Reacting To Your Anime Hot Takes
Vložit
- čas přidán 7. 06. 2024
- New idea, also, I'm back lol...
Follow my Instagram - / kannas_ricebowl
Follow my Twitter - / kannas_ricebowl
Check out my animation channel - / @tryingsakuga7339
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research.
#jujutsukaisen #attackontitan #ufotable #sakuga - Krátké a kreslené filmy
"When a Content creator runs out of ideas, He gets his Audience to come up with Ideas"
Its been 3 seconds into the vid and bro is already spitting facts
hit take: Vincent Chansard is currently the best animator in the industry. He is one of the only people I see consistently pump out high quality cuts on a regular basis, both in terms of action and non action
That's a stretch
It depends on personal preference though. But from a technical and visual point of view, Vincent is truly one of the greatest talent that animation industry has ever witnessed.
@@imnotdream4602I don't think that's a stretch tho Vincent has been dishing out incredibly long and smooth cuts, and every single work is so consistent and polished his cut on ep 175 where luffy throws lighting and kaido's destroyer of death was one of the most insane cuts ever and he still regularly appears on one piece
@@JustAsh001 i'm not saying it's a stretch, that's the guy above my comment😅. Vincent literally animated an entire fcking city block in ep17 of JJK ss2 and plenty of other incredible sequences anytime he appears. Calling him the current best animator is not even an exaggeration to me. But there are countless number of amazing animators out there, so considering Vincent as the best one is still a subjective take tho
Ion think that’s a hot take tho, just sorta an opinion some people also share
As much as I loathe the use of A.I. in any creative sphere, I do think it could rly help with stuff like automated CG shading, motion tracking, lighting and particle simulations for CG environments, etc.
To some degree, kinda. But you can't just rely on AI for stuff. Bc at the end of the day, AI is really just a couple lines of code, it can't really understand those things fully, and were not even considering artistic expression. At that point AI might end up ruining a scene instead of helping it work, bc it can't understand artistic creativity.
I see what you mean but even things such as motion tracking and particle sims still require artistry in my opinion.
@@malvernwijaya439 thats why it should be used as a tool to help lessen the workload on animators for stills/dialogue scenes while also opening up that time for animators to make cool shit.
@@ChilledBacon I can see that, but as soon some of the dialogue scenes contain character acting, dynamic storyboards, complex perspectives, more fluid movement, color theory or more AI is completely out of the picture. These are all things that are made out of artistic expression and to help make the scenes more interesting to look at. For example: Goshozono using fisheye shots and dynamic storyboards in S2 of JJK, or chainsaw man's absurd amount of character acting. Projects like those makes AI completely useless in that area bc it might end up ruining a scene instead of helping it. The only way I could see AI helping is in mouth open mouth close dialogue scenes or generic still frames. But that would probably be more fit for the more generic low quality anime.
@@malvernwijaya439 more complex character acting yes, but a majority of anime contains stacic images with manipulation/repeating frames for mouth movement. which could easily be created and fixed utalizing ai. there are tons of use cases for ai but it should (and hopefully) never be used as a crutch or replacement for animators. it should give animators more time to make the cool shit
i knew it bro was from India, its impressive how much he know about animation
No its not, atleast in your logic.
@@KNM_Piash bros just trying to start something
@@Pextun fr
@@Pextunyou cooked him 💀
Hot take : Akihiro Ota's sequences are UNREAL and Vincent's draw the best IMPACT FRAMES in the industry as of right now
Ota and Vincent are both easily the best animators in the industry rn
Here’s one of my hot takes.. i really think you should make more videos just talking about anything anime related more frequently because i enjoy your content Probably Pretentious.
video idea: Compare japanese animation to western animation
That’s interesting but you would need to specify what time period, if you are talking about older Disney films they blow nearly every animated film completely out of the water but in modern day the west just cant get the people who are skilled enough to make something that looks visually appealing 99% of the time
hope the next one is longer. this was way too short
Hot Take: Mecha anime is the best genre of storytelling in the anime medium.
The thing about AI in art is that there's an actual right and ethical way to use it
i.e you develop your own model ( or atleast use one that's untrained in general ), feed your own work into it and then generate references that you can use for your own art. The animators for spider-verse actually did something like this, and even some indie-game devs do it.
