The sad thing is that he probably would have died happier here with his friends rather than regenerating in a moment of fear and loneliness in the last special from his original run.
God I love how Jack is a human from the future and much more knowledgable about all of this stuff and much more okay with it. Just, how he’s the one reassuring both companions, even his little “good luck doctor”. It’s just something I appreciate, a human companion who is aware and not emotionally decanted because he knows it’s natural.
Jack is a guy the doctor regenerating doesn’t affect him emotionally the way it does the two girls. Plus Jack was time agent so he probably had to learn about a lot of different alien species at the Time agency including time lords.
Well Donna didnt know what was happening, Rose did but loved 10 so this might as well be him dying. Jack not only knew but didnt have the same feelings Rose did so is just more able to accept the change
I love that too. Unlike a lot of the other companions, Jack is nearly on the same level as the Doctor in many ways. So in the Doctor’s absence or in a crisis situation, the other companions will often defer to him as the second in command.
That defeats the purpose If there was going to actually be a regeneration then everyone would've know who the new actor was, but since there wasn't no one knew.
@@doctorwhofan9426 did you understand what I was saying? My point was not that one would be better, but that it wouldn't be possible for it to be a surprise because people know the casting and shit like that
You gotta admit that after all the buildup, complete with the romantic running toward each other in the street, his nearly getting killed by a Dalek, and a successful re-regeneration, that hug was a tad anticlimactic. I was sorely disappointed that the Doctor and his long lost lady love didn't have an epic makeout moment in front of Jack, Donna and everybody. Yeah I get that RTD was saving it up for the Bad Wolf Bay scene with Ten2 but come on man I FELT CHEATED
@@SPECTRE_Madman this counted as a full regeneration. The Doctor only had twelve regenerations in his original cycle, so when he regenerated into 11 he had none left. The other regeneration was used to change into the War Doctor.
Really he only stayed the same because he finally had hope he could be with Rose again and didn’t want anything to get in the way. He loved her too much to change and risk loosing her.
This is by far the best regenerating effect to this day in entire history of the show. It looks clean, reminding more an ascension than rebirth. It's almost like birth of the star, god or any other celestial being. I'd say only Jodie's regeneration to 14th incarnation only looked as good as this one.
Realistically, the hand shouldn’t have grown into another Tenth Doctor. If you think about it, the whole point is that he used the regeneration energy to heal, but not to change-he siphoned that off into the hand. So the HAND should’ve regenerated. What I’m saying is, the hand should’ve grown into Matt Smith lmao
but he took the healing for himself and gave the hand the changing, so the hand would be Matt Smiths hand, so after the Real regeneration, the Tenth should have become 11 with 1 hand
@@adamoliver5589 Yeah, and it's also not dragged out. Tom Baker and David Tennant's regenerations were both too long, probably because they were fan favorites.
10 lived for 4 years, regenerated and kept the same face here, lived another 2 years, then regenerated again. The Doctor got real slack with holding onto regenerations near the end of their cycle apparently.
So this makes you wonder "Why doesn't the doctor cut off his hand everytime while he could still regenerate it back and then, come time to regen again just pop it into the hand?" LOL
while that could make sense their are a few problems with it not cinclding how would the first version take their hand off without healing, i mean maybe surgery but anyway. one cause gross imagine every time you regenerate oh before i do anything time to lob a limb off and two because the doctor and timelords also change their face since they see the new face as a new person and all the things they've done before are forgiven and passed off as a different person, that and it be incredibly boring being the same man or woman for 2000 years following 12's age
I don't like how he explains regeneration. Wouldn't it make more sense if he had to change or else he would die because his body is dying so he needs a new one?
Imagine if he regenerated into Matt Smith and then they wanted the old doctor back so they hit him and he regenerated and used the hand to revert back to David Tennant and then would turn into Matt Smith in The End of Time Part 2
well no but following that logic, the hand in a jar would be ten's then eleventh's and then ten's again after the Meta Crisis, while actual ten's would go from ten's to eleven's to twelve's since he put the energy from one hand into the other but it doesn't work like that anyway
God it’s so sad that the Doctor has to regenerate in a time like this… but wonder what the next series will be like- wait a second, did he just regenerate into himself???
Ok so if this is just able to happen why does the doctor just not cut off his hand every regeneration so he always has that choice of staying the same. Besides it not like it hurts him that much considering his reaction in the first debut of the tenth doctor.
This is a pretty big plothole though, because by this logic the Doctor never needs to change, he can just wait til he's healed and get rid of the remaining energy.
