I completely agree, in comparison with “Like Spinning Plates” the live version is much better and more clear. I love the electronic touch but the album version is a bit too electronic.
So I was learning this song today and saw your comment. I think it goes even deeper than what you're saying. Even a simple sounding song like this isn't simple. The words don't match up with the piano hits, it's syncopated. Which means it takes twisting your brain a little bit to figure it out. Not only is it beautiful, but it's kind of hard to play and sing this at the same time, and I didn't even notice until I tried. He's a genius.
Exactly.. I play the Jonny parts in my radio cover band and it is amazing how `simple' the songs sound but how well they are composed. I always played classical music but playing Radiohead is so much fun.. for me it is classical music but in a modern jacket.
@@porouscrump when we write songs this comes automatically. it is way more difficult to learn some one elses song than it is to write your own. I find this aspect of music funny. I've done both - learned complex stuff like Bach and written my own stuff as well as played variations on a Bach theme ...
Man I love this song.. It hurts me as a musician to see such a brilliant song be composed of six chords.. I especially love how Thom threw in a small chunk of the There There chord progession. If you listen closely you can sing "Why so green and lonely" from There There over top of the second part of the song. I think it's brilliant
took me 15 years to see this comment and now I can't ever hear this song the same again. Thank you. Just when I thought it couldn't get any better, I was wrong. The beauty of Thom and Radiohead...listen to a song a million times and on the millionth and one time discover something new.
thom is such a fool. He does the greatest live performance of one of the best songs ever written and all he says at the end of it is a mundane "that was good". Such a gross understatement.
@@etherealbonds Objectively, it probably isn't (if there even is an objective way to measure it). But it's still one of *my* favourite songs of all time. So y'know, you can fuck off.
Can we talk about how insane this rhythm is for a second? I mean seriously... I'm trying to learn this song for 3 days straight on my piano and I'm nowhere near to figure out that rhythm with those sick chord changes! And this guy is singing to it like it's nobody's business... Seriously guys. Slow this down to 0.5 and try to listen to it. Even they fucked it up at the beginning.. I have to play it at 60bpm and still fucking it up every chord change.... unbelievable! Unfreaking believable!! Greatest fu*king musician that ever walked this earth. Period!
apart from being an amazing song...what i love is the fact even though its a solo thom song, radiohead band mates still play it with him. true friends...true music...truly fucking awesome
This proves how they do this for the love of art and not for the love of money, considering how much they have played together, some would get tired of their band mates. They are a true band, no faking anything. Pure friendship and trusting each other for as you said, his solo work.
Thom is like Elvis, Mozart, Freddie Mercury, And Kermit the frog all rolled into one but then again there's no-one else like him and you can tell he genuinely has affection for everyday people. I wanna be like that.
Try to save But it doesn’t come off the rug Try to build a wall that is high enough It’s all boiling over All boiling over Try to save your house Try to save your songs Try to run But it follows you up the hill It’s all boiling over All boiling over Your loved ones Your loved ones A normal conversation A normal conversation You should have took me out While you had the chance You should have took me out While you had the chance All the rooms renumbered And the losers turned away Don’t turn away Don’t turn away There were ten in the bed And the little one said ‘Roll over’
@Pelle Koopman this song was a radiohead song but they never made things together anc completed it but thom took this song and turned into something different but amazing!
+Ido Eisenberg Jonny Greenwood of Radiohead is 50% . It is one that transfers the Thom genius in music. Jonny Greenwood , the other guys in Radiohead !!
conrad1on I still do, too! I've never seen them live ever and like you said...chances are getting slimmer every year. Without youtube, I'd be completely screwed :P
I know this song for 15 years now, but only today I noticed that the ending part is pretty much same melodically as the ending of "There There", just higher
My fav' off THE ERASER (wonderful album, btw), and this version wins it in my heart : even better than the album one IMHO. THANXXXX A LOT, THOM (+ Jonny and Nigel) !
I envision Thom Yorke dying of a heart attack one day, on stage, having just completed one of the greatest live performances in music history. Gives everything, this man.
Ar die Yep. Ppl might not care about this, but it's a weird few decades, cause it's the new millenium(it would be the same if it was just a new century), and so we don't really have a name for the decades, (the 00's?), people try to avoid saying it...and they seem scared to say 10's...I havent heard anyone use it yet...but 20's, 30's, 90's, no problem....so it's like we're floating through time right now, you used to have a clear cut decade...like a box. Now it's more like, 1997 to 2015 is basically the same decade. 15 years go by like it's just 7....
