, exploitative con-people documenting every second of their childhoods. I really hope there are adults around them with their actual best interest in heart so when they get older they have a support system and sense of family/trust.
birds of a feather flock together
what are your thoughts on the video near the end where she talks about being real w her fans then goes right into how she truly believes she is a mermaid and her father was a king of the ocean ?
i do think she’s smart sometimes but then she says shit like that dead seriously and i’m like uhhh maybe not
Cateherine & austin r not smart....they r simply cunning...if they wre smart, they coud have had long term succesful business instead everyone is suing them.
@@lilwavesz honestly some of the smartest people are also some of the weirdest but I feel like even that’s an example of her coming off as crazy but actively trying to connect to her audience in a way lol. Like she’s pretending to be much more naive than she is. But she’s probably just being silly. I still think she’s smarter than she leads on, but I don’t think she’s bright enough to keep her brand safe mostly bc she’s stayed with Austin who is a nightmare.
@@jcelinacoffee she’s not just being silly if you watch the full video she’s 100% serious about it, it’s actually concerning to watch. but i get your point!!
“But when the world needed *Madison* most, she -vanished- returned.” 🙌
😂 Omg Avatar is one of my favorite shows 🥺💜
Don't click on that link unless you want a religious fanatic arrogantly pushing their religion onto you when nobody asked them to, and certainly no one consented.
If your deity is so anxious that we worship it, it doesn't need humans to do the work for it. It can come here in person and impress me, but I won't hold my breath for thar to happen.
@@padmelotus I always report comments like that as spam, but they keep popping up all over CZcams like a virus.
@@GwendolynnBY CZcams never does anything about it anyways.
Wait til all of these children grow up. It'll be tell all book & interview time. They're going to be (hopefully not) broke, abused, mentally affected/traumatized, angry, and God knows what else. They'll have every right to tell their sides and I hope CZcams's around to hear it.
I'm from one year in the future, and may I just say that we stan a queen who sticks to her principles, as Madison doesn't exploit her baby, or even show her face! ❤
The way that man absolutely cannot say Dolores has me rolling. That is exactly why she goes by Catherine 😭
Butchered it. It’s not even hard😂
Doe La Riss 🤣🤣🤣
Right
@@TheBossydee LMAO
@@TheBossydee thank u for this bc I keep having to remind myself how you'd even mess that up, it's such an awkward way to put the emphasis
SHE'S BACK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! CONGRATS ON THE BABY BESTIE you are so impressive for being a mom. a COOL mom!
Omg thank youu 🥺💜😭
@@cruelworldhappymind Cruel world happy mom
@@cruelworldhappymind Congrats on having your baby and welcome to the world little bean! 💜
@@cruelworldhappymind congratulations to you, your husband and your new arrival 💕
I'm wishing you all the best for your future and the future of your family 💕
One thing that I will say is THANK YOU for not saying your baby’s name all over the Internet! You truly love your baby! ♥️
I'm a mum and I just can't understand how people exploit their kids like this. Most of them are too young to say no and I dread the kind of damage it does to them.
i’m 9 months pregnant and i give you so much props. you’re talking so much and so clear, i would be completely out of breath.
You ever notice how whenever crooks get called out for losing all their money because they're crooks, the part they always contest hardest is the money part? People be like "The Ace family cheated everyone and lost their house" and this lady is all "that's not true, our house is fine!" Like objectively they're way more ashamed of poverty than being actual criminals.
This comment needs to be pinned. 💯!
finally. everyone thinks she’s innocent yet Austin is the bad one like no, they are BOTH terrible.
People have a strange idea that beautiful women are innocent or they just give them a pretty pass
I'd even say she's worse because her terrible and toxic behavior is a bit more insidious. At least with Austin he's up-front.
Yes! She is a wolf in sheep's clothing, with Austin we know what to expect but people think because is is so soft spoken she can't do no harm.
Mhmmmmm!
Let’s not be dramatic
Sadly MONEY & GREED comes before their family , fans & morals that they don't even care about scamming and exploiting their own children . No longer being able to make profit off their first kid getting older, they decided that they could make money off another and had the second child & same idea with their third kid. So sad and shameful.
