Video

Vote Green. Not perfect, but better than the others. 🇺🇦🐾🦘🐨🦘🐾🇵🇸

Really enjoyed this episode ! What you guys are doing is so so important. Keep going!

Amazing 😍 You are the future, your task requires a massive effort, but please don't stop changing the narrative. Young Jews are the Key to the problem, love you guys! It's time to start dreaming a different paradigm. It's clear that we don't want this reality, but we have to decide what a new one'd look like. I agree with the concept that every government in the west has gone astray and are not serving the people any longer.

In order to keep the pattern of hate going I don’t believe that they will completely annihilate the Palestinian’s because how will they be able to fuel their hatred that the brainwashing is reliant on.

Wow. Indie the Universe is calling you to make a movie with Elk Harpaz and Hebrew Canaanite. It’s time for the world to start healing from this horrible pain. I am born Catholic but it does not define me and when people combine identiy with religion you get cult. Please please please guys make it a movie. Sooo grateful to have found you guys ❤

Are you guys not mentioning the religions on purpose or just because you dont think that it has an impact on the situation?

Amazing chat, please do it again ❤❤❤ free Palestine 🇵🇸🇵🇸

Thank you for your work guys!

1:00:00 Talking about "opening the cage" , a good comparison could be South Africa when they decided to abolish the apartheid system and give black Southafricans equal rights, same thing goes for the abolition of slavery and the gaining of equal civil rights for Afroamericans. They all live together in one country even though one of the two groups in each of these 2 countries brutally opressed and abused the other group for such a long time.

I'm so glad you got out Elek I was getting very worried about you guys as i hadn't seen anything for a while and heard they were throwing people in jail for posts. Around the world they are cracking down on free speech around isrsel massively! I think it's better to leave and not support in any way if you feel better to leave Elek. Alon you have a different process but you would be welcome anywhere you went, including here in south africa but your connection to the land is real and authentic and maybe your work is there to help palestinians from within. Indie please don't go until palestine is free! I felt ill when I visited and I didn't even know anything at that point but i could tell there was insanity there and the intimidation and body searches at the airport were disgusting and dehumanisung and I'm not palestinian and wasn't even political at thst time. When palestine is free, those who don't belong will leave and those who do will stay as in south africa. It's the deoth of lies and propodanda and power if the israel lobby and integration with the military industrial western imoerial project that make palestne unique. It's the key to exposing the power structures of tge west. Beatiful conversation. You are the solidarity of life, such a joy to listen to. Thankyou.

Inshallah soon

Completely disagree with Denile about Arabs as a people hate or have issues with Palestinians. It’s quite the opposite. I do believe that in certain classes ( usually upper class, western educated, western facing Arabs in certain countries LIKE the UAE where denile spent some time, do have an issue with Palestinians mainly due to propaganda from their autocratic leaders who are anxious to normalise with Israel and have spread the idea that they have spent millions on Palestinian leaders and groups and got nothing worthwhile in return. But as a regular Arab I know Palestinians are loved in a painful and sad way. So no totally disagree. Not all Arabs are khaleeji

love it.. still catching up with episodes :)

Yeah delete my comments instead of cope with reality.... By the way what genocide? The October seventh one? Because there are no other genocide stop the bullshit

So Israelis are now Palestinians

And don’t worry about the length of the episode, I enjoyed every minute. Thanks again, very touching and inspiring stuff, can’t agree more to what was shared amongst the three of you. So much love ❤❤

Love you, your conversations are like medicine against the desperation I feel almost constantly since October 7th. Thank you from the bottom of my heart for being, I would be so happy to meet you one day and play music together, have good conversations and dream a beautiful world ❤❤❤