The problem is that no company ( anime studio or otherwise ) or " tech-bro " wants to actually do this because it's far more cost effective to do what some companies are currently doing
i.e replace staff entirely with AI generated content or just generate images trained on pre-existing artwork and say it's your own
THANK YOU!!!! This is exactly what I've wanted to point out for ages.
Actual AI is really just taking the artistic process to the software you use really. After all, engineering itself, especially with software, is often more art than science.
People who are interested in both art and software development can make it a new feature of something, but there aren't that many of them who use AI.
I think when discussing AI in the animation industry, it's important to distinguish between generative AI and AI in general. Like you said, Spiderverse has used AI for the stylization of their work (namely the linework you see on the characters' faces, like wrinkles and dimples) to reduce workload by training their model to accurately place those lines where they belong.
However, there's no use of generative AI in the production and that's the important part. Generative AI hurts artists and is complete garbage. There's nothing good that can come out of it.
I loved your AI take. I started to get myself into animation last year and this Ai thing really demotivates me. I hope they never use it in real proyects
great video!! i'd love to se more in this style
Couldn't agree more with this guy. As an art student I think there is no problem with artists using Ai as a tool for inspiration or to explore their ideas but I think no artists would want to implement AI in their work. As someone who finds art as therapeutic and a way of escapism I would not let Ai take that from me but I think anime companies would love to use it since they would have to invest less which will lead to the destruction of the artistic beauty of ANIME. I like anime cuz when I see a beautiful scene I can imagine the passion and hard work of the team of artists, va's and producers behind it. It gives me GOOSEBUMPS but if AI enters the scene it would not be the same anymore
But you see I have heard that Japanese people are very stubborn to integrate modern tech in work mainly in anime industry idk why though and it will take quite some time like 5h6 years to integrate ai for anime work as it will impact many jobs freelance as well as old workers also. I think you understood what I wanted to say. Have a nice day/night
@@only-anime8241 They seem to be on board with AI and NFTs, literally the worst parts of technological advancement. They just don't like useful technology.
@@thomasffrench3639 I see thanks for updating me
@@only-anime8241 I was being tongue-in-cheek and not serious. Some technological advancement they accept, but some they don’t accept
@@thomasffrench3639 oh
Would really appreciate it if you do a video essay ranking best looking anime of Kyo ani and Trigger like you did for Mappa and Ufotable.
personally i think since ai is inevitable it should be used more as a tool as opposed to a replacement. with time and proper feeding of image models that are ethically sourced (like actually paying people to create the models for the ai to reference), it can probably help with in betweens, coloring and shading. it would not/should not be used as a "insert idea get idea done" kinda thing, but more of a "this can help speedup the production a bit and cutting down costs that *S H O U L D* help pay the animators more (unfortunately the greed of higher ups will prevent this obv).
obviously still have a cleanup crew to go through the frames to make sure they are proper and whatnot.
make the best use of something that is an inevitability.
OBVIOUSLY super complex animation work/cool perspective shit will be done purely by humans since ai cant replicate the creativity we have. im just hoping it ends up being used for dialogue scenes or simple frames since they still take time to make.
The man is back. ❤
Writer put there soul and sweet into anime ain't no way a Ai can replace them
Can't believe you are from India your English is so good atleast someone is trying something different in India apart from anitubers
India just has cringe wanna be different, glory hunters, elitist anitubers
How about video about chinese anime. I personally have some favourites like Link click, scissor seven, fog hill of five of elements and blade of guardians.
2:26 Oi that's my neighbour(I live in Bangladesh)
Same🙂
Same bro
That guy with the hot take on yutapon needs to see some sequence by Hiroto Nagata.
That man single-handedly blind me with his sequence lmao.
LOVED the video
You should talk about the Sakamoto Days and Fairy Tail 100 years quest trailer
2:47 I can't stand it when people say shit like this (the Hot Take I mean, not the reaction to it). Reducing works of art (be they an anime or manga or whatever else) to its most surface level traits is easily the weakest, most foolish, most dishonest way to criticize them. It's no different from a person taking a quick look at Berserk out of context and saying "This is just edgy torture porn", or taking on look at 2B from Nier Automata and saying "This is just a pretentious sex bot game", or pausing a cut of animation in the middle of the sequence to poke fun at how the individual frames look, as if animation isn't DEFINED BY THE SEQUENCE IN MOTION.