I love that around 21:50 she said “I never really wanted to be famous BUT-“ and then describes it what it’s like to be famous. She apparently doesn’t wanna be famous but she wants a voice, she wants to be peoples inspiration, and she wants to be well known and heard. Idk that sounds like exactly what fame is
I hate how they say that they're thankful their daughter isn't afraid of the camera. While there can be shyness in children at a young age, she's had a camera in her face since her birth and given how much the family makes off her she would probably have to deal with a camera in her face regardless of her feelings. Atp she may very well just be used to that much visibility in her life, not that she actually "likes" the camera
Exactly, of course she’s used to the camera it’s all she’s known..
Yeeees! Like "she likes being on camera"...how on earth can they know if she doesn't like it, she's never experienced anything else. "She's a natrual."? Well of course she's a "natrual" she's only known that life!
She’s letting Austin take the fall now she’s ready to move on without him. She’s a lot smarter then she’s portraying.
Omg, now that would be something
I don’t think she’s going anywhere
@@username4261 what do you mean that would be something it's exactly what's going on don't be dull smdh
Big facts
She's getting sued by the company she ruined so I don't think she's moving on. lol
Girl never apologize for being a good momma and putting yourself your baby and your family first!! We will enjoy the video when you put it out. The people that rush content are the same people that get mad when said rushed content isn’t as good quality because it was rushed. Much love xoxo 😘
Something that messes me up the more I hear that clip in videos talking about this family is that they say “things wouldn’t be the same” if Elle didn’t want to film, but don’t clearly state that they wouldn’t continue to make Elle and/or the other kids part of the blog.
If hell exists, the “ace familiAeee” and “your girl Biaaaaaaaa-nca!” would be my worst alarms down there.
😭
I thought "Biaaaaaaa-nca" was bad, but it sounds like music compared to "ace familAAAAAAY"
Austin is a warning of what we are all in for if we go to hell after we die
Omg same 😭
🤣🤣🤣🤣
The craziest part to me is that *people seriously bought the skin care* line even after the total mess of an App, a charity event, and a failed beverage line
It seems that her skincare products arent that bad tho. Especially the lip balm. I mean i dont have it. I just watch other’s videos trying and the reviews on the web.
That's what's shocking to me. At this point in time and after all their straight up scamming, I struggle to feel bad for anyone who is giving these people their money
Honestly the products are amazing , the lip balm and cleanser are great
Somebody else did ALL the work. And they’re now suing her.
The juice 😂😂😂
I’ve lost any sympathy for people that continue to be ripped off by this family. Everyone who buys any of their products or merchandise is just paying for their lifestyle, it’s not like everyone doesn’t know about what they’re doing.
I could definitely picture in 20 years a bunch of children taking their internet celebrity parents to court for not being compensated for their work as a child
No amount of money “saved” can give a child his/her childhood back.. This reminds me of the Truman Show.
i guess you are not american. In this video, it seems to be the only problem !
@@catherinegrun6729 it seems u are american🙄 because they never said it was good. They jist said they’re never going to get a childhood despite how wealthy they are.
SWISH!!
right? feel sad af for the kids,
She’s consciously making the decision to portray naivety
Yeaahhhhhh. Play dumb until the games up.
Its smart, very smart.
August 26th is my oldest's birthday! Congratulations and good for you taking time off. I pray that laws are passed to protect children like these. In the meantime, thank you for shining a light on all of it. We viewers have a lot of power. If we withhold revenue from these people, maybe others will think twice before exploiting their kids.
Congrats on another video! You always do a great deep-dive on these stories that you cover, and above all else, doesn't condone hate upon those you cover in your videos and give them the benefit of the doubt. Certainly much more forgiving and hopeful than I would've been... Wish you all the best from Brasil!
The fact that Catherine is supposedly close with Kylie Jenner of all people speaks volumes. Kylie is the queen of scamming people with her bad quality (and extremely expensive!) products and then staying absolutely silent when the backlash rolls in. No doubt Catherine got some Kardashian/Jenner tips for completely avoiding accountability.
She even kinda sounds like them.
more like she wants to be Kylie
I can totally see how all of these get rich quick scammers would know each other as part of a talentless, flash in the pan, out of touch, morally bankrupt club of liars. Even Kylie is a scammer getting rich off of her fake beauty. She looks nothing like what she used to and is only a model because of extensive cosmetic surgery. As someone who truly loves fashion and, more so, good makeup no one could ever convince me to buy Kylie cosmetics. She’s not a makeup artist or aesthetician or even educated in any meaningful way. I don’t know if she was legally an adult when she launched the line. Why on earth would her ghost-formulas be any good at all? For all I know, maybe she doesn’t even know how to apply makeup because professionals do it for her. It’s all a lie. As they say, believe none of what you hear and only half of what you see. Hold up, it’s now “and none of what you see, either.” Stick with your gut, don’t fall for marketing scams (“influencers”) and stick with tried and true products from ethical companies with good reputations. Don’t believe opinions of people who have a financial interest in lying to you.
