Unique and Challenging! - The "First Cylinder" Puzzle

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 24. 03. 2017
  • The objective of the First Cylinder is to separate the upper cylinder from the lower. But before you can do so, you have to understand the mechanic that's inside. A well-balanced puzzle, challenging your imagination, to understand the mechanic behind.
    My Amazon.com shop:
    www.amazon.com/shop/mrpuzzle
    As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
    The puzzle shown in this video is available here: www.puzzlemaster.ca/browse/in...
    jpgamesltd.co.uk/buy-puzzles/...
    More cool puzzle shops I do recommend:
    US:
    bit.ly/2GXglAA
    bit.ly/2J9eARK
    bit.ly/2IeqoRR (10% discount by using voucher "Mr Puzzle")
    Europe:
    bit.ly/2C1ZEoI
    bit.ly/2Ik1QGK
    bit.ly/2GpfN5w
    Asia:
    bit.ly/2pPHka0
    The links above are affiliate links. If you click the link and buy a product, I will receive a commission from the seller.
    Subscribe for further puzzle reviews, recommendations and solutions.
    Music:
    Mandeville von Kevin MacLeod ist unter der Lizenz Creative Commons Attribution license (creativecommons.org/licenses/...) lizenziert.
    Quelle: incompetech.com/music/royalty-...
    Interpret: incompetech.com/
  • Hry

Komentáře • 362

  • @irishnurhd3288
    @irishnurhd3288 Před 7 lety +234

    there's a bunch of these puzzle solvers, but Mr puzzle is the only one I can stand to watch.

    • @DigitalViscosity
      @DigitalViscosity Před 7 lety +11

      FLEB is pretty decent, but I still like Mr puzzle better. FLEB can be too nerdy and his voice annoys me

    • @oksills
      @oksills Před 6 lety +9

      Irish Texas AMEN to that! He's completely converted me. Before, this type of thing was boring to me. But, his manner, voice, accent, and method have pulled me in. I'm subbing and buying some puzzles!

    • @StefanReich
      @StefanReich Před 6 lety +1

      You prefer the German? That's crazy

    • @Jake-jy5pq
      @Jake-jy5pq Před 6 lety +5

      Irishtherapist Big Moneyham I like him and Chris Ramsay

    • @melbazar
      @melbazar Před 6 lety +4

      Chris Ramsay is great too, But i like Mr's Accent :D it makes me happy

  • @thinkcivil1627
    @thinkcivil1627 Před 6 lety +3

    I like the analytical way you approach each problem. I have a friend who is an architect and besides other interests, difficult puzzles are a hobby for him. In past videos, you've mentioned similar phrases (2 or 3 dimensional for example) and it really is a different way of looking at the world. Thank you for your excellent videos!

  • @themightybodie
    @themightybodie Před 7 lety +61

    the first cylinder puzzle is trying to open the biscuit tin while holding a cup of tea

  • @jimhood1202
    @jimhood1202 Před 3 lety +1

    Very elegant mechanism. I like the outward simplicity of the design. Enjoyable to watch.

  • @hristorbital
    @hristorbital Před 7 lety +322

    It's possible the V stands for the roman 5, which should be a hint (5 balls inside). I'm sorry if you mentioned it and i missed it in the video.

    • @Mr.Puzzle
      @Mr.Puzzle  Před 7 lety +142

      No, I did not.
      Very interesting hint!

    • @spleenforsoul
      @spleenforsoul Před 7 lety +5

      That is exactly what I was thinking. I was going to post it and I seen you already did :)

    • @sethcragan6908
      @sethcragan6908 Před 7 lety +4

      Bitcoin buyNsell ..why, makes perfect sense.

    • @oenta83
      @oenta83 Před 7 lety +8

      The "V stands for his 5th production, and has nothing to do with how much balls are in there.

    • @screwball1010
      @screwball1010 Před 6 lety +47

      I wish my ex had had an indicator of how many balls had been inside her before we dated.

