She's so tiny and adorable. I love her and always will, no matter if her songs are on the charts or not. She helped me a lot. I hope to meet her one day and thank her for everything.
***** Just because they're skinny themselves it doesn't mean they think a chubby person is ugly, my skinny friends always tells me that I'm beautiful and I'm chubby, although they think that they are too fat.. It's all in their head. It's about low self esteem, everyone can't help it. Some people have a hard time gaining weight, I thought it was mean to say you hate skinny people like.. overall (that's what it sounded like at least). So, like, ''wtf?'' to you too.
Artpop was ahead of it's time and that's on PERIODT. No one can look at this and say they don't see someone being absolutely authentic with authentic music
Yeah even some of her fans were lashing out on her it was a ridiculous time. I'm glad I enjoyed it.. my fave part was SWINE FEST. The deluxe version of Artpop came with the entire performance I love rewatching it. My Botticelli Punk Girl ♡
"I try to sell myself but I am really laughing because I just love the music not the bling" - Lady Gaga 2013 Honestly, I don't think she or anyone will ever beat that verse.
I have to agree with you. That line is awesome. It makes me think of people who are only in it for the money, or the bling. Not the music. Gaga is in it for "the music not the bling."
nicholas bert I feel she wouldn’t have been allowed to say that. She pushed the boat as far as she could, and went for self depreciation😔 absolute living legend
@@ginasousabranco5637 just shut up I love Madonna so much but Gaga absolutely more creative than her and btw she is great VOCALIST that Madonna could never ...!!!both are not the same at all
@@ginasousabranco5637 Madonna couldn't even stay in tune for like 3 seconds lmao. She barely could push her voice out her lungs. Don't get me wrong, Madonna is a legend but calling Gaga a Madonna ripoff is really a wrong statement. This performace was better in any way, shape or form than the one you linked.
Coming back 7 years later and realizing this album was one of the most advanced points of psychedelic and interpersonal artistry that my generation didn't nor could comprehend at the time of it's release. I will have a family one day and show my children her performances and say, I was young then and I experienced this. For that I'm grateful.
I feel bad for anyone who missed out on the ARTPOP/ArtRAVE era. I remember BEGGING my parents at 15 to let me see the concert for this album live, and then I arrvied at the venue at 8:00AM to be the (second) person in line with a GA pit ticket. It was without at doubt it was most wild, enthralling, and beautiful show I've ever been to.
Very jealous ! I was too young at the time and never would have been able to go financially, I saw her finally at the chromatica ball and that was amazing, so sad I will never be able to experience the artrave but glad I have seen someone I look up to so much live finally. Everything that went wrong during this era for her that we know and don't know included is really a huge shame, it is an incredible body of work and deserved so much more, even though it was ahead of its time, if only things had been slightly different like DWUW staying solo or having a different feature, Vocal and instrumental productions not having been diluted e.t.c. At least it has been celebrated more than ever these past couple years, Gaga herself tweeted about the artpop petition and how it means a lot to her that finally it is getting some flowers, a truly iconic album that deserves the title of legendary.
I think she did promote it but her management was in turmoil and didn't do their part and also her detractors were so adamant at bringing her down and they were already talking trash about her and the album before she even released it. I think she was fighting against a lot of forces at the time but I liked the album myself and this song is one of the highlights of the album for me, in fact this version is better than the album version IMO.
I've always love ARTPOP and think it is her most interesting album. The farther along the album goes, the more that this strange aura starts to take over. Can't quite explain it.
Yeah! because they missed out hahaha I have so much merch, a ManiCure shirt, and magazines from that time. Even the v.i.p book from ArtRave.. my Artpop cd is deluxe with the Swine Fest performance ♡
This performance deserves soooooooooooo very much credit it's a masterpiece! the hair the outfit the stage the melodies the way she plays at the piano how she manages to get down on those stairs where she couldn't see a single fucking step...
+utopiachild71 The safest way to do it is barefoot as she can feel the stairs with her feet as she goes down them.. With shoes on she would have probably fell and broke her neck..
I hope someday she will make a museum with all the pianos (the paw, the burning piano, the heel, the bubble piano, the super tall piano...) and clothes, it would be so epic!
Rion some of her items are already in museums and some she has kept :) some of her items such as an outfit from Bad Romance, her Grammy outfit from 2010,and her meat dress are all in "The Rock and Roll hall of Fame and Museum"
+Rion YAS!!! Imagine all the different disco sticks lighting the way to a stairway of high heels: like the armadillo ones by McQueen, the pumps with lucite penis stilettos, the meat boots, the knee-high black patent leather studded BTW era tour boots. And rooms full of clothing & props themed for each album, like the Fame, etc. That's such a great idea! Oh, & of course, the purple pyramid studded keytar!