She’s doing the same procedures they love too. It’s sad
No she’s not close with Kylie. You’re probably thinking of Chantel Jeffries.
Let’s not forget that when Austin and Catherine were first promoting the ace club, they advertised how Elle would be going live on there. Does anyone else think that’s incredibly dangerous to put your kids out there without any parents present??
Omg what? That’s sickening
I’m sure someone was going to be supervising her, but it’s definitely still wrong
Ace club ? I did that for 3 months and they have yet to upload videos so I canceled it ! This family such scam
Austin is way too protective yea he’s selfish but he wouldn’t let her go live maybe if he’s there but it’s not like Ryan’s toys
@@Rachel-qd8zn Sorry you got scammed. It takes a lot of personal strength to admit it. I hope you can spend the money on something nice you actually get some benefit from now!
I really wish all companies would spend more time and put more thought into their packaging. I bought some makeup from a brand and it came smashed to hell and broken and when I reached out, they said it was my fault for not buying purchase protection and that they are not responsible for shipping…as a customer I was devastated :/
Come on bestie tell us the company so we can never buy from them again!
My best friend would copy everything I bought or had until one day I mentioned I was training to run a 5k.A month later at my nieces birthday party as she was leaving she briefly said oh by the way I’m running a 5k next Saturday and I asked if anyone wanted to do it with me but no one wants to.She never asked me.I was done being friends with her and I’ve never been more happy.It’s truly hard to find real true friends.
Catherine was smart from the beginning. To me, this could have been her plan from the beginning, to let Austin ahead when it came to public events and the family persona, saving her brand as her own lifeboat in case things blew up. She's been in the public eye ever since she was a kid, and she knows how to play the game and win.
Her antics with 1212 tell me that’s she’s like that one character from GoT, she’s not as smart as she thinks
Except she's being sued multiple fronts ..... She's also a scammer and using her kids
@@TheDelethar haha do u mean Sansa? 🤣
the ultimate genius 😳 maybe….
These 2 are the same. I believe she maybe worse.
I also think shes the Mastermind behind everything. Of course Austin is in everything and at fault, but I think she uses him also as a Figure who takes the blame so she can have a "innocent" Image and can protect him when plans/ scams dont work out
Yep. This is Catherine McBroom💯
and if things get really bad (losing fame) she can play the victim
Completely agree. She hinds behind the sweet, young, pretty Mom image she has curated. I wouldn't be surprised if she's setting up Austin to be the fall guy for all their joint scams. Then walks away with millions that shes hid in shell corporations.
I actually think that the mother and father of Austin are more responsible and Catherine and Austin just listen to them. I feel this more so due to the shyla and Landon situation.
This. All of this.
I'm just falling down this rabbit hole in a hard-core way, and your videos on them are PERFECTION.
1. Congratulations on the new family member💜 sending y’all love and light💜 2. Your videos.. omg I love them so so much! Thanks a lot💜
So my grandpa was a child actor starring in many movies such as it’s a wonderful life and a John Wayne movie and until the day passed he never talked about, never let us watch the movies and if we brought it up he would be mad. From what I know from my mom he hated it and said it was the worst thing he ever did. And this was in the 30’s and 40’s when these rules weren’t a thing. Come to find out his mom took all the money and used it.
Man, that sheit scars his whole life. Just like the Olsen twins
That's so sad. I hope he has peace about it now. 😢
@@admiralackbar4652 the Olsen twins are mega millionaires aces kids ain't getting money right now
@@admiralackbar4652 The Olsen Twins have money, they have a combined net worth of half a billion dollars.
@@julsc2106 virtually none of that money is leftover from their acting careers. It’s from the fashion empire they built up. They are fashion moguls, with products in high end department stores and Sephora.
the people who say that Catherine isn’t aware of everything going on around her DEFINITELY shows you’ve never delt with a narcissistic/toxic relationship with a woman.
Those people saying that are the narc females. They all defend and cover for each other.