  • @teramark69
    @teramark69 Před 7 lety +106

    Have you ever spoken to any of the actual creators of these puzzles? It would be fascinating to know how they come up with the ideas for these intricate puzzles!

    • @Mr.Puzzle
      @Mr.Puzzle  Před 7 lety +38

      +Mark Criss Hi Mark, that's an interesting point for the future I guess.

    • @DragoVolcar
      @DragoVolcar Před 7 lety +23

      Mr.Puzzle I KNEW you sounded like the guy from The Room. You typing Hi Mark has confirmed it!

    • @akbychoice
      @akbychoice Před 7 lety +3

      A little larger diameter to hide the cut out and no hole in the bottom would make it even tougher to solve. Be easy to make a wooden version on a lathe.

    • @AstralComposition
      @AstralComposition Před 7 lety +5

      I did not hit her I did not hit her oh hi mark

    • @roughshaf7321
      @roughshaf7321 Před 7 lety +1

      Oh hi mark

  • @conradkabay6166
    @conradkabay6166 Před 5 lety +1

    I love listening to this guy. I have purchased one puzzle (so far) just by what he recommends. He is a great salesman (IMO) and I think I want to buy this puzzle.

  • @JayLamm
    @JayLamm Před 7 lety +102

    You should try and crack the Lament Configuration--also known as Lamarchand's Box. It's hard to come by and devilishly notorious to solve.

  • @benjaminlucas6944
    @benjaminlucas6944 Před 6 lety +12

    Mr.Puzzle nice vids! You should do a riddle at the end of each video and answer it in the next video

  • @poetnathan26
    @poetnathan26 Před 7 lety +22

    I love your accent! I find your videos very soothing to watch and listen too. Thank you:)

  • @PumpkinHeadJim
    @PumpkinHeadJim Před 7 lety +484

    looks like an herb grinder if you know what I'm saying

    • @Mr.Puzzle
      @Mr.Puzzle  Před 7 lety +65

      Thought the same when holding it in my hands the fist time :)

    • @Mr.Puzzle
      @Mr.Puzzle  Před 7 lety +39

      Nope.

    • @chedisLoL
      @chedisLoL Před 7 lety +26

      Zingtron god you sound so gay.

    • @RoyalKype
      @RoyalKype Před 7 lety +3

      big pumkin head ass jim I get you (;

    • @clashface
      @clashface Před 7 lety +5

      big pumkin head ass jim snoop Dogg would be proud

  • @robertclark3258
    @robertclark3258 Před 6 lety

    Sir, you are truly a puzzle genius! I truly enjoy your videos.

  • @hassanelhaddad9990
    @hassanelhaddad9990 Před 7 lety

    As you said it has a very unique solution
    the fun for some difficult puzzles is , when you solve one by chance and you forgot the steps , you can not put it back easily , it is another challenge , so it is a double fun .
    thank you Mr. puzzle

  • @Jon-Jon309
    @Jon-Jon309 Před 5 lety

    Took me 2 days using pen and paper to try and track what troubleshooting steps I had already taken LOL TY for showing how to put it back together.

  • @markinnes4264
    @markinnes4264 Před 7 lety +15

    That's an unusual and well made puzzle that makes you think

  • @andrewfong3406
    @andrewfong3406 Před 7 lety +85

    this guys the new Bob Ross

    • @dooterscoots2901
      @dooterscoots2901 Před 7 lety +4

      except bob ross was missing a finger and was in the army

    • @unforgivenromantic
      @unforgivenromantic Před 6 lety +1

      dooterscoots Air Force.

    • @michaelgiannes
      @michaelgiannes Před 6 lety +3

      bob ross beats the devil outta this

    • @A_Man_In_His_Van
      @A_Man_In_His_Van Před 5 lety

      Watch stevemre1989. He is the most relaxing to watch. Its strange, but relaxing abd informative.

  • @ItsaRomethingeveryday
    @ItsaRomethingeveryday Před 7 lety

    I never woulda figured this one out! Great Video!!

