Sahih al-Bukhari 106 Narrated `Ali: The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "Do not tell a lie against me for whoever tells a lie against me (intentionally) then he will surely enter the Hell-fire."
@@comparativereligiondailynews Banu ummayah is the problem actually.. they're the prime evils in islam ... enemies of Rasool Allah and his ahlul bayt..
I do not want to say anything negative about Shia Muslims, but I want to remind us that as Muslims, we follow the Quran and the traditions of our Prophet (peace be upon him). May Allah guide us to the right path. I would like to request that we refrain from insulting the Prophet (peace be upon him), his companions, his wives, or any other Muslims or non-Muslims in a negative manner. This is considered haram (forbidden) and serves no purpose.
here's a quick explanation of the benefits: - ur bad sins of this year and the year before are going to be erased - ur level of deen is going to get higher
So many critics here! Everyone wants to thanks Allah by fasting on this day on the victory over pheroah but no one wants to cry over the martyrdom of the beloved grandson of prophet Muhammad (pbuh)...I just want to ask one thing to all of you, who's more closer to prophet (pbuh)? What would prophet (pbuh) have done on this day if his holiness had witnessed the battle of Karbala?! Celebrated on the victory over pheroah or Cried over the martyrdom of his beloved grandson?!
@@ghadakhafagi4057 No, it's not. We don't fast with the niyah of pleasing allah on this day. Instead, we give up on eating and drinking from Fajr till Asar ( the time when Imam Husain ibn Ali was martyred. ) so as to understand the suffering of grandson of prophet muhammad who was so close to prophet that he called him as his own son.
@@alijafri786 That's not what Iman Ali said in your books long time before the martyrdom of Hussain (May Allah be pleased with them). In the following video you can see the quotations for yourself. czcams.com/video/Rz7fUtmgKx0/video.html
I won't really beat up myself for this understanding. But many people do. May Allah aza wajjal Guide us all Ameen! to the way of The Prophet whom we all have to Follow.
@@ItachiAli1993 the got no real sanad or hadith that there 12 imams mourned likes this. And do all these biddat procession with the horses. Mourn for hussian like how the propeht did. These guys meant to follow ahulul bayt and the prophet yet far from following the sunnah.
this guy doesnt understand how chain of narration goes. if they weren't there or were 4 years old doesn't disprove that the person that was their told them when they were there or old enough to understand. the chain goes i heard so and so said this from so and so. so they dont have to have been there only they have to have learnt about it when they were old enough and sane and trustworthy
1. The prophet SAW didnt live to fast the year after, which means Ibn Abass RA was 13 when the prophet died. Making him 12 years when the prophet made Ashura hadith. 2. The jews and the Quraish were fasting even before the prophet went to Madina. So hopefully you get this fact right. 3. If the prophet fasted, and Ibn Abass and the others fasted the year the prophet dies, why do you have to connect the death of our beloved swahaaba Hussain RA with the name of the fasting? Its a coincidence that he was killed on that day many years later, but people were fasting before he was killed. Hopefully you explain the fasting of Ashura without connecting dots that cannot be connected.
Said by a Shia whose books are full of fabricated Narrations. A Shia should never talk about hadith grading. There is no base for this, despite all tries by some Shia scholars. Shia hadith grading comes 6th century.
Shia know this they don't call it "Sahih" it is more dangerous to treat a book like Bukhari as "sahih" we are all products of history time Sunni & Shia reflect on how their bias has affect their beliefs then their will be no need for sects just learning
Authentic, according to Shia narrations that show it should be fasted: *Al-Baqir said " Fasting on the Day of Ashura eliminates the sins of an entire year" [Tahdhib Al-Ahkam, graded Sahih by Al-Khoei]* *Imam Musa Al-Kadhim said "The Messenger of Allah would fast on the Day of Ashura" [Tahdhib Al-Ahkam, graded Reliable by Al-Majlisi]*
HajiJesus Bukhari has many fabricated Ahadeeth. Any islamic source is vulnerable & prone to discredibility, criticism and falsehood, apart from the Holy Qur'an. May Allah bless
@@fromdarkness2lght587 Prove it. We can prove Shiasm is false, not by Hadith you dont accept but by Quran. Here are the main beliefs of Shiasm about Imams: 1. Infallible 2. Better than prophets 3. Don’t forget anything 4. Know all the knowledge of Islam 5. Know everything from past religions. Have authentic version of Torah/Bible. 6. Can do miracles. Not karamat. Miracles like splitting oceans. 7. Knowledge of the Unseen. 8. Can Speak with Angels. 9. Supported by an angel greater than Gabriel, called rouh. 10. Can speak all the languages of the world. 11. Know when they will die. 12. Dies with their own permission. 13. Can see you and hear you wherever you are. 14. Created thousands or Millions of years before Adam. 15. God created the world for them. 16. Will come back to live before the end of the earth. This world. 17. Will revive their enemies. And seek revenge from them. 18. Can speak to the Jin and animals. Order the jin. 19. Control all atoms of the world. Wilayat takwineya. 20. Collected better version of Quran. 21. Born clean. Born from womb. From the side of their mothers. 22. Can recite Quran from womb. 23. Have other divine books. Musahaf Fatima for example. 24. Our deeds are actions are present to them on daily bases. On the night of Friday. 25. Only them can interpret Quran. 26. Possess Ancient relics. Khatam Suleiman. Stick of Moses. 27. Get to decide who enters heaven and who does not. 28. Can bestow blessing to anybody. 29. Quran is mainly talks about their Imams. Like third. 30. Can bring out new religious rulings. Fast half of the day of Ashura for example. 31. Last Imam will abrogate Islamic laws and bring Torah(Jewish) Laws
ʿĀshūrāʾ is the tenth of Muḥarram as established by (1) the mutawātir practice of this Ummah consistently throughout the generations since the time of the Prophet (ﷺ) until our times without any disagreement. (2)In Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim and others on the authority of Ibn ʿAbbās; Muslim narrates: باب أَىُّ يَوْمٍ يُصَامُ فِي عَاشُورَاءَ Chapter: Which day should be fasted for ʿĀshūrāʾ? وَحَدَّثَنَا أَبُو بَكْرِ بْنُ أَبِي شَيْبَةَ، حَدَّثَنَا وَكِيعُ بْنُ الْجَرَّاحِ، عَنْ حَاجِبِ بْنِ عُمَرَ، عَنِ الْحَكَمِ بْنِ الأَعْرَجِ، قَالَ انْتَهَيْتُ إِلَى ابْنِ عَبَّاسٍ - رضى الله عنهما - وَهُوَ مُتَوَسِّدٌ رِدَاءَهُ فِي زَمْزَمَ فَقُلْتُ لَهُ أَخْبِرْنِي عَنْ صَوْمِ عَاشُورَاءَ . فَقَالَ إِذَا رَأَيْتَ هِلاَلَ الْمُحَرَّمِ فَاعْدُدْ وَأَصْبِحْ يَوْمَ التَّاسِعِ صَائِمًا . قُلْتُ هَكَذَا كَانَ رَسُولُ اللَّهِ صلى الله عليه وسلم يَصُومُهُ قَالَ نَعَمْ . Hakam b. al-'Araj reported: I went to Ibn 'Abbas (Allah be Pleased with both of them) and he was reclining using his mantle as a pillow near the fountain of Zamzam. I said to him: Tell me about fasting on Ashura. He said: When you see the new moon of Muharram then count the (days) and observe fast on the 9th. I said to him: Is it how the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) observed the fast? He said: Yes. [Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim 1133]
1. If ibn Abbas is rejected because he was 4 when prophet came to medina, then how can we accept any narration from hassan & hussein when they were 4 & 6 when the prophet died صلى الله عليه وسلم? They would need to narrate their reports from other elder companions. 2. Majority of shia reports dont even go back to the prophet صلى الله عليه وسلم, it goes back to imam ja'far and imam baaqir & they never quote that they heard a hadith from any one who lived with prophet Muhammad. Imam jafar was born 60 years after the prophet died صلى الله عليه وسلم. And imam baqir was born over 30 years after the prophet passed away. Majority of shia hadith are sourced back to these two imams and they never even met hassan and hussein, let alone the prophet Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم. So nothing is really reliable from shia hadiths anyways. 3. Even if you accept what he is saying, More sahabah narrate the the hadith of fasting muharram than 3 he mentioned. Even the imams i mentioned along with Ali also narrate the hadith of fasting ashurah of muharram in shia books.
@crabinthetophat490 if they learned from them then they are proof that your garbage beliefs are not what the ahlul bayt taught because they didnt transmit what the 12vers belief in fiqh or creed.
Dude stop celebrating ashura as a day of blessings , Ahlulbayt are pure from ur nasibiyah u are the generation of people whom ali(as) slaughtered in badr, khandaq, Jamal and suffin , shiate muawiyah (ahlus sunnah wal jammah) is still doing these Shenigans to hide the Murderer of Imam hassan and Imam hussain. Ur so called rightly guided caliph were so power hungry that they didn't even attend the funeral of prophet instead they were present at saqifa doing politics on who will grab the power first. The killer of Abu dhar is also one ur rightly guided caliph wallahi ur hypocrisy and double standard are enough for me to curse the b@stards at saqifa more and more
It's simple really, if you observe Ashura solely because of Hussain's death, then it is Bida'ah because the Prophet s.a.w didnt do that. Then again, Shi'a muslims somehow would rather follow their own books than Qur'an & Sunnah which they claim to be fabricated by Muawiyah. They also will injure their bodies on this day when Allah specifically mentions that you shouldn't harm yourself. But here's the funny part, y'all learn nothing from Hussain's death other than to wage wars in the Middle East.
What are you talking about??? 1) Real Shias are told to not harm themselves, so people who do that are committing sin (check Iran's leader opinion). 2) Prophet Mohammad (SAW) and prophet Isa (mentioned in true hadith) already knew what was going to happen in Karbala which highlight the significance of Imam Hussain's story. Also, it is likely that our prophet had been given the knowledge of reality in the past, so listening to Jews is strange. 3) Why don't you talk about Saudi regime attacking poor kids in Yemen and becoming friends with Israeli criminals??? 4) Sunnis don't recommend giving food for charity in this month, why??? In my opinion charity can be done anytime and day. You don't recognize the significance of this event
@@m.a4491you gou triggered huh ? Why YOU do not talk about the genocide over sunnis in Syria done by shiites and Iran ? You emptied parts of the country from sunnies and brought shiites from out of the country. The hell with your leader .
