Liverpool 3-1 Nottingham Forest, FA Cup S/F 1989 (Old Trafford)
Vložit
- čas přidán 24. 01. 2011
- 15/04/89. Hillsborough. Britain's worst sporting disaster. 96 football fans went to a game, but never returned home. The game in question was the FA Cup semi-final between Liverpool and Nottingham Forest. It was abandoned after 6 minutes. 3 weeks later, the semi-final was replayed at Old Trafford. I dedicate this video to the memory of the 96, and hope that one day they get the justice they deserve. Martin Tyler is the commentator.
- Sport
What a player John Barnes was....best player in the country at the time.
RIP 96 LIVERPOOL FANS. YOU WILL NEVER BE FORGOTTEN xx
I'm a Chelsea fan and I remember watching that fateful day at Hillsborough. There is always going to be rivalry between fans but the so called fans who use this disaster and others to mock each other in my opinion is disgusting. I remember in 1985 Chelsea played at Hillsborough on the first day of the 85/86 season. I was with my two brothers, one being only 14 and when we were queueing to get in there was only 2 turnstiles open and we were getting crushed against the wall at the side. I had to lift my younger brother up to stop him getting hurt. I know that is nothing compared to what happened that awful day but it was a bit scary. Like you say the 96 will never be forgotten and my deepest sympathies go out to all the families and friends of the fans who so tragically died that day. I might be on my own when I say this but I think the Hillsborough stadium should have been demolished and a shrine erected to commemorate their sad loss and Sheffield Wednesday should have relocated to another ground. I mean there is a place of remembrance at the site of the World Trade Centres and when the awful story about what happened at Fred West's house came to light that house was demolished so why not Hillsborough? Also I think I'm right in saying that the Heysel Stadium was demolished after that tragedy. How can anyone stand or sit at Hillsborough after what happened I don't know.
Heysel was due to be demolished anyway wasn't anything to do with the trouble or deaths but totally agree with you about leppings lane end went there myself twice in the late 80's and it was a deathtrap.
YNWA
Never… 😔 🕯🌹💕🙏🏽
I remember watching the game on TV. I was 14 and loved Liverpool even though i am from Oxfordshire. Bloody hell summers were just so beautiful back then. I miss being a kid!
Wow a Liverpool fan from Oxfordshire who would of thought!
Can never understand people who support teams no where near where they live. I mean Oxford had a half decent team back then too. My brother in law supports Liverpool even though he’s from Notts. I don’t even take him seriously when he wears the top and tells me all about the current team form etc. I say you can know all you like about the history of the club, current form etc etc but I still don’t see you as a Liverpool fan you’re from Notts 🤦🏻♂️ where as I got a mate who is from Liverpool and is a casual fan. He wouldn’t even know who they are playing next, what position in the league they are in etc and hasn’t followed them for weeks. But even so when he wears the top and I saw him earlier in the pub about to watch them on tv in the semis today everyone still saw him as a real Liverpool fan. I guess it means something to be from the place your team represents.
@@megadave1197 I was a kid, I grew out of supporting them in the end.
Yes mate , I was 14 in November 89
Fabulous times .
Much much better than todays premier league .
I don’t watch football anymore . I hate it
@@megadave1197some waffle that 😂😂😂😂😂
You look at this and think why wasn't the tie originally played at Old trafford in the first place?
Very true every football fan knew about leppings lane end and Hillsborough in general they didn't use it for most of the eighties because of crushing don't know why they went back there.
Hindsite is a wonderful thing isn't it, the Liverpool v Forest game should really have been played at Villa Park as the red would have taken a bigger supporting away crowd and that stadium had the larger capacity to accommodate it, as an Evertonian we should have played Norwich at Hillsbrough in the other semi. whats dones done now and its in history im sorry to say.
Hillsborough had a larger capacity than Villa Park; Old Trafford had a larger capacity again. However, OT couldn't be used on the 15th, as United had a home match. Hillsborough shouldn't have been chosen simply because the ground didn't have a safety certificate. Add in the incompetence of the policing and stewarding, and you're left with the entirely preventable loss of 96 lives; hundreds injured; and an unknowable amount of PTSD. Why lessons weren't learned from the 1981 and 1987 semi-finals is beyond me.
