Ooni Gas vs Electric Pizza Oven Comparison
Vložit
- čas přidán 19. 06. 2024
- A common question i get asked is "what is the best type of pizza oven?" people used to want to know the best method to good on between Wood or Gas. Since the release of the Ooni Volt 12, Its thrown another cooking method into the mix... Electric!
Therefore i felt it was my duty to test out the best method to cook a pizza - musing gas or an electric pizza oven!
In this video we look the ooni volt 12, and the ooni koda 16, compare the ovens, look at the running costs and do a real time cook on both ovens to decide which is the best for your needs!
⬇️PRODUCTS USED IN THIS VIDEO⬇️
OONI VOLT 12 - Electric Pizza Oven
🇺🇸 - tinyurl.com/6b3vzknx
🇬🇧 - tinyurl.com/y9vvx2a7
🇪🇺 - tinyurl.com/6b3vzknx
🇫🇷 - tinyurl.com/mry9nsxy
🇮🇹 - tinyurl.com/r9h6nk39
🇩🇪 - tinyurl.com/mwzjkevb
OONI KODA 16 - Gas Pizza Oven
🇺🇸 - tinyurl.com/3fyusrzs
🇬🇧 - tinyurl.com/kfb2e4s
🇪🇺 - tinyurl.com/7ed3az8f
🌡 Erick Hill Laser Thermometer - amzn.to/3cIYK3y
🍕 Frozen Pizza Dough - www.homemadepizzaclub.co.uk
🌱 Botanium - Simplified Indoor Growing - botanium.se
CHAPTERS
Intro - 00:00
Gas vs Electric Oven Comparison - 00:3
Lighting the Pizza Ovens - 03:26
Running Costs - 03:02
Temperature Check - 04:16
Further Oven Info - 05:59
Real Time Cook on Gas - 06:43
Real Time Cook on Electric - 08:22
Pizza Compare & Taste Test - 11:05
Final Thoughts - 12:22
👩🏼🍳 PIZZA DOUGH RECIPE - my usual go to (Bakers Percentages)
100% - Caputo Nuvola Pizza Flour
68% - Warm Water
2.6% - Fine Sea Salt
0.3% - Active Dried Yeast
🥣 DOUGH METHOD
Mix yeast & water,
Mix Flour & salt
Combine ingredients in bowl until it forms a large ball.
Bulk Ferment for 2 hours at RoomTemp.
Divide & shape into dough balls
Second fermentation - 24/48 hours Cold Temp.
Bring up to room temp before stretching & cooking.
MORE INFORMATION
Visit my website for more pizza cooking videos!
🌎 - www.tomvoyage.co.uk
Or follow me on Facebook, Instagram & TikTok.
✅ @TOMVOYAGEUK
#pizza #ooni #pizzalover - Jak na to + styl
Thank you for giving this comparison. . . While the difference was not what I was expecting, it gave me a good insight to the value and simplicity of the Volt and its ability to still be a very good pizza oven.
That being said, I am still happy with my Ooni Karu and will stick with that.
The Ooni Karu will always be my favourite!
The difference in bake you are experiencing is 2 things. You preheat the electric oven too long. No more than 20 minutes. I find it overheats the stone. 2nd real difference is the heating element in the top is controlled by the thermostat. You need to rotate the pizza more often in the electric oven as opening the door will not only let out steam but also kick the heating element back on. You can get similar results to the outdoor oven this way.
Another method which the head engineer suggested is to bake with the door 100% open during the entire bake. It might drop the heat a lot but it will keep the heating element all the way on.
The other method which will give you a consistent result is set the oven to 425C and then when time to bake a pizza, set it to 450c. It will keep the heating element on as well as not overheat the stone.
What does overheating the stone mean, results wise? The video showed less char on the electric.
@@ryeguy01 his bottom is burnt
Mo, Where did you read the head engineer advising to cook with the volt door open for the entirety of the bake??
@@ryeguy01 Putting it out there... neither of those pizzas looked good. Gas pizza had char on the edge of the crust but the bottom was pretty pale. The bottom on the Volt looked about right but the problem with the Volt is that having an element on top and element on the bottom, means the side of your pizza is always going to be soft unless you cook it like a biscuit. (And Neapolitan pizza is pretty bland anyway)
@@AntonGully What would you suggest for a great indoor pizza oven?
Great comparison Tom thank you
Thank you for watching
Great video, thanks.
Thank you so much enjoyed your video.