I've been searching for that keyboard that Jonny is playing for ages, and I have finally discovered it's called the Ondes Martenot. It was invented in 1928 and was one of the earliest electronic instruments ever built. And it's awesome. I want one.
@@leehiro4840 I bet he does. A good one isn't cheap. It's used in a ton of stuff from Olivier Messiaen's music to the original star trek series music. Beautiful sounds...
Sadly I do not, though I still would like one… funny to be brought back to a comment I made over a decade ago to be reminded of something I was interested in back then that I still happen to be interested in!
Harried, haunting and most importantly hopeful. A serenade of the scars and soul a lot of we subjects seem to subsist of. Still listening after so many seasons.
Yup. And in fact, ALL of his work is brilliant. Plus the man has some very interesting ideas/positions about the world we live in. Definitely a man to treasure... and not only the artist : ALL of him !
This is the first time I've seen Nigel playing live with them! I know he usually does behind the scenes work but I was actually surprised when it was him and not someone else like Colin :)
Fun Guy agreed, also how is Creep still their most popular song. Even if we’re talking Pablo Honey, Blowout is much better. But yeah, Radiohead is the best.
sometimes i regret being born in 2005 and finding out about their music only now because i've missed.. everything.. but i still very thankful to this universe that i can listen to them and i know them. they have changed my life a lot
a famous pop phenomenon? Sgt Pepper...Revolver....Abbey Road...White Album...(Tomorrow never knows, A day in the life, Hapiness is a warm gun, Blue jay way, Its all too much, Fixing a hole...etc etc...) OK!!!
In an interview they asked Johhny what was better than Radiohead. The guitarist replied: anything the Beatles have recorded is better than Radiohead. I guess he knows more than us.
Try to save it but it doesn't come off the rock Try to build a wall that is high enough It's all boiling over a All boiling over Try to save your house Try to save your songs Try to run But it follows you up a hill It's all boiling over All boiling over Your little voice Your little voice No more conversation No more conversation You should took me out when you had the chance You should took me out when you had the chance All the rooms were numbered And the losers turned away Don't turn away Don't turn away
I love how Nigel just causally walks in and lays down some phat beats
Great timing Nigel, it was slick...
Exaaaaacly 😄
so funny
The beats are already playing. All Nigel did was turn the volume up so we could hear them.
Dare I say this is BETTER than the album version?
Will you can hear Thom and the piano better in this version.
It's a lot quieter. Definitely a different vibe to this version.
Agreed
This is more "rock-ish", album version is IDM stuff.
I completely agree, in comparison with “Like Spinning Plates” the live version is much better and more clear. I love the electronic touch but the album version is a bit too electronic.
something I love about Thom is how ordinary he seems to be, then all of the sudden the music starts and he blooms like a flower.
Brenda Luna like a lotus flower
So I was learning this song today and saw your comment. I think it goes even deeper than what you're saying. Even a simple sounding song like this isn't simple. The words don't match up with the piano hits, it's syncopated. Which means it takes twisting your brain a little bit to figure it out. Not only is it beautiful, but it's kind of hard to play and sing this at the same time, and I didn't even notice until I tried. He's a genius.
Exactly.. I play the Jonny parts in my radio cover band and it is amazing how `simple' the songs sound but how well they are composed. I always played classical music but playing Radiohead is so much fun.. for me it is classical music but in a modern jacket.
@@porouscrump when we write songs this comes automatically. it is way more difficult to learn some one elses song than it is to write your own. I find this aspect of music funny. I've done both - learned complex stuff like Bach and written my own stuff as well as played variations on a Bach theme ...
Like the ocean 😌
best singer of the 21st century
Kyuso KK and 20th !
Well it is a broad statement he is good but not the best Jeff Buckley can sing pretty good too so 🤷🏻♂️
@@cem5470 Jeff Buckly wasn't 21st century, he died in 97.
cem serdar Jeff Buckley influenced Thom and Matt Bellamy , I would give it Thom tho not for pitch perfect but for the pure character of his voice
I like him so much but the best...no at all.
"That was Good".... Thom mate, that was fucking gold. :)
I just love Jonny Greenwood's stance. Haha. He's always so focused on his music.
