NativLang
NativLang
  • 203
  • 103 359 579
Are animal signals ever like words? – Can Animals Grammar? #5
Are animal calls meaningful? Are they words? Animated signal profiles of prairie dogs, monkeys, insects and more.
Subscribe for parts 6-8: czcams.com/users/NativLang
Sources for claims: docs.google.com/document/d/1tK2GjVO19cmd4fBnRwhHrZK7RKYo08nnD_XS10a1wRA/
Patronize me per creation: www.patreon.com/NativLang
Tip me once: www.ko-fi.com/NativLang
~ Shortly and sweetly ~
In previous parts we met animal signals from elephant calls to jacky dragon actions. Are these anything like human words? Let's get into the semantics of some suspiciously meaningful animal communication systems.
Please watch parts 1 through 4 for background and buildup. This one falls in the middle of building up from syllables (last time) to sequences (next time).
~ Resources ~
Art, animation and music by me. My sources document backs up claims and gives credit for images, fonts and sounds:
docs.google.com/document/d/1tK2GjVO19cmd4fBnRwhHrZK7RKYo08nnD_XS10a1wRA/#heading=h.t1f629ieweiz
In that same document I link to groups focused on animals, their habitats and the people who care for them. There's a narrative tie-in that I hope works at the end of the series; meanwhile I'll just mention and link:
docs.google.com/document/d/1tK2GjVO19cmd4fBnRwhHrZK7RKYo08nnD_XS10a1wRA/edit#heading=h.gpolixoat5xi
zhlédnutí: 19 319

