Why is eating dogs any different from eating cows, pigs etc? Simple, dogs are purposefully tortured to death in China, cows, pigs, chickens etc are killed quickly and relatively painlessly, that's the difference. If you want to see the awesome side of China, the fascinating culture and scenery that isn't related to killing man's best friend, check out our awesome documentary: www.vimeo.com/ondemand/conqueringsouthernchina Discount code: STAYAWESOME
If they were not tortured to death would there be any issue at all? I think most people who are against eating dog are only against it because of the "mans best friend" mindset and use the torture as a foothold to stop it (which is perfectly fine no animal should ever be tortured). Just curious on your opinion if they were bred like cows/pigs/chickens would we all still have a problem with the consumption of dog?
"Man's best friend." emmmm, a very western centered statement. Imagine an Hindu walking around South Africa and saying how horrible are the South Africans, they eat cows! I can't stand it! Please do not apply your culture and ideology on another, it may only shows your illusional moral superiority. In Chinese idioms, dogs are portrayed overwhelmingly as a creature with negative connotations. Ex: 狼心狗肺(The heart of a wolf and the lung of a dog), meaning rapacious as a wolf and savage as a cur; 狐朋狗友(Make friends with dogs and foxes), meaning being friends with the wrong type of people; 鸡犬不宁(Fowls and dogs are not in peace), meaning something causing a big chaos. And the list goes on. If "dogs are purposefully tortured to death" while other animals are not, you argument should be dogs deserve to be "killed quickly and relatively painlessly" as well, and most of Chinese people will agree with you. Most of people on earth against animal cruelty.
Ron S yeah thats fucked up. It happens alot in factory farms too though in america with some animals. But purposefully beating an animal just to beat an animal. I think id do something about it if i saw it right in front of me.
Ron S im not against other countries eating dogs and cats, yet someone who goes around stealing other peoples pets just to sell to butcher shops is really fucked up.
Ron S that's your opinion dogs getting beaten isn't as worse as eating them they can be healed stealing is plain wrong but as a dog person eating them is disgusting and emotionally sad I don't think you're a dog person otherwise you wouldn't actually believe that kind of topic
not everyone torture them. the main reason they beat them is, killing a chicken is very easy, there're machines and tools for killing cows and pigs, but there's no machine that has been invented to kill dogs, and dogs are dangerous. and quite often,those who kill dogs are often those who steal them. and, a certain religion is questioning: do western people eat pigs? and, how bulls are treated in spain even though they have certain machines to kill them rapidly? and, do australian really eat cute kangaroos?
The most disturbing part for me in the video wasn't seeing the dog carcass. It was watching those guys hop a wall and take some family's pets. Can't imagine coming home and seeing that footage knowing that my poor dogs were beaten, slaughtered and served to some villager for an appetite whim or to balance their chi. Lived in Taiwan for almost 20 years and fortunately saw 20 years worth of gradual improvement in attitudes towards animals -- dogs more so than cats. (Though that was improving, too.) This necessary cultural shift in China can't happen fast enough for me. BTW, took in a stray kitten in 2007 and brought it with me when I moved back to the US in 2014. After watching your video, I'm going to have to go give her a pet. That said, it's almost noon here and the lazy bum hasn't gotten up yet...
Yes, while I am no dog lover, I did find the scene of the dog being stolen hard to watch, especially the part where it was fighting from going over the wall. I would cut that part out; maybe show the thieves going in, nothing more needed.
So, as long as the dogs are not "pet dogs", I think people can still eat them anyway. You know, just like some people love to have pigs as their pet, but still others can enjoy bacon and sausage Because I do not see the difference between a dog and a pig.
As Winston said during the video, it's mostly just cultural. In the west(I'm Australian), dogs have a history of being a pet, or a working animal. They help herd sheep, or even help the vision impaired to live their lives. Probably for that reason, we, as westerners, probably can't associate dogs with food. The whole thought just makes me cringe, and I want to go n give my little one a great big hug right now. She really is a part of my family.
I was stationed in the Philippines in the 70's. When you were eating there was one simple rule, never ask what kind of meat are you being served. If you weren't eating fish, pork or chicken you were eating dog. I used to go to a bar that had taco Thursday, order a beer and get free tacos. The last time I went with a buddy we had downed a few beers and eat a plate of tacos. The waitress asked if we wanted more tacos and my buddy asked what kind of meat was used and she answered in her native language. He didn't understand and she said you know arf arf. The tacos were good but that was the last time we went to taco Thursday.
Oh boy the 3rd demonizers, we are poor doesn't mean kill innocent beings, we don't commit massacres, we don't burn others people house, we aren't serial killers, we do not enable people
yeah, there it is cat meat that is more popular Ihave heard, they consider cat meat to be delicacy, sick and disgusting , I love my cat soo much, she is like my child, can never imagine someone cooking her for dinner
@@theshockerpit7274 if you're using that argument, China could be exempted as well. Dog eating has occurred in most cultures in East Asia, including Vietnam and Korea. The reason China is so known for it is because it got increasingly popular there during the famines in the 1970s and 1980s where there was a lack of food. Since then it has caught on with the Chinese who are already desensitized to that kind of stuff. This is why China has never been known for prominently eating dogs throughout its history, and even the Yulin dog eating festival came about in 2009. During this time, the other nations like Korea were becoming more and more western and eventually outlawed the eating of animals while China still allowed it.
Don't ever go to Yulin dog market. I couldn't handle it, I attacked a couple of traders there, I had to be escorted by the police away and nearly thrown in jail, I lost the plot. What is disgusting is the totally unnecessary suffering of the animals and how they slaughter them. Some boiled and skinned alive, from that moment on I decided I was going to leave China after considering living there with my now Chinese wife, that was in 2007. I heard that the dog meat market has expanded even more now. This experience had such a profound effect on me I also became a vegetarian from that day on and still am today. My Chinese relatives still find this very odd even today. I did leave China a year later and now live back in England.
daniel miller - yes they do, one of mine is an avid dreamer & barks like mad apparently chasing things in he sleep with legs going and everything - it´s a marvel to watch and simply wonder what he´s dreaming about, whether it´s birds or cats he´s chasing :) :)
The enjoyment many of the traders and butchers seem to get from inflicting pain and suffering on the dogs is insane. The lack of empathy really goes towards indicating that there seems to be an entire segment of that population that are clinical psychopaths.
I don't have any problem with eating a dog, necessarily... but I think it's somewhat questionable to eat the meat of a predator animal, as it encourages raising animals for meat farming. This process requires animals to be confined to small and undesirable conditions, which is torturous for an intelligent carnivore. However, one thing I DO have a problem with is animal torture... I once saw a video of Chinese men torching a dog's face while holding the dog by the neck with a pair of tongs. It was fucking disgusting and kept me from sleeping well for a few days. It filled me with such disgust it is almost beyond comprehension. Those people should have their testicles brutally ripped from their bodies.
I shouldn't have watched this. The image of that man stealing a dog and pulling it so heartlessly over the fence is going to haunt me for a very very long time.
walk with the truth. its very sad. yes, but your money does the talking. donate to help the activists. and dont buy dog meat. and the torture will stop. same goes for other meats around the world if you feel for them.
Chinese people are poor, they cannot afford other meats like beef or mutton, I meaning sometimes they eating dog to get protein, you may think it's ridiculours, but that's the truth why some Chinese eat dog, by the way, vietnam and south korea people eat dog more often
Thank you for making this video. I am Chinese. I know that many people eat dog meat, but there are very few young people who eat dog meat. But there are still a certain number of people still eating. I can hardly accept this fact. Because the dog that accompanied me for three years when I was a child was taken away by a stranger, I cried for a long time😭😭. I hate people who eat dog meat. I will promote more to the domestic media, and only by putting pressure on them can this happen.
Like in other countries, when people earn more money and get more educated, older senseless traditions are dropped, which is sometimes good. There are always a few younger people who like these bad traditions, though. In my country, we are trying to outlaw bull fights.
Lol. You Chinese posses an inferior culture. Your nation wants to dominate the world but it’s the furthest from deserving this right. So many disgusting things in your overpopulated trash ridden country. Hopefully your peeps can turn it around.
If a family considered a cow or a chicken their pet and a part of their family, people wouldn’t go and steal that cow or chicken from the family foR food. They also wouldn’t then proceed to torture the animal in the most inhumane manners possible before consumption. That’s the point.
@@octave1 If you watch undercover documentries, you will find out how back in the west how we also mistreat farm animals of all sorts, whether it be force feeding geese, to beating pigs and cows, keeping them in closed environments and since they can't even move, they get rashes and all sorts of horrible diseases and problems, like gangrene. It's a universal thing.
While I agree with you on all your points towards eating dog meat, Hindu’s see us the same as we see Chinese for eating beef. A cow is sacred to Hindus, it is effectively their dog or cat. My belief, if an animal is going to be culled for any reason, it should be done in a humane and stress free way as possible. Loving the topics Winston, 10/10 for daring to touch on some controversy occasionally. 👍👍
His point is. Western culture consumes beef daily and other cultures think we are fucked up for doing so. Switch it around where they don't eat beef at all but consume another animal that we would never eat in a western world and we think they're the fucked up ones. Who's in the right?
One of my friends who lived in a small rural village Guangzhou when she was younger had her pet dog stolen and her family got a box filled with the dog's bones afterwards. Most Chinese hate the idea of hurting dogs and eating dogs but in certain areas some people are just......urggggggg
@@Jonathan-tk4dd Yes it is because they aren't bred the same way. There is a reason dog is "man's best friend", it was bred for its empathy and bond with humans.
dont try to say its just happening in certain places so u hide ur criminal country and criminal goverment and barberian people in ur country, dogs are beaten, burnt, cooked alive in china and this is savage , if a video of dogs being cooked alive would go viral in US millions and millions of people would protest becuz theyr not savage.dogs are suffering and u just care about the international face of china
Thank you for making this video, as painful as it was for me (and you, too!) I have been teaching ‘in China’ (online from the USA) for almost 3 years now and I have grown to love the people and the beauty of the country, but there are still some things I just can’t understand, like the existence of this trade. I am encouraged to know of the growing activism against it, and I remember one of my young students once spoke of this subject in a shamed whisper. I hope these young ones can make a difference. Thank you for this, and all the videos you do that give outsiders an inside look at this incredible country! You rock! 😁👍🏻
Just because you don’t understand, it doesn’t mean you have to understand. There are so many things that you won’t understand from any culture. It is right to have an opinion, but it is not right to be an ignorant.
