Tom what? Ripley - Il cielo in una stanza

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 7. 04. 2024
  • From the "Ripley" series.
    "II Seven Mercies" , episode 2, 2024.
    Il cielo in una stanza - Mina
    Mina Mazzini is, for Ripley, one of those many elements of a life that he longs for but can only inhabit furtively; of a plane of possibilities that has been, by chance, destined to be witnessed through daydreams. A life that contrasts with the one he has been designated to live. A life of poverty, of nothing, of crime, a life of being unwanted.
    He comes to her music, to Mina's music, through this new life, through Dickie, through one of her vinyl records. In this scene, perhaps for the first time, we see his daydreams materialize before his eyes.
    Just as Andrew Scott embodies Tom Ripley, Johnny Flynn as Dickie Greenleaf, and Eliot Sumner as Freddie Miles, with the original version of "Il cielo in una stanza" from 1960, Hildegard de Stefano embodies Mina Mazzini.
  • Krátké a kreslené filmy

Komentáře • 169

  • @BeigbederUtuve
    @BeigbederUtuve Před měsícem +68

    Quando sei qui con me
    Questa stanza non ha più pareti
    Ma alberi, alberi infiniti
    Quando tu sei vicino a me
    Questo soffitto viola, no, non esiste più
    Io vedo il cielo sopra noi che restiamo qui
    Abbandonati come se non ci fosse più
    Niente, più niente al mondo
    Suona un'armonica
    Mi sembra un organo
    Che vibra per te e per me
    Su nell'immensità del cielo
    Per te, per me
    Nel ciel

    • @suzanatriboni3335
      @suzanatriboni3335 Před měsícem +2

      Grazie del testo! Bellissima canzone!

    • @O-YKEM
      @O-YKEM Před měsícem +4

      Thank you ❤

    • @megapangolin1093
      @megapangolin1093 Před měsícem +2

      Grazie mille.

    • @Symmz
      @Symmz Před měsícem +3

      Grazie! (Im American)

    • @auloagostinis5644
      @auloagostinis5644 Před měsícem +2

      Sembra passato chissà quanto tempo da quando è stata cantata questa bellissima canzone, in realtà era l'altro giorno.

  • @danilomedeiros4323
    @danilomedeiros4323 Před 13 dny +13

    An act as simple as getting some ice cubes from the fridge will never be the same again.

  • @peterzisoulis4831
    @peterzisoulis4831 Před měsícem +96

    This is way too good for Netflix ! 😍😍😍

  • @marcoleonti4510
    @marcoleonti4510 Před měsícem +87

    A hommage to Italian culture and art like no other. Beautiful!

    • @caiocax
      @caiocax Před měsícem +5

      Patricia Highsmith loved Italy and this is an ode to la bella Italia..

    • @enzorizzuto210
      @enzorizzuto210 Před měsícem +6

      Magnifico omaggio a Mina.❤

    • @yourstruly1232
      @yourstruly1232 Před měsícem +1

      Truly

  • @MrRenatopepin
    @MrRenatopepin Před měsícem +72

    OMG, Netflix did this? Wtf is going on? Fucking stunning cinematography. Gotta watch this now

    • @Godzilla52
      @Godzilla52 Před měsícem +9

      Technically it was a Showtime Production originally, but Netflix acquired it after Showtime sold it off during post-production due to getting folded.

    • @lisapenny7069
      @lisapenny7069 Před měsícem +12

      Its fantastic, and the music is incredible throughout

    • @Anthony-wp7tz
      @Anthony-wp7tz Před měsícem +5

      I’ve watched it three plus times. I’ll watch this scene and then just keep watching it. Brilliantly shot and acted

    • @FrenchieM
      @FrenchieM Před 11 dny

      Watching die a second time It’s brilliant

  • @hjkim813
    @hjkim813 Před měsícem +49

    While I was watching Ripley the series, this scene captured my eyes. So beautiful and touching..
    I have recorded exactly the same.