I think she knows it all. I think she has been gaslit for years and lacks the ability to stand up. Watch how often he says things that are "jokes" that undermine her and demeans her. That chips away at who you are until you are a shell that is easy to control. I'm watching Shyla later today (damn it's long) but I bet it was similar.
I personally believe she’s completely okay
Why can’t people just accept that maybe she’s cool with an open relationship and maybe they’re both assholes to each other off cam and they’re fine w that too? 😂
@@dmejia6431 How can people accept something they have no information about ? I don't think the couple ever made a comment about the status of their relationship.
Ofc she knows it all. She’s married to the man
just wanted to say that i am a new subscriber and ur videos have so much care and thoughtfulness !! i appreciate the quality you always put into ur videos
Is it just me or does Catherine's business tactics seem relatively similar to the kardashians.....
All the scams and using their kids and beauty to get whatever they want
That's exactly what I was thinking!
"youre a bulldog. youre a powerhouse" LOLOL that was so awkward.
You must get a lot of the kooky QAnon people finding your channel by mistake, due to your channel name. Do they ever see signs in your art, like "The Red paint dripped over the blue, that means they're going to get the deepstate on November 9th!"?
@@ArtisticlyAlexis L O L This is the best thing. I have never thought about that. But that is freaking hilarious. I hope they do. I hope they look into the paint as a higher conspiracy. As if my channel is a portal into that lolol
veryyyyyy
She ate it up though 🤣
I totally missed it. What part did that happen?
Catherine: "Theres no such thing as a coincidence. The fact that you're watching this means we are energetically aligned... 👁️👄👁️"
Edit: Lol kudos to y'all that get the reference
Vry odd rite!? 😯
Dead 💀
🤣🤣✋🏼
GOD IS GOOD!! THIS FAMILY IS NOT REMEMBER GOD SEES ALL!
Stop 😭😭😂
Congratulations on the birth of your baby girl @Cruel World Happy Mind + Mr. CWHM 😻💕💕🐣
I love your work & I'm doing a re-watch of your uploads over Christmas. I hope your first Christmas with your baby girl is just precious!! Have a great holiday period @CWHM, see you in 2022 🤞🏼🤩💕💕
Thank you for shining light on this. I've thought about this for a long time and there can be nothing but bad as the fruit of all this.
the fact that peole would use her possibly being an escort to put her down but not her role in exploiting her children really shows peoples priorities
This!
YUP!
Plus atleast when she was an escort she was making the money honestly…well more honest than a scam.
When they’re promoting these schemes it’s always “us”, “we”, “together”, “our”. But when they go wrong it’s just Austin? When things are going good Catherine is strong, and a girl boss, and independent and influential and inspirational. But when things go wrong, she’s just an oblivious bystander or even a victim. That’s giving her a really big pass on all of the blame. If you’re in all the videos promoting these things, have your name and face on all of them, you can take part of the blame when those products are bad.
repent Jesus christ is coming, repent before it's too late, Jesus loves you ,
@@combsbrushes777 gay
YASSSSS
@@combsbrushes777 Amen!! 🙏🙏
Wheeeew girl I am not playing around when I tell you that the “hmm…interesting” @ 13:15 sent a shiver down my spine. I had to rewind it and watch it again, I was shook! You’re gonna be such a great momma congrats to you and your family.
You're glowing :) congratulations on the wonderful soon new arrival x
I'll be honest as well, Catherine sounds like she's an active co-conspirator in the scams- if not the ringleader half of the time. Just that Austin is waaaay more outspoken than she is, because I think she's very conscious of her being the trusting figure and the lesser of two evils... Which is extremely clever.
Also, Shyla's video was... pretty difficult. It makes you wonder what truly goes behind closed doors with this family. :/ It's scary.
Also regarding the bit with the solo video and how she talked about her "previous life"...it was almost like she watched the Little Mermain way too many times and wanted to roleplay BEING Ariel or something.
Her fakey high-pitched voice drives me crazy.
My mother is narcissistic and *very* manipulative. My whole life I knew that when she used a sweet high-pitched voice it meant she was trying to seem sweet, innocent, maybe a little dim, and likable and all so she could get something out of whoever she was talking to.
When she’d use that voice on me I quickly learned to be on my toes and watch what I say because she was about to use it against me.
So now whenever I encounter someone that does the fake-high-pitched-voice thing, I get instant manipulation vibes.
