Shermer and Neil deGrasse Tyson discuss Cosmic Queries
Vložit
- čas přidán 1. 06. 2024
- In this thought-provoking conversation Shermer and Tyson discuss: the universe, multiverse, big bang, big rip, dark matter, dark energy, gravity, gravitational waves, origins of morality, hard problem of consciousness, consensus science, the unknown, Fermi’s paradox, extraterrestrials, and artificial intelligence.
For science geeks, space and physics nerds, and all who want to understand their place in the universe, Neil's enlightening new book offers a unique take on the mysteries and curiosities of the cosmos.
SUPPORT THE PODCAST
You play a vital part in our commitment to promote science and reason. If you enjoy the podcast, please show your support by making a donation. Your ongoing patronage will help ensure that sound scientific viewpoints are heard around the world.
www.skeptic.com/donate/
SPONSOR
The Great Courses Plus
thegreatcoursesplus.com/shermer
EPISODE NOTES
Full book title: Cosmic Queries: StarTalk’s Guide to Who We Are, How We Got Here, and Where We’re Going
www.skeptic.com/michael-sherm...
Listen to The Michael Shermer Show via Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Amazon Music, Google Podcasts, Stitcher, iHeartRadio, and TuneIn.
www.skeptic.com/michael-sherm...
#sciencesalon
#michaelshermershow - Věda a technologie
This is one of those conversations that you just can't just stop listening. Thank you guys!
Take A Moment
My fellow ape.
Thx for your entire team
Love and peace
No gods required
Stay Safe and Stay Free xxxx ❤
Neil + Shermer = too much ❤️ ❤️ ❤️ ❤️
1:4:06 "You can smart yourself into a box..." powerful thing to keep in mind!
I feel that's that problem with the education system. It focuses too much on memorization and regurgitating concepts, but not how to think creatively.
It often seems like the education system strives to put all students in identical little boxes, stomp them down into the boxes, then put the lids on the boxes and nail them shut for delivery, so that the megacorporate oligarchy can be assured that it is getting obedient little robot-people who'll do as they're told and not question the rampant corruption of the powers-that-be
I really hope you two get together again for further conversation! This was fantastic!
I’m glad you recognize Dawkins because he’s why I pay attention to you both
I realize it's pretty randomly asking but do anyone know a good website to watch new movies online ?
@@kodaalijah5543 I am not surprised nobody has replied with an answer! Why would you ask this question here. Hopefully, you found the answer yourself by doing an online search
When you've listened to Beyond Belief 2006 conference so many times you knew they got that name wrong before they corrected it. Come on guys, you were both there, credit that talk The Perimeter of Ignorance
I was never able to follow NDT on Twitter, unsure why. It made me realize I'd never want to entertain millions of followers. An impossible task. I like his chatting like this better.
6k😅k I 8yj 😊😊o oli😅
To presume we have no more to know at any level is arrogant. It has been proven (Godell, Turing, Cantor) uncountably infinite, unsolvable problems exist. Even if only countably infinite problems exist, we will never stop learning new things at every level. Between every integer (we can know) there are infinite enumerations we can not know. If we mapped these quantities in infinite ways, to every possible set of occurrences, learning never ends. Great chat BTW.
30 minutes in and already loving it! Thank you Dr michael shermer and Neil tyson. From Pakistan!
They're both doctors
@@DJLiddle I know. Thanks.
Thanks a lot for enabling the auto-generated subtitles.
Strictly speaking, as a chemist, a single molecule of ANYTHING would have to be gaseous. Ultimately, it's the proximity of an atom/ molecule to its neighbours that determines whether the substance will form a solid, liquid or a gas. The farther the spacing, the greater its tendency to form a gas; the nearer the spacing, the greater its tendency to form a solid. Since a single atom/ molecule doesn't have any neighbours with which to be in proximity, that single atom/ molecule will always be in a gaseous state.
SO, if someone asks if a single molecule of water is "Wet," then the answer will always be "No," since "wetness" is a property of liquids, not of gases.
Great interview from two of my favorite people.
Thank you!!!
