Just like RDR1 was ahead of it's time for the year 2010 similarly, RDR2 is ahead of its time, raising the bar of brilliance ever higher: Nothing short of a masterpiece. Plain and simple
I can agree except for one point: Ragdolls Unfortunately the ragdolls are not that complex and advanced in RDR2 as it was in RDR1 but the reason for that is, that since GTA5 the euphoria engine isnt a feature with priority anymore (Rockstar Games said this once in an interview)... Sad story...
One of the most amazing things about RDR2, for me at least, is the weather. The thunderstorms at night where you can't see until a lightning bolt shoots across the sky, or the sandstorms and blizzard where legit can't see five feet in front of you. How the character and your horse react to it. Absolutely insane. I love the way his hair grows, and how he sweats in the heat. The fact that if he comes home covered in mud, he gets yelled at to bathe, or how he gets tired if he doesn't get enough sleep and it changes his shooting.
Rdr2 is one of my favorite games but I disagree about the weather. Instead of slow realistic transitions between cloud patterns and weather types, it just quickly transitions in a matter of seconds. Ive played on Xbox and ps4 and it's the same on both so it's not a bug and no one ever talks about it. It will be clear skies and then all of the sudden transition into a rainy day in 3 secs and then 30 secs later transition back to clear. The weather system is completely broken..
RDR1's ragdoll physics are still the top in gaming overall. Even RDR2 couldn't keep up. Edit: to anyone saying no, i have a video on my channel proving that RDR2 forces the bodies to fall in pre-set positions. Variation is very limited. Be warned, you won't be able to unsee how bad the Ragdolls are after the video
Gonna be really interesting when we look back at how graphics have developed 8 years after Red Dead 2. Especially considering how good we thought Red Dead 1 looked back in the day.
RDR2 looks like how I remembered RDR1 looking when I played it back in the day. RockStar does't make a lot of games but you know that when they do, it will have some of the best production value ever seen in video games. RDR2, to me, is still the most quality video game I've ever experienced.
@@thecreativeblood4461 because its easier to program pre set animations, than create a system that accurately and realistically simulates real life physics for a game the size of RDR2
I wish it end Being a Trilogy cause there isn't That much Of Game Trilogy..If this one end in 3rd one than rdr series will be sure called the best Trilogy
@believetruthcleared239 sometimes 2 is better than 3. I can't imagine red dead 3. All the outlaws were dead or became farmers and the world was leading to WW1, there's pretty much no story after that, Jack marston probably joined the army or he died.
@@xxcronomaxx7986 I like to imagine with the “RED DEAD by J. Marston” book in gta v, Jack became an author and hopefully settled down with a woman in Beecher’s Hope and died peacefully in his old age.
It's crazy how completely different it handles compared to Rdr2. The horse physics improved so much. I never realized how much of a priviledge it was to be able to make hairpin turns without much difficulty
@@LayerZlayer2000 still looks good on ps3. At least the updated version. Disc version is a lttle bit rougher. And maybe not as good as on xbox because it already looked slightly better on 360. But it still holds up on PS3. I was surprised myself when I booted it up recently.
The horses in both are insanely detailed, but for a game released in 2010, RDR1 gets the credit for paving the way on making such a complicated animal right in video games. RDR2 had a great game to be influenced with-itself. And in that sense it’s noticeably better, but you get the idea. Besides BOTW I don’t see a lot of other recent games nailing those physics, muscle movements and small behaviors like R* did
You know you did a great job creating a game that you can compare a sequel being made 8 years later and they both feel timeless. RDR 1 and 2 are way ahead of their time. RDR1 could be a PS4 game, RDR2 could be a PS5 game.
I think he meant that the animation after shooting the leg of ncp in rd1 seems more realistic then in rd2 ... as if you shoot both legs they just sit down and fire
i remember how blown away i was first seeing the mud and snow effects in rdr2. the detail in the trail you're making to how dirty you get from falling down on the ground. it was an amazing detail to see back in 2018 and it still is. truly ahead of its time.
They crazy part about RDR2 is certain parts of the game are stand alone games of their own, big game hunting, fishing, stage coach robbery, poker. Just a masterpiece.
I always said with Red Dead 1 in particular, "ok I'm satisfied, video games have reached a point to where they'll always look good if they're at least this good looking." Years later, I still stand by that.
Remember guys that rdr1 was released in 2010 for PS3 and RDR2 was released in 2018 for PS4 and we can say that for 2010 game is much more better than many other game in this day and it even better than cyberpunk!!!
@@namgunaucao9771 you are right bro, other game than Rockstar game tittle is really bad when it came to physic,detail and many other thing to!! Ubisoft,cdpr and other game company DNT take serious to detail and physic than Rockstar game lol.. The only game that really close to best physic is CSS (counter strike source)!!
@@cjgsfhomie yeah i like css to. Ragdoll better than csgo. And i dont know why ubisoft, cod, cdpr always use trash ragdoll lol. I like thier games but ragdoll make me sick. If far cry games has euphoria and gore blood like rdr2 is awesome.
