PM “clearly breached” MCC & “undoubtedly violated” RPA whilst ECI response “insult to constitution”
Vložit
- čas přidán 16. 05. 2024
- Modi's "very clearly and categorically" breached Model Code of Conduct and "undoubtedly violated" Representation of People Act; Election Commission has "abdicated its solemn duty" and "insulted Constitution of India": Dushyant Dave
...........................................
In a hard-hitting and outspoken interview, one of India’s most highly regarded Supreme Court lawyers, Dushyant Dave, has said the Prime Minister is “guilty, very clearly and categorically, of breaching Clauses 1 and 3 of the Model Code of Conduct” and added he has “undoubtedly violated” Section 123 of the Representation of People Act. Mr. Dave said the Prime Minister has “demonized and disparaged” as well as “maligned” the minority community. At one point in the interview, Mr. Dave even suggested that the Prime Minister could be open to class action on the grounds of defaming the Muslim community when he called them infiltrators, something similar to what happened to Rahul Gandhi when he was found guilty of defaming all Modis.
In a 21-minute interview to Karan Thapar for The Wire, Dushyant Dave, a former President of the Supreme Court Bar Association, also spoke extremely critically of the Election Commission of India. He said it has “abdicated its solemn duty conferred by the Constitution”. He accused it of “gross impropriety” and called it’s response to the allegations against Mr. Modi “a disgrace”. Mr. Dave said the Election Commission has “insulted the Constitution of India”.
Asked by The Wire, how the Election Commission should respond, given that for three consecutive days (Friday, Saturday and Sunday) Mr. Modi has continued to demonize Muslims and lie about the Congress manifesto, disregarding the notice issued by the Election Commission on Thursday, Mr. Dave said that the Election Commission should issue “an interim direction” which would “injunct” Mr. Modi from demonizing the Muslim community and speaking untruths about the Congress manifesto.
I am only giving you the main broad points made by Mr. Dave. This is an extremely forceful and powerful interview. Mr. Dave makes clear that his view the Prime Minister has breached both the MCC and RPA has been expressed after due consideration and care and made as a thoughtful lawyer and not made polemically. I strongly recommend you see this interview.
Join The Wire's CZcams Membership and get exclusive content, member-only emojis, live interaction with The Wire's founders, editors and reporters and much more. Memberships to The Wire Crew start at Rs 89/month. / @thewirenews
Election commission is dead in India for bjp
Save Indian democracy from BJP
First time in 70 years pm didn't kept respect either pm chair or constitution its unfortunate 😞
He is a repeat offender.
60 to 70 percent of the country are in his pocket. You and I will be treated like insects criticising him
That's why we needed an educated person as prime minister of this Nation.
Vote for the I.N.D.I.A alliance
Save the country
Save the Constitution
Save democracy
Vote for NDA and save yourself 😂
If country, constitution is saved,you are automatically saved
@@deepdive259 very useless comment. please never write anywhere
@@deepdive259
23 villages from mumbai(Palghar) returned freebees saree given by modi
and ask
dont give us free bies
give us jobs
better
schools
better health care
they say sabka sath sabka vikas
where is vikas
If you would have given us jobs, we would have been able to buy these sarees ourselves. Who is Modi government to give us sarees? Are we your wives? You think we cannot buy our own clothes? We will buy better sarees than these. We want work, we are hardworking. We are not sitting at home," said Ladkubai
Country is destroyed by parties like tmc , sp and rjd who brought criminals to parliament
The PM should be put behind bars.
Modi does not deserve to be a pm.
He even does not deserve to be called a human being
Now people have Chance not to be again by casting their vote.
The PM Modi should be behind bars for his untruths about his breached of moral code of conduct.
He is a big liar
There will be many more reasons that emerge for him to be behind bars.
The spineless commission, does not have the dare to question the emperor.
We are all indebted to the Hariyana man Durve Rathee as his vidios are in Hindi.
Emperor?? Kuch bhi kisiko bhi emperor mat banao. Politicals are supposed to be desh sevaks
Not emperor he is an error..
The vitriol and hate spewed by the PM is beyond appalling. I don't know how his supporters are ok with his crass and uncouth behavior.
All his supporters are crass and uncouth... he is catering to his audience.
Every time you believe he can’t stoop any lower, he surprises you.
His supporters don't appear to be educated themselves. They have sullied the August Parliament.
Rahul Gandhi was convicted for his remarks on people of a certain community, although his statement was misinterpreted. Now, what about Modi, who clearly made disgusting, disgraceful and derogatory remarks on Muslims?? Shouldn't he be indicted ??
Are members on aimim indicted
Shame to have him as a PM
ECI is baised, why citizens should not doubt malign intentions of ECI ?
Down Down Modi Save our Nation. Jai hind
Sir aap jaise patrakaaron ko salaam
It is high time the Supreme Court initiates immediate action against the ECI officials and the leader, they cannot remain silent spectators when the future of this nation is in peril.
Supreme Court must take suo motto cognizance of this violation. It cannot afford to stay silent while the constitution is being raped.