I genuinely hate how common this kind of thought destroying "criticism" has become on the internet, it's like we champion who can think the least.
Said perfectly honest JJK does have problems most pieces of art have problems but seeing the same 2 word criticisms that say the same 2 words is just brainless. It seems like we are getting further into bandwagoning mentality where what people want to see happened encapsulates the story the author is trying to tell which makes discussion on any art feel almost meaningless. Furthermore it feels like people point out to individual scenes and criticize it more often then looking at the context for individual scenes using JJK as an example people complain about fights but these fights are set up from the starting episodes of season 1 and have huge impact on where the story moves forward as a whole.
I'm personally ok with folks using AI to create something more ambitious than they otherwise could as opposed to using AI to cut corners
Do anime breakdown on anything cool recently
We are truly doomed if Attack on Titan is the peak of mainstream anime, might elaborate later
Late answer to your rebuttal of my take : I think you're posturing. Obviously more aspects of the production are more grunt work than others, that's why animators work digitally and not traditionally anymore. You'd probably say the pressure to switch was economical, but the truth is that it allowed for better animation to be made because of faster feedback resulting in being able to fail faster and therefore improve faster. It also allowed for individual animators to work on their own project and make a breakthrough in the industry like Makoto Shinkai. AI as a tool is not different from that switch to digital animation and if anything is narrow is your understanding of AI and where it can be implemented in the pipeline and how flexible it could be.
Can you tell me the name of your favorite 'color artist', or 'in-betweener'? I don't think you can because the range of artistic expression is very limited compared to the effort required, and in the context of an industry, some jobs are more valuable than others. They just are.
I recall Shirobako adressing this, when the scare at the time was more about CG impeding on 2D and the message was more or less this : Those who actually have a vocation for this and are willing to learn the tools at their disposal will survive.
Your arguments I gotta say were just hot air and I feel were only designed to get some cheers. If you've read this, hopefully I've made you reconsider your opinion.
Firstly, there are still plenty of animators who draw traditionally, I'm sure this number will decrease eventually, but digital animation, in concept, is the same as physical animation. You draw lines and stuff with a pen, it's not that different. While I can't name my favorite in between animator or color artist, I can tell you that both these steps are crucial learning points for people who eventually become key animators and color designers (I'm speculating a bit in case of the latter). Streamlining of these steps through AI will reduce on the job learning opportunities, a concept that's already at an all time low, leading to the widespread decrease in the quality of an average anime.
That gatekeeping meme caught me offguard hahaha
04:08 that rymed with my name lmao
whats the anime at 2:04
I am also Indian and I never thought of you being Indian, I feel good that there is a great content creator about anime and animation exist in India.
Love your content and love from India and 2 animation is the peak of human art
Glad my take made it into the video
Real for mentioning the CODM community the threads there are so annoying when it comes to "weeb" culture
This is a great idea but i think the video should be longer
This mine:
The most interesting series is when the story change its narrrative and the writing style in the middle of story that make different atmosphere to their audience.
Example: Steins;Gate [before ep 12 & after ep 12], VInland Saga [S1 & S2], Chainsawman [part 1 & part 2], 86 [part 1 & part 2], Gintama [honestly I didn't watch this, but I think its quite fit to this take] and Houseki no Kuni [Phos, Moon Phos & Human/God? Phos]
Hot take: Solo leveling was very inconsistent with only 2 well animated episodes🤷♂️
Who cares all the fights were well animated at least.
Because it has only fights if you remove that element what you have
L
Want the studio dry the animator to the ground to make everything consistent?
The important scenes are very well made.
It's just useless to put a lot effort to an episode that it doesn't really matter but even tho, they still did amazing stuffs for some of the kind of episodes.