Ibne Abbas is not in the chain of Hadith, please do not lie حَدَّثَنَا قُتَيْبَةُ بْنُ سَعِيدٍ ، حَدَّثَنَا اللَّيْثُ ، عَنْ يَزِيدَ بْنِ أَبِي حَبِيبٍ ، أَنَّ عِرَاكَ بْنَ مَالِكٍ حَدَّثَهُ ، أَنَّ عُرْوَةَ أَخْبَرَهُ ، عَنْ عَائِشَةَ رَضِيَ اللَّهُ عَنْهَا ، أَنَّ قُرَيْشًا كَانَتْ تَصُومُ يَوْمَ عَاشُورَاءَ فِي الْجَاهِلِيَّةِ ، ثُمَّ أَمَرَ رَسُولُ اللَّهِ صَلَّى اللَّهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ بِصِيَامِهِ حَتَّى فُرِضَ رَمَضَانُ ، وَقَالَ رَسُولُ اللَّهِ صَلَّى اللَّهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ : مَنْ شَاءَ فَلْيَصُمْهُ ، وَمَنْ شَاءَ أَفْطَرَ . ام المؤمنین عائشہ رضی اللہ عنہا نے فرمایا قریش زمانہ جاہلیت میں عاشورہ کا روزہ رکھتے تھے، پھر رسول اللہ صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم نے بھی اس دن روزہ کا حکم دیا یہاں تک کہ رمضان کے روزے فرض ہو گئے، پھر رسول اللہ صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم نے فرمایا کہ جس کا جی چاہے یوم عاشورہ کا روزہ رکھے اور جس کا جی چاہے نہ رکھے۔ Sahih Bukhari#1893 Status: صحیح
But How could fasting on 10 Muharram be Maqrooh ,However Prophet peace be upon Him said that you can fast on any day except Eidul Azha or Eid ul Fitr and alone fasting on Juma day?
As Salaam Alaekum. This gentleman even doesn't know how to logically interpret some piece of knowledge. First of All these Ahadith have been narrated by multiple Sahabah in Bukhari and Muslim including Ibn Abbas, Ayesha, Abu Hurrraira and Rabi bin Maoz etc. This is a Hadith Mutawatir if you look at number of Turuq in Kutub Sitta. As far as his objections are concerned, the reply to that is that Rasool Ullah (SAW) lived for 10 years in Madinah after his Migration. During these 10 years all these Ashab saw Rasool Ullah Fasting that day hence they would have asked about the reason or heard about this reason from their friends. When someone explain it to someone else then he will explain in the way narrated in ahadith. Anyway, Sunni Don't claim that these Ahadith are exact verbatim of Rasool Ullah (SAW,), as we know that there has been some "Hadeeth bil ma'na" transmission as well. Additionally, Ayesha RA and others also narrated that Rasool Ullah and Kuffar of Quraish actually fasted on 10 Muharram before Hijrah as well and he (SAW) asked us to add another day (9th) to distinguish ourselves from Jews. Wallahu Aalum bis Sawab.
Ahlul bayt are free of this cult It was narrated that Sahl ibn Sa‘d said: The Prophet (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) said: “I will reach the Cistern ahead of you. He who comes to me will drink, and whoever drinks will never thirst again. There will come to me some people whom I will recognize and they will recognize me, then they will be prevented from reaching me. I shall say: ‘They are of me,’ but it will be said: ‘You do not know what they introduced after you were gone.’ So I shall say: ‘Away, away with those who changed (the religion) after I was gone.’” Narrated by al-Bukhaari (6212) and Muslim (2290).
King of the kings Imam Hussain A.s has showed us the true islam being martyred so if you beleive in him Your a true mumineen or else beleive in Yazid and company its your choice, dont just believe in the mullahs to Your own research... I was a sunni now i belief in the shia Aqeeda which is the true islam if the holy Prophet s.a.w and his progeny open YOUR eyes....
You people are like christians glorifying a man as if he will get you closer to Allah, the prophet PBUH wouldn't even get his beloved uncle to enter jannah
Assalamalaikum I have a question about fasting on 10th Muharram for your mother who is dead is it allowed to keep her qaza roza on that day is it Haram, makrooh or will it not be qabool please give me the reply
If u disqualify sunni fasting the day of Ashura it means that also shia fasting the same day doesn't make sense because it's not close to prophet Muhammad SAW
@@ghadakhafagi4057 The book of jaafariyat? can you share a link or pdf version of this book. FYI this was used as one of the references in the link you shared
Your scholars ? Who is your scholars? Why don’t you ever mention the greatest scholars names ?? Khomeini ? Beheshti? Taloqani? Muntaziri? Khameni? Panahian??? Why ? Are you really Shia ? Or hiding behind political Supports??
Assalamualaikum I am a Tabatabaei from Malaysia. A Shafie by fiqh Ashaari by creed and Qadiri by Tasawuf. I start to learn Bihar ul Anwar. I need more English materials in Shia sciences. Salam to brothers.
I'm fascinating with Tabatabaei works. Me too learn from Malaysia, with creed of Ashari, Fiqh of Shafie, Syattari-Ghazali by Tasawuf, learn this Ahlu Bayt Fiqh
shias made their religion much more harder to follow, whats wrong with fasting in that day? no harm was done, i'm only 6 year in being a muslim , only shiites almost made me left islam.
@@farahmo4519 My parents were nominally Christian but I became Muslim. Alhamdulillah If you were born to Sunni parents but don't believe Sunni Hadith over Shia ones, then you are Shia
Oh yes for Muslims ashura is supposed to be the 10th of Muharram as they follow the lunar calendar after prophet Muhammad but for jews ashura would have been the tenth of Gregorian calendar the tenth of January or December can't differentiate.
How can fasting in the name of allah be makruh... Prophet sallallahu alaihi wasallam used to fast every Monday and Thursday..ok let's accept that Jewish calender does not coincide with the day of Ashura of Muharram .. but what's wrong in fasting? What do we lose? Fasting is an act of worship. How can fasting be makruh?
The previous hadith itself says that jews did fast to celebrate the victory of Moses but before the battle of Karbala and now how could we celebrate the martyrdom of imam Hussain (a.s)!
Are you fasting to respect/acknowledge the martyrdom of the grandson of prophet Muhammad (s.a.w.s.) or because of fake hadits related to the jews story? Fasting supporting an invalid cause is makrooh
Basically I am fasting for the event of Imam Hussain and His Family faced in Karbala I haven't read those Jews Hadith from Sunni sources. I am also Ismaili Shia in my mind came and I fast on 9 & 10th of Muharram for the sake of Prophet Family Moula Qabool Karen Aameen
I never find any harm for fasting in Ashura the Niyat Is an important factor if we are fasting for celebrating that Event which was placed and forgetting an Event of Karbala so obviously it is bad while if we're fasting and remembering an each things happened in Karbala so there seems nothing harm in my opinion Ya Ali Madad
Theres not a single isnad in al kafi that is authentic yet you question the authenticity of bukhari? The entire book is exaggerated and slanderous. After extensively studying the shia and their beliefs theres no questions they are outside the fold of Islam.
Imam al-Sadiq (as) about fasting I swear upon the Lord of the Sacred House (the Ka‘bah)! Such a day is not a day for fasting. That day is only reserved for sorrow and mourning that has been inflicted on the inhabitants of the skies and the earth altogether. It is a day of happiness and pleasure for the son of Marjanah and Ibn Ziyad’s partisans and the people of Sham. Allah’s curse be on them and their offspring. The day of ‘Ashura is a day when all the tombs and mausoleums of the earth except the tombs of Sham cry for al-Husayn. Therefore, Allah will unite on the Day of Resurrection anyone who fasts on that day or looks upon that day as a day of celebration with Ibn Ziyad and his partisans, discontent with a transformed heart…’” Al-Kafi, vol. 4, p. 147, hadith 7; Wasa’il al-Shi‘ah, vol. 10, p.
@@wewinners7338 i feel pity on you ... You claim to love and follow Prophet Muhammad ﷺ but don't love His grandson and family ... And respecting banu umayya who are the killers on Imam Hussain ع... Those Laeen ل disrespected the daughters, sisters and wives of Aal e Muhammad ﷺ .... Slapped those innocent even to Syeda Sakina ص who was just a 4 years old kid .. and even those Laeen slaughtered 6 months old infant Hazrat Prince Ali Asghar ع.... But you don't care about it ... What kind of Muslim you're????? ... By just saying all that rubbish in cmnts simply proves your UNCONDITIONAL love for Muhammad and Aale Muhammad ﷺ
@@tripleduck I'm an ex shia I've lived this shirk life I know all about it , the most misguided jahil people are the shia scholars tryst me , I'm sorry don't mean to be rude my family is still shia , just read the books of shia , full of shirk and bid'ha Alhumdulillah Allah guided me
@@stepstojannah8173 I'm sad to hear that. You are surely misguided by shaytan. I pray to Allah to guide you again and open your way to jannah sister. We all will see and know who were in the right path on the day of judgement InShaAllah.
@@afzaali1256 Thank you but really you should compare sunism with shiasm and be sincere ,then Allah may guide you Alhumdulillah I'm certain , I mean its clear sunism is all about tawheed where shiasm is nothing but shirk May Allah guide us all
@@stepstojannah8173 I have done quite well comparison. From the beginning up to date. From when the wilayat of Imam Ali a.s (ghadeer khum) was taken away from him. When ever this topic came up while me speaking to my sunni friends (classmates). They give up and reply me no more just by simply saying 'history is history and what have happened have happened we have noting to say, we follow what our forefathers have followed'...... is this justice, is this how it works? No dear. And when I ask them to read the history, they say sunni scholars consider reading history as haram... why so? Common sense! Cause the truth will come out.
حَدَّثَنَا مُسَدَّدٌ ، حَدَّثَنَا إِسْمَاعِيلُ ، عَنْ أَيُّوبَ ، عَنْ نَافِعٍ ، عَنِ ابْنِ عُمَرَ رَضِيَ اللَّهُ عَنْهُ ، قَالَ : صَامَ النَّبِيُّ صَلَّى اللَّهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ عَاشُورَاءَ ، وَأَمَرَ بِصِيَامِهِ ، فَلَمَّا فُرِضَ رَمَضَانُ تُرِكَ ، وَكَانَ عَبْدُ اللَّهِ لَا يَصُومُهُ ، إِلَّا أَنْ يُوَافِقَ صَوْمَهُ . رسول اللہ صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم نے یوم عاشورہ کا روزہ رکھا تھا اور آپ صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم نے اس کے رکھنے کا صحابہ رضی اللہ عنہم کو ابتداء اسلام میں حکم دیا تھا، جب ماہ رمضان کے روزے فرض ہو گئے تو عاشورہ کا روزہ بطور فرض چھوڑ دیا گیا، عبداللہ بن عمر رضی اللہ عنہما عاشورہ کے دن روزہ نہ رکھتے مگر جب ان کے روزے کا دن ہی یوم عاشورہ آن پڑتا۔ Sahih Bukhari#1892 Status: صحیح
Ashura' commemorates the day that Allah saved the Children of Israel from Pharaoh. Fasting on Muharram 10, known as the Day of 'Ashura', expiates for the sins of the past year. When the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) arrived in Madinah in 622 CE, he found that the Jews there fasted on Muharram 10 and asked them the reason for their fasting on this day. They said," This is a blessed day. On this day Allah saved the Children of Israel from their enemy (in Egypt) and so Prophet Musa [Moses] fasted on this day giving thanks to Allah." The Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) said, "We are closer to Musa than you are." He fasted on that day and commanded Muslims to fast on this day. (Al-Bukhari) The following year, Allah commanded the Muslims to fast the month of Ramadan, and the fasting of 'Ashura' became optional. It is also reported that the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) intended to fast on the ninth and tenth. Ibn 'Abbas reported: The Messenger of Allah fasted on the day of 'Ashura' and ordered the people to fast on it. The people said, "O Messenger of Allah, it is a day that the Jews and Christians honor." The Prophet said, "When the following year comes, Allah willing, we shall fast on the ninth." The death of the Prophet came before the following year. (Muslim and Abu Dawud) For more on 'Ashura' and Muharram, please read: The Significance of Fasting the Day of 'Ashura' Virtues of the Month of Muharram & Fasting during It Thus, according to scholars, you may choose to fast 'Ashura' on three days (ninth, tenth, and eleventh); two days (ninth and tenth); or one day only (the tenth). The Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) said, "Fasting the day of 'Ashura' (is of great merits), I hope that Allah will accept it as an expiation for (the sins committed in) the previous year." (Muslim) But this expiation of minor sins comes only if you avoid major sins. It is a big mistake to rely on fasting a single day to "wipe your slate clean." If you neglect your daily Prayers or the fast of Ramadan, or if you backbite, lie, commit adultery or other major sins, fasting on 'Ashura' alone will not atone for your sins. The great scholar Ibn Al-Qayyim Al-Jawziyya (b. 691 AH/1292 CE) wrote: This misguided person does not know that fasting in Ramadan and praying five times a day are much more important than fasting on the Day of Arafah and the Day of 'Ashura', and that they expiate for the sins between one Ramadan and the next, or between one Friday and the next, so long as one avoids major sins. But they cannot expiate for minor sins unless one also avoids major sins; when the two things are put together, they have the strength to expiate for minor sins. Among those deceived people may be one who thinks that his good deeds are more than his sins, because he does not pay attention to his bad deeds or check on his sins, but if he does a good deed he remembers it and relies on it.
