are diamond engagement rings a scam? 💍💸💔

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 9. 03. 2024
  • numerous aspects of marriage have been commodified over the years, from the actual wedding to the engagement ring. what used to be a simple sign of your affection, has turned into a way of proving "your love" to others. in today's video we decided to take a look at engagement rings. how they became a tradition, when diamonds became the standard, and why we feel pressured to spend so much money on something that doesn't really matter.
    follow us! 🌸
    / moderngurlz
    / moderngurlzz
    / moderngurlz
    / moderngurlz
    get in touch 💌
    moderngurlz@night.co
    contact@moderngurlz.com
    co-writer 📝
    sami gotskind
    / samigotskind
    editor 🎬
    aalyiah victoria
    www.aalyiahv.com/
    music! 🎶
    / future-james-pure-imag...
    Music by Tarious Hill - Out Of Season - thmatc.co/?l=5A8754D3
    Music by Brodie Love - Tall Glass Of Juice - thmatc.co/?l=651385D0
    Music by Gil Wanders - By The River - thmatc.co/?l=69ABD9D5
    intro/outro by
    nicole w.b
    / cherryinferno
    Copyright Disclaimer under section 107 of the Copyright Act of 1976, allowance is made for “fair use” for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, education and research. All the videos, songs, images, and graphics used in the video belong to their respective owners and this channel does not claim any right over them.
  • Zábava

Komentáře • 260

  • @audreylockhart90
    @audreylockhart90 Před 2 měsíci +886

    I specifically told my fiancé I didn’t want a diamond ring, and he proposed with a lovely amethyst ring, which is my birth stone!

    • @trinaq
      @trinaq Před 2 měsíci +61

      Aww, that's so sweet and thoughtful! I personally think that amethysts are prettier than diamonds, though maybe I'm biased, also being a February baby.

    • @hamdialihassan1048
      @hamdialihassan1048 Před měsícem +10

      @@trinaq mine’s ruby which honestly if I ever get engaged I would love one! Or a yellow diamond/topas since that’s my favorite color

    • @valeriarossini543
      @valeriarossini543 Před měsícem +4

      omg that's so sweet and such a cute idea

    • @strawberrykun6136
      @strawberrykun6136 Před měsícem +4

      When you're born in April 😭😭

    • @prisle
      @prisle Před měsícem

      Hmm are there pretty garnets out there? (january gal here)

  • @Alice-jj2rt
    @Alice-jj2rt Před 2 měsíci +694

    Diamonds themselves are also a scam. They’re not a rarity. In fact, they are a LOT more common than you’d think. The reason they’re so expensive is because one company owns over 90% of all naturally occurring diamonds so it’s equivalent to “you can’t get this nowhere else honey so send me your life savings if you really want it”

    • @kittykittybangbang9367
      @kittykittybangbang9367 Před 2 měsíci +9

      I think this is what money game part 2 was about

    • @K.C-2049
      @K.C-2049 Před 2 měsíci +33

      and then it's not even just the artificial rarity, it's the emotional blackmailing of "if he doesn't spend x amount of money for your ring, he doesn't really love you". like... the fucking nerve.

    • @ahstiasummers5583
      @ahstiasummers5583 Před měsícem +4

      Supposedly, an ex-Jared jeweler advised on buying created white sapphire instead of diamond. Still durable, cheaper than real diamond, and only a professional jeweler would be able to tell the difference

  • @wyltedleaves
    @wyltedleaves Před 2 měsíci +544

    Short answer: yes. Long answer: yes, they are.

  • @racheltalley4364
    @racheltalley4364 Před 2 měsíci +224

    I have an emerald. The number one comment I get is "Oh! For your birthstone!"
    Nope. My favorite color is green. Get what you want, not what is expected. 💚

  • @neztradamus
    @neztradamus Před 2 měsíci +329

    Go vintage, 100%. My engagement ring is 1800s Georgian. It's like having piece of history on your finger. I'm constantly wondering who it belonged to and what kind of life she had. And it's an heirloom I'll pass down (:

    • @pssurvivor
      @pssurvivor Před 2 měsíci +11

      do spare a thought for the slaves that mined it too

    • @paulinatanousis5116
      @paulinatanousis5116 Před 2 měsíci +55

      @@pssurvivorantique rings don’t contribute to current poor mining practices

    • @jacktadash
      @jacktadash Před měsícem +12

      I exclusively harvest fingers for this reason.

    • @SuperTrizna
      @SuperTrizna Před měsícem +26

      ⁠@@pssurvivorspare thought to your thought: to avoid the continuance of dehumanization when referencing people that were enslaved, it’s best to refer to them as that. In lieu of referring to these humans as “the slaves”. People who were enslaved is more accurate, negating the inherent devaluing of their person in the act of enslavement, especially as modern humans speaking in retrospect.