People please understand he is stating the way they are killed that is wrong, not that it is wrong to eat dog. Beating, burning,boiling and torturing them while alive is what is wrong.
Dogs have been domesticated, evolved to rely on humans for food. This is why eating dog is wrong. They are loyal pets, guarded the cave for a bone, stayed when the food ran out and did not eat us despite being carnivorous. The Chinese also ate each other during 3 famines over the centuries. Mental illness from mass hysteria and mistrust of their govt is what I see when I watch coverage of life in China.
It is wrong to eat dog, but its also understandable if you are poor and starving to eat it. Humans can agree once an animal reaches a certain point of being sentient and awareness it is wrong to eat them
sad sushi Why is eating one animal permissible and eating another isn't? Your society eats cows but in others the cow is something respect and don't eat. Don't knock someone else's society simply because you do things differently in yours.
sad sushi You ever been to a hog or cow slaughterhouse? Chicken factory? Why is one more inhumane than the other? They all suffer pretty terrible and for their entire lives.
Subhajit Choudhury Again, what is the justification for eating one animal and not the other for you? Is it social conditioning or the manner in which it is killed or both? Is it okay to eat a dog so long as it is killed in the same manner as your favorite animal to eat?
@@thetitansofcitycarter7207 you think hunting is less ethical than factory farming? if youre gonna eat an animal it should live happy and free. hunting is more humane and takes more responsibility than buying meat from a store that lived in suffering its entire life
I'm Chinese and I get racist comments at school about me being Chinese. They always start laughing about how I'll start putting cats and dogs in the oven! That's not true! Not all Chinese people eat dog some do but some don't. I don't eat them. Me and my family raised one when I was growing up! ^^
chinese do eat dog, but not as tradition. about 5% like eating, 5% against strongly, rest 90% don't eat or care. but you know 5% is large number in China.
But why these rest are not raising their voice against it .all dogs lover will help them . being quite is also wrong which it means that are also instigating this .
Hejas Closet because they believe the more pain the animal endures the more nutritious the meat will be. They happy because people will pay good money for it.
I have heard of this over the years, but it's still a shocker to SEE it. I was reading the comments and someone had mentioned that CATS are also "on the menu". Is this true? Are cats eaten as well?
I see in the comments that the "eating dog its like eating any other animal" is a very popular opinion and I disagree, here is why: Dogs are not called "mans best friend" for no reason, they have pretty much being the reason of our incredible advance as a spices since the nomad life of our ancestor, they had helped us hunt, protect out farms and livestock (thousands of years ago pretty much every continent had his shepherd dog variant) dogs are a fundamental part of our history and have evolve to understand us and communicate with us, they understand our facial expressions and voice tonalities a dog is not just some animal, they have put their trust in us and we on them. To eat them (let aside torture them) is inhumane, is betray that inter- species relationship formed 30 thousand years ago its just horrible and cant be put in the same box as cattle, pig or any other animal
Dogs, cows, horses, pigs, sheep, chicken etc are examples of domesticated animals that have been selectively bred to have characteristics we want. The ancient Chinese rated the cow very highly and hence did not eat it very often because it was needed to plough the fields, rather like some use a horse or now a tractor. Pigs tended to mature very quickly and were considered a good food. In addition pigs are very good at digging for foods hidden in the ground, some peoples used pigs to find truffles. Dogs were employed as guards to warn of thieves. If you want to make the moral case for putting dogs ahead of other animals don't harm any of them to be consistent. Really it is just an emotional thought to protect one animal species and not another. Nor can you ever be fully morally right as everything you do, use and occupy has harmed animals in some way - eg farming, infrastructure development, pollution (going into the land, air and water) and the list goes on.
@@neurozero Dog is not very commonly eaten. Pork is the most common meat for meals by far. You'd have to be mental to breed dogs for meat seeing as though they take about 2 years to reach adult weight, under 60lbs. Pigs about 6 months to get over 260lbs. Profit is very important. Chinese people have even been injured when shopping for pork and there was a shortage.
Kitti Kat corona was found out about in a lab and yes I agree with dogs helping us advance but we’re forgetting that if there was nothing to hunt it would be useless,if you don’t get what I’m trying to say,I’m trying to say that ,considering how much animals such as cows and pigs effect our daily life’s we should really care for them,examples;1:During ancient nomad times the way people lived was by making houses out of cow fur and to not die they would kill cow and eat it meaning if cow didn’t exist we probably wouldn’t even be alive.2:Cows and pigs are used in so many industries such as clothing,food,entertainment(eg.Zoo’s) and the reason you even have strong bones is most likely because of cows,3:They were here before dogs and it’s not fair that when humans came along we killed them however the part of the Chinese tradition I disagree with is when they torture the dogs,that is extremely cruel.
Hello! I live in the North of China, in Shenyang. I am a vegetarian and activist in the past...I help now send money to couple of animal refuges and activists. But I want to do more...without making local governments angry ( or being deported). Maybe you can give me some tips , or maybe you know some activists in the North and refuges. Thank you in advance and thanks for doing this video. People need to know it and see
This is a stupid analogy. Chinese eat dogs because of their agrarian society (as noted in the video). In India, they choose to not eat cows due to religion.
It's not only in China. Even in my country, Indonesia, there are a lot of people eats dog meat. In some town, you have even have to put a collar to your dog, or else you can't blame people if you dog is killed and eaten by them.
I've purposely stayed away from this particular post. Glad I finally watched it. You handled it very well. As well as can be expected with the subject matter. Stay Awesome!
serpentza - I appreciate all your videos. Thank you for doing such a great job on covering China and Chinese culture. That said, I think "staying on the fence" as you mentioned in this video is counter productive to making the world a better place for both animals and humans. Although eating Dog meat in China is a cultural or traditional practice for some, the cruelty involved, as you mentioned (beating a dog to death, boiling a dog to death, torturing a dog before you kill it, stealing pets for consumption) is an act that can't be tolerated anywhere on the earth regardless of cultural conflicts. Cruelty in any form cannot exist if the human race is to move forward in the next step towards the betterment of our species. I know you do not like to get political in your videos, but I implore you to always condemn cruelty in your videos and not sit on the fence when organizations like No Dogs Left Behind ask for your help. The more we stand up against cruelty in the world, the more likely it will be less tolerated by all.
Amen. Fuck these stupid traditional beliefs. What if we had a traditional belief that beating a Chinese guy to death was part of our culture to celebrate our strength. I don't think that would be allowed. It's just not acceptable under any circumstances.
This is why i would never want to live in a country were i am not allowed to own a gun. Criminals like this don't need prison they wont learn anything. They should simply be put down.
Every year I cry my way through the tweet storms about Yulin unable to understand any of what’s going on~ Thank-you for painting a clearer picture for me. ✨🍃🌸🐶🙏🏻🐱🌸🍃✨
I lived in China for around two years in Beijing but traveled all around the country, from South to Inner Mongolia, Tibet, etc. and I never saw dog meat being served or was offered any except one restaurant in Beijing so it's definitely not common and I do think it's more of an older generation thing, much like in South Korea where I also lived for many years. Hopefully the younger generation will put an end to it or at least push it farther into obscurity. Thanks so much for your videos man, they let me feel like I'm back there again certainly miss it.
Jesse Day i am Chinese.every friend I know never eat dog meat. and the North of China eat dogs because Korean Chinese people, South is yulin people some traditional things.
Without specifically looking for it, I saw dog meat in northeast China a couple of times and also in Beijing in the 1990's. If you looked for it, I'm sure you'd find more.
Ikr, I've never eaten dog meat and neither have my family and I'm surprised everytime I visit america, people assume it's a mainstream meat that we use for our daily lunch. Italians eat horse meat but I don't assume most of them eat it. (sigh)
do you even understand English? how does that answer indict anything about he disliking it? enlighten me (sarcasm, in case you fail to see what I mean) . you can find stupid people making stupid statements online right about anything and anyone, so my question is why the heck you lash out of it on Chinese nationalists huh? have you read any outrageously ridiculous claims made by them? do you do the same to Koreans or Japanese or anyone for that matter? judging by your family name, Chew, sounds like you are an insecure south east Asian with Chinese heritage with self hating complex? because that's VERY COMMON in south east Asian Chinese (by the way Chinese heritage merely means only somehow your ancestry came from southern China, and China is huge, which barely means anything or have anything to do with bloodline, in most cases your genetic makeup is probably much closer to Vietnamese than to us)
youtube actually recommend this to me in my feed just now and my eyes darted back and forth between you and the dog in the thumbnail and I thought "they have the same haircut!" 😆👍
I subscribed because you’re showing people the real China not like other people just blaming the whole country for eating dog meat. Yeah the new generation is changing people’s mind and trying so hard to save those poor dogs I really hope our government could care more about animals not just pandas or tigers. Again thank you so much for telling the truth, I love dogs more than I love humans lol I’m such a dog person.
I would starve to death rather than killing and eating my dog because i know she would never try to eat me and rather starve to death with me... Sadly you can't say same for majority of people, if you are starving to death with some people better watch your back. People are killing each other in waayy better conditions..
I thought that all Chinese eat dogs. sry for that . you know what is the main cause of their sorrow that you all people are not raising your voice. Actually you really don 't care about that. If you really care about that you have to persuade your gvt. to end all this. Tolerating something wrong is also wrong.
Ggoddkkiller same here, I will never do anything harmful to my dog, but I can’t say about other people, some of my friends from other countries told me they loved their dogs but if possible, they would try dog meat for once before they die.
Maybe that's what comes with modernization and having disposable income to acquire a pet? Dogs are easy to get attached to but that being said so is a little piglet! My friend has one and I've got to say that little s.o.b. is a charmer.
I remember being pointed out dog food restaurants in Harbin northern China when I went there with my then Chinese girlfriend about 17 years ago. I also remember seeing a few pet dogs around, a small long haired toy breed, don't know the name. What was funny was that they don't cut the talls or clip the hair, so you see these small dogs with enormous long hairy tails dragging along the ground. Very cute. I could see the owners, who would take them out for a quick pee and run around, were very fond of thier pets.
I saw one of these disturbing aftermath of a dog being chained and nailed (I think) to a post on yt shorts, Reported it and now hopefully it will get taken down, I just don't understand why someone would do the deed and then post a video of the aftermath to yt shorts? Like when people don't know what's coming? Sick, utterly sick
Winston - You state later in this video that "the majority of Chinese people don't eat dogs". It would have been nice to start the video with this comment vs "Yes, Chinese people eat dogs". Frames the situation more accurately.
