Women, Shari'ah and Islam - Hamza Yusuf
Vložit
- čas přidán 24. 03. 2011
- Get 1000 free mp3 files of Hamza Yusuf,
Siraj Wahhaj, Ayden Zayn and others!
www.aydenzayn.com/free
"30 Facts About Islam" free eBook: www.30factsaboutislam.com
Buy the DVD for this title: www.islamondemand.com
Why is Islam Better?: • Can You Explain Why Is...
Find more Islam On Demand lectures here:
iTunes/Apple Music: www.islamondemand.com/itunes
DVDs and MP3s: www.islamondemand.com
Subscribe/Follow:
Newsletter: www.islamondemand.com/subscribe
CZcams: / islamondemand
Facebook: / islamondemand
Twitter: / islamondemand
TikTok: / islam.on.demand
Instagram: / islamondemand
Visit our websites:
www.IslamOnDemand.com
www.30FactsAboutIslam.com
www.AydenZayn.com
www.Islamogram.com
And please don't forget to like, share and subscribe!
TERMS OF USE:
If you use any part of this video or audio in your own production, you must do AT LEAST TWO of the following (and they MUST REMAIN as long as our content appears on your channel):
1) Add an end screen that either links to our channel or links to our video that contains the content you used. For instructions on how to do this watch this video: • How To Add End Screen ...
2) Add a card that links to our channel. The card's teaser text should say “Check out Islam On Demand”. For instructions on how to do this watch this video: • How to Add a Card to a...
3) Add our channel to your list of recommended channels.
4) Add the following text in the VERY TOP of your video's description: Check out the Islam On Demand CZcams channel: / islamondemand
5) Add a legible and clearly visible text overlay that appears in the FIRST HALF of your video and remains on screen for at least 7 seconds that says “Support Islam On Demand at www.IslamOnDemand.com"
LOL! So when I first started watching I didn't think I would make it through the first minute of this. I'm a woman, I'm an american, I'm a christian...but you know what? This dude is incredibly articulate and I think I'm learning something about my Islamic brothers and sisters.
Lovely of you to recognize that we're all in fact brothers and sisters
I am American and I converted to Islam because of the truth of his words. Allah is great and has honored women. We complete half of the religion of our spouse. Honor your spouse. Honor your women. Honor to men. We are different and Allah complemented our differences, strengths and weak through the other. Alhamdullilah.
Hamza is an amazing individual. You will notice that the likes of David Wood will never make videos about him.
Im a grown man, 6feet tall 215 pounds.
I read your comment n went aww 😬
To explain what is equal and what is equality
islam is so beautiful, alhamdulillah, I am grateful for being muslim
A’udhu billahi min ash Shaytanir Rajim (I seek Allah’s protection/refuge/shelter from Shaitaan, the Accursed one)
+N6236
Why are you denying what everybody in the world know about Aisha? ..
Aisha had sex with Muhammad when she was 9 (moon years, she was actually younger), as Aisha said in Hadith Sahih Al-Bukhari, Volume 7, Book 62, Number 64:
Narrated 'Aisha:
that the Prophet married her when she was six years old and he consummated his marriage when
she was nine years old, and then she remained with him for nine years (i.e., till his death).
Volume 7, Book 62, Number 65:
Narrated 'Aisha:
that the Prophet married her when she was six years old and he consummated his marriage when
she was nine years old. Hisham said: I have been informed that 'Aisha remained with the Prophet for
nine years (i.e. till his death)." what you know of the Quran (by heart)'
Now is the time to vommit, don't you think?
What "beautiful" is there to immitate a pedophile, jew hating, suicidal, woman hating mass murderer (Muhammad killed 900 jews in Medina after he defeated them, Ibn Ishaq p 464) ?
@GuruTruthSpeak
According to islam, virgins cannot object if parents wants to marry them away, so your comment is yes another atempt to whitewash islam.. According to Qur'an 65:4, there is no lower limit to when to marry a girl..It has absolutely nothing to do with psychological maturity, yet another attempt to whitewash islam. No matter if a girl is married or not, it is pedophilia to have sex with them, and islam position on this is digusting.