Okay, I have so many thoughts… way too many thoughts… I hope you don’t mind a lot of reading… I don’t have any personal connection to Palestine, I’ve just become obsessed with it since the 7th, I can’t take my eyes off of what’s going on, and I have been learning as much as I can. I really really enjoyed this discussion! I think what all of you are doing and sharing is very valuable. Please don’t stop! ♥️ (1) Regarding LGBTQ+ in Palestine: this is very much a deliberate trope that is overblown by the West. It’s also kind of disingenuous. While it is true in many places in West Asia and North Africa are culturally less accepting, it’s not actually that different from a lot of places around the world. Even here in the US, there is violence and discrimination and bullying against LGBTQ+ people, and getting disowned by your family and/or friends is a pretty common experience. How accepting people are here depends on where in the country you are. Of course things are gradually getting better over time, but there’s still a long way to go. Also, yes, Israel will try to use blackmail against gay and queer Palestinians to use them as informants. Let me tell you, one thing I know is that it is far worse to be seen as a collaborator with the occupiers than to be found out to be non-hetero. For Palestinians, there is nothing worse than being a collaborator with the occupier. That is why the PA will never be able to take control, because Palestinians will never accept them as legitimate because they collaborate with the occupiers. But anyway, surely you’ve heard of the Palestinian music artist/singer Bashar Murad? Palestinians are as varied as any other society, which means you’ll find people who are homophobic, people who are completely accepting, and everything in between. I mean, there are Palestinians who are leftists, Palestinians who are atheists, etc. And in fact, despite that Hamas is an Islamist organization, they have welcomed collaboration with the DFLP, which is a far-left Marxist-socialist secular organization. (2) I think the difference in connection to the land between Israelis and Palestinians is a keen observation. And we can see this difference playing out in the massive destruction to the land that the IOF is doing, total destruction without a second thought. Historically too, when they took over they changed the landscape in ways that were unhealthy for the native environment. Also, in the West Bank, the settlers destroy olive trees, and that’s a big deal because olive trees are both important and amazing. Also, by the way, all the bombs and destruction and all the flying of jets and helicopters will almost certainly have an effect on climate change. (3) Why can’t the IOF find Hamas? Because they’re too scared to go into the tunnels. 😂 Look, all civilians are above ground, and nearly all resistance fighters are underground. And the IOF knows that. So if they really wanted to go after only the resistance fighters and avoid “collateral damage”, they’d go into the tunnels. But they rarely have gone into the tunnels, and only the most shallow tunnels. Even the most powerful bombs won’t have any effect on the tunnels except the few that are less than 10m down. And they know that. The tunnel network is probably still at least 80% intact, if not more. The resistance fighters only come out of the tunnels to carry out operations against the IOF, and go back down when they’re done. (4) It’s not only Palestinians from the diaspora who can’t go to Palestine. If a Palestinian living in Palestine, born and raised there, leaves to, for example, go to school, or on holiday, or to a conference, or even for specialized medical treatment, they oftentimes cannot go back, because they are not allowed reentry. (5) Regarding Palestinian leadership: they have had good leaders, great leaders, but they always get either assassinated or permanently imprisoned. This is intentional, and a common tactic used by imperialist / colonialist powers, to take out any good leadership, so they are constantly held back from unifying and efficiently rising up. This is precisely part of the broader methodology of “divide and conquer”. They also have done the same thing the US has done in so many countries around the world: secretly support extremists and authoritarians, so they are almost guaranteed to have an excuse to use military force against them. Of course I don’t need to tell you why Israel would want an excuse for violence against the Palestinians. Fun fact: truly democratic governments would be far more common if it wasn’t for the US interfering to prevent or dismantle them. (6) When the topic of safety and security is brought up, it’s only ever for the Israelis. The issue of safety and security for Palestinians is never brought up. The same is true of feelings in general: Israelis’ feelings are to be taken into consideration and accommodated for, while Palestinians’ feelings should be ignored… blah blah blah, you get where I’m going with that. (7) I believe there is evidence that certain Israeli authorities did know that some kind of attack was going to happen. There were definitely a bunch of warnings, but they were just flat out ignored. On the one hand, I think part of this has to do with the deeply ingrained racism and supremacy: they looked down upon the Palestinians so much that they could not fathom they would be capable of something like Oct 7. On the other hand, I think there are reasons to think it’s very plausible the Israeli government was willing to sacrifice the lives of their own people so as to have an excuse for extreme military violence against the Palestinians. Why else would they plant settlements / kibbutzim along the wall around Gaza? I definitely don’t think anyone in Israel had any hand in planning the attack. If they had, I don’t think they would ever have allowed themselves to be so humiliated by the Palestinians. I mean, even the resistance fighters that day were shocked at how successful their operation was and how far they got and how long the IOF took to show up. Also, surely you know about the Hannibal Directive (or Doctrine), right? And that it was implemented on Oct 7? And that it is quite plausible and probable that the IOF killed several Israelis? You’ve heard of this, right? And now of course, the situation with the hostages, the fact that it’s clear that those in power don’t give a damn about the hostages and have no desire to rescue them. (8) Have you seen the debate between “Destiny” and Javad Hashmi on the YT channel Modern-Day Debate? (I’d post a link, but YT always deletes my comments with links.) I recently watched it… it almost drove me insane, because it’s “Destiny” 😫… but I couldn’t help wondering what you would think of that discussion. Yikes, sorry for writing so much! I guess I just get too engaged sometimes, and I have way too much going on inside my head! LOL 🇵🇸♥️🇵🇸

