Video

Lol. Amazing that a population once heralded for its steadfastness and having a backbone now has neither .

Karamazov kardeşler'le yeraltından notlar arasında gidip geliyorum. Düşünce bombardımanı, felsefe olarak yerlatından notlar. Karamazov da bir roman olarak çok iyi. Sonra Cinler romanı gelir bence. Yazdıgı herşey güzel bence. Neyse.

what subject is he teaching here? i cant imagine this lecture will help his students in an exam. maybe for a Dostoyevsky/psychology dissertation. ok, let's say its not for the exam -- its for life. well there's a forum for that. but the classroom isnt it. maybe he should have held after school discussions for life.

he's not a horrible person. he's just weak.

Miss alemania tan alemana como un kebab jajajajjaja

She just needs better makeup and hair-- her stylist sucks

Hyperborea...MYTHICAL utopian GIANTS....according to the Greeks. Who live somewhere in the north and are friends whit the Greeks

I hated "Notes from the Underground." "The Idiot" is just boring.

I don't always agree with Peterson, but his reverence of Dostoyevsky and interpretations of his books are 🔥

😊

JP needs to fact-check himself sometimes lmao - the utopian bit is not accurate - a historian and philosopher

It is because of this left oriented society in germany. "Everyone should can be miss germany even if she does not look german" bla bla bla

Bro sipping on a yapuccino

I would be willing to bet he’s never read it. He learned about Dostoyevsky in his undergrad humanities class and keeps regurgitating the same tired shit over and over and over and over.

Peterson understands Dostoyevsky up-set-down. Such an idiot.

Yes! 😊 1. Dostoevsky's Crime and Punishment is an awesome book. Arguably one of the greatest novels ever written. I think it's as good as The Brothers Karamazov which is also arguably one of the greatest novels ever written. 2. The fact that Dostoevsky wrote at least two great novels places him among the very best novelists of all time. And I fact I think he wrote more than two great novels. See also The Demons (which, for one thing, was amazingly prescient in warning about the revolution and totalitarianism that would come in Russia after Dostoevsky's own death) and The Idiot (which foregrounds the holy fool tradition in Russian Orthodoxy, where a person no less than a proposition can be an argument for God; one need not be a theist let alone agree with Dostoevsky to appreciate the artistic merits and moral values of Dostoevsky's work on the holy fool, such as appreciating the quiet unassuming and even unintelligent - but not unwise! - and extraordinarily kind and caring grandmother whom everyone loves). 3. Some of Dostoevsky's short stories like "The Dream of a Ridiculous Man" and "White Nights" are well worth reading too. 4. For Crime and Punishment, I'd strongly recommend the translations done by either Oliver Ready (if you prefer British English) and/or Michael Katz (if you prefer American English). These two translations are both faithful to Dostoevsky's Russian (which is a mixture of 19th century Russian and old Church Slavonic Russian and other things) and also very readable, with exciting literary flow, lively, and capture the idioms and subtle meanings in Dostoevsky that are so often missed by other translations. Ready's translation has a good introduction and helpful notes, while Katz's translation is also published in the Norton Critical Edition which is a great series for classic literature including Dostoevsky since it comes with so much informative material. It's an immense aid to better understanding the book to have good supporting material in addition to a good translation when reading the classics. 5. In general, unless you can't afford to buy the Ready or Katz books (currently approximately $20 each), I'd prefer to shy away from the (free) Constance Garnett translation. It was a beautiful translation for its time, and Garnett deserves our undying gratitude for translating almost all the major works of Russian literature into English, but today her translation feels a bit dated (published in the early 1900s). It's of course not as up to date with the latest scholarship on Dostoevsky. It uses older Victorian/Edwardian English which tends towards the prim and proper, whereas a lot of Dostoevsky doesn't sound like a British Victorian (e.g. how Dostoevsky portrays the Russian peasants speaking). Garnett simply skipped or elided some phrases, sentences, and passages in Dostoevsky that she didn't quite understand at the time or by trying to smooth out these sections, since Dostoevsky's style is often jagged and chaotic in Russian, as if he is a stranger on the street who has suddenly grabbed you and is shouting at you in a somewhat though not entirely incoherent fashion. 6. That said, and to be fair, there have been really good modern updates of Garnett that are definitely worth reading. For instance, the Norton Critical Edition of The Brothers Karamazov is based on Garnett's translation which in turn has been revised and updated by Matlaw and McReynolds. That's a great translation of The Brothers Karamazov, though I'd personally still tend to prefer Michael Katz, but Garnett-Matlaw-McReynolds is as good. Ignat Avsey also did a good translation of The Brothers Karamazov. 7. Finally, I'd prefer to avoid Pevear and Volokhonsky. They're probably the most popular or commonly used English translation today. Not only of Dostoevsky but other Russian writers as well (e.g. Tolstoy, Chekhov, Turgenev, Pushkin, Gogol, Bulgakov). I mean, P&V aren't as horrible as some say, they're okay, decent, but they're nowhere near as good as other translators like Ready and Katz. For example, read the free articles: "The Pevearization of Russian Literature" (Gary Morson), "The Pevear/Volokhonsky Hype Machine and How It Could Have Been Stopped or At Least Slowed Down" (Helen Andrews), "Socks" (Janet Malcolm), and "Pevear and Volokhonsky Are Indeed Overrated" (John McWhorter).