@@ItsYourBoyLeo_- Bro thinks he cool hating GTA 5 because everyone does lmao, let's be honest here you only hate GTA 5 because of physics, and that's a fact.
@@ItsYourBoyLeo_-You'll just be hatin on GTA V because of how rockstar milked that game but we all know deep down GTA V is a great game admit it or not
@@obiwanjakobe9620 thats what call improvement,Horse in real life Does Need rest.In rdr1 they Can Go brrr without losing Breathe But in rdr2 every horse has different Stamina..Its more realistic in fact
Personally, I'd have to say Red Dead Redemption 2 wins overall. It has a more varied map, better gameplay (in my opinion), and more activities to do in the open world. I know that Red Dead Redemption was released in 2010, so it obviously can't be as detailed as Red Dead Redemption 2, but I feel Rockstar already knew what they had to build off of with Red Dead Redemption 2.
of course bruh rdr1 came out in 2010 and rdr2 was released in 2018 so of course the physics would be way better than rdr 1 and rdr 2 would have more graphical power overall.
But the walkstyle for all walking, jogging and running are different than from Arthur's. Maybe not the same as in the original game, but you can see the difference from Arthur's.
Comparing an old game with a new one... Old rdr was great at that time and rdr2 is great at this time... First one raised the bar and now 2nd one is just mesmerizing. Rdr3 will be a beauty
both are great..But My Personal RDR2 is God tier Game..I cant Go wrong against How Better than The Physics Look In rdr2 But Yes The Leg shot In rdr 1 looks Cool
Both are ahead of there time But Speaking About Game Than RDR 2 Is naturally Better and A Big Improvement..Doubt That we will ever got a masterpiece like RDR 2
RDR1 John has contextual voice lines for literally everything. A feature that didn't carryover in RDR2. and it's a shame because the combat lines were so good in RDR1
7:36 I like the mention of Bill Williamson. The two tie together so well. Also 10:06 the detail with this guy. Johns rifle stock whacks the NPC in the ear, and he stumbles and put his hand to his head.
NPC after being shot in the arm an feet by John 1 time: kneels on the ground and shoots with only one arm. John after being shot in the chest 5 times: "anyway"
I definitely like the Dead Eye better in RDR1. I also like the drunk animations. I remember I came out of that bar stumbling around at night once and John passed out right next to the alley behind it. A woman just so happened to be getting stabbed right at that moment and I could NOTHING but lay there and watch. It made me feel the impact of being too drunk to help someone. It was a wild experience.
I think it'd be more suiting to ask which do we prefer. Both are amazing looking pieces of art. I find it meaningless when people always pit older games that were well received at the time against modern titles that are obviously superior *technically*. Maybe a decade from now, Redemption II may not look all that flashy like it does today.
I don't think graphics will improve too much in the near future for Rockstar. It will probably be technical stuff like raytracing, render distances, liquid physics and resolutions. Rockstar has patented some new AI NPC technology however, and I bet that NPC behavior comparisons will be trending on CZcams in 8 years where RDR2 NPCs seem fake to us in comparison. I also suspect their future games will have seasons and dynamically changing temperatures like RDR2 has realistic weather, and other technical improvements like that.
@@noamias4897 I believe it definitely makes sense because so far the graphics are top notch nothing really to fix besides the smaller things like you mentioned.
Exactly, rdr1 feels more Arcady & at times more like a western (prob cuz it’s further out west) It feels cartoony and the characters are more over the top. Whereas rdr2 is more grounded and real but full of small & tiny details.
@@lesgrossman6332 Red Dead Revolver better fits the description you gave rdr1. imo, the first Red Dead Redemption was the perfect blend of arcady and grounded. A believable world mixed with gameplay that doesn't feel so delicate. Don't get me wrong, rdr2 is a great game but it often feels too much like a simulator for my tastes.
It has the worst shooting mechanics in a Rockstar game since gta4 and some of the worst controlling movement in a third person shooter game to ever be implemented.
@@Pedro_Le_Chef bruh It didn't.. The shooting was great And better than rdr 1 Why are bumping down like Like A Kid?.. If Someone Thing Itd Better it's better and How Can U keep your opinions real Against Millions of Peoples
Only thing is rdr was ahead of its time for when It was released. Same for rdr2. As serious as they both are I feel like rdr was a tad more arcade style and kid based. Like rdr deadeye had big goofy x marks and rdr2 has small x's. That and also it came out when I was a kid. fuckin love the red dead redemption series
I always found the ragdoll and the detail of the bullet marks on the NPCs incredible in Rdr1, in fact, I even think it's superior to the 2nd game, apart from that the game has many details that remain current... but in general terms Rdr2 is unbeatable, although there was a very small downgrade in this detail of Ragdoll in the 2nd, it greatly elevates everything that the 1st game did, and its story is one of the most incredible stories I've ever seen playing video games... well, Rockstar made two amazing games
RED DEADS 2 horses is why I cannot play ghost of Tsushima . You can’t play any game with horse after red dead 2 . It was to the point where I though of my horse as an actual pet
@@raf5ay Huh? Gambling is worse in RDR2. There's no high stakes poker, no cheating, no liar's dice. The bounty hunting and duels are massively better in RDR1 because they are infinite and full of action (bounties have gangs) . RDR1 has way better gang hideouts. Please present arguments next time.
