Chemist Ranks Reddit's Top Skincare Products
VloĆŸit
- Äas pĆidĂĄn 30. 05. 2024
- I tried to put Reddit's most discussed skincare products on /r/skincareaddiction into a (highly subjective) tier list - I thought this would be a fun, quick chatty video but it turned into a bit of a rabbit hole! (That seems to happen a lot đŹ)
đ€đ PRE-ORDER MY BOOK: The Science of Beauty geni.us/TheScienceOfBeauty
Subscribe for videos every fortnight: bit.ly/labmuffinyt
List: www.looria.com/reddit/skincar...
Powered By Chemicals Mugs: labmuffin.com/shop/
đđ» I'm Michelle, a chemistry PhD, cosmetic chemist and science educator, here to explain how beauty products work, debunk myths, and help you make smarter decisions about your skincare, hair and makeup!
Blog labmuffin.com
Instagram / labmuffinbeautyscience
Facebook / labmuffin
Twitter / labmuffin
TikTok / labmuffinbeautyscience
âš Want smooth, glowing skin? Grab a copy of my FREE Essential Guide to Exfoliation! labmuffin.com/exfol
𧎠PRODUCTS (affiliate links)
Cerave Hydrating Facial Cleanser: go.shopmy.us/p-936405
Cerave Moisturizing Cream: go.shopmy.us/p-936406
Cerave Foaming Facial Cleanser: go.shopmy.us/p-936407
Cerave Healing Ointment: go.shopmy.us/p-936408
Cerave Renewing Sa Cleanser: go.shopmy.us/p-936409
Cosrx Advanced Snail 96 Mucin Power Essence: go.shopmy.us/p-936410
Paula's Choice Skin Perfecting 2% BHA Liquid Exfoliant: go.shopmy.us/p-936411
The Ordinary Niacinamide 10% + Zinc 1%: go.shopmy.us/p-936412
The Ordinary Hyaluronic Acid 2% + B5: go.shopmy.us/p-936414
Neutrogena Hydro Boost Water Gel: go.shopmy.us/p-936415
La Roche-Posay Cicaplast Baume B5: go.shopmy.us/p-936417
The Ordinary Glycolic Acid 7% Toning Solution: go.shopmy.us/p-936419
Cetaphil Gentle Skin Cleanser: go.shopmy.us/p-936420
Shop more of my favourite products here: shopmy.us/labmuffin
Powered By Chemicals Mugs: labmuffin.com/shop/
đș RELATED POSTS AND VIDEOS
Free exfoliation guide labmuffin.com/free-guide
Busting cleansing myths: âą Washing Your Face Wron...
How my skincare routine changed: âą My Skincare Routine: 2...
Best and Worst of The Ordinary: âą Best and Worst of The ...
Top sunscreen recommendations 2022: âą Top Sunscreen Recommen...
Easy DIY vitamin C serum: âą Easy (5 Minute) DIY Vi...
Every sunscreen question answered: âą Every Sunscreen Questi...
Busting haircare myths - build-up, silicones: âą Busting hair care myth...
Do you need sunscreen indoors? âą Do You Need to Wear Su...
How to reapply sunscreen over makeup: âą How to Reapply Sunscre...
Clean beauty is a myth: âą Clean Beauty Is a Scam...
Korean skincare favourites: âą I tried influencers' K...
Matter of Factâs impressively bad skincare science: âą Impressively Bad Skinc...
𧎠SKINCARE GUIDE 𧎠Find out more: labmuffin.com/skin - Jak na to + styl
As both an Aussie and a uni student I really appreciate how much you care about the cost of products. That's a huge factor in decision making for me!
There is no proof that more expensive products are better. Literally zero. It's just marketing and spin by people connected to the skincare industry, including some dermatologists who are paid stooges.
When the science isn't there, follow the money.
You should talk about fermented skincare (galactomyces, bĂfida, sacaromyces)
Yes i would like to listen to her opinion on fermented skincare
I would LOVE to hear her opinion on them because I am considering purchasing some because I have issues with hydrationâŠbut if it I just a gimmick, Lab Muffin would say so!
Yes! I asked about bifida a couple of videos ago.
It would be interesting assuming she hasn't covered it in some of her k-beauty videos. I know I've heard derms recommend some products like in essences.
@@KellyBurnett138 if you're anything like me, fermented ingredients will dry you out like nothing else. I tried the Secret Key rose essence and at the end of the first day of use, the skin around my nose and mouth was peeling off. I felt like a snake.
One thing I've been burned with recently in skincare is marketing not being clear about which cleansers can remove makeup (including waterproof mascara) and which just clean your face from a sunscreen only day. It's all labelled as (oil, gel, foaming etc) cleanser!