The album version it's beautiful as it is but when she sits on the piano and performs a few seconds of the song stripped from all the other sounds, she gives you a glimpse, like a gift, of how she concieved the song, how it was born. Just her voice and a piano. And it's simply magical
@@ginasousabranco5637 youre obsessed look at you commenting in a gaga performance video with this😍😍😍😍welcome in the fandom hun And just to let u know even if its a rip off gaga outdid madonna's performance 😍your fave has to be ashamed after gaga performed this
***** Mine too. This is my fave performance and i dont usually have one. When i saw this the first time i immediately fell in love ♥ its just really beautiful and always makes me want to get up and dance and sing with her :D.
Artpop It's sad. I pray to God she can make a comeback and get The Fame Monster type of sales. She deserves it. The next single release is gonna be so critical for her career. It's either make or break!
...that's definitely not true a single can not break an artist of her caliber. Even if she is not as big a force as she was when she premiered, she is incredibly talented and has made a permanent influence in pop culture--she will always have a great number of fans, more than a lot of artist in America.
Anyone who says she can't sing is wrong and have no idea what good singing sounds like. I'm a singer/songwriter and am in awe of her talents and skill.
@@legendsrule8968 If Gaga and her fans can belong together then her art and pop culture can belong together. "We could, we could belong together ARTPOP" She's screaming out to not stick to the status quo of pop culture in 2012/13. Lot's of people didn't get the album or understand it upon it's release however if she released this album post 2018 it'd would of been incredibly succesful
This performance shows how artpop would sound if she had followed her instincts instead of trying to unite her complex message with her label desire for radio friendly songs. artpop is a very intellectual album dressed as generic music, that's why some people love it and others hate it
It's polarizing but I think that's what makes it so interesting. I think it would've definitely been more interesting had her vision completely pulled through.
I do hope that gaga will realize that she can actually launch her own label and release anything she has on mind. i am even disappointed that obviously, LG6 (as what her fans are naming her next album) is being delayed (and delay) all over again because of her label. gaga's Adele tweet (and the popstar tweet) are the hint of it. Sad that we (as fans) are being hindered from seeing and hearing the potential and all of her ideas because she is being caged by her label.
Xiao Buddz “Lg6” is not a name that we call it- it’s what we call an album we don’t know the name of. LG- lady gaga 6- sixth studio album. Simple as that
+Taylor how so? The best producers were on it, David Guetta (Fashion!), Zedd (Aura, Donatella, G.U.Y), Madeon (Mary Jane Holland, etc.) and the list goes on.
+Taylor The album was mediocre because of the poor writing, not the actual production. Zedd, Madeon etc did a fantastic job with the production and the album was praised for its production
I think this is one of her most underrated live performances. It came after the horrendous fall out with Troy Carter and all the evil people who literally tried to ruin her. To me, this is very much a phoenix rising from the ashes moment.
+Fahad Ahmed = Farthard Ahdouche. I can rhyme & mock too, point is, it's ignorant. Whether you have something positive or negative to add, form a concise thought. What you say matters to others; if you sound stupid, people will assume you are. On a side note, insulting someone in a public forum only makes you look bad, not the person you're attacking.
+Fahad Ahmed you must have a lot of time to go on a singer's videos and write your shitty opinions that no one wants to hear. Write comments like that and of course the Little Monsters are going to retaliate. Fucking hell just get off Gaga's back and leave her alone. ARTPOP was an amazing album that people have not realised changed the course of the music industry because she introduced a new and fresh genre that people are now using to produce music.
then why the fuck would you comment on my comment, when i and obviously the rest of the people on here to watch this performance, don't want to hear your opinion? You make no sense, move along.
+CaptainEnigma Avenged God, I love this performance too, I love too how she bounced back with grace from the over opinionated haters. This is real talent.