    • @Me-vn3gz
      @Me-vn3gz Před měsícem +1

      i wanted this but my bf wants it to be unique to me so he designed one (i still don’t know what it looks like)

  • @hamdialihassan1048
    @hamdialihassan1048 Před 2 měsíci +119

    I would love to get a series from you where you talk about every aspect of a wedding like the dresses, the several events like engagement parties, the bachelor/bachelorette parties, shower, the rehersal dinner, the actual wedding, some people even do a brunch the next day, the honeymoon etc. Thanks 🙏

    • @booksandtea1663
      @booksandtea1663 Před 2 měsíci +10

      Great idea! Tessa please consider this!

    • @sliceoflolabelle
      @sliceoflolabelle Před měsícem +3

      this would be so good

    • @ahstiasummers5583
      @ahstiasummers5583 Před měsícem

      I know some of those other extra parts comes are because dowries have, for the most part, vanished from a majority of the world. So to supplement the dowry aspect of marriage, they add in various mini parties. Or like diamond rings, the rich used to do all those extra pieces as a show of wealth and the poor emulated them

  • @brysonrenee
    @brysonrenee Před 2 měsíci +228

    my now husband knew i didnt want a diamond and that i wanted it to be fairly inexpensive and fun to look at. so they got me an alexandrite ring that changes color in different lighting. they researched what stones would be tough enough to withstand my clumsiness and what metals would be best against tarnishing and my allergies. The time they took to choose something they knew i'd like and would be best for every day life was so thoughtful and better than any diamond to me 💖

    • @kyndramb7050
      @kyndramb7050 Před 2 měsíci +15

      My Nana used a Alexandrite ring as her ring too. She still kept her small original ring in her jewelry box, but loved that huge Alexandrite stone. ❤

    • @aamu3
      @aamu3 Před 2 měsíci +3

      this! i want this!!!

    • @awesomyth
      @awesomyth Před 2 měsíci +3

      This is a great idea! Gonna have to save that for if I ever get married too. 😁

    • @annejeppesen160
      @annejeppesen160 Před měsícem +3

      Your husband is a keeper!

    • @mortalkaiban
      @mortalkaiban Před měsícem

      I also got an alexandrite stone! I wasnt expecting it but I'm happy with it.

  • @abbysc417
    @abbysc417 Před 2 měsíci +251

    I’m really happy with my moissanite engagement ring. It looks exactly the same but was much more affordable for my husband and didn’t require child labor 😳

    • @ganymededarling
      @ganymededarling Před 2 měsíci +27

      Same here. And they are more sparkly than diamonds which is a major plus! They are beautiful.

    • @NR-fg2qc
      @NR-fg2qc Před 2 měsíci +14

      I bet it sparkles so much more too!

    • @FrancescaSola1
      @FrancescaSola1 Před měsícem +3

      Me too, and I LOVE the sparkle!

    • @withelisa
      @withelisa Před měsícem +3

      I have a dark grey moissanite e-ring! Its sparkle is so colorful and dramatic. Huge fan of moissy.

  • @pssurvivor
    @pssurvivor Před 2 měsíci +48

    i love pink sapphires. i'd never buy a diamond because of ethical concerns, but i am not opposed to lab grown ones if i can find a nice oval princess cut pink one. also there are so many breathtakingly beautiful gemstones other than diamonds.

  • @Friesnotlies
    @Friesnotlies Před 2 měsíci +54

    As an older gen z newlywed, I definitely agree with purchasing what makes you happy. I found I liked smaller rings that were nowhere near thousands!! Also lab grown and moissanite are wonderful options if you do not want to shell out on a diamond

  • @trinaq
    @trinaq Před 2 měsíci +178

    Once again, I always end up agreeing with Tessa's concise, well written arguments. I personally don't care about a flashy, expensive engagement ring. All that should really matter is the love that you and your partner share, not how much it costs.

    • @Frogface91
      @Frogface91 Před měsícem +2

      I told my husband that I didn't want to feel owned, that I'd only accept an engagement ring if we got one for him, too. He liked the idea but then when we decided to marry I suggested we just save the money instead. My mum wasn't pleased but we're happy with the minimalist look of just our wedding rings.

  • @verynotreally
    @verynotreally Před 2 měsíci +32

    I love diamonds, but when it came to my engagement ring, we went antique. My engagement ring has two rose cut diamonds ‐ a cut that's very out of favour because it doesn't show off fire and are very thin. But I love rose cuts - they glitter rather than blindingly sparkle. We paid $400 for my ring, and I love it.
    I would only caution anyone looking for alternatives to diamonds: if you mean to wear your ring every day, make sure you choose a stone that's hard enough for daily wear. Diamonds and their lab-grown equivalents, moissanite, ruby, sapphire, etc. These stones can all survive daily wear through the years. Lots of stones can wear away, fog up, or even break (emeralds can be particularly prone to breaking, even though they are quite hard). Or just refresh your ring every few years! Have fun! There are no real rules!

  • @kimberlyterasaki4843
    @kimberlyterasaki4843 Před 2 měsíci +42

    I wear my grandmother’s ring and I love it. It was free, vintage, much more sustainable, and a symbol of almost 70 years of my grandparents love. The best part is that I didn’t even have to get it resized, which makes it feel all the more special. Even if she can’t be at my wedding, her ring will be with me for the rest of my life and marriage.