Any tips on how to tell them apart would be great
I got stuck in this but itâs pretty simple actually, any oil based cleanser such as an oil or balm cleanser remove makeup because makeup tends to be oil based and water canât remove oil micellar is also included even though itâs water based because of the particular structure of micelles can move oils. Sunscreeen only days u only need a water based cleanser since most sunscreen are water based .
@@heylol2667 alot of sunscreen are water resistant now so i think what cleanser you use can depend on how many layers and reapplications you put on
@@CJ-up7pn I forgot that, thx
Oil cleanser clean the best, especially for sunblock and makeup. I use it as a double cleanse.
The one time I used CeraVe (a cleanser and a moisturizer) I understood how fragrance free products can actually irritate the F out of your skin, while some fragranced products can work just fine.
Same! For some reason CeraVe always irritates my skin so much, whereas many fragranced products do not.
@@zoyarockjet Idea for a video : Ranking high end skincare products. Just to watch a video about skincare with zero mention of this **** brand.
Well, of course. Fragrance isn't the only potential irritant, it's just one of those ingredients that has a risk of irritation with little to no benefit for our skin (it's added for user experience and/or product stability). There have been a few CeraVe products that have irritated my skin, as well as products from Eucerin, Vanicream, and La Roche Posay (all of the big names in sensitive skincare). Avoiding fragrance is a generally good idea because we can develop sensitivities and allergies to it, and it can increase the irritation potential of other ingredients, but ANY product (fragranced or not) can be irritating. Including fragrance is a choice, and it's not worth it for me, but might be worth it for others for the sensorial pleasure.
I think itâs because they use such cheap ingredients in their products. I can not use any cerave products besides the healing ointment without my skin becoming inflamed and itchy.
@@quinlantaylor04 Just because something is affordable, fragrance free and in a big bottle - which make any dermatologist swoon it seems, doesnât mean itâs good⊠(Outside of the US, CeraVe isnât even that affordable.)
Fun video. More like this plz.
Neutrogena does make a fragrance free version of the hydro boost product you showed, I believe itâs the same one. Itâs marketed for extra dry skin
I think that's the gel cream rather than the water gel, which is lighter in texture - they're in the same looking jar though, and there's a good chance Looria mixed up the two as well! I don't know why brands do this đ©
@@LabMuffinBeautyScience I have used both the water gel and gel cream (in the UK this is) and they pretty much smell exactly the same, i use the water gel in the summer and gel cream in the winter for my oily skin. both pretty fragrance free and I don't like really fragranced things just my preference as I prefer neutral smells - so maybe they have different formulations in the UK
â@@georgiesuttonart I've tried both versions of hydro boost too (in Canada, if that matters). The water gel triggered my allergies (sneezing, itchy eyes) while the gel cream didn't, so I used the gel cream for a while even though I have combination skin, not extra dry skin. To me the gel cream smells kind of like the water gel but not as strong. Other than the fragrance I found them very similar, but the gel cream did feel a little bit more hydrating in my opinion. (I stopped using it after about a year because I discovered that Cerave PM lotion works a lot better for me.)
@@LabMuffinBeautyScience even Neutrogena mixes them up. I tried to order the gel cream once and received the water gel đ
@@LabMuffinBeautyScience ahhh. I was wondering if it was the case if looks/sounds the same but is actually different! Hence the âI believe itâs the same one.â I was like surely she must know this with a skincare channel!
I could watch you talk about skincare forever! Youâre so knowledgeable, you make skincare chemistry so accessible, and youâre an Aussie so I can actually purchase the stuff you recommend. Love your channel
Hi Michelle. After you mentioned it, I went and watched your video on cleanser myths. Watching your vids has made me realise a lot of the criteria I used to use to ID products to avoid isn't grounded in science. I'd love to see a vid from you saying what info you look out for in products to decide what to avoid buying. Thanks.
@@Make_AWish That's awesome to know, thanks đ
As someone who never wants Halloween time to end, Iâm appreciating your jumper.
It's awesome!
I wonder where it's from, I want one too!
When she moved ordinary glycolic to holy grail at 18:21 , I was so satisfied. Itâs my go to for feet and back of arms KP.
It's so freaking budget-friendly!
I really need to try this for my KP
@@LabMuffinBeautyScience I know, I like the whole brand for this reason. I've actually been wanting to try out their lactic acid serum since my skin seems to like AHAs and that one seems to work the best for me. I also really liked using their Hylauronic acid serum but my only mild gripe is that it does feel a bit sticky.
@@rhifri4398 Use it in combination with salicylic acid, and some kind of hyperpigmentation treatment. I cycle between glycolic, Topicals faded, and salicylic acid, paying attention not to overdo the acids to avoid sensitivity. Best of luck.
I want to try the ordinary so much but here in my country is super expensiveđą
Michelle, you are THE BEST! I seriously love your content. Super interesting and to the point. You deserve so much success!
Omg I am doing a marathon of your videos! Such great content in a way that is positive and informative but still very authentic. Bravo for sharing, keeping it real, and not being a Debbie downer! Thanks for bringing down these long chemical names down to earth. Bravo!