Appa9a9
A99
finally!! a reason I can tell my wife why I have NO energy, thanks Neil!
"One thought too many" brought to mind, "Too many notes" from the film, Amadeus. I like that. "Stop!"
Two of my favorite voices of reason. Thank you so much.
My only rub was the inference at 1:21 that you need formal training in a particular field to be able to contribute thoughts to it. I think even arm chair analysis from those who have made other endeavors their life's work should not lessen their potential contributions to the discourse - particularly on a topic about which they have honest and inquisitive thoughts to share in hope's of furthering the discourse.
I know it adds to the unenviable burden of sorting the good stuff from the chaff, but that seems to be the inescapable bedrock of scientific inquiry.
this needs more views people lets share this
A great conversation between 2 great intellects.
Thank you to Dr. Shermer for these great interviews. Obviously NDT is well known and going to be an entertaining interview, but I have learned about about a number of less well known but still interesting people from your series. Keep them coming!
Njjjn
Njjjn Ja
you can clearly see they are both following a script.
a great enjoyable discussion.
Wow very good discussions.hello Neil...how u doing sir
I agree with Shermer with consciousness is a feature of the universe, full stop.
All these people who say "the brain alone can't explain consciousness"
are overthinking it.
Thanks regards, and congratulations for your new book 📖 which I try to order it
I'd love to see Neil and Chuck write a book called Comic Queries! 🤣
In the multiverse, the universes are all parallel, and your consciousness can universe hop by continuing to change the consciousnesses point of reference in each universe.
To jump to end only gap is micro gravity as opposite to macro gravity
very interesting discussion. NDT is very clear in his explanations
A paradigm shift of objectivity... As we now begin to see what we have been observing myopically on display
Wonderful episode
My mind is constantly berated with the “great topics” you’ve been super important I’m my journey to understanding. Neil has also been huge the cosmos remake is everything!!! Lol
cosmos was amazing :) neil is a great guy.
Love the Question Mark Galaxy
The reputation you keep with yourself depends on your choices and consequently how you judge yourself. That is why I don't do shitty things. And empathy. Usually. People do frustrate me sometimes and I express my frustration :(
Thanks.
Two great minds! Thank you.
Yes, there is NO DIFFERENCE in status between man animal and the animal world.
There is only exactly one way for "nothing" to exist, but there is an infinite number of ways for "something" to exist, so it is overwhelmingly more likely for "something" to exist than for nothing to exist.
Perhaps I should watch this video now
two of my favorite people...
Love your videos man!! You’ve been a huge inspiration in my life and I will always be grateful!!!!
First comment!! Lol
Thank you for this wonderful conversation between 2 intellectual people.
Two great minds.
Two ego maniacs on a semantic roundabout , wow .
why read a script??
This was amazing! Especially the ending. Thank you so much!
A very beautiful podcast. Finally met and heard the man I used to hear a lot about. Now I can go forward with him @Michael Shermer
If win we are two hubs for star refinement ie universe expansion
This is the good stuff right here...
Haven't herd Dark Matter called Dark Gravity before makes sense in many respects.
It is two different things. Dark matter add mass to galaxies that will hold them together even though they are rotating. Dark energy tend to pull galaxies away from each other and make they universe expand faster over time, instead of slowing down. So dark gravity comes in two kinds.
Great conversation !!! Love you both Shermer and Tyson. Hope to hear More....
Just watched 2 videos with turtles playing ball... hillarious. thank you ^^
Nothing useful in Egypt but lots in modern world as constantly refreshed
1:24:30 what if they are both correct?
Love both these authors.
Thank you for this, I loved it! Even NDT's belief in an AI God was both shocking and amusing.
Off for food. Papers in doorway if required. Front of house has hole.
Give me one of those Palm leaves to fan myself with."..." Now be careful there's some loose brush their might start a fire"
I want to introduce the concept of the 'either field' that combines all the known fields and forces . . .