Glad you enjoyed it, thank you for watching!
Thanks Tom , always a great review. I prefer a flame over the electric. Take care.
Thanks for watching 🍕👍
The bubble appearing in the Volt is because of too thin pizzabottom/lesser toppings and maybe a little too hot stone, the same will happen in the koda 16, or any other oven for that matter. Seems also based on the chared bottom from the Volt it was too hot. This happend to me alot when I started out and made the pizzas too thin.
Thanks for the tips, I’ll bear this in mind when doing future bakes
User manufactured error
Happens with me too. And you are right
I think you should turn more heat to the top
Great video I think I'm going with the gas version it is only 12 dollars here for 13 litres of propane gas in Mexico keep up the good work
Wow thats cheap! i'll see you soon 😂✈️🇲🇽
Bro! You did an energy efficiency comparison and I love it! The orange flames in the Koda look nice but that color comes from un-combusted carbon that is incandescening.
Glad you enjoyed it - thanks for the info 👍🍕
Great comparison there between the two ovens but you do know that the koda16 burner is not just high and low, by pushing in and turning the control knob towards the off position it dials down the gas flow rate to basically a simmer, I bake Detroit style and cast iron deep pan pizzas in my k16 regurlarly on this super low heat setting for low and slow bakes.
Koda 16 is a great oven for these reasons. Extreme stone temps.... but then u can back it off for the bake..
Thanks for the comment, and yes I agree but I do feel that the Koda 16 goes down in steps of high, medium and low but still a great oven! Love ot
Molto chiaro, grazie!
Thanks for watching 👍🍕
Great video, thanks.....
Thanks for watching!
Thanks Tom! I really enjoyed your review on both.
Thanks for checking out my video! I used the volt last night after the wind and rain started was ideal to cook some pizza from the comfort of the kitchen!
I need one of these in my life
You certainly do!
thank you for this excellent video. I am thinking of getting myself a ooni 16" and I heard you mention that if you cook many pizzas eventually the stones looses heat. Could you tell me if that's a problem for you or if there are easy solutions. One of the reasons I'd like one of these ovens is to save time while making many pizzas for my family. cheers!
Thanks for the comment! It's not really a problem unless you're not prepared for it. When cooking for people i will usually do 3/4 pizzas then have a break for 5-10 minutes whilst i add more fuel and let the stone re heat. Once you get used to it its easier, and having the gas attachment helps here as its easy to turn up to add more heat
Thanks for this. That darn bubble again screwed up the cook. Lost a lot of top heat when you opened that door which is why the cook was uneven. I wish you would have done the comparison over again. That dough was beautiful, very active, you may need to slap more air out of the base when you stretch.
Thanks for the tips
How hot does the table top get underneath?
very cool Video. Now i know what to by. Ooni Volt. Greetings from Frankfurt/M. - Germany
Thanks for watching! And when you do decide to buy, please use my links as it helps to support the channel!
Ps. Would love to visit Frankfurt someday, I’ve heard it’s a really cool city!
Yep it is. It's calld Mainhatten in Germany, becaus of the Hightowers.. Frankfurt is the only City wich sutch Buildings. Sorry for my english. Greetings from Mainhatten@@TomVoyageuk
I use the Breville Pizzaiolo. Never failed. It’s all about the dough that makes a great pizza.
id like to give the revile a try, my coffee machine is a breville (sage in UK) Barista express and i love it
great video, Next time i like to see gas vs wood..
Hi! If you check my other videos I already have done this comparison! Thanks
The Koda Looks to be a better bake, I have a Koda and love it🙏🥰💕
Yeah it’s a great oven the Koda16!
These oven are okay but I much prefer the quality and size of the Danish Witt pizza ovens with or without the rotating stone.
Thanks for the comment, I haven’t tried a Danish Witt oven before? Might be interesting to try it out!
Since you use 12” and 16” for pizza size, could you please toss in the Fahrenheit temp along with the Celsius?
I do need to try and remember to do this!
Can you use the Koda indoors ? I live in Buffalo and we get six feet of snow outside
only the electric
GReat job with the analysis, I really appreciate the cost of operation summary. I want both!
Thanks for watching! Glad you found it useful
With the unreliable weather in the UK the Volt has got to be better.
And the taste? Is it different ??
Ooni claims on their site that the Ooni Volt would use 1.02kWh over the course of 1 hour at full power, not 1.6kwh. Have you tested/measured how much it actually uses over an hour using a watt meter? I'd love to know the true answer.