To be fair, I think the sensory experience/enjoyment of using a skincare product matters to most people, regardless of whether they're looking for it to be "effective" or not. People who use plain/boring, fragrance-free products like Cerave or Cetaphil don't necessarily "not care" what the products smell or feel like on their skin, it could for instance just mean that they have super sensitive noses and detest all fragrances (like yours truly, lol đ)
I'm a scent junkie (can't live without a puff or two everyday and ever part of my area has a plugin or diffuser). I don't do scented skincare or makeup because I don't want any other scent upstaging my SOTD on my body.
Weirdly I LOOOOVE the experience of the basic Cetaphil cleanser. My skin feels so clean and it feels like a milky massage. To be fair I have dry skin so a lot of other cleansers leave my skin feeling stripped.
Same, I use unscented stuff pretty much wherever I can (except dental products; I do like mintiness) because bathrooms are usually bath/shower + toilet in the same room, and I end up associating any cleanser or soap smell with a âbathroom smellâ
Yeah I really hate scented or "sensory" skincare. It feels like your paying for unnecessary premium for them to markup more the product. You can add your own perfume after skincare. Skincare means for me is going for healthy and practical way. It's like drinking fresh unadulterated water and not getting juice or soda. Makes me feel good that I'm doing something healthy rather than guilty pleasure.
@@trawrtster6097 Haha, that's such a great expression, "bathroom smell". đMy problem is that most fragrances, no matter how "fresh" or fruity" or whatever they claim to be, smell artificial to me. They have this weird, sharp, chemical undertone that makes them smell completely fake and nothing like the fruit or flower they're trying to emulate. So, fragrance free it is. đ€·ââ
Thanks Michelle! I always learn so much from your videos! I love how you have such clear and helpful explanations even on videos with a different theme like this ranking video
Here in the US (not sure about other parts of the world), thereâs actually a fragrance and dye free version of the Neutrogena hydro boost named âgel cream extra dry,â and itâs personally one of my holy grails. Itâs very hydrating and has just enough occlusives to keep my dry-leaning skin happy. The texture is amazing, and itâs one of the only moisturizers Iâve tried that sits nicely with my facial hair
this is, like, the most useful video I have seen in a long time, no bs, just useful information, thanks!
I have naturally oily skin, so I'm not a fan of slugging as well. Cerave healing ointment is a holy grail for me as a lip balm, for rough dryp spots (hands, elbows, knees), and open wounds. It's probably my most used product among this list, then again, none of the usage is on my face so that begs the question of how skincare is defined. Loved the information and the video!
Iâve always gone back and forth with the Cerave Hydrating Cleanser, wanting to like it because it seems so popular, but everytime I use it I get thisâŠtingling/burning feeling?? Which Iâm confused by because Iâd assume itâs gentle. So lately I just stick to a basic, gentle oil cleanser in the morning to break up and wash off the layer of crusted oil on my face lol
I feel the exact same way!!! I keep forgetting it does that and will go back to it if something else irritates my skin.... And then I'm like "Wtf, why did I use this again?" đ Also switched to just using an oil cleanser for double cleansing instead for the moisture đ
I had that problem and found out I'm allergic to one of its ingredients đ
They changed the formula. The previous formula for me didn't give me that feeling. This new one though I can't use and had to find another product instead.
@@lf2659 it was amazing for my skin before since it's so dry and what you're saying makes so much more sense to me now! đ
@@jakeh6977 Yes I like to buy in bulk so I had a old one I was using up. Then one day it just started to burn my face I was like why then I checked the packaging and realised that the formulas had changed and had to get rid of a full bottle of it.
I think it'd be awesome if you did videos on skincare ranges by brand - not necessarily testing them, but just what you can see based on their claims and ingredients!
So that's why your picks and topics are so familiar to me! I was following beauty subreddits around the same time.
I think you were right on with your rankings. Thanks for your content.
Thanks Michelle. You're a great source of information!
Neutrogena HydroBoost does have a fragrance free version. It is for Extra Dry skin. But it is actually not that much different from the one that is for oily skin (with fragrance), so I always bought the one for extra dry skin. It is really a great moisturizer.
The cerave moisturizing cream causing closed comedones just made me realize thatâs why I have so many on my forehead!
Iâve used both of the Cerave pm and daily moisturizers. Didnât like either. The pm just stayed on top of my face- feeling wasnât good in the morning. The daily was alright, nothing to yell about. Iâve used many of Paulaâs choice. Very good for most. Still have a tub Iâm trying to get through of the Cerave. I really enjoy you sharing these and all your knowledge behind the products! Thank- you so much! A very Happy New and Healthy Year to you!đ
The cerave moisturizing lotion is my holy holy holy grail. It treated my dyshidrotic eczema really well when I wanted to move away form using hydrocortisone creams, I got a really bad reaction on my lips from the cerave lotion and the cream healed it (in combination with petroleum jelly), and anytime I get dry patches or chafing around my nose that heals it quickly. Although it's a thick cream, it doesn't look shiny or greasy at all, it looks matte, which surprised me big time because thick creams are always greasy. I love it.