    • @kjmh90
      @kjmh90 Před 10 dny

      Perfection 💯

  • @neorich59
    @neorich59 Před 15 dny +14

    Just finished watching Ripley, for the 2nd time. This is one of the (many) knockout scenes.
    Takes your breath away, spine tingling and even though I didn't understand a word, my reaction was (and still is) the same as Tom Ripley's.
    Welling up.......utterly beautiful setting, song and singer!

    • @FrenchieM
      @FrenchieM Před 11 dny +1

      I can’t stop playing it 😂 Mina, find her on CZcams.

  • @sukkim8445
    @sukkim8445 Před měsícem +39

    You are a true champion for uploading this. An utterly mersmerising scene from a wonderful series Ripley.

  • @jimhuang7547
    @jimhuang7547 Před měsícem +38

    What a great tribute to Mina. Got the hairstyle right and even included the mole on her right cheek. Perfetto!

  • @BeigbederUtuve
    @BeigbederUtuve Před měsícem +66

    Una mini-serie maravillosa, con una fotografía espléndida y ya para morirse, esta canción de Mina (Il cielo in una stanza) que se nos hace corta y hay que buscarla para deleitarse una y otra vez escuchándola. Bravo Bravissimo !!!

    • @BeigbederUtuve
      @BeigbederUtuve Před měsícem +2

      Hahaha please don't follow reading if you don't want to know... SPOLIER. I read I wrote... "Para morirse" An spanish sentence meaning we love something so much that we are dead when finished (listening, watching, eating...). And it is real hahaha... Two people listening to Mina in this Caffe will be dead. Hahaha.

    • @JuanRodriguez-mc8lu
      @JuanRodriguez-mc8lu Před měsícem +3

      Una de las canciones italianas mas bonita y eso es decir mucho con tanta calidad que tienen la musica de ese pais.

  • @hvodinh
    @hvodinh Před 17 dny +12

    Hildegard de Stefano is mesmerizing in this too short scene. She has the graceful head and arm movements that makes it such a great tribute to Mina. What an incredible artistic achievement by Netflix this series is. Bravo!

  • @turbojohnson1061
    @turbojohnson1061 Před 22 dny +9

    Ripley is a despicable person but when moved by an Italian song he becomes human, just like us. A narrative note of an absolutely brilliant subtlety and of extreme importance for the character-audience relationship.

    • @marjoriestclair
      @marjoriestclair Před 22 dny +2

      Did you notice though, that only Tom’s LEFT eye teared up at the end of the song? His right eye stayed dry. Psychopaths have very differently wired brains than ours. Parts of their brains are literally shrunken and the empathy centers are weak to non-existent. I wonder if anyone else caught this about Tom’s left eye tearing. I studied psychopathy and psychopaths once several years ago and it is an interesting topic! Scary as hell, though.

    • @turbojohnson1061
      @turbojohnson1061 Před 22 dny

      @@marjoriestclair I did not notice that. Interesting stuff.

  • @anaguerradh
    @anaguerradh Před měsícem +23

    La mejor serie que he visto en años. Una explosión de arte, la fotografía evocadora, hermosa, insuperable, un placer para los sentidos y encima esta maravilla de cancuón en ese entorno mágico, para ver una vez y otra…bravo¡!!!

  • @allanlangdale1028
    @allanlangdale1028 Před měsícem +26

    Television finally has its Citizen Kane. I think Ripley is a masterpiece of televisual art. It points to the remarkable potentials of long-form television. It's hard not to see it earning a handful of Emmys.

    • @GooseBeans1
      @GooseBeans1 Před měsícem +2

      Yea I’m sad it’s set a record for the least viewed limited series released from Netflix ever…. Sad that this generation is killing film noir

    • @Anthony-wp7tz
      @Anthony-wp7tz Před měsícem

      It did??? They don’t know what they’re missing

    • @of7551
      @of7551 Před 25 dny +1

      What a show. The way ripley slowly falls in love with Italy while jumping from place to place to avoid being caught. I wasn’t sure on the black and white at first but after 10 minutes I understood why they did it. Even when you strip away the sun and the colourful buildings the amazing architecture is on show. I liked how the shots would linger on the architecture for a few a bit longer than usual. We just like ripley fall in love with Italy with him.