Totally agree. Just saying that for the person casually viewing this video without knowing too much about Winston's travel or the reality of the infrequency of dog meat eating, the first few minutes of this video paints a different picture that much later on is addressed. By then, the first impression has already been made. I do like Winston's videos and think he portrays his honest view on China.
Aj C totally agree. For example, there are some American people are super racist, but u can’t say American people are racist. Especially in the videos where people may not watch the whole video but just a few seconds for a glance.
Tianci - my point exactly. Humans are already wired to think fast - with biases - in many situations (re: Daniel Kahneman's works), and quick first impressions may leave overpowering impressions.
Translate This - I believe this topic is especially incendiary and strongly stokes emotions for many people. I would say that the majority of people don't eat dog and especially do not approve of the extreme cruelty that other videos show (thankfully not this one - the dognapping aside). One needs to sit through this entire video in order to see how the village majority does bring some justice against these loathsome gangs. By then, however, some viewers may have already been had their racist views confirmed or been insulted. Careful of that human search engine...
The evil uncle power up sound had me chuckling the 1st time. My sides were left aching the second time. Winston.......if you see this please make this a permanent feature.
I have seen multiple videos of people skinning a dog while it is alive and screaming. This is the most horrific trade in the world right now and needs to be stopped. Also it is not also the torture part that is horrific it is the fact they eat a dog. A dog is a dog and you shouldn't eat them. It is in their dna to be companions not food.
I think a man capturing a dog by a neck and dragging it over the wall deserves some kind of disclaimer and/or censoring. The topic is very important to cover and know about what’s happening; however, you just said we’d see dog meat. No indication of a poor dog struggling and panicking to get away from thieves that then proceed to drag it over a high wall by the neck.
Singapore Chinese here. Thanks for tackling this topic. Love the way you presented it. I'm neutral like you on dog meat. Its a cultural thing. I don't eat it but I'm okay with others doing so if they like to. That said, kidnapping and killing others' pets is out of the question. Those thugs need to go to jail. Once again, great video. Stay awesome!
2 important points that you have highlighted 1. Dog-eating is more prevalent among people of lower social classes and does not represent the entire population. 2. No legal framework to deter animal abuse.
1. You'll find that the majority of the Chinese people are lower class, so that's kind of representative of a large portion of the population. 2. No legal framework to deter human abuse either.
+Live I'm gonna be straight forward. 1. You're wrong. The majority of lower class don't eat dogs nor any other kind of pets. Just go walk on the street and visit some restaurants and you'll get the answer- the majority of catering business don't offer dog meat. 2. You're wrong again.
physika fuck the important points you scumbag , it's wrong and all dog eaters should be killed. When we were younger we would ask Asians that moved to our country if they ate dog meat and those that were stupid enough to say yes we beat to within an inch of their lives, sport beatings and when reports came in on the news about dogs disappearing in certain neighborhoods we would go there find out who had recently moved in from China or Vietnam. We would pay them a visit and once they admitted to it we would again beat them and cut off a hand. When word got out that we were looking for them the dogs stopped disappearing from these neighborhoods. Many Chinese and Vietnamese don't eat dogs and told me that when those that did arrived in the US or Canada all they saw was free meals walking down the street.
I disliked not because I don't like you, Winston, but because I am a dog lover and I'm showing solidarity with your other fans who hate this practice in China and in other countries doing the same. Thanks for educating everyone.
What upsets me is the inhuman cruel evil methods they use to kill. Skinning and boiling a puppy ALIVE (which is equivalent to skinning and boiling a human toddler) is insane, merciless, barbaric and monstrous. Can you imagine if there was eye for eye justice and humans who did this were beaten, had the flesh on their bodies skinned off while alive and then burned, poked and boiled alive. I'm horrified and haunted by the photo's of puppies in these torturous scenarios on the internet with soul crushing pain in their eyes.
andrea chen they are cooked that way because a starfish that has been dead over 24hrs is too tough to eat although i have never seen it on a menu and crabs the meat in them decomposes really fast once they are dead that is why most are cooked alive although alot of people put a knife through their head before cooking and comparing that to beating a dog to death is just plain and simply stupid
They are barbaric.. Why on earth y to uld u torture the thing ur about to eat and put inside ur body... In the middle east and India they kill the animal in a happy prestige state so that the meat doesn't spoil upon death... If you torture the animal before death its meat will taste bad
Although it may be a disturbing topic to talk about, it is a must to change peoples perspectives on such behavior. People These days a pitiful and gutless, and in my opinion, need to be shown more of the disturbing things in life to really get them to show appreciation towards anything in this life. They don't care because they aren't made abundantly aware of the situation. People get away with this sort of behavior because the general census of the public is they don't care. They don't care because they aren't informed, so thank you for talking about this subject and bringing it to the light.
I lived in southern China in early 60s. Beef was $10/lb. My family bought like 4 oz to cook as flavor. One could buy life dog for $1/lb. So it was much cheaper to eat dog than beef for the nutrient. A 15 lbs puppy would feed our family for days. People living in the farm never had chance to eat beef because they were not available. They often raised dogs for food.
Good video Winston! But at 1:33, it says “高丽狗肉店” which高丽stands for the old korean empire or the korean people. So you probably were at Jilin or Liaoning province when you film this because a lot of the korean Chinese ethnical group(朝鲜族）lives, and Korea has a dog eating culture too.
The restaurant is in China for Chinese people to eat, that’s like a sushi restaurant in Miami, sure it’s Japanese food but there aren’t going to be Japanese people in miami
please sign this petition if you want to protect more dogs from being eaten. Please make this visible to everybody! www.change.org/p/boycott-pyeongchang-2018-winter-olympics-in-south-korea-a-dog-eating-nation?j=203701&sfmc_sub=318096696&l=127_HTML&u=37604413&mid=7233053&jb=7979&utm
The Korean are indeed culturally more famous in eating dog meat. The history of the west protesting the east about eating dog actually started against the Koreans, when they were about to host the Seoul Olympics in 1980s. As you duly pointed out in the video, the Chinese are traditionally agrarian people that didn't have a special historical tie with the dogs as the more or less pastoral European people in the past. However, the northern Chinese, historically influenced by the northern nomadic minority, did feel more strongly to the dogs than the southerners do. The Koreans are however not sharing this feeling. So it is fair to say that in the north, the dog-eating practice is more a Korean influence. Personally, as a proper southern Chinese, I do not share your feeling with the dogs. I would not refuse a dog hot pot if offered although I had it only once in my life. I am indeed against the torturing and illegal capture of any animals, not just dogs.
I remember there is one video of yours whereby a chinese lady scolding and shouting saying that 'Chinese don't eat dogs!'. If you able to provide me the link to that video,I would like to bash her up properly for saying that.
Well done for covering the tough subject, I to am a dog lover and I was sitting on the fence at the start of the video with the argument what is the difference between eating a chicken, a pig or a dog, all can be pets for people, but the fact that people are stealing peoples pets and then battering them to death because they think the meat tastes better, well shocking quite frankly. If you hadn't covered this topic I never would have realised that.....what an eye opener. Keep opening all our eyes, fantastic channel and advchina is fantastic as well.
Edward Snowden I think hit a dog to death because they dont want cut the head want a whole dog. not because it tastes better. In chinese markt or restaurant you see a lot of dead animal as a whole body. even a crocodile
A chicken or a pig are totally different than a Dog.. That's like saying were the same as a chicken or a pig..I know Dogs are under us..But a chicken and a pig are way under a dog😐
Does anyone not understand different animals have different pain networks and clearly perceive reality differently? Eating a lobster for example is not like eating a human or dog.
🇧🇷 Não falo inglês, mas as imagens me fazem entender... Acabei de assistir seu último vídeo, chocante!!! 😵😓 Seus videos 📽, são necessários, a verdade sempre vai aparecer, mesmo que seja por minoria 👍🏻🇧🇷
I’m a Chinese and I’m surprised that you know more China than me, because I thought people don’t eat dogs anymore. You are telling the truth and I support that, Chinese eat dogs and cats is already became a stereotype, and this is terrible that government didn’t make any laws about this. I’ve talked about it with my friends they said because there’re still a lot of poor Chinese people can’t feed themselves so they don’t give a damn about other animals. China have a lot of good people they love animals they love travel they love people but also there’re a lot of shitty people. I like your video and keep doing it, tell more people about the true China(good or bad). I hope you have a good life in China! And don’t let those shitty twat bother you💪🏼💪🏼💪🏼.(I hope you can read my comment)
peter song well, firstly I did not slander Chinese, I’m just clarifying the truth, did the government ever consider the dogs and cats? No they did not, they just keep letting it happen, u can’t deny it. And yes I’m a Chinese a Chinese that facing his own country’s problems.
I don't actually think it is against the law to eat dog or cat in Australia, (my country) or any Western country. I know the aborigines up North eat cats, it is the first good thing to happen since feral cats took hold up there. The thing is we have a culture where dogs and cats are friends, not food. I have had companion rabbits for years now. It is interesting to me how abhorrent the idea of eating rabbit has become to me, despite the fact I both killed and ate rabbits when I was younger and on the farm. Indeed our farm cat who transitioned to the city and who used to massacres rabbits and all small creatures on the farm, also came to love and adore rabbits once she lived with one and the rabbit even broke her of bird killing. What's more I saw after that rabbit suddenly was killed by another neighbourhood cat, that she immediately adopted and loved the next one who came along and I doubt she'd ever have been able to think of any rabbit as food again. That's how universal it is. Not just humans but animals too can find a new paradigm in accepting other sentience as no longer food, but people like us. It is cultural. I myself have begun to pull away from eating meat due to gradually coming to recognise the same sentience and feelings, the most basic important stuff, in all living creatures. I'm off mammals now and birds are starting to seem too much like people to me these days. Also I've seen things in fish, just small aquarium fish I have kept, which have me wondering about them too. I'm not vegan .. yet ... but I get it. Culture is powerful and more like the current of the river. Not something you can really fight against without meeting eternal resistance and eventually being worn out. I make personal changes and leave the societal ones to sort themselves out as people evolve, or not.
oh the will get it, don't worry about that, but they stopped recording those parts i believe. last year there were videos on liveleak where the hung them in a public square after some thieves were caught
ArAcHnId777 Killing the dog thieves is def going too far! Imprison them, yes! Ruin their social standing in a community, sure! Make them pay restitution! Make it Illegal to abuse and kill dogs and cats!