My recent absolutely abhorrent skin situation (retinoids, woohoo) had me browse reddit for hours as well, so this video could not have come at a better time!đ
Oh god, I love this channel. You are such a good teacher; perfect balance of education and entertainment! Speaking of CeraVe, I would love if you did a deep dive into ceramides in skincare. I've heard a lot of mixed information about the ratio of ceramides: cholesterol: fatty acids that's needed to be effective in skincare. I've seen some studies that ceramides in the majority of products don't do anything (either too low a concentration or incorrect ratios), and if they're not in the right ratio, might actually do more harm than good.
I agree with you on CeraVe products being boring and kind of joyless to use. I've also just accepted that I enjoy at least a little bit of foam in my cleansers and the hydrating cleanser is so unsatisfying to use. To me, this partly explains the popularity of Asian skincare: you get the affordable price point and products geared toward soothing and skin health but a more fun user experience. Also, the cosmetic elegance of Asian products is just a cut above what you get in most American drugstores.
On the topic of niacinamide and irritation (along with other single ingredients or ingredient groups people tend to label as irritating or comedogenic), something I think about a lot is the time someone on SCA blamed their severe eye irritation on petrolatum, but the product they used had peppermint oil in it.
Is it the ingredient on the label/at the top of the ingredient list/demonised by clean beauty, or is it the ingredient with high known irritation risk?
That's so cool you were a monitor on there. I'd love a similar video for the Reddit Asian beauty skincare thread as well
The CeraVe foaming cleanser is my most purchased skincare product of all time. I will never be without it. I find it to be one of the most hydrating foaming cleansers on the market. Even more than the Vanicream cleanser which I also love
I actually had my skin barrier damaged after trying CeraVe foaming cleanser, and healed it with Vanicream cleanser. This just shows that skincare is so individual...
youâre so right!!! iâll never buy a different cleanser again since i started using the cerave foaming cleanser, i love it so much
It burns my eyesđ
close ur eyes when you wash ur face and make sure to get off all the soap before opening them again hope this helps !!!
Same. I've tried lots of cleansers and keep going back to cerave foaming. It gets all the dirt and make-up off without damaging my skin barrier. Foams perfectly and feels amazing.
I love love love that sweater. It is perrrrfect in every way
For me, the first product that I felt like I saw myself with noticeably clearer skin was Differen Gel. I was worried because I saw that it can cause purging when you first start using it, however I didn't experience that problem. I want to try out Paulina BHA soon.
the Cerave foaming cleanser is definitly the product i cant go without, i have normal to oily skin and it always leaves my skin smooth and soft, and its affordable. very interesting to hear so many people react to it differently tho, really goes to show theres no such thing as a one size fits all product :)
Girl, you are the best! Thank you for the video
Spot on yet again Muffin! It took me two years into my skin care journey to disabuse myself of the myth that "foaming cleansers are harsh" across the board. My skin is more resilient now and my favs are either Rovectin Foaming Cleanser or the new Ordinary Foaming Cleanser after, of course an oil or balm first step cleanse. PS: The Ordinary HA Serum I am using up on the ends of moist hair...locks in moisture nicely...then won't repurchase as it is redundant.
What a great video! I love hearing your thoughts.
i'm using the cerave Hydrating Cream-to-Foam Cleanser, yea it isn't the nicest in terms of smell, but it cleans makeup, sunscreen, face really well & its value bottles are pretty affordable
10:47 Sums up my experience using the Paula's Choice 2% BHA. After a while, I realised that keeping it on my face ended up just making my face quite itchy, which in turn led to me scratching it, which in turn led to more acne.
The salacilic acid cleanser, on the other hand, ended up being what I needed.
Thanks for shouting out, Tiara Willis and her use of the term Glazed Donut. I enjoy using CeraVe Healing ointment during the winter or on nights, I need to repair my skincare barrier from irritation.
I've been a fan of Paula's Choice Skin Perfecting 2% BHA for years but I started looking for an alternative when they kept raising the price. Finally, I found one with Naturium BHA 2% Liquid. I've been using it for 2 years and l love the formula and results.
This is so informative! Iâm currently trying to work out a new skincare system as there is something pilling and itâs making me crazy!
the chemical smell from cerave foaming cleanser is so true! the moisturizer has that smell too
I used that Cerave cleanser 4 years until it started drying out my skin, I don't know if they changed the formula or what .
Now I use the Cetaphil one and I love it. My skin is very dry but not overly sensitive and I prefer cheaper cleansers and spend more on the other stuff
Yes! Me too, Iâm so glad I wasnât just going crazy. I had to switch up my entire skincare routine because it wasnât doing what it used to.