  • @pumpapaj8977
    @pumpapaj8977 Před měsícem +16

    So incredibly beautiful. What a masterpiece by Zaillian.

  • @mtb5778
    @mtb5778 Před měsícem +10

    Favourite scene from an amazing series. Amazing attention to detail.

  • @caiocax
    @caiocax Před měsícem +19

    The actress is just stunning.

    • @ArgentinaKuHunting
      @ArgentinaKuHunting Před měsícem +2

      Quien es la actriz que canta?

    • @ariefm
      @ariefm Před měsícem +7

      Hildegard de Stefano playing young Mina in this scene

  • @sart56
    @sart56 Před měsícem +31

    Italians live in a parallel world. Often unknown. The world has lost an important piece of art, music.... Now with the internet, lost masterpieces are being rediscovered. As if another world had existed.

  • @creative4art
    @creative4art Před měsícem +12

    The Sky in the Room (English)
    When you are here with me
    this room has no more walls
    but trees
    infinite trees.
    When you are here near me
    this purple ceiling,
    no, it doesn’t exist anymore.
    I see the sky above us.
    We stay here
    abandoned
    as though there were
    nothing, nothing left in the world.
    A harmonica is playing.
    To me it seems like an organ
    that vibrates for you and for me
    up in the immensity of the sky.
    For you, for me:
    in the sky.

  • @jordicasas7627
    @jordicasas7627 Před měsícem +13

    Mina!! She is present in all the chapters or Ripley as she is in all the chapters of my life. Ti amo come un pazzo!! ❤❤❤

  • @Feoktistovs
    @Feoktistovs Před 28 dny +8

    Talented Mr Ripley with Damon and Law is a great film and one of my all-time favourites, so I was excited about this adaptation and how they will tell Ripley's story again but with a new look and new perspective on the character. I think Andrew Scott was phenomenal as Ripley, a cold, merciless, and conniving con man/killer who clearly was chasing a lavish lifestyle through other people in means to get a satisfaction that he believes he deserves. But what makes this performance stand out to me more than Damon's, even tho I love Damon's portrayal as well, is that this Ripley is completely cold, he is not needy or begs for attention or approval. He is just a bad guy. Some may say a narcisstic sociopath or psychopath. He barely showed any emotion whatosver to the people he hurt or killed, the only thing he cares about is making sure he is in a good place and anything else does not matter unless he is feeling great, other people are just toys in means to get what he wants. But he also appreciates art and life in his own way, but the sad part is that in reality, he is a loner, a runner and seems like he never was truly loved for who he is as a person I mean I could go on and on but I hope you understand what I am trying to say. Oh, and also, he is definitely less charismatic than Damon's version. With Damon's portrayal, he was oozing charisma in this one. Ripley is just a creepy, calculated manipulator with a look of a complete Psycho. Either way, I appreciate both performances and like both of them in they own ways, I think the Damon's movie version is more of a entertaining film but this one is definitely more for film buffs and people who appreciate authenticity, amazing acting, masterful cinematography, outstanding sets and great writing. Also, this one feels like straight out of the book, I imagine reading one of those books and imagining these scenes playing in my head while I am reading one of these pages, this even feels like a book but I can see how this series won't be for everybody and that's understandable. It's a very neo-noir/psychological while the movie was more of a fun thriller. Don't get me wrong the movie was still very well made, but it was definitely more colourful in it's approach and more for mainstream audiences than the show Ripley, I can see some people absolutely be bored by this but I really enjoyed it overall. Would give it a solid 8/10.

  • @CarotideEtude
    @CarotideEtude Před měsícem +8

    I just learned a peculiar detail that changes the reading of the scene. The original song was composed by Gino Paoli about an encounter with a prostitute. I don't refute that you can have a meaningful time when you pay for sex, but it strikes me interesting it could be seen as a comment on how Ripley is basically imagining himself as someone who has emotions in this scene just as he is imagining Dickie wants him the same way, just as a paid sex encounter is an imagined love making - the partner is not doing it out of emotion or lust but to make a living. And for Ripley meeting people is also just a transaction, as he is unable to see other people as anything other than means to his goals and little else. So Ripley is in essence both the sex worker's customer and the sex worker here.