  • @ilpesto554
    @ilpesto554 Před 2 měsíci +202

    Natural diamond are scan. Lab grown ones need more advertising. My man said he HAS to spend 6 salaries on ring. And i still cant persuade him i prefer rubies and sapphires if it has to be something expensive. Poor man🤡

    • @kryw10
      @kryw10 Před 2 měsíci +64

      I don’t like that he won’t listen, tbh. That would make me very uncomfortable.

    • @im_an_oyster
      @im_an_oyster Před 2 měsíci +31

      Tell him you'll straight up say no if he proposes with such an expensive ring

    • @annejeppesen160
      @annejeppesen160 Před měsícem +33

      From an outside perspective that is a major red flag!

    • @jacktadash
      @jacktadash Před měsícem +15

      Sounds like a dummy I'd leave him girlfriend.

    • @bluewilliams4911
      @bluewilliams4911 Před měsícem +9

      To be fair, rubies/sapphires aren’t generally obtained much more ethically. They’re just cheaper

  • @bmo_95
    @bmo_95 Před 2 měsíci +20

    My husband picked out a sapphire that reminded him of my eyes. It was perfect and way more meaningful. I told him I didn't want a diamond ring on one of our first dates.

  • @eimere
    @eimere Před 2 měsíci +15

    In my country (generally speaking) the couple decides together to get married, as in a serious conversation, and there's no such thing as the need for an engagement ring or calling each other fiance. Then you will have your wedding ring and that's it

  • @VioletNKisHere
    @VioletNKisHere Před 2 měsíci +59

    Love shouldn’t have to be proven by money.

  • @AngryTheatreMaker
    @AngryTheatreMaker Před 2 měsíci +56

    One thing I will say about my partner--he was certain we had a future from early in our relationship, and he asked me what sort of stone I'd want in a ring if/when he gave me one. So I told him, "No diamonds." Quite aside from the concerns cited here, there's something about colorless diamonds that always struck me as somewhat lacking in soul and expressiveness (unless you're expressing how much money you spent).

    • @beckahcruz7463
      @beckahcruz7463 Před 2 měsíci +4

      Yes, I agree! I've been putting off my engagement for many reasons, including my health, but a big reason is also the rings. I'm not sure what I want. I do know I don't want a diamond. I think they are ugly and extremely boring! I could do a colored diamond but those are also expensive. We definitely don't have the money for that. If I spend thousands of dollars it will be on something more important than a ring.

    • @AngryTheatreMaker
      @AngryTheatreMaker Před 2 měsíci

      @@beckahcruz7463 Colorless diamonds are ugly, aren't they? I myself don't need to give up a kidney, as lovely as some fancy diamonds are. I've had my eye on a yellow sapphire--prettier than your average diamond and often fetching a shockingly affordable price. Well, that and sapphires are high enough on the Mohs scale to be wearable for every day.

    • @ahstiasummers5583
      @ahstiasummers5583 Před měsícem

      Like other expensive things and beauty trends, look back in history. It was a show of wealth from the times when there was no machinery to mine diamonds and jewelry was created fully by hand and brute strength. Poor people emulated the rich and wanted diamond engagement rings

  • @Theboggblog
    @Theboggblog Před 2 měsíci +73

    See I do want a diamond ring, but I want a natural smoky black diamond. They’re on Etsy for $6k AT THE ABSOLUTE MOST, most of them range at the $500 to $1k mark. One of the things I don’t want in a husband is someone who makes bad financial decisions.

    • @withelisa
      @withelisa Před měsícem +11

      Just one note- black diamonds are gorgeous but they do get their color from inclusions, so they're brittle and prone to cracking compared with other gemstones. If your heart is set on it and you are careful, ofc go for it and enjoy! I wanted one too but ended up choosing a dark grey moissanite instead for durability. It's absolutely stunning. A very different sparkle (clear and colorful rather than smokey and moody diamond), but suggesting just in case ❤️

    • @dog5221
      @dog5221 Před měsícem

      ​@@withelisa100% this! Tons of lab made options are resilient and affordable! Moissanite also has more brilliance imo (even in darker toned stones)

  • @Wendy-je9zf
    @Wendy-je9zf Před 2 měsíci +27

    congratulations on your engagement, and I think shedding light on how the diamond industry has utilized marketing, as well as exploited business practices to artificially inflate. The prices of diamonds is incredibly important, especially because the tradition of different rings is one that I think is really fun, but there are definitely more ethical ways to go aboutgetting a ring and or creating a ring with your partner

  • @marisadesilva5566
    @marisadesilva5566 Před měsícem +8

    My partner just proposed with a Sri Lankan Ceylon Ruby, he also got a vintage second hand silver bracelet melted for the band of my ring from Argentina. I prefer this more as he spent 3 months on it and I’m mixed race, half Sri Lankan half Argentine. I appreciated the sentiment and hard work 😌🥰

    • @mariadeeva8993
      @mariadeeva8993 Před měsícem +3

      Wow, it was so incredibly thoughtful and caring of him! Congratulations on your engagement!