Scherben very true the tunnel was too steep and didn't adhere to the safety rules it was a 1 in 6 gradient when it should have been 1 in 10 I think plus barriers were added, moved or removed without any upgrade to the safety certificate in pens 3 and 4 , signage was inadequate and the supposed capacity of the whole terrace was wrong. It wasn't used for 6 years after 1981 and why they started using it again is beyond me. As you say the warning signs were there in 87 and 88.
I'm unsure what you mean by the "wasn't used for 6 years". If you mean the Leppings Lane terrace, that was in use, as United filled it on three occasions in the 80s prior to the disaster. :)
Barnes' movement @ 4.22....incredible!
Martin Tyler with his familiar expressionless commentary upon Liverpools goals.
I thought that first goal was disallowed the way he described it
Zakariyya Yusuf he cant exactly go crazy can he? He would have been called disrespectful for it
I heard his commentary for the Barcelona comeback. No enthusiasm what so ever
Funny they scored their second goal just as I was reading your comment and I all I could hear was, "Liverpool lead again! Is it Aldridge again? It certainly is!"
Is this commentary original? I have a feeling it was added on years later for rebroadcast purposes. Tyler's voice was higher than this in the 1980s.
@robicenco1 It seems like it's dubbed over
When footballers played 50+ games a season and didnt complain. When the balls were harder but you saw better goals that relied on skill and power (rather than a light weight ball bobbling about too much) and when more importantly than all, football had a community.
and stadiums were death traps...
@@supertarantatikataka3313 no they wernt ya nonce, just better
@@getthecansin So what happened at Hillsbrough.💁🏿♂️
@@flalingbashers2957 miss management by stewards and police… proven
@@getthecansin happened before though at Ibrox in 71 and Bolton in 46 with plenty of deaths both times.They were death traps potentially
I like seeing old games like this because you have players like Aldridge who had come up through the leagues and paid their dues before getting a move to a club like Liverpool where they made their name, not being paid 20 grand a week since they were 18 years old.
Well growing up through the leagues didn't teach him to show respect for his fellow pro's did it Joe. After the entire footballing world came together to show support and sympathy after Hillsborough, for him to disrespect someone for scoring an own goal is nothing short of disgusting not to mention the bereaved families expecting nothing less than their club to show dignity in very difficult circumstances.
Was to young to attend this game ( Forest fan ) but had relatives who did and were saddened by Liverpool's opening song 'we hate Nottingham Forest......' after the help and assistance Forest fans gave at Hillsborough, which was a tragedy for everyone in football especially everyone in the ground. Shame really but never mind, RIP 96.
Rivals never enemies
Help and assistance? Once aware of the scale of the tragedy they kept there mouths shut, initially they were insulting and booing the fans on the pitch. Forest fans didn't come onto the pitch and the SWP decided they needed to waste officers from helping the injured and dying by forming a line right across the halfway line. How did Forest fans help? I do remember several of your fans and that manager of yours blaming the Liverpool fans for the disaster. That's about it.
Now you see that's an old Liverpool song from the 70's and it goes ' We hate Nottingham Forest We hate Everton to . We hate Man Utd but Liverpool we love you. So that's what the song was and was sung at every game back then so it has nothing to do with what happened at Hillsborough.
@@garethfieldstead7547they were chanting you Scouse b's and "sign on" while the disaster was occurring
probably the most important game Liverpool ever won.
I was on Leppings Lane with my dad on that terrible day and we didn't have any inclination to go to this replayed match, though we watched it live on television. I went to the final, but Hillsborough had taken its toll and the magic evaporated in the midst of this dreadful event.
One of the best matches that I never saw on TV.
I heard the commentary on the Radio and it sounded like a fantastic match.
I only got to see it on the internet just few years ago on CZcams.