Remember that the DNC is a private corporation funded, at least in part, by corporations with ties to the military/industrial/financial complex. Regional proxy wars are more connected to Wall Street and the perpetuation of the dollar as global currency than to purveying 'freedom and democracy.'

Thank you to all 3 of you for your soulful, honest 'peace talks'. This genocide in Gaza has forced us to pay very close attention to how connected humans are around the world. In my lifetime I won't see a less violent world (I'm a 62 year old woman in the US) but my Gen Z sons have their eyes wide open. Fight the power. #FREEPALESTINE

The whole problem is that America is a Z1onist State. They want this Gen0cide. It is pure horror.

This was an excellent show. I came here because of Indie and now I've subscribed. Thanks 🙏😊

I read that one gay man was allegedly thrown off of a roof by Hamas, but he was also a mid-level Hamas officer, so... his latest performance review might have played a part, I'm thinking.

One state, all power to people under 18 years old. done.

@hebrewcanaanite, welcome to NYC! I'm in Queens. A Buddhist for Palestine! Israel is destroying the earth, adding significantly to climate change, in addition to being genocidal maniacs. Zionism is absolutely a cult. The birthright trip keeps people exhausted and drugged while repeating their indoctrination environment. Thank you so much for realizing and being an anarchist to imperialism and colonialism. ❤

كل الشكر على هذه المقاطع القيّمة التي عرفنا من خلالها بشخصيتكما الجميلة الصادقة و كذلك المتوازية نفسياً مقارنة بالانفصام النفسي الهيستيري الذي يضرب اليوم،سكان فلسطين المحتلة!! لكن عندي ملاحظة على ما قاله ضيفكم الكريم،،لما قال أن العرب لا يريدون الزواج من الفلسطينيين🫨،،و هو بذلك يُعَمم مشكلته العائلية على كل العرب ، و هذا ما يكذبه الواقع في زواج الآلاف من الفلسطينيين في كل البلدان من المغرب العربي الى مصر،،(غزة وحدها فيها آلاف من الزيجات مختلطة) إلى الشام،،،،،الخ 🌺🌸🌷

When do people move society forward. NOT during an violent occupation. War and violence always results in loss of human rights. Palestine is no different and to use LGBTQ rights to promote Israel and excuse genocide is lazy. Much love to all 3 of you.

Alon & Elik, You should read They Knew How a Culture of Conspiracy Keeps America Complicit by Sarah Kendzior. Alon made me think of the book about how our world is a mafia led world order. It also addresses conspiracy vs conspiracy theory. It is not a wacky qanon like book. When you mention how Palestine could free all of us, I agree. And if we allow this live streamed genocide, more will happen in the future.