    • @marisadesilva5566
      @marisadesilva5566 Před měsícem +2

      @@mariadeeva8993 thank you lovely xx ♥️

  • @diamend5
    @diamend5 Před 2 měsíci +25

    Agreed! I love my blue sapphire engagement ring! I told my husband that I didn’t care if it was real or fake, or anything from a topaz to aquamarine, that I just preferred to not have a diamond and it had to be any shade of blue.

    • @bluewilliams4911
      @bluewilliams4911 Před měsícem

      Most sapphires are also mined through unethical means and in a country under a military junta that’s been committing a genocide for like… a decade now, and those which arent are still mined through child labor, but ok go off i guess.

  • @trinaq
    @trinaq Před 2 měsíci +35

    Please cover more outfit analysis videos, namely "Pretty in Pink", or "10 Things I Hate About You", two of my top teen movies. Also, I'd love if you continued the 15 Best Dresses in Cinematic History series.

  • @_cupidscharm
    @_cupidscharm Před 2 měsíci +17

    I’m not getting engaged any time soon because I’m in high school, but on top of the ethical issues with them, I find diamond rings a bit boring already. most of the ones I’ve seen have the same two appearances: that brilliant cut with the thin band, or that emerald cut with the big band.
    I’ve been doing research on lab grown gems recently, and I’ve found so many cool synthetic gems that look way better than diamonds!! if I ever do get an engagement ring, it’s going to be something with angel aura quartz or dragons breath opal. way cooler than diamonds imo

    • @dog5221
      @dog5221 Před měsícem +1

      It's great to see other young people thinking about this and showing lab grown gems some love! Only thing I'd say is opals (speaking from experience 😭) cloud and break easily cuz of their softness score.

    • @_cupidscharm
      @_cupidscharm Před měsícem

      @@dog5221 yeah, I’ll definitely keep an eye on them! I have a pair of moonstone earrings that I wear to school and I get so paranoid if I break them because they’re like a 5-6 on the mohs scale 😭😭
      I think I’ll settle on angel aura quartz tho! I like how it has that shiny multicolor sheen, it looks like something out of a fantasy novel

  • @SnehaSrivastava-dx6kp
    @SnehaSrivastava-dx6kp Před 2 měsíci +34

    Omg please do a breakdown on fashion in Bollywood movies 🙏

    • @victorlolxd7347
      @victorlolxd7347 Před 2 měsíci

      Bollywood does not wear clothes they where full-body jewelry

    • @pollycipher
      @pollycipher Před 2 měsíci +1

      I'm still waiting for a video about 15 green dresses in Cinematic history.

  • @chococatey
    @chococatey Před 2 měsíci +6

    I ended up choosing a teal sapphire engagement ring. The color feels more unique to me without all the ridiculous prices of diamond rings.

  • @audreyconfer7678
    @audreyconfer7678 Před 2 měsíci +9

    I told my boyfriend that if he wants to marry me, I want a sapphire. I don’t want him to spend his life saving on a stone that I don’t even think is that pretty. He already got me a gorgeous sapphire promise ring for our first anniversary, and I’m so proud it wasn’t an arm and a leg for him

  • @tessaarmstrong4770
    @tessaarmstrong4770 Před měsícem +4

    My husband picked moissanite because he’s a big nerd and, I quote, “its particular crystalline structure and rock to hand ratio for price”
    We call it the shiny rock of monogamy.

  • @LittlexRose
    @LittlexRose Před měsícem +5

    Was anyone else singing “diamonds are a girl’s best” while watching

  • @VidWatcher01
    @VidWatcher01 Před měsícem +2

    10:23 "A TOPAAAAAAZZZZZ!???" IDK why I cracked up at that so hard!🤣🤣🤣

  • @sarracenia8816
    @sarracenia8816 Před 2 měsíci +8

    2:38 all veins run to the heart

  • @iamclassicforlife
    @iamclassicforlife Před 2 měsíci

    Grateful to you for making this video!
    Needed to watch it!

  • @SpinningOrange
    @SpinningOrange Před měsícem +2

    If I ever marry I want a gold ring with engraved flowers and no stones. I want something that I'd be comfortable wearing everyday.

  • @PrairieWindSun
    @PrairieWindSun Před 2 měsíci +12

    You don't need an engagement ring at all for a joyful loving relationship. At the end of the day its just vanity based on wealth. Rejecting a true loving person due to lacking such a requirement only brings more misery in the future.

  • @lyandraangel
    @lyandraangel Před měsícem +3

    My husband and I have star sapphire rings. Still rather expensive, but much more unique. There are diamonds on my wedding band, but mostly because it's my birthstone.

  • @TheActualRed
    @TheActualRed Před 2 měsíci +14

    I work with my hands, i had a titanium ring with a design, but no stones. That ring took a lot of abuse.