Video

Animals make "wild" syllables - Can Animals Grammar? #4
zhlédnutí 25KPřed měsícem
Animated profiles of small sound and gesture units heard and seen in animal repertoires, from elephants to canids to jacky dragons. Subscribe for parts 5-8: czcams.com/users/NativLang Sources for claims: docs.google.com/document/d/1tK2GjVO19cmd4fBnRwhHrZK7RKYo08nnD_XS10a1wRA/ Tip me once: www.ko-fi.com/NativLang Patronize me per creation: www.patreon.com/NativLang ~ Shortly and sweetly ~ Last t...
Why talking animals disappointed most everyone - Can Animals Grammar? #3
zhlédnutí 33KPřed 3 měsíci
Did any trained animal ever really learn to speak? In my last animation, experts trained animal communication's biggest celebrities. Here the animal stars undergo scrutiny and one conference tanks hopes for future nonhuman linguistic marvels. Subscribe for parts 4-8: czcams.com/users/NativLang Tip me once: www.ko-fi.com/NativLang Patronize me per creation: www.patreon.com/NativLang ~ Shortly an...
Teaching animals to be grammatical - Can Animals Grammar? #2
zhlédnutí 34KPřed 5 měsíci
Humans tried to teach nonhumans to talk, training animal communication's biggest stars. Which animals did we teach to use words and sentences, and how good was their grammar? Subscribe for parts 3-8: czcams.com/users/NativLang Tip me once: www.ko-fi.com/NativLang Become my patron: www.patreon.com/NativLang ~ Summary ~ Last time I introduced my animated series about grammatical animals. We'll sp...
Can animals grammar? - introduction to my animated series
zhlédnutí 46KPřed 6 měsíci
Are animal signals word-like or even sentence-like? Are their sounds and signs somehow meaningful and structured? Let's spend some videos together exploring the possible linguistics of animal communication. In part 1 I'll introduce this series and the many grammatical animals we'll meet along the way. Groups to support: docs.google.com/document/d/1tK2GjVO19cmd4fBnRwhHrZK7RKYo08nnD_XS10a1wRA/edi...
SOV: Why is this the most popular word order across languages?
zhlédnutí 114KPřed 10 měsíci
When languages around the world build a basic sentence, 43% arrange the words this way: subject - object - verb. Who does this? (Hint: not English!) How is it unique? Why is it so popular? Subscribe for more: czcams.com/users/NativLang Become my patron: www.patreon.com/NativLang Check my sources: docs.google.com/document/d/1r3Am9jL5hVZr0YiQfm7okTtNO42MjG709dS2XUPs7MY/ ~ Briefly, with *spoilers*...
OSV: Why is this word order so rare in languages?
zhlédnutí 626KPřed rokem
There are six basic word orders. Which languages have different ones and where? Why is this one so rare? Sources: docs.google.com/document/d/1W9zHIS1T34aq2giAwWev1HKZkJ2_8gIyvfub96mOvSk/ Support: docs.google.com/document/d/1W9zHIS1T34aq2giAwWev1HKZkJ2_8gIyvfub96mOvSk/#heading=h.gpolixoat5xi Art, animation and music by me. Open doc above to read sources for claims and for pics, sfx. Subscribe fo...
What are (linguistic) nothings? ~ Reading comments and studying Saussure together
zhlédnutí 53KPřed rokem
My last animation about why linguists believe in invisible words was captivating, also confusing. Let me consider your feedback and try once more. Join me and we'll study zeros again. ~ Links mentioned this time ~ Sources for this video: docs.google.com/document/d/1_duCLZZVbNwpENJXCQJ6nWd2BWK_8-MZxDDzwdRhS3w/ Support impacted people: docs.google.com/document/d/1ywiOfzN5FZt2sh7s3V8EfCB54vUoHg4iA...
Why linguists believe in invisible words - the story of zeros
zhlédnutí 259KPřed rokem
Do languages have unspoken meaningful nothings? Grammatical ghosts? Syntactically significant silences? Linguists sure seem to think so. They've been writing zeros in their grammars for years. What are these nulls? Where do they come from? Are they really there? Subscribe for more: czcams.com/users/NativLang Become my patron: www.patreon.com/NativLang Read my sources: docs.google.com/document/d...
What makes Papuan languages so unique? - features from the area with the most languages
zhlédnutí 160KPřed rokem
Melanesia is the place with the most languages on earth, most of which are Papuan. These are the features that set them apart from surrounding language families. Solidarity: docs.google.com/document/d/1ywiOfzN5FZt2sh7s3V8EfCB54vUoHg4iA1VevAxgZeU/#heading=h.8iwaseaw0ce6 Voices: docs.google.com/document/d/1sI3YRMA6jM7GrqiWkGLXS-2FeMYGHhta1smhXQY6BG0/ Sources: docs.google.com/document/d/1ETctVEewo...