You even admit to agree on this issue, which is even more disgisting
@@NNamesis- He's an Indian scammer. 'Has been trolling Muslim vids for ever.
"anu Smriti says:
"Never trust a woman. Never sit alone with a woman even if it may be your mother, she may tempt you. Do not sit alone with your daughter, she may tempt you. Do not sit alone with your sister, she may tempt you."
- Manu Smriti, book of laws
The best hour and a half I have spent on CZcams. JazaakAllah sheikh Hamza. May Allah reward you.
I agreeee
The way the room is situated it is an elongated room with two large niches in one of the elongated walls. Sh. Hamza is sitting directly in front of the niche where the men are sitting (about 8 feet back) and the sisters are sitting in the other niche. The short wall between each niche separates the men from the women. Envision it like a large but shallow cursive W. Both can see the speaker. Probably more information than what you needed! :)
HAMZA___FROM TRINITY TO TRUE-UNITY.
That's a poor reflection on the Saudi government, not Islam. The fact is that Islamic law is NOT applied correctly there or in most other majority Muslims countries. Women cannot drive a car... where is that in the Islamic teachings? Nepotistic rule over the people... where is that in the Islamic teachings?
That was amazing mashallah. This guy has so much knowledge subhanallah. And I love his sincerity, as in, if he doesn't know something...he'll admit that he doesn't know. Many other scholars might just put forth their opinions but he tries his best to stick to what he knows..and mashallah shaykh hamza knows a lot.
My God! What an informative Chanel! May Allah reward you for it
Honestly I was disappointed when I saw the title of the lecture as manymen always badger women in their requirements. I was pleased as the lecture progressed. JazakaAllaheir Shaykh Hamza.
what an amazing lecture! alhamdulillah :)
Thank you for your exchange & I pray you continue to be pious & treat people well. Peace.
Shaykh Hamza Yusuf is awesome Masha'Allah.
To know & respect the cultures of other people is a sign of intelligency. Hamza is a wise man. Respect to people like him.
Thank you so much for making it available in my country
May Allah reward this man.
Relevant still after 10 years. 👌
why there is no option to share this video? I would like to share it. thanks for uploading. May Allah give u the reward :). I really love the lecturer.
@deeba123 Ameen. Thank you. Would you kindly add our website URL to your list on your channel page? Jazak Allah Khair!
I love this man.
This was like 30 years ago and the only difference is that the Shaykh has a few grey hairs now. Masha Allah
Nice teachings and discussion. I learned a lot Alhamdulellah. Just one suggestion Br. Hamza, if you could repeat the question please, as some of the participants has no mike close to them.
Jazak Allah Khairan
@BoredToDistraction (3) Of couse I removed the spaces and replaced the colon, dot and slash... same result. I'll tell you what, instead of relying on an unreliable website why don't you pick up the book and quote it for YOURSELF.
Quoted from the webpage I shared above (Sunnipath) "Female circumcision is itself obligatory in the Shafi school [but] it does NOT call for the removal of the clitoris (badhr) but rather a slight trimming of it (khafad) to increase sexual pleasure. If the removal of the clitoris was intended the word badhr would've been used alone. Since the correct practice has become so lost & has deviated in many cultures to gross mutilation many opt to take the Hanbali or Hanafi dispensation..." (Continued)
GREAT channel
keep it up:)
jazakallah great lecture
beautifully explained.
subhanallah,very good.
One of my all-time favorite videos on CZcams , thank you so much for sharing this with us .
Now, you say it's boring, ok I did also did too when I was younger. But now, I see so much pain & sorrow around me, I want to do good & help, that's just my humble self but that also didn't mean I didn't go round doing whatever I wanted, spending what I earned on nothing but for me. Now, I look at the Quraan, it teached to be kind to your neighbours, kind to this & that. Now this became interesting to me because it speaks to all humans.
@BoredToDistraction (2) I started watching the video but the man talking is citing these Bukhari ahadith: 6.399, 7.18, 5.234. Before commenting on these, I need to read the text for myself. But it's hard to find them using this number system. Typically there should be 3 numbers: Volume, Book, Hadith number. As you can see he only uses two. If you would like to discuss, please reference or quote ONE hadith yourself. Let's do one at a time, please.