In my opinion Red Dead Redemption is better the story is better and John's a bad ass. But Red Dead Redemption II is funnier and I love Arthur and the graphics are amazing. But you got to think they let us down with John in Red Dead Redemption II as he isn't the John we know
We all know that RDR2 is amazing and ahead of it's time. What shocked me though, was how ahead of it's time RDR1 also was, the ragdoll, detail, and the muscles in the horses portruding when they walk, is all very ahead of it's time in 2010
Seu canal é o melhor de comparações e detalhes. Bom trabalho. É muito interessante ver a riqueza de detalhes que os desenvolvedores fazem e passa despercebido pela maioria das pessoas. Saudações do Brasil.
RDR1 is not only the best but it was ahead of its time. I went to its midnight release. I recall playing it in the living room and a family member asked, "What movie are you watching". All my gaming friends online were in awe about it. We played for hours telling each other how realistic it was, the horse movement/muscle etc. RDR2 is awesome but RDR1 paved the/its way.
I love how you can feel Arthur’s energy even when he passed. It’s weird, but yet beautiful (Edit: By energy I mean there’s literal spirit animals from the passed camp members, specifically birds flying alongside John as he travels to Mount Hagen. The birds can symbolize good energy/spirits as Mary Beth, Hosea and Lenny. If you see deer’s, that’s probably Arthur’s spirit animal. It symbolizes that he’s still there with you when he passes, as you continue to play as John Marston.) Didn’t anyone notice that?
@Jonathas Fiorito vdd mano, mas a rockstar vacilou muito em não fazer um online bom, pq gosto de mais de rdr2 tô zerando pela terceira vez e pegando platina, se tivesse um online só ia jogar rdr kkkkk
Like and Subscribe😉😀
9:55 you should have used the push button in RDR1 (R2) to actually shove NPC. You can't do that in RDR2.
@@Pedro_Le_Chef you can push In Npcs in rdr2 Bruh
@@Pedro_Le_Chef that is available in rdr 2 aswell
these videos are the best men 🔥👏🏼😎
@@Pedro_Le_Chefض
Just like RDR1 was ahead of it's time for the year 2010 similarly, RDR2 is ahead of its time, raising the bar of brilliance ever higher: Nothing short of a masterpiece. Plain and simple
I can agree except for one point: Ragdolls
Unfortunately the ragdolls are not that complex and advanced in RDR2 as it was in RDR1 but the reason for that is, that since GTA5 the euphoria engine isnt a feature with priority anymore (Rockstar Games said this once in an interview)... Sad story...
Still has the best graphics even though it ran on ps4 that’s crazy
@@exorio2.012 rdr2 still looks good but very plastic and artificial, fh5 has far better graphics
@@nvwasntthere Bruh,Are You Blind..Rdr 2 has way better graphics than That Generic Racing Game..
@@Muhammad._.Shoaib I think People is Overrating rdr 1 in comment section Where even rdr 2 won the comparison video
There's nothing more scary looking than a bear tackling you and mauling you to death in RDR2. It's truly horrifying.
Thats what i wanna mention
That's why you stand your ground..... It's terrifying in it's own right, but you feel like a badass afterwards
Stay completely still no movement thank me later
There's nothing more terrifying than going to tall trees in rdr1. You'd find 3 bears waiting to rape you lmfao
Would be terrifying if it couldn't be solved with a simple QTE
One of the most amazing things about RDR2, for me at least, is the weather. The thunderstorms at night where you can't see until a lightning bolt shoots across the sky, or the sandstorms and blizzard where legit can't see five feet in front of you. How the character and your horse react to it. Absolutely insane. I love the way his hair grows, and how he sweats in the heat. The fact that if he comes home covered in mud, he gets yelled at to bathe, or how he gets tired if he doesn't get enough sleep and it changes his shooting.
Lack of sleep changes the way he shoots? In what does it change? I've never noticed anything about that
@@luka6335 Less accuracy and it's harder to paint targets in Dead Eye as the reticule will wobble all over the place.
@@raulferreira1138 Ohh alright! Ty
Sleep or no sleep, RDR2's shooting is bad. RDR1 is superior in that aspect
Rdr2 is one of my favorite games but I disagree about the weather. Instead of slow realistic transitions between cloud patterns and weather types, it just quickly transitions in a matter of seconds. Ive played on Xbox and ps4 and it's the same on both so it's not a bug and no one ever talks about it. It will be clear skies and then all of the sudden transition into a rainy day in 3 secs and then 30 secs later transition back to clear. The weather system is completely broken..
RDR1 horse physics is still better than Assassins Creed recent titles' horse's physics
RDR1's ragdoll physics are still the top in gaming overall.
Even RDR2 couldn't keep up.
Edit: to anyone saying no, i have a video on my channel proving that RDR2 forces the bodies to fall in pre-set positions. Variation is very limited. Be warned, you won't be able to unsee how bad the Ragdolls are after the video
@@Pedro_Le_Chef no
@@zero-vi6gl yep. This isn't even debatable.