Man I love this song.. It hurts me as a musician to see such a brilliant song be composed of six chords.. I especially love how Thom threw in a small chunk of the There There chord progession. If you listen closely you can sing "Why so green and lonely" from There There over top of the second part of the song. I think it's brilliant
I was thinking exactly the same!
took me 15 years to see this comment and now I can't ever hear this song the same again. Thank you. Just when I thought it couldn't get any better, I was wrong. The beauty of Thom and Radiohead...listen to a song a million times and on the millionth and one time discover something new.
7
I love how Jonny's hair is always the most prominent feature of his face when he performs.
Micah Buzan you again, mate
i knew i'll find your comment here
Wait - there’s a guy under there?!
YOU LITTERALY HAVE ATLEAST A COMMENT UNDER EVERY RADIOHEAD VIDEO
Forever returning here.
This takes me to other dimensions.
4:59 *Thom Yorke:* _"That's good."_
... *Me:* _"Yes Thom, that certainly was!"_
ya wanna drink whisky through the whole night with girl who is fully understanding this fuckin great song
+John K LOL
this is the best shit i ever read
I feel this
Absofuckinlutely
❤
thom is such a fool. He does the greatest live performance of one of the best songs ever written and all he says at the end of it is a mundane "that was good". Such a gross understatement.
It’s not one of the best signs every written. Take it easy
Good, is ecstatic in world of Yorke. If all was declared great, creativity would be swamped in self congratulation.
You didn't listen to much music if you consider this "one of the best songs ever written".. Holy shit those Radiohead fanboys are something else. 😂
@@etherealbonds Objectively, it probably isn't (if there even is an objective way to measure it). But it's still one of *my* favourite songs of all time. So y'know, you can fuck off.
This the first time you've ever heard Thom? He says this after every performance.
Can we talk about how insane this rhythm is for a second? I mean seriously... I'm trying to learn this song for 3 days straight on my piano and I'm nowhere near to figure out that rhythm with those sick chord changes! And this guy is singing to it like it's nobody's business... Seriously guys. Slow this down to 0.5 and try to listen to it.
Even they fucked it up at the beginning.. I have to play it at 60bpm and still fucking it up every chord change.... unbelievable! Unfreaking believable!! Greatest fu*king musician that ever walked this earth. Period!
One of Thom's best songs without a doubt
This version is so good I want to die .
bit drastic
Hahaha
It's kind of true. Reading your comment while listening made me kind of cry... (eek face)
Lol same here
Larks' Tongues In Aspic me too, dude. Me too.
apart from being an amazing song...what i love is the fact even though its a solo thom song, radiohead band mates still play it with him. true friends...true music...truly fucking awesome
This proves how they do this for the love of art and not for the love of money, considering how much they have played together, some would get tired of their band mates. They are a true band, no faking anything. Pure friendship and trusting each other for as you said, his solo work.
@@RockyStradlin Especially with Thom and Jonny in a new band now! Beautiful stuff
Thom is like Elvis, Mozart, Freddie Mercury, And Kermit the frog all rolled into one but then again there's no-one else like him and you can tell he genuinely has affection for everyday people. I wanna be like that.
Kermit the frog lmaoo bro what
@@yurgh10690falsetto voice maybe?
Eraser is my favourite album ever by anyone.
Try to save
But it doesn’t come off the rug
Try to build a wall that is high enough
It’s all boiling over
All boiling over
Try to save your house
Try to save your songs
Try to run
But it follows you up the hill
It’s all boiling over
All boiling over
Your loved ones
Your loved ones
A normal conversation
A normal conversation
You should have took me out
While you had the chance
You should have took me out
While you had the chance
All the rooms renumbered
And the losers turned away
Don’t turn away
Don’t turn away
There were ten in the bed
And the little one said
‘Roll over’
not-a-gain.
try to save
but it.....
Who's still coming back to this gem in 2019? ... the week of Thoms new solo album release ... its gonna be a glorious day.
Back in 2020 just to taste the masterpiece, again, again and again
Man... Such a talented band.. I'm in love with everything they create :)
@Pelle Koopman this song was a radiohead song but they never made things together anc completed it but thom took this song and turned into something different but amazing!
Thom Yorke is the MESSI of music!!
You useless shit
Hahahaha
+gizem aktan that escalated quickly...