  • @rebeccag8589
    @rebeccag8589 Před měsícem +3

    This was very interesting! But I'm just here to say I really appreciate the clips from films and TV shows I love, particularly classic films. The Gilded Age, Gigi, Funny Girl, Sunset, Gentlemen Prefer Blondes, Roman Holiday, Camelot, Kramer vs Kramer, The Age of Innocence, etc.! (And understandably, Breakfast at Tiffany's and Moulin Rouge. Haha).

  • @justanothernicole
    @justanothernicole Před 2 měsíci +7

    A friend of mine got engaged with a ring made of wood her husband himself crafted (he took the wood from a tree from the selvatic zone where they met) and I thought it was so romantic and very meaningful, I couldn’t have an expensive diamond ring without seeing the blood through it

  • @xiRollwithitx
    @xiRollwithitx Před 2 měsíci +12

    I'm inheriting my great grandma's diamond ring, I was also named after her which makes it all the more special! It doesn't even need to be resized, fits like a glove. 👌

  • @alannahhurley386
    @alannahhurley386 Před měsícem +2

    I would like a vintage art deco style emerald ring. I like they are so classy while still being unique. I would also love a vintage fur coat😍

  • @yltraviole
    @yltraviole Před 2 měsíci +11

    I'm a fiddler. The only jewelry I wear is earrings, because anything else, I'll play with it, fiddle with it and inevitably lose it. I'd constantly worry about losing something as expensive as a diamond engagement ring. I'd like a pretty, cheap ring that can easily be replaced.

    • @cornflakes-does-stuff
      @cornflakes-does-stuff Před 2 měsíci +3

      I thought you meant fiddler as in the instrument and for a second there I was very confused :"D

  • @marikkelaszlo3355
    @marikkelaszlo3355 Před 2 měsíci +16

    My mom still prefers mined diamonds over lab-grown diamonds cause she thinks the fact that the diamond is found has more status symbol than the ones that are made in lab, same with pearls, she sees found pearls from the sea are better than the ones that are farmed. 😭😭

    • @beckahcruz7463
      @beckahcruz7463 Před 2 měsíci +5

      It's so tough to change people's minds about these things 😓

    • @marikkelaszlo3355
      @marikkelaszlo3355 Před měsícem

      @@beckahcruz7463 yeah, and it’s weird cause they’re still both diamonds!!💎 just made under different conditions!

    • @antoniacapellaborges6566
      @antoniacapellaborges6566 Před měsícem +6

      Show her the videos of the conflict in Eastern DRC and ask her what those kids think of her rings

  • @moonstoneuniverse8516
    @moonstoneuniverse8516 Před 2 měsíci +28

    Me: All rings are a rip off they were made to trick us into thinking material items are love
    My foreign boyfriend: Giving gifts is a sign of love and rings, necklaces and any jewelry can mean that
    I just wanted to throw this out there makes you think.

    • @trinaq
      @trinaq Před 2 měsíci +5

      Talk about food for thought, your boyfriend has hit the nail right on the head.

    • @wyltedleaves
      @wyltedleaves Před 2 měsíci +14

      You don't have to break the bank for a gift to be meaningful.

    • @ahstiasummers5583
      @ahstiasummers5583 Před měsícem

      It's one thing to think that "more money = more love", thinking that the more money someone spends on you the more that they love you. It's another to hand pick a special item and spend lots of money on it because you know that person and that they'd love this thing

  • @bella-zk6sy
    @bella-zk6sy Před 2 měsíci +5

    i told my boyfriend i am not into diamonds as we don't know where they are sourced from. getting jade instead 🥰

  • @empressfreya9872
    @empressfreya9872 Před měsícem +1

    Watching this video the week I got engaged (with a gorgeous, non-diamond stone) is just perfect timing

  • @bethlovesthings
    @bethlovesthings Před 2 měsíci +1

    Great video, i am very aware of the history as I LOVE mineralogy. I definitely did not want a really expensive engagement ring because I would be too anxious to wear it ever if cost something extravagent.
    I also always knew I didn't want a diamond as the main stone and about five years ago, I fell in love with teal sapphires. Sapphires can still withstand daily wear. I love that there are so many options these days (stones & settings).
    I don't have an issue with engagement rings, but rather the expectation and EXPENSE that people are pressured into, aka people without the means to afford a thousands on a ring, go into debt for it these days.
    Plus, in the wise words of Thrice "a ring don't mean nothing if you can't hold the weight."

  • @GiulianaBruna
    @GiulianaBruna Před měsícem +2

    I specially told my now husband I didn't wanted him to spend to much, and I got a delicate and beautiful pearl one. I don't know anyone who has a diamond ring here. Even more, I don't know anyone from previous generations who have an engagement ring, just the gold ones.

  • @MorganRimming
    @MorganRimming Před 2 měsíci +5

    Before even watching the video and only seeing the title, yes. Yes they are. It was all a marketing ploy because diamonds weren't selling like that.