  • @g0gomeo
    @g0gomeo Před měsícem +12

    Esto es cine, esto es arte, todo en el pasado fue mejor sin duda.

  • @tarheel72681
    @tarheel72681 Před 23 dny +6

    WOW! I have no idea what she was saying but that was a mesmerizing scene. The black & white makes it more intimate somehow and the actress/singers performance was perfection. I think i replayed this scene 20 times lol

  • @Inthemixmedia
    @Inthemixmedia Před 16 dny +2

    Great scene only in the breathtaking, beautiful amazing Italy and with Stings daughter!!!!

  • @kariricine
    @kariricine Před měsícem +6

    Maravilhosa interpretação da musicista e atriz Hildegard De Stefano

  • @lacoloranga4791
    @lacoloranga4791 Před měsícem +8

    La canzone piu bella del mondo

  • @yourstruly1232
    @yourstruly1232 Před měsícem +8

    I watched this scene prolly 20000 times for this scene 🎬 she says when u n me r together in our room no ceiling exits there is the sky above us and no wall but suddenly abandoned trees infinite trees surround us and The sky is for you and for me. 💞💗

    • @Anthony-wp7tz
      @Anthony-wp7tz Před měsícem +1

      Ha same here

    • @Anthony-wp7tz
      @Anthony-wp7tz Před měsícem

      I believe the audio is from this movie
      czcams.com/video/uyc1PWaY1n4/video.htmlsi=DyzLB0H6TgVvcaWP

    • @yourstruly1232
      @yourstruly1232 Před měsícem

      @@Anthony-wp7tz yes there’s many movies where she sings ‘il cielo in una stanza’, it was very popular. And it’s been revived in the Netflix series Ripley, based on the novel
      The talented Mr Ripley. Both r great 😊

  • @alecwolf1443
    @alecwolf1443 Před měsícem +11

    Just WOW.

  • @user-mg7iv1ks6c
    @user-mg7iv1ks6c Před měsícem +5

    리플리 더 시리즈에서
    이 장면은 정말 인상깊었어요. 미나의 칸초네 처음 알게되었고 미나가 노래부르는 거같았죠ㅎ^^

  • @monanegrete8062
    @monanegrete8062 Před měsícem +10

    Love this song I fall in love again ❤plus a heart capturing movie🌹🌹

  • @sabrinazullo2829
    @sabrinazullo2829 Před 5 dny +3

    La più bella serie

  • @chrisadams6595
    @chrisadams6595 Před měsícem +9

    Wow fantastic song , fantastic scene !!

  • @matheuslino1651
    @matheuslino1651 Před měsícem +7

    tantos detalhes... tantas possíveis interpretações da canção com o geral do fim da série... Belíssimo!

  • @kateryan6420
    @kateryan6420 Před měsícem +7

    Priceless

  • @neorich59
    @neorich59 Před 14 dny +1

    Every time I hear them say "Ripley," it brings to mind:
    "Ripley, she doesn't have bad dreams because she's just a piece of plastic!" (Newt, Aliens II)
    😉😉

  • @user-nh4rk5le9l
    @user-nh4rk5le9l Před 21 dnem +2

    Essa cena é magistral. Tudo é lindo, os atores, a música, a fotografia. Minissérie que não sai da minha cabeça. Bravo !

  • @BeigbederUtuve
    @BeigbederUtuve Před měsícem +11

    He tenido que ir a buscarla a los créditos para descubrir a una joven actriz, cantante y portentosa violinista. Mis respetos y admiración por este ángel, Hildegard de Stefano. Recordar su nombre que esta mujer llegará alto. Gracias bellísima!!

    • @RicardoRXful
      @RicardoRXful Před 27 dny

      Hace una muy buena actuación, pero no es ella la que canta, la voz es de MINA

  • @megapangolin1093
    @megapangolin1093 Před měsícem +6

    Rivetting, blessed, cascade of beauty, poise, elegance and voice. Breathtaking exploration of sensuality. Encore!