+Ido Eisenberg He totally is!!! :) :) :) I instantly like you x
+Ido Eisenberg Jonny Greenwood of Radiohead is 50% . It is one that transfers the Thom genius in music. Jonny Greenwood , the other guys in Radiohead !!
Shit, even this is 10 years old now. Stupid march of time.
+conrad1on Ik, damnit!...I hate time and especially that I can't go back in it...to see these guys back in the day!
I still want to see them now, but the chances of that are slim.
conrad1on I still do, too! I've never seen them live ever and like you said...chances are getting slimmer every year. Without youtube, I'd be completely screwed :P
Me too, in so many ways.
music like this cannot be "old" !
Like in a lot of Yorke's music, there's a tender beauty and an uneasy tension at the same time. It's great.
How does he constantly make everything sound so fleeting and hauntingly beautiful?
Can't go wrong with Thom's voice with Jonny on ondes martenot
I keep coming back
This inspires me to make music
"......Try to run, but it follows you up a hiiiiilllllll...." That part and his vocals always gives me chills.
I know this song for 15 years now, but only today I noticed that the ending part is pretty much same melodically as the ending of "There There", just higher
My fav' off THE ERASER (wonderful album, btw), and this version wins it in my heart : even better than the album one IMHO.
THANXXXX A LOT, THOM (+ Jonny and Nigel) !
I adore this song and this version is incredibly beautiful.
I'm listening to it on repeat tonight❤
The things that these human beings can do... unbelievably amazing!!
Human you said ? 😅
That "it's all boiling over" line comes into my head when stuff is piling up...it's beautiful
Johnny is incredible
It's amazing how mistakes become a unique part of the song. I waited for Thom to stop and snap his fingers.
I envision Thom Yorke dying of a heart attack one day, on stage, having just completed one of the greatest live performances in music history. Gives everything, this man.
@icono, WTH? What other kinda morbid ‘visions’ do you have? That’s ok, never mind.
@@SaneTXJane well we will all die.... A sudden heart attack in the middle of his favorite Moment would be everything but a bad thing....
can't believe this was 8 years ago
crazy
can't believe this was 8 months ago
Simoyorke 20 indeed!
Ar die Yep. Ppl might not care about this, but it's a weird few decades, cause it's the new millenium(it would be the same if it was just a new century), and so we don't really have a name for the decades, (the 00's?), people try to avoid saying it...and they seem scared to say 10's...I havent heard anyone use it yet...but 20's, 30's, 90's, no problem....so it's like we're floating through time right now, you used to have a clear cut decade...like a box.
Now it's more like, 1997 to 2015 is basically the same decade. 15 years go by like it's just 7....
Gerry Delafino THATS FUCKED BUD
I've been searching for that keyboard that Jonny is playing for ages, and I have finally discovered it's called the Ondes Martenot. It was invented in 1928 and was one of the earliest electronic instruments ever built. And it's awesome. I want one.
Do you own one now, after 12 years?
@@leehiro4840 I bet he does. A good one isn't cheap. It's used in a ton of stuff from Olivier Messiaen's music to the original star trek series music. Beautiful sounds...
Sadly I do not, though I still would like one… funny to be brought back to a comment I made over a decade ago to be reminded of something I was interested in back then that I still happen to be interested in!
Harried, haunting and most importantly hopeful.
A serenade of the scars and soul a lot of we subjects seem to subsist of.
Still listening after so many seasons.
Just another masterpiece. The usual incredible chords and melodies from Thom and crazy good lead accompanying from Jonny
I'll always be upset. I function......but I will always be upset and this song defines it.
This might be the best song I have ever heard.
Johhny , you 're a fucking genius , man...
Been a fan for so many years and still blown away.. lucky to be around when this is.
I can't stop listening to The Eraser, I haven't put it down since it came out.
L A it’s an amazing and innovative album!
Have you put it down yet?
@@milobaird1043 Still coming back to it...
Don't turn away.
thom yorke's solo work is amazing!
Yup. And in fact, ALL of his work is brilliant. Plus the man has some very interesting ideas/positions about the world we live in.
Definitely a man to treasure... and not only the artist : ALL of him !
This is my favorite song of all time. It strips your soul gray
This is the first time I've seen Nigel playing live with them! I know he usually does behind the scenes work but I was actually surprised when it was him and not someone else like Colin :)
The timing was good the first time but i guess good isn't enough for Mr. Yorke. What a legend!