  • @widowgirl1254
    @widowgirl1254 Před 2 měsíci +1

    Congrats on your engagement ❤❤❤

  • @fann458
    @fann458 Před 2 měsíci +2

    I'm fascinated by gems that match's the eyes since I bought a peridot and silver ring for my birthday years ago.
    I have my eyes set on a emerald + gold ring after my graduation but I'm not that in love with diamonds... I just like big stones with color in it

  • @braeburnapfel5178
    @braeburnapfel5178 Před 2 měsíci +2

    Nowadays, I just don't really see the point in engagement rings... You'll have a wedding ring anyway, shouldn't that be enough? Also, diamond rings are really expensive and (in my opinion) aren't even that pretty. Personally, I told my boyfriend (now fiancé) I didn't need an engagement ring and I am still happy with this decision 😊

    • @mitsusah2612
      @mitsusah2612 Před měsícem

      I think the diversity of today's relationships means that there isn't really a one true way to view relationships, engagement and marriage. Your situation sounds very nice and I'm sure it is the right choice for you. I also know couples who don't want to get married, so they just got engagement rings and live together and started their own families. That works for them. The diversity of situations is beautiful and sticking to a traditional "man proposes with a diamond ring, couple saves money and maybe gets help from both sets of parents and then gets married and both get wedding bands" only needlessly restricts couples. And yeah, diamonds are expensive because the sellers manipulate the market. I agree that is isn't really worth it, but some people like diamonds and they can do as they please.

  • @marionleblanc8580
    @marionleblanc8580 Před měsícem

    I like how this doubles as a movie quizz 😅

  • @weirdoinpink
    @weirdoinpink Před měsícem

    Mine is pink Morganite and I absolutely love it!!

  • @bethlovesthings
    @bethlovesthings Před 2 měsíci +6

    Also now that you are engaged, I'd be interested in seeing you dissect other parts of the wedding / planning industry too. Aka the "wedding tax" etc.

  • @bri9irl1991
    @bri9irl1991 Před měsícem +1

    I have a beautiful morganite and moissanite engagement ring. I'm obsessed.

  • @AR-de8qz
    @AR-de8qz Před 2 měsíci +2

    My birthstone is a diamond and it's so disappointing because it's the most boring basic gem imo. Instead I got a custom pink sapphire because it's my favorite color. He even had me pick out the ring and we designed it together. I'm very happy with it 💗

  • @limonade2684
    @limonade2684 Před 2 měsíci +4

    The Luther ring is wrong. He married Katharina von Bora and the original wedding ring is in a museum in Leipzig, Germany. It is made from gold and ruby and only one piece. There was no engagement ring.

  • @sarahallegra6239
    @sarahallegra6239 Před měsícem +1

    When my now-husband and I started discussing marriage, I specifically told him I did not want a diamond ring for many reasons, including that I just think they’re a bit boring. He got me the most beautiful moonstone ring (at my request) which I treasure and always gets compliments! But when he gave it to me, he made me promise that if anyone ever asked about my ring, I had to tell them it was what I asked for so no one would accuse him of being stingy. I agreed and we’re going to be celebrating 13 years of marriage this year ❤

  • @SLATESLATES
    @SLATESLATES Před 2 měsíci +1

    personally emerald (birth stone) or a healing stone (amethyst, selenite, quartz) for engagement. then a diamond, gold, or silver band for the wedding. I know what I want.

  • @Sewingistherapy
    @Sewingistherapy Před měsícem +1

    Yes, they are a scam. And they are pretty much worthless to resell. I told my husband not to go into debt on a ring before he proposed. Then my grandmother ended giving me her diamond from my late grandfather. We have struggled financially our whole marriage and have tried to sell it twice (not at a pawn shop). We were offered so little for it that it would have been an insult to take it. So I still have it and it worth far more now as a gift from my grandmother than anything else.

  • @rainpooper7088
    @rainpooper7088 Před měsícem +1

    I'm from Germany and I don't think you really saw diamonds, let alone large ones, being put on engagement rings before the internet made it trendy, most people I know either used one set of rings for both engagement and wedding or used plain silver (or another metal of that color at least) for their engagement rings and then "upgraded" to plain gold (occasionally engraved with names and wedding date on the inside) for the actual wedding rings. Also, both partners tend to wear them, not just the woman.

  • @EsperElves
    @EsperElves Před měsícem +3

    Love the video. Personally, I find diamonds a little bit boring and definitely overrated. I always prefer other gemstones and there are so many different ones. It would be a lot more interesting to see who wears which gemstone to see each individual's preference, taste and character.

  • @MinisDunyasi5
    @MinisDunyasi5 Před 2 měsíci +8

    It started as a ripoff and still is a ripoff.

  • @Kalistorydreamer
    @Kalistorydreamer Před 2 měsíci +2

    Wow the history of the rings in ancient times and what they looked like back then interest me. Though the rings being once made out of bone freaked me out a little 😅. And yeah, I’d rather not go for a diamond ring either, even if I’m wealthy since 1. Really expensive, and 2. I prefer more colorful stones, so I might go for an Alexandrite, Mojssanite, and/ or Opal if I get engaged. Plus hearing about the awful treatment of workers in the diamond mines made me not want a mine diamond even more. Coincidentally, Opal is also my birth stone.