Wow....did she EVER did a bad song?? I never heard this song before. I only became a little monster about three weeks ago, by pure accident. I never took Lady Gaga that serious...thinking she was just another plastic autotune pop idol. How wrong I was! Since about three weeks - when I got the time - I've been binge watching Gaga video's, interviews and performances and I'm stunned. Stunned by her talent and stunned I didn't notice her before. She's a TRUE artist, in every meaning of the word and this performance is....just wow. I cannot find the words. Fantastic. Awesome. Pure art in it's finest form. I've always been a Bowie fan and the biggest Queen fan around since 1986, forever mourning the loss of both Freddie and David. But I cannot express how happy I am now having discovered Lady Gaga. To me she's the new Mercury, the new Bowie of this century and the new Kate Bush as well. But: a true original, just like Mercury, Bowie and Kate Bush. Of course true artists cannot be compared, there will never be another Freddie Mercury and there will never be another David Bowie. But I'm pretty damn sure there won't ever be another Lady Gaga as well. I could go on like forever, but let's keep it to this. Thank you Stefani for your music, for your performance, your charisma, your personality and...your ART! Please stay around for the coming 50 years!! :-)
I'm glad I did! ;) I'm somehow jealous you discovered her years before I did. I didn't follow pop music since my late twenties and I was born in 1971. I was 20 when Freddie died and I remember the day as yesterday. I also remember exactly where I was and what I was doing when I heard the sad news about David Bowie. Anyhow...I've been listening to my own personal oldies since the beginning of this century. But I'm glad that I have now found a new incredibly talented true artist that is still alive! ;-) And still I'm wondering...why didn't I notice earlier?? :-\
I feel the same way. I never really cared for pop music. But I became a fan a few months ago. She is really amazing. Im also sad I've been missing out on her these past 10 or so years. But I'm here for the rest of the ride.
Im his fan from 2012 and i love her so much She has a pure heart but people judge gaga before they see who really is gaga So they dont know how much talent and pure heart gaga have ❤️
I agree - not many people can sound this good with only a piano - no auto tune a she’s awesome. This reminds me a little of Tori Amos - she sounds best just playing a piano (sometimes two) and singing.
She always gives everything in her everytime she performs it's just beautiful to watch you can truly feel how into it she is. Rockstar behavior! Or just an artist :)
such an unexpected title track. didn't sound like what I thought it would, I was pleasantly surprised. probably one of the best title track songs I've heard
Sounds alternate. Sounds pop. Sounds old. Sounds modern. And risky. And the face of Lady Gaga. I was very critical of previous work in this pop artist. But now she's really showing what he can do. Sound different and alternative relative to other current pop artists. My congratulation Lady gaga great job.
I'm so happy somebody (for example you) noticed it. This song is really different. It reminds me different songs but no one. And the sound is so good. Thank you for giving her a chance to show you her best.
Where did heavy criticism and negative with respect to the work that Stefani Joanne Angelina Germanotta was producing in his previous albums. Never liked what she was doing at the beginning of his career as Lady Gaga. I always thought she was more limiting your talent with pop songs midianas. But with this her new job, she did something very different! A sound and my personality in pop and electronic music today as produtor.Se one day I can do something with it or have a very happy to produce an entirely different that has touched the world of current pop music sound oportunidade.Ficaria. I make electronic music and very different from the alternate path atuas compositores.Sigo pop. And Lady Gaga loves this alternate world.
I'm not trying to be mean, but it's really hard to understand what you say in English because you make very essential grammar mistakes or you use a terrible translator. Like this part: "...one day I can do something with it or have a very happy to produce an entirely different that has touched the world of current pop music sound oportunidade..." what???? I'm not a native English speaker, but please, use a better translator or something.
April 14th of 2021 and i listening this performance on repeat! ARTPOP is number 1 all over the world, after 8 years!!! Let's celebrate Little Monsters and make justice for ARTPOP!
If you do not like her, that is fine. However, that is your opinion. Gaga has changed my life with the album ARTPOP. It defiantly 'freed my mind'. Helped me fined my artistic side, and thanks to this album I am doing piano lessons, drawing, painting, and after listening to her interviews I started losing weight after I found out she also struggled with an eating disorder. I was very obese (16.5 stone) and now I am 9 stone. And I am 16 years old. So all I can say is thank you Gaga! :)
monachairlines totally agree!! Thanks to Gaga I started to see life in a different way, a better way, with a smile on my face, accepting myself as I am, I stared bass lessons, dancing lessons, caring about myself, my body, my mind. I don't care what people say, I am me, thank u Gaga. I love music but I love this artist.