In what authentic Islamic text does Islam justify such a practice??
@ShesGotManHands it's not impermissible in Islam to ask questions. And even though they were long winded, the sisters did not ask trivial questions. Hamzah Yusuf was patient and understanding, mashaAllah.
Alhamdulilah, more, more!
salam alaikum can i post this video in my channel
Spot on Sir!! Spot on!! Jazak Allah Khayr (May Allah reward you). Love this, best lecture/discussion, myth/disinformation buster ever :) I love Islam. I love Allah.
SubhanAllah how merciful Allah is so beautiful
Admirably articulate brother. Very pleasant to listen to. May allah bless and reward you with jannatul firdous
In order to claim that something is "sexist", one must first comprehensively understand the physiological makeup of both genders, what are the physical capabilities, the mental dexterity, how men and women conceive and react differently to events, how they communicate, etc.
Do we know anyone who has this kind of knowledge?
Because for someone to suggest that Women and Men should all be treated exactly the same in all aspects has made a very hasty, superficial judgement.
Relate to people in the workplace based on their merits and abilities, not because of their gender. Even if there are differences on an overall statistical basis (and this may be due to socialization and upbringing), that says nothing about the capabilities of an individual. For example, while few women enter engineering, my female cousin is an excellent engineer. Islamic assertions that "men are the keepers of women" is not appropriate in modern society.
a great lecture clearly hijacked by the person asking all those questions
can you tell me what time in the video he says that.
(Contined from before) "because the former considers [female circumcision] a sunna while the latter considers it a courtesy to the husband. And living Shafi scholars in many lands mention that given that the CORRECT practice has become an almost-lost art, the ruling within the school of the prevalent forms of circumcision would be IMPERMISSIBILITY". Quoted from: qa(dot)sunnipath(dot)com/issue_view(dot)asp?ID=4932
Mashallah best work u r doing.May Allah bless you people. I want to ask a question about one's income distribution among his relatives according to Islam. Is it compulsory to always give part of income to husband's brother, sister n all?I know that one have to give part of income to parents, but please can you clear this confusion?How much should be distributed and in what condition?If a person is covered under the pressure of debts then also it is compulsory? Jazaak Allah Khair.
It taught me that whatever money I earned, I can give to someone who needs it. Not everyone see's that & that's the problem. If only people just read the book with an open mind & just let it speak for itself. I haven't read it all yet I will confess.
It's a shame she doesn't see it the way the good muslim's do. However, I hope you both will live happy together & give charity. If anything bad happens, look at in the Quraan so see if there's a solution!
Are you talking about the meeting he had with Bush in the oval office days after 9/11? That's called "da'wah". He gave him a Qur'an and was a voice for American Muslims to tell George Bush to his face that Islam absolutely condemns the actions of 9/11. Do you?? Stop listening to the rumors. Many Muslims were emotional and got angry when they heard Hamza met with Bush and they automatically drew conclusions gossiped to no end. Where is your EVIDENCE that he "advised Bush to attack Afghanistan"?
Very good points
Wikipedia cites many Islamic sources that condemn female circumcision. Search for "Religious views on female genital mutilation" on Wikipedia: Female circumcision "is practiced by many Sunni Muslims although it has a controversial religious basis in Islam, and is mainly derived from culture. Cultural and religious intertwining caused the incorrect belief that female circumcision is related to the religion of Islam."
You yourself quoted the dispute in your previous comment: "Some consider this hadith to be da'eef (weak) and therefore muhkhar (rejected), but others rely on it." If some republicans endorse Mitt Romney but a majority do not, you cannot say "The republicans endorse Mitt Romney". The fact is that the vast majority of Muslims do not view female circumcision (or whatever you want to call it) as obligatory or even recommended.
Your quote shows the dispute over this text. So when you first said "Islam justifies" it you have to correct yourself and say instead "Certain schools of Islamic thought justify it". Regarding these schools, they define female circumcision in very particular terms that are MUCH DIFFERENT than how it's practiced today in places like Sudan. What you find in these places are CULTURAL practices that date back to pre-Islamic times that contradict the CORRECT way that causes no harm or mutilation.
