What does a Judo Black Belt think of Jiu-Jitsu?
Vložit
- čas přidán 16. 03. 2018
- Since Ryan was out of town, we decided to sit down and interview a different kind of martial arts black belt. Meet Idean Salehyan, our Judo black belt instructor in Dallas! So what does he think of the Jiu-Jitsu/Judo debate?
WANT TO LEARN FROM KAMA JIU-JITSU?
Try our new Patreon page! We upload regular tutorial/technique videos for you to study and up your game!
- patreon.com/kamajiujitsu -
Wanna try our Jiu Jitsu in person? We service the Orange County, CA and Dallas/Fort Worth areas teaching adult, children, women, and advanced classes. Contact us today for more info!
kamajiujitsu.com/
WANT TO LEARN RICKSON GRACIE'S JIU-JITSU FROM THE GRANDMASTER HIMSELF? Pick up his Self Defense Unit here!
www.gallerr.com/academy/ricks...
AMAZON AFFILIATE LINKS
Need some Jiu-Jitsu Gi's or apparel?
These should get you going! - amzn.to/2CVDdxl
Check out these Jiu-jitsu books! KJJ Approved!
Gracie Jiu-jitsu Master Text Book by Helio Gracie -amzn.to/2j6gNVk
The Canon of Judo: Classic Teachings on Principles and Techniques - amzn.to/2ybnpV6
Mind Over Muscle: Writings from the Founder of Judo -amzn.to/2ybrdWq
GEAR USED FOR THE VIDEOS:
Panasonic GH5 Camera - amzn.to/2Fa2WaF
Zoom H1 Audio recorder (it's really good) - amzn.to/2oGxtmt
Osmo Mobile Phone Gimble - amzn.to/2FhSIEu
Kama Jiu-Jitsu is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.
Music by:
Xad - Story
/ xad-story - Sport
"A good judo throw is a thing of beauty, it's art."
angel666 if a judo guy flipped you on your ass you would know about it mate
Indeed i do bjj and grappling with judo guys is fun. Before we get to the ground that stand off of who topples who is always so much fun
Judo guy = "I bet you can't take me down"
BJJ guy = "Yes take me down, I dare you."
Now are we talking on a nice, cushy mat, or on asphalt?
@Leo Sim then there's me, who runs really fast.😂
@Leo Sim dude. It was a joke in case it wasn't obvious. I can fight and I've fought quite a bit. 😉
I am personally a judo guy who went to a bjj class I was easily able to take them down, so I was able to have an advantageous position on the ground
How much i have to say JUDO HAVE GROUND TECHNIQUES AND BASED ON JUDO GROUND TECHNIQUES WAS CREATED BJJ.
Oda developed Kosen Judo way before Maeda travelled to Brazil. The ground game was already very advanced in Judo dojos from Kyoto. The rivalry between stand-up Judo vs ground-game Judo already existed before Carlos and Hello were born. It existed in the Tokyo vs Kyoto Judo rivalry. The Kyoto branch of the Kodokan was highly focused on ground work almost exclusively. Granted, the Gracies certainly popularized the ground game across the world, but 80% of modern BJJ is just a slight improvement of what already existed in Judo ne-waza.
Bjj and judo can learn from each and they should respect each other's styles and work together
Daryl Fields I’ve heard that judo is like ice cream, and bjj is like the cherry on top.
@@zackiinu7194 It's more like Judo is ice cream and bjj is gelato at least that's from my experiences
Mo Narchis That’s even better!
Everything BJJ has today is known as Kosen Judo. If you want to see where all and I mean all of your groundwork comes from then just search Kosen Judo and it'll all make sense when you see older Japanese Jodokha's from 70, 80 years ago all the moves are there if you want to search it, spider guard, you'll even see some butt scoutting,. Nothing personal just want to keep it real. I've been training for years and crossed trained with some BJJ clubs by me it was good but I went back to just Judo and really enjoy the fight-ending throws we use if its ever needed. Ask Helio Gracie the founder of BJJ how good Judo's grappling is,
@@aymanabaza6475 I know but bjj people won't acknowledge it
I would really like to see the rift healed. More schools like this that have a Judo program AND a Jiu-Jitsu program, maybe even a wrestling program, to create a school with a complete grappling system. There's no reason BJJ and Judo should be trained a different locations. They are two parts of the same whole.
I agree.
I did Judo in the 1980-90s. Back then, it was 50/50 standing/ground. I won most of my competitions on the ground with submissions. I stopped for university. I came back post 2000s and it was a different sport. In order to keep itself as an Olympic sport, it made itself different than wrestling, more dynamic, and aimed more as standing. The rules changes they implemented were so significant -- no leg grabs, stand after even five seconds of inactivity, fewer partial points, quick penalties for inactivity, etc. -- while led to Judoka just going into guard assuming a quick stand up. IMO, this was too far removed from reality. Without their rules (even at 30+ and out of it for a decade) I could slaughter teen/twenty year-olds on the ground.
I looked ab BJJ, but again, too far removed from reality. Dropping to guard all the time is just asking to be kicked to death.
Yes, I can see just training both, and I'm sure some clubs share space. However, it's sad. If Judo didn't go through the 2000s rules changes, I'm pretty sure BJJ wouldn't have taken off. Judo would mostly have coverage it, except maybe no-gi training.