This album was meant to push the boundaries and merge ART & POP two things that don't really go well together, because one is deep and the other is shallow, she wanted to make them belong together, through her (the way she's been doing since her 1st album, making Pop Music in a very Theatrical way, very Artsy, very dramatic, putting on fashion to expand the performance Art out of the stage into real life (like you see Paparazzi taking photos of her artistic fashion instead of her drunk at a club or with boyfriends) because she wanted to control the argument of her own fame, for them to focus on her artistry instead of her celebrity, she had such a master degree on Fame culture like you cannot believe, even experimented on it, took a purple teacup with flowers print everywhere she went doing interviews and the teacup became famous, proving what a powerful imagery that can be, using her own fame as a vehicle for even an object ☕ to make the news, it did make the news. 😅 She was just 23 years old, 22 when she started. Genius! So going further on that, she wanted ARTPOP to be a "reverse Warholian expedition" in which instead of the Pop Icon like Marilyn Monroe going into the canvas, becoming Art, in Pop Art, she wanted to reverse it now with ART or "the canvas" going into the POP Icon, her: Lady Gaga. Into Pop Culture. ARTPOP. When she had avant-garde fashion on, theater makeup on, very creative wigs, headpieces, crazy shoes, she's making Art out of herself, with powerful imagery, as a "Pop Star" who makes Pop Music but also experimented on the music (she did that too on all her previous albums bringing what's next in music, but pushed it further on this album) to bring technology, the future (that's why this album is so ahead of it's time, it came out in 2013 and just now it's getting more recognition) it's experimental in the sounds and entire production of the music and vocals, nobody got it then, it wasn't commercial because commercial meant to be basic for it to be catchy and POPular, for the radio, instead, this was very out there, very ARTsy, not for everyone. At first she thought about making two parts, one more Pop the other more Art experimental, but then it would go against the concept idea of them belonging together so I believe she put the most experimental songs on the 1st half and the most Pop songs on the 2nd half, the song ARTPOP is in the middle of the album as a bridge that merges both Worlds together and the song is self explanatory in the lyrics, "we could belong together ARTPOP". Let's talk about how this song in particular "ARTPOP" gives me underwater vibes, totally on purpose because if you close your eyes and imagine Botticelli's Aphrodite or Venus how she was born in the sea from a giant oyster, I can almost feel the bubbles surrounding the Venus on her seashell under the sea, is crazy but it gets you there! Or if you like mermaids, that could be too, half reality, half fantasy, it's so brilliant!!! 🎶🐚♀️💖🎨👌🏻 But nobody talks about that, seems like only I noticed it. :/
I can totally see where you're going with the underwater vibes, I see it that way too. It also sets the mood for watching art pieces in a submarine. I loved reading your comment, it helped me understand more of Gaga's intent to express herself in the album
Justice for #ARTPOP. ARTPOP has returned to the Top 5 on US iTunes, 7 and a half years since release. It's never a bad idea to show Lady Gaga's diverse catalog some love and appreciation. #BuyARTPOPoniTunes.
She is always so ahead of her time... It's almost as if she traveled from the future and is blessing all of us peasants with her Godly transcendental vocals YAASSSS
Tonight my mom, and I were watching Jimmy’s show with a musical guest. I told her about how Jimmy gives room to artists when they perform. The biggest one I could remember was this performance. I showed her how stunning this was and she was blown away by it all. Little did I know it’s going to be 10 years since Gaga gave us this album. I bought this album when it first came out, and it is one of the best that I own. Lady Gaga, you are a true artist. ❤
I truly believe people didn't understand this album. She doesn't care about sales, she just celebrated artpops birthday this year that's how you know she actually cares about what she produces. This album in my mind was too artistic for people to truly understand.
I am not the biggest fan of Lady Gaga but, damn this album was underrated. People didn't want her to change/evolve so they underappreciated such a great album.
no..you are a LEGEND if you do it...Lady Gaga is a POP LEGEND...she will be bigger than Madonna in the future...just wait...shes doings very smart...she just realased a Jazz album with TONY BENET...a Jazz legend ♥
This is the best performance I've seen of this song. It really is so good, the lightning, the outfits, the stage, the opening in the piano. It really is high quality thing!
What a star, our generation will not appreciate her until she is gone. We live in a world where everything is disposable. Remember when you decide to throw something in the trash that gaga is recyclable and can be used forever, a true artist that can be moulded into countless things. I love you!
robert patuson some time this year, we don't know yet but all we know is its being recorded as we speak and its called LG5 or something and that it will sound a lot like her older stuff
You're right: Lady Gaga is often misunderstood because she's too much genius and innovative. Anyway she will remain in the music world for far in the future
I personally thing ARTPOP album is her most personal album, it was a celebration of her pain, its very raw and primal, from songs like dope, swine, artpop and do what u want, and we Little Monsters share that with her, something the rest of the world missed to see. I love ARTPOP and its always in my consciousness.
+Doubleyouexwhyamzed OMFG samee, the only songs from AP i didnt listen to much were jewels and drugs and mary jane holland. I loved it. I have NO idea why people thought it was different. It was better than anything she had done by then.
Lady Gaga is a Genius! Her music is in tune with human consciousness. I didn't understand this album at the time. I was stuck on the