I haven't tested exactly what it would use, But it would be interesting to know, Is there some sort of gadget that would do this?
@@TomVoyageuk I think you can get certain smart plugs that can capture that information via phone app.
Can you please tell me about much money would you have spent on wood/charcoal per hour?
It's difficult to say as i buy charcoal in large bags and use on many different ovens throughout the year, I also source wood for free as often as i can and dry it out myself.
How hot does the bottom of the volt get? Is it safe to put on a laminate bench? Cheers.
Good question, I've not actually tested the underneath heat of the volt but if its anything like the top its only warm, not hot. I will check next time i fire up the volt for you though.
@@TomVoyageuk thanks Tom, appreciate it.
I own the Volt. It is perfectly safe to put on a laminate worktop. Mine is a permanent fixture in the kitchen and not just for pizzas. It can be used for many different styles of cooking.
Thanks Mick!!!
Would you say the electric oven would be better for a windy environment than the gas?
Yes most likely as the open front of the Koda 16 could be subject to blowing out if there is a strong gust from the front. The electric on the other hand is fully sealed
Are these 2 good for small business?
Yes they will be good, especially the volt as can be used inside too
the prices for electricity are super high in germany, still cheaper than gas though. The price per hour is interesting but the ooni Volt need alot of time to heat up, so i guess you are wasting 20 minutes before oyu can put the pizza in. The other thing is, the volt is alot more expensive, you have to take that into your calculation as well.
Thanks for the comment, I personally don’t think 20 mins to heat up is that long really, as my home oven would take a similar time and use more energy. I guess the price does need to be considered but that will also come down to how often you’re using the oven, as to weather you think it’s a worth while investment
@danbarb9728 Well, tell me then, when you have no Ooni oven at home and you make a pizza in your regular oven, is there an option where you are ''not wasting 20 minutes''? You are also ''wasting'' 20 minutes of gas running until it reaches the right temperature? And like Tom said, 20 mins to heat up really isn't much. Jesus, some people nowadays...
Should have compared to the 12" gas, which is much better and much cheaper (than the electric).
The only benefit of the electric is it's ability to be used indoors, some people don't have the space outdoors or can't be outside in some weather.
The Koda 12 also can be easily modified with a turntable eliminating the need for the 16's larger area and larger burner.
The 16's price tag and dimensions are what destroys the product for many people, the advantages are unnecessary for experienced cooks.
As I said in the video I don’t have the 12” version of this oven
A benefit to me is not having to worry or just forgetting and running out of propane. I have a propane pizza oven and would much prefer this.
It’ll also be much cheaper to operate, which won’t matter to the average person who makes a couple pizzas here and there. I make about 12 a week so I go thru a $22 propane about every 5 weeks. This would probably pay for itself in about 2 years.
I think too much heat from the bottom, not enough from the top because you kept opening it to spin and because of the bubble. One turn should be enough and wait as long as possible before turning it if you have to.
Thanks for your comment
Wood I’m thinking. Looking at the 16
Wood will always be the most fun to cook on! 🔥
The electric uuni 12 its a bit of failure. The heating element its to close to the stone. They designed it with a bit of error. Should have been a bit more taller, with an extra height 50mm and to adjust the bottom temperature 50°C lower than overall air temperature at the top.
I think the designers did a great job in creating an oven that is small enough to fit onto a counter top, but can still reach 400+c inside, whilst being warm enough to touch on the outside!
Hi what's a grandma pizza ?
Very thin style of pizza, usually rectangle and from New York rather than Italy! 😉
It's basically sheet pan pizza.
Ooni karu 12g vedio???
I'm really tempted to order one.... theres quite a few weeks wait though to get one!
@@TomVoyageuk mee too just waiting for your deep review and comparison to 12
Both ovens are extremely overpriced, like 3 times the price of a competitor that offers almost exactly the same build, but at a much lower price.
The Ooni electric oven is also just 12 inches. That's really too small. Compare it against a Cozze 13 inch, priced at 300 EUR (vs 900 EUR for the Ooni).
The Ooni gas oven is nearly twice the price of a pellet fired Bighorn oven (currently priced at 179 EUR) with a large chimney and therefore a lot better than the Ooni.
The Cozze oven is also availabe in 17 inch for just 400 EUR. I don't understand people who spend 900 EUR on an inferior Ooni oven when they can have the real thing (Effeuno P134 HA509) including a biscotto stone) for the same price, with way better results. The only reason I can think of is that you got the Ooni for free because you run a CZcams channel.