The culture is very different.
BJJ guys behave like ghetto bros (courtesy of the Gracie culture), which is quite incompatible with the respectful demeanor of Judo rooted in traditional Japanese culture.
Being thrown onto concrete would be a fight stopper. With Judo you can probably fight more opponents at once.
How?😕
Roman Chumachenko I would think judo would be more “throw and go” so you could move from person to person but I don’t know what takedowns/throws bjj uses so I could be wrong
@@mintyghost8263 You could do " throw and go" I guess but if you are facing a group of people, there is no way to handle the fight with judo. Honestly, I haven't seen a single martial art that would handle more than one opponent for a regular practitioner. In bjj it's either wrestling takedowns or ankle picks from the old school judo.
I think there was a American Olympic judo guy who has a fight with like 6/7 guys many went to hospital from being slammed into concrete. Extreme example but he won the fight
Jujitsu weakness is multiple attackers and amazing strikers who have good defence against being taken down. No art is complete. You still need striking period.
Judo black belt here. Great commentary. I’m into the self defense side of judo like you are. Judo has a lot to offer for someone interested in self defense, and the focus on sport has caused this aspect of judo to be greatly neglected.
On the sportive side, we have a lot of BJJ guys join our school to learn the stand up game because it seems that their clubs do not emphasize this. Conversely we have guys who train at BJJ schools to improve their ground game. Each has something to teach someone from the other style. Just like you mention.
What do you think of judo vs wrestling? Ive been training bjj for years but I've always found judo fascinating. I've always wanted to pick it up, but I'm seeing so much wrestling being utilized in mma that it makes me wonder if I'd be better off going that direction. I wonder if it has to do with there being no gi
Freestyle wrestling is excellent to know. No question. I don't think judo is better than wrestling and vice versa. They both provide tools for dealing with the clinch. Judo works fine with no gi once you learn out to apply it without the jacket. I've played no gi with wrestlers. Some I could throw, some I couldn't. There was one guy who was a top college wrestler, and he whipped my ass many times. So ultimately I think it depends on the guy rather than the style. The only criticism I have about freestyle wrestling is that it emphasizes leg attacks too much. This makes it predictable. When someone is predictable it is more easy to defeat him. Consider, you used to see a lot of double leg shots in mma but now you don't see them so much because fighters have honed their double leg defenses. On the other hand, having leg attacks in the arsenal is helpful. That's one thing I don't like about IJF rules. They won't allow leg attacks.
honest lee Can’t go wrong with either. But if you can train wrestling in high school or college, do so. You get more training sessions and more intensity than in most judo clubs. It’s not so much about which is “better”, but about who trains more intensely.
in the end, i'll choose a trained individual over an untrained individual anytime. train in whatever you have access to that you also enjoy.
Kama Jiu-Jitsu I think you must train for the right purposes ,the right way, and also train a martial art that is effective for it to make a big difference. There are many martial arts that dont give you an edge in a real fight so just being trained under a discipline because you enjoy it could give you a flawed perspectice on how you think you will perform in a fight.
in the street though a ippon wins a fight quick,landing a person who doesnt know how to breakfall can do serious damage
TheSilatiger A young man in my town, from my old judo club in the 90's was honored by police after stopping an attacker with a machete assaulting a woman. He locked up his arm, threw, then pinned the assailant, all with whatever techniques he learned in judo. You are 100% correct: One hard, swift Judo throw on the street and it's game over for the other person. I know a few people and some law enforcement personnel ending situations like this based on one hard throw.
fhx for reply
Ukkun Kun If flight possible, flee. If not, fight. But if fight is chosen, be prepared for 'Manslaughter' criminal charge, Lawyers, Court, Prison etc.
lol, you guys call it quick landing? wrestlers call it getting tossed on your head, and yeah that's potentially lethal on the street, holy shit.
Going on the ground in street fight is not very good idea
I’m a kodokan Black belt, and Gracie Jiu-Jitsu black belt promoted by GM Reyson Gracie, I live in japan for 22 years , and judokas always tend to forget the fact that Jigoro Kano studied JuJutsu. Mitsuyo Maeda was student of Tomita that trained at Tenshin Shinyo Ryu school that was specialized in newaza , when Mitsuyo Maeda taught the Gracie the Art was called Kano JuJutsu.
" judokas always tend to forget the fact that Jigoro Kano studied JuJutsu."
We know exactly where Judo comes from, thanks very much. Jujutsu, Jiu-Jitsu, Judo... all branches of the same tree.
What are you talking about? You mean to day that bjj players tend to forget that bjj comes from judo and Judo is jujitsu
@@Holmesson exactly! Very well said
There's a judo black belt at our gym and he throws everyone on their ass. It's pretty awesome stuff
Yup. But he also probably has a lot to learn on the ground. I think it’s a shame that the two arts have specialized to such a large extent.
Rustedblade Okay, egomaniac Judoka fool. Whatever you say.
Rustedblade Awwwe their he goes again. A real percieved intellectual living in his head led to speak on things.
Getting it wrong you sound bitter of Bjj. If you believe the last part of your comment you'd be better showing self control and keeping that imagined fantasy coming out of your pie hole shut.
But hey let free speech be free. It's a great thing to still have.
@rustedblade talks the talk but he admitted in another reply he doesn't walk the walk. Take it with a grain of salt. (That rhymed!)
