I would respectfully disagree. In such a live room there should be more detachment. But his playing was superb. The 32' reed on the last chord was the way God intended!
Really wonderfully recorded, played and registrated! Hope you will bring out all the Guilmant sonatas on (SA)CD sometime! Your recordings bring out some style connection with Mendelssohn. It has lots of subtle nuance!
Bravo! Eine wirklich hervorragende Interpretation. Ich vermute eine Zimbel, die etwas herraussticht, an einigen wenigen Stellen hört es sich dadurch nicht mehr so schön brillant an wie der Rest. Alles in allem: sehr schöne Interpretation.
+Steven Dreyer Nein, eine Zimbel ist das nicht, die würde ich auch nie für Guilmant nehmen. Es sind einige Töne der tiefen Hauptwerksmixtur, die etwas herausstechen. Die hohen Frequenzen verlieren im Raum mit zunehmendem Abstand deutlich an Intensität. Ein größerer Mikrofonabstand hätte aber ein unklareres, verhallteres Klangbild zur Folge.
Woahhh, I am impressed by what great this music is!! I expected it to be like of that other modern dumb ass organ writer of "symphonies", you know. That's a pleasan surprise, thank you
Fantastic!! For once someone who doesn’t make a formula 1 race out of this wonderful piece of music! 🙏🏻🙏🏻
Absolutely 🎯
And it is still demanding!!!
Yes it is, that's why I like it so much.@14reger
Marvellous and wonderful to have the score to follow.
Such clarity. Outstanding playing. This piece deserves more performance than it often gets. It is usually eclipsed (unjustly) by other finales.
Splendid and majestic, just as it should be.
Wow. I really love it. What a beautiful piece, very well played. Thanks!
Glitzert schon sehr stark, aber sehr schönes Tempo, auch agogisch gefällt es mir sehr gut!
Que lindo y que nitidez , brillante,gracias.
Definitely going to ask the organist at my parish to play this for the postlude after mass.
A
Clearing my soul
Really breathtaking
like your tempo. not frenetic. clean, musical playing. Sehr gut!
Ich tippe auf 4‘ scharf mit Quinte 2 2/3 könnte aber auch zimbelstern Register sein das es so hell und glitzernd klingen lässt. Großartig 👏
Sumamente Maravilloso!!!
THANK YOU for the music sheets that goes with it!!!
i like that toccata and fugue cameo on the lower keys
Wow!
It's totally like a symphony!!
It basically is, as there's a version of the whole sonata as a symphony itself.
Bravo
Divine!
다들 달란트가 너무나 크군요~ 멋집니다.
Bin jetzt die nr 300 die dieses fantastische Play gefällt! Hab ich jetzt gewonnen ;-). Gruss aus NYC
Nice legato playing!
I would respectfully disagree. In such a live room there should be more detachment. But his playing was superb. The 32' reed on the last chord was the way God intended!
"fatfinger" at 7:45? (back it up to 7:39 to set it up)
Excellent. I have only one question. How do you play the last chord on the pedals? I only have two feet.
I play the deep D with the left foot, the upper D with the heel and f sharp with the tip of the right foot.
Don't you run the risk of cutting your foot if that f is sharp?
@@davidjames1684 Ar ar ar ; )
Really wonderfully recorded, played and registrated! Hope you will bring out all the Guilmant sonatas on (SA)CD sometime! Your recordings bring out some style connection with Mendelssohn. It has lots of subtle nuance!
Bravo! Eine wirklich hervorragende Interpretation.
Ich vermute eine Zimbel, die etwas herraussticht, an einigen wenigen Stellen hört es sich dadurch nicht mehr so schön brillant an wie der Rest. Alles in allem: sehr schöne Interpretation.
+Steven Dreyer
Nein, eine Zimbel ist das nicht, die würde ich auch nie für Guilmant nehmen. Es sind einige Töne der tiefen Hauptwerksmixtur, die etwas herausstechen. Die hohen Frequenzen verlieren im Raum mit zunehmendem Abstand deutlich an Intensität. Ein größerer Mikrofonabstand hätte aber ein unklareres, verhallteres Klangbild zur Folge.
Triple pedal?!?
Trop lent . . . .
mia gfoits allaweil
dats ulot uh noatz.
It should be played faster, the indicated tempo is 120
Woahhh, I am impressed by what great this music is!! I expected it to be like of that other modern dumb ass organ writer of "symphonies", you know.
That's a pleasan surprise, thank you
Bit too slow but well played none the less
Everyone else plays it to fast. In such a live acoustic room it simply cannot be rushed.
@@dleimkuehler Yes, in the time since I posted that comment I must say my opinion has changed.