Lenita A they do have that law so they can kill good people and say it's a crackdown on corruption Chinese government always attacks freedom fighters liu xiaobo was killed by the Chinese government because he was smart
I am. a Chinese but from. Singapore. I have a pet dog and I am disgusted by the footage on how dogs are treated and sold as a delicacy. The Chinese in China also enjoy rabbit meat and I own a rabbit too.
Hopefully this video will indeed help the fight against such practices, AND the horrendous cruelty...I have to admit I'm feeling melancholy and did tear up especially at the footage of the dogs being stolen and dragged over the fence! 😥 It also rings a special bell with me, because 10+ years ago when we stayed in South Korea, we saw dogs tightly crammed into cages (padlocked); and I just felt so very helpless that I couldn't break them out of there; KNOWING the fate that awaited them... Sometimes in life, sadly we can do nothing... * Sidenote, since I suppose the chances of my comments being seen often - You guys think some things like petrol & other costs THERE are high!? - You need to check out MY home state of QUEENSLAND, Australia; now I believe THE highest IN THE WORLD for registration, fuel etc - HIGHER than the BIG ones like London, Paris, NY 😬 PS; I used to have 2 Corvettes (sold only recently); a C4 similar to yours, and a 1980 one-off show car :-) Have a great day mate. Steve
One Australian gentleman just admitted he hunts and eats dogs regularly. It's ok if you are quick when you kill them. We should do something to stop it. It is legal to eat dog meat in these countries: 1. China (although it’s legal to consume dog meat, it’s against Food Safety Law to sell dog meat) 2. India (although illegal but consumed in eastern states) 3. South Korea 4. Vietnam 5. Philippines (third most consumed meat; although temporarily banned under the British pressure; the British government also bombed and killed Chinese in order to sell heroin when the Chinese people banned heroin) 6. Austria 7. Belgium (during food shortage) 8. France (during food shortage) 9. Germany (during every major crisis; prohibited since 1986) 10. Netherlands (during food shortage) 11. Poland (dog fat made into lard, which by tradition is believed to have medicinal properties) 12. Slovakia (Europe’s only dog eating festival) 13. Switzerland (dogs and cats are eaten) 14. Canada 15. USA (uncommon since the native Americans were wiped out; but in early 20th century, widely consumed because of meat shortage) 16. Australia 17. New Zealand 18. Arctic and Antarctic (British and Norwegian explorers ate sled dogs for food) 19. Cameroon 20. Congo 21. Ghana 22. Morocco (banned by Islamic law; but consumed in some regions) 23. Nigeria (encouraged by newspapers)
It's great that you tried to keep your points as objective as possible while discussing this topic, greatly appreciated. The addition of that metal gear solid alert sound on some of the pedestrians was a nice touch.
That is the "evil uncle" notification. Most of his street videos have some of these alerts now. You can check out past videos for explanations of "evil uncles".
Ooh- a heart from Winston! Well, back atcha sir. I watch all your vids and find them really interesting and helpful. I do business in China and visited a couple times this year. I watched tons of vids by you and C-Milk to learn about culture and what to expect. I'm really looking forward to watching Northern China! Keep up the awesome work!
I have seen enough before, and could not watch this vid. Thanks for making it though. God have mercy on every living creature in China :( This cannot stop soon enough.
although i dont eat dogs，the westerners who would campaign against eating dogs would have no problems with foie gras in their countries，double standard，as always
yeemynn Zhou dogs were bred specifically for hunting or companionship. Hundreds of Generations of dogs bred with the express purpose of serving humans. It’s fucked up because we bred them to be companions
How is it fucked up? What makes you think goat and pigs are bred just for consumption? In Hindu culture, cow is treated like a god and mother. But, in west it is just the opposite. So, leave your judgment at home when you look upon other culture.
But the animals in the west have been bread for consumption. Hence why cows are white with black spots and huge udders (and not brown with long fur), or why chickens are double the size they was 50 years ago, and why the pigs we eat aren't huge wild animals which could rip your face off at any moment, but fat pink things with lots of meat.
Citizen Smith Freedom For Tooting. Uh not the same thing. Its wrong to the West to eat dog, its wrong to Indians to eat cow/meat in general, etc. Who the hell is right then? Fact is, what one person believes is not the universal truth
Eating any animal is fine, as long as it is treated right, and killed as quickley as possible. It would piss me off to watch someone kill a dog as that is not common in America. But in some countries they would freak out if you killed a cow. I like eating beef, as long as it was not abused.
God this video reminds me... when i was 11 years old I STUPIDLY clicked on a video of a dog being skinned alive by two chinese men. I don't know when or where this was but, I've been scarred since.
Why is eating dogs any different from eating cows, pigs etc? Simple, dogs are purposefully tortured to death in China, cows, pigs, chickens etc are killed quickly and relatively painlessly, that's the difference. If you want to see the awesome side of China, the fascinating culture and scenery that isn't related to killing man's best friend, check out our awesome documentary: www.vimeo.com/ondemand/conqueringsouthernchina Discount code: STAYAWESOME
If they were not tortured to death would there be any issue at all? I think most people who are against eating dog are only against it because of the "mans best friend" mindset and use the torture as a foothold to stop it (which is perfectly fine no animal should ever be tortured). Just curious on your opinion if they were bred like cows/pigs/chickens would we all still have a problem with the consumption of dog?
"Man's best friend." emmmm, a very western centered statement. Imagine an Hindu walking around South Africa and saying how horrible are the South Africans, they eat cows! I can't stand it! Please do not apply your culture and ideology on another, it may only shows your illusional moral superiority. In Chinese idioms, dogs are portrayed overwhelmingly as a creature with negative connotations. Ex: 狼心狗肺(The heart of a wolf and the lung of a dog), meaning rapacious as a wolf and savage as a cur; 狐朋狗友(Make friends with dogs and foxes), meaning being friends with the wrong type of people; 鸡犬不宁(Fowls and dogs are not in peace), meaning something causing a big chaos. And the list goes on. If "dogs are purposefully tortured to death" while other animals are not, you argument should be dogs deserve to be "killed quickly and relatively painlessly" as well, and most of Chinese people will agree with you. Most of people on earth against animal cruelty.
Marcus Ogilvy I am not replying to you, mate
Woops! Removed it haha
Ever seen a video off a chicken factory?
Stealing and beating dogs to death is far worse than actually eating them. I can’t understand that kind of cruelty.
All for a dollar I guess. I mean a yuan
Ron S yeah thats fucked up. It happens alot in factory farms too though in america with some animals. But purposefully beating an animal just to beat an animal. I think id do something about it if i saw it right in front of me.
Ron S im not against other countries eating dogs and cats, yet someone who goes around stealing other peoples pets just to sell to butcher shops is really fucked up.
Ron S that's your opinion dogs getting beaten isn't as worse as eating them they can be healed stealing is plain wrong but as a dog person eating them is disgusting and emotionally sad I don't think you're a dog person otherwise you wouldn't actually believe that kind of topic
egyption wolf how do you heal a dog from being beaten to death?!
Legends tell he's still walking till this day...
China's a big country :)
Pedometer has exploded....
Fucked you eat pigs cow buffalo suddenly u care about dogs
Enough memes!!!
OMG I have watched so many of these. This cracked me up too much 😂😂😂
The thing that bothered me the most was that poor turtle
F in the Chat for the turtles and dog
not everyone torture them. the main reason they beat them is, killing a chicken is very easy, there're machines and tools for killing cows and pigs, but there's no machine that has been invented to kill dogs, and dogs are dangerous. and quite often,those who kill dogs are often those who steal them. and, a certain religion is questioning: do western people eat pigs? and, how bulls are treated in spain even though they have certain machines to kill them rapidly? and, do australian really eat cute kangaroos?
@@hardtropic4750whay the fuck are you on about?
*what
hard tropic shut up 50center
I'm Chinese, not a dog person and don't have any pets, but i will never eat dogs or cats.
Im not chinese but why did my dog disappear?! And why is my dinner weird?!
@@buffalominotaur9962 not funny, didnt laugh
@@praaise is that the donkey kong not funny didnt laugh meme?
@@buffalominotaur9962 yes
@@buffalominotaur9962 do you suck
The most disturbing part for me in the video wasn't seeing the dog carcass. It was watching those guys hop a wall and take some family's pets. Can't imagine coming home and seeing that footage knowing that my poor dogs were beaten, slaughtered and served to some villager for an appetite whim or to balance their chi. Lived in Taiwan for almost 20 years and fortunately saw 20 years worth of gradual improvement in attitudes towards animals -- dogs more so than cats. (Though that was improving, too.) This necessary cultural shift in China can't happen fast enough for me. BTW, took in a stray kitten in 2007 and brought it with me when I moved back to the US in 2014. After watching your video, I'm going to have to go give her a pet. That said, it's almost noon here and the lazy bum hasn't gotten up yet...
Yes, while I am no dog lover, I did find the scene of the dog being stolen hard to watch, especially the part where it was fighting from going over the wall. I would cut that part out; maybe show the thieves going in, nothing more needed.
can definately agree
So, as long as the dogs are not "pet dogs", I think people can still eat them anyway. You know, just like some people love to have pigs as their pet, but still others can enjoy bacon and sausage Because I do not see the difference between a dog and a pig.
As Winston said during the video, it's mostly just cultural. In the west(I'm Australian), dogs have a history of being a pet, or a working animal. They help herd sheep, or even help the vision impaired to live their lives. Probably for that reason, we, as westerners, probably can't associate dogs with food. The whole thought just makes me cringe, and I want to go n give my little one a great big hug right now. She really is a part of my family.
Black Powder did you actually watch the video?
I was stationed in the Philippines in the 70's. When you were eating there was one simple rule, never ask what kind of meat are you being served. If you weren't eating fish, pork or chicken you were eating dog. I used to go to a bar that had taco Thursday, order a beer and get free tacos. The last time I went with a buddy we had downed a few beers and eat a plate of tacos. The waitress asked if we wanted more tacos and my buddy asked what kind of meat was used and she answered in her native language. He didn't understand and she said you know arf arf. The tacos were good but that was the last time we went to taco Thursday.
That's a funny story. But then maybe not so funny after all.
Bruh i would not know what to do wtf 🤮
i've seen neighbor torching the dog. i think philippines dont allow that anymore
In Olangapo, I discovered that dog meat is tastier than monkey meat...