Qué horror!!!

This novel is about the atheistic literature of his time. Dostoyevsky brings to life the atheistic ideal of Nitse decays before Nitse was born. He is a brilliant individual, totally honest with him self going into the depths of evil motives of human and finding some basic solid truth to them. But bringing life to this persons makes a huge discovery! How could this alive person be? He is miserable. He is to be pitied. He is not strong . He is dying slowly in his little hole with his own poison. This is the only though that outperforms any other element of truth of his self-awareness

As an Iranian I'm very sorry for this if the world was ok she couldn't even won in miss village contest

Such a interesting, read written, and I believe 1864 or something like that but characters are as true as they are today

Left green woke agenda

I want to go with the police people 😂

If you think this analysis is brilliant, you should try a lecture by a competent literature professor

Didn’t that painter 👩‍🎨 warn us ?

As a German we are disgusted 😢

Its called replacement being promoted

At this point, we should we glad that she's an actual woman

Who is the Blue Hater influencer? She/It needs to get she/it's due recognition and credit. (Much like Bud Lite & Mulvaney) That she/it is opposed to all these things is outright spitting in every American's face

I read “The idiot”when I was young, because of the title. I read it out, but man, that book was totally boring!

Maybe it is a man secretly? 😂😂😂

Them without make up are just the same

She is at least a woman, in the Netherlands they chose a dude as miss Netherlands. Oh sorry did I said dude I mean "transgender".😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

Completely ridiculous outlook on life somehow makes Dostoyevsky great. How? No explanation is offered. How about a system in which people get the cakes and desserts they earn? Such a system never crosses D's mind.

Bruh

Too much disrespect here. These contests are not just about look right ?

Dude Germany maybe😂

It wasn't very long ago that he was telling us that the Brothers Karamazov was the greatest novel ever written. It's not unreasonable to say that neither of them make the best novels written by Dostoyevsky. I wonder what he'll say when he gets round to reading Proust, or Tolstoy or Nabokov, or Gogol, or Joyce, or ...

Its such an offemse how the other didnt win that this calls for WW3.

Miss? 😂😂😂😂😂😂

How the fuck did she even win?

All of this is true. But premised on a full stomach. If you are hungry, happiness is a plate of food, period. As Peterson has said, you cannot argue with hunger, pain, fear and heartache. So don't. It changes the way you look on surfeit, easy living, abundant leisure. Eaten with humility, you will not despise bread, let alone cake.

Letters describes the left perfectly

68 years old. So much to learn. Yet so much more to un-learn.

Do you think the president position should have an age limit?

Peterson. For what it’s worth, man, I, personally, will never forgive you. You mock truth and trust, but the main reason, actually, is that you’re so up your intellectual arse that you have given up on people. And, if there such a thing as sin, that is it, man. Yes, every human being is a horrid animal, BUT he/ she is not just an animal, god fucking damn it! You treat them like mere animals. Many have done so, most if not all, bloody shepherds. Fear, lies, and material comfort or lack thereof to keep them on their toes at the basis of Maslow’s pyramid salivating after some putrid carrot at the end of whatever meaning of life. There is so much potential for good and good things in every individual, forever dead primarily not because they lack whatever integration (how many can realistically do that?), but because the systems they’ve been kept in have been nothing more than cultural animal pens full of the animal excrements of ideologies- including the religious ones and other ones that either made them feel like technological gods, slaves content to be crucified, or little blind messiahs- all at the mercy of criminals. Yes, I am bitter. Yes, I am angry. So should every human being be. Maybe feeling like this will make them get out of their heads and do something to change things for the better. You and the likes of you just beat them and misdirect their justifiable misery to where? Fucking heaven? Jung’s projective paradise of integrated/ systematised delusions complex with spiritual connotations? Ultimately, there’s no difference between you and the neoliberals (or whatever they’re called). Same manipulative method, same end goal, just different ideologies and modus operandi. I protest. I am bitter. I am full of regrets. I am disgusted. And I’m just a crazy woman in a world of ‘sane’ people. That’s why I am hopeless. If you who are a highly intelligent and cultivated man do what you do, what can I expect from others? Shame on you. Shame on you.

Eckelhaft 🤢 nicht 1 richtiger Soldat dabei sowas nennt sich Armee...lächerlich diese Objekte 🤮🤮

Joke army

USA: "Our army is such an embarrassment nowadays..." Sweden: "Hold my pride flag."

Well i didnt know that sweden army recruits mentally ill people...

I heard Sweden has less crime rate. Gay way😅