The Language of the Gods: Sanskrit | Arth - A Culture Fest, Delhi
Vložit
- čas přidán 10. 09. 2024
- David Frawley, Nagaraj Paturi & Sampadananda Mishra in conversation with Hema Hari.
What are the ideals of a language like Sanskrit? David Frawley, Nagaraj Paturi & Sampadananda Mishra raise the question and discuss with Hema Hari at Arth - A Culture Fest.
Subscribe to our channel: / arthaculturefest
Follow us on our social handles:
Twitter: / arth_live
Facebook: / arthlive
Instagram: / arth_live
Do read Rajiv Malhotra sir's book 'The Battle for Sanskrit'. It will provide you with the tremendous knowledge on the subject.
Yes. It also tells of the indologists trying so hard to malign our heritage.
Sanskrit is beautiful and Structured language😍😍😍😍
Correction it samskrit
@@musicnav8394Correct spelling in IAST (International Alphabet of Sanskrit Transliteration) is - Saṃskṛta.
संस्कृत् ❎
संस्कृत ✅
We are indebted to Dr. Fawley for acknowledging the universally prevailing importance of Oam. We Hindustanis look dwarfs in comparison to Dr. Fawley. हरि ॐ
We are busy running behind job and money while the Acharya became Rishi through sadhana.
David Frawley is modern Rishi
czcams.com/video/t4Hadm3cQjQ/video.html
You forget Jay lakhani
No Rishi would have a Judaeo/Christian name.
I too like him so much for his wisdom
Swami Paramatma name is not judeochrstian ...name comes from language swing
He is also known as vamdev shahtri
The only sanskrit speaking village is Mattooru village in Shimoga district of karnataka
The only Sanskrit daily newspaper is Sudhanwa from mysore Karnataka
Sanskrit language was protected by Southern Hindu Vijayanagara empire started by two Kannadiga warrior brothers Harihara and Bukkaraya of Karnataka when it was almost on the verge of destruction by outside invaders
Kanndigas Telugus and Malayalis use and even common man understands more sanskrit words in day to day speech than by any speakers of north indian languages
The great book Kautilya's Arthashastra in sanskrit was rediscoverd in the library of Mysore Wodeyar Maharaja by south Indian a sanskrit scholar
In addition to Brahmins, Jains and Lingayat communities of Karnataka have a long history of sanskrit pandithya and religious literary tradition
Now we came to a point were a talk on Samskrutham is given in English language, that to people of India.
Thank you for this informative session, it is very insightful. So beautiful
Thanks to the organizers. It is enlightening to listen to learned people on the subject. I wish such sessions be convened and these learned professors be given more time to speak more and more
OM Or AUM Is The Universal Sound Of Vibrations, Words Are Sound Spoken In Any Language Of The Tongue!
Most brilliant program. Feel like going back to school now. Feel like an illiterate with English now.
There is no escaping now with English. The idea is while english remains the communication language so far,, We must still learn Sanskrit. Learning sanskrit it self opens up the dormant brain cells and DNA. Who knows Sanskrit may take over English. Lets make the beginning into the new future.
This is absolutely remarkable. I take pride in our rich culture and this has ofcourse strengthen my positivity towards it. Sansktitam can is the best way for Indians to revive it's own culture.
Omg my favorite David
How can someone dislike this lovely video .
Sanskrit is the soul of all Indian languages...hence there should not be any adversaty against any..all languages have deep respect.Event the western theologist who have studies the comparative religion...say only Sanskrit language has the terms to describe the spiritual journey to higher realms...like Yojana to describe distance,palang the measurement of continents,dweepa described by Rishis innner dimensions of Brahmananda,Madalas,Parbramas.
Vishva-Samskrita-Dinam..... Sabhi logon ko 🙏
Let's teach the entire world Samskrtam 🙏🙏🙏
Proud of our heritage
tamil is also perfect as sanskrit....... grammer of tamil was dictated by shiva himself { I m not tamilian}
What did u get from this !!? . Nothing .These scholars r repeatedly explaining it's SAMSKRUT & meaning still u guys following the same . Durbhagya
Very good conversation
i am proud of heritage< but will learn English . All speakers are proficient in English.
Thanks for educative discourse. Why not bring out ancient history related to the country
All excellent speakers including the host. Too short a session.