You should probably be ashamed of yourself
They did that in Vietnam too. Stole domestic dogs and sold to the market. So awful and horrible.🤮
Well to be honest it was kind of a survival thing like they were having a food shortage so you know you have to do what you have to survive
Oh boy the 3rd demonizers, we are poor doesn't mean kill innocent beings, we don't commit massacres, we don't burn others people house, we aren't serial killers, we do not enable people
The human race is just an evil disease..........................@#%
yeah, there it is cat meat that is more popular Ihave heard, they consider cat meat to be delicacy, sick and disgusting , I love my cat soo much, she is like my child, can never imagine someone cooking her for dinner
@@theshockerpit7274 if you're using that argument, China could be exempted as well. Dog eating has occurred in most cultures in East Asia, including Vietnam and Korea. The reason China is so known for it is because it got increasingly popular there during the famines in the 1970s and 1980s where there was a lack of food. Since then it has caught on with the Chinese who are already desensitized to that kind of stuff. This is why China has never been known for prominently eating dogs throughout its history, and even the Yulin dog eating festival came about in 2009. During this time, the other nations like Korea were becoming more and more western and eventually outlawed the eating of animals while China still allowed it.
Don't ever go to Yulin dog market. I couldn't handle it, I attacked a couple of traders there, I had to be escorted by the police away and nearly thrown in jail, I lost the plot. What is disgusting is the totally unnecessary suffering of the animals and how they slaughter them. Some boiled and skinned alive, from that moment on I decided I was going to leave China after considering living there with my now Chinese wife, that was in 2007. I heard that the dog meat market has expanded even more now. This experience had such a profound effect on me I also became a vegetarian from that day on and still am today. My Chinese relatives still find this very odd even today. I did leave China a year later and now live back in England.
They are sickos. Dogs dream when they sleep like you and I.
daniel miller - yes they do, one of mine is an avid dreamer & barks like mad apparently chasing things in he sleep with legs going and everything - it´s a marvel to watch and simply wonder what he´s dreaming about, whether it´s birds or cats he´s chasing :) :)
good on you buddy, the world can change one enlightened person at a time.
The enjoyment many of the traders and butchers seem to get from inflicting pain and suffering on the dogs is insane. The lack of empathy really goes towards indicating that there seems to be an entire segment of that population that are clinical psychopaths.
I don't have any problem with eating a dog, necessarily... but I think it's somewhat questionable to eat the meat of a predator animal, as it encourages raising animals for meat farming. This process requires animals to be confined to small and undesirable conditions, which is torturous for an intelligent carnivore. However, one thing I DO have a problem with is animal torture... I once saw a video of Chinese men torching a dog's face while holding the dog by the neck with a pair of tongs. It was fucking disgusting and kept me from sleeping well for a few days. It filled me with such disgust it is almost beyond comprehension. Those people should have their testicles brutally ripped from their bodies.
I shouldn't have watched this. The image of that man stealing a dog and pulling it so heartlessly over the fence is going to haunt me for a very very long time.
At least you know the truth
walk with the truth. its very sad. yes, but your money does the talking. donate to help the activists. and dont buy dog meat. and the torture will stop. same goes for other meats around the world if you feel for them.
Agreed. I stopped watching immediately after seeing the guy try to take the dogs. Fucking bullshit this was shown without warning.
He warned at the beginning... i was fully expecting the footage shown...
My heart dropped to me feet when I saw that; but, yes, now I/we know. >
I have totally heard that from Chinese people...that it's JUST a southern China thing. Thanks for speaking the truth.
go watch deep web, they will eat you too
Chinese people are poor, they cannot afford other meats like beef or mutton, I meaning sometimes they eating dog to get protein, you may think it's ridiculours, but that's the truth why some Chinese eat dog, by the way, vietnam and south korea people eat dog more often
but squirrels, rabbits, bears, deer, raccoons, possums, alligators, and iguanas are acceptable as a southern USA thing. Nbd
@@NeonKue
Dogs are useful and smart, you can teach them so many stuff.
Uhuh , and you believe that ofcourse.
Thank you for making this video. I am Chinese. I know that many people eat dog meat, but there are very few young people who eat dog meat. But there are still a certain number of people still eating. I can hardly accept this fact. Because the dog that accompanied me for three years when I was a child was taken away by a stranger, I cried for a long time😭😭. I hate people who eat dog meat. I will promote more to the domestic media, and only by putting pressure on them can this happen.
Like in other countries, when people earn more money and get more educated, older senseless traditions are dropped, which is sometimes good. There are always a few younger people who like these bad traditions, though. In my country, we are trying to outlaw bull fights.
Lol. You Chinese posses an inferior culture. Your nation wants to dominate the world but it’s the furthest from deserving this right. So many disgusting things in your overpopulated trash ridden country. Hopefully your peeps can turn it around.
You tell lie.china eat dog.
wdym? dog meat is banned in china rn, u get caught eating dog u get arrested or sent to concentration camp.
If a family considered a cow or a chicken their pet and a part of their family, people wouldn’t go and steal that cow or chicken from the family foR food. They also wouldn’t then proceed to torture the animal in the most inhumane manners possible before consumption. That’s the point.
Daddy Tachanka Yes, cows are killed fast and easy, and if you kill a dog (which I don’t support), you should do it quick, not inhumane.
Blastboys // Octave Exactly. It is literally, at that point, the least you could do.
@@octave1 If you watch undercover documentries, you will find out how back in the west how we also mistreat farm animals of all sorts, whether it be force feeding geese, to beating pigs and cows, keeping them in closed environments and since they can't even move, they get rashes and all sorts of horrible diseases and problems, like gangrene. It's a universal thing.
I had a pet chicken, fluffy, and I forget to get chicken breasts from the shop so I smashed his head in and slow cooked him at 180 degrees
@@SlapRoundTheChops with a picture like that, I don't blame you.
While I agree with you on all your points towards eating dog meat, Hindu’s see us the same as we see Chinese for eating beef.
A cow is sacred to Hindus, it is effectively their dog or cat.
My belief, if an animal is going to be culled for any reason, it should be done in a humane and stress free way as possible.
Loving the topics Winston, 10/10 for daring to touch on some controversy occasionally. 👍👍
His point is. Western culture consumes beef daily and other cultures think we are fucked up for doing so. Switch it around where they don't eat beef at all but consume another animal that we would never eat in a western world and we think they're the fucked up ones. Who's in the right?
Lol we hate dog eating nation and love beef eating nation. That's the irony.
Get out while you can mate!!
God bless those activists saving the dogs!
One of my friends who lived in a small rural village Guangzhou when she was younger had her pet dog stolen and her family got a box filled with the dog's bones afterwards. Most Chinese hate the idea of hurting dogs and eating dogs but in certain areas some people are just......urggggggg
Where those people beaten and arrested?
You need to track them down and give them the beating of thier life
@@Jonathan-tk4dd Yes it is because they aren't bred the same way. There is a reason dog is "man's best friend", it was bred for its empathy and bond with humans.
@@Jonathan-tk4dd I will never accept the torture of any poor animal!
dont try to say its just happening in certain places so u hide ur criminal country and criminal goverment and barberian people in ur country, dogs are beaten, burnt, cooked alive in china and this is savage , if a video of dogs being cooked alive would go viral in US millions and millions of people would protest becuz theyr not savage.dogs are suffering and u just care about the international face of china
@@Jonathan-tk4dd peasant.
Sitting watching this with my dogs. Can’t imagine. And I’m from the countryside in the US.
Thank you for making this video, as painful as it was for me (and you, too!) I have been teaching ‘in China’ (online from the USA) for almost 3 years now and I have grown to love the people and the beauty of the country, but there are still some things I just can’t understand, like the existence of this trade. I am encouraged to know of the growing activism against it, and I remember one of my young students once spoke of this subject in a shamed whisper. I hope these young ones can make a difference. Thank you for this, and all the videos you do that give outsiders an inside look at this incredible country! You rock! 😁👍🏻
Just because you don’t understand, it doesn’t mean you have to understand. There are so many things that you won’t understand from any culture. It is right to have an opinion, but it is not right to be an ignorant.
Heart breaking. 😞
People please understand he is stating the way they are killed that is wrong, not that it is wrong to eat dog. Beating, burning,boiling and torturing them while alive is what is wrong.
Finally, someone with common sense!
Dogs have been domesticated, evolved to rely on humans for food. This is why eating dog is wrong. They are loyal pets, guarded the cave for a bone, stayed when the food ran out and did not eat us despite being carnivorous. The Chinese also ate each other during 3 famines over the centuries. Mental illness from mass hysteria and mistrust of their govt is what I see when I watch coverage of life in China.
It is wrong to eat dog, but its also understandable if you are poor and starving to eat it. Humans can agree once an animal reaches a certain point of being sentient and awareness it is wrong to eat them
I spent a year in Korea and they eat dog also
😥
sad sushi Why is eating one animal permissible and eating another isn't? Your society eats cows but in others the cow is something respect and don't eat. Don't knock someone else's society simply because you do things differently in yours.
sad sushi You ever been to a hog or cow slaughterhouse? Chicken factory? Why is one more inhumane than the other? They all suffer pretty terrible and for their entire lives.
Subhajit Choudhury Again, what is the justification for eating one animal and not the other for you? Is it social conditioning or the manner in which it is killed or both? Is it okay to eat a dog so long as it is killed in the same manner as your favorite animal to eat?
Subhajit Choudhury Either you're looking for an argument or you're not comprehending my point. Either way, have a good day.
7:10 that's brutal, they're snatching Fido, a family member. People's pets that's crazy!!!!
They say that the way a country treats it's animals is a reflection of their social values toward injustice and basic empathy toward others.
Huh you got deer and buffalo hunting in America and Canada.
@@thetitansofcitycarter7207hunting is in every country, what i don't like as an American is factory farming and the welfare of livestock
@@youtubehandlesareridiculoushunting is banned in india even though it's a poor country. Where as American kill innocent animals for their enjoyment.
@@thetitansofcitycarter7207 you think hunting is less ethical than factory farming? if youre gonna eat an animal it should live happy and free. hunting is more humane and takes more responsibility than buying meat from a store that lived in suffering its entire life
Quite telling
ok I'm gonna go hug my dogs now bye
eat it
FrenchFriMashups hahahaha
FrenchFriMashups me too
ramon did you eat ur dog? or have you burned him yet?
I'm going to hug my pig.
i m Chinese but i will never eat dog
何泳瑜 don't listen to this guy I know not all Chinese people eat dogs
Its not the eating, it is the torture that is so upsetting
何泳瑜煞笔玩意儿，那是你没吃过，真香
我也不吃，但我觉得吃狗肉没有什么错
monsieur boeuf de tête fking
I'd eat a dog if I were hungry enough, but there is no reason to torture any animal.