  • @AlejandroCastillo-cu8ew
    @AlejandroCastillo-cu8ew Před 10 dny +2

    Toda la pasion italiana en su maxima expresion

  • @mariamicaelaherrera6319
    @mariamicaelaherrera6319 Před měsícem +7

    Bellissima canzone e la serie!

  • @marapaltrinieri5667
    @marapaltrinieri5667 Před 16 dny +1

    Scena da una realtà virtuale. Capolavoro di un addio

  • @StephenTinius
    @StephenTinius Před 15 dny +1

    Eliot Sumner is so perfect as Freddie, just the right mix of softness and protection, both inviting and wary. Freddie know immediately that there's something up with ... "Ripley" ... "Ripley" ... and then the not-so-subtle signal to Dickie. Hildegard de Stefano's impeccable outfit, spectacular hair and spotless physical rendition are just mesmerizing. A short cover, less that 2 minutes, but spot on. Enjoy.

  • @BichaldoTV
    @BichaldoTV Před měsícem +1

    El como ella casi se corta al final cuando lo ve llorando es simplemente cine 🚬

  • @suzanatriboni3335
    @suzanatriboni3335 Před měsícem +6

    Bravissima!!!❤

  • @YoYo-st5nh
    @YoYo-st5nh Před 6 dny

    The moment he tastes the magic. The moment he decides there is no going back anymore. He needs to do what needs to be done.

  • @gracieladistefano9803
    @gracieladistefano9803 Před měsícem +3

    Maravilloso

  • @kathyselvaggio2229
    @kathyselvaggio2229 Před 23 dny +1

    wow, wow, wow. I'm completely smitten.

  • @matheuslino1651
    @matheuslino1651 Před měsícem +4

    "la luce! sempre la luce!"

  • @franciscojaviersainz6972
    @franciscojaviersainz6972 Před 22 dny +1

    Excelente serie y hermosa canción.

  • @georgepremium4541
    @georgepremium4541 Před měsícem +6

    Che musica da Mina circa 1960

  • @jeros1923
    @jeros1923 Před měsícem +5

    finally a real ART

  • @georgepremium4541
    @georgepremium4541 Před měsícem +5

    This scene should have been in the movie as well

  • @TheSizenandosales
    @TheSizenandosales Před měsícem +1

    Lindíssimo!!!!

  • @Jenhka
    @Jenhka Před měsícem +3

    Beautiful!

  • @The-life-of-stray-cat
    @The-life-of-stray-cat Před měsícem +1

    Thanks

  • @bowdlerise
    @bowdlerise Před měsícem +2

    fantastic!

  • @mehmetdonmez7651
    @mehmetdonmez7651 Před měsícem +2

    Very touching!

  • @d.r.2369
    @d.r.2369 Před měsícem +4

    Eargasm

  • @kateryan6420
    @kateryan6420 Před měsícem

    Mr Ripley e rimasto encantato.

  • @LycanVisuals
    @LycanVisuals Před 24 dny

    God damn this was shot nicely.

  • @kateryan6420
    @kateryan6420 Před měsícem

    Perfetto.

  • @juleskinkead4604
    @juleskinkead4604 Před 14 hodinami

    mina was to Italy as the wonderful Mirielle Matthieu was to France during the same era

  • @peterzisoulis4831
    @peterzisoulis4831 Před měsícem

    ❤❤❤

  • @DoubleOBond
    @DoubleOBond Před měsícem +4

    Why do you think Tom Ripley teared up during this scene?

    • @feniaax
      @feniaax  Před měsícem +18

      Mina is, for Ripley, a sort of a symbol, an embodiment of a life he longs for but has been destined to witness from afar, from his own daydreams. Tom is someone divorced from the world and others by his own fate. Orphaned, raised as a moral imposition, and not by will (by his aunt), he resented the world as a reflection of her and his own life.
      When he sees in the midst of an existence of nothingness and miserable crimes, by pure chance, a bridge to that life that he could only imagine, he crosses it forever. Boarding a train across Europe, he writes to his aunt, "You're free of me now. And I of you."
      In his odyssey, in Atriani, in Dickie, he finds the archetype of his imagination; a life of hedonism, of possibilities, of beauty. Still, a life that is not his own, that he can only inhabit furtively. But at least, for the first time, he can inhabit. Just like with Mina, when he sees her on Dickie's vinyl, when he listens to her on the record player. When he travels to Naples, and in a cafe, going down the stairs, his daydreams perhaps for the first time materialize before his eyes.