This was only made , so that Muslims forget about the MASSACRE OF KARBALA AND IMAM HUSSEIN (A), it's political in it's MAIN title. This never took place, and the hadeeth is fabricated, so Muslims over the years don't take a stance and resist the tyrannical and oppressive governments.
Shia scholars mainly read bukhari and muslim. Instead they should read kaafi of Yakub kalini and then analyze it. It is very wise of shia leaders that they keep shias away and ignorent of what is there in kaafi. Like Barhmans of Hindus kept shudras away from vedas.
Problem with scholars like you is you think Ahlul Sunnah are like Ahle Tashee public who dont read Quran nor hadith and accept whatever their scholars say... But thats not the case....you can make your public fool but not every muslim
Is prophet did command self inflicting pain like the shia are doing? I think shia tradition is more problematic. If you disregard hadith since it is problematic then atleast you must follow what is in the QUR'AN Such doing never practice by prophet Muhammad and even Ali A.S And atleast hadith is debatable if not acceptable but selfinflicting is no sense to be part of Islamic tradition. If you are talking about age Prophet Muhammad is the youngest among prophet.
the prophet did mourn for the death of imam hussein...did you know that? theres nothing wrong with slapping your chest. No harm to the body in doing so.
So what implies that he spoke to Jews on hijri 1.... It was 10th hijri...As PBUH said it I would be alive I will fast either a day boforeor after....so all mis information with due respect
Hey super intelligent man....in bukhari this hadith is narrated by Abdullah Ibn Umar and by Talha bin Ubaid Ullah and Hazrat Ayesha R.A. in hadith no. 1891, 1892 and 1893...it is not narrated by Abdullah ibn Abbass When you guys will stop spreading lies??? Secondly, this event took place in the last year of Prophet S.A.W life, because Prophet S.A.W also said if I am present next year I will fast on either 9th or 11th of muharram as well to differentiate from them (jews).. and by that time hazrat Abdullah ibn Abbas was 14 years of age because he was born in 3 BH
You are Sunni and love Shia? You wouldn't say that if you knew what they say about Aisha and the companions of Muhammad sallallahu alaihi wasallam. And that preacher is not more value as a particle of dust in relation to ibn Abbas. He is a great Jahil who speaks with jahil . May Allah guide him and may Allah curse all people who curses the companions of Muhammad sallallahu alaihi wasallam.
A shia talking about the science of hadith is funny in itself . It is like an earthworm teaching others how to fly . You people dont have any such tradition ,if any than that is because of the influence of people of sunnah . The people who follow Quran and sunnah on the manhaj of sahaba (which includes the ahlul bayt as well )
I think out of respect for prophet Musa (saws) we should still fast for thr same reason adding an extra day for respect. Passover is coincided with our Sacrificial Eid so the Sunni point of view is to be respected as well assuming they also celebrate the better known Ashura of ahl ul bayt.
The sheikh was trying to argue that the Sunni hadith he quoted was fabricated also apparently the Jewish day for that fasr wasn’t at the time of 10th Muharram it was for another month
Causing pain to one's own self is a sign of ignorance narrated in sahih hadees.Then why does Shia do matam and cause pain to themselves .However Allah choses the martyers to grant them Jannatul Firdaus .Sign of a believer is that when they are in musibat they say InnaLillahi wa innaa Ilayhi Rajioon.
When our PROPHET (S.A.W.S) passed away from this World . HAZRAT SYEDNA IMAM HUSAIN (RZ) was four to five years old and he too was a Child . So , do Shia follows the Hadees narrated by IMAM HUSAIN (RZ)
@@iqbalquadri8117 first and foremost there is no hadis from Imam Hussain a.s which he narrated at this age, it was Hazrat Ali a.s and secondly its not only us but in the actual criteria of narration of hadis that can be considered authentic is not accepted for very young kids like 3-4 years. You need to do a thorough and unbiased research to understand this. Thank you
There are so many other days to fast. The benefits remain the same. May Allah swt open up our intuition and our hearts to truths, and give us the strength to fast today. No one is stopping you, as long as you know your heart is open in love for God and in His submission. If we do things to disrespect His messenger and his descendants, it just says more about us than Allah swt. Prophet Muhammad saww is our primary prophet, not Prophet Musa a.s. So unless we're also Jewish, the saving of the Israelites probably holds less on our hearts than the massacre of 74 innocent souls, many of whom were direct descendents of the Holy Prophet saww and Islam was SAVED in its original form because of this. Just something to think about. One day, so much confusion. Makes me understand why it's so difficult to remain Muslim in these end of days times.
The fact is 18000 kufans shia e ali done bayyah to muslim bin aqeel that they will give imam hussain side if he comes to kufa . However ubayd ullah ibn ziad was very clever and bridbed them all . Who was ibn ziad ? His father was appointed govneor in iraq by mola ali.. these were shia e ali influences too . Shimar joshi was also in the camp of mola ali in battle of safeen.. The fact is it wasent just the yazidis it was also those who claimed to be shia e ali that let down imam hussain like they did with his father . The famous hadith of bibi zainab was that these kufans will be regeetting this till the day of qiymmat. Those who proclaim it was sunnis that killed imam hussain know that the real truth is yaziid the pleet will be with the dogs in fire.
Ok as a Sunni I also agree with your commentary. Ok then why you beat yourself on 10th of muharram? Did Muhammad (saw) beat up h8s self when his closest companions where brutally massacred at war?
If we could please have straight forward and coherent responses from our Sunni brethren instead of beating around the bush that would be great thanks 🙏
U expect logic and humbleness from banu saqifa??? Imam Ali and other ahlulbayt were too nice for these b@stards , These people are supporter of those people who saw their idols being smashed by Ali(as) , there forefathers were sl@ughtered in jamal and siffin by Ali himself don't expect these people to show an inch of respect for muhammad and aale muhammad.
The level sectarian nonsense is epic with this one. He questions Ashura fasting hadith ascribing it back to Ibn Abbas who was 4 years old etc.. Here is what's in hadees books, and these narrations go back to Ali (RA) and Aisha (RA) - 1- It was narrated from `Ali (رضي الله عنه) that The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) used to fast on the day of `Ashoora’ and enjoined others to do so. Grade: Hasan because of corroborating evidence; this is a da'eef isnad because of the weakness of Jabir al-Ju'fi] (Darussalam) Reference : Musnad Ahmad 1069 In-book reference : Book 5, Hadith 487 2- Narrated `Aisha: Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) ordered (the Muslims) to fast on the day of 'Ashura', and when fasting in the month of Ramadan was prescribed, it became optional for one to fast on that day ('Ashura') or not. Reference : Sahih al-Bukhari 2001 In-book reference : Book 30, Hadith 106 USC-MSA web (English) reference : Vol. 3, Book 31, Hadith 219
Sir but there is a Hadith on musnad Ahmad I cannot recall the number but it is recommended to fast on 10th of muharram and also an extra fast before or after asshura in order to be different from jews
I think it a wrong idea. Because if you observed the life of Hazrat Mohammad (SA), he fasted this day. So all sahabi saw that and followed him. Then it is Mukruh now?
No, he's trying to prove that these hadits are not authentic. Remember that many have brought in their own hadit in the nameif our Prophet. It's our duty to ensure these fake hadits are removed as soon as possible
None of the companion of Prophet or Prophet's narration is weak .Allah gave all the companions of Prophets title of raziAllahu .You should be respectful when you refer them .
Why you dont care? Its your religion brother. You should seek the truth doesn’t matter where it is. Make Allah (swt) pleased with you. Wish you the best.
Don't take anything from these Rawafid Zakirs unless you go and verify it with Ahlusunnah ulama. He is brainwashing his audience and altering, destorting, and corrupting the ahadith. I can bet on this. 😆 I challenge you go and check the ahadith he mentioned and verify them with ulama you will know the truth. They speak lies, propaganda and mislead their audience in the name of Ahlul Bait.
@@seanselby001 Did you ever verify the ahadith of ahlul sunnah? You are presenting yourself and your law school as if you are 100% on the truth. And your only argument is „because we are sunni and we are always right and we are the measurement“ No Shia is brainwashing you. We just telling you to read your own books. But most of the sunnis dont even know their own books and believe everything what the sheikh tells him. For example: Thaqalayn, its not Quran and Sunnah, its Quran and Ahlul Bayt. Will you call me a liar and accuse me of brainwashing you or will you do your duty as a muslim and educate yourself (neutral) on this topic? good luck, wasalam
However it is not obligatory to fast on 10 Muharram after fard Ramzan came .Any who wants to fast can fast and who doesn't want to fast can do that also .
@@burhanhussain8697 don't use excuse to curse other's, once ayatollah Khomeini said, "Shia's have no right to curse sunnis. Second thing, fasting on ashura is not happiness but if you see in second sense, it is also method to feel hunger of companions in karbala. Please my brother, leave the sects of shia and sunni, be true Muslim and don't get involved in division.