Only one fight jin woo vs igris was well animated,even that fight won't be in the top 20 or 30 best animated best fights of all time. Other fights were average at best. That fight with purple haired guy was slideshow with sparks of swords clashing lmao. I wish solo leveling was adapted by mappa or ufotable. Or if A1 actually made the show look better. Solo leveling only carried by the hype of its webtoon. Cause the webtoon fanbase is so huge and the webtoon is actually goated. The anime is meh. Solo leveling deservd the treatment that a mid like demon Slayer got for it'd first season. 26 episodes. Insane animation. And a climax fight which made demon Slayer a cultural phenomenon, and aniame of.the year and animation of the year. Solo leveling even after the anime, has majority of it's fan base cause of the webtoon. @@hariswasti3816
Another problem with AI is that, the thing that makes art so appealing is it's uniqueness but ai art is too repetitive and feels boring, art is something that only humans can master not some stupid AI.
💚💚
what's wrong if you used AI for storyboarding?
Great video but should've included my take
Really didn't expect you to be indian as an Indian myself 😅
dang that's the fastest 8 minutes of my life
A.I hype in anime is not gonna correspond the expectations that's why Sony is gonna build anime studios in Philippines and Thailand for local animators help cloverworks and A-1 Pictures. People are dreaming that A.I is gonna resolve anything but will not A.I tech used others artists projects and mixed together not create anything from zero
the first guy was completely lobotomised
Hot Take: Hayashi Team managed to produce the best looking CGI foreground in any anime ever with Attack on Titan
It's even way better than anything, including what Studio Orange produced so far
Infinity castle scenes in demon Slayer and background buildings in any show made by ufotable. People can't even tell those buildings are cgi. Tegens earrings are cgi, gyutaro's weapon was CGI.
@@indianflippingart9593 You can easily tell they are cgi and can also feel the sterilization of the environment too, the difference is that they don't use toy shaders and leave it like that. Instead they push for shadows to hide light and then use texture paint to match the setting, heck they even have a 3d tanjiro prop for back shots and certain scene (most noticable in season 1). This is very basic 3d knowledge and japan are like 10 years behind on this stuff compared to the western implementation of 2d/3d.
@@Jekiterio sure
@@indianflippingart9593 Foreground CGI bro, and sorry for not clearing my point here, my point is that the creatures not the props which ufo also excels at
Mmmmmm yes!
Out of 300 comments, bro only reacted to 8, not because the other 292 were illegible or repetitive, but because the takes were either too good or bad to pass down judgement. But I'd still call him lazy.
I think your just salty that he didn’t respond to your take
I'm actually in video, 🙌🎉
You everywhere bruh!💀
Fan of Harem yeah!😭
But I guess we both following probably pretentious. On this, I agree with you mate🗿
6:05 i disagree. there will be another show as genre defining and mass appealing in the future, we just dont know it yet. the same was said about dragon ball z, or for some naruto, or literally any other big show. Actually dragon ball z is a major one considering how massive it was in mexico.
anime as a medium is always changing and ever growing. a new generation will come along and view a different show as genre defining and so on. there will be another show as good as aot, it just wont look like aot
Animax should come back fr man🐣
"Dangers in *Ur* Heart" is overrated.
I mean, what has it brought to the table that
1. Tora Dora
2. Your Lie In April
3. Sono Bisque Doll
4. Beyond the boundary etc didn't bring?
😭
Lololol
I thought you were gonna use a face cam?
I thought so too, but the setup process was too complicated and I rage quit. I haven't fully given up yet, I'll invest in a softbox light setup soon and see if it works.
@@ProbablyPretentious ah gotcha. Yeah hopefully it’ll work out next time you give it a go
🧡🤍💚
JJK IS basically just action, nobody watches that show for anything else it's the main draw of the show and THAT"S OK! Give me JJK Season 2 over some boring anime nonsense any day! Season 2 was one of the rare anime seasons i actually finished till the end and that's a rare thing for me.
Whether you watch jjk only for action or not, It does have a good plot and story which makes it more fun. Considering how much action s2 alone had, it still managed to tell a story that was interesting.
It's a very action heavy show but still the overall story is good and catchy the characters are great and the female cast is some of the best, the villains and power system everything is good
I watch it for the charcters and the emotions. I didnt particuraly care about any if the season 1 fights but I loved everything in season 2 and the manga.