Well technically he should only be called the 10th because the whole the of the war doctors life he didn’t call himself doctor and only did till at the very end and that was for about 2 minutes but even if you include the war doctor, the 11th (10th) doctor didn’t change his face or personally and used a regeneration to heal himself pretty much, so hes the 11th and 12th incarnation but still only the 11th doctor
I'd like to think it's because he didn't necessarily have a reason to. Ultimately I think his love towards Rose was what drove his dislike towards change, he wanted hold on to those feelings as long as possible and maintain the hope of being with her, when that hand turned into a carbon copy of him who was able to actually live out that sort of life with rose, he kind of came to terms with the fact that as the Doctor and a true Timelord he would never have that life. I think the issues he dealt with here probably subconsciously played a role in him regenerating into someone who was more accepting of change.
Because then he would have had to steer the TARDIS with one hand. It wouldn't regrow like the first time because his regeneration process was already finished.
The first time he had already completely changed and was within the first day of his cycle where his body was still healing and such. This time he was just healing from being hit by a dalek blast and didn't want to change so the rest went to the hand. Not enough to regrow unfortunately, but would've been funny to see him copy and paste over and over
This dude really use his hand as a horcrux
He's killed enough that he can make them all he wants.
I guess it's kinda off topic but does anybody know of a good site to stream new tv shows online ?
@Luciano Kendall Thanks, I signed up and it seems like they got a lot of movies there :) I really appreciate it!
@Tadeo Jayden no problem :)
@@lucianokendall9291 Wow, these spam bots have been made smarter, they now stage retarded conversations!
The sad thing is that he probably would have died happier here with his friends rather than regenerating in a moment of fear and loneliness in the last special from his original run.
Yeah he seemed ready, there was no sadness, just ‘right, i’m regenerating’
Take note:
When your a time lord chop off your hand multiple times so you can feed off all the spare hands to heal yourself
Plus the doc has basically infinite regens now, it's not even like they're "wasting" a body anymore.
yeah well I always thought he was able to do that because his body wasn't severely mutilated/damaged or anything
God I love how Jack is a human from the future and much more knowledgable about all of this stuff and much more okay with it. Just, how he’s the one reassuring both companions, even his little “good luck doctor”. It’s just something I appreciate, a human companion who is aware and not emotionally decanted because he knows it’s natural.
Jack is a guy the doctor regenerating doesn’t affect him emotionally the way it does the two girls. Plus Jack was time agent so he probably had to learn about a lot of different alien species at the Time agency including time lords.
@@satinekenobi4ver855 I’m sorry their gender means what?
Well Donna didnt know what was happening, Rose did but loved 10 so this might as well be him dying. Jack not only knew but didnt have the same feelings Rose did so is just more able to accept the change
I love that too. Unlike a lot of the other companions, Jack is nearly on the same level as the Doctor in many ways. So in the Doctor’s absence or in a crisis situation, the other companions will often defer to him as the second in command.
@@raconbacon5649 this is what I’m saying yes
Love how you connected the once separated scenes together.
Thank you, it always bothered me that whenever they post it they only do one half
@@doctorwhoproductions834 you do a great job mate keep up the good work 👍
This was almost the best kept secret in all of Doctor Who. Imagine he had regenerated, nobody had a clue who it would have been!
Probably Smith
Not as the next best kept secret.
That defeats the purpose
If there was going to actually be a regeneration then everyone would've know who the new actor was, but since there wasn't no one knew.
@@danzackblack5829 no a surprise is better
@@doctorwhofan9426 did you understand what I was saying?
My point was not that one would be better, but that it wouldn't be possible for it to be a surprise because people know the casting and shit like that
Little did we know we will never see him do that again
We kinda did with the Curator, but from our perspective it's still in the future.
That's because Ten was the vainest of the Doctors.
Twelfth literally spent his last season refusing to regenerate, beat that
@@deuce5546 No he didn't, it was just the Christmas special.
This comment didn't age well... thankfully. There's another regeneration into David Tennant coming up!
other time lords: that’s not supposed to happen
Since when has The Doctor ever played by the rules?
@@dambust232 Never
Like he's regenerated more then a time lord is too.
You gotta admit that after all the buildup, complete with the romantic running toward each other in the street, his nearly getting killed by a Dalek, and a successful re-regeneration, that hug was a tad anticlimactic. I was sorely disappointed that the Doctor and his long lost lady love didn't have an epic makeout moment in front of Jack, Donna and everybody. Yeah I get that RTD was saving it up for the Bad Wolf Bay scene with Ten2 but come on man I FELT CHEATED
I look at this scene and only see 2 people who are completely in love with each other.
XtremeHeatRaiser That’s What I was gonna say 😂😂 Donna and Jack are perfect together 😂
The Doctor and Jack?
@@Silverwind87 Rose and Donna dude.
If he’s regenerated again why doesn’t he just chop his hand off again Unlimited regenerations
@@SPECTRE_Madman this counted as a full regeneration. The Doctor only had twelve regenerations in his original cycle, so when he regenerated into 11 he had none left. The other regeneration was used to change into the War Doctor.