@burhanhussain8697 ameen. And may Allah also make him share a room with yazeed. There is a special place on hell for yazid and his lovers .😂 That is where the genius who announced that shias killed Imam Hussein has a reserved place next to yazid
There are 20 hadiths not just one 2nd ibn Abbas is sahabi if sahabi narrate anything regarding prophet saw then it means it's authentic and for your 3rd logic ibn Abbas was born in 619 and prophet saw died on 632 so it means he was not 4year old you should first learn these things before misguiding innocent Muslims imam hassan as narrated about due e qannot which is done in vitar Nimaz and imam hassan was 8 year old but still we accept this hadees because imam hassan is also a sahabi so plZ don't misguide if u follow really imam Ali
My dear brother, did you just do 632 - 619 = 13 which is not equal to 4 year old? So you mean to say that when prophet was dying, it was at this moment the story of jews unfolded? Rethink brother. What did the sahabis said about the event of Ghadeer when Imam Ali (a.s.) was made the prophet's sucessor
@@alijafri786 dear if ibn Abbas was just 4year but at the time when prophet die he was 13 so he heard it from prophet so Hadith is true and 2nd there are more than 50 hadiths narrated by different shabha so you can't deny fast of 10 Muharram and 2nd prophet said that keep 9muharrum fast to so there were no resemblance with Jews
Not everyone is a Sunni and Muslims should unite. Not focus on differences but what we have in common. Mutual love for ISLAM and Allah. Sunni/Shia doesn't even matter in the US.
@@alijafri786 ANY PHRASE?? go n validate yourself before u say that.. He's not the only in you tube if u personally hate him.. there' are many other prominent scholars who give guidance with reference of Quran n Hadith.. whether u want to follow as per P(saw) or random human logic, is upto u
How can Musa save the bani israeel on each month on the 10th from pharaoh. Also has it ever crossed his mind that ibn abbas could've said what the prophet saws said about the jews fasting and then he did it also when he was qualified
Did you even understand what he meant to say? Also, if you believe the hadits from the likes of Maviya rather than the hadits fro prophet's own household then my dear brother, you are on the wrong path.
Walaa Tafarraquu wata kuunuu SHIYA'A .......... Then why should you call your self Shia while Allah tell us dont be among them. Please brothers try to know the TRUTH behind the BEGINNING OF SHIAYISM before following it.
The one who beat their chests are the ones who don't have love for our prophet , ahl al Bayt and sahabas .. We Sunnis are commanded to walk on the path of Calipha e rashidun i.e. Hazrat Abu Bakr r.a. , Hazrat Umar r.a. , Hazrat uthman r.a. , Hazrat Ali r.a. , Hazrat Hasan Ibn Ali r.a. and the sahabas and the martyrs of Islam We respect all your imams except Imam Mehdi r.a. because he's not even born yet ... We respect Them more than you
You respect the Ahlulbayt so much that you fast in celebration on ashura because the jews were freed from firaoun's tyranny but you don't care that the Prophet's grandson was killed brutally on ashura.
@@freepalestine1673 sunnis called sunnis because we follow the ( sunnah ) of the prophet Mohammad ﷺ and the mowlid the shia created it after more than 500 years after him
@@freepalestine1673 The first to invent this were the kings of the Fatimid state in the fourth century AH and those who called them (Al-Mu’izz li-Din Allah) and it is known that he and his people are all heretical Ismailis, philosophical.
What a stupid excuse for a so called Muslim. Ibnu Abbas was not 4, because prophet Muhammad, SAW fasted the year before he past away not when he came to madinna. As the hadith says if I live to next year I'll fast on the 9th as well which he did not live to. The other thing about month not being known is silly, are you telling us that the prophet and his sahabba did not know which month is which how ridiculous. You rather beat yourself and cry the cry of wolf then follow the sunnah, it was pure coincidence that Hussein RA was unfortunately killed this day.
I am sure Prophet knew the month but he’s saying the word Ashura on the 10th of Muharram became popular because of Imam Hussain and shia commemorating Imam Hussain martyrdom. However, back in the day every 10th of the month was referred to as Ashura. Your book doesn’t specify of the month since every 10th was referred to as Ashura. For example Prophet Muhammad could’ve said Ashura in Safar. P.S hope you realize this is Saudi propaganda to minimize the importance of 10th of Muharram. Wahhabis are pushing to fast on the 10th of Muharram and telling people it’s a celebratory day so people don’t get to know about Imam Hussain and the sacrifice he made for Islam on this day.
Kulayni) says, “I asked this same question from Imam al-Sadiq’s (as) father, too. He gave the same answer as Imam al-Sadiq (as) and added, Beware! This is a fast about which no Qur’anic verse has been revealed and is not an observed way of conduct. It was only the way of conduct for the partisans of Ziyad when they killed al-Husayn ibn ‘Ali (as)’.” This is a fast which was discontinued after the Qur’anic verse enacting the fast of the holy month of Ramadan was revealed. Doing that which is abandoned is an act of innovation Al-Kafi, vol. 4, p. 146, hadith 4; Wasa’il al-Shi‘ah, vol. 10, p.
You ate checking the chain of bukhari. Great. Have you ever chekced the chain of 'usoole Kafi'? I doubt you have ever seen Kaafi or red it ever. Go and check your mother books first. There are more than thousands of statements in usoole kaafi without proper chain.
It is not imitating the Jews, we have more right to Musa then the Jews and the prophet pbuh added one more day of fasting so we are different then them.
But don’t you have the a right on prophet Muhammad (saw) more than Musa(as)? Your Hadiths state the prophet himself never fasted on this day so why do you? Also you’re Nabi Muhammad’s(saw) ummah not Nabi musa’s (as) so you’re supposed to follow him (saw) first. Also, the Jews don’t fast on this day because Musa (as) was saved but rather they fast because God gave Musa (as) the 10 commandments. There is no such fast not even for Jews for the day when Musa (as) was saved. So if anybody should be fasting it should Jews on this day not Muslims. So why do you fast on a day which never even existed?
firstly denying bukhari does not make you a non-muslim because bukhari is not Quran accept Quran there is no book that can never have a mistake and secondly he is not denying the whole bukhari is just talking about single fabricated hadees
Lol I didn’t know Bukhari and Muslim were Gods words and even if, he’s not denying, he’s explaining it a lot of the Hadith in your books ARE labelled za’eef (weak) so chill
Fasting is only prohibited on Eid and if the person is impure Other than that its allowed in fact fasting is actually really good for your soul and cleans your sins away
Sahih al-Bukhari 106
Narrated `Ali:
The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "Do not tell a lie against me for whoever tells a lie against me (intentionally) then he will surely enter the Hell-fire."
Yeah so be aware of yourself
Yes. So try to do according to the truth . Don't blindly follow banu ummayah's fabricated ahadees
@@waseelabatool
Banu Ummayah is not all problematic. Don't be a blind follower either.
@@comparativereligiondailynews Banu ummayah is the problem actually.. they're the prime evils in islam ... enemies of Rasool Allah and his ahlul bayt..
Please never stop uploading it helps a lot
He, as a shia will not accept sunni point of view. Biased
I do not want to say anything negative about Shia Muslims, but I want to remind us that as Muslims, we follow the Quran and the traditions of our Prophet (peace be upon him). May Allah guide us to the right path. I would like to request that we refrain from insulting the Prophet (peace be upon him), his companions, his wives, or any other Muslims or non-Muslims in a negative manner. This is considered haram (forbidden) and serves no purpose.
here's a quick explanation of the benefits:
- ur bad sins of this year and the year before are going to be erased
- ur level of deen is going to get higher
So many critics here! Everyone wants to thanks Allah by fasting on this day on the victory over pheroah but no one wants to cry over the martyrdom of the beloved grandson of prophet Muhammad (pbuh)...I just want to ask one thing to all of you, who's more closer to prophet (pbuh)? What would prophet (pbuh) have done on this day if his holiness had witnessed the battle of Karbala?! Celebrated on the victory over pheroah or Cried over the martyrdom of his beloved grandson?!
Fasting this day is in Shia books too.
@@ghadakhafagi4057 No, it's not. We don't fast with the niyah of pleasing allah on this day.
Instead, we give up on eating and drinking from Fajr till Asar ( the time when Imam Husain ibn Ali was martyred. ) so as to understand the suffering of grandson of prophet muhammad who was so close to prophet that he called him as his own son.
@@alijafri786 That's not what Iman Ali said in your books long time before the martyrdom of Hussain (May Allah be pleased with them). In the following video you can see the quotations for yourself.
czcams.com/video/Rz7fUtmgKx0/video.html
@@alijafri786 correct
@@alijafri786so basically you mean to say that understanding the pain of imam hussain RA is more important than pleasing Allah?
I won't really beat up myself for this understanding. But many people do. May Allah aza wajjal Guide us all Ameen! to the way of The Prophet whom we all have to Follow.
The way of the AhlulBayt is the way of the Prophet
Logic
@@ItachiAli1993 Indeed. All the Sahaba followed the Prophet. (peace be upon him). Don''t beat yourself on Greek philosophy.
@@ItachiAli1993 the got no real sanad or hadith that there 12 imams mourned likes this. And do all these biddat procession with the horses. Mourn for hussian like how the propeht did. These guys meant to follow ahulul bayt and the prophet yet far from following the sunnah.
The prophet said to stay away from grey areas or doubtful things and focus on what is sure.
this guy doesnt understand how chain of narration goes. if they weren't there or were 4 years old doesn't disprove that the person that was their told them when they were there or old enough to understand. the chain goes i heard so and so said this from so and so. so they dont have to have been there only they have to have learnt about it when they were old enough and sane and trustworthy
Which hadith states that Prophet prohibited it
If the prophet wasn't fasting on that day during his time, your question isn't even valid.
They are shia'a, soooo much unreferenced talk
@@alijafri786😂😂😂 that's a terrible response
1. The prophet SAW didnt live to fast the year after, which means Ibn Abass RA was 13 when the prophet died. Making him 12 years when the prophet made Ashura hadith.
2. The jews and the Quraish were fasting even before the prophet went to Madina. So hopefully you get this fact right.
3. If the prophet fasted, and Ibn Abass and the others fasted the year the prophet dies, why do you have to connect the death of our beloved swahaaba Hussain RA with the name of the fasting? Its a coincidence that he was killed on that day many years later, but people were fasting before he was killed.
Hopefully you explain the fasting of Ashura without connecting dots that cannot be connected.
Said by a Shia whose books are full of fabricated Narrations.
A Shia should never talk about hadith grading. There is no base for this, despite all tries by some Shia scholars. Shia hadith grading comes 6th century.
As a Shia Muslim is it haram to fast on ashurah?
Shia know this they don't call it "Sahih" it is more dangerous to treat a book like Bukhari as "sahih" we are all products of history time Sunni & Shia reflect on how their bias has affect their beliefs then their will be no need for sects just learning
Authentic, according to Shia narrations that show it should be fasted:
*Al-Baqir said " Fasting on the Day of Ashura eliminates the sins of an entire year" [Tahdhib Al-Ahkam, graded Sahih by Al-Khoei]*
*Imam Musa Al-Kadhim said "The Messenger of Allah would fast on the Day of Ashura" [Tahdhib Al-Ahkam, graded Reliable by Al-Majlisi]*
HajiJesus
Bukhari has many fabricated Ahadeeth. Any islamic source is vulnerable & prone to discredibility, criticism and falsehood, apart from the Holy Qur'an.