  • @ibieiniid4240
    @ibieiniid4240 Před 3 lety

    the only place I come when I'm in the mood for a puzzle solve with a side of spectator colonoscopy.

  • @dickreckard5026
    @dickreckard5026 Před 7 lety +53

    This mechanism could be stacked to create a combination lock.

    • @SilentShadovv
      @SilentShadovv Před 7 lety +10

      That would have rated it 10 out of 5, haha :)

    • @johnniewalker39
      @johnniewalker39 Před 6 lety +1

      Dick Reckard
      i thought about the same thing !

  • @mr-pubg-1083
    @mr-pubg-1083 Před 6 lety +3

    So satisfiying whene he preses it and makes the noise

  • @romeorosos1849
    @romeorosos1849 Před 6 lety

    everytime i watch your videos i fall asleep so i use this remedy for my insomnia love ur videos 😊

  • @herotgd327
    @herotgd327 Před 7 lety +3

    When i see ur first hanayama puzzle solution i already sub xD love ur vids keep making it so i can cheat to my friends when they have one xD

  • @mitchkatz4918
    @mitchkatz4918 Před 3 lety

    thats so cool! would be good to see the action of what you were doing with the scope in the bottom

  • @angelisone
    @angelisone Před 7 lety +14

    It's not a cheap puzzle to buy.
    Running close to $100.00.
    That is too expensive for me to buy for my daughter.
    But your review was nicely done.

    • @intorsusvolo7834
      @intorsusvolo7834 Před 7 lety

      angelisone it looks like you can make it yourself for much cheaper

    • @angelisone
      @angelisone Před 7 lety +1

      Not unless you will provide good directions.

    • @ytubesucksazznow
      @ytubesucksazznow Před 7 lety +1

      100 fucking dollars for cnc machined aluminum,,, wow im in the wrong fucking business.

    • @austertheu-tuber9213
      @austertheu-tuber9213 Před 7 lety +1

      APCWORLDSUXAZ What's expensive is not the material, it is the thought that put into making this puzzle

    • @angelisone
      @angelisone Před 6 lety +1

      Why not just put $100.00 in the envelop without signing your names?
      If the professor know & love you, then he or she would reply back to you.
      Long time ago, I found a tiger cub. I fed that tiger cub & nursed her back and set her free.
      7 years later I came back to that place and was almost being attack by wild dogs.
      A tiger jumped out of nowhere and killed three wild dogs & made other run away. Then that tiger came to me and laid on her back, in front of me so I can reach down and hug her.

  • @MasterMindmars
    @MasterMindmars Před 6 lety

    Excellent. Thank you

  • @jacoblaughbon3323
    @jacoblaughbon3323 Před 6 lety

    Great Vid. Will try to find this puzzle in my travels. :)

  • @horbi6205
    @horbi6205 Před 6 lety

    Somehow klemmt hier🤣 sehr schön! Hätte ich sein können... Ich mag deine Videos.

  •  Před 7 lety +6

    Cool videos you have,I'm subscribing! hehe

  • @Auieist
    @Auieist Před 7 lety +2

    thank you for your videos

  • @georgiivanov61
    @georgiivanov61 Před 7 lety +5

    Wait, do you actually have to press and release the top cylinder between each ball?
    Wouldn't it work if you just press and start rotating/rolling it?

    • @Mr.Puzzle
      @Mr.Puzzle  Před 7 lety +5

      +Georgi I think there are faster ways then the way I did. But you need to rotate the big cylinder to get the balls move completely inside.

    • @MuiMui555
      @MuiMui555 Před 6 lety

      if u dont release the cylinder before turning, the balls would just slide of to the other side again instead of falling directly into the hole i guess.

  • @IEBATechThoughts
    @IEBATechThoughts Před 6 lety

    Wow. That's a very creative puzzle!

  • @jerryfrugoli3339
    @jerryfrugoli3339 Před 6 lety

    Oh I love this one!!! I too have yet to see this one before!!!! I didn’t hear you mention if this was stainless steel metal, or if this was manufactured from aluminum? I’ll be purchasing several of these and sharing with friends. Thank you for sharing it with me.