Same! I go super basic on the cleansers since you wash them off anyways⊠and then I invest $80 once every 6 months on a retinoid đ
When do you think they changed it? Iâve recently been dealing with dry skin when this cleanser used to be my holy grail and noticeably reduced my dry skin
I canât believe I forgot you were a mod on SCA! 2014 really was a peak year for the beauty community on Reddit, lol. MakeupAlley is such a great throwback, too! I still check their reviews, even though they arenât quite as active as they were about a decade ago.
The hydrating cleanser from CeraVe remains an all-time holy grail cleanser for me. I could never get into the tub because my skin doesnât like petrochemicals (too occlusive for me, I guess). The lotion and salicylic acid cleanser, though, are fantastic for my body during the summer. Paulaâs Choice 2% BHA used to be my holy grail, but I switched to the COSRx version a few years ago and prefer it. Iâve used the Ordinaryâs niacinamide serum for a few years now, and itâs effective (the zinc is especially good for my rosacea), but itâs definitely not pleasant to use, so Iâm experimenting with other niacinamide serums nowadays. I have the older version of the Cicaplast balm and have enjoyed it. I still love me some hyaluronic acid, but I prefer Indeed Labs or the Inkey List to the Ordinary. I agree with you, though: nowadays, since hyaluronic acid is in so many products, it feels redundant to use a separate serum for it. Iâm trying out Great Barrier Relief to try to get both niacinamide and hyaluronic acid in one go rather than in separate products.
I loved this video concept!
I love the CeraVe PM for a regular daytime moisturizer for days I don't leave the apartment/need sun protection!
And their retinol in the packaging with purple accents is a lovely starter retinol nice and gentle but still works hard the way a retinol should!
I LOOOOOVE the vanicream daily facial moisturizer. It is so good and such an elevated formula for no reason. Its such a beautiful texture. It feels very lightweight but it is so moisturizing. It has a natural to glowy finish. It doesnât feel greasy or look wet/oily.
Love this video!! I have used a lot of these products. I love the CeraVe Hydrating creamy face wash. The Neutrogena Hydro boost does have a fragrance free version- it says "extra dry" on the packaging.
Great video! Thank you! Iâm convinced Iâm on right way in my skin care routine
I actually really enjoy the sensory experience of the Cerave hydrating cleanser, (for an unscented product) it feels really nice! Also wierdly I find the Cerave lotion more moisturising that the tub one, it goes on so light but my skin feels more moisturised a few minutes later (must be those vesicles!) I think my skin loves the glycerine in their products
I was actually really surprised with your review of the SA cleanser from CV. It's one of my everyday go-tos and I never notice any drying effect unless I don't put moisturizer on after (as with most cleansing products) and have only noticed a faint smell to it. My skin leans towards the dry side, so I was taken aback by the comments.
A tier list for each group of product based on principal active ingredients please!!
++++
I'm one of those unfortunates who can't do any niacinamide (haven't even tried The Ordinary's version), and the Cetaphil oily skin cleanser was the only one that worked for me. So I'm devastated that they reformulated
Have you tried the neutrogena hydro boost gel cleanser? I think they have one which is gentle and without niacinamide.
Iâve seen a lot of dermatologists say niacinamide in concentration over 5% are likely to be irritating! So personally I wouldnât use The Ordinary Niacinamide Serum.
Oh my god... I didn't realise they reformulated. I stopped using a while ago on my face cause its too harsh in combination with my hard water but I kept been using it to clean my glasses since it's still pretty gentle. I've had a breakout on my eyebrows for a while and couldn't figure it out. This has got to be it. I'm going to have to do a test... and find a new soap-free cleanser for my glasses lol. Also I second 07miagirl's suggestion for the hydroboost cleanser. I get the fragrance free and it is very nice for my oily, sensitive skin.
@@07miagirl I definitely will give it a go, this will help me get over my "Neutrogena burned my face in the 90s" trauma đ
@@cassh1280 I get them on my temples and around my eyes, maybe our foreheads are especially susceptible đ
Thanks for seconding the Neutrogena suggestion, I too am oily and sensitive
Oh my god, Makeup Alley, that was an unexpected blast from the past. I spent soo many hours on those forums.
Great video :) I absolutely love your Halloween sweater!
I was the biggest fan of the CeraVe foaming cleanser but I switched to the hydrating cream-to-foam cleanser. I love a foaming cleanser but I do like the creamy hydrating cleanser, so this is the best of both.
into 5 seconds to the video and I AM IN LOVE WITH YOUR SWEATER đ
Haha thank you! It's from an Australian company called Black Milk
@@LabMuffinBeautyScience I LOVE BLACK MILK I bought the moon phases robe from them and I'm still in awe of it, never bought anything like it. You're so lucky to have it near you! Thankfully for me, the Australian and Canadian dollar are pretty close lol
I donât consider myself acne-prone and I have normal to dry skin, definitely not oily, but the Cerave Moisturising Cream caused me a ton of closed comedones. I literally had to google what it was, because breakouts like that werenât a thing for me before. Now I'm scared of trying any new moisturisers and apparently the term ânon-comedogenicâ is an inaccurate dumpster fire.