Respect To You and Sorry for Your Loss from an LFC Fan
Been a very long time since I’ve seen the highlights of this game. Old Trafford looks much fuller then I remember it being. I was stood on the Trafford Road end of the ground for this. And the atmosphere amongst the fans that day was strange to say the least. Don’t ask me to explain as I can’t
Seriously? Maybe 97 fans unlawfully killed at the original game had something to do with it. Come on think before posting nonsense.
I'm a Liverpool supporter and I have to agree with you. It was uncalled for and showed another side of John Aldridge I hadn't seen before..apologies
I don’t think John Aldridge meant any disrespect he was caught in the moment. Met him a number of years ago absolute gent👍
They will never be forgotten God bless the 97
Forest was not strong as in the 70s, but still a serious team in the late 80s and early 90s
Aldo regretted the head rub and apologised.He was a top striker and was a winner.
What are you referring to??
@@chopperdieshispubesginger6946
8:27
Hated him for it at the time, really disrespectful to Forest.
Is it true or just another urban myth that Tony Adam's made a point of ruffling Aldridge hair following Arsenal win at the end of that season saying that was for Laws?
He done it twice didn’t he?
Obviously didn’t regret it that much……he’s in a select club of one of only one footballer(s) past and present who I’ve zero respect for ……..
was glad to hear that bruce is well
Thanks for posting, good video again.
Good old Aldridge, not too distraught by recent events to humiliate a decent pro like Laws by ruffling his hair with a big grin on his face. What a great lad.
Do you think he was a bit emotional? Fucking idiot.
Aldridge is a bell end, always was.
It wasn't Aldridge it was Chelsea. Disgusting behavior. Is it true Adam's ruffled his hair after the title decider the following month? Great!
David O’Leary done the same hair ruffle to Aldridge in the final game of this season and Aldridge didn’t like it.
Tony Adams
Never forget as an 11 yr old .
so many memories
Walk on, walk on....with hope in yopur heart and you'll never walk alone!!!!!!!!
I remember getting up on a Sunny day in May, no school, taking my ball to the local park, and spending the entire morning kicking it around on my own, dreaming about the upcoming game, doing all the commentaries etc! " Oh, HE'S SCORED!
They weren't happy days, I'm suspicious of nostalgia, but that was a lovely memory of being a kid.
I don't know why so many people bitching about Aldridge. Then again this was a time before football fans got so fucking offended by every little thing.
Given the significance of this match, the crown distribution seems rather odd - theres is masses of empty space on the predominantly seated Scoreboard End and yet the mostly standing Stretford End is full. Given the 39000 attendance in a ground which at the time held well over 50,000 the logical thing would to fully utilise the seated sections and reduce the number of standing tickets.
Not a Liverpool or Forest fan but I've always hated that Aldridge hair ruffle moment. Especially at this game of all games.
Ye ,that always grates on me, as does the whole game. it shouldn't have been played,LFC should have withdrawn from the competition
In Aldridge defence, I think it was out of character an done in the heat of the moment. It did look in really bad taste. he is a scouse and Hillsborough devastated him. this game was maybe a release from the previous 3weeks of hell
+red men
I was just thinking that. That Liverpool could have withdrawn from the competition and bowed out.
Was it not only after consultation with the families that they chose to continue? I remember both Everton and Forest saying that if Liverpool withdrew, they would too so that the trophy would just go unrewarded.
red men What would withdrawing have achieved? Playing it gave the fans and players a much needed distraction and winning it was a great tribute
@@gavb9816 it was totally in character a truly awful human being
What great great memories eh .
Waking up morning and first thing comes in ur head is football
AND Nothing but football..
Wow who wears short shorts? Barnesy wears short shorts
Rip the 97 massive Liverpool fan 40 years always treasured and remembered great game ❤❤❤❤ we had a ledgend team this day atmosphere electric ❤❤❤😂
Nice touch with Man U flying the Liverpool flag above OT; Jonny Barnes was a machine was he not?!?
Why wasn't the first game played here? That'll be the question that's asked over and over. YNWA..
United were at home on the 15th.