अतिउत्तम
Does the english word hand derived from Sanskrit word hasta?
might be...
like 'Path' from 'पथ'
Juggernaut from जगन्नाथ
Yes dr
i have decided to learn samskrit bhasha ,it begins
13:55 "as though they were doing it for a computer or a computer like system" sir that system is our brain :) cognitive linguistics :D
19:40 ankhein khuli ki hkhuli reh jayngi hriday ke bare m sun kr
Brilliant brilliant brilliant!
Atleast write Samskrit correctly in the video's title ...
It is sad to see that the panel discussion regarding the beauty of Sanskrit was in English. If we cannot talk about the ancient language of Sanskrit, using the present Indian languages such as Hindi, Urdu etc., I'm afraid it will be very difficult, if not impossible, to revive Sanskrit.
Listen Donald Duck
Urdu first of all is not indian
It's a language which is just corruption
Of hindi
There are SouthIndian viewers too
So Hindi is not essential
It is because we don't know Sanskrit and David Frawley don't know Hindi
@@sattwikmohanty3272 xcatly this hindi , urdu shud be kicked outta bharatiyo sangbidhan. sanskrit in neutral lipi can come in there.
The problem is with pronunciation and not English. We need to teach people how to pronounce the word 'Sanskrit'. The same problem we had with Bangalore hence the spelling was changed to Bengaluru thereby distorting it, now the first two parts can be pronounced like you do the state of Bengal-uru. Again we need to teach people how to pronounce. The problem could have been solved by telling people that Bang is not pronounced like the English word bang but like bang in Bangladesh.
Great session 👍
Love David
Sanskrit is a nice language with special qualities but please keep it separate from our mother tongues. Both are beautiful to me and no need for any language like English/Sanskrit to boss over my mother tongue!!
When frawley says "all the worlds linguistics came out of sanskrit" is he saying that all the 7000 languages of the world are related to sanskrit? And that there is ultimately only one language family?
Yes, everything derived from samskrith
Yes
Maybe not each and every language on planet Earth. That is an exxageration. But 90% of modern languages that are spoken today in the world are born out of Sanskrit. And this is not a claim. There is enough study, proofs and evidences to show that.
26:19 both sanks and tamil
At last Indians are realising their true self....
bangla is older than sanskrit , shud b link bhasha of bharatbarsha
7:53
God knows Languages! Ha...ha...ha....
Ya it's good entertainment and time pass .
First sound Om is from God. Without languages how are you going to communicate or understand what God is? Finally, God can be found when all words and religions come to end for the person. Hence when your mind stops and goes to silence.
I do know, Ana Al Haq.
@@suethompson6497 how do you explain and imagine of God?
samar Inam Not as somebody related to one religion or other, nor in a specified language or culture sitting beyond the sky controlling the fate of humans and all beings on the planet. God can’t be known by finite mind, even the word God is not enough to describe what you are asking. Languages like Sanskrit/ Tamil evolved by Rishis of old were a tool to help people quieten the mind and help make the search of what this existence is, that we think we live as body and mind.
🙏🙏🙏👌👌👌
Also you can listen to my TEDx talk on Sanskrit here:
czcams.com/video/AmUJLx47ZDg/video.html
Jaihindusthan
CBSE board should 60+40=sanskrit+language
God's language is not Sanskrit. God's language is Silence.
Glorify of sanskrit and hindi ..is being told in english is sad reality
Who is the God ?
Brahman
The gap between our thoughts is also allah or shiva or the formless divine. The space within an atom where electrons move around is also allah or shiva or the formless divine. The space around us is also allah or shiva or the formless divine. Shiva or allah or the formless is both transcendent and immanent
Shiva/allah are omnipresent/omni potent. It is thee reason why hindus do meditation/yoga. Hindus also focus on stone deities in hindu temples and connect with formless shiva or allah within and around while sanskrit mantra vibrations (the divine language) being recited in the background which can help us transcend our 5 senses to access shiva/allah within and withiout. Universe is made of sanskrit vibrations
The gap between our thoughts is also allah or shiva or the formless divine. The space within an atom where electrons move around is also shiva or allah or the formless divine. The space around is also shiva or allah or the formless divine. Shiva or allah is both transcendent and immanent. It is omnipresent and omni potent. Islam, christianity and judaism are wrong in saying formless god is just up there in the sky
@@indianmilitary
Don't equate shiva and allah .