New Guinea - lessons from a cradle of agriculture and languages
zhlédnutí 117KPřed 2 lety
This island is home to bananas, sugarcane and more languages than anywhere else. Watch how words, crops and people connect in a place now known to be an original cradle of agriculture. Aid: docs.google.com/document/d/1ywiOfzN5FZt2sh7s3V8EfCB54vUoHg4iA1VevAxgZeU/#heading=h.8iwaseaw0ce6 Voices: docs.google.com/document/d/1sI3YRMA6jM7GrqiWkGLXS-2FeMYGHhta1smhXQY6BG0/ Sources: docs.google.com/docum...
Why French sounds so unlike other Romance languages
zhlédnutí 2,7MPřed 2 lety
Sound changes left French unlike Latin, Italian, Spanish or Romanian. How? Here's the recipe. Subscribe for more: czcams.com/users/NativLang Become my patron: www.patreon.com/NativLang ~ Briefly ~ Follow my animated recipe for a taste of how sound shifts changed French pronunciation throughout the ages: Latin, Gaulish and Frankish influence, an early Romance era of Oïl vs Oc, Old French, Middle...
Why West Africa keeps inventing writing systems
zhlédnutí 856KPřed 3 lety
These dozens of modern African scripts are adding a brand new chapter to the history of writing! Subscribe for more: czcams.com/users/NativLang Become my patron: www.patreon.com/NativLang ~ Briefly ~ Meet Adlam, N'ko, Vai and over twenty more scripts that capture West African linguistic features and give new visual representation to native West African tongues. Topics covered: - backstories of ...
The Languages of Africa
zhlédnutí 645KPřed 3 lety
My animation about the many languages, language families and language areas of Africa. Links to African & diaspora language/linguistic history creators: docs.google.com/document/d/1gbsoD71MNajMJFncLzZjz4E7AZnhoUhgPwGq9H5jSK8/ Subscribe for more: czcams.com/users/NativLang Become my patron: www.patreon.com/NativLang ~ Briefly ~ At first, the map of Africa's many languages seems complicated. Howe...
Writing doesn't always end in alphabets - the enigmatic Egyptian counterexample
zhlédnutí 356KPřed 3 lety
As hieroglyphic writing reached the end of its life, Egyptians didn't simplify it like the alphabets emerging all around. They made it even more complex. Meet what Egyptologists call "enigmatic" or "cryptographic" hieroglyphs. Subscribe for more: czcams.com/users/NativLang Become my patron: www.patreon.com/NativLang ~ Briefly ~ I'm following up on my tale of Egyptian phonology with this intrigu...
What Ancient Egyptian Sounded Like - and how we know
zhlédnutí 15MPřed 3 lety
What Ancient Egyptian Sounded Like - and how we know
Clocks around the world: how other languages tell time
zhlédnutí 898KPřed 3 lety
Clocks around the world: how other languages tell time
But are Mesoamerican glyphs still used today?
zhlédnutí 159KPřed 3 lety
But are Mesoamerican glyphs still used today?
Is this the earliest writing in Mesoamerica?
zhlédnutí 236KPřed 3 lety
Is this the earliest writing in Mesoamerica?
First Contact Survival Kit - learn an undocumented language from scratch
zhlédnutí 242KPřed 3 lety
First Contact Survival Kit - learn an undocumented language from scratch
The Languages of Siberia
zhlédnutí 425KPřed 3 lety
The Languages of Siberia
The Languages of Siberia - OLD (bad audio)
zhlédnutí 52KPřed 3 lety
The Languages of Siberia - OLD (bad audio)
The Ainu language - short history, plus a note about last speakers and pandemics
zhlédnutí 297KPřed 4 lety
The Ainu language - short history, plus a note about last speakers and pandemics
Mongolic: meet a language family, including Para-Mongolic
zhlédnutí 255KPřed 4 lety
Mongolic: meet a language family, including Para-Mongolic
Khitan: deciphering China's forgotten Para-Mongolic language
zhlédnutí 361KPřed 4 lety
Khitan: deciphering China's forgotten Para-Mongolic language
Language nods - meaningful messages from native speakers
zhlédnutí 192KPřed 4 lety
Language nods - meaningful messages from native speakers
African Romance: searching for traces of a lost Latin language
zhlédnutí 801KPřed 4 lety
African Romance: searching for traces of a lost Latin language
What English does - but most languages can't
zhlédnutí 2,9MPřed 4 lety
What English does - but most languages can't
Features English is missing - but most other languages have
zhlédnutí 2,3MPřed 4 lety
Features English is missing - but most other languages have
Altaic: Rise and Fall of a Linguistic Hypothesis
zhlédnutí 472KPřed 4 lety
Altaic: Rise and Fall of a Linguistic Hypothesis