@scherben ... 100% Correct
Is Ray your arl fella, mate?
terrific side lfc at that time, full of amazing players & yet, my favorite one, john barnes always stands out
Barnes was not only a top drawer footballer, but a proper winger. He must look at today's inverted wingers and chuckle. Imagine Ian Rush playing today? No chance.
@ureds27 How is that in anyway typical for Liverpool? I have been there countless tims and never have I experienced anything like that or felt threatened in anyway.
You can always count on martin tyler to not get excited when Liverpool score.
so what? knobhea
Forest were in an impossible situation here. Should we just let Liverpool win? - like the whole world wanted us to, or beat them and be universally hated for it? A reason why so many fans stayed away that day. Not a pleasant game to watch.
Steve Forest why was Brian Clough in the stands?
ajwasp he had a touchline ban
The vast majority of neutrals wanted a Forest win mate. Only Liverpool/Derby and maybe a handful of Leicester fans didn't!!!
@G K Does the truth hurt snowflake? :-)
Shoulda never have been played as a mark of respect to those that died
Just listened to John Aldridge on LFC's podcast and he regrets and apologised to Brian Law for that celebration after that own goal
I had been for a ride on my yamaha rdlc 125cc that day i came home dad was in his greenhouse mum busy in the kitchen they broke the news that their were reportedly "issues" on the radio saying game stopped it was and still is a sad sad memory for our country that the moment in time is sadly true
Justice at last!
22 days after Hillsborough. Holy Cr*p.
Old Trafford a better designed stadium, should've been the ground to host in the first place, why were fan pens ever a thing? Why if all the fans are the same team would they remain in place? I think that Liverpool rightfully didn't withdraw, it was better to honour those who had been victims by trying to win the cup. Who'd have thought in 2018 after it seeming like we'd had justice, proceedings have currently been thrown out against Bettison?
oh my god what a joke
Ironically, the pens were in part due to fan hooliganism. Heysel 1985 (which, unlike Hillsborough, was the fault of fans together with poor stadium choice/UEFA management) being one incident during a very troubled time. There was standing room in stadiums to allow for bigger capacities and more revenue. In the 60's and 70's it wasn't uncommon to see crowds right on the touch and goal lines. At times, they were literally on the pitch. Hillsborough was the disaster that revolutionized stadium safety standards. And it's the main reason that today you can go to a football match in relative safety. I always thought Old Trafford or even Wembley would have been a better choice. Hillsborough had been the location of the exact same fixture the year before and there was no major incidents. The disaster happened because of inexperienced police officers in charge in 1989. It's also worth mentioning that as I write this (15 Jan, 2019), Duckenfield, who was the officer in charge at Hillsborough, is on trial for manslaughter. Along with several others.
@@muttley8818there were no major incidents in 88 but a lot of fans and the club expressed fears about it. One of the victims allegedly said to his brother "oh no not there again*
that was a time all were so pleased to hear Rushie departure and Aldi came 😁👍
Barnes made football looking so easy.
Still sad of the title loss of 1989 but 1988 was the best year ever.
Aldridge was out of order ruffling Laws hair after the defender was unfortunate enough to score an own goal, little wonder O'Leary did it back to Aldridge in the title decider
Must've been a weird game to go to.
i liked the first goal, it was unusual
Back when a minutes silence was impeccably observed
Exactly!!!
Not sure Liverpool would ever have lost this match or indeed the final.
It’s all history good or bad,but all supporters. Have there memories respect to all
Who's here from Guardian?
Odd seeing Liverpool playing at Old Trafford and wearing red
Exactly, same with any other team who normally wear red.
It was a great day, tinged with sadness, I was in the liverpool end, the tickets were only £5.00.
at 7:45 the guy pass the ball to the goalie and the goaliee grabbed it with the hand? was that allowed back then?? o:
leo portillo, er..yes!!😆👍
If I remember rightly, the law changed in 1992.
What team, what a player Barnes was. But the FA Cup should have been cancelled that year. YNWA 96
Aldo with the hair toss lol.