May Allah bless
@@fromdarkness2lght587
Prove it.
We can prove Shiasm is false, not by Hadith you dont accept but by Quran.
Here are the main beliefs of Shiasm about Imams:
1. Infallible
2. Better than prophets
3. Don’t forget anything
4. Know all the knowledge of Islam
5. Know everything from past religions. Have authentic version of Torah/Bible.
6. Can do miracles. Not karamat. Miracles like splitting oceans.
7. Knowledge of the Unseen.
8. Can Speak with Angels.
9. Supported by an angel greater than Gabriel, called rouh.
10. Can speak all the languages of the world.
11. Know when they will die.
12. Dies with their own permission.
13. Can see you and hear you wherever you are.
14. Created thousands or Millions of years before Adam.
15. God created the world for them.
16. Will come back to live before the end of the earth. This world.
17. Will revive their enemies. And seek revenge from them.
18. Can speak to the Jin and animals. Order the jin.
19. Control all atoms of the world. Wilayat takwineya.
20. Collected better version of Quran.
21. Born clean. Born from womb. From the side of their mothers.
22. Can recite Quran from womb.
23. Have other divine books. Musahaf Fatima for example.
24. Our deeds are actions are present to them on daily bases. On the night of Friday.
25. Only them can interpret Quran.
26. Possess Ancient relics. Khatam Suleiman. Stick of Moses.
27. Get to decide who enters heaven and who does not.
28. Can bestow blessing to anybody.
29. Quran is mainly talks about their Imams. Like third.
30. Can bring out new religious rulings. Fast half of the day of Ashura for example.
31. Last Imam will abrogate Islamic laws and bring Torah(Jewish) Laws
ʿĀshūrāʾ is the tenth of Muḥarram as established by (1) the mutawātir practice of this Ummah consistently throughout the generations since the time of the Prophet (ﷺ) until our times without any disagreement. (2)In Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim and others on the authority of Ibn ʿAbbās; Muslim narrates:
باب أَىُّ يَوْمٍ يُصَامُ فِي عَاشُورَاءَ
Chapter: Which day should be fasted for ʿĀshūrāʾ?
وَحَدَّثَنَا أَبُو بَكْرِ بْنُ أَبِي شَيْبَةَ، حَدَّثَنَا وَكِيعُ بْنُ الْجَرَّاحِ، عَنْ حَاجِبِ بْنِ عُمَرَ، عَنِ الْحَكَمِ بْنِ الأَعْرَجِ، قَالَ انْتَهَيْتُ إِلَى ابْنِ عَبَّاسٍ - رضى الله عنهما - وَهُوَ مُتَوَسِّدٌ رِدَاءَهُ فِي زَمْزَمَ فَقُلْتُ لَهُ أَخْبِرْنِي عَنْ صَوْمِ عَاشُورَاءَ . فَقَالَ إِذَا رَأَيْتَ هِلاَلَ الْمُحَرَّمِ فَاعْدُدْ وَأَصْبِحْ يَوْمَ التَّاسِعِ صَائِمًا . قُلْتُ هَكَذَا كَانَ رَسُولُ اللَّهِ صلى الله عليه وسلم يَصُومُهُ قَالَ نَعَمْ .
Hakam b. al-'Araj reported:
I went to Ibn 'Abbas (Allah be Pleased with both of them) and he was reclining using his mantle as a pillow near the fountain of Zamzam. I said to him: Tell me about fasting on Ashura. He said: When you see the new moon of Muharram then count the (days) and observe fast on the 9th. I said to him: Is it how the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) observed the fast? He said: Yes.
[Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim 1133]
1. If ibn Abbas is rejected because he was 4 when prophet came to medina, then how can we accept any narration from hassan & hussein when they were 4 & 6 when the prophet died صلى الله عليه وسلم? They would need to narrate their reports from other elder companions.
2. Majority of shia reports dont even go back to the prophet صلى الله عليه وسلم, it goes back to imam ja'far and imam baaqir & they never quote that they heard a hadith from any one who lived with prophet Muhammad. Imam jafar was born 60 years after the prophet died صلى الله عليه وسلم. And imam baqir was born over 30 years after the prophet passed away. Majority of shia hadith are sourced back to these two imams and they never even met hassan and hussein, let alone the prophet Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم. So nothing is really reliable from shia hadiths anyways.
3. Even if you accept what he is saying, More sahabah narrate the the hadith of fasting muharram than 3 he mentioned. Even the imams i mentioned along with Ali also narrate the hadith of fasting ashurah of muharram in shia books.
Bruv you do understand 4 scholars of Sunni school of though Hanaif, Maliki, Shaafi etc learned and got tutillage from the Immams?
@crabinthetophat490 if they learned from them then they are proof that your garbage beliefs are not what the ahlul bayt taught because they didnt transmit what the 12vers belief in fiqh or creed.
Dude stop celebrating ashura as a day of blessings , Ahlulbayt are pure from ur nasibiyah u are the generation of people whom ali(as) slaughtered in badr, khandaq, Jamal and suffin , shiate muawiyah (ahlus sunnah wal jammah) is still doing these Shenigans to hide the Murderer of Imam hassan and Imam hussain.
Ur so called rightly guided caliph were so power hungry that they didn't even attend the funeral of prophet instead they were present at saqifa doing politics on who will grab the power first.
The killer of Abu dhar is also one ur rightly guided caliph wallahi ur hypocrisy and double standard are enough for me to curse the b@stards at saqifa more and more
It's simple really, if you observe Ashura solely because of Hussain's death, then it is Bida'ah because the Prophet s.a.w didnt do that. Then again, Shi'a muslims somehow would rather follow their own books than Qur'an & Sunnah which they claim to be fabricated by Muawiyah. They also will injure their bodies on this day when Allah specifically mentions that you shouldn't harm yourself. But here's the funny part, y'all learn nothing from Hussain's death other than to wage wars in the Middle East.
What are you talking about???
1) Real Shias are told to not harm themselves, so people who do that are committing sin (check Iran's leader opinion).
2) Prophet Mohammad (SAW) and prophet Isa (mentioned in true hadith) already knew what was going to happen in Karbala which highlight the significance of Imam Hussain's story. Also, it is likely that our prophet had been given the knowledge of reality in the past, so listening to Jews is strange.
3) Why don't you talk about Saudi regime attacking poor kids in Yemen and becoming friends with Israeli criminals???
4) Sunnis don't recommend giving food for charity in this month, why??? In my opinion charity can be done anytime and day.
You don't recognize the significance of this event
@@m.a4491you gou triggered huh ? Why YOU do not talk about the genocide over sunnis in Syria done by shiites and Iran ? You emptied parts of the country from sunnies and brought shiites from out of the country. The hell with your leader .
Ibne Abbas is not in the chain of Hadith, please do not lie
حَدَّثَنَا قُتَيْبَةُ بْنُ سَعِيدٍ ، حَدَّثَنَا اللَّيْثُ ، عَنْ يَزِيدَ بْنِ أَبِي حَبِيبٍ ، أَنَّ عِرَاكَ بْنَ مَالِكٍ حَدَّثَهُ ، أَنَّ عُرْوَةَ أَخْبَرَهُ ، عَنْ عَائِشَةَ رَضِيَ اللَّهُ عَنْهَا ، أَنَّ قُرَيْشًا كَانَتْ تَصُومُ يَوْمَ عَاشُورَاءَ فِي الْجَاهِلِيَّةِ ، ثُمَّ أَمَرَ رَسُولُ اللَّهِ صَلَّى اللَّهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ بِصِيَامِهِ حَتَّى فُرِضَ رَمَضَانُ ، وَقَالَ رَسُولُ اللَّهِ صَلَّى اللَّهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ : مَنْ شَاءَ فَلْيَصُمْهُ ، وَمَنْ شَاءَ أَفْطَرَ .
ام المؤمنین عائشہ رضی اللہ عنہا نے فرمایا قریش زمانہ جاہلیت میں عاشورہ کا روزہ رکھتے تھے، پھر رسول اللہ صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم نے بھی اس دن روزہ کا حکم دیا یہاں تک کہ رمضان کے روزے فرض ہو گئے، پھر رسول اللہ صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم نے فرمایا کہ جس کا جی چاہے یوم عاشورہ کا روزہ رکھے اور جس کا جی چاہے نہ رکھے۔
Sahih Bukhari#1893
Status: صحیح
If you really love Prophet peace be upon Him then Obey Him and His companions.
*progeny
@@nedhak yes ofcourse .
His Ahlebayet*
im sunni but u should say companions and family not just companions or not just family
“Companion “ who ?
These are not real companion they were musrik and laaantis
Salamun Alaikum, Many thanks for your excellent commentary and analyses.
Yazeed did not kill Hussein radia allahu alayh you shia did
But How could fasting on 10 Muharram be Maqrooh ,However Prophet peace be upon Him said that you can fast on any day except Eidul Azha or Eid ul Fitr and alone fasting on Juma day?
Yeah there is no basis upon which to say it is makruh
The basis is the Household of the Prophet.
As Salaam Alaekum. This gentleman even doesn't know how to logically interpret some piece of knowledge. First of All these Ahadith have been narrated by multiple Sahabah in Bukhari and Muslim including Ibn Abbas, Ayesha, Abu Hurrraira and Rabi bin Maoz etc. This is a Hadith Mutawatir if you look at number of Turuq in Kutub Sitta. As far as his objections are concerned, the reply to that is that Rasool Ullah (SAW) lived for 10 years in Madinah after his Migration. During these 10 years all these Ashab saw Rasool Ullah Fasting that day hence they would have asked about the reason or heard about this reason from their friends. When someone explain it to someone else then he will explain in the way narrated in ahadith. Anyway, Sunni Don't claim that these Ahadith are exact verbatim of Rasool Ullah (SAW,), as we know that there has been some "Hadeeth bil ma'na" transmission as well. Additionally, Ayesha RA and others also narrated that Rasool Ullah and Kuffar of Quraish actually fasted on 10 Muharram before Hijrah as well and he (SAW) asked us to add another day (9th) to distinguish ourselves from Jews. Wallahu Aalum bis Sawab.
You are forgetting Musa AS was a Muslim in iman. Hebrew by race.
Ahlul bayt are free of this cult
It was narrated that Sahl ibn Sa‘d said: The Prophet (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) said: “I will reach the Cistern ahead of you. He who comes to me will drink, and whoever drinks will never thirst again. There will come to me some people whom I will recognize and they will recognize me, then they will be prevented from reaching me. I shall say: ‘They are of me,’ but it will be said: ‘You do not know what they introduced after you were gone.’ So I shall say: ‘Away, away with those who changed (the religion) after I was gone.’”
Narrated by al-Bukhaari (6212) and Muslim (2290).
Ignorance is bliss
King of the kings Imam Hussain A.s has showed us the true islam being martyred so if you beleive in him Your a true mumineen or else beleive in Yazid and company its your choice, dont just believe in the mullahs to Your own research... I was a sunni now i belief in the shia Aqeeda which is the true islam if the holy Prophet s.a.w and his progeny open YOUR eyes....