Thanks for watching
in the chapters you meant "real time cook on gas" not "real time cook on wood" because this stove (not electric) is gas-powered, not wood-fired
Thanks for the heads up I’ll get that changed
That electric seems like it would be a power hog. I can’t imagine using that thing indoors though. It’ll still smoke if you’re using extra virgin olive oil.
What a shame. Where we live, no open flame outdoor appliances, so it’s mandatory electrics. And no way I will pay $1K US for an oven that only cooks a 12” pizza.
Ah man that’s a shame, do you have a balcony? Or is it an apartment? Yes the volt is expensive but I think I will use it more as winter comes around!
@@TomVoyageuk It’s a condo with a large patio. The insurance company prohibits anything open flame on patios or balconies. We have several gas grills permitted in the courtyard for common use, and a number of owners have electric grills on their balconies or patios (as do we, the balconies are on the 2nd and 3rd floors). But that is the situation, and it can’t change. Insurance companies swing a lot of weight. My brother-in-law had the insurance company tell him he was going to have to remove a number of tall trees near his house, he refused. Then they showed him the next year’s premium, and he had them removed.
Didn’t know for the UK but in Serbia gas is extremely cheap and electricity is much more expensive, so no doubts at all, plus gas one you can take on campink in the forest fore example. But i makes sense since you turn back to Russian gas now you pay a lot
WTH is a pizza ‘R’oven?
Thanks for watching!
I can't...."Pizzerovens?"
I can!
The bottom of the (electric) pizza is actually burned
Thanks for watching!
Margherita its a light pizza and the stone is too hot that’s because act like that 😉
Thanks for watching 👍🍕
Hi Tom could I ask a question please. I'm currently considering a ooni volt, if already have a karu but can barely use it due to the weather lol it don't have a enclosed area like you outside. I assume you have used the volt many times now would you say there is genuinely much difference between the taste of the gas and electric volt? Or much difference between the bakes such as rise etc. Are you still using the volt? Thank you so much I'm really struggling and would appreciate some genuine feedback 🙏
Hi thanks for watching and thanks for the questions, to be honest there is no real difference between the taste of gas and electric, but the gas tends to give a better intensity to the cook, meaning a better leopard spotting. The volt is great and I use it a lot indoors when the weather is rubbish or if we want a low hassle pizza night. The volt is more complex to use though and does take some getting used to, as there are more controls and variables when using electric. Mainly to balance the top and bottom heating element. That said I’m once you build confidence with electric, you’ll love it I’m sure! 👌
The gas looks much better.
Thanks for watching!
wow your propane is so expensive
It really is 👎
I just look at that electric $1,000 pizza oven and laugh.😅
How come just because of the price?
@Tom Voyage Price is part of it. It just takes the fun away from using a real wood fired or gas pizza oven. A regular oven does just fine for me if I want to use it in the winter. Really don't need another gadget that takes up space in the kitchen that also might have issues with parts going bad. I use my Koda all year! 😁
I do the same ngl 🤣
@@alge3399 I use my electric pizza oven almost every night. 10 mins pre-heat, 5 min cook. Have used it 200 times in the past 12 months and I would not be surprised if it lasts 10+ years without fault. Don't need a pizza turner or peel. It's just a cheap clamshell but it was less than the cost of a pizza steel for a conventional oven. I do think the price is too high for the ooni but I'd happily own one.
@@prndownloadwhat oven du you have?
Poke your crust with a fork
Why?
Gas-powered pizza ovens have a gas taste
Never experienced a gas taste to pizza
I had Burger King today. Now I have onion ring gas, it's awesome!😀
Please stop opening your pizza oven. And punch your dough down before cooking it. This is why the electric oven performed worse- because of you
Thanks for watching
@@TomVoyageuk no qualms with you personally, mind you. Just the manner of comparison
Both look awful.
Thanks for watching!
@@TomVoyageuk They do though don't they! They look under cooked and just not right. They look soggy.
Thanks for the comment
Pizzas or ovens look awful? I’m sure you would inhale that pizza if hungry 😊
I bet he likes pineapple on pizza 😬
ooni is made in china
Most likely yes, but that isn’t really a indication of how quality a product is, most things now are made in the far East, including high quality products like Apple and Samsung electronics etc
great video, thank you.
Thanks for watching!