My memory of this game is probably very different to most on here. I was at Villa Park watching Everton beat Norwich when Hillsborough was happening. Then like everyone with any empathy realised if the balls had come out the hat in a different order that could have been me and my club suffering. Between Hillsborough and this rearranged game John Aldridge announced he was seriously considering he may never kick a ball again. I knew at the time he would . Then Brian Laws scores an own goal. Nottingham Forrest indeed the entire footballing world stood as one with Liverpool, and how does Aldridge repay it? He takes the piss out of Laws. Laws on the ground devastated at scoring an own goal has Aldridge come along and ruffle his hair. No sympathy , it may be a small thing, you could argue after Hillsborough people weren't thinking properly. I was genuinely disgusted at Aldridge throwing back all the sympathy his club and himself had received with this selfish uncaring act. I will never forget this and have never heard a single person ever mention it. That's my memory of this game , instead of my first thought being a club their fans and players showing the strength to live this nightmare again and come through the other side it's of John Aldridge humiliating a fellow pro for his mistake. Thanks John I hope you're proud.
That hair-ruffling incident shamed Aldridge. I remember it well. Like you I was at Villa Park watching the Blues beat Norwich (terrible game) on the day of Hillsborough and remember the news filtering through on the radio. If I had been Brian Laws I'd have sought him (Aldridge) out after the game and demanded he explain himself. Maybe he was just immature (or, more likely, thick) but it jarred horribly with the atmosphere the game was played under.
An everton supporter bitterly offended by something a Liverpool player did? What a surprise. Class and dignity FC. You lot will be going down next season hopefully. Good riddance to bad rubbish.
@carlkermode899 another hypocritical Liverpudlian failing to recognise the many morally corrupt things the club, officials players and fans do. Class and dignity? You don't know the meaning of the words.
Disgrace from Aldridge patting Laws on the head after the goal. Hopefully Laws caught him before the final whistle.
Fair comment, I don't disagree. But there's always a degree of collective responsibility in football supports. If there's collective will to stamp out e.g. the singing of a certain song, then it will be stamped out. If there isn't, then it won't. It's hard on the decent fans who don't sing the songs, but there you go.
Everything's been said in comments before..but you have to Give Clough credit as being one of the greatest football brains of his and most eras..created so many gr8 footballers and teams and such attractive football..said stupid comments about LFC supporters after Hillsborough that make it hard for most to acknowledge his achievements
Comments he retracted and apologised for
Not sure if I would of gone to this game if I was a liverpool supporter but I am sure most of the 96 would of been ok with it.
We meet again
Safe terracing not difficult to arrange and desperately needed in modern football.
@SuperWowzah er, isn't he Irish?
Who Aldridge? Not really.
I love the way you got booed in the old days if you did tippy tappy around your own box....Wish that happened now !!!
Aldridge looked a mug ruffling Law's hair after his unfortunate own goal. Really poor sportsmanship.
Lol the Fifa commentator back in the day.
Players souness should have signed: n Martyn, petrescu, keown, s Pearce, McAllister, r.keane, Lee Sharpe, shearer, le tissier.
Should not sign: d.james, Ruddock, m.wright, Dicks, p.stewart, m.thomas, n.clough, Walters, Saunders.
Redkhapp, macca, Fowler soon to come. Get sol Campbell and le saux into youth set up with them. Phase out Staunton, Houghton, McMahon, Beardsley, slowly. Sell or exchange rush but keep Barnes as central midfielder
Sorry I rush jaldridge
Can you imagine scoursers on the stretford end ffs
@ureds27 Labelling Liverpool fans as 'Stupid Scouse Pricks' collectively is just wrong. You judge them based on the very small negative minority; did 15 million fans charge at you or was it 15?
Should never have been played, cup should of been scrapped as a mark of respect - very sad.
rest in peace
mohd fauzi Hamdan
N.martyn. petrescu, keown, Pearce, Staunton, McAllister,, Barnes, mcmanaman, r.keane, letissier, shearer. Sub. Fowler, redknapp, Lee Sharpe,
This was difficult game to watch at the time. Similar fences and all, from tv as young lad.