Go play both games and compare the ragdoll physics réactions.
RDR1 is more advanced.
@@Pedro_Le_Chef Dude shut up and stop spamming the same everywhere..
Because it’s Ubisoft, they rush every game they make
Gonna be really interesting when we look back at how graphics have developed 8 years after Red Dead 2. Especially considering how good we thought Red Dead 1 looked back in the day.
one of The most Beautiful Graphical Game Is rdr2 or In One word GOATED 🐐
*Cough* *cough* Cyberpunk *cough* *cough*
@@mrumbrella9961 hell no
@@mrumbrella9961 cyberbug 2077
@@mrumbrella9961 On the trailers looked pretty well but ingame even on ultra + psyco rt looks bad
RDR2 looks like how I remembered RDR1 looking when I played it back in the day. RockStar does't make a lot of games but you know that when they do, it will have some of the best production value ever seen in video games. RDR2, to me, is still the most quality video game I've ever experienced.
my thoughts exactly
Absolutely. The only game I've played that's even close to RDR2 is TLOU2. Those games are on another level from everything else.
Rockstar is the boss of open world games and great story telling can't wait for GTA 6
Perfectly said
Yes 🔥
I would say that drunk effect and shooting NPCs in legs are better in rdr1
Yep. Much better. Ragdoll physics have been downgraded in RDR2. Bodies are programmed to fall into the same, pre set positions.
@@Pedro_Le_Chef why?
@@thecreativeblood4461 something in new games nowadays
@@Pedro_Le_Chef you are in every rdr2 vid ever
@@thecreativeblood4461 because its easier to program pre set animations, than create a system that accurately and realistically simulates real life physics for a game the size of RDR2
My favorite series ever. Completely reinvented grounded storytelling in games
I wish it end Being a Trilogy cause there isn't That much Of Game Trilogy..If this one end in 3rd one than rdr series will be sure called the best Trilogy
@@believetruthcleared239 or they could completely mess it up
@@notoriouslysky i wish it didn't
@believetruthcleared239 sometimes 2 is better than 3. I can't imagine red dead 3. All the outlaws were dead or became farmers and the world was leading to WW1, there's pretty much no story after that, Jack marston probably joined the army or he died.
@@xxcronomaxx7986 I like to imagine with the “RED DEAD by J. Marston” book in gta v, Jack became an author and hopefully settled down with a woman in Beecher’s Hope and died peacefully in his old age.
Rdr 1 doesn't even feels that old.. Damn rockstar
It's crazy how completely different it handles compared to Rdr2. The horse physics improved so much. I never realized how much of a priviledge it was to be able to make hairpin turns without much difficulty
You gotta admit rdr1 still looks great
True
It does on xbox one x and series x on ps3 not
@@LayerZlayer2000 still looks good on ps3. At least the updated version. Disc version is a lttle bit rougher. And maybe not as good as on xbox because it already looked slightly better on 360. But it still holds up on PS3. I was surprised myself when I booted it up recently.
@@zensoredparagonbytes3985 well on xbox series x and one x it's 4k and it looks so much better compared to the 720p the ps3 has in that game
@@zensoredparagonbytes3985 czcams.com/video/4jfI09l5dcI/video.html series x is even way better🥰 best remastered you will ever get
Rdr 1 has the real wild west vibes
It's because is really happen in the West
Nope it has the spaghetti wild west vibe the one from the movies. Rdr2 has a more realistic wild west
@@DasHooviepeople are so blinded by nostalgia it’s crazy.
czcams.com/video/oIlIfiKcD4k/video.html watch the video for 4k gameplay of rdr2
The horses in both are insanely detailed, but for a game released in 2010, RDR1 gets the credit for paving the way on making such a complicated animal right in video games. RDR2 had a great game to be influenced with-itself. And in that sense it’s noticeably better, but you get the idea. Besides BOTW I don’t see a lot of other recent games nailing those physics, muscle movements and small behaviors like R* did
I think majority of companies are just lazy 😂
RDR2 surpassed BOTW in physics
In Red Dead 2, your horse's balls shrink in cold environments.
The last of us 2
@@harchosmiaso you like staring at a horses balls
each had its own atmosphere
You know you did a great job creating a game that you can compare a sequel being made 8 years later and they both feel timeless. RDR 1 and 2 are way ahead of their time. RDR1 could be a PS4 game, RDR2 could be a PS5 game.
RDR 2 Is worth To be a Ps10 Game honestly
@@Yeash338 at this point ps10 games will be real life simulators
@@masudbillah6196 And Ps20 Literally Real Life
Rd1 is definitely aged you wearing rose tinted glasses man, I played through it in summer 2021
@@ClaytonTheCracker he didnt ever say any bad about rdr1? What the point To say That so
The details on the horses in the first one are still one of the greatest graphical marvels in all of video gaming
Rdr1 cougar attacks John. John’s reaction: STOP THAT! 😂
Lol
1:09 the rdr1 horse looks like farcry 6. This shows how far ahead rockstar is from other companies like ubisoft
Rdr1 John looks goofy hit by a bear 4:36
I love the leg of ncp in rd1 seems more realistic then in rd2
I kinda disagree..rdr 2 leg fall looks more realistic In order
idk
yea...pretty cool tbh
Fr
I think he meant that the animation after shooting the leg of ncp in rd1 seems more realistic then in rd2 ... as if you shoot both legs they just sit down and fire
i remember how blown away i was first seeing the mud and snow effects in rdr2. the detail in the trail you're making to how dirty you get from falling down on the ground. it was an amazing detail to see back in 2018 and it still is. truly ahead of its time.