10:I'm regenerating *explodes into a bright light*
10:AHHHHHHHHH
11:AHHHHHHHH
11:Legs! Still got legs
Donna and Jack:wat
Rose: *Vietnam flashbacks*
10: I'm regenerating! **blasts with regeneration energy**
10: AHHHHHHH!
11: AHHHHH- oh. Legs. Still got legs. Fingers, nose.
Jack: wat?
Donna: wat?
Rose: Docto-.
11: fish fingers and custard. I want some
8365th Doctor (me): XD
Rose: No, not again! *notices it's Matt Smith* Actually, I'm okay with this.
If he actually regenerated into Matt Smith, then Rose would've been the only conpanion to consecutively stay with two incarnations of the Doctor
Say what you want about the doctors, but the regeneration scenes for any of the them are always amazing, fake or not.
I just love how he went 'what do you think' just to Rose as if only what she thought mattered
It also echoes his first scene with her -- same question at 1:48 czcams.com/video/ltPTWJYkUcU/video.html
I was supposed to cut it shorter but forgot so enjoy the scene even longer
Thank you sooo much!!
Really he only stayed the same because he finally had hope he could be with Rose again and didn’t want anything to get in the way. He loved her too much to change and risk loosing her.
losing*
oh, and that theory is ridiculous.
@@pudding1823lol dude corrected him then replied again 😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@bjhhhj1217 Sammich gaming clearly has hate in his heart lol
@@dmainman349 lmao
This the most tenth doctor regeneration of all time.
I love Rose’s explanation of regeneration
14th Doctor took notes apparently 😂
00:17 waiting for November to end 00:25 1 minute till December
It's starting
I hate this and I hate you
@@lamchop5035 ok
@@charliebann5605 i read this when he said it, lol
I think I get this joke 🤣🤣
David Tennant holds the recoard for most filmed regerations
9 to 10
10 to uhh 10.5
10 to 11
13 to 14
And soon to be 14 to 15
@@doctorwhoproductions83414 to 14 + 15
@@doctorwhoproductions834 14 to 14 and 15. he can't just let it go
This is by far the best regenerating effect to this day in entire history of the show. It looks clean, reminding more an ascension than rebirth. It's almost like birth of the star, god or any other celestial being. I'd say only Jodie's regeneration to 14th incarnation only looked as good as this one.
Best regeneration ever
Honestly, who knows how many more times we'll see David as the Doctor. Who is to say that he won't regenerate again in 10 more years.
I love the confused look on Jack’s face when he didn’t change his face.
Imagine if this is where Matt Smith showed up
Realistically, the hand shouldn’t have grown into another Tenth Doctor. If you think about it, the whole point is that he used the regeneration energy to heal, but not to change-he siphoned that off into the hand. So the HAND should’ve regenerated.
What I’m saying is, the hand should’ve grown into Matt Smith lmao
but he took the healing for himself and gave the hand the changing, so the hand would be Matt Smiths hand, so after the Real regeneration, the Tenth should have become 11 with 1 hand
Pure class that move.
XD just got spoilers but now I know what to look forward to
You know what, I actually prefer this regeneration scene to Tennant's _actual_ regeneration scene.
Probably because its more emotional and realistic ? Is that the reason ?
@@adamoliver5589 Yeah, and it's also not dragged out. Tom Baker and David Tennant's regenerations were both too long, probably because they were fan favorites.
@@Silverwind87 yeah i get what your saying, quite the opposite of Christopher eccleston because with him i was left wanting more
Hey, here's a thought; how come regeneration energy is enough to damage a TARDIS and injure humans, but clothes are perfectly fine?
I wish I knew the song during the part while rose is explaining to Donna about him regenerating
10 lived for 4 years, regenerated and kept the same face here, lived another 2 years, then regenerated again. The Doctor got real slack with holding onto regenerations near the end of their cycle apparently.
Be so awkward if he later regenerated for real into Matt Smith with only one hand...
He could've apologised for scaring them like that.
Imagine if smith came at this regen would of been cool tbf
The reason he didnt do it the second time was because evey cell in his body was destroyed by radiation. He had to make an entirely new set.
Nah, it’s because he didn’t have the hand.
So this makes you wonder "Why doesn't the doctor cut off his hand everytime while he could still regenerate it back and then, come time to regen again just pop it into the hand?" LOL
while that could make sense their are a few problems with it not cinclding how would the first version take their hand off without healing, i mean maybe surgery but anyway.
one cause gross imagine every time you regenerate oh before i do anything time to lob a limb off and two because the doctor and timelords also change their face since they see the new face as a new person and all the things they've done before are forgiven and passed off as a different person, that and it be incredibly boring being the same man or woman for 2000 years following 12's age
Imagine he regenerated and the beam from his regeneration accidentally hit one of them 😂
Goddamn rose-doctor-Frankenstein shit comes out
It wouldn't have done anything. The regeneration beam is a healing force and the Doctor can use it to heal people.