What a way to interpret a song! Extraordinary!!!
Want to know how good Radiohead are? ... Even when it went "wrong" at the start, it still sounded about 1,000 times better than any other band!
Fun Guy agreed, also how is Creep still their most popular song. Even if we’re talking Pablo Honey, Blowout is much better. But yeah, Radiohead is the best.
Big facts
@@jonahlouque9621 I always say that Creep is Radiohead’s worst song by far yet even that song is miles beyond most other bands
@@Matthewsavant it's definitely not their worst. It's at least top 5 on its album
That was good... Bloody hell that was amazing!
I think we should all thank God that we live in an era that includes Radiohead!
I miss Thomas doing stuff like this!
This song is absolutely brilliant, gives me goosebumps every time i hear it!!!
Thom on a piano is all I need in life ❤
glad i’m not the only one who hears the resemblance with There There. So beautiful 😭
Looks at date.
16th July 2006.
Looks on iPhone.
18th July 2015 *shudders*
+Ross MacDoodle and now...24th March 2016 :P
4th of June, 2018.
And I‘ve been coming back to this video over and over.
2018
31st January 2019 *exhales*
@@jqreal0172 31th? I think you mean 31st. Haha. This coming from Sunday, May 5th, 2019.
May be 10 years old but wow this is still fantastic and even better live
Still sounds pretty good in May 2024.
lit in 2020
I love this live version
I love this song. i don't know how, but over the days, this song is saving my life. i am so grateful for this
This is the only version I listen to.
Wow... It's been 13 years... Time flies
Thom is able to take his pain and put it into something we can all learn from.
Unsettlingly beautiful song and performance
I love the tempo of this song
Still soundz good in July 2021
whatever the fuck is going on at 2:20 is heavenly.
does he say:
start. a. gain.
when he snaps his fingers
Yes
Not again
Yep
I think I have watched this song a hundred times and I still love it
How is it even possible to write a song like this... It's completely beyond me!
this is so good. this is so fucking good.
потрясающая музыка, заворажывает с первых нот....
This is definitely my favorite very of this song. Such an excellent live performance per usual 👌🏽
sometimes i regret being born in 2005 and finding out about their music only now because i've missed.. everything..
but i still very thankful to this universe that i can listen to them and i know them. they have changed my life a lot
Omg this is so good
Radiohead....Beatles of the future
a famous pop phenomenon? Sgt Pepper...Revolver....Abbey Road...White Album...(Tomorrow never knows, A day in the life, Hapiness is a warm gun, Blue jay way, Its all too much, Fixing a hole...etc etc...) OK!!!
In an interview they asked Johhny what was better than Radiohead. The guitarist replied: anything the Beatles have recorded is better than Radiohead. I guess he knows more than us.
The bit where Nigel just wanders on and joins in is fantastically cool..this is music gold on so many levels, I can't watch it enough times!
4:07 he is living the moment
天才
The deep of the soul...
I love how Thome just started the song over when it didn't start the way he wanted it to. Brilliant!
that little catch in his voice at 3:11..... oh man. Beautiful
Try to save it but it doesn't come off the rock
Try to build a wall that is high enough
It's all boiling over a
All boiling over
Try to save your house
Try to save your songs
Try to run
But it follows you up a hill
It's all boiling over
All boiling over
Your little voice
Your little voice
No more conversation
No more conversation
You should took me out when you had the chance
You should took me out when you had the chance
All the rooms were numbered
And the losers turned away
Don't turn away
Don't turn away
the ending sounds really similar to the end of There There
Yeah, i thought the same!
same chords progression, in different tune thou
Identical chord progression
fr fr
Awesome band
Fantastic ❤️
what sort of magic is this?
its from another time haha
@@subterraneanhomesickalien it's beyond time
It's like Alohomora, opening your heart instead
2:55 is where the fire starts
Awesome... These guys are so good!! Love the Ondes Martenot John is playing... I can't get enough of this!
Thank you Thom. Another piece of art, pure and simple. May you change music for ever.
I woke up in the middle of sleep simultaneously with my girlfriend to this one night. we fuckin broke up. life is so stupid sometimes.
they take simplicity and turn it into incredible. true musicians
You are a genius what a masterpiece of music and how good you are as a band, thank you for all the magic you create together