It makes me nauseated and definitely makes me distrust that person.
Hearing about Catherine’s origins makes her marriage to Austin that much more confusing to me. She’s well educated and has experienced the world but yet she’s settled her life into Austin’s delirium’s 😟 he feels like he’s incredibly narcissistic and controlling
I used to teach horseback riding lessons to a very famous adolescent CZcamsr (my other young students would recognize her and be absolutely starstruck), and I always thought it was weird that her dad drove around in a very nice truck and his license plate said “CZcamsr” (but missing some of the letters to make it fit on the plate). It was extra weird to me because the channel was very much centered around her and her younger sister as the stars, rather than around the entire family (although they do make plenty of appearances on the channel). It would be like if you’re a doctor and your dad was not a doctor, but the license plate on his car said “doctor”. Like… it was such a bizarre thing to me haha. Especially when he acted like a really normal guy in person, and CZcams didn’t seem like some super consuming part of his personality (he actually never even talked about it to me or anyone else at the stables, that I’m aware of). But the girl was very sweet and seemed well adjusted and very happy. She seemed to be doing great in school. She was talkative, polite, imaginative, and told me about all the of the fun sleepovers and time she spent hanging out with her friends. She was able to come to the barn several days a week as/pursue her interests and hobbies. Her mother sometimes filmed her time at the barn for their channel, but it wasn’t that often. Her mother was always very kind and sweet, and her younger sister was also very sweet and seemed happy and talkative. I never felt like they crossed any boundaries filming, and they never stepped on mine or anyone else’s privacy at the barn. I still think about her and hope that things to continue to be good for her ❤️ the Internet fame would be too overwhelming for me, personally haha
The selling posters of their kids is flabbergasting. And the people who bought the posters are even more sickening I can’t even comprehend it. I use to be a fan back in 2017 but I realized this family was fake asf and I’m glad others are starting to see it now. Trust me that’s done in the dark always comes to light
I find you kind of pathetic for bein suckered foreven a minute.
@@MMAFan20 🤣😂
There is a lot of sick people out there and I don't understand why some of these family channels don't think of those sick people. I don't think I could ever shove a camera in my children's (in the future) faces like that. I'll be thinking about their mental health state and the people in this world. Who knows what they Coyld be doing to those posters of toddlers. Its disturbing
where is this energy when it comes to child actors, jojo siwa?
@@niyaaa.loveee jojo siwa is an adult lol
As a new mother with a pretty solid following on Instagram, I don’t post a SINGLE photo of my daughter on social media at all. I absolutely do not believe that children should have their image posted all over the internet without their consent. I just can’t get how a parent would put their kids out there like that. It’s so icky.
It’s so weird to me seeing kids with Instagram accounts and their parents writing the captions as if they’re talking
My aunt is an MUA with a large following in Insta. She asks her kids if they wanna be in her page etc and they all say no and she respects that. I don't think I could ever put my kids pics online if I have children. Stuff like that should be private
Why are you on Instagram? Who's attention are you seeking?
Instagram is literal posion of society.
@@koklol2837 So true 💯🎯
Frr
Honestly it makes me really happy how you told your subscribers that you had your baby like in the middle of the video and then moved instead of putting it in the title to capitalize off it. It’s a nice way of letting subscribers know without exploiting the baby.
Your editing is so freaking cool! I love the scenes you have playing in the background.
Catherine could have married or dated anyone she wanted, but she chose Austin and that speaks more volume than anything else. I have to believe that she is a bad person because she knew how Austin was and could have left at any moment to be with someone more attractive, more famous, who had more money, etc.
Catherine was a jumpoff, those famous mem werent an option for her to marry, thus Austin.
@@quadmsolutions4723 exactly! I'm not judging her, because ultimately it's her pu$$y and she could do what she wants with it. However, when you and your friend Chantel are being passed around by men in the industry, and that's what you are known for, you can't expect for anyone to take you seriously.
@@saraa1741 I'm not judging either, its just that @H H said "Catherine could have married or dated anyone she wanted" and we all know that's 🧢, being a jumpoff is hardly dating let alone marriage 😆
They’re both snakes, both wanted to be famous so bad. All Catherine has ever done was chase the money. She got stuck with Austin because she got pregnant 3 months into dating him. The pregnancy/Elle happened to be the best thing for them as thats what got them attention on social media and eventually youtube.