If you dislike Islam come up with smthing that satisfy you TRULY thn I m ready to talk to u about it but Surly there isn't any batter guidance thn Islam (and yhhh m talking about the actual (Quran) Islam not the Islam presented by haters of Islam). Respect for all Humanity, Salam :)
@robertgift also, if youre so against it. Theb please explain how a book thats 1400 years old contain scientific facts that have only been discovered with technologies of the 20th & 21st century?
@MrChavre If shari'ah is dead, the Archbishop of Canterbury Rowan Williams would have never said this in 2008: "There's a place for finding what would be a constructive accommodation with some aspects of Muslim law" and that shari'ah law in the UK "seems unavoidable". Although I highly doubt you'll watch it, the video on our channel called "Can Shari'ah Be Accommodated in the West?" elaborates on his points.
(: (: I ADMIRE SHEIKH HAMZA YUSUF !!! :) :)
hes got the goods for sure
You're right, there is no such thing as a good mutilation. But the procedure described in the Sunni Path link I cited does NOT describe mutilation. It says the "slight trimming" of the clitoris. You are the deluded one if you EQUATE a "slight trimming" with "mutilation". What's TRULY mutilation is the COMPLETE or even PARTIAL removal of the clitoris and/or labia minora, or any other EXTREME procedure that VIOLATES the valid Islamic practice which preserves a woman's reproductive & sexual health.
Alhamdulillah
"Dr. Muhammad Salim al-Awwa, Secretary General of the World Union of the Muslim Ulemas, states that while the hadith is authentic, it is not evidence of legitimacy..." (there is much more). This quote is taken from the same Wikipedia page I referred you to. So I suggest you read it again.
Condemnation? Fact is that female circumcision was a PRE-EXISTING custom among Arabs BEFORE Islam. He was simply giving instructions to those who observed this custom. Damned if you, damned if you don't.
Your love is individual, Islam's live is mankind & the world but ultimately, Allah, God.
Salam. Please pray that Allah accepts my dua 💔
Please bring this to Savannah ga.
I've seen it too, but i didnt notice it until you said so....Maybe it recently started growing? Or maybe it wouldnt grow past that so instead of having that bit there all the time, he removed it?
I think this lecture took place in 1997.
Its a moot point in my mind because the hadith is weak which you acknowledge. Wikipedia cites many Islamic sources that condemn female circumcision. Search for "Religious views on female genital mutilation" on Wikipedia: Female circumcision "is practiced by many Sunni Muslims although it has a controversial religious basis in Islam, and is mainly derived from culture. Cultural and religious intertwining caused the incorrect belief that female circumcision is related to the religion of Islam."
ManshaAllah tabaraka Allah Alhamdullillah. I am watching from Kampala. Alhamdullillah may Allah forgive us all and help us be pleasing to Him and help us and answer all our prayers and forgive us and remove all fitna from us and keep us all in the right faith whatsoever, and help us in the meeting with the prophet Muhammad pbuh and other believers as with just His Mercy the Most Merciful we are grateful, only by Him we are what we are. Subhanallahu Alhamdullillah Wa laillaha illah lahu wa Allahuakbar wala hawla Wala kuwata illah billahi aliyul adhim tabaraka sm rabbika dhuljalal wa'alikram. May Allah forgive us.
It's because charity we know it now, is not law, only "individual" sense of kindness. Not everyone is willing. But when a law is set, everyone rich person must while the poor gain. A balance for human to grow. So you tell me that if it's a rediculous book? One’s intellect has to be applied in the understanding of the Book. This is something that the Quran itself has commanded us to follow at every step of life.
My Allah grant us inner strength! May Allah bless sheikh Hamza yucef, I've always look up to him!
@BoredToDistraction (3) Actually there is a comprehensive science of hadith methodology (centuries worth) that has determined which hadiths are authentic and which are not. The reality is that many have been passed down by people who were considered untrustworthy and many have been outright fabricated. Unfortunately, many orientalists use such hadiths to support their arguments. So we cannot simply ignore this science.
The URL you gave me came back 404 Page Not Found.