I'm Chinese and I get racist comments at school about me being Chinese. They always start laughing about how I'll start putting cats and dogs in the oven! That's not true! Not all Chinese people eat dog some do but some don't. I don't eat them. Me and my family raised one when I was growing up! ^^
Anti Infidel Knight we are smarter than you think
Is that's why SNOOP DOGG never made a concert in China?
srsly? ujokingaboutdogcruelty?
Lol
He is a dawg not a dog
No, he is Dogg - read in his wikipedia
No, it's because marijuana is illegal in China.
Thank you for not including footage of dogs being beaten to death
I'm a dog lover and I couldn't watch straight for some part.
Thanks a lot for making this video. I cannot imagine how painful work it was.
Thanks for being so up front and honest.
The metal gear alerts for evil uncles always makes me laugh.... good on you for addressing this controversial topic.
Thanks I've been looking for that sound effect
😂😂 I love this special touch
chinese do eat dog, but not as tradition. about 5% like eating, 5% against strongly, rest 90% don't eat or care.
but you know 5% is large number in China.
Chen Wu 5% is like my country population
Fenistere Inc. yes, still big number.
but if yoi say chinese people eat dogs, that means everyone, so it cause unsatisfied.
exactly, i feel my white friends are stupid when they ask me if i eat dogs......so bs
But why these rest are not raising their voice against it .all dogs lover will help them . being quite is also wrong which it means that are also instigating this .
European kills Jews，we know Germany is a coutry of Europe，and 70millions people is large number in Europe
When I see videos of them “cooking” it seems that they are enjoying it. They laugh, they film and the don’t care about the screams. WHY?!
Hejas Closet because they believe the more pain the animal endures the more nutritious the meat will be. They happy because people will pay good money for it.
Lemon Lady I mean that they look happy when they are torturing! 💔
@@hejajamal lol talk about the pigs IDIOT. Pigs are ALSO PETS and they SCREAM aswell. Its always DOGS that are SHOULD BE PETS.
Real Versity plus pigs aren’t Mans best friend are they?
Real Versity who helps people emotionally? Who helps cope with a lost of a family member? Who Helps Find dead people to give them a proper bearal?
I have heard of this over the years, but it's still a shocker to SEE it. I was reading the comments and someone had mentioned that CATS are also "on the menu". Is this true? Are cats eaten as well?
*I see someone’s a fan of Metal Gear Solid.*
I would love to electrocute bullies in metal gear, and smell the smoke from the soft core.
And also his N7 jacket! Coming from a huge ME fan.
I love how you always spot the evil uncle's with that soundbite absolutely hilarious. Yes this was a tough subject but thanks for doing it.
I see in the comments that the "eating dog its like eating any other animal" is a very popular opinion and I disagree, here is why:
Dogs are not called "mans best friend" for no reason, they have pretty much being the reason of our incredible advance as a spices since the nomad life of our ancestor, they had helped us hunt, protect out farms and livestock (thousands of years ago pretty much every continent had his shepherd dog variant) dogs are a fundamental part of our history and have evolve to understand us and communicate with us, they understand our facial expressions and voice tonalities a dog is not just some animal, they have put their trust in us and we on them. To eat them (let aside torture them) is inhumane, is betray that inter- species relationship formed 30 thousand years ago its just horrible and cant be put in the same box as cattle, pig or any other animal
Dogs, cows, horses, pigs, sheep, chicken etc are examples of domesticated animals that have been selectively bred to have characteristics we want. The ancient Chinese rated the cow very highly and hence did not eat it very often because it was needed to plough the fields, rather like some use a horse or now a tractor. Pigs tended to mature very quickly and were considered a good food. In addition pigs are very good at digging for foods hidden in the ground, some peoples used pigs to find truffles. Dogs were employed as guards to warn of thieves.
If you want to make the moral case for putting dogs ahead of other animals don't harm any of them to be consistent. Really it is just an emotional thought to protect one animal species and not another. Nor can you ever be fully morally right as everything you do, use and occupy has harmed animals in some way - eg farming, infrastructure development, pollution (going into the land, air and water) and the list goes on.
You call it "man's best friend " in china they call it Lunch
@@neurozero Dog is not very commonly eaten. Pork is the most common meat for meals by far.
You'd have to be mental to breed dogs for meat seeing as though they take about 2 years to reach adult weight, under 60lbs. Pigs about 6 months to get over 260lbs. Profit is very important.
Chinese people have even been injured when shopping for pork and there was a shortage.
Kitti Kat corona was found out about in a lab and yes I agree with dogs helping us advance but we’re forgetting that if there was nothing to hunt it would be useless,if you don’t get what I’m trying to say,I’m trying to say that ,considering how much animals such as cows and pigs effect our daily life’s we should really care for them,examples;1:During ancient nomad times the way people lived was by making houses out of cow fur and to not die they would kill cow and eat it meaning if cow didn’t exist we probably wouldn’t even be alive.2:Cows and pigs are used in so many industries such as clothing,food,entertainment(eg.Zoo’s) and the reason you even have strong bones is most likely because of cows,3:They were here before dogs and it’s not fair that when humans came along we killed them however the part of the Chinese tradition I disagree with is when they torture the dogs,that is extremely cruel.
Hello! I live in the North of China, in Shenyang. I am a vegetarian and activist in the past...I help now send money to couple of animal refuges and activists. But I want to do more...without making local governments angry ( or being deported). Maybe you can give me some tips , or maybe you know some activists in the North and refuges. Thank you in advance and thanks for doing this video. People need to know it and see
Nodogsleftbehind is a good place to start
Nice
I wonder if there are any indian videos titeled "Do European people really EAT COWS?"
Why don’t you make one?
I don't have a suit yet :)
Damn..... that hurts. Lol
This is a stupid analogy. Chinese eat dogs because of their agrarian society (as noted in the video). In India, they choose to not eat cows due to religion.
Actually India is one of the largest beef exporters in the world after australia
I’m glad you covered this topic
Yes. Oh... You didn't want me to answer the question in the title, huh? Aaaaand now I'm definitely not going to China.
I would never go. Discusting they are.
@Sumio Ostuka THIS
Jasaba senara your spelling is disgusting
Thank you for making this video! VERY hard to see and hear but important for the world to understand what is happening.
It's not only in China. Even in my country, Indonesia, there are a lot of people eats dog meat. In some town, you have even have to put a collar to your dog, or else you can't blame people if you dog is killed and eaten by them.
exccept in china the dog collars comes with your meal
I thought muslims don't eat dog meat. But maybe only for some Indonesian Muslims.
Gun H all undeveloped countries eat dog ex: china,indo,etc
If you see "warung kaki lima" with sate Guk-guk" or Sate Jamu, that's dog meat.
Jono Bond,
How nice of you to demonize Chinese.
I've purposely stayed away from this particular post. Glad I finally watched it. You handled it very well. As well as can be expected with the subject matter. Stay Awesome!
Thanks mate, it was a tough one
I don’t understand why people disliked this video. Man is only telling the truth...
1.6K dislikes who eat dogs but hate you for being exposed.
serpentza - I appreciate all your videos. Thank you for doing such a great job on covering China and Chinese culture. That said, I think "staying on the fence" as you mentioned in this video is counter productive to making the world a better place for both animals and humans. Although eating Dog meat in China is a cultural or traditional practice for some, the cruelty involved, as you mentioned (beating a dog to death, boiling a dog to death, torturing a dog before you kill it, stealing pets for consumption) is an act that can't be tolerated anywhere on the earth regardless of cultural conflicts. Cruelty in any form cannot exist if the human race is to move forward in the next step towards the betterment of our species. I know you do not like to get political in your videos, but I implore you to always condemn cruelty in your videos and not sit on the fence when organizations like No Dogs Left Behind ask for your help. The more we stand up against cruelty in the world, the more likely it will be less tolerated by all.
Amen. Fuck these stupid traditional beliefs. What if we had a traditional belief that beating a Chinese guy to death was part of our culture to celebrate our strength. I don't think that would be allowed.
It's just not acceptable under any circumstances.
Nah, he cant do shit bout it can he. Better to stay neutral
bruh if I caught you trying to steal my dog it would be your last day on this earth lol.
guess u dont know what family means
Morgan Brown same if they tried to steal my dog or cat I'd shoot them to death
Morgan Brown same!
This is why i would never want to live in a country were i am not allowed to own a gun. Criminals like this don't need prison they wont learn anything. They should simply be put down.
train them to attack niggas who try to run up
Every year I cry my way through the tweet storms about Yulin unable to understand any of what’s going on~
Thank-you for painting a clearer picture for me.
✨🍃🌸🐶🙏🏻🐱🌸🍃✨
Say it with me: *"Some cultures are BETTER than others"*
I lived in China for around two years in Beijing but traveled all around the country, from South to Inner Mongolia, Tibet, etc. and I never saw dog meat being served or was offered any except one restaurant in Beijing so it's definitely not common and I do think it's more of an older generation thing, much like in South Korea where I also lived for many years. Hopefully the younger generation will put an end to it or at least push it farther into obscurity. Thanks so much for your videos man, they let me feel like I'm back there again certainly miss it.
Jesse Day i am Chinese.every friend I know never eat dog meat. and the North of China eat dogs because Korean Chinese people, South is yulin people some traditional things.
Without specifically looking for it, I saw dog meat in northeast China a couple of times and also in Beijing in the 1990's. If you looked for it, I'm sure you'd find more.
Winston Posegate Dude, Ting dynasty is dead.
Ikr, I've never eaten dog meat and neither have my family and I'm surprised everytime I visit america, people assume it's a mainstream meat that we use for our daily lunch. Italians eat horse meat but I don't assume most of them eat it. (sigh)
Well, people assume all Chinese eat dogs, just like everyone should assume all African practice cannibalism, all americans are fatty.
I really appreciate how your views are always neutral. I can feel the sense of professional journalism from your videos.
do you even understand English? how does that answer indict anything about he disliking it? enlighten me (sarcasm, in case you fail to see what I mean) . you can find stupid people making stupid statements online right about anything and anyone, so my question is why the heck you lash out of it on Chinese nationalists huh? have you read any outrageously ridiculous claims made by them? do you do the same to Koreans or Japanese or anyone for that matter?
judging by your family name, Chew, sounds like you are an insecure south east Asian with Chinese heritage with self hating complex? because that's VERY COMMON in south east Asian Chinese (by the way Chinese heritage merely means only somehow your ancestry came from southern China, and China is huge, which barely means anything or have anything to do with bloodline, in most cases your genetic makeup is probably much closer to Vietnamese than to us)
Jacky Chew lol bring something new eh , 30 years same old same , free tibet lol , so desperate , its actually cute
LMAO
You say Hong Kong = China = dog eating, but it’s illegal to eat dogs in Hong Kong 😂😂failed racism
Well welcome to our isolated mainland world lol
youtube actually recommend this to me in my feed just now and my eyes darted back and forth between you and the dog in the thumbnail and I thought "they have the same haircut!" 😆👍
eating any type of animal really isnt the problem, or shoudln't be. cruelty is the problem.