The same thing happened to me when I started using the daily moisturizer for dry to normal skin from cetaphil. My skin is not fully back to normal but itâs getting better after switching to using lighter water gel moisturizers; currently trying aveeno oat gel moisturizer. Only problem is this and other products with a similar texture (like neutrogena hydro boost) seem to come in 1.7oz tiny jars that cost 20 usd. Iâm still looking for more budget friendly version.
This also happened to me using their moisturizer but after one or two weeks if was gone. It happens to me with every new product I try as I have sensitive skin.
I was apart of that group of people that broke out with The Ordinaryâs niacinamide serum, so Iâve been scared of niacinamide since. I think I might the ingredient another shot after hearing that it might just be the product! I believe i was also using it when it was expired, so that mustâve also been a factor of the sudden flare of pimples. I also want to try the Paulaâs Choice product mentioned! Great video :)
Hey! How did that go for you, assuming you have tried a different niacinamide product? The ordinary's serum broke me out too and haven't tried niacinamide ever since...
id honestly love to see a dry skin version of this but everyone seems to have oily skin ;-;
Old comment, but regardless,
I have combo, some dry spots some oily, so jump between recs and actives for both, but I also have VERY dry eczema prone hands. The biggest thing that makes a difference for dryness is simple.
Oils.
Actual ones.
Not petroleum. Not more glycerin. Not silicones. Not more HAs and hydrating ingredient. I dont need more occlusion or water.
I. Need. Oil.
Maybe some esters in a pinch, but not preferred.
There are still fragrance free moisturizers with oils higher in the formula on the market, and if you're down bad, mix some extra oils with your moisturizer and use that. Or add a layer of straight oil as your last step.
Works wonders.
I'm a simple gal, so safflower or sunflower are nice, jojoba is good but more expensive, and I've used straight canola on my skin in a pinch (mostly if I'm cooking and using my hands. I legit can't touch water without needing to moisturize after, so, food grade canola oil. It workes.)
nah u ve oily skin mainly because u r a girl.
@@rosieweaves99 Thank you!! Gonna do this with coconut oil (already using it for my hair anyways)
As someone with fairly oily skin, I was kinda forgot that the CeraVe healing ointment is used for slugging. I have never tried slugging, and due to the mess it could cause and the possibility of making my face feel suffocated in product, I doubt I will ever try it. But, I adore the ointment for saving my super chapped lips and for protecting my cuticles, since I work with my hands a lot.
14:39 I used the Cetaphil Gentle Skin Cleanser right before and right after the reformulation. The change in appearance from whiteish to clear confused me quite a bit, because all their product labels look so similar, but I was certain I bought the same one!
Both versions were âmehâ on my face, but the newer one is slowly getting used up as my second-in-command body soap for when I need something gentler.
Unfortunately I am one of the few that react badly to the Cosrx snail mucin, I have never ever had any acne from a product until I tried this! So many small closed comedones, and in places where I usually never get acne (my forehead). Just goes to show you how people react differently to products, even "holy grail" products
I have combination skin and I found that it gives me closed comedones on my forehead (which is more normal/oily) but is a holy grail product for the bottom half of my face (the very dry half) and where I get hormonal acne! So I only use it on the bottom half now and I love it
@@amyeddelman does that mean you're two faced? /j
I love when my biases are confirmed. đ I hate the CereVe Hydrating Cleanser. It made my skin break out like crazy.
cerave cleansers are HGs for me, both as facial cleansers and shower gel. I have very flaky combination skin on my face and they get rid of that mess. I just can't leave it on my face for long, otherwise it starts burning, especially around my lips. I have all 3 presented in this video and use the one that feels appropriate for different body parts on different days
Thank you, excellent content!
Love this ranking system! Just need to switch around the colours ;)
No one asked but I thought it's nice too see if anybody used the same products as me. These are my holy grail rn:
1. Laneige deep cleanser (so good, effective, non drying, really good price).
2. Rice Water - I'm From (long lasting hydration and it cleansed up my clumped pores).
3. Vitamin Tree Gel Moisturizer - I'm From (not too occlusive, hydrating enough. Good under makeup. Acne prone skin friendly. Good for lips too!)
4. Cerave Retinol (for night) - not sure about this, too mild I barely notice any improvement. But definitely safe.
5. Etude Sunprise mineral sunscreen (plan to switch to cosrx, I used to love Sunprise but it dries my forehead skin sm now).
Sorry for broken English.
Edit: after weeks, I start to notice some improvement on under eye wrinkle ..so I kinda like the Cerave retinol now.
your english is really good!