  • @jdaily__2943
    @jdaily__2943 Před 6 lety

    MR.PUZZZZZZZZZLLLLEEEEE! Nice content!

  • @IaKhanic
    @IaKhanic Před 7 lety +2

    Great video sir!

  • @hrishizone3647
    @hrishizone3647 Před 7 lety +10

    great video sir..👌

  • @vicious-pi3rd
    @vicious-pi3rd Před 7 lety

    You can easily memorize where the opening are at and use your minds eye.While rotating it.Sort of like seeing with your hands with your eyes closed to find something in a familiar area.

  • @boonker2k
    @boonker2k Před 7 lety

    Do more puzzles like this one and the box one

  • @BCZF
    @BCZF Před 7 lety

    Beautifully machined

  • @lilcarlp1792
    @lilcarlp1792 Před 6 lety

    I love Mr.puzzle he is so cool and humble

  • @ymisoflyg8612
    @ymisoflyg8612 Před 7 lety

    can u press the top cylinder in when the V is lined up with the notch...hold it pressed in..and slowly keep rotating the whole puzzle slowly and just have the balls fall in one by one with every rotation without ever letting go of the top piece that's pressed in? so can be solved in one push and 5 to 6 full rotations?

  • @chaosincarna
    @chaosincarna Před 6 lety

    When will you try the Lemarchand's box? I hear the Lament Configuration is the hardest to figure out.

  • @vladiputin4904
    @vladiputin4904 Před 7 lety +1

    schönes video, ich hoffe auf mehr guten content (:

    • @Mr.Puzzle
      @Mr.Puzzle  Před 7 lety

      +Vladi Putin Ist schon in Arbeit

  • @ianmooney5495
    @ianmooney5495 Před 4 lety

    Hi Mr.Puzzle, any chance you can make a video on Wil Strijbos' Aluminium Cross?

  • @jackalbrecht8301
    @jackalbrecht8301 Před 6 lety

    I like the way he says unique.

  • @hisamkhalaf2196
    @hisamkhalaf2196 Před 6 lety

    Hi Mr puzzle ...i think you are quite intiligent to be an invinter ...you have a pure mind ...why do'nt you be so ....??? i like what you do anyway ...go on....thank you so much ...

  • @ZivkoSkobic
    @ZivkoSkobic Před 6 lety

    Can it be used as a storage for a small note or something similar?

  • @YoKnow
    @YoKnow Před 6 lety

    Tell him to do the elephant next because I love them just as much. Plus you know it came with two or three of those tricky puzzles

  • @williaml2579
    @williaml2579 Před 7 lety +1

    tks for showing this interesting puzzle. Can you share the link of where to buy it from? Tks

    • @Mr.Puzzle
      @Mr.Puzzle  Před 7 lety

      +William L I bought it directly from the creator.

  • @pawloiox2585
    @pawloiox2585 Před 6 lety

    You spend more money on puzzles than me on my jordan collection

  • @metametodo
    @metametodo Před 6 lety

    I like puzzles that the process to reassembly is different from the process to disassembly.

  • @baigmusic
    @baigmusic Před 6 lety

    Hey Mr. Puzzle, how do you get your audio recording to sound so clean without any background noise?

  • @Seminolerick
    @Seminolerick Před 6 lety

    A unique combo lock

  •  Před 6 lety

    Dude that sound 2:55 kills me man

  • @Ulujmf
    @Ulujmf Před 6 lety

    Can you give a link where you got your pen microcamera? Thanks

  • @TheLewylew
    @TheLewylew Před 6 lety

    did you forget the link to buy this puzzle?

  • @voticiano
    @voticiano Před 7 lety

    Hey Mr. Puzzle, where can I buy the puzzles you solved in your channel?

  • @Knight11692
    @Knight11692 Před 6 lety

    You can't get it on the link listed it's not on the page at all.

  • @MarcSputnik
    @MarcSputnik Před 4 lety

    Echt gute Erklärung auch bei den anderen Videos!