Rory McClernon so you eat dogs and cats too? That is just sick.
@@rajory6057 so you eat beef and turkey too? That is just sick.
Jory Jory meat is meat. If you eat beef or pork is no different from eating other types of meat.
Matthew Sato so you mean eating human meat is fine?
Jory Jory YES YES YES, THAT IS EXACTLY MY POINT, THANK YOU FOR EXPLAINING IT FOR ME.
I subscribed because you’re showing people the real China not like other people just blaming the whole country for eating dog meat. Yeah the new generation is changing people’s mind and trying so hard to save those poor dogs I really hope our government could care more about animals not just pandas or tigers. Again thank you so much for telling the truth, I love dogs more than I love humans lol I’m such a dog person.
I would starve to death rather than killing and eating my dog because i know she would never try to eat me and rather starve to death with me...
Sadly you can't say same for majority of people, if you are starving to death with some people better watch your back. People are killing each other in waayy better conditions..
I thought that all Chinese eat dogs. sry for that . you know what is the main cause of their sorrow that you all people are not raising your voice. Actually you really don 't care about that. If you really care about that you have to persuade your gvt. to end all this. Tolerating something wrong is also wrong.
Ggoddkkiller same here, I will never do anything harmful to my dog, but I can’t say about other people, some of my friends from other countries told me they loved their dogs but if possible, they would try dog meat for once before they die.
Maybe that's what comes with modernization and having disposable income to acquire a pet? Dogs are easy to get attached to but that being said so is a little piglet! My friend has one and I've got to say that little s.o.b. is a charmer.
Do Chinese eat pekingese dogs?
I remember being pointed out dog food restaurants in Harbin northern China when I went there with my then Chinese girlfriend about 17 years ago. I also remember seeing a few pet dogs around, a small long haired toy breed, don't know the name. What was funny was that they don't cut the talls or clip the hair, so you see these small dogs with enormous long hairy tails dragging along the ground. Very cute. I could see the owners, who would take them out for a quick pee and run around, were very fond of thier pets.
I saw one of these disturbing aftermath of a dog being chained and nailed (I think) to a post on yt shorts,
Reported it and now hopefully it will get taken down, I just don't understand why someone would do the deed and then post a video of the aftermath to yt shorts? Like when people don't know what's coming? Sick, utterly sick
Winston - You state later in this video that "the majority of Chinese people don't eat dogs". It would have been nice to start the video with this comment vs "Yes, Chinese people eat dogs". Frames the situation more accurately.
Totally agree. Just saying that for the person casually viewing this video without knowing too much about Winston's travel or the reality of the infrequency of dog meat eating, the first few minutes of this video paints a different picture that much later on is addressed. By then, the first impression has already been made. I do like Winston's videos and think he portrays his honest view on China.
Aj C totally agree. For example, there are some American people are super racist, but u can’t say American people are racist. Especially in the videos where people may not watch the whole video but just a few seconds for a glance.
Tianci - my point exactly. Humans are already wired to think fast - with biases - in many situations (re: Daniel Kahneman's works), and quick first impressions may leave overpowering impressions.
Translate This - I believe this topic is especially incendiary and strongly stokes emotions for many people. I would say that the majority of people don't eat dog and especially do not approve of the extreme cruelty that other videos show (thankfully not this one - the dognapping aside). One needs to sit through this entire video in order to see how the village majority does bring some justice against these loathsome gangs. By then, however, some viewers may have already been had their racist views confirmed or been insulted. Careful of that human search engine...
That one scene when Winston doesn’t wear a suit...
Im Blasian (Chinese & Black) and all i hear from my friends is “Dont you eat dogs”… knowing that I don’t..
My puppy and I agree that Justice would be a headshot.
The evil uncle power up sound had me chuckling the 1st time. My sides were left aching the second time. Winston.......if you see this please make this a permanent feature.
I plan on it ;)
Wasn't the evil uncle sound the "you've been seen" alarm out of the old metal gear solid games?
Master Chief Oh God, drama queen.
Yes, metal gear solid alert.
This is pretty horrible. It's far worse than I expected. I didn't know about the torture-part. Jesus...
How do you know he didn't make it up?
@@marujitadiaz9019 because he showed videos and if you do any kind of research, you can see for yourself.
I have seen multiple videos of people skinning a dog while it is alive and screaming. This is the most horrific trade in the world right now and needs to be stopped. Also it is not also the torture part that is horrific it is the fact they eat a dog. A dog is a dog and you shouldn't eat them. It is in their dna to be companions not food.
+ Jonathan Carswell
Yea, right?! This (+Marujita Díaz's) was the most ignorant, lazy, and numb-skull defaming question I've ever heard!!!
Ya know, a stray dog would probs bite you to death too were it hungry enough.
I think a man capturing a dog by a neck and dragging it over the wall deserves some kind of disclaimer and/or censoring. The topic is very important to cover and know about what’s happening; however, you just said we’d see dog meat. No indication of a poor dog struggling and panicking to get away from thieves that then proceed to drag it over a high wall by the neck.
I'm glad to hear that changes are happening in China with the new generation. Thanks for your sensitivity and the disclaimer at the start.
nothing is changing. there are still no animal cruelty laws and the younger generation thinks it is cool to eat everything and fast
Singapore Chinese here. Thanks for tackling this topic. Love the way you presented it. I'm neutral like you on dog meat. Its a cultural thing. I don't eat it but I'm okay with others doing so if they like to. That said, kidnapping and killing others' pets is out of the question. Those thugs need to go to jail.
Once again, great video. Stay awesome!
2 important points that you have highlighted
1. Dog-eating is more prevalent among people of lower social classes and does not represent the entire population.
2. No legal framework to deter animal abuse.
1. You'll find that the majority of the Chinese people are lower class, so that's kind of representative of a large portion of the population.
2. No legal framework to deter human abuse either.
+Live
I'm gonna be straight forward.
1. You're wrong. The majority of lower class don't eat dogs nor any other kind of pets. Just go walk on the street and visit some restaurants and you'll get the answer- the majority of catering business don't offer dog meat.
2. You're wrong again.
"2. You're wrong again."
No you!
if you're looking at gdp per capita then yes
if you're looking at CPI then no.
physika fuck the important points you scumbag , it's wrong and all dog eaters should be killed. When we were younger we would ask Asians that moved to our country if they ate dog meat and those that were stupid enough to say yes we beat to within an inch of their lives, sport beatings and when reports came in on the news about dogs disappearing in certain neighborhoods we would go there find out who had recently moved in from China or Vietnam. We would pay them a visit and once they admitted to it we would again beat them and cut off a hand. When word got out that we were looking for them the dogs stopped disappearing from these neighborhoods. Many Chinese and Vietnamese don't eat dogs and told me that when those that did arrived in the US or Canada all they saw was free meals walking down the street.
I used to have a dog as a pet. He passed away nine years ago.
Atsushi Takayasu aww, so sorry to hear that..
I disliked not because I don't like you, Winston, but because I am a dog lover and I'm showing solidarity with your other fans who hate this practice in China and in other countries doing the same. Thanks for educating everyone.
What upsets me is the inhuman cruel evil methods they use to kill. Skinning and boiling a puppy ALIVE (which is equivalent to skinning and boiling a human toddler) is insane, merciless, barbaric and monstrous. Can you imagine if there was eye for eye justice and humans who did this were beaten, had the flesh on their bodies skinned off while alive and then burned, poked and boiled alive. I'm horrified and haunted by the photo's of puppies in these torturous scenarios on the internet with soul crushing pain in their eyes.
she's talking about cruelty you fucking moron, you don't have to torture an animal to eat it. talk about a strawman bullshit response. what a dropkick
@@Fanta.... Westerners boil star fish and crabs alive. Why don't you treat them more humanely?
andrea chen they are cooked that way because a starfish that has been dead over 24hrs is too tough to eat although i have never seen it on a menu and crabs the meat in them decomposes really fast once they are dead that is why most are cooked alive although alot of people put a knife through their head before cooking and comparing that to beating a dog to death is just plain and simply stupid
They are barbaric.. Why on earth y to uld u torture the thing ur about to eat and put inside ur body... In the middle east and India they kill the animal in a happy prestige state so that the meat doesn't spoil upon death... If you torture the animal before death its meat will taste bad
don't they do sort of the same thing to lobsters or something?
Although it may be a disturbing topic to talk about, it is a must to change peoples perspectives on such behavior. People These days a pitiful and gutless, and in my opinion, need to be shown more of the disturbing things in life to really get them to show appreciation towards anything in this life. They don't care because they aren't made abundantly aware of the situation. People get away with this sort of behavior because the general census of the public is they don't care. They don't care because they aren't informed, so thank you for talking about this subject and bringing it to the light.
I lived in southern China in early 60s. Beef was $10/lb. My family bought like 4 oz to cook as flavor. One could buy life dog for $1/lb. So it was much cheaper to eat dog than beef for the nutrient. A 15 lbs puppy would feed our family for days.
People living in the farm never had chance to eat beef because they were not available. They often raised dogs for food.
The dog meat restaurant is Korean dog meat restaurant……. Say the full name of it plz.
Good video Winston! But at 1:33, it says “高丽狗肉店” which高丽stands for the old korean empire or the korean people. So you probably were at Jilin or Liaoning province when you film this because a lot of the korean Chinese ethnical group(朝鲜族）lives, and Korea has a dog eating culture too.
The restaurant is in China for Chinese people to eat, that’s like a sushi restaurant in Miami, sure it’s Japanese food but there aren’t going to be Japanese people in miami
korean nation is chinese as nationality
Stop nitpicking. In the same video you have dogmeat served in "Chinese China" areas like Shenzhen
please sign this petition if you want to protect more dogs from being eaten. Please make this visible to everybody! www.change.org/p/boycott-pyeongchang-2018-winter-olympics-in-south-korea-a-dog-eating-nation?j=203701&sfmc_sub=318096696&l=127_HTML&u=37604413&mid=7233053&jb=7979&utm
The Korean are indeed culturally more famous in eating dog meat. The history of the west protesting the east about eating dog actually started against the Koreans, when they were about to host the Seoul Olympics in 1980s. As you duly pointed out in the video, the Chinese are traditionally agrarian people that didn't have a special historical tie with the dogs as the more or less pastoral European people in the past. However, the northern Chinese, historically influenced by the northern nomadic minority, did feel more strongly to the dogs than the southerners do. The Koreans are however not sharing this feeling. So it is fair to say that in the north, the dog-eating practice is more a Korean influence.