Komentáře

  • @LeefUmbrella
    @LeefUmbrella Před 13 minutami

    Candle is a bad example since it probably comes from Old English, which borrowed the term from Latin.

  • @ALEHOLLYESHORTS
    @ALEHOLLYESHORTS Před 9 hodinami

    1:31 in Italian, we say: 2 caffè, like 2 coffees

  • @RazzUK
    @RazzUK Před 11 hodinami

    Wow, just found this channel. our voice is so so similar to max Miller from Tasting History that I had go and check you weren't him!

  • @veronicaguzman3210

    What?!?! Claudius is here?!?!?

  • @why5482
    @why5482 Před dnem

    The way the box like characters work is that you have to let the people in before closing the door

  • @user-xq1xd3re7d
    @user-xq1xd3re7d Před dnem

    If the neo latin languages were an family ,french would be the one raped by the celtic languages while dalmatian would be the one killed by slavid languages

  • @squirrelvert
    @squirrelvert Před dnem

    Lots of good stuff in here but lots of little and one or two fairly big errors. Also it’s a fun video, but don’t let the high production values and 90% correctness and academic quality make you think that everything you’re seeing in it is accurate.

  • @Cacalopreiooooo
    @Cacalopreiooooo Před dnem

    ངབེ

  • @TheEbola
    @TheEbola Před dnem

    in Turkey we learn in school that our language is a part of the Ural-Altaic family which includes all the Altaic languages plus Uralic languages like Hungarian, Finnis and Estonian.

  • @ezzovonachalm9815
    @ezzovonachalm9815 Před dnem

    Why not beginn with roman genealogy which were of greater interest for us than iroqui or bananish

  • @7N_GA
    @7N_GA Před dnem

    I think you can do this in arabic

  • @helpIthinkmylegsaregone

    the Tower of Babel wasn't an attempt at explaining anything, it was a revealed/received story. "God of the Gaps" is a strawman argument. Religious narratives don't form from attempts to explain historical or a natural mechanics.

  • @cycrothelargeplanet

    2:18 You pronounced x as ʀ̥

  • @GaasubaMeskhenet
    @GaasubaMeskhenet Před 2 dny

    I'm still getting this vibe that we are/have been demanding too much before giving credit

  • @GaasubaMeskhenet
    @GaasubaMeskhenet Před 2 dny

    My cat can say 4 words that we've come up with together

  • @GaasubaMeskhenet
    @GaasubaMeskhenet Před 2 dny

    Ok but why is grammar the only thing were focusing on My cat says "wow" when he wants to be petted. He sats "aaaaam" when he wants "ham" (what we call wet food) why do we need grammar on top of vocabulary to acknowledge that animals can communicate to us and mean it?

  • @GaasubaMeskhenet
    @GaasubaMeskhenet Před 2 dny

    One of the apes at kanzi's center drew the symbol for Outside one day when it had been raining a lot so no one had been playing outside

  • @victoriaarakelian3210

    I ownder if "muluvanice" could be also "painted" or "drawn" meaning "I was painted by Laris"

  • @user-gn6gl9vm6y
    @user-gn6gl9vm6y Před 2 dny

    Why does English sound so unlike other Germanic languages?

  • @angusmackaskill3035

    It doesnt, it sounds just like italian and Spanish

  • @cavitturnali3890
    @cavitturnali3890 Před 2 dny

    I suspect it’s not “you peel us” but rather “you rob us.” Yes, I base this assertion on an unrelated language such as Turkish. However, if one were to look at a map they would be pleasantly surprised to find Turkey and Georgia are side by side. Indeed, Georgia was under Ottoman rule for quite some time and expressions such as these end up being borrowed from language to language. The word used for “peel”, “undress”, and “rob” is the same in Turkish. And it makes sense despite not doing so at first glance. However, one would recognize that in each case the verb expresses that something that belongs to something is being removed. Cloths from the body, wealth from a person, and the inedible exterior from a fruit or vegetable.

  • @angelsperanza9244
    @angelsperanza9244 Před 3 dny

    The first empire but not the last to get too inflated to the point of collapse.

  • @yipperson2974
    @yipperson2974 Před 3 dny

    can you do one on australian aboriginal languages?

  • @Rajae-mn7cx
    @Rajae-mn7cx Před 3 dny

    They talk annoying

  • @mirceavolosen2876
    @mirceavolosen2876 Před 3 dny

    Love Hungarian. I learned Hungarian .Took me 2 weeks to read and write. I just finished reading the Bible in Hungarian. On the way to work, I am finishing the second audio in Károly Bible.

  • @freshprince69
    @freshprince69 Před 3 dny

    Was the corpse an Etruscan? It's interesting how it got mummified in Egypt if that's true.