Allah is in some imaginary 7th sky
Shiva is every where
Plz note it is Baasha or bashh which means bark. Sanskrit means stabilised 1 who, where in, and in what context is it used or arrived at? Indian govt. is draining the Exchequer, of common man's tax to enable a corpse to survive. All the three pandits' adivce is like bandit don't try to interpollute Indian languages esp.. Tamil and Dravidian origin and culture try to cheat indo European or indo Iranian language family.and not Dravidian family. Vedas are prayer songs .where is knowledge? it could not able to arrive at finality of what is beyond life . You Pandits' first try to talk in Sanskrit and let the. babblers clap and appreciate
Periyartard barking against Sanskrit while keeping his Sanskrit name!!😂😂😂
What is the God?
If you really want to know, read Geeta (at least), ask questions and try finding answers. You'll be surprised.
Poor God! He can only speak to and understand 24500people in India whose mother tongue is dead sanskrit? God dont know writing UNTILL Guptas period 400CE! So GOD stole Nagars script Nagari and changed the name as Devanagari? God is a plagiarist? There is no god for rest of the world who could not speak Sanskrit? . Peace is built on understanding, and wars are built on misunderstandings.
Hehe..the irony is he is welcoming people to discuss about sanskrit in english..and and and, I am writing this comment too in English
There is no escaping now with English. The idea is while english remains the communication language so far,, We must still learn Sanskrit. Learning sanskrit it self opens up the dormant brain cells and DNA. Who knows Sanskrit may take over English. Lets make the beginning into the new future.
Unfortunately !
samskrit
Ye hindi me kyo nhi bolte adhi bate smj nahi hai
@Tenuguvaadu brother can you please tell me are Telegu people positive towards Samskrit or not, because I have seen many Tamil people like Sadhguru who do not like Samskrit at all.
Megha Dhiman, very good to see that you said this because people in India do not say such thing because they think that if we'll say like this then others will think that we are weak in English and even weak intellectually. They don't think that English is not our mother tongue.
@Tenuguvaadu brother, could you please help me by telling 'what is avadhana prakriya'. By the way why are you being rude with me. I didn't say anything against Telegu, I love all Indian languages including Telegu.
@Tenuguvaadu And also I want to say that my second comment was not to you.
@@officially_nitin
czcams.com/video/OCo5aJOUJTY/video.html
A suggestion going forward. Please don’t make topics so theoretical. Demonstrate what you are trying to convey. Example: talking about a boxed item with blades able to cover 360 degrees while moving air....simply saying Fan drives home the point. This was an opportunity lost to excite people into learning this language. To preserve or help a language or any subject for that matter thrive, the method of teaching MUST be addressed, else this loss will continue.
Gyan chakshu khul gae
Rajiv the plagiarist!
scroll.in/article/740814/plagiarism-row-how-rajiv-malhotra-became-the-ayn-rand-of-internet-hindutva
Last week, historian Richard Fox Young charged Hindutva activist and author, Rajiv Malhotra with plagiarism. Young, an Associate Professor of the history of religions at the US-based Princeton Theological Seminary, listed out seven instances where Malhotra had plagiarised by quoting verbatim or picking ideas from other works without acknowledgement.
Pointing to global academic standards, such as Princeton University’s guidelines on the use of references, Young accused Malhotra of a “lack of academic integrity” given his “repeated failure to acknowledge outside sources”. (A summary of Young’s charges can be found here).
Interestingly, the New Jersey-based Rajiv Malhotra did not deny the charges per se. On Twitter, his defence rested on the fact that the standards Young was citing were too high.
The Malhotra Syndrome
The essay is almost a perfect encapsulation of Malhotra’s style. Containing very little insight, it deals mostly with personal attacks on the people he disagrees with. Some of these can be quite vicious such as when he brings up the fact that scholar Sarah Caldwell was sexually abused as a child in order to refute her work. He characterises American academics studying Hinduism as “psychosexual deviants or other misfits in their own culture” whose writing is driven by the “lucrative market” for “negative exotica and for positive cultural loot”.
To use the words of Amartya Sen, both aim to “to miniaturise the broad idea of a large India ‒ proud of its heterodox past and its pluralist present ‒ and to replace it by the stamp of a small India, bundled around a drastically downsized version of Hinduism”.
According to Lamarkism if some one not use their brain and logical thinking for long time, then their brain become defunct like sanskrit proponents ! 1.. Sanskrit ia an anatolian rudimentary language brought to India by nomadic aryan then perfected.by heavily borrowing from Dravidian and Pali and PRAKRIT. All these borrowed words are plagiarism . sanskritists stole from all.languages but dishonestly claim other languages borrowed from sanskrit. Shame! 2. Do not have a script because it was a oral primitive language .."san script" means no script.. in tamil "Eluthakilavi" means no script. 3. Borrowed dravidian Nagars script called Nagari and changed name as deva-nagari..deva in persian ( original Aryan) language means demons or devils ..sanskrit devils script or devils language! 4. Also 2300 years ago, all Ashoka's inscriptions were in greek and pali no sanskrit indicating no sanskrit language then whereas tamil inscription carbon dated in Keeladi is 2600s old and in Adichanallur 2900yrs old. 5.only perfected and borrowed the script Nagari darvidian during GUPTAS period in 400AD. THEY CHANGED NAME AS DEVANAGARI.. 6. Most sanskrit texts are either translated or plagiarised from dravidian or Buddhist or Jains..7. SANSKRIT is gender and race or caste discriminatory..that is women cannot learn or read or write in sanskrit so also nonbrahmins. So all other indians used their mother tongue dravidian tamil or proto darvidian! there was no women writer or authors on sanskrit whereas there were more than 47 tamil women authors even before sanskrit borrowed developed its script..8. Sanskrit is the youngest Indo-European language ans many vedic and ouranic names were found in Anatolia and the invading aryans brought their Proto sanskrit from Anatolia. 9. Is Sanskrit compulsory in NASA for AI (Artificial Intelligence) research? Robert Frost, Instructor an Flight Controller at NASA Answered Dec 4, 2014: No, that's another internet hoax/urban legend traceable back to a single paper written in 1985 by an indian!
Then where do you all place the "Great Tamil" which is far more better and older but alive till today.
Tamil is good. It actually sounds like the language of the first man. Very primitive sounds.
But doesn't sound like the language of gods
Tamil is just another vernacular language (originated in kaliyuga after 4000 BC) like other indian regional and world languages. Tamil is one of the oldest vernacular language but tamil does NOT have vibratory frequencies which are in sync with resonances of matter. it is the reason why sanskrit is the divine language. Sanskrit sound vibration led to universal forms when soul (shiva) combined with shakthi (intelligent energy). This is vedic metaphysics. It has been validated by both scientific double slit quantum experiment and first person empiricism
😂😂😂, nice joke, tamil nor better, neither older.
@letgoletlive
You are only a bunch of dumbfucks who converted for ricebags
@Arid Arid You are contradicting by your own stand. I don't deal Rice business that I may sell you or give you freely. Neither I beg you for Rice bags. Discussion is about oldest living language. As per you Tamil Nadu should have been named as Sanskrit Desh. Does it make sense ??
And why is God?
To know yourself better, God has created you so that you could have senses to ask this question one day.
Please, as Hindus we should NOT be (mis)using the Monotheistic/Christian terms "God" "gods" and "Lord." Wish David would use his Sanskrit/Hindu name instead of his Monotheistic name.
And that "deeper language" is proto-indo european...not sanskrit
Uhh no. Sanskrit is the oldest. In Satyayuga people only spoke Sanskrit. Later languages were a result of Kaliyuga.
@@veena3648 yes. Of course. You are absolutely correct
@@patrickmccartney7544 There is no proof of proto- indo european langauge other than claims..Only in mother civilization (india) sanskrit culture (sanskriti) is still being preserved in the form of hindu temples, sanskrit mantras/vedic metaphysics, festivals, sashtras (science, dance, music etc) , allegorical stories, ithihasas (ramayana, mahabharatha), Baghavad gita, pilgrimage centers. Sanskrit and sanskriti (culture) are synonymous in india and no other country has it.
You can ask why then the root language is sanskrit for most European languages. it is because of migration of hindu/vedic people from India to other parts of the world before 4000 BC. So called pagans (celts/druids) were descendants of hindu/vedic people who migrated to Europe before 4000 BC. Pagans (who followed distorted hindusim) were converted to christianity by force in 300 AD. Jews and muslims were also descendants of namboodiiri brahmins of kerala who migrated to mecca and jerusalem long before the origins of abrahamic religions.