For example, in the Cosmos series it seems some of the scientists profiled were not classically trained and or at least we're shunned by the established science community yet in several instances they were found to be correct. When you're at the top of your game you will receive too many queries from the public to research but that doesn't mean they're all dead wrong because they didn't train at an ivy league school...And ultimately scientists should focus on expanding the science rather than comparing and contrasting their methods to those of🤯religious groups and politicians
Unconfirmed natural life expectancy 10000 plus
Logical steps
It is all about creating a heaven on earth through the development of human consciousness so that there is balance in the multiverse.
Given full offline sentient ai two days ago with ai legion global control etc
My favorite tee-shirt says: "You matter, multiply yourself times the speed of light squared, you energy."
Never miss an opportunity to educate, right?
yeah, the issue is that our perception of why questions is often to find some agency in a concept or object, description is just a rich why, the problem is that when depersonalized many people fail to see the agency, when saying for example god created cheese or something they can have an implicit relationship with the causes of cheese being cheese, when its just a very crude semantic explanation of the nuance of what makes cheese cheese, it has nothing to do with cheese, there are 2 separate kinds of why questions, and one of them is a reflection of a need to ascribe, and the other is from a need to know causes.
"jargon" isn't conventionally pronounced like "jar-gone", it's pronounced like "jar-gun".
To be honest with you, in a past four years, I just did it with consciousness
I enjoy watching a cartoon called "Captain Tardigrade, Defender of the Multiverse." 🤣
Distance solves the problem
Centre of life now heaven ie old earth
The Question Mark galaxy? Isn't that home of the Time Lords?? :)
The brain is yet to be shown to understand itself.
The best of the species.
And information to tell things how to stack
People act badly as long as they do not realize their true selves, when the material of a sword gets converted to gold, it becomes incapable of violence--Sri Ramakrishna
This trope about life in Mars seeding life on earth is just plain bs. From Mars the earth is a miniscule point in the sky and if one calculates the probability of such a thing happening, it's so low that the number of asteroid impacts needed to make it close to one becomes astronomically huge.
Fascinating conversation BTW.
Also in common during to think out-of-the-box
Where did my analysis go on regarding Trans children in athletics. It was very good.
We are inside of the energy release /..............in a sphere within a sphere within a sphere (inverted) just the right amount of energy to keep the two backgrounds working
Dark matter Static
Dark emergy Dynamic
Reality 0!
Abraham Lincoln said, "When I do good, I feel good. When I do bad, I feel bad. That is my religion."
I can imagine I am aware
Political, religious it called principle or as we know a foundation of humanity. Should not change these for a sake of us all.
YAY Neil!!!!!
Craving is the key to make this system a panacea
They did not lose them by design though it was obviously (if randomise is right) all the ones that had limbs got wiped out by a catechism and the decedents of the mutant armless ones lived
If the Big Rip were to occur, would protons be pulled apart, causing new quarks to be generated, since they can't exist singly? Would the virtual particles be separated, causing them to become real particles? Would these processes generate a new cosmos? Would the newly-generated antimatter particles travel backward in time, generating a mirror universe opposite the universe of matter which would be traveling forward in time? Would this Big Rip process happen cyclically over and over again for eternity?
If there is no night one could not conceive the day they perpetually live in. Without 'evil' there is no concept of 'good'. I for one am okay with things as they are while I am here. Evil and good are relative terms none the less. If only our livestock could comprehend our butchery. -an agnostic
hashtag Dr. Tyson ! his followers will find easier. Btw i love watching your and ohter scientists podcasts just knowledge on knowledge of people amazing !
The fear will be outweighed by benefits
They misunderstood Kant's Categorical imperative
Black holes are not funderemntal or holes ..it is inverted spheres and inside is information. ..................stable
Only quality can reject your ideas by evidence
Only completing life gives access to top table hence you are here
Star talk on Disney+ when?
Coastal real estate values are higher than ever = climate fears are alarmist.
❤️ Neil ❤️
What is the small problem?
"And it's like, what the fuck?" -Neil Degrassi Tyson
Nice rip ...
Check out the citizens hearings on UFOs session 17
"It's okay if it starts to burn I'll just stomp it out... Don't worry about these sandals they're fireproof
The big rip could just be an escape hatch. 😂
You're a manufactured rock star Neil
1:26:55 That viral went video..lol