That or it would have hurt, a lot.
@cnyte09 You say that, but 11 did use his to obliterate an entire Dalek battleship and has destroyed the inside of his own Tardis twice with it.
So I feel like "hurt a lot" would be an absolute understatement lol (missed the last part of your comment, my bad).
For Real, i thought he regenerates and Matt Smith will clear the Daleks (because i knew Matt Smith will be the next doctor)
Using 1 uno reverse card to deflect the regeneration
What ever the music was when he regenerated I would love to see a doctor regenerate with that music
I don't like how he explains regeneration. Wouldn't it make more sense if he had to change or else he would die because his body is dying so he needs a new one?
If he had touched his own hand would it have regenerated into a full timelord instead of a meta crisis?
Does anyone else really want to see what face that hand would have just to see who almost replaced 10?
It was still Matt Smith.
Really weird seeing billie after that movie
What movie is that
Imagine if he regenerated into Matt Smith and then they wanted the old doctor back so they hit him and he regenerated and used the hand to revert back to David Tennant and then would turn into Matt Smith in The End of Time Part 2
then he'd be dead when he saved wilf
*So, after he puts the regeneration into the hand, does that mean that is the hand of the 11th Doctor (Matt Smith) ?*
No
well no but following that logic, the hand in a jar would be ten's then eleventh's and then ten's again after the Meta Crisis, while actual ten's would go from ten's to eleven's to twelve's since he put the energy from one hand into the other but it doesn't work like that anyway
Watch the show.
God it’s so sad that the Doctor has to regenerate in a time like this… but wonder what the next series will be like- wait a second, did he just regenerate into himself???
What episode it is?
The Stolen Earth and Journeys Ends
Ok so if this is just able to happen why does the doctor just not cut off his hand every regeneration so he always has that choice of staying the same. Besides it not like it hurts him that much considering his reaction in the first debut of the tenth doctor.
It didn't even bleed
Cool
ye
When someone hits me In the face 0:53
Best Regenerate ever....
But didn't this consume a regen slot or does it not work until the full change?
Illusive Prime I think he has to go all the way
@@penginpower5015 Nope. This counted. It was confirmed in Eleven's final episode.
Oh
10 had "vanity issues"
@@filthycasual8187 Wouldn't it be the war doctor that counted lmao
This is a pretty big plothole though, because by this logic the Doctor never needs to change, he can just wait til he's healed and get rid of the remaining energy.
That's not how it works lol...he even explains why it worked in this video cmon pay more attention.
I'm confused. Is this an alternate scene on how season 4 could have ended? I mean, don't get me wrong, this is cool AF, but what is this?
I’ve just joined the regeneration cliff hanger to make one whole scene, in the show it stops half way though the regeneration with TO BE CONTINUED
So 11th and 12th doctor are the same right?
Well technically he should only be called the 10th because the whole the of the war doctors life he didn’t call himself doctor and only did till at the very end and that was for about 2 minutes but even if you include the war doctor, the 11th (10th) doctor didn’t change his face or personally and used a regeneration to heal himself pretty much, so hes the 11th and 12th incarnation but still only the 11th doctor
Well i be damned the tardis didnt blow up
It was terribly damaged
He was only healing himself so it wasn't destructive
@@ultracraftyt3701 well no shit it's a joke
@@Pookiebear7659 ok
Doctor should end up with?river or rose
Jack.
So shouldn't the hand be Matt Smith then ?
I don’t get why he didn’t cut his hand of and do it again next time he needed to regenerate....
In the words of Ryan George::
“So the movie can happen!”
I'd like to think it's because he didn't necessarily have a reason to. Ultimately I think his love towards Rose was what drove his dislike towards change, he wanted hold on to those feelings as long as possible and maintain the hope of being with her, when that hand turned into a carbon copy of him who was able to actually live out that sort of life with rose, he kind of came to terms with the fact that as the Doctor and a true Timelord he would never have that life. I think the issues he dealt with here probably subconsciously played a role in him regenerating into someone who was more accepting of change.
Because then he would have had to steer the TARDIS with one hand. It wouldn't regrow like the first time because his regeneration process was already finished.
The first time he had already completely changed and was within the first day of his cycle where his body was still healing and such.
This time he was just healing from being hit by a dalek blast and didn't want to change so the rest went to the hand. Not enough to regrow unfortunately, but would've been funny to see him copy and paste over and over
Imagine Jodi Whitaker doing this and she's around for another 3 years as the doctor.
And they say doctor who can’t be scary.
"Didn't need to change, didn't want to, why would I? Look at me"
Ugh, 10 get over yourself 🙄