  • @manojkumargujju
    @manojkumargujju Před 6 lety +6

    I want to buy it there is no link in the description

    • @Mr.Puzzle
      @Mr.Puzzle  Před 6 lety +6

      Unfortunately it is very rare and difficult to get. I did not find a link where to buy it.

    • @chrisvaldesistheman
      @chrisvaldesistheman Před 6 lety +3

      Mr.Puzzle if you come across a link to buy this in the future, will you be so kind as to post it as an update to this video? Thanks!

  • @BenNJapan
    @BenNJapan Před 7 lety

    Where can I buy this puzzle? I see no link in the description for this puzzle

  • @KurtisQu
    @KurtisQu Před 7 lety

    When you open a mr puzzle video: *scary music* install hooked, skips as

  • @Cray2TheZ
    @Cray2TheZ Před 6 lety

    This looks just like my grinder! :P

  • @bjarnehansen1101
    @bjarnehansen1101 Před 6 lety

    Wo hast du das Rätsel gekauft? Online oder gibt es hier in Deutschland einen laden wo man das erwerben kann?

  • @kamikami-bn6zh
    @kamikami-bn6zh Před 6 lety

    i want to ask you from where do you get those puzzles , i realy want to try them.

  • @athuldevin
    @athuldevin Před 6 lety +8

    what about its rating

  • @TheAdityavuppala
    @TheAdityavuppala Před 7 lety +1

    Very nice

  • @hp5792
    @hp5792 Před 6 lety +4

    What if it Exploded when you opened it up

  • @brianhiles8164
    @brianhiles8164 Před 3 lety

    You say the mechanism for opening is unique, but it seems similar in function and design to the _Titan Ball_ puzzle, which I am confident that you have heard of.
    In the _Titan,_ also fabricated of turned aluminum, it has two ball bearings, not five, and two dedicated detentes, not an axial path.

  • @justindewoody
    @justindewoody Před 6 lety

    Where did you get that little camera with the led lights on the end of it?

  • @sophianicole8671
    @sophianicole8671 Před 6 lety +4

    Couldn't you just press down and turn it all at the same time? The hole would remain open to the balls and they would be able to fall out one by one as you turned it?

    • @jakewastaken
      @jakewastaken Před 6 lety

      No. It's not made that way. The fist ball will keep the second from entering the cylinder.

    • @2512Eu
      @2512Eu Před 6 lety

      My guess is, that the balls have some free space along the trench, so if you press the top, and just centrifuge it, a ball could have a chance to fit in the hole, depending on the rotation speed. But even if you figuere out where the hole is and once centered, you really have to turn the cylinder with the hole down

    • @2512Eu
      @2512Eu Před 6 lety

      oh yeah, maybe fitting a small magnetic rod through the lower hole might attract the balls, so while rotating the top you feel the first ball get throught that aligned passage. But that is a post-viewing conclusion. I like the spinning idea and catching the momentum.

  • @Kenshar1984
    @Kenshar1984 Před 7 lety +10

    Please make some videos on logic word puzzles / riddles!

    • @Mr.Puzzle
      @Mr.Puzzle  Před 7 lety +9

      +Kenshar1984 You have any special puzzle in your mind? If yes, please let me know the name or manufacturer.

    • @Mr.Puzzle
      @Mr.Puzzle  Před 7 lety +11

      Very interesting idea!
      I will check about the possibilities to do that.
      Thanks!

  • @fontunetheteller410
    @fontunetheteller410 Před 6 lety

    Show me a link to buy that tiny camera please!!!

  • @Zhenmaster007
    @Zhenmaster007 Před 6 lety

    nice reggae music in the background, :) gets me relaxed

  • @mutantkoffee
    @mutantkoffee Před 7 lety +1

    foking challenging one, I loved it.

  • @Arthur-nc6yp
    @Arthur-nc6yp Před 6 lety +1

    Looks like Robert Langdon's device at Inferno.