No need to take action, communal voters will polarize immediately
Yes SC should act Accordingly
It should not loose it's credibility
If SC keeps quiet
People will loose confidence in trials and hearings.
EC has to act Accordingly also,
But it is not, why so biased ?
But the s C turns deaf ear to all such cries ?!.
SC don't have police Or army, there are thousands of cases government don't take actions,
We need people like you with courage to utter the truth in constitutional position like election commission
Tn seshan is the best chief election commissioner in indian history
Only persons of the calibre of Karan Thapar and Dushyant Dave sir could dare to do such a strong program. Thanks sirs.
Excellent Excellent Dhave sir,
Great great views,
Thapar sir Excellent interviews
Great going
May God bless you
Save democracy
Do we really have SC judges who can take on ......what PM has spoken......???
The Chief Election Commisioner must make amends and take action against PM and then resign!
time to oust this govt
Great discourse
Mr Dave is a very courageous and knowledgeable person Stay safe and take care of yourself
Fellow citizens please vote for INDIA and save this country.
Please go and vote positively without fail.
Showing some concerns in the media and not voting will do immense damage to our country.
Please save demovracy and thereby our lovable country INDIA.
Vote responsibly vote for change
Vote for no to wealth redistribution
Very beautiful presentation of facts
Thanks so much to Karan & Dave for this interview. We want more and more such eminent and noble people to come forward and condemn this PM for his hatred speech. It is really disgusting to see how a leader like the P🤩
Modi is not a democratic,he is king so we must defeat him this time
Democratic Raj of India.
Not just kings...people praise him like he's God...shame on him and the people who praise him
In my 70 years never seen this kind of speech of a PM in the country which is not a good for the country's future generation to come EC should take serious action on this subject because rules are equal for every citizen of the country.very good discussion between you both which is 100 per cent truth but who will bell the cat.
Good video report from Karan Thapar ji based on Discussion with distinguished lawyer and intelligent personality on various issues of national importance.
He should be tried in a court of law for violation of law
Very well Dushyant dave ji
Vote for change.
But who has the courage to book him .. he know nobody in the country wil take any actions against him..
This is an evil side of him. If he hits a hat trick, be ready for the worst.
Good day...
Mr. Dave, my regards to you.🎉
Is it not time to file petetion in SC on both ECI and PM..are these above Constitution?shame, PM has lowered the dignity of chair he occupies.is it because of his illiteracy?
You're right, it's because he is illiterate and his cohort of ministers are spineless.
Under what legal provision that PM Modi is not arrested and so not put him behind the bars???
We require people like T N Seshan
Kudos Karan and Dhave you have" dared to be a Daniel and dared to make it known!".
Why the PM is not taken to Court? Is he above the laws of the land?
Just now, Today 29th April, 2024 @ 3.20pm, there comes the BREAKING NEWS: The Delhi High Court dismissed the Petition filed for Breach of MCC by the PM, saying that his reference to Religion is NOT A BREACH. Where lies Justice?
Our Courts are all ‘saffron’…no justice can be expected. Shame, cowards!
OMG!
Mr Dave is a bold person and he doesn't shy away from answering
Unfortunately we are missing someone like Mr Seshan 😢
Mr Dave has pointed the way who will bell the cat???
EC cannot treat the PM, or any other person for that matter, as sacrosanct however high he is, EC has undoubtedly abdicated its responsibility and acted with unhidden bias.
PM should be a role model to its citizens, unfortunately Modi is anything but !!! SAD to see him lie all the time and hurts to see his desperation !!!
Speaking truth is forbidden according model code of conduct !!!!
Truth🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 Truth and Modi are antonyms.
Yes, somewhat these apprehension of hate speech is violation of not only freedom of speech but the way democracy itself is. I am not agreeing with what Modi said because he clearly twisted things or lying but our concern should be about freedom of opinion.
@@DaveShree Shouting hateful and provocative slogan everyday five times is not hate speech ?????
@@krishanuadityapandey4414 This is tool for governments to censor discussion which need some challenging or alt view, mainstream narrative is monopoly of governments and they want you to discuss in those limits only.
😅🎉
Eci is spineless and without any credibility... Sad
Democracy is ostensibly there, but it is infact really missing - That last line pretty much sums up Gujurat model being forcefully implemented all over India.
It is high time now it is the duty of the responsible citizens of this country to act now before it is too late
Let's face it Mr. Thapar and Mr. Dave! The PM was targeting his core vote bank by uttering those words against the Congress and the muslim community. It's another matter that those were false but when has the PM bothered about these small details?? ECI should have taken cognizance and the notice should have been given directly to the PM. But that's like expecting the HR department of a company to pull up the owner and CEO!
Respect for people who speak. Even if it doesn't matter.
The PM will not understand what it means if he has ever read the manifesto.
Why competent people not taking this to Hon SC demanding an immediate verdict...
S C has become a Joke! They are demoralising and letting down people of India! Long ‘Bhashan’ but no concrete judgement / action against the guilty and wrong-doers.
Answer is given in the interview at the end by Mr. Dushanth Dave himself.