  • @Licensed1
    @Licensed1 Před 3 dny

    Up Sut Aye Bow A-mem

  • @talbino7821
    @talbino7821 Před 4 dny

    Sigh. That's what happens when a language that originally started its life as a Germanic language got chopped up and radically changed around over many centuries - compared to other languages which were untouched (for the majority of time) by outside influences. In its defence, English grammar is definitely far easier than some other languages out there. Where it trips everyone up is its incomprehensible spelling and pronunciation rules !

  • @luiskel
    @luiskel Před 4 dny

    I thought I came here to listen to somebody speak latin

  • @zakariah_altibi
    @zakariah_altibi Před 4 dny

    Are you saying the word nightmare, is originally ghaelghamare

  • @dnd-yd2uu
    @dnd-yd2uu Před 4 dny

    Ashoka didn't invented writing system in India!!, he just standardised the Brahmi script, there were already versions of brahmi script used around the subcontinent,

  • @NickyDIY101
    @NickyDIY101 Před 4 dny

    2:07 this is interesting that they have qieyun. and how people (today) know how to pronounce Qieyun ? it is not like Pinyin that we could refer to Roman character

  • @marzo21
    @marzo21 Před 4 dny

    SVO

  • @CdFMasterVideo
    @CdFMasterVideo Před 4 dny

    Talking about different calls and signs from animals and not letting us hear or see any of them is criminal!

  • @Landoverse
    @Landoverse Před 4 dny

    25 year Japanese language student here. Thank you for explaining why I hate my life🤣

  • @reimundnoll1999
    @reimundnoll1999 Před 4 dny

    Great video. I still doubt we can say how Etruscan was spoken in reality. Orthografie always is an abstraction. Under words there are morphems, phonems and finally phones, which most concretly represent the spoken language. But of course the science still brought a lot into daylight.

  • @OrigiNaous
    @OrigiNaous Před 4 dny

    We still use Coptic language during liturgy

  • @j.n.-fr5uh
    @j.n.-fr5uh Před 4 dny

    so thats why theyre called occitan french

  • @Chipicatcapybara3J123

    000 0000 000

  • @LH-ft2yy
    @LH-ft2yy Před 5 dny

    The peak of Egyptian civilization was actually right at the beginning - Pre Dynasty world. With every new kingdom, Egypt declined. So, writing is not making us wiser. The reason why we started to write things down is because of amnesia that humanity has been living with for some thousands of years due to trauma. People before didn't have to write things down because memory, information was inherited.

  • @wackyruss
    @wackyruss Před 5 dny

    And later on came Cajun French and Creole French in Louisiana!

  • @tpnmrtknn7692
    @tpnmrtknn7692 Před 5 dny

    word "RUMA" in finish language means - ugly.

  • @tristanpineda562
    @tristanpineda562 Před 5 dny

    We are full of hubris if the Hieroglyphic was used for 3,500 years while we are barely a thousand and a half and full of huffing and puffing.....like a crane standing at the back of the big water Buffalo.......!!!

  • @sircappyiii3079
    @sircappyiii3079 Před 5 dny

    Yo broh why does the thumbnail look like CaseOh?

  • @eyepatchpirate7726
    @eyepatchpirate7726 Před 5 dny

    Is the book you mention Isidore's De differentiis verborum?

  • @moenajadmmh194
    @moenajadmmh194 Před 5 dny

    "Dia(O), saya(S) ngelihat(V)" but with coma😅we have OSV in casually not Officially.(Bahasa Indonesia)

  • @artiom7568
    @artiom7568 Před 5 dny

    Une baguette (magique) et un 🥐 it is all what you need 😂😅

  • @artiom7568
    @artiom7568 Před 5 dny

    French : too many rules English : embrace the chaos

  • @_RKPhoenix_
    @_RKPhoenix_ Před 5 dny

    Honestly one of the most underrated channels. Great work!

  • @EG-ry1dz
    @EG-ry1dz Před 6 dny

    "Merci à tous", not "merci tout le monde"