Hats off cloughie got some good players Chapman hodge Parker crossley
i always felt Liverpool should have withdraw from this competition. i did at the time
I know the sentiment and there rational I this is what he families would have wanted and well win it for them
i seriously doubt the families cared one little bit about football. I know many liverpool fans never went back to the game after that day
They timed that well so.
A lot of people on here slating Aldridge for his hair ruffle I am a Liverpool fan and looking at it again it is embarrassing ,and not really the best but take a look at today's footballers most are cheats diving and throwing themselves to the ground cheating their fellow professionals not at all disrespectful .hey ?far worse in football than that moment
5:13 why did he say 1-1 at old Trafford
because it was at old trafford :) this game was originally played at hillsborough but we all know what unfortunately happened... so they decided to replay the game a month later at old trafford instead! fa cup semi-finals used to be played at neutral venues years ago... until wembley took them in recent years and spoilt the whole thing about 'getting to the final at wembley' :/
Because the teams had scored one goal each.
Awful understated monosyllabic commentary as always from Martin. There needs to be an enquiry as to how this guy has stayed in his post for so long. MartinGate
YOU REDS Stevie Sutton almost seemed to let that secound goal in, so agree about Aldridge disgusting he should be ashamed of himself.
If you fell the same as I do a true lfc fan join me by making posters saying FUCK THE SUN and hang them up
Get over it. 35 years and still cry arsing. They made the mistake of believing the police and have apologized on numerous occasions since. No wonder everyone hates you. Not like Liverpool fans are angels.
And today you got your wish,,,YNWA
@graemea67 yeah right,truth hurts don't it?
A large minority of Forest fans tried to jeer out the minute's silence before this game. So clearly not all of you put aside 10 years of pure hate.
As for "drop kicking a women[sic] at semi final in 1988"... you're just bullshitting.
The only game Liverpool won at Old Trafford in the entire 1980's
So what ? Winning at old trafford were not imortant in those days, beating Liverpool in one ore
two matches was all what United had to play for.
United 0 Liverpool 1, April 7th, 1982.
Smudger Smith, Not true. Research yur facts, muppet!!👎
@@scherben8870 yeah you tell the united tosspot
@@davidreed1995 I'm a United tosspot, too ;)
btw he wasnt being cheeky he is a scouse and loves the scouse people. Its called emotion
But I heard the same thing about Pool fans that day from my mate who was at the game. Is he completely wrong? I know this isn't the place for it, but it's not the first time I heard it. Every team has fans who act like twats on matchday, and Pool are no different. Right?
No, but football being football it made songs about Hillsborough sadly inevitable. Maybe if Liverpool fans hadn't made it their business to taunt United about Munich for so long, United supporters wouldn't have seen fit to taunt them about Hillsborough. But they did, so I guess we'll never know.
The celebration was even better, in May 20th, 1989. Liverpool won the title. THEY DID IT FOR THE 96 FANS!!!!
Liverpool didn't win the title in 1989. Arsenal did!!!
YNWA
Aldridge a bloody disgrace for showing a lack of sportsmanship and dignity to Laws 8:29 after own goal,he wouldn't have done that to Stuart Pearce.He would still be in bloody orbit.Forest on the day were on an hiding to nothing with the countrys' sentiment and emotions demanding a Liverpool win. R.I.P.the 96
Na mate. Vast majority still wanted a Forest win! A far more popular club up and down the UK.
And a massive portion including myself hate Liverpool with a passion.
Hillsborough as dreadful a tragedy as it was would never change my opinion.
Good lad.
barnes same no n character like coutinho
Nice piece of shithousery from Aldridge after the og 😂
Have to say it again... Barnes was one of the all time greats.
Aldridge, no class
@ureds27 Once again with the stereotypes; how many liverpool fans do you know? Of course I'm ashamed of the SMALL minority that have let this club down (e.g heysel), and offended by everything? How exactly?
lol @ 8:29
How did ya get on beating Oldham??? Ahahahahahahahahahahahahahah!!!!!!
Formerly i love Liverpool fc now i love man utd
Not a football fan then
David sentosa your a twat you Spanish arshole