  • @Desklamp1234
    @Desklamp1234 Před 7 lety +8

    i could make the best puzzle ever, just a cylinder like this that only opens when you say the 1 thing a man has never said. "Wow my wife always seems to be right"

  • @Collateralcoffee
    @Collateralcoffee Před 6 lety

    I wonder where the link to get it is...

  • @saadatsaeidi6354
    @saadatsaeidi6354 Před 6 lety

    Hi, Please let me know where i can order one, I checked amazon , its not there

  • @TheFrenchPug
    @TheFrenchPug Před 2 lety

    Its beautiful

  • @keniangervo8417
    @keniangervo8417 Před 6 lety

    What is your difficulty rating for this puzzle? It seems awesome but hearing some people like you did it very fast and others very slow, it made me think

  • @koelling
    @koelling Před 4 lety +2

    looks like a doorstopper 😜

  • @johnsmith1474
    @johnsmith1474 Před 6 lety

    It appears you could align the transfer passage once, then evacuate all the balls by tilting and rotating.

  • @tdear66
    @tdear66 Před 6 lety

    The mechanics of that reminds me of that puzzle. I have it, but can't get it open. It is a sphere instead of a cylinder, but it has three rotating rings that make up the body of the aluminum baseball sized sphere with a plunger button at the pole with ball bearings inside moving around.

  • @vern2982
    @vern2982 Před 6 lety

    any links to get this puzzle?

  • @timbosak2519
    @timbosak2519 Před 6 lety

    Very impressive! But I was drinking and didn’t catch the re-assembly. Looks confusing. That’s why your a better man than me.

  • @jeremytenorio3099
    @jeremytenorio3099 Před 7 lety

    I made one of these. easy peasy rice and cheesey. mine doesn't have the cutout in the female end though so you have finesse it more to get the ball bearings to drop.

    • @Mr.Puzzle
      @Mr.Puzzle  Před 7 lety

      +Jeremy Tenorio The one I showed would impossible to solve without the cutout. The balls could not get out

  • @razznation6205
    @razznation6205 Před 7 lety +14

    gute videos machst du, mach weiter so 💪

    • @Mr.Puzzle
      @Mr.Puzzle  Před 7 lety +5

      Danke!

    • @Sebastian77t
      @Sebastian77t Před 6 lety +2

      wo kann ich das denn kaufen?

    • @Mercutio87
      @Mercutio87 Před 6 lety

      Sebastian77t den Link habe ich auch vergeblich gesucht, das Video habe ich auch nicht geschaut, das Puzzle interessiert mich aber bis jetzt am meisten, ich muss es haben 😂

  • @pavloskairis9994
    @pavloskairis9994 Před 6 lety

    to assemble again, around 10:00, what happened to the magnet?

  • @gagodeaqp7078
    @gagodeaqp7078 Před 5 lety

    Where did you put the magnet

  • @Mercutio87
    @Mercutio87 Před 6 lety

    Leider kann ich keinen Link finden, wo ich das Puzzle bekommen kann 😔

  • @EBLITZR
    @EBLITZR Před 6 lety

    first thing I thought of is a grinder 😂🌿

  • @mayyn77
    @mayyn77 Před 6 lety

    where do you buy puzzles like this?

  • @traviantist
    @traviantist Před 6 lety +1

    hard to use pepper shaker

  • @Spencer18861
    @Spencer18861 Před 6 lety

    so where can you buy this

  • @MrEsphoenix
    @MrEsphoenix Před 6 lety

    that'd make a cool little safe mechanism if there was some space inside

  • @vitakyo982
    @vitakyo982 Před 6 lety

    Where did you get the mini-camera ?

  • @david1528
    @david1528 Před 6 lety

    Where can I purchase the cylinder puzzle?

  • @CountKoski
    @CountKoski Před 6 lety

    Now that balls are magnetized it may be a different puzzle altogether - possibly shut forever.

  • @geramelendez9318
    @geramelendez9318 Před 6 lety

    Whats the name of this puzzle and who is his creator?? Pleaseeee

  • @nichts_als_die_Wahrheit

    where can i buy this puzzle?