The problem is when people like you make sweeping generalizations about a medical procedure that can take on many forms. Female circumcision evokes feelings of disgust among people who ASSUME the procedure necessitates the complete removal of the clitoris and labia minora, But this is NOT the case. The Sunni Path link I gave you before states the PROPER Islamic stance: "a SLIGHT trimming of [the clitoris] to increase sexual pleasure". How is a SLIGHT trimming "evil, disgusting, misogynistic"???
It is not really a medical procedure, when it is done on religious premises. One should not alter the creation of Allah. Female genital mutilation IS evil and disgusting, no matter, how much they are cutting. When you are removing completely functional parts of the body, for no _medical_ reason, it is mutilation.
One should not go and cut part of their children's body, just because they interpret their religion that way. IF someone wants to go under the knife, they should have full understanding about it, and give their permission, as an adult. Not to be some helpless child under the elders force.
Zel Elz it’s recommended not obligatory.
Its not to increase her sexual pleasure but its to take away her ability to pleasure. A women to have sexual pleasure is considered potentially harmful in islamic context. There is a fear that she will possibly cheat against her husband. Or some other zenaa' or masurbate herself .to avoid her having accusations they just cut her clit out as a child.
as far as i can understand, naqs here is not used in a negative context, it is a disability, shariah is sympathetic towards it and is allowing for ease in responsibilities.
@janecooper In islam, women and men have equal rights but they do not have equal responsibility. For a woman to be the same as a man in Islam is an injustice.
,
"equal rights" lol, stop it, youre too funny! I cant take it! haha like the husband beats the wife and asks: "are you feeling equal already? no?" BAMM*
lachusity thats not islam do ur reasherch
youre the funny one
Live Shan I know right
@BoredToDistraction (4) But these "details" are in dispute. Your premise is being challenged. YOU are CLAIMING he "committed horrendous crimes" by posting very DETAILED descriptions of his SUPPOSED crimes. Then you get defensive when I challenge you to provide proof by saying you will not argue the DETAILS! Very strange.
Second point... Let's assume for argument's sake that this video was NOT edited. Bush said "Those who commit evil in the name of Allah blaspheme the name of Allah." Heck, I'd stand up and clap for that statement! What's wrong with that?
I can tell you at the same time, my friend who is a girl & is Muslim is THE best to discuss Islam. Your arguement holds not value or ground with that statement. You must look into it yourself. The book is for YOU to read, not someone else from a culture that abused the system because they weren't taught it properly or treated it right. Man used & abused the book to make it their advantage. But when you look at it as a whole, it's a system that works.
I'm only 14:00 in so who knows? I may wind up being all pissed off about this but Shar'iah interests me because so many people are against it. I just wanted to check out the law about women I guess in Shar'iah and see if it's actually any more limiting than what the christian law says about women.
God Bless Him, even I as a woman, had enough with the women's questions within 5 minutes. lol
There was nothing wrong with the women's questions. Seeking knowledge is not blame worthy
Subhan' Allah, how easy it is to deceive the masses with simple video editing. How can you be 100% certain this is the original UNEDITED video? I remember watching this live & cannot recall this moment where Hamza Yusuf clapped at that point in Bush's speech. If he did I would have remembered it! It's very possible the clip of him nodding and clapping actually took place in a different part of the speech but was moved to the part you see in this video. This stuff is done all the time!
Assalamu alaikum alhamdulilaah
@BoredToDistraction (5) Again, you are building your arguments on a premise to which I don't accept. Slow down sparky! You're jumping way ahead of yourself! I'm not trying to avoid the debate (I could have simply not replied if I wanted to do that). In reply to your comment I could say "What's wrong with Muhammad's behavior?" Do you see how we'll be going around in circles if we don't settle the first debate first?
Because it's meant to be for him, to purify ourselves for the hereafter. Say, if you had an amazing utopian city surrounded by ocean, unreachable but through boats or planes. Lets say, you have strict rules that only certain kinds of people you want into your utopia. I want to live there but I need to be the kind of person that would fit well to your utopia, I have to do what you would ask. But I make mistakes, would you forgive my mistakes?