These are potatoes Comrade Commissar why are we using potatoes instead of
real grenades???
@@cpl.dmitrititov Because real grenades are valuable. In fact, they are worth a lot more than you are
I remember watching the mud effects on the first trailer back in 2016, that sold me
RDR2 obviously is better in eveything, except Dead Eye. That shit was fucking satisfactory in RDR1.
RDR 2 Dead Eye is a masterpiece
strongly agree
Only with levels 2 and 3 so I can x on explosives and lanterns
the sound of the gunfire makes rdr1's deadeye better
not only that.
RDR1 has way better aiming, Ragdolls and health systems.
Infinite duels/bounties/random events too
Drunk John from rdr1 is fucking hilarious 😂😂
They crazy part about RDR2 is certain parts of the game are stand alone games of their own, big game hunting, fishing, stage coach robbery, poker. Just a masterpiece.
Same for RD1, night watchman, poker... that's the better game.
I always said with Red Dead 1 in particular, "ok I'm satisfied, video games have reached a point to where they'll always look good if they're at least this good looking." Years later, I still stand by that.
@@otdreamer193 obviously modders can make it better. They are doing it AFTER the developers release their game.
@@Zanoladab ur annoying
@@warpdarkmatter thanks
That is true.
@warpdarkmatter😂
The Atmosphere of RDR1 is amazing. Dark and gives off that western vibe
Remember guys that rdr1 was released in 2010 for PS3 and RDR2 was released in 2018 for PS4 and we can say that for 2010 game is much more better than many other game in this day and it even better than cyberpunk!!!
Dumb 😂
Rdr1 ragdoll still better than most ubisoft, cod, the last of us, gow, cdpr games lol. R* is best in ragdoll(gta v still nice)
@@namgunaucao9771 you are right bro, other game than Rockstar game tittle is really bad when it came to physic,detail and many other thing to!! Ubisoft,cdpr and other game company DNT take serious to detail and physic than Rockstar game lol..
The only game that really close to best physic is CSS (counter strike source)!!
@@cjgsfhomie yeah i like css to. Ragdoll better than csgo. And i dont know why ubisoft, cod, cdpr always use trash ragdoll lol. I like thier games but ragdoll make me sick. If far cry games has euphoria and gore blood like rdr2 is awesome.
RDR is not better than Cyberpunk...
Both are ahead of its time
Rockstar's Masterpieces👑
Let's be honest Rockstar can make horrible Games * Gta5* cough cough. Or they can make masterpieces like the rdr2 story line
@@ItsYourBoyLeo_- Bro thinks he cool hating GTA 5 because everyone does lmao, let's be honest here you only hate GTA 5 because of physics, and that's a fact.
@@limbo7700 don't I have my opinions
@Jobrogaming ok at least we got a good game and not wasting money on fictional cars that we will never get
@@ItsYourBoyLeo_-You'll just be hatin on GTA V because of how rockstar milked that game but we all know deep down GTA V is a great game admit it or not
Both were masterpieces for their times, period!!
Rd2
Rdr2 is still a masterpiece and incomparable to other games even almost 5 years later
Now rdr2 became very outdated i can't play it anymore
@@vegetasticknodes27 Rdr2 is outdated? Name a game with better details.
@@doge_69 the gameplay and the animation is outdated not details
I remember playing this game back in 2010 and getting amazed when this happened 2:22 no other game has given me that "wow" moment since
Yes i try this directly on red2 sometime with « boss » i doing that and you feel so powerful to bad they dont put that in 2
The facts he's shooting a shotgun with one arm on both his knees though
RDR 2 Is obviously better than 1 But We had To Appreciate How good rdr 1 Was good of its time(Same as rdr2)..
RDR 1 even looks better than the newest Saints Row
@@YellowSubmarine8 true imo.. The new saints row Really sucked bad..
It's not "obviously better" tho. I still prefer RDR1, even when you compare them in terms of storytelling.
rdr1 is better
@@DeadX2rdr2 is better
the drunk effect on the rdr1 is like the effect when you make niko(gta 4 main character) drunk
man they should've re-released rdr2 for the current gen consoles.
it's because? so it was just a new generation exclusive? that that would be horrible, because it's better that the game is for both generations
@@diegomaradona6293 what?
@@diegomaradona6293 its already on 8th gen consoles..?
Nah no release they should do a normal patch that's it but they won't
The horse riding was a big improvement.
Man for real I played RDR1 recently and I hated the way the horse controlled I went off a cliff twice in a mission had to restart it three times
Yes and no still pretty clunky
@@LayerZlayer2000 Clucky In Which way? it pretty behave as ir Horses tbh
The old horses were better, the new ones regain stamina way too slow.