  • @Elisa-006
    @Elisa-006 Před 2 měsíci +14

    Never been so early

  • @555rox555
    @555rox555 Před měsícem

    Not me getting a diamond ring commercial before the video started 😂😂😂😂😂

  • @SkySpiral8
    @SkySpiral8 Před 2 měsíci +9

    I love my lab grown diamond. Small, much more durable than other stones, and ethical.

  • @myriamdhaiti2935
    @myriamdhaiti2935 Před 2 měsíci

    I've been telling people that ❤❤❤. I love your vidéos.

  • @MrHenrytheoctopus
    @MrHenrytheoctopus Před měsícem

    Would it be possible for you to add the names of the movies/tv shows that you’re showing clips of? Maybe as hardcoded text at the bottom of the screen?
    Some of those movies look good, and I’d like to watch them, but I don’t even know how to start on finding them 😢

  • @annaorr6808
    @annaorr6808 Před 2 měsíci +10

    Are diamond engagement rings a scam? Yes and no. Yes, they are more common than people realize and the price is SERIOUSLY overinflated. No, diamonds are the hardest naturally occurring substance in the world, which is important for something one could potentially wear for decades and be passed down for generations. My advice: if you are choosing to have a stone on your engagement ring, choose a stone that can LAST for generations.

    • @andreiaalto
      @andreiaalto Před 2 měsíci +2

      So… get scammed now so that the rock you bought wont break when your relative happens to have her ring finger stuck in an industrial hydraulic press in few generations?

    • @AngryTheatreMaker
      @AngryTheatreMaker Před 2 měsíci +2

      Hence the recurring popularity of stones that are a 9 or thereabouts on the Mohs scale (rubies, sapphires). I am personally eyeing a juicy yellow sapphire.

  • @gazerockerzavii
    @gazerockerzavii Před 2 měsíci +5

    My partner makes good money. Could have bought me a very expensive one... But he knows me. He got me a handmade silver ring with a who knows what kind of stone from my favorite Japanese jeweler. Absolutely love it...

  • @sasamafrass
    @sasamafrass Před 2 měsíci +8

    My boyfriend (now husband) and I bought each other rings for our first anniversary. Oh man the pressure the salesman put on my husband to buy a bigger, more expensive ring! We did buy a small, $700 diamond ring that I picked but sometimes I wish we had gone with an alternative stone. When we went back to buy my wedding band we were pressured to buy a more expensive diamond band that was bigger and more expensive than the engagement ring. I stuck to my guns and said I wanted a smaller ring and we got one for $500.

  • @zawwnypow5813
    @zawwnypow5813 Před 2 měsíci +1

    I loove this video! This is so important and I completely agree with everything you said. Keep being a good caring person. Congrats on your engagement ❤

  • @DragonGeeGee21
    @DragonGeeGee21 Před 23 dny

    I just gotta say… I’ve been trying to manifest a proposal from my man lol
    But already knowing the history of diamonds, I’ve been pinning aquamarine, sapphire and other beautiful jewels into my ”wedding ring” board 🥺💍💕

  • @stephanieking6236
    @stephanieking6236 Před měsícem

    When I got engaged I asked my now husband to get something secondhand because of my sustainability values, and my preference for vintage styles. I love my yellow gold marquise cut ring even though it's not trendy right now. It is perfect for me, and for the quality of ring, it was a bargain. Secondhand is a great way to go with reputable sellers!

  • @victorlolxd7347
    @victorlolxd7347 Před 2 měsíci +6

    Honestly…. This is the 1 thing where i feel like it REALLY makes sense to go ALL IN on… Because of the meaning behind it and the idea of wearing it forever…

    • @TimidAction
      @TimidAction Před 2 měsíci +1

      I agree! Whatever makes the bride happy, whether it’s a dainty or extravagant ring

  • @nomaniworu
    @nomaniworu Před 2 měsíci +1

    Gold band moissanite stone 👌🏼

  • @LostPaperChild
    @LostPaperChild Před 21 dnem

    There's no such thing as a "conflict free" diamond, no matter what the industry tells you. And lab grown diamonds still have a significant impact on the environment so however you spin it, it's just not worth it imo. And that's what I told my boyfriend. I'd rather spend two months worth of his salary on literally anything else.
    This is one of the best videos on your channel. This is the stuff I've been talking about for years!

  • @lenawalters1866
    @lenawalters1866 Před měsícem +1

    I got engaged with a 600$ garnet and gold ring I picked out. The garnet definitely shows some wear after ten years but honestly nothing is forever. The nicks and scratches are just a show of time passing. I'm still very happy with my decision. Garnets are my favorite stone and it brings me joy. You could argue that a more expensive ring would have held out better and maybe? But why? The ring is symbolic sure but it's not like it's tied to the marriage like it's The One Ring and if one is destroyed so will the other go.