"JJK IS basically just action, nobody watches that show for anything else". Spoken like a true ignorant. Speak for yourself man.
@@LJay_4eva the story is not that good it does in fact have plot holes in it and a retcon. People who watch JJK watch it 90% for the action and 10% for the slice of life bits.
So let me get this straight. You disapprove of AI because then animators will lose their jobs but approve of piracy because content theft does not mean animators will lose their jobs. If a publisher doesnt make the money it needs to make becaues of piracy, then they lose money and they have to lay off staff. Both things are equally bad yet you approve of one.
Hot question
Can PP speak Hindi??
Yes, I'm Bengali, so that too.
Aot is peak
finally my theory of you being an indian is true lol
Hot take: I personally think Mappa animation is NOT good, it's a lot of CGI, to many frames in animation. Too TOO smooth, example chainsaw man has too much frames which make the impact look soft. IMO. I wish I could've said this earlier. Aot last season was 🚮❌. And there company has a whole bunch of issues with low pay, problems etc.
But I honestly also think there old animation was good. Like jjk first season, hells paradise etc.
.. This is my opinion tho and how I feel. A1 studio is my personal favorite, like mashle, solo leveling.🔥💯
Ye brother man since that kaju nr 8 vid i rlly have lost respect for u
TF did I do lmao?
@@ProbablyPretentious go read my comments on the kaju nr8 vid
@@ProbablyPretentious Bruh! I just don't get Kaiju no.8 fans.😭
They just need to hear any and everyone glazing and praising every bit of the show trying to fill up their delusions that it's a worthy replacement for AOT(not that AOT needs a replacement. Kaiju no.8 can be a story of its own)
It's like going upfront and saying that the "first 200 EPS of OP is "like" unnecessary ramble and fillers about Luffy rescuing his crew that's incapable of not getting harmed and the animation is ***sh" . The fans would dig out your IP and trace all of your socials 😭
@@zfon1deiIt’s not even that interesting lol
Brooo
Do your face reveal already!!
*HOT TAKE:* When the SHOW is serious like DEATH NOTE or VINLAND SAGA the the dub is TOP TIER. But when it comes to ANIME made for YOUNGER people like YU-GI-OH or KONOSUBA DUB is dogsh*t
Here take my hot take,Mushoku Tensei is the best isekai with the one of the most great cast of characters who actually feel human & their realistic developments
Not really a hot take; Mushoku and rezero are the most popular isekaj, they are like the big 2 of isekai.
Great cast? Most of these characters are just stock isekai characters that get abandoned after major arcs.
Plus the only time they act human is when it's something to do with loss. These characters rape and sexually harass people but that doesn't matter cause the author is porn addict that seemingly thinks sexual harassment is only for gags and jokes.
try lord of the mysteries dude actually great cast of characters and a very uniqe power system and world building
It's not really a hot take. Getting best in Isekai isn't that hard anyways. I don't love it. It's ok to me
@@chasinghaze0962 Dude.
That's so true! 😭😭
It's like when there are 100 students in one class and the highest grade in there is D.
💀
2:11 The industry isn't losing money cause those people were never gonna pay to watch anime or read manga.
To the guy made the take on AI being good, NEVER COOK AGAIN!
But I did cook, I'm afraid you just never had a 5-star meal. 😉
Bro finally said he's from india 😭😭😭😭
no one knew it :O
@@miyou12 Wasn't it a universal fact? 😶
Y are bruhs acting like it is news?😭
Pretty sure he's said that before too
3:30 to be honest jjk is actually made of action only like if you think of it and says its Shonen and all so i don't think it makes sense cuz even while being shonen we all know that story also matters and if you are following its manga currently then you can find out what do i mean from this
Hot take:Beserk cgi is better than trigun stampede cgi tbh
HARD DISAGREE LOL 😂
based
Oh hell nah trigun changed the whole concept of cgi=bad berserk was a mess
Saying AI has no place in creative industries really shows a profound ignorance on how computers work. If you use any digital machine in your work (which the anime industry has in mass for at least the past 2 decades) you have already used AI tools no matter how much human effort was put into the final work it is still a product of programs which use AI to function.