@@obiwanjakobe9620 thats what call improvement,Horse in real life Does Need rest.In rdr1 they Can Go brrr without losing Breathe But in rdr2 every horse has different Stamina..Its more realistic in fact
RDR1 had a better drunk walk
thats the most irrelevant thing for a game though
@@streetzomb69That's a game defining feature.
Both Game are a Masterpieces
2:56 the monotone "oh god help me"
6:09 you got an event while recording... this went so funny lol
0:04 Stupid Question ... but the Answer is ez .... BOTH
Personally, I'd have to say Red Dead Redemption 2 wins overall. It has a more varied map, better gameplay (in my opinion), and more activities to do in the open world. I know that Red Dead Redemption was released in 2010, so it obviously can't be as detailed as Red Dead Redemption 2, but I feel Rockstar already knew what they had to build off of with Red Dead Redemption 2.
RDR1 walked so RDR2 could run.
@@SxVaNm345 exactly
As a RDR1 fan boy and simp, can't disagree. RDR2 was a perfect sequel/prequel/whatever
Me too is the best game ever made
@@vegetasticknodes27 hi vegeta i think arthur is smarter
RDR2 is better I'd say. 👌🏻
of course bruh rdr1 came out in 2010 and rdr2 was released in 2018 so of course the physics would be way better than rdr 1 and rdr 2 would have more graphical power overall.
@@driverfurqan3619 relax dude lol
I think it would have been better if John's movements were the same as in RDR1.
It feels weird for him to do Arthur's moves.
It just more realistic.
Yes very true
But the walkstyle for all walking, jogging and running are different than from Arthur's. Maybe not the same as in the original game, but you can see the difference from Arthur's.
@@teknotaois2003 It has nothing to do with it, they could have recreated the mannerisms with mocap.
@@Nacut6c its still arthurs sometimes
And the crazy thing is is that RDR2 is made for PS4 era. A console with hardware almost 10 years old in 2022.
Ps4 era games had awesome graphics tho
*xbox one x and series x the better versions same goes for rdr1 on these both
@@royalvaibd4339 yeah xbox one x had
Don't forget that rdr 1 was made in ps3, and look how it look 14 years later for an old gen console
Red dead redemption looks like GTA 4 with San Andreas animation in the countryside
Bro The Of shooting in rdr1 Is ridiculously Funny
It Has shared Team Tho
No the animations aren't similar
@@c00lmanable it is bruh
Comparing an old game with a new one... Old rdr was great at that time and rdr2 is great at this time... First one raised the bar and now 2nd one is just mesmerizing. Rdr3 will be a beauty
Gta 6 First for more then 10 years there won't be rdr3
I doubt they will make a RDR3 as the online didn’t generate enough money, rockstar have gotten greedy now even dlc is a thing of the past
Rdr1 still looks amazing
Yea Reminds Me of a Mobile game name Six Guns Lame literally Everything is same but graphics Improved..I wish The remake will add rdr2 deatils
@@SSS-sd6bx you can't even compare that fool🤣
RDR2 is better in everything … except for drunk motions, RDR1 wins that
both are great..But My Personal RDR2 is God tier Game..I cant Go wrong against How Better than The Physics Look In rdr2 But Yes The Leg shot In rdr 1 looks Cool
Both are ahead of there time But Speaking About Game Than RDR 2 Is naturally Better and A Big Improvement..Doubt That we will ever got a masterpiece like RDR 2
Rdr1>rdr2
@@DeadX2both is good
@@tanushjaison5972 rdr2 is mid IMO rdr1 is better in every way the only thing rdr2 is better in is graphics snow details and it has dual wielding
Ambos son juegazos pero en detalles no hay quien supere a Red Dead redemption 2
Pero el único que se le acerca es el propio RDR 1
@@Xatarino GTA 4 aswell and Gta 4 Is also Better than Rdr1 and Can Give a Strong fight against Rdr2
@@Artics564 gta 4 better than rdr1? You're drunk
@@christopherpoblete8562 it refers that gta 4 has more realistic details than the first red dead redemption.
3:56 when RDR1 John said to the snake "Don't bite me!", I felt that
RDR1 John has contextual voice lines for literally everything. A feature that didn't carryover in RDR2. and it's a shame because the combat lines were so good in RDR1
@@Pedro_Le_Chef “You can’t even shoot a fart out of your own ass!” One of my favorite combat lines.
RDR2 cougar and bears are terrifying AF
6:01 RDR2 also has same drunk animation but better like RDR1 if you drank much.....
No it doesn’t
I like how rdr1 makes people limp by making there legs disabled
7:36 I like the mention of Bill Williamson. The two tie together so well.
Also 10:06 the detail with this guy. Johns rifle stock whacks the NPC in the ear, and he stumbles and put his hand to his head.
You know Bill Williamson is actually in the game, as well, right?
Both games were a masterpiece
2 incredibles games 🙏🏼
NPC after being shot in the arm an feet by John 1 time: kneels on the ground and shoots with only one arm.