@@quadmsolutions4723yes! She obviously had to settle for the bottom feeder that is Austin McBroom.
Catherine is trying to start a cult. She's got that toxic positivity, #girlboss energy. She says nothing when she speaks. 🤦🏼
Lol with all that numerology 1212 & stones heck yeah 😂
I love your work, do you have one about the Fathering Autism channel? I am disabled person with a disabled child and the way they exploit their daughters disability rubs me soo wrong. The Dad Podcast covered it a bit but they are still not fully understand.
You are a wonderful creator and I bet all this work also transfer into your care taking of your kiddos. You're doing a great job!!
Specifically the mother of the Fathering Autism channel is HEAVILY into the MLM and uses MLMs to say money will be going to their daughters future, but theres no evidence that they care
Not sure why you ended up in my recommended, but I'm glad you did. I was only vaguely aware of the ace family, bit this was so we'll done and comprehensive, well researched, and entertaining I watched both parts back to back.
The fact that Catherine & Austin was both in relationships and cheated on their partners and got together THEN had a baby quickly afterwards.. everything and anything that’s happening now is KARMA. I don’t feel bad for neither of them & they are both terrible people. Catherine is more quiet about it but her actions speaks volume.
I only feel bad for them bc them suffering means their kids suffer :(
I don't feel badly for them. But, I do feel badly for their children.
Imagine your parents smearing your embarrassing childhood moments all over the internet for cash, then never seeing a dime of it because they spent themselves into DEBT with that ill-gotten cash.
7:34 kind of a red flag he made dinner reservations before she agreed to the date
It's insane how many people view her as a victim. No no no.
And the fact that her skincare line was valued and seen as successful with all the scandals.
She’s dangerous
catherine is a just a really good actress 😭😭 she knows what she’s doing
Wellll considering that movie she did back in like 2012-2014 we can second guess that
@@user-hs1nr4he1k i havent seen it but im sure it was horrible 💀 she has gotten better as playing the innocent wife
Exactly
Catherine saying “there’s just so much life going on in everyone’s world” sent me
Congratulations! I was wondering how you and your fam was doing. Looking forward to more deep dives when you are ready! Be well to all 3 of you💖✨✌️🥳
No, you're right. She runs all of it and he is her shield. He is also her patsy. When it all goes south, which it will, he will be blamed. She has her 'savings' still, trust me.
I just said the same thing!
the whole "vapid girl" image she portrays is a calculated move, she's definitely the smart one in the relationship. it's just a shame she doesn't use that intelligence for something more worthy and meaningful than scamming her fans and business partners.
If she had a chunk stashed away before, you know she did that trick again
I agree Catherine’s online personality downplays how smart she actually is. She’s clearly doing a lot of the plotting behind the scenes. What if she throws Austin under the bus by staying silent. Shyla is woke for breaking away and not exploiting her daughter for profit. The mcbrooms were so ready to take advantage of her and her daughter.
Was sheila not doing the same thing until she made enough money to bounce ?let's not be naive here .
Smart=Scheming.
Great job on commentary. You put so much work into this.
She’s one of those people who honestly isn’t a good liar. Watching their videos you can clearly tell when they’re lying and scamming. It’ll come crumbling down one day and I honestly just feel bad for their kids
: you made a great point in that the adults are spending their childrens’ money, without properly compensating the children as the faces of their brand and promoting their products and merch!!
Madison is back!! Such a great series. I didn't even know who these people were but anytime you delve into something I am there to learn and listen.
Omg thank you!!
I wish I could erase these people from my brain. Ur lucky.
I know the ACE family because of my high school friends and other CZcamsrs talking about them through the years. I never watch a video on their channel and will keep it that way too🤣‼️
My first thought seeing this video in my subscription feed “SHES BACK!”
SAME!! 🎉
Narcissistic, manipulation and deflecting with gaslighting viewers. I used to watch them till I stopped a while ago. Glad I did since watching these. I get the feels he makes the fires and she tries putting them out by covering them up.
She’s much smarter and calculating but I feel she quite manipulative but probably. Wouldn’t be surprised if he abuses her though. Look at the video of where she dresses in dress up with the short skirt and he leans against the wall. He moves forward while she quickly steps back and her voice gets smaller. Also the row in the kitchen and he quickly goes towards her then stops
So well put together, can tell how much time and effect you put into each video. What happened to the spider tho, I need closure lol was in the Austin vid before this one 😱🤣