62 yrs old waking in Maryland and crying listening to you three. Change will happen through this type of activism. I’ve been very depressed after a week long political spectacle w/ a crystal clear message that Harris will not condition weapons to Israel & the US will continue their partnership & complicity in genocide. Thank you. #FreePalestine

❤ love Indie Nile and you guys

אחים שלי אתם. לא ידעתי שאתם מחיפה. פעילים במסגרת פוליטית כלשהי? איך מזמינים אתכם לקפה

As a Muslim Arab Iraqi citizen, knowing there are anti-zio-nist in the occupied Falestine has filled my heart with hope💗 I truely hope that Falestine will be liberated and our Jewish Iraqi people return to their homeland🫶 Praying for peace in Middle East 💗

Love both of them ❤️

Omggg all my favorite people togetherrrrr

Love all 3 of you!

Free Palistine ❤️

It's really amazing to see and watch jews and Palestinian discussions ❤

I come from Indie's channel. This was a very interesting conversation. Thanks for sharing. Free Palestine 🇵🇸 🕊 ❤

Wow, this is beautiful. Almost a chocolate peanut butter situation. Three of my favorite people on this platform coming together having a great conversation. I'm so happy to see Elik again and that he is doing good, as far as i can judge. Listening to you guys is always a highlight for me, evrn though my englisch is not the best. You are having the conversations/talking about things i cant really talk about with the people around me here in Germany. I can only imagine the pressure you guys are under in your country and i appreciate your courage so much!

This is such an important conversation- so thankful for Indie’s work that led me to this meeting of hearts and minds.🙏💜 On the topic of diaspora Palestinians visiting our ancestral homeland, there is legislation in IL that criminalizes the Boycott Divest Sanction movement and prohibits foreigners who are supporters of BDS from entering the country. For those of us who fall into this category, it is actually illegal for us to visit. Also, I think the topic of connection/separation to the land/Earth that @HebrewCanaanite touched on is worthy of further exploration sometime. (I could relate so much to that, having grown up in the US in a place named after the Native Americans who once lived there, as well as to Indie's finding a sense of "home" in airports...) The state's decades-long ecological apartheid-- water theft, aggressive monoculture, destruction of native flora, herbicidal warfare, and so much more as land continues to be reduced to toxic rubble-- must also play a role in this feeling of disconnection?

..heart melting conversation guys.. it's so great to see you young guys TALKING.. makes me feel "there is hope" you know.. (the voice of Elik is.. "girl!".. deep..)

Please don’t believe that Americans don’t give a shit, Elik. We do! The polls show >80% of Americans want a ceasefire, NOW. Our politicians, Republicans, Democrats, and Independents have all been bought and paid for by AIPAC & CUFI & the arms manufacturers. Our media has, too. So have the University Administrators. But ordinary people know this is complete insanity, no matter what the media, the politicians, or University administrators say. I’m glad you escaped to Seattle & New York for now. While you’re in NY, go visit Norman Finkelstein! You know brother Norman gives a shit!

I am from Seattle :) it's so interesting to think I could have been to events with you or your friend - what a small world!

You guys give me HOPE ❤ we people have to wake up and unite. Your voices easy to listen to. Just came across your channel now. Will be sharing your channel. So great

Jewish people did fight back during the Holocaust. However, part of the "revised" Jewish history that believes Jews can only survive if they have a a Jewish State, removed Jewish resistance of antisemism and the Holocaust from history. We are taught that we were passive and died (sheep to the slaughter)- and that in Israel we finally fought back and became violent and took what we wanted. This is part of a very black and white thinking of Zionism. There were Jewish Partisans. Also the Warsaw Ghetto Uprising was almost successful. They had to fully burn it down to stop the intense Jewish resistance.

Who are these idiots who don't understand that black nail polish is a goth thing, and not necessarily a queer thing?

Actually the Palestinian genocide started in 1941 when the Zionists started stealing and smuggling American weapons and anthrax AKA weapons of mass destruction and sending everything to what is known as Israel today where they slaughtered and misplaced thousands of people before the 1948 ethnic cleansing even became a thing. The reason they assassinated JFK was cause he found out all this crap and was about to cut them off completely

YAAASSSS IM SO GLAD YOU GUYS DID AN EPISODE TOGETHER!!! PLEASE DO MORE COLLABORATIONS!!!

Oh precious honest loving beings, much appreciation for all of you being!

I love the amount of critical thinking on display in this video. The best to you three.