John after being shot in the chest 5 times: "anyway"
For RDR2 thre should’ve been a difficulty setting, like in RDR1. Because with hard mode in RDR1 I really felt like I was surviving in the wild west
I definitely like the Dead Eye better in RDR1. I also like the drunk animations. I remember I came out of that bar stumbling around at night once and John passed out right next to the alley behind it. A woman just so happened to be getting stabbed right at that moment and I could NOTHING but lay there and watch. It made me feel the impact of being too drunk to help someone. It was a wild experience.
This game is 4 years old ? Cant belive
I think it'd be more suiting to ask which do we prefer. Both are amazing looking pieces of art. I find it meaningless when people always pit older games that were well received at the time against modern titles that are obviously superior *technically*. Maybe a decade from now, Redemption II may not look all that flashy like it does today.
Thank you that's exactly what I was thinking obviously RDR2 looks better it's the newer game.
I don't think graphics will improve too much in the near future for Rockstar. It will probably be technical stuff like raytracing, render distances, liquid physics and resolutions.
Rockstar has patented some new AI NPC technology however, and I bet that NPC behavior comparisons will be trending on CZcams in 8 years where RDR2 NPCs seem fake to us in comparison. I also suspect their future games will have seasons and dynamically changing temperatures like RDR2 has realistic weather, and other technical improvements like that.
@@noamias4897 I believe it definitely makes sense because so far the graphics are top notch nothing really to fix besides the smaller things like you mentioned.
Exactly, rdr1 feels more Arcady & at times more like a western (prob cuz it’s further out west) It feels cartoony and the characters are more over the top. Whereas rdr2 is more grounded and real but full of small & tiny details.
@@lesgrossman6332 Red Dead Revolver better fits the description you gave rdr1. imo, the first Red Dead Redemption was the perfect blend of arcady and grounded. A believable world mixed with gameplay that doesn't feel so delicate. Don't get me wrong, rdr2 is a great game but it often feels too much like a simulator for my tastes.
Bruh drunk john in rdr1 hits different
OLD or NEW..Nothing will Beat Rdr2..Its just a Flawless masterpiece 🗿
I Think Gta 4 and Last of us 2 Can give a tough fight they are not better but Can Give a Really Good compete
True..Old,New or Upcoming Didn't matter rdr 2 always be The King
It has the worst shooting mechanics in a Rockstar game since gta4 and some of the worst controlling movement in a third person shooter game to ever be implemented.
@@Pedro_Le_Chef bruh It didn't.. The shooting was great And better than rdr 1
Why are bumping down like Like A Kid?.. If Someone Thing Itd Better it's better and How Can U keep your opinions real Against Millions of Peoples
@@Pedro_Le_Chef worst Clown Take ever
RockStar are king of open world games
I missed the drunk mechanic from Red Dead Redemption
Only thing is rdr was ahead of its time for when It was released. Same for rdr2. As serious as they both are I feel like rdr was a tad more arcade style and kid based. Like rdr deadeye had big goofy x marks and rdr2 has small x's. That and also it came out when I was a kid. fuckin love the red dead redemption series
Both Game Is My Favourite ☺️
Favorite is only one.
@@letral1308 than 2 is my fav
@@Laila5234 Ok.
i wish rockstar releases RDR1 on pc cuz my pc can't run RDR2
من آرزوی دارم نسخه ۲ را بازی کنم ولی پول ندارم کنسول بازی بخرم😭
What is your PC specifications?
@@nima9035 play on pc
@@nima9035 پشمام ایرانیی😂
That's not happening for a long time since they lost the source code of red dead 1
I always found the ragdoll and the detail of the bullet marks on the NPCs incredible in Rdr1, in fact, I even think it's superior to the 2nd game, apart from that the game has many details that remain current... but in general terms Rdr2 is unbeatable, although there was a very small downgrade in this detail of Ragdoll in the 2nd, it greatly elevates everything that the 1st game did, and its story is one of the most incredible stories I've ever seen playing video games... well, Rockstar made two amazing games
@otdreamer193With the difference that GTA 4's story is good while 5's absolute garbage.
RED DEADS 2 horses is why I cannot play ghost of Tsushima . You can’t play any game with horse after red dead 2 . It was to the point where I though of my horse as an actual pet
Ghost gameplay>>>>>>>>>>>RDR2 gameplay
RDR1 continua sendo impressionante, ainda mais para a época.
I still liked RD1 way better.
Cuz it’s easier?
Would be nice if u made John in rdr2 look like John in rdr1 more so the comparison would be better
Yea Like in 6:01 rdr2 john Can Have The same animation as rdr1 Drunk John But U have To Drunk To much In rdr2 which is realistic
@@SSS-sd6bx realistic doesn't always mean fun
RD2 is way better! But for a game from 2010 RD1 is pretty good and one of the best!
Way better in visuals.
Combat, ragdoll physics and activities are all better in Rdr1.
Activities??
@@raf5ay infinite bounty hunting, duels, random events, town jobs, more gang hideouts and more mini games.