@@hotpotato1898 thankyou
Hello! We use the same sunscreen and I have very oily/acne-prone skin and it helps to regulate the sebum production :) do you have normal/dry skin?
@@chococat3972 mine is combination, nowadays my forehead is a bit dry ...so that's why
I still canât believe they discontinued the laneige cleanser đđđ
I only use the snail mucin after procedures that irritate my skin like dermaplanning, peel off masks, and waxing. It's so much more soothing than any aloe product
Oh I actually use the fragrance free water gel! I find the perfume in the normal one irritates my skin but the fragrance free one is just what works â€
I love the cera ve healing ointment. Not that much for me, but for my son. Itâs winter here and I started to see that his face turned red after being outside and had a rough feeling. Since Iâm putting this cream on his face before he goes to bed or outside the problem has stopped. This product is not available where I live so I had to order it from Amazon. It turned out to be rather pricey but it lasts forever and Iâm not complaining đ
Omg I am so glad I watched this. I had been using the the tub cereve and wondering why even though my skin looked better it wasnât clearâŠ
That Neutrogena gel cream does have a fragrance free option
Yes, and it's one of Dr. Dray's favorites.. đđ
She talked about the water gel, not the gel cream, theyâre different products, although the packaging is almost identical
Cerave has a cream to foam cleanser now and I find it to be a better version of the foaming cleanser. Less drying and doesn't contain niacinamide, which unfortunately never works well for me.
This was such a good and interesting video idea!!
The Neutrogena Hydroboost does come fragrance free in the Extra Dry version, which is also more moisturizing!
I have just gotten into skincare past my very few safe products. I know it might be trash but I've been using clean & clear's step 3 moisturizer since 2012 because for years everything made my skin so much worse. Just started branching out and tried out the ordinary's lactic acid. I've been getting dry patches even with moisturizing and cleansing- this stuff has been a dream. I look forward to adding more and trying out things from the ordinary + CeraVe( started using the cleanser in 2019). Once something doesn't mess with my skin, I become quite brand loyal. I'd like to get into more Korean skin care (Korean beauty was for a long time the only make up I could use with my undertone + not angering my skin). I look forward to watching your clean beauty video!
I love your BM shirt!!! I have the purple one, it's so comfy and cute
That was such an interesting trivia you shared abt your moderator experience in the past. I still lurk in Asianbeauty and a few other subreddits(not much on skincareaddiction though) that have really added value to my consumption choices, or lack of.
I also visit makeupalley, another place I go to for unbiased feedback where I can filter comments. I wish there were even more sites like these now, but they seemed to have been forgotten/overlooked now.
Just me walking down memory lane, lol. I would like to request a video, or even just a short, on makeup/skincare hybrids. Is there actual science or just another marketing scheme? What works, where to focus instead. Because like what skincareaddiction members prefer, I would like a streamlined routine(both skincare and makeup) that is efficient and gives best value for money.
I loved the "filter by skin type" function on MakeupAlley!
That's a good idea for a short, thank you! I'll add it to the list...
MakeupAlley is the best! An absolute goldmine for no-nonsense beauty recommendations.
I also used to love makeup alley - good memories! I also loved, and regularly referred to, beautypedia (by Paula Begoun) until recently. Devastated that theyâve changed it and got rid of all the reviews đ©
The Neutrogena hydro boost moisturizer for dry skin is fragrance free and I haven't personally compared the two versions, but I have heard people say they are the same formulation except for the fragrance. I am very oily and I use the dry version without fragrance and it works great, so it's worth a shot.
i've been using the bar cleanser version of the CeraVe Foaming Cleanser, and it has that nice yummy relaxing skincare scent without being chock full of fragrance đ Maybe you'd like it more than the liquid (I do). I had actually posted about it on Reddit recently so it's funny you made this video now. One other product I would add as holy grail is the Cetaphil Redness Relieving Night Moisturizer
Those both sound great, thank you for the recommendations!
I had no idea cerave had a bar cleanser! Any chance if you know if they are sold in Australia?
The Cerave hydrating cleanser bar is my favourite cleanser of all time!! It foams nicely but it's so gentle, so effective, smells so clean and creates much less waste than the big plastic bottles!
@@Wthhybl1 not sure sorry, I'm in the US. I checked Chemists warehouse and Amazon australia, but didn't see it. You may need to import it, or I'm sure there's an alternative!
@@katemckate Yes! Aside from the lower price compared to the liquid, reducing my plastic consumption was one of my main reasons to try it. And I would have never guessed the hydrating version foams! That's great, but for my oily skin I gotta stick with the foaming cleanser for sure lol.
I live in Canada and lived in the United States previously. The Neutrogena hydroboost is available in fragrance free and the Cerave hydrating cleanser now exists in a foaming version.