For instance, in Al-Baqarah, Quran talks about spending in the way of Allah and how Satan motivates man into spending elsewhere for these worldly wishes. And then in the middle of this discussion, Allah says
"But none will grasp the message except the men of intellect." (Quran 2:269)
We can have a better world if we follow the teachings of Quran and authentic Sunnah of the Prophet Muhammad (saw)
That email was laughable. Honestly it didn't deserve my time. But if you insist I will try to reply back if I can find the time, insha' Allah.
I just replied to it.
*love
Yeah, they're "brainwashed" by cultural norms that have been passed down through their families for ages. If this practice is part of Islam, why don't Western Muslims practice this in full force? Surely the hadith you quoted (which again is considered by many as weak) cannot be the text that "brainwashed" them. In this text the Prophet (P) is not mandating it or even recommending it. He seems to hear of a woman about to do it and simply says do it in such-and-such a way that is better for you.
@BoredToDistraction If you were born, raised and lived in 6th century Arabia you would look at things just a WEE BIT differently.
Fear Allah
+FABRIKKATOR : You are Ignorant.
men and women are equal humanitarian way but not eqaul in identically
@MrChavre You hit the nail on the head: "extremists"... that's the real monster. Extreme interpretations of the Qur'an and hadith literature is the problem which results in a practice that justifiably "belongs in a cave".
Too many people on this comment thread think they are too great and worthy of judging others. Judgment is up to Allah. go try and be better Muslims instead of poking holes in everything, If you don't like it, take what's good and leave what's bad. That is the sunnah.
@BoredToDistraction This is what I mean by arrogant. You think just because a civilization came AFTER another the latter is more civilized. While I agree people evolve & can learn from predecessors its not NECESSARILY the case that the latter are better. You're not seeing my point that CULTURAL NORMS differ between time & place & neither may be wrong within their culture's CONTEXT. For example marrying cousins: acceptable in many Eastern cultures but frowned on or despised largely in the West.
And, in this world there's is still plenty of space to contain more people. We as humans aren't using the space well enough & or helping each other enough because of individualism. If you were exceedingly poor & a Muslim helps you out at of charity also because the law of Zakat as mentioned before, you would be back on your feet. Isn't that a solution to the worlds problem?
A sincere and honest question for you... Female circumcision is considered "genital mutilation" but male circumcision is not. Why?
Ones commanded by god the other isnt. And all other forms of mutilation are discouraged.
I have looked at the website and i dont see what you are claiming.Can you be more specific in your claims, as they are very serious.
Where are your direct quotes of Hamza Yusuf saying "usa are on the right to attack afghanistan". Stop paraphrasing and give me quotes so that we can discuss the FACTS.
Oh... it's clear to me now. This is a fruitless discussion. You are one of those. As-salamu' Alaikum.
Body rocker for sure
I would look into Islam further against Christianity, find out the difference between the 2. But please don't just think it's dumb & stupid, cos if it's true. The joke is on you. Never say something is stupid unless you have full on hard facts or knowledge, cos if you do, it just makes you ignorant. I appreciate your comments & I fully understand your side. But I hope you'll at least give it a chance & your girlfriend once more. Remember, don't mix culture with religion.
❤️❤️❤️❤️
@BoredToDistraction I've heard many tall tales before, but this one is completely new to me. Please provide a quote from an AUTHENTIC Islamic source to verify this story. And please don't copy-and-paste from some right-wing agenda-driven website. Go to the source and read it for yourself. Then share the data with me, including exact volume, chapter and verse numbers.
You know, I think that most people who say they know their religion because they're "born" into it & "live" it, probably haven't fully read the book or understood, or the people or parents understood it. It's for mankind as a whole, a unification of all with various different cultures as I said but when the culture disrupts, the final law prevails. So, education is full priority over anything. Where did you & your gf come from if you don't mind me asking?
You're not being fair in your logic. You say "some" republicans but you refuse to say "some" Muslims. By saying "Islam does justify" female circumcision you're saying it without qualification. You're saying all of Islam justifies it & hence all Muslims justify it. I will accept that SOME Muslims justify female circumcision or whatever you want to call it (mutilation, etc.). Can you admit that it's SOME Muslims and NOT all? And therefore it can be argued its NOT from CANONICAL Islamic teachings.