Allah is king of kings
Yes my brother. Labbaik ya Hussain !!
You people are like christians glorifying a man as if he will get you closer to Allah, the prophet PBUH wouldn't even get his beloved uncle to enter jannah
Assalamalaikum I have a question about fasting on 10th Muharram for your mother who is dead is it allowed to keep her qaza roza on that day is it Haram, makrooh or will it not be qabool please give me the reply
Yazeed did not kill Hussein radia allahu alayh you shia did
@@wewinners7338Okay yazeed is your father so always try to save him.. good going 😂
If u disqualify sunni fasting the day of Ashura it means that also shia fasting the same day doesn't make sense because it's not close to prophet Muhammad SAW
Shia do not fast this day fyi.
@@JN-eq3gl They should according to their own imams and books
drosq8.com/play.php?catsmktba=12343
@@ghadakhafagi4057 The book of jaafariyat? can you share a link or pdf version of this book.
FYI this was used as one of the references in the link you shared
@@JN-eq3gl They do fasting but just until Midday and without the intention of religious fasting. Shia myself i still don’t understand that.
Your scholars ? Who is your scholars? Why don’t you ever mention the greatest scholars names ?? Khomeini ? Beheshti? Taloqani? Muntaziri? Khameni? Panahian??? Why ? Are you really Shia ? Or hiding behind political
Supports??
Assalamualaikum
I am a Tabatabaei from Malaysia. A Shafie by fiqh Ashaari by creed and Qadiri by Tasawuf. I start to learn Bihar ul Anwar. I need more English materials in Shia sciences.
Salam to brothers.
I'm fascinating with Tabatabaei works. Me too learn from Malaysia, with creed of Ashari, Fiqh of Shafie, Syattari-Ghazali by Tasawuf, learn this Ahlu Bayt Fiqh
May Allah guide u both to the pure aqeedah and correct ahlul sunnah wal jamah
Don't support shia bro
shias made their religion much more harder to follow, whats wrong with fasting in that day? no harm was done, i'm only 6 year in being a muslim , only shiites almost made me left islam.
😭Dont follow them please.. Islam teaches us patience fasting is not wrong.
Why don't you simply fast for the ahle bayt then? You do other practices that weren't done anyway...
I am sunni but wallahi sunni hadiths don't make sense and most sunnis want to keep their eyes and ears closed. May Allah guide us.
Farah mut3a child why r u lying
@@AF-zr6px son of Adam, do you know my parents? Do you know our Prophet Muhammad pbuh and his beloved family? 🤔
@@farahmo4519 Being Sunni isn't inherited from your parents
@@stevenv6463 vast majority of people follow their parents beliefs. What's yours?
@@farahmo4519 My parents were nominally Christian but I became Muslim. Alhamdulillah
If you were born to Sunni parents but don't believe Sunni Hadith over Shia ones, then you are Shia
Oh yes for Muslims ashura is supposed to be the 10th of Muharram as they follow the lunar calendar after prophet Muhammad but for jews ashura would have been the tenth of Gregorian calendar the tenth of January or December can't differentiate.
How can fasting in the name of allah be makruh... Prophet sallallahu alaihi wasallam used to fast every Monday and Thursday..ok let's accept that Jewish calender does not coincide with the day of Ashura of Muharram .. but what's wrong in fasting? What do we lose? Fasting is an act of worship. How can fasting be makruh?
The previous hadith itself says that jews did fast to celebrate the victory of Moses but before the battle of Karbala and now how could we celebrate the martyrdom of imam Hussain (a.s)!
@@qamaronnisa801 fasting is an act of worship how can it be correlated to celebrating the martyrdom of Imam Hussain (R.A)?
Are you fasting to respect/acknowledge the martyrdom of the grandson of prophet Muhammad (s.a.w.s.) or because of fake hadits related to the jews story?
Fasting supporting an invalid cause is makrooh
Basically I am fasting for the event of Imam Hussain and His Family faced in Karbala I haven't read those Jews Hadith from Sunni sources.
I am also Ismaili Shia in my mind came and I fast on 9 & 10th of Muharram for the sake of Prophet Family
Moula Qabool Karen
Aameen
I never find any harm for fasting in Ashura the Niyat Is an important factor if we are fasting for celebrating that Event which was placed and forgetting an Event of Karbala so obviously it is bad while if we're fasting and remembering an each things happened in Karbala so there seems nothing harm in my opinion
Ya Ali Madad
Why would I trust Bukhari & Muslim?
You wouldnt believe cause you're shiite
@@allahswarrior7050 so shia believe in wich book... Rather then quran
czcams.com/video/wPk5ZyZPjxw/video.html
In this particular matter imams have said similar hadiths in Shia books
drosq8.com/play.php?catsmktba=12343
@@ghadakhafagi4057 the book of jafariyat?
Theres not a single isnad in al kafi that is authentic yet you question the authenticity of bukhari? The entire book is exaggerated and slanderous. After extensively studying the shia and their beliefs theres no questions they are outside the fold of Islam.
for shia were is the evidence of flogging yourself during ashura
Imam al-Sadiq (as) about fasting
I swear upon the Lord of the Sacred House (the Ka‘bah)! Such a day is not a day for fasting. That day is only reserved for sorrow and mourning that has been inflicted on the inhabitants of the skies and the earth altogether. It is a day of happiness and pleasure for the son of Marjanah and Ibn Ziyad’s partisans and the people of Sham.
Allah’s curse be on them and their offspring. The day of ‘Ashura is a day when all the tombs and mausoleums of the earth except the tombs of Sham cry for al-Husayn. Therefore, Allah will unite on the Day of Resurrection anyone who fasts on that day or looks upon that day as a day of celebration with Ibn Ziyad and his partisans, discontent with a transformed heart…’”
Al-Kafi, vol. 4, p. 147, hadith 7; Wasa’il al-Shi‘ah, vol. 10, p.
I also heard that on 10th Muharram prophets faced difficulties is this true
Yazeed did not kill Hussein radia allahu alayh you shia did
@@wewinners7338 are u stupid ?
Last i check the prophet s.a.w. didn't ask u to fast because of Hussain.
@@wewinners7338 i feel pity on you ... You claim to love and follow Prophet Muhammad ﷺ but don't love His grandson and family ... And respecting banu umayya who are the killers on Imam Hussain ع... Those Laeen ل disrespected the daughters, sisters and wives of Aal e Muhammad ﷺ .... Slapped those innocent even to Syeda Sakina ص who was just a 4 years old kid .. and even those Laeen slaughtered 6 months old infant Hazrat Prince Ali Asghar ع.... But you don't care about it ... What kind of Muslim you're????? ... By just saying all that rubbish in cmnts simply proves your UNCONDITIONAL love for Muhammad and Aale Muhammad ﷺ
Since when a shia scholar understands the chain of hadith , uou don't even know tawheed lol
الله مستعان
why don’t you watch his ‘islamic beliefs’ course before making this baseless statement?
@@tripleduck
I'm an ex shia I've lived this shirk life I know all about it , the most misguided jahil people are the shia scholars tryst me , I'm sorry don't mean to be rude my family is still shia , just read the books of shia , full of shirk and bid'ha
Alhumdulillah Allah guided me
@@stepstojannah8173 I'm sad to hear that. You are surely misguided by shaytan. I pray to Allah to guide you again and open your way to jannah sister. We all will see and know who were in the right path on the day of judgement InShaAllah.
@@afzaali1256
Thank you but really you should compare sunism with shiasm and be sincere ,then Allah may guide you
Alhumdulillah I'm certain , I mean its clear sunism is all about tawheed where shiasm is nothing but shirk
May Allah guide us all
@@stepstojannah8173 I have done quite well comparison. From the beginning up to date. From when the wilayat of Imam Ali a.s (ghadeer khum) was taken away from him. When ever this topic came up while me speaking to my sunni friends (classmates). They give up and reply me no more just by simply saying 'history is history and what have happened have happened we have noting to say, we follow what our forefathers have followed'...... is this justice, is this how it works? No dear. And when I ask them to read the history, they say sunni scholars consider reading history as haram... why so? Common sense! Cause the truth will come out.
حَدَّثَنَا مُسَدَّدٌ ، حَدَّثَنَا إِسْمَاعِيلُ ، عَنْ أَيُّوبَ ، عَنْ نَافِعٍ ، عَنِ ابْنِ عُمَرَ رَضِيَ اللَّهُ عَنْهُ ، قَالَ : صَامَ النَّبِيُّ صَلَّى اللَّهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ عَاشُورَاءَ ، وَأَمَرَ بِصِيَامِهِ ، فَلَمَّا فُرِضَ رَمَضَانُ تُرِكَ ، وَكَانَ عَبْدُ اللَّهِ لَا يَصُومُهُ ، إِلَّا أَنْ يُوَافِقَ صَوْمَهُ .
رسول اللہ صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم نے یوم عاشورہ کا روزہ رکھا تھا اور آپ صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم نے اس کے رکھنے کا صحابہ رضی اللہ عنہم کو ابتداء اسلام میں حکم دیا تھا، جب ماہ رمضان کے روزے فرض ہو گئے تو عاشورہ کا روزہ بطور فرض چھوڑ دیا گیا، عبداللہ بن عمر رضی اللہ عنہما عاشورہ کے دن روزہ نہ رکھتے مگر جب ان کے روزے کا دن ہی یوم عاشورہ آن پڑتا۔
Sahih Bukhari#1892
Status: صحیح
Ashura' commemorates the day that Allah saved the Children of Israel from Pharaoh.
Fasting on Muharram 10, known as the Day of 'Ashura', expiates for the sins of the past year. When the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) arrived in Madinah in 622 CE, he found that the Jews there fasted on Muharram 10 and asked them the reason for their fasting on this day. They said," This is a blessed day. On this day Allah saved the Children of Israel from their enemy (in Egypt) and so Prophet Musa [Moses] fasted on this day giving thanks to Allah."
The Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) said,
"We are closer to Musa than you are."
He fasted on that day and commanded Muslims to fast on this day. (Al-Bukhari) The following year, Allah commanded the Muslims to fast the month of Ramadan, and the fasting of 'Ashura' became optional. It is also reported that the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) intended to fast on the ninth and tenth. Ibn 'Abbas reported: The Messenger of Allah fasted on the day of 'Ashura' and ordered the people to fast on it. The people said, "O Messenger of Allah, it is a day that the Jews and Christians honor." The Prophet said, "When the following year comes, Allah willing, we shall fast on the ninth." The death of the Prophet came before the following year. (Muslim and Abu Dawud) For more on 'Ashura' and Muharram, please read: The Significance of Fasting the Day of 'Ashura' Virtues of the Month of Muharram & Fasting during It
Thus, according to scholars, you may choose to fast 'Ashura' on three days (ninth, tenth, and eleventh); two days (ninth and tenth); or one day only (the tenth). The Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) said, "Fasting the day of 'Ashura' (is of great merits), I hope that Allah will accept it as an expiation for (the sins committed in) the previous year." (Muslim) But this expiation of minor sins comes only if you avoid major sins. It is a big mistake to rely on fasting a single day to "wipe your slate clean." If you neglect your daily Prayers or the fast of Ramadan, or if you backbite, lie, commit adultery or other major sins, fasting on 'Ashura' alone will not atone for your sins.