I agree about CeraVe, there's not a lot of fun to it but for me this past transition season between summer and fall, I was finding every face wash and moisturizer was upsetting my skin and making me incredibly red. I turned to the cera ve cleanser (for the first time) and Avenes aqua gel, and my face is both extremely soothed and smoothed â€ïž
The Cerave PM lotion is my favorite! I use it during the day and I have combination skin so itâs just perfect. I pray they never change the formula.
actually there is a fragrance free option for Neutrogena hydro boost cream just look for the one that extra dry skin for the unscented one but im not sure if they do sell it in other countries thought
I think it's a slightly different formula, in the same looking jar? The gel cream is thicker, but the water gel is very light and almost like a jelly. Both are really lovely and lightweight though, and I actually prefer the gel cream!
I personally think its very similar to the cerave lotion which i prefer.
This was a great video thank you! I wasnt sure about the cica balm, but I think Im going to try it now :D
If you try it now you might run into the reformulated version cicaplast baume b5+, so this review might not apply to that one.
Iâve realized that I love my Versed dew point moisturizer
Iâd love to see a video dedicated to waterproof sunscreens, also is it easy to cry off sunscreen ?
I use The Ordinary Hyaluronic acid for makeup prep. I saw Robert Welsh recommend using a HA serum for oily skin rather than a moisturiser, so I gave it go. Can recommend. It's cheap as!
I really liked how you thought out the ranking of these! đ
I knew you where at sca but im unsure if i knew you where a mod. I started slowely stopping going there in 2019 and unsubbed it completely in the beginning under lock down, so it was a short time from starting at 2018, I wished I was there earlier bc it felt a much better forum before it hit the 1 million subscribers marks.
Thank you! I was most active around 2014-2016 - I agree, it was more fun when it felt like there was more of a community! There was also a lot of intense moderation work to get it to be like that too (mostly deleting posts where someone asked a question that would only be relevant to them, and telling them to post it in the daily question thread), but it was a lot of work and it was pretty boring!
10:07 I broke out from the Ordinary Niacinamide serum. Like a couple HUGE cystic type breakouts, which is uncommon for me. I was talking to someone about it and they said that it's not the niacinamide but the zinc in this serum! That makes a lot of sense to me since niacinamide is in so many products now and I've been fine, but not with zinc.
Aw the makeup alley days! I also used to read beautypedia often (in particular the comments). Good times, Sephulta reviews just donât compare in terms of helpfulness
Totally agree on the glycolic toner. Would have done the exact same shuffle as itâs fine imo but truthfully, nothing else in that price range comes close
I also used to love makeup alley - good memories! I also loved, and regularly referred to, beautypedia (by Paula Begoun) until recently. Devastated that theyâve changed it and got rid of all the reviews đ©
Beautypedia was my jam..then I became an esthetician â€ïžđ
After ceraVe changed their formulas I noticed it would irritate my skin. Especially if I used an active. It never used to do that. Another influencer mentioned the same experience and discontinued use as did I. La Roche Posay all the way for me.
it would be interesting to have one on the top olive young korea products!
hydroboost did nothing for my skin and made my skin look very pigmented red, like it was irritated but i felt no irritation. cerave cleansers confuse me because most of them target sensitive/dry skin but always dry me out,or make my skin irritated.
i currently use loreal revitalift hydro/moisturizing cream, laroche posay SPF 60 sunscreen and ocasionally CeraVeâs retinol resurfacing serum alongside my moisturizer and my skin has never looked more clear. the Loreal cream makes my skin look shiny but not oily, just hydrated and the sunscreen doesnât leave a weird film or make my eyes watery :)
Neutrageno gel comes in frangrance free version tooâŠits just labeled for extra dry skin
Hi Michelle,
I just found your channel, guess i've been a fan for awhile now because i used to use your blog to help me formula some of my own skincare several years ago.
Was wondering when you get the time if you can do a post about the Ordinary conflicts chart and address any inaccuracies in it. For example I always believed that Niacinamide and Ascorbic Acid is perfectly fine to combine. As far as i know the study which demonstrated Niacinamide converted to Niacin was performed in the 1970s using high heat which our faces would not be exposed to. Another conflict which I'm not so sure of is Ascorbic Acid and Matrixyl 3000 (or even copper), there's been various discussions around this with The Ordinary stating the Matrixyl peptides will hydolyse, whilst Timless informing their customers this is perfectly fine.
Thanks for all the content, keep up the great work!
I love the Ordinary glycolic acid toner. I use it daily.
I feel like you focused too much on Cereve healing ointment being used for slugging. Iâm with you, I donât really like full face slugging (feels too messy) but I LOVE the healing ointment for my hs spots, my dry, cracked lips in the winter, and protecting my eyelids when Iâm putting on adapaline. Iâm sure there are other great uses as well!
I've always used the cicaplast for healing my tattoos it works so well
Cetaphil gentle skin cleanser has been my go to for so long. I didn't realise that many people were against it lol