ECI SOLD OUT ; IN THE GREAT INDIAN SALE !!!!! SAME WITH JUDICIARY WITH DECISION REGARDING VVPAT AND EVM !!!
Aam Janta ko Jagrook Hone ki Jaroorat Hai.---- AJAM, Buxar, Bihar.
The negligence & fear of EC to act upon, is mere free hand to communal violence.
Than you Karan for this honest, courageous interview with Dushyant Dave ji. One of my highly respected 💯
Just remember the remarks made by C J I on appointment of CEC.Let there be any amount of violence not only by Modi even by another leaders of B JP. EC will not take any strict action against them.
A very nice and vold interview,high high respect and admiration to youu karan sir and dube sir for this outspoken and clean clear message that the pm has truly voilaged the law and EC are obligated and tamed by the bjp.
We the Citizens respecting the laws of India looking upto Supreme Court take Suo Motto on this illegality, insult to Constitution of India and Institutional puscillanimous actions.
This interview is an eye opener for all citizens. It is the prime duty of the Election Commission to take serious note of the hate and illegal speeches being made in elections irrespective of who makes such speeches. There is no level playing field for all political parties. It is an unequal election battle in terms of money power and man power. ECI should exercise their powers and enforce rule of law.
Very shocking speech
It seems this election commission is more loyal to Modi than many of the BJP workers. The only objective of the election commission now is to get as many seats for the BJP by hook or crook. The Supreme Court is also giving good support to the election commission.
Mr. Dave is absolutely correct from the judicial point of view.
जब जब भी लगता है कि नरेंद्र मोदी नीचता की पराकाष्ठा को पहुंच चुके हैं, वे एक तल और नीचे चले जाते हैं, अभी तो पता नहीं क्या क्या देखना बाकी है।
Absouletly , he has made himself a name in the history to be First from down.
He has gone so low that is impossible to anyone to go lower than.
तू देखेगा 2080 तक
मणी शंकर अय्यर उवाच।
Mr. Dave is always welcome for honest discussing national issues.
Concerned people should file defamation suit against PM in appropriate court.
Punishment should be given
Will Mr. Rajeev say (ECI)something for same??
P.m should be debarred from standing for the election.
Was Rahul Gandhi disbarred for calling sitting pm a thief
All the sane ones, and there are many, also think so. He must be debarred!
I salute the courageous Mr Dave.
Where values meet legality, and justice finds its voice. 📜⚖️ #ConstitutionalMorality #EthicalLaw
Candid interview of shri Dave.
Modi must be barred to speak and be not allow to contest.
We are always with neutral and intellectual media and Karan Thapar
❤😂🎉.
Salute to conscience keeper of the Nation, Shri. Dave.
No good citizen will like the type of speeches made by so called star campainer.
सार्थक भावनाओ को सुनकर जनता को होसला मिलेगा ।सैलूट दोनो महानुभावो को ।
It's indeed very unfortunate that we no longer have EC like Mr.T.N.Sheshan. Nowadays we have Selected Commissioners who are committed only to the selector.. otherwise how can it be so helpless
The best part of the program is summ8ng up the statements and arriving a clear statement.
Baffled by the act of ECI
.....or the inaction you mean??
140 crores of INDIA's population observing Modi PM of INDIA lying in his Rajasthan speech regarding Congress party's manifesto and the Muslim community & ECI still not taken any ACTIONS violating MCC
Useless commission.
The dazzling Karan Thapar.... congratulations
Protect our constitution
Silence or not initiating appropriate actions by EC is more worrying than PMs speech. Where are we heading to..? Last hope is on from the Apex court
I would like to know whether there is any way ECI can be held responsible for its rather lenient view on utterances not in conformity to ideal code of conduct?
The PM's speech, filled with venom and hatred, is deeply disturbing. Its difficult to comprehend how his supporters can condone such crude and disrespectful actions.
Karan sir, you're doing an excellent job. Please continue doing it. Our nation requires journalists of your caliber. Jai Hind!
Supreme court should take suo moto case against the election commission and the prime minister. Election commission ows its position to the constitution and not to the p.m.
ECI AND SCI DONT WALK THE TALK. UNFORTUNATE THESE PEOPLE SHOULD RESIGN OUT RIGHT HERE AND NOW.
Shame on ECI (CEC and other 2 Commissioners)
Who is ready to catch the bull by the horns? Can the public put a case against Pm?
Not easy to catch a donkey.. it always kicks..
Excellent. Every statement of Mr Dave was a pearl.
Excellent discussion hats off to both Karan and Mr. Dushyant 🎉
I’m still surprised why Congress is not approaching the honourable Supreme Court to take action against Mr Modi.
The SC has become a JOKE…has let down the Citizens of India! All talk, no action!
If CEC has flagrently violated Constitution of this country he undoubtedly liable to prosecuted by Honourable SC judges keeping in mind the high respect of the Constitution if not then no matter.but it must be in larger public interest to protect Loktantra.
Not only CBI, ED, even SC, High courts are working under BJP's Modi
Nice interview
Excellent ; hats of to you, sir.
Dr Dushyant Dave ji an honest n dauntless patriot.