The great scholar Ibn Al-Qayyim Al-Jawziyya (b. 691 AH/1292 CE) wrote: This misguided person does not know that fasting in Ramadan and praying five times a day are much more important than fasting on the Day of Arafah and the Day of 'Ashura', and that they expiate for the sins between one Ramadan and the next, or between one Friday and the next, so long as one avoids major sins. But they cannot expiate for minor sins unless one also avoids major sins; when the two things are put together, they have the strength to expiate for minor sins. Among those deceived people may be one who thinks that his good deeds are more than his sins, because he does not pay attention to his bad deeds or check on his sins, but if he does a good deed he remembers it and relies on it.
Habibi the Prophet doesn’t get his Shari’ah and inspiration from Jews
Bro did you even watch the video? 😂
This was only made , so that Muslims forget about the MASSACRE OF KARBALA AND IMAM HUSSEIN (A), it's political in it's MAIN title. This never took place, and the hadeeth is fabricated, so Muslims over the years don't take a stance and resist the tyrannical and oppressive governments.
It's in Shia books too. This person doesn't know his own books
@@ghalibahmed6676 Check your own books about fasting in Ashurah. It's the same as in Sunni books
drosq8.com/play.php?catsmktba=12343
Because RasulAllah sallallahu alaihi wasallam his family ahle bayt and companions fasted on this day.
Why do shias beat themselves?
Shia scholars mainly read bukhari and muslim. Instead they should read kaafi of Yakub kalini and then analyze it. It is very wise of shia leaders that they keep shias away and ignorent of what is there in kaafi. Like Barhmans of Hindus kept shudras away from vedas.
Problem with scholars like you is you think Ahlul Sunnah are like Ahle Tashee public who dont read Quran nor hadith and accept whatever their scholars say...
But thats not the case....you can make your public fool but not every muslim
Shia were not present at the time of Prophet.....u emerged from nowhere
Is prophet did command self inflicting pain like the shia are doing? I think shia tradition is more problematic. If you disregard hadith since it is problematic then atleast you must follow what is in the QUR'AN
Such doing never practice by prophet Muhammad and even Ali A.S
And atleast hadith is debatable if not acceptable but selfinflicting is no sense to be part of Islamic tradition.
If you are talking about age Prophet Muhammad is the youngest among prophet.
the prophet did mourn for the death of imam hussein...did you know that? theres nothing wrong with slapping your chest. No harm to the body in doing so.
@@AdamTaghavi1 the prophet said that those who hit themselves and tear their clothes are not one of us
@@synczy7307
Tell those that go overboard, not the right-minded amongst us.
U can't mourn for anybody's death greater than 3 days
czcams.com/video/wPk5ZyZPjxw/video.html
So what implies that he spoke to Jews on hijri 1.... It was 10th hijri...As PBUH said it I would be alive I will fast either a day boforeor after....so all mis information with due respect
Hey super intelligent man....in bukhari this hadith is narrated by Abdullah Ibn Umar and by Talha bin Ubaid Ullah and Hazrat Ayesha R.A. in hadith no. 1891, 1892 and 1893...it is not narrated by Abdullah ibn Abbass
When you guys will stop spreading lies???
Secondly, this event took place in the last year of Prophet S.A.W life, because Prophet S.A.W also said if I am present next year I will fast on either 9th or 11th of muharram as well to differentiate from them (jews).. and by that time hazrat Abdullah ibn Abbas was 14 years of age because he was born in 3 BH
If you love the prophet you shouldn’t have insulted the wives of the prophet SAW the mothers of the beliviers
I am sunni but I love Shia
You are Sunni and love Shia? You wouldn't say that if you knew what they say about Aisha and the companions of Muhammad sallallahu alaihi wasallam. And that preacher is not more value as a particle of dust in relation to ibn Abbas. He is a great Jahil who speaks with jahil . May Allah guide him and may Allah curse all people who curses the companions of Muhammad sallallahu alaihi wasallam.
@RF Eng. Where did I say that all Shia are disbelievers?
I am Shia and I love Sunni & Sunni speakers like Nouman Ali Khan
@@hojboj3222thanks that's so sweet of you!
@RF Eng. Allah knows who is in the right path but looking Quran and shia ali practices it is gone to far that we can say that is going SHIRK
You Shiites have doubts about fasting on the day of ashura , when your version of ashura didn’t even exist during the time of the prophet (pbuh) 🧐
A shia talking about the science of hadith is funny in itself .
It is like an earthworm teaching others how to fly .
You people dont have any such tradition ,if any than that is because of the influence of people of sunnah .
The people who follow Quran and sunnah on the manhaj of sahaba (which includes the ahlul bayt as well )
I think out of respect for prophet Musa (saws) we should still fast for thr same reason adding an extra day for respect. Passover is coincided with our Sacrificial Eid so the Sunni point of view is to be respected as well assuming they also celebrate the better known Ashura of ahl ul bayt.
الغضب العلوي تفجر
It didn't happen on that day.
czcams.com/video/wPk5ZyZPjxw/video.html
The sheikh was trying to argue that the Sunni hadith he quoted was fabricated also apparently the Jewish day for that fasr wasn’t at the time of 10th Muharram it was for another month
Pls read my reply to him. He doesn't even know his own books
Lol 😂. According sunni, All Sahih Bukhari and Sahih Muslim hadits are Authentic
Causing pain to one's own self is a sign of ignorance narrated in sahih hadees.Then why does Shia do matam and cause pain to themselves .However Allah choses the martyers to grant them Jannatul Firdaus .Sign of a believer is that when they are in musibat they say InnaLillahi wa innaa Ilayhi Rajioon.
When our PROPHET (S.A.W.S) passed away from this World . HAZRAT SYEDNA IMAM HUSAIN (RZ) was four to five years old and he too was a Child . So , do Shia follows the Hadees narrated by IMAM HUSAIN (RZ)
Great Straw man argument!
Please Talk on concrete facts, which hadis you are referring from Hazart imam Hussain a.s please elaborate
I am saying all of Hadees which were narrated by Imam Hussain RZ
Many SAHABA ( Companions of PROPHET S.A.WS ) were 4vto 5 years . So do you people won't accept there narrations ?
@@iqbalquadri8117 first and foremost there is no hadis from Imam Hussain a.s which he narrated at this age, it was Hazrat Ali a.s and secondly its not only us but in the actual criteria of narration of hadis that can be considered authentic is not accepted for very young kids like 3-4 years. You need to do a thorough and unbiased research to understand this. Thank you
MashaAllah
Bro u do the matam.. Where as it is not permissible according to our school of thoughts. Can't we even bare the pain off imam by fasting at least.
What if your wrong? Probably should fast for Allah subhanahu wa ta’ala!
There are so many other days to fast. The benefits remain the same. May Allah swt open up our intuition and our hearts to truths, and give us the strength to fast today. No one is stopping you, as long as you know your heart is open in love for God and in His submission. If we do things to disrespect His messenger and his descendants, it just says more about us than Allah swt.
Prophet Muhammad saww is our primary prophet, not Prophet Musa a.s.
So unless we're also Jewish, the saving of the Israelites probably holds less on our hearts than the massacre of 74 innocent souls, many of whom were direct descendents of the Holy Prophet saww and Islam was SAVED in its original form because of this.
Just something to think about.
One day, so much confusion. Makes me understand why it's so difficult to remain Muslim in these end of days times.
The fact is 18000 kufans shia e ali done bayyah to muslim bin aqeel that they will give imam hussain side if he comes to kufa . However ubayd ullah ibn ziad was very clever and bridbed them all . Who was ibn ziad ? His father was appointed govneor in iraq by mola ali.. these were shia e ali influences too . Shimar joshi was also in the camp of mola ali in battle of safeen.. The fact is it wasent just the yazidis it was also those who claimed to be shia e ali that let down imam hussain like they did with his father . The famous hadith of bibi zainab was that these kufans will be regeetting this till the day of qiymmat. Those who proclaim it was sunnis that killed imam hussain know that the real truth is yaziid the pleet will be with the dogs in fire.
There's nothing hard I this world like truth.
Ok as a Sunni I also agree with your commentary. Ok then why you beat yourself on 10th of muharram? Did Muhammad (saw) beat up h8s self when his closest companions where brutally massacred at war?
If we could please have straight forward and coherent responses from our Sunni brethren instead of beating around the bush that would be great thanks 🙏
U expect logic and humbleness from banu saqifa??? Imam Ali and other ahlulbayt were too nice for these b@stards , These people are supporter of those people who saw their idols being smashed by Ali(as) , there forefathers were sl@ughtered in jamal and siffin by Ali himself don't expect these people to show an inch of respect for muhammad and aale muhammad.
The level sectarian nonsense is epic with this one. He questions Ashura fasting hadith ascribing it back to Ibn Abbas who was 4 years old etc.. Here is what's in hadees books, and these narrations go back to Ali (RA) and Aisha (RA) -
1- It was narrated from `Ali (رضي الله عنه) that The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) used to fast on the day of `Ashoora’ and enjoined others to do so.
Grade: Hasan because of corroborating evidence; this is a da'eef isnad because of the weakness of Jabir al-Ju'fi] (Darussalam)
Reference : Musnad Ahmad 1069
In-book reference : Book 5, Hadith 487
2- Narrated `Aisha:
Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) ordered (the Muslims) to fast on the day of 'Ashura', and when fasting in the month of Ramadan was prescribed, it became optional for one to fast on that day ('Ashura') or not.
Reference : Sahih al-Bukhari 2001
In-book reference : Book 30, Hadith 106
USC-MSA web (English) reference : Vol. 3, Book 31, Hadith 219
Did you even bother to listen what he was saying before commenting?
Sir but there is a Hadith on musnad Ahmad I cannot recall the number but it is recommended to fast on 10th of muharram and also an extra fast before or after asshura in order to be different from jews
Glass color defines surrounding color
I think it a wrong idea. Because if you observed the life of Hazrat Mohammad (SA), he fasted this day. So all sahabi saw that and followed him. Then it is Mukruh now?
It's the pagans who used to fast this day. Check it out
czcams.com/video/wPk5ZyZPjxw/video.html
@Noor Latif Show me the hadith from Muawiyah and please translate that for me in English.
Please this happened the last year of the holy prophet
Masha Allah 💖
he's simply trying to prove our phrophet (pubh) liar, naauzubillah... astagfirullah how can he do this. may allah guide him
No, he's trying to prove that these hadits are not authentic.
Remember that many have brought in their own hadit in the nameif our Prophet. It's our duty to ensure these fake hadits are removed as soon as possible
I can't believe I fasted on the right day. alhamdulillah.