    • @CarotideEtude
      @CarotideEtude Před měsícem +5

      It's simply the unquestionable beauty of that performance, her elegance and implicitly understanding the meaning of the song that describes a shared, ephemeral moment between lovers, even if he didn't speak Italian well at this point. Yet he already has fallen in love with Dickie or at least what he represents.

    • @annal2740
      @annal2740 Před měsícem +6

      It's so clever and subtle, superb acting by Andrew Scott. His tangible affinity with great art is ne of the elements that has us rooting for Ripley, despite our better moral judgement.

    • @DoubleOBond
      @DoubleOBond Před měsícem +1

      @@feniaax well done, very eloquently put.

    • @Anthony-wp7tz
      @Anthony-wp7tz Před měsícem +1

      He looks sooooo insane

  • @Manu-ct2xy
    @Manu-ct2xy Před měsícem +2

    La luz, siempre la luz

  • @christophwaltz8919
    @christophwaltz8919 Před měsícem +2

    pointbreak x Ripley after this scene.

  • @rezalustig6773
    @rezalustig6773 Před měsícem +3

    I’m gonna get the papers get the papers

  • @claudiavaldinocci2073
    @claudiavaldinocci2073 Před měsícem +1

    where was this scene filmed?! Please 🫶🙏🏻

  • @Mandarb7073
    @Mandarb7073 Před měsícem +6

    Must. Learn. Italian.

  • @HelinhoPln
    @HelinhoPln Před 9 dny

    Qual o nome dessa atriz/cantora?

    • @robertoegosum1501
      @robertoegosum1501 Před 2 dny

      La cantante è Mina (Mazzini).
      Forse conosci 'Parole, parole, parole'.

  • @JuicyFinn
    @JuicyFinn Před měsícem +32

    I think the voice is Mina's version, meaning that the voice does not belong to the woman on screen - which makes the lipsync all the more impressive to be honest, it's 100% perfect.

    • @thynguyen031792
      @thynguyen031792 Před měsícem +8

      Of course, Mina's voice. Nothing sounds like her voice

    • @ariefm
      @ariefm Před měsícem +3

      She IS playing young Mina in this scene 😊

    • @DavidAntrobus
      @DavidAntrobus Před měsícem +6

      It also gives it a slightly Lynchian feel, which totally works for the whole mounting dread vibe.

    • @thguillaume
      @thguillaume Před měsícem +6

      I think that you are right but I have never heard a version with Mina where the intro is piano solo and a mix with her voice so much in the foreground as this one. To me this one is the best version .

    • @BeigbederUtuve
      @BeigbederUtuve Před měsícem +2

      @@thguillaume Totally agree with you. I heard here a new clean voice and as I listened to other songs of this actress-violinistplayer-singer I believe she is so great... Because she played as Mina, black dress, so relaxed, finger moving, singing... And she confused a lot of people thinking she is not singing, playback... But she does in just two minutes a great performance, marvelous to remember and don't forget. And we cannot forget the producer and who was the responsibility of choosing this great woman. Perfect work. Thanks!!!

  • @yakov8515
    @yakov8515 Před měsícem +2

    sensitive killer

  • @user-sj2ox5cb5s
    @user-sj2ox5cb5s Před měsícem

    what are the drinks on the table?

  • @enginkonuk2877
    @enginkonuk2877 Před měsícem +2

    Who is this woman?

    • @federicoklein4935
      @federicoklein4935 Před měsícem +3

      This version of 'Il cielo in una stanza' is by Mina.
      The first and original version of the song was written and recorded by Gino Paoli

    • @BeigbederUtuve
      @BeigbederUtuve Před měsícem +4

      Hildegard de Stefano. Buscando he encontrado que además de actuar, canta y toca el violín. Pero seguro que tiene más cualidades. Por favor Hildegard, si lees esto o tu manager, no seáis humildes y enriquecernos e iluminarnos con todo lo posible sobre ella. Gracias miles!!!