@@Pedro_Le_Chef yeah all these things are better in rdr2 expect ragdoll
@@raf5ay Huh? Gambling is worse in RDR2. There's no high stakes poker, no cheating, no liar's dice.
The bounty hunting and duels are massively better in RDR1 because they are infinite and full of action (bounties have gangs) .
RDR1 has way better gang hideouts.
Please present arguments next time.
6:00 people talking about John’s noble deeds while he’s pissed drunk like a fool
Nice video bro
The wolves in rdr1 have an animation where they pull on your arm.
RDR 2 wins graphically and mechanically but there will never be another RDR 1. The story has still yet to be beat
OMG I'm a huge fan
Even mechanically, RDR1 is better.
Free Aiming is so fun in RDR1.
@@ernestandrews3723 thanks lol
@@Pedro_Le_Chef free aiming in Rdr1 is Literally Aimbot Unrealistic af..and No Mechanics In rdr 2 had been better
The dead eye in red dead 1 is outstanding 👌 👏 p
I like RDR 1 dead eye
Obviously, RDR2 wins, but RDR1surprisingly held it's own. It was actually really good, had better effects than Cyberpunk 2077 at the very least
Rdr1>rdr2
horse physics of 2010 game is still way better than ubisoft's AC horses (Valhalla)🤣
Don't compare Ubish*t Against Rockstar
Far cry too. Like the last one it looks like something rockstar would have made a decade ago
2:19 even with his injured leg the npc fights for his life, rockstar always remembering these smallest details
I like RDR2 More So Its better For Me . Otherwise Both masterpiece 👍🏻
In my opinion Red Dead Redemption is better the story is better and John's a bad ass. But Red Dead Redemption II is funnier and I love Arthur and the graphics are amazing. But you got to think they let us down with John in Red Dead Redemption II as he isn't the John we know
Did you really want the same John in the prequel? I enjoyed seeing him grow up and become a family man
Yea I know but I'm taking about the looks not his personality.
@@anthonyfernandez82 And the main thing I loved about rdr1 was the outfits and we don't have those sadly.
2:53 npc getting obliviated
Some random NPC: "Oh lord help me💅"
I like the old death animations for npcs
Goofy way dead animations💀
It shouldn't be a competition. They're both nearly 10 years apart in age, and were both/are both staples in the gaming industry. They're both amazing.
my opinion, dead eye is better in the first red dead
I do miss the limping RDR1 had. Even when you disarmed someone twice in RDR1, they'd start limping for some reason. Always made me chuckle.
Rockstar gets a lot of shit for taking forever on making video game sequels but my goodness it’s always a treat when it finally does release.
GTA VI is goin to be the greatest game of all time when it came out
RDR 2 Is A Masterpiece
Same can be Goes for Rdr1 and If we are saying better than Rdr 2 is better game
@@SSS-sd6bx it's not
We all know that RDR2 is amazing and ahead of it's time.
What shocked me though, was how ahead of it's time RDR1 also was, the ragdoll, detail, and the muscles in the horses portruding when they walk, is all very ahead of it's time in 2010
One thing I couldn't stand, is John's animations in the second game. They were awful and weird looking. He looked cool in the first one.
Seu canal é o melhor de comparações e detalhes. Bom trabalho.
É muito interessante ver a riqueza de detalhes que os desenvolvedores fazem e passa despercebido pela maioria das pessoas.
Saudações do Brasil.
Greetings!
I like how rdr 2 won the Comparison but Some Nostalgic Simps Can't Handle that imo
RDR1 is not only the best but it was ahead of its time. I went to its midnight release. I recall playing it in the living room and a family member asked, "What movie are you watching". All my gaming friends online were in awe about it. We played for hours telling each other how realistic it was, the horse movement/muscle etc. RDR2 is awesome but RDR1 paved the/its way.
2 wins in in everything except drunk john.
And dead eye, and shooting legs - those were better in RDR1
@@PolishGod1234 nope
I love how you can feel Arthur’s energy even when he passed. It’s weird, but yet beautiful
(Edit: By energy I mean there’s literal spirit animals from the passed camp members, specifically birds flying alongside John as he travels to Mount Hagen. The birds can symbolize good energy/spirits as Mary Beth, Hosea and Lenny.
If you see deer’s, that’s probably Arthur’s spirit animal. It symbolizes that he’s still there with you when he passes, as you continue to play as John Marston.)
Didn’t anyone notice that?
Bro what?
People just say the dumbest shit. It's a video game. Chill out. "yOu cAN sTiLl fEeL arThuR's energy!"
Average Arthur fanboy be like:
John > Arthur
Rdr2 O Melhor Jogo já produzido... Anos luz a frente de quaisquer outro... Pena que a Produtora o abandonou...
Cara, abandonou como o caralho, é literalmente o segundo carro chefe da impresa
@@g.sedrez mas em questões de atualizações não tem mais nada
@Jonathas Fiorito vdd mano, mas a rockstar vacilou muito em não fazer um online bom, pq gosto de mais de rdr2 tô zerando pela terceira vez e pegando platina, se tivesse um online só ia jogar rdr kkkkk
For me I prefer red dead redemption cause I love it’s story and you can go to Mexico