Personally, as a proper southern Chinese, I do not share your feeling with the dogs. I would not refuse a dog hot pot if offered although I had it only once in my life. I am indeed against the torturing and illegal capture of any animals, not just dogs.
Eating dogs doesn't really bother me. The fact that most asian countries tend to treat animals like shit does bother me though.
Thanks for your honest comment and sharing your unbiased point of view.
I remember there is one video of yours whereby a chinese lady scolding and shouting saying that 'Chinese don't eat dogs!'. If you able to provide me the link to that video,I would like to bash her up properly for saying that.
Well done for covering the tough subject, I to am a dog lover and I was sitting on the fence at the start of the video with the argument what is the difference between eating a chicken, a pig or a dog, all can be pets for people, but the fact that people are stealing peoples pets and then battering them to death because they think the meat tastes better, well shocking quite frankly. If you hadn't covered this topic I never would have realised that.....what an eye opener. Keep opening all our eyes, fantastic channel and advchina is fantastic as well.
Edward Snowden I think hit a dog to death because they dont want cut the head want a whole dog. not because it tastes better. In chinese markt or restaurant you see a lot of dead animal as a whole body. even a crocodile
Alexander Neumann They also do something else much more barbaric. I don't want to upset people . I'll leave it.
shut up
A chicken or a pig are totally different than a Dog.. That's like saying were the same as a chicken or a pig..I know Dogs are under us..But a chicken and a pig are way under a dog😐
Does anyone not understand different animals have different pain networks and clearly perceive reality differently? Eating a lobster for example is not like eating a human or dog.
That was painful; thank you for being honest and sharing the truth though.
🇧🇷 Não falo inglês, mas as imagens me fazem entender...
Acabei de assistir seu último vídeo, chocante!!! 😵😓
Seus videos 📽, são necessários, a verdade sempre vai aparecer, mesmo que seja por minoria 👍🏻🇧🇷
Why do people eat dogs? They’re basically eating something that’s supposed to be in your hands to take care of not to fry and make dog Chick-fil-A.
I’m a Chinese and I’m surprised that you know more China than me, because I thought people don’t eat dogs anymore. You are telling the truth and I support that, Chinese eat dogs and cats is already became a stereotype, and this is terrible that government didn’t make any laws about this. I’ve talked about it with my friends they said because there’re still a lot of poor Chinese people can’t feed themselves so they don’t give a damn about other animals. China have a lot of good people they love animals they love travel they love people but also there’re a lot of shitty people. I like your video and keep doing it, tell more people about the true China(good or bad). I hope you have a good life in China! And don’t let those shitty twat bother you💪🏼💪🏼💪🏼.(I hope you can read my comment)
Thanks mate! You are the hope for a brighter future!
you are slanding I can t believe you are a chinese
peter song well, firstly I did not slander Chinese, I’m just clarifying the truth, did the government ever consider the dogs and cats? No they did not, they just keep letting it happen, u can’t deny it. And yes I’m a Chinese a Chinese that facing his own country’s problems.
I don't actually think it is against the law to eat dog or cat in Australia, (my country) or any Western country. I know the aborigines up North eat cats, it is the first good thing to happen since feral cats took hold up there. The thing is we have a culture where dogs and cats are friends, not food. I have had companion rabbits for years now. It is interesting to me how abhorrent the idea of eating rabbit has become to me, despite the fact I both killed and ate rabbits when I was younger and on the farm. Indeed our farm cat who transitioned to the city and who used to massacres rabbits and all small creatures on the farm, also came to love and adore rabbits once she lived with one and the rabbit even broke her of bird killing. What's more I saw after that rabbit suddenly was killed by another neighbourhood cat, that she immediately adopted and loved the next one who came along and I doubt she'd ever have been able to think of any rabbit as food again. That's how universal it is. Not just humans but animals too can find a new paradigm in accepting other sentience as no longer food, but people like us. It is cultural. I myself have begun to pull away from eating meat due to gradually coming to recognise the same sentience and feelings, the most basic important stuff, in all living creatures. I'm off mammals now and birds are starting to seem too much like people to me these days. Also I've seen things in fish, just small aquarium fish I have kept, which have me wondering about them too. I'm not vegan .. yet ... but I get it. Culture is powerful and more like the current of the river. Not something you can really fight against without meeting eternal resistance and eventually being worn out. I make personal changes and leave the societal ones to sort themselves out as people evolve, or not.
Poverty is more crucial than eating dogs. I care poor people more than dogs.
I love the public humiliation against those people who stole dogs!
That will hurt them more then beating!
I think they deserve a good beating too.
oh the will get it, don't worry about that, but they stopped recording those parts i believe. last year there were videos on liveleak where the hung them in a public square after some thieves were caught
really? link me please i want to watch
ArAcHnId777 Killing the dog thieves is def going too far! Imprison them, yes! Ruin their social standing in a community, sure! Make them pay restitution!
Make it Illegal to abuse and kill dogs and cats!
Lenita A they do have that law so they can kill good people and say it's a crackdown on corruption Chinese government always attacks freedom fighters liu xiaobo was killed by the Chinese government because he was smart
I don't see why is it such a big problem that they eat dog meat? Why is eating dog meat any worse than eating a Pig or cow or chicken or fish?
I am. a Chinese but from. Singapore. I have a pet dog and I am disgusted by the footage on how dogs are treated and sold as a delicacy. The Chinese in China also enjoy rabbit meat and I own a rabbit too.
Hopefully this video will indeed help the fight against such practices, AND the horrendous cruelty...I have to admit I'm feeling melancholy and did tear up especially at the footage of the dogs being stolen and dragged over the fence! 😥
It also rings a special bell with me, because 10+ years ago when we stayed in South Korea, we saw dogs tightly crammed into cages (padlocked); and I just felt so very helpless that I couldn't break them out of there; KNOWING the fate that awaited them...
Sometimes in life, sadly we can do nothing...
* Sidenote, since I suppose the chances of my comments being seen often - You guys think some things like petrol & other costs THERE are high!? - You need to check out MY home state of QUEENSLAND, Australia; now I believe THE highest IN THE WORLD for registration, fuel etc - HIGHER than the BIG ones like London, Paris, NY 😬
PS; I used to have 2 Corvettes (sold only recently); a C4 similar to yours, and a 1980 one-off show car :-)
Have a great day mate.
Steve
One Australian gentleman just admitted he hunts and eats dogs regularly. It's ok if you are quick when you kill them. We should do something to stop it.
It is legal to eat dog meat in these countries:
1. China (although it’s legal to consume dog meat, it’s against Food Safety Law to sell dog meat)
2. India (although illegal but consumed in eastern states)
3. South Korea
4. Vietnam
5. Philippines (third most consumed meat; although temporarily banned under the British pressure; the British government also bombed and killed Chinese in order to sell heroin when the Chinese people banned heroin)
6. Austria
7. Belgium (during food shortage)
8. France (during food shortage)
9. Germany (during every major crisis; prohibited since 1986)
10. Netherlands (during food shortage)
11. Poland (dog fat made into lard, which by tradition is believed to have medicinal properties)
12. Slovakia (Europe’s only dog eating festival)
13. Switzerland (dogs and cats are eaten)
14. Canada
15. USA (uncommon since the native Americans were wiped out; but in early 20th century, widely consumed because of meat shortage)
16. Australia
17. New Zealand
18. Arctic and Antarctic (British and Norwegian explorers ate sled dogs for food)
19. Cameroon
20. Congo
21. Ghana
22. Morocco (banned by Islamic law; but consumed in some regions)
23. Nigeria (encouraged by newspapers)
It's great that you tried to keep your points as objective as possible while discussing this topic, greatly appreciated. The addition of that metal gear solid alert sound on some of the pedestrians was a nice touch.
That is the "evil uncle" notification. Most of his street videos have some of these alerts now. You can check out past videos for explanations of "evil uncles".
Ooh- a heart from Winston! Well, back atcha sir. I watch all your vids and find them really interesting and helpful. I do business in China and visited a couple times this year. I watched tons of vids by you and C-Milk to learn about culture and what to expect. I'm really looking forward to watching Northern China! Keep up the awesome work!
I have seen enough before, and could not watch this vid. Thanks for making it though. God have mercy on every living creature in China :( This cannot stop soon enough.
So they wake up one morning and they're like "I want a doggy burger"
It takes courage to speak about this, big fan, keep it up
Hey I’m in Beijing and you’ve taught me a lot before I took my trip here! I would totally love to meet you!
"I love my dog"
Has his dog bond outside with a short chain.😡
... thank you,...you 're awesome...keep us posted.. don't care what people says...you n your buddy is still the best...
although i dont eat dogs，the westerners who would campaign against eating dogs would have no problems with foie gras in their countries，double standard，as always
yeemynn Zhou dogs were bred specifically for hunting or companionship. Hundreds of Generations of dogs bred with the express purpose of serving humans. It’s fucked up because we bred them to be companions
How is it fucked up? What makes you think goat and pigs are bred just for consumption? In Hindu culture, cow is treated like a god and mother. But, in west it is just the opposite. So, leave your judgment at home when you look upon other culture.
But the animals in the west have been bread for consumption. Hence why cows are white with black spots and huge udders (and not brown with long fur), or why chickens are double the size they was 50 years ago, and why the pigs we eat aren't huge wild animals which could rip your face off at any moment, but fat pink things with lots of meat.
Citizen Smith Freedom For Tooting. Uh not the same thing. Its wrong to the West to eat dog, its wrong to Indians to eat cow/meat in general, etc. Who the hell is right then? Fact is, what one person believes is not the universal truth
I didn't know foie gras was a thing. I didn't know that torturing dogs to death for food was a thing either.
Eating any animal is fine, as long as it is treated right, and killed as quickley as possible. It would piss me off to watch someone kill a dog as that is not common in America. But in some countries they would freak out if you killed a cow. I like eating beef, as long as it was not abused.
Enjoying the evolution and content of your channel, keep up the great work!
God this video reminds me... when i was 11 years old I STUPIDLY clicked on a video of a dog being skinned alive by two chinese men. I don't know when or where this was but, I've been scarred since.