    • @enginkonuk2877
      @enginkonuk2877 Před měsícem +3

      @@BeigbederUtuve Gracias Senor! This moment in that tv show was perfect. She impressed me a lot. I m still watching that part even i finished that tv show :)

    • @feniaax
      @feniaax  Před měsícem +3

      @@federicoklein4935 No. The song was written and composed by Gino Paoli, but the first recording of it (and release) was performed by Mina Mazzini. Gino later recorded and released his own rendition as well, when he achieved notoriety in the music scene.

    • @maurodomenicopiccininni1300
      @maurodomenicopiccininni1300 Před měsícem

      @@feniaax Exactly!!!!!!!!!

  • @museum5003
    @museum5003 Před 29 dny +2

    Made in Italy

  • @yourstruly1232
    @yourstruly1232 Před 9 dny

    At 1:45 min in she’s the female Julian Casablancas 💘

  • @franj1
    @franj1 Před 7 dny

    The casting of Freddie is completely ridiculous.

  • @annal2740
    @annal2740 Před měsícem +4

    The only thing that isn't perfect in this clip is the terrible casting of Freddy.

    • @feniaax
      @feniaax  Před měsícem +5

      If I have to be honest, I detest "diversity quotas" in casts, but I don't feel like it was the case here. I found Eliot's interpretation completely organic, credible. I believed the character. I didn't see someone playing it.

    • @madcatt09
      @madcatt09 Před měsícem +1

      💯

    • @annal2740
      @annal2740 Před měsícem

      @@feniaax Fair enough. But it was impossible to believe she was a man.

    • @caiocax
      @caiocax Před měsícem +2

      Eliot was perfect as Freddy.

    • @caiocax
      @caiocax Před měsícem +2

      @@feniaax Eliot was amazing.

  • @wearethenightparty
    @wearethenightparty Před 28 dny +1

    Such a weird 2024 conceit to pop a woman in the role of Freddy and expect the characters to act like she's a man and for viewers to also pretend that she's a man. What a bizarre, anachronistic thing to do to an otherwise excellent production. Completely blew the suspension of disbelief.

    • @marjoriestclair
      @marjoriestclair Před 26 dny +1

      Eliot is androgynous enough to pull it off. Many things in the world to be upset about and you choose this? Bless your heart!

    • @joewhite22
      @joewhite22 Před 23 dny +1

      @@marjoriestclair Well it would be weird to start complaining about the wars in Ukraine or Palestine for instance, in a comments section for a clip from Ripley, wouldn't it?

    • @marjoriestclair
      @marjoriestclair Před 23 dny

      @@joewhite22 I think you know exactly what I meant here. Stop bitching about stupid stuff, in other words.

    • @joewhite22
      @joewhite22 Před 22 dny

      @@marjoriestclair It's not bitching though, it's someone giving their opinion on a show that they otherwise find excellent. Is there a rule that says you can only praise a show? I happen to agree with their criticism too. I don't find the casting of this character convincing.

    • @marjoriestclair
      @marjoriestclair Před 22 dny

      @@joewhite22 I think the casting was perfect. You don’t. Fine. Enough said. It’s just the petty shit flung at a perfectly good actor who did a wonderful job in spite of your esteemed opinion that seems a bit vapid. Cheers.

  • @marapaltrinieri5667
    @marapaltrinieri5667 Před 16 dny

    Just the foolish passion of USA' s intellighentsija for ITALIAN'S Ghosts, Amen

  • @user-kx1rd3hz5k
    @user-kx1rd3hz5k Před 16 dny +2

    Heard about. Intrigued now. Haven't seen a big one since True Detective. This the 13th adaptation of a Highsmith novel. It feels commensurate with this very troubled period. Purple Noon was Alain Delon's big break through in the role of Ripley in 1960. Dreams of life what ifs.....