  • @noodle_witch
    @noodle_witch Před měsícem

    Well, I just received a natural diamond engagement ring and now I feel bad.

  • @gunterJo
    @gunterJo Před měsícem +1

    My sister made fun of me cuz my husband proposed with a moissanite ring, while her husband gave her a 3k diamond ring and she even said that he probably doesn't love me enough to give me a more expensive ring, I really don't care I know that a ring is not a meter for love, but I thought it was that she think it is.

  • @OwlBard
    @OwlBard Před měsícem +1

    If / when I get engaged, I don't want a diamond. I don't know what I want, but I definitely want something unique and cool. Maybe a jade ring or something.

  • @aamu3
    @aamu3 Před 2 měsíci +1

    id just wana pick rings together 🥹

  • @isabelleroberge2857
    @isabelleroberge2857 Před měsícem

    Short answer: YES!

  • @pollycipher
    @pollycipher Před 2 měsíci

    I would get an amethyst engagement ring because Its my birthstone and I always want an a piece of amethyst jewelry. It would be on a gold band of of course.

  • @DanielaMartinez-wt6ir
    @DanielaMartinez-wt6ir Před měsícem

    I'm not a fan of rings in general, I have the knack of fidgeting and taking them off in odd places, and neither is my gf, so when we got engaged we exchanged novelty pins since it felt more like us. We had a couple of years in between getting engaged and making it public and when we did so, uff, my in laws were very pushy about _the_ ring and how expensive it should be (my SIL even volunteering to buy one for us). I'm kinda bummed out how society still expects this from people. I still got myself a fake one to take to wedding related stuff.

  • @christinadrawz9470
    @christinadrawz9470 Před měsícem

    i dunno, after seeing the movie Blood Diamond, i've been looking at diamonds in a different light. if you know u know

  • @knepri
    @knepri Před měsícem

    YES.

  • @pull_up_the_roots
    @pull_up_the_roots Před 2 měsíci +1

    100% yes. Don't even need to watch the video for that answer. Your money is probably better spent on a nice vacation somewhere, IMO.

  • @idakarlsson5172
    @idakarlsson5172 Před měsícem

    I want an iron ring, or a silver+wood ring.

  • @KatieT97
    @KatieT97 Před měsícem

    When my husband was thinking about proposing we went to look at rings to give him an idea of what I liked. The lady at the jewelry store first led me to diamond rings of course and the cheapest one was $6000. My husband eventually proposed with a white gold ring with amethyst and small diamond accents that was only $700 plus a free ruby pendant.

  • @nicoletim8095
    @nicoletim8095 Před měsícem

    I got my birthstone. I have an emerald. 😊 My now husband got it in Mazatlan near where it was mined.

  • @chelseashamim9148
    @chelseashamim9148 Před měsícem

    My ring is amethyst 😊

  • @Emma-hf4zf
    @Emma-hf4zf Před měsícem

    Just go for gold. white or yellow. You're buying something that's actually precious and doesn't depreciate in value over time.

  • @rinderanh
    @rinderanh Před měsícem

    Thanks for the education

  • @laurasilvera3766
    @laurasilvera3766 Před měsícem

    In Uruguay, where I live, engagement rings aren’t really a thing… You just talk with your BF/GF and decide if you want to get married and start planning the event… Most ppl that get engagement rings it’s because on North American media influence, and diamonds are Not the stone of choice, cubic zirconia for clear and emerald, ruby and sapphire for colored stones.

  • @mmps18
    @mmps18 Před 2 měsíci

    Yes.

  • @cba7873
    @cba7873 Před měsícem

    Always have been

  • @YearofShakespeare
    @YearofShakespeare Před 2 měsíci +1

    I heard that a good quality engagement ring could be sold by the bride to make up for the bride’s family’s incurred costs for the wedding if the groom backed out. If the bride backed out, she needed to send back the ring and her family swallowed the wedding costs. So it’s like earnest money that the groom will see this engagement through. I didn’t watch the video, so maybe she addresses this

  • @TheWickedMerman
    @TheWickedMerman Před 2 měsíci

    My fiancée didn't help pick out her engagement ring because I wanted it to be a surprise. Thankfully, I do know her taste very well. I actually got it from this online place called Juyoyo. The band is thin and twisted, the main stone is a moonstone, it has little diamonds beside the main stone, and it's rose gold. Me and my fiancée aren't conventional, so I didn't go with the typical gold and honestly, I think rose gold looks prettier than silver or gold. She brags about the ring (And the fact that it makes her happy makes me happy), and we're having a fairytale-themed wedding (Because there's no way I'm dressing like a butler for my wedding like all the other men in this world) and the colors of the wedding are rose gold, pink, gold, and a bit of white. She said that she planned her color palette to match her rose gold ring. When I saw the ring I just knew that it was her and that's why I got it. It was about 1,000 something dollars (I promise that a good number of Juyoyo's rings are more fairly priced) but the fact that it made her so happy made it worth it for me.