Lmao it’s haram to fast and celebrate on the 10th of Muharram
@@GreenTaqwashut up
perfectly explained
None of the companion of Prophet or Prophet's narration is weak .Allah gave all the companions of Prophets title of raziAllahu .You should be respectful when you refer them .
Ya sheikh check the hadith of qatada radiallahu anhu is sahih
I don't care what he is saying. I am sunni but I respect shias too ❤️
Why you dont care? Its your religion brother. You should seek the truth doesn’t matter where it is. Make Allah (swt) pleased with you. Wish you the best.
Don't take anything from these Rawafid Zakirs unless you go and verify it with Ahlusunnah ulama. He is brainwashing his audience and altering, destorting, and corrupting the ahadith.
I can bet on this. 😆
I challenge you go and check the ahadith he mentioned and verify them with ulama you will know the truth. They speak lies, propaganda and mislead their audience in the name of Ahlul Bait.
@@seanselby001 Did you ever verify the ahadith of ahlul sunnah? You are presenting yourself and your law school as if you are 100% on the truth. And your only argument is „because we are sunni and we are always right and we are the measurement“
No Shia is brainwashing you. We just telling you to read your own books. But most of the sunnis dont even know their own books and believe everything what the sheikh tells him. For example: Thaqalayn, its not Quran and Sunnah, its Quran and Ahlul Bayt.
Will you call me a liar and accuse me of brainwashing you or will you do your duty as a muslim and educate yourself (neutral) on this topic?
good luck, wasalam
@@hamsa446 they are in darkness and misguidance
they cursed umar, uthman and ayeesha. they don't respect us sunnis.
The modern ashura is mad by Jewish and Iran pagan mind of dividing Muslims . according their believe Ali and husein R..A . can help people
However it is not obligatory to fast on 10 Muharram after fard Ramzan came .Any who wants to fast can fast and who doesn't want to fast can do that also .
Yazeed did not kill Hussein radia allahu alayh you shia did
@@wewinners7338 may Allah raise you with Yazeed.
@@burhanhussain8697 don't use excuse to curse other's, once ayatollah Khomeini said, "Shia's have no right to curse sunnis.
Second thing, fasting on ashura is not happiness but if you see in second sense, it is also method to feel hunger of companions in karbala. Please my brother, leave the sects of shia and sunni, be true Muslim and don't get involved in division.
@burhanhussain8697 ameen. And may Allah also make him share a room with yazeed. There is a special place on hell for yazid and his lovers .😂
That is where the genius who announced that shias killed Imam Hussein has a reserved place next to yazid
Sheikh so its better we beat ourselves on day of ashura than fasting.
It's better to read the events of Karbala in detail
There are 20 hadiths not just one 2nd ibn Abbas is sahabi if sahabi narrate anything regarding prophet saw then it means it's authentic and for your 3rd logic ibn Abbas was born in 619 and prophet saw died on 632 so it means he was not 4year old you should first learn these things before misguiding innocent Muslims imam hassan as narrated about due e qannot which is done in vitar Nimaz and imam hassan was 8 year old but still we accept this hadees because imam hassan is also a sahabi so plZ don't misguide if u follow really imam Ali
Shia books say the same as the Sunni books
drosq8.com/play.php?catsmktba=12343
My dear brother, did you just do 632 - 619 = 13 which is not equal to 4 year old? So you mean to say that when prophet was dying, it was at this moment the story of jews unfolded? Rethink brother.
What did the sahabis said about the event of Ghadeer when Imam Ali (a.s.) was made the prophet's sucessor
@@alijafri786 dear if ibn Abbas was just 4year but at the time when prophet die he was 13 so he heard it from prophet so Hadith is true and 2nd there are more than 50 hadiths narrated by different shabha so you can't deny fast of 10 Muharram and 2nd prophet said that keep 9muharrum fast to so there were no resemblance with Jews
@@furqan3679 Can you share the link to exact hadith with reference of Ibn Abbas. I want to read the original text.
@@alijafri786 hadiths of ashura start from Sahi Muslim 2637 to onwards you will find it easily
Clearly this guy doesn’t even know what he’s talking about…clearly he’s not a sunni
Not everyone is a Sunni and Muslims should unite. Not focus on differences but what we have in common. Mutual love for ISLAM and Allah. Sunni/Shia doesn't even matter in the US.
czcams.com/video/wPk5ZyZPjxw/video.html
@@vijayb6380We don't listen to the likes of Zakir Nayak. They are puppets and would take out any phrase and mould it and speak anything for money
@@alijafri786 ANY PHRASE?? go n validate yourself before u say that..
He's not the only in you tube if u personally hate him.. there' are many other prominent scholars who give guidance with reference of Quran n Hadith.. whether u want to follow as per P(saw) or random human logic, is upto u
Probably as per you, whatever Sunni people do is wrong. You ppl have even changed the kalima, how can we trust you.
How can Musa save the bani israeel on each month on the 10th from pharaoh. Also has it ever crossed his mind that ibn abbas could've said what the prophet saws said about the jews fasting and then he did it also when he was qualified
Read my reply to him. This person doesn't know his own books
Did you even understand what he meant to say? Also, if you believe the hadits from the likes of Maviya rather than the hadits fro prophet's own household then my dear brother, you are on the wrong path.
Walaa Tafarraquu wata kuunuu SHIYA'A .......... Then why should you call your self Shia while Allah tell us dont be among them. Please brothers try to know the TRUTH behind the BEGINNING OF SHIAYISM before following it.
A Rawafidh talking about Chain of Narrations.. Lol... Doomsday is coming..
Read my reply to him ... these hadiths are also in Shia books through other narrators
your comment is disrespectful and full of arrogance
Where Prophet peace be upon Him didn't mention Muharram is that it was obvious and not required to mention since they were at that time
The same way it was obvious in regards to Ghadir?
The one who beat their chests are the ones who don't have love for our prophet , ahl al Bayt and sahabas ..
We Sunnis are commanded to walk on the path of Calipha e rashidun i.e. Hazrat Abu Bakr r.a. , Hazrat Umar r.a. , Hazrat uthman r.a. , Hazrat Ali r.a. , Hazrat Hasan Ibn Ali r.a. and the sahabas and the martyrs of Islam
We respect all your imams except Imam Mehdi r.a. because he's not even born yet ... We respect Them more than you
Where are you commanded? Did the prophet command you? If not, this is biddah.
You respect the Ahlulbayt so much that you fast in celebration on ashura because the jews were freed from firaoun's tyranny but you don't care that the Prophet's grandson was killed brutally on ashura.
Masha Allah Excellent Video
Great answer, Sheikh 👍
czcams.com/video/wPk5ZyZPjxw/video.html
This video is just like how salafis condemn mawlid.
Mowlid is their birthday it’s shia birthday 😂
@@Ibn_al_sham123 mawlid is the birthday of prophet muhammad. I'm not sure what your comment meant cuz sunnis celebrate it too.
@@freepalestine1673 sunnis called sunnis because we follow the ( sunnah ) of the prophet Mohammad ﷺ and the mowlid the shia created it after more than 500 years after him
@@freepalestine1673 The first to invent this were the kings of the Fatimid state in the fourth century AH and those who called them (Al-Mu’izz li-Din Allah) and it is known that he and his people are all heretical Ismailis, philosophical.
He is right
What a stupid excuse for a so called Muslim. Ibnu Abbas was not 4, because prophet Muhammad, SAW fasted the year before he past away not when he came to madinna. As the hadith says if I live to next year I'll fast on the 9th as well which he did not live to. The other thing about month not being known is silly, are you telling us that the prophet and his sahabba did not know which month is which how ridiculous. You rather beat yourself and cry the cry of wolf then follow the sunnah, it was pure coincidence that Hussein RA was unfortunately killed this day.
I am sure Prophet knew the month but he’s saying the word Ashura on the 10th of Muharram became popular because of Imam Hussain and shia commemorating Imam Hussain martyrdom. However, back in the day every 10th of the month was referred to as Ashura. Your book doesn’t specify of the month since every 10th was referred to as Ashura. For example Prophet Muhammad could’ve said Ashura in Safar. P.S hope you realize this is Saudi propaganda to minimize the importance of 10th of Muharram. Wahhabis are pushing to fast on the 10th of Muharram and telling people it’s a celebratory day so people don’t get to know about Imam Hussain and the sacrifice he made for Islam on this day.
@@lymphtics9218 exactly!!!
Kulayni) says, “I asked this same question from Imam al-Sadiq’s (as) father, too. He gave the same answer as Imam al-Sadiq (as) and added,
Beware! This is a fast about which no Qur’anic verse has been revealed and is not an observed way of conduct. It was only the way of conduct for the partisans of Ziyad when they killed al-Husayn ibn ‘Ali (as)’.” This is a fast which was discontinued after the Qur’anic verse enacting the fast of the holy month of Ramadan was revealed. Doing that which is abandoned is an act of innovation
Al-Kafi, vol. 4, p. 146, hadith 4; Wasa’il al-Shi‘ah, vol. 10, p.
اسم السيد بلا زحمة
Plzz built correct knowledge
I don't know howcan we be shia
You ate checking the chain of bukhari. Great. Have you ever chekced the chain of 'usoole Kafi'? I doubt you have ever seen Kaafi or red it ever. Go and check your mother books first. There are more than thousands of statements in usoole kaafi without proper chain.
We never claim it to be Sahih. You call your books Sahih.
Alaihissalm
اسم السيد
Fasting not Ashura is haram since it’s imitating Jews. It’s not even makrooh but haram
It is not imitating the Jews, we have more right to Musa then the Jews and the prophet pbuh added one more day of fasting so we are different then them.
But don’t you have the a right on prophet Muhammad (saw) more than Musa(as)? Your Hadiths state the prophet himself never fasted on this day so why do you? Also you’re Nabi Muhammad’s(saw) ummah not Nabi musa’s (as) so you’re supposed to follow him (saw) first.
Also, the Jews don’t fast on this day because Musa (as) was saved but rather they fast because God gave Musa (as) the 10 commandments. There is no such fast not even for Jews for the day when Musa (as) was saved. So if anybody should be fasting it should Jews on this day not Muslims. So why do you fast on a day which never even existed?
Sunnate Nabwi VS Bidate Umawi
May Allah s.w.t guide you to the truth. Astakfaar you are denying Bukharl and Muslim shareef
firstly denying bukhari does not make you a non-muslim because bukhari is not Quran accept Quran there is no book that can never have a mistake and secondly he is not denying the whole bukhari is just talking about single fabricated hadees
Lol I didn’t know Bukhari and Muslim were Gods words and even if, he’s not denying, he’s explaining it a lot of the Hadith in your books ARE labelled za’eef (weak) so chill
I heard it’s even haram to fast on 10th of Muharram.
prophet Muhammad (saw) said that fasting is prohibited on Eid ul fitr and Eid ul Adha
Fasting is only prohibited on Eid and if the person is impure
Other than that its allowed in fact fasting is actually really good for your soul and cleans your sins away
@@simrajamil5814 yes
czcams.com/video/wPk5ZyZPjxw/video.html