Judo is pretty cool. I recommend looking into Catch wrestling and Greco Roman wrestling. The western equivalents and just as good as modern Bjj and Judo.
Matter of fact look into the origins of the Kimura, i believe in catch it's called Double wrist lock and Kimura did catch wrestling. Or check out Maeda, I'm pretty sure he had experience in Catch wrestling.
As a retired former practitioner of both Judo and JuJitsu (Godan US Judo Assn., Godan Golden Gi JuJitsu Society) I have to say that Idean did a fantastic job of explaining in this video. Too many people today are unaware of the relationship between old style Judo which was known as Kano JuJitsu and the Newaza emphasized art of Gracie JuJitsu.
Is it still possible to learn the original jujutsu?
Sports aside, Judo is a modified form of Jujutsu with a shifted emphasis, which was made famous and then infamous by the Samurai. At the time of its creation it was still Jujutsu, but that name had a stigma, so the founder removed the "jutsu" and replaced it with "do", which made it seem more philosophical. So that's where we get the name Judo. Judo, is just Jigoro Kano's modified version of the Jujutsu that he was taught. BJJ is Judo, but with emphasis placed on the ground game and with modifications.
So when you go out there into the world to learn striking, throws, grappling, and submissions from a plethora of global martial arts, all you are doing is coming full circle and creating your on Jujutsu. Jujutsu Watashi No Michi.
Very well said! Bjj is judo no matter how they try and twist it. Brazilian jiu-jitsu is a "do" art , which is nothing but judo newaza with a different rule set.
Man, great video! Really impressed by this gentleman's insight, respect, and articulation.
Judo back in those days isn't the judo you see today. Judo back then looked more like jujitsu today. The rule sets that surround judo today hurt judo with lost techniques and strategies. Hence, there are people that want to bring that back. And you hit a great point about the sport of anything and points.
There is aspect of it that helps in that by focusing their training to fewer techniques, they are better at those techniques (hypothetically).
Great explanation
@@gxtmfa Having sparred with these "nu Judo" types, I can only say they're mostly more GORILLA-LIKE in their approach to Judo. But they lose the subtlety and efficiency.
The Japanese Kodokan fighters maintain the traditional spirit in high level competitions a bit better.
Extremely fair and concise analysis. Thank you. Keep up the good work.
Wow. I have been looking for this explanation for a long time. Thank you very much.
As someone who practices both judo and jujitsu I found this video super enjoyable.
Ditto!
Christopher Carpenter would you agree that Judo is good for self-defense or not
yes, it is good for self defense or not
lol
The most intelligent compersion the topic on the whole internet!!!
What a great video, thanks for sharing!
Very well spoken video properly explaining the difference between judo and jiu-jitsu.. coming from about 8 years at a traditional judo school I completely agreed with this!.. well done!
Wow that’s super insightful. Grew up doing Judo for most of my childhood. then had a hiatus for 25 years. now entering a journey in JiuJitsu. Purely as a journeyman. I would love to combine these two arts.
I agree both should be taken at the same time. They work very well together.
Work? Have you ever seen a Judo take down in the UFC?????? THats how usless they are
Thank you Mr Salehyan for your very honest and mature explanation of judo and bjj. I enjoyed watching your presentation.
Great vid. Shows understanding and respect for both disciplines.
My background is Judo, Aikido, and Taekwondo. I'm currently taking Kenpo and Jiu-Jitsu. My judo and Aikido help but not as much as you would think for having 30+ years experience. Thanks for your view on this , I I like hearing other people who are making a transition from one to the other
As someone who trains both. Judo really helps out during bjj competition. The fight always starts standing up. Every bjj tournament I go to the ref always laughs and says your a judo guy! The un orthodox grips really mess people up, and trying to take and not get taken down takes a lot of energy leaves both people tried. Both arts complement each other nicely.
seeing as how they come from the same "genesis," it makes sense that they would complement eachother...
Great video. We do the same at Colossal Fight Company, although currently our Judo classes do not immediately follow jui jitsu classes. Keep up the good work!
Great explanation on the differences! Much appreciated.
The Gracies did not to quote the video "developed the ground work of judo to a much higher level", what they did were always judo. Read Oswaldo Alves's interview, he has done more in developing modern BJJ than just about anybody. His most accomplished student was Rolls Gracie. Oswaldo Alves himself spent time studying judo four four years in Japan and under the famous sensei Isao Okano, and there were techniques Master Alves have not seen in BJJ. Even the Sankaku-jime (triangle strangle) was not really used much in competition until Rolls found it is some old judo book and began using it. So it is important to study history first before one teaches it, many instructors are ignorant of the history of this martial art. Furthermore, if the average American black belt in judo has a hard time against blue or purple belt in BJJ, he has not studied judo comprehensively, and not has studied newaza well, period.
Ever wonder why Judo blackebelts are allowed to compete at Blue Belt level BJJ competitions? His comments are valid, yes there are exceptions but most Judo Schools historically much weaker on newaza.
Great comment. Brazilian guy speaking here. Can you link the interview you mentioned? Thanks
That's some important info I wasn't aware. Another thing people likes to forget is that Mitsuyo Maeda was a Catch Wrestler. The Wrestling (they have their own developed system, Shoot Wrestling) in Japan is somewhat unknow for so many people and for I'm investigating is responsible in more than one way in BJJs birth since wrestling was something popular in brazil too.
Best comparison of GJJ vs Judo ever! Thank you!
usa pokerpro glad you liked it
usa pokerpro wtf
gracie
Bjj came from Judo.. I do both... but in bjj you focus on ground work, in 3 months of bjj probably you have trained more groundwork than a person than has trained 2 years of Judo. That means a white belt without stripes its in the same of a blue belt.in Judo.
usa pokerpro I've rolled no gi with some guys and they really have adapted their judo skills for grappling. I will soon do the same
Excellent and honest analysis. Well done sir.
Excellent info. Was an honour to learn this
Judo is great for any fighter to learn as its a great transitional from standing to ground. BJJ might be superior grappling but no one starts on their knees. Saying that a black belt in Judo usually just gets fed to the BJJ white belts and its pretty even until you get to blue when youre considered a very capable fighter. Both are super if you have time to do both. This guy is great and his judo background will make him a superb BJJ guy.
Try to learn the real one martial art, the Japanese jujitsu not the grappling Bjj.
Total agree with this man. Martial arts are one big family learning off each other.
Very interesting, thanks for the great content
real honest and very intressting . we are not here to compare whitch is best ,but to learn the best of these 2 arts
Judo is also a school of Jiu-Jitsu; Kano Jiu-Jitsu.
The main difference and influence here are the competition rules; IBJJF vs IJF vs etc.
Close.
Kano brought 10 schools of jujitsu together. This was initially called kano ryu jujitsu. Then Kano removed all the techniques that required superior size, strength, or stature.
He then infused a spiritual mindfulness to his training and dubbed what he had distilled as "Kodokan Judo"
Since they are the same art they should be trained together . As Joe Rogan said Jūdō on the street is lethal in that environment .
Really good explanation ,well done sir 😎👍🙏
great commentary. the point advantage you're talking about in bjj comes from folk style wrestlers. it's a longstanding technique/game of the system to "tech" your opponent instead of going for a head to head battle. it's actually respected in the wrestling community, because it shows that you have the ability to dominate your opponent in individual aspects of the sport. we love it because it's an undeniable evidence to the strong character and dedication of an athlete.
This guy explains things very well from many angles. .
During the 40s the Japanese government used school P.E. classes to teach military skills, such as grenade throwing and using bayonets, to the youth of Japan. After Japan's defeat, Judo (also Kendo, Kyudo, and Karate) were banned from the P.E. curriculum in schools and universities in an effort to remove nationalistic and military style training. It wasn't until 1950 that Judo was allowed to be taught in schools again. This was only after petitions were made that described Judo as a sport that developed physical and mental faculties and not instruction for hand to hand combat. It's likely that most Japanese Judoka today were introduced to Judo at school where Judo had to exist as a sport not as a combat art. I wonder how much this has influenced the sport aspect of Judo today. It's also interesting to note that BJJ's origins are from earlier pre-war judo.
well said do vs itsu
Many many good points in this video!
Great explanation of difference between Judo and BJJ, as well as sports vs self-defense training. Respect. :)
I study both and love both, my judo sensi who's a fellow student at the BJJ club I train at referred to it as learning a similar game with different rules, he compared it as being like the difference between rugby union and rugby league (I'm based in the uk). Thank you for this great comparison.
Also I know here in the UK judo guys like neil adams and Raymond Stevens (who's a roger gracie black belt) are being hired by BJJ schools to do seminars on the stand up game.
In NZ that's how I describe it too. Same martial art different sports
That is awesome that you teaching Judo at the same school that you teach Brazilian Jiu Jitsu!
That's normal at our academy.
Both are great and compliment each other. The best fighters I have seen understand more than just one art.
thanks ryan, really really on point and an excellent explanation - neutral, objective, and i couldn't agree more - judo and jiu, both excellent, especially if you practice both!
I go to Gracie Barra for BJJ where I live and you can always tell who does or did judo in the past. That hip game, basing, and tilt is unmistakable to me now. Anytime I feel (not see) these things I know a hip toss attempt is coming. Fun competition because until it is on the ground things are pretty exciting at least to me.
Couple of points of expansion.... Maeda went to the US with an older Kodokan instructor to act as an assistant (guy to be thrown, etc--but also guy to take on challengers, since the older instructor was advanced in years). One night, at a pretty high profile demonstration, Maeda stayed back at the hotel because of gastrointestinal problems (he had the runs due to travel...a pretty common problem even today). And at the demo, the older instructor was challenged and then beaten. Maeda took this failure personally, and stayed behind to do challenge matches against all comers after the scheduled tour was over. Kano was basically infuriated by this...Maeda was acting like the jujutsu thugs Kano was trying to differentiate judo from by doing challenge prize fights. Kano pretty much told him not to bother coming back to Japan, so Maeda continued his touring into Brazil, where he hooked up with the Gracie family. Using his own family connections and knowledge of Japanese, he was valuable to the Brazilian government in relating between them and the Japanese immigrant community there. His close ties to the Gracie family led to his teaching the kids judo/jujutsu, which was the start of GJJ. (at the time, the line between "judo" and "jujutsu" was pretty grey... judo was essentially jujutsu, but called by a different name by Kano's Kodokan for PR purposes--jujutsu had a bad public image because jujutsu schools were spending their time prize fighting, brawling in the streets, etc, and just generally acting pretty ghetto....but Kano had much higher aspirations for the practice)
But note--there was a large influx of Japanese immigration to Brazil at this time, and Maeda wasn't the only judo/jujutsu practitioner among them. BJJ isn't ONLY directly drawn down into the country through Maeda and the Gracie family.
That explains BJJ culture a lot:
Brazilian Jewish thugs who learned from a Japanese thug rejected by Jigoro Kano.
Very thorough explanation.
That is awesome! I think every Judo and Jujitsu club should do both. And also, very good and fair description of both styles.
I really like the idea of being able to cross train at one school in the same night and from early stages of development. Brilliant business idea. Why didn't I think of it first? lol
The ridiculous ijf rules destroy judos takedown defense because there's no need to worry about someones hand on your leg
in th Kodokan leg grabs are still allowed. In many clubs too. It doesn't take long to learn to sprawl.
@@augustineleudar you mean in Japan?
@@mpforeverunlimited yeah at the Kodokan but theres also clubs around the world that follow Kodokan not IJF rules -
As opposed to bjj where you can freely pull guard...
Great instructive video. I now better understand the fundamental differences between judo and bjj, thank you.
Well explained. Thank you.
My jiu jitsu coach is also a black belt in Judo. He brought his judo coach to class tonight to teach us something a little different.
I’m a white belt for 10 months and I’ve had terrible anxiety when it comes to standing. I’m definitely going to cross train judo . Absolute game changer for me personally.
judo is so epic, i love the judo throws
How long should I train BJJ before moving into cross training judo?
@@lordkasten3161 doesn't really matter. They won't contradict each other and it will help your bjj
@@lordkasten3161 You should train Judo before, mainly for health reasons:
BJJ teaches really bad postures and doesn't train you to break falls at all properly.
Even BJJ black belts hit the mat like potato sacks.
Having trained both, I definitely agree that Judo breakfall is more detailed and teaches you how to fall from every side and position.
I do Judo, BJJ and nogi. I love them all. They've each got different strengths that complement my wrestling and make my training more complete.
good comparison between BJJ and Judo! from a reliable source ! thanks for this! :)
Great thoughts and Insides.
Please don't buy into the Gracies narrative saying that Helio invented the guard. He did not invent the guard. The open and closed guard was used in Japan from at least the 1890's through the very early 1900's.
Look up the book written by Taro Miyake and Yukio Tani. It's called: "The Game of Jujitsu" and details how to get subs from both the open and closed guard. The book was written in 1906.
What Helio did do was develop techniques to defend yourself in vale tudo from the guard position.
What were the samurai doing other than preparing for a “street fight”?
isalehyan "Judo is nothing less than a martial art. When a soldier breaks his sword and runs out of arrows, in the end, life and death is determined with newaza.”
- Tatsukuma Ushijima
i've only heard one of them say that, but who knows what they all believe. what i've heard most, was that if not for Helio, no one would really be fighting from the guard. not that the concepts and techniques didn't exist before, but that prior to him, no one really did it, is all.
BigJules89 that is awesome love it
Kama Jiu-Jitsu I agree. Helio and his family preserved and also developed Jiu Jitsu to become street applicable. Most people would not know how to fight from various guard positions and defend themselves.
Jiu Jitsu in Japan from a century ago eventually turned into the sport throwing judo that we see today and all the guard pulling was banned by Jigoro Kano because it negated his tachi-waza (throws) that he developed and he also felt that judo was becoming too sportive and was losing its self defense aspect. No more guard pulling in Kodokan Judo as a result.
The only ones that continue to practice guard pulling in competition is in the Kosen Judo ruleset. Kano allowed this because he also wanted newaza to be developed at the same time.
Fun fact: the triangle choke was developed in Kosen Judo in the early 1920's.
Judo is starting to get less effective due to all the rules that doesn't allow you to break grips once you establish them, no double legs, single legs, etc. along with not allowing you to be on the ground for long.
TapsandTraps This is true if your school focuses on competition only. At Kama we continue to teach all of judo, including leg attacks, gripping, etc.
Hayashi's Dojo in El Paso TX does traditional judo. We train grip breaks, leg takedowns and techniques that are restricted by IJF. I think it depends on where you train and who you train with.
I gave up on IJF nonsense 20 years ago. Using the Kosen Ruleset allows for greater newaza.
Look into 'Freestyle Judo'. It's an alternative rule set that brings judo back to where it was before all the crazy IJF rule changes.
I've seen a lot of videos on BJJ they just pull guard against a judo, they always try to pull guard every single time. in a fight you'll start by standing up. ronda rousey was good because of her Judo, she will use a Judo throw slam you on the ground in a position to hit an arm bar. the weakness of BJJ is their stand up game. if I was to weight out Judo ground to BJJ stand up then Judo ground game is better. overall in a street fight judo will be more effective.
Well said , the main reason for a person to practice any kind of self defense sport is .... (self defense), then other reasons follow.
Thanks for this.
as judo player of 30 years to me judo ground work was at its best in early 80s
I know a judoka who is a bit older, and competed internationally in the 80s. I had this person watch some BJJ black belts grappling, and she wondered why they didn't just choke off the opponent in many instances when it was completely possible, or why they didn't do certain things on the ground. She said the way she was taught was also groundwork heavy and they did randori with a lot of ground work. It makes me wonder if today judo has been watered down in that department since then? Since you mention that it was at its best in the early 80s.
a good throw can end the fight
I bet it will end the fight if the floor is asphalt.
Not always
@@marcelodiaz5006 just yesterday a guy thrown on the mat and he is in hospital. Not even asphalt mind u 😉
@@changym1980 i said not always, no "never", idiot. And thats a fucking honor for you? so asshole the judo guys are for consider a guy hurt as a "victory"? come on, fucking stupid. And i didn´t question you
@@marcelodiaz5006 lol when did I say hurting a guy from throw is a victory? I said throwing on the mat can seriously hurt someone. I think u have serious problem in understanding or having English problem!. But well a BJJ guy will not understand what is real jujutsu as to believe what the Gracie said they are doing reap jujutsu, in jujutsu the concept of throwing someone down wearing an armour is an effective way to end his life, the samurai who manage a throw would finish their opponent with a wakizashi, that is the original concept of ippon, u won't want to grapple your opponent on the ground in the battlefield for obvious reasons. Judo is a physical education, not for hurting people.
Quite out of topic but I remember how I always respected Judo yet it never felt like a sport for me. During my first class of wrestling I would learn about uchi mata (no gi version of course) and I remember our little sparring sessions at the end where I executed it flawlesly and of course I take into consideration the skillset of my opponent who was quite new to wrestling himself but definitely higher in grappling experience. So I executed uchi mata and just by the name got curious of its origin, then I found a little more about Judo and actually loved the sport. You guys are absolute legends!
BAHAHAHAHA!!! you're doing a martial arts interview at a gun range? I think I am in love!!!!
boom boom boom...
On hard surfaces, judo is King. Pavement being my preferred weapon of choice.
People who don’t train always seem to think there’s some sort of beef between BJJ and Judo. In reality, most judo and jiu jitsu guys I’ve met while training love cross training with both and enjoy having members of the other art to learn from. I’ve met Judokas with amazing newaza and some BJJ guys can take down Olympic-style judokas because said BJJ guys shoot double and single legs.
Great explanation with a good degree of humility and respect.
Great comments good perspective
Mitsuyo Maeda only changed the name from judo to ju jitsu in Brasil because he wasn't allowed to use judo in prizefighting from his masters so he changed it to Brazilian ju jitsu when he taught the gracies.
My school teaches judo and bjj. I'm a white belt in both, but I think they go hand in hand. I haven't done nearly as much Judo, but it seems more focused on takedowns.
You already bring up a valid point ,and ive been watch only 5 .minutes ,and except for i think the two arts do or should translate into each other becacuse after you throw you immediately go into your juijitsu game so you can and should combine the two arts to have a complete game plan,and to be a well rounded fighter .
Nice Vídeo. I'm a Judo black belt and I like history, what many people don't know is that Mitsuyo Maeda ( Conde Comma) was a ground fight specialist in the Kodokan institute, that's why he taught that emphasis to his students and as mentioned in the video, Helio Grace developed that to a new level.
If I could, I'd do both. They complement eachother to perfection.
Great commentary!
I know the rules of competition mold both arts but speaking on the art itself, what techniques does BJJ have that Judo doesn't?
If one were to train in just the art of Judo not influenced by competition which includes all the banned techniques of throws and groundwork, do you think one can arrive to the same level that the Gracies did for example?
The reason I ask is because I have been to many Judo dojos and you're correct most focus on the next tournament which causes them to neglect much of the groundwork and banned techniques. After this long search I have found a dojo that focuses on Judo as an art includine all the banned techniques like leg locks, even neck cranks and sometimes striking.
You just might have something good there.
Well, it's a complicated answer and I probably can't do justice here. But original Kodokan Judo wasn't a "style" so much as Kano's attempt to integrate and preserve traditional jiu-jitsu when the samurai arts were in decline (Meiji era). So, Judo has nagewaza (throws), katamewaza (pins, submissions), and atemiwaza (strikes), all taken from various systems of jiu-jitsu. In one sense, judo "has it all".
But for a whole variety of reasons, that I can't go into depth here, Judo has come to focus more on nagewaza. There is also katamewaza and some schools are better than others; kosen judo focuses on this a lot more. You're lucky you found a school that is well-rounded, but that's not the vast majority of schools.
So here is my experience. Yes, I learned newaza/groundfighting in Judo. There is also not much in BJJ that I have 'never seen' (maybe some leg locks and stupid inverted-spider-worm-x-guard stuff). But its a matter of learning the crude mechanics of a technique and the finer details. For example, before I got to Kama, I had learned sankaku jime (triangle choke) from guard in Judo. But seeing Ryan teach it, I saw a bunch of small details I'd been missing. Same with rear naked choke, kesa gatame, armbar from mount, etc, etc. The level of detail is simply amazing, and opened my eyes to a lot of what I'd been missing.
That said, most BJJ schools really suck at throws and takedowns--not all, but most. Now, I've seen old videos of Helio Gracie demonstrating jiu-jitsu and he clearly knew how to do throws. Rickson Gracie even entered Sambo competitions. But for whatever reason, that side of things isn't taught as much. So as I said in the video, they come from the same origins, but have come to focus on different things.
isalehyan You're reply is much appreciated sir.
Thank you.
Normally I troll bjj channels just to get a discussion (argument) going on bjj being fancy newaza but comming from a fellow Judoka my ignorance tends to lessen and I must say your explanation is very eye opening.
Very informative video thanks man! I am considering getting myself into judo with my 5 and 7 year old boys. I like the idea of BJJ and judo together. Where are you located at? I am in Sacramento CA there is only 2 judo clubs here. I wish there was a BJJ and Judo like yours together. Keep up the good work!
This guy knows his shit . Good shit.
You should have asked the Gun Range guys what they thought of Judo & Jiu Jitsu
They built the gun range and the entire building with the jiu-Jitsu studio in mind.
My brothers-in-arms ain't no dummies
A lot of the jiu jitsu guys are also gun range guys.
@@gxtmfa this is the way
Excelente. Bjj and judo together. A winning solution.
I did not know Mitsuyo was a Judo guy. I always read that he was a Jiu Jitsu Champion. I guess you learn something new every day!
I trained karate and kickboxing as a teenager and young adult. Went into my first GJJ class and felt like a newborn. That school also trained Judo throws, wrestling takedowns, and jiu-jitsu with light striking to learn how to keep a tight guard and avoid getting smacked in the face.
Im a sensie for japanese jujutsu (empashis in the more combat oriented with dai to ryu and some shotikan elements thrown in)
We often get this same question from.new students on the differeneces between what we do vs bjj or judo etc. This explanation youve given is by far the absolute best ive heard
How do you sleep at night knowing that crap you teach dont even work in real life??? you should be ashamed
The "pure technique" vs. having to use just "brute strength" (hint - strength is a skill) is a canard but you hear it a lot in Jiu Jitsu and Judo.
Real good analysis of Judo and BJJ. I remember in college guys would say that BJJ was just Judo, but there was animosity towards the art due to its success and popularity. Haters gonna hate.
I’m a white belt judoka and I’m only two lessons in. I know comparatively nothing except what I’m receiving from my instructors. I will offer this though. They have told me there are three ways to throw, in any throw in judo. There’s a polite, competition way of throwing that also maintains control for newaza when you move to the ground, where you throw, hold and control your partner as they go to the mat, then close quickly on them as they can’t get away from your grip and evade your newaza. This is safe, polite and correct. Then there’s the beginner’s mistake, impolite and slightly more dangerous way of throwing, where you throw, but don’t control, let go your grip and increase the risk of hurting an inexperienced judoka by letting them drop. However, an experienced judoka will likely not take any damage, break fall and roll out of any ground danger and come back at you. Then there’s the nasty way to throw. You throw, control and drive them into the ground purposefully, and not necessarily safely, and that’s how you hurt, wind, injure and dominate opponents. I tell myself I need to stick to number one, never do number two because it is unsatisfactory for all reasons and I pray I never get to having to do number three. As a good practice and as a humbling exercise, a huge and very kind black belt took me on a tour of the mat only to work on my grip (for the purpose of improving my technique and control), and after five minutes of him resisting my amateurish attempts to tai otoshi, or de ashi barai, I was wasted. Throughout, he kept encouraging me, pulling me off balance now and then to wake me up to his threat, never hurling me like he so easily could, but helping me understand the value of the grip to me, and telling me it was good when I moved right, held right in the position and despite him being twice my size, I could see how the technique was aiding me mechanically. I’m really getting addicted! I’ll also add I’m 43 and this is my first experience with judo. Anyone reading this wondering if they’re too old, look at it this way - I’m glad I didn’t leave it until I was 44. The glass is half full.
Much respect and thank you for the comparison of Judo and BJJ.
Enjoyable video. Ironic what started Japan became separated and is now being brought back together in the melting pot of nations.
Back in 2009 I was a study abroad student in South Korea and I ended up finding a Judo club that had their own gym on campus. What baffled me was that when our randori session went to the mat they stopped, while I kept going. They did not practice the newaza portion.
Love to see a segue of Aiki-jitsu right into BJJ for the best combat techniques.
I THINK OF IT LIKE THIS:
JUDO: KISS ME ON THE STREET SWEEP ME OFF MY FEET.
JITSU: SWEEP ME OFF MY FEET, SCREW ME ON MY BACK....
No homo, man...
Yeah that turtling up is something i'm still trying to get out of my muscle memory. I realised it was a silly idea even before i started jiujitsu, because i never liked the idea that if i can hold you down for twenty seconds i win, even if i can't actually finish you, so i never tried for the pin. I still studied the immobalisations like any judoka, and i think it's definitely helped in my jiujitsu, but i only ever wanted to use them to tire my opponent and to work towards the submission. And so in judo when people turtle up imm really excited, cos i can get my hooks in or pull of a Jigoku Jime (hell strangle) or do a rolling jujigatame. Even so, i still fall into the turtle position if i get nearly broken down (what i call being taken down, but from the knees). Then i realise (my back's open) so then i start to open up, to roll to my back, then i realise 'no stay there! Your body was tight, now you've given them space to hook in' - then i'm defending the choke.
The problem is that because of the jiujitsu i know, even just the little bit i've learned, when we do newaza in judo, i don't often end up needing to turtle. And because of that i never get practice to not-turtle.
But in any case, i agree with the sportive habits, i'm trying to identify all the sportive habits i have and try to get rid of them. For example, trying not to turtle up and making sure i never pull guard (thankfully i've never needed to do that because of my judo background). It is definitely important to know if you're training your martial art or your martial sport
Thanks! Turtle is only one example. Try throwing someone who is trying to punch your face! The grips, distance management, and entries into throws are very different from sport judo where strikes aren’t allowed. Early Judo knew all of this stuff, since it was closer to original jiu jitsu.
isalehyan i agree. I've actually preemptively tried to counter this as when i spar i imagine that my opponent's gripping me is them punching me and try to avoid them and control them as if that were the case. I haven't had any practice involving strikes yet, but i have considered after my jiujitsu and judo game improves to look into training MMA, even recreationally, just to get a complete idea of what my skills are and how they can be applied in what is as close to a real streat fight as i will get to practice
easy to do now. just throw punches and slaps while training. slowly take up the intensity as time goes on and your skills increase.
Kama Jiu-Jitsu idk if my own personal desire to train MMA should affect the way in which my fellow club members train with me, but i'll give it some thought
Kama Jiu-Jitsu besides, i want to have a good grappling game that's solid before i start complicating things with punches and things involved. I think i won't train MMA until i get a black belt in judo and maybe i'll wait until i get a high belt in BJJ, like blue or purple, before i start to apply what i know to more complicated contexts
I found it rather interesting that while we have a video discussing martial, hand to hand, self-defense, there is the overlap of people on the gun range practicing a martial, non-hand to hand self-defense. Nice juxtaposition!
My dojo recently had a clinic where we invited a Judo blackbelt, Sensei Jason Harai, to teach us Judo throws. It was awesome! I like that what he showed us can be used with or without Gi. And let's face it guys... life is too short to pull guard. :)~
You are Delusional 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Thank you
I like how he dodges the main question that's on everyones mind, would a bjj practitioner beat a judo practitioner
depends. what's the objective? an ippon, or a sub?
There is no answer because they are different rule sets. The BJJer would have a small advantage in their slower ground game with it's long buildups but not in the much faster judo ground game where you have to be actively moving or be stood up. The standing game would just be ugly using current rules where you can't touch pants.
A friend uses a basketball way of deciding this: he says that the difference between the judoka and BJJer ground game is smaller than their difference standing.
But I'm not sure this solves it.
I believe that people who practice a martial art under a certain rule should always have an advantage against someone who crosses over from another martial arts.
I don't deny the Gracie's modified and spread jiu jitsu throughout the world, but there were others like, Luis Franca who learned from Mitsuyo Maeda, and not the Gracie's. Also, Oswaldo Fadda was a non gracie lineage that learned and taught almost the same jiu jitsu as the Gracie's. Ryan or Dave, can you tell me if there's any difference in jiu jitsu from the Gracie's side or the Fadda side. Thanks, love the channel!
I think at the time, they were largely the same. Not so sure about today.
Kama Jiu-Jitsu thanks!! Love the channel! Keep up the videos...
Should also add Soshihiro Satake and Geo Omori to the list of influences on Franca and the Gracies. Maeda gets all of the credit, but there were other Kodokan black belts in Brazil that contributed to the development of the art.
Great commentary and I agree with your analysis. I've done both myself. When I started JJ, I was Sandan in Judo and I found I was on par with most blue belts and a few purple belts. Throwing people was easy, even the brown and black belts couldn't hang with me standing so they stopped trying and went right to guard. It was a hard transition for me at my age. I started JJ when I was 46 thinking that I didn't want to get slammed around anymore but I still wanted to train in something that would be easier on me physically and I had a good working knowledge of. Boy was I wrong. JJ is just as brutal as Judo. I didn't last too long because of my ego, thinking I should have been hanging with the brown belts at least. In the end, I trained way too hard and no one wanted to train with me because I was too aggressive. Even if I got tapped, I would come back even harder and it was all bad. I finally quit and realized afterward that I could have made the transition if my black belt ego wouldn't have gotten in the way. Judo and JJ together make a VERY formidable style and if you can get very good at both you will be devastating. I wish I would have started JJ earlier in my life and found a way to work with both of them.
you know what your problem was.
now go back to JJ, armed with your newly recognized realization, and earn another black belt!
I think the hardest part for someone transitioning to a different style, especially after achieving a black belt, is putting on a white belt and starting over. I’ve done it twice. But starting from scratch, with no preconceived notions, is the only way to learn and grow. It’s not about being better than other students, but being better tomorrow than you are today. I had to admit to myself that my newaza sucked before I allowed myself to fully be a student again. But I think it paid off.
BJJ can be hard on the body, but it’s way easier than judo to sustain in later years. Letting go of the pound and grind mentality from judo is hard. But if you find the right training partners and pace your self well, BJJ can be a great way to go as our bodies age.
and you can be of great benefit to your school and training partners ;-)
Dude Jiu Jitsu schools start the roll from the ground stop making shit up. a purple belt with destroy a Judo black belt with ease. We start the roll on our knees
Very well said! I kept hearing someone scream in the background though (it was music maybe), and that made the video annoying sometimes. Awesome points from this guy though. Thumb up.
Lol, could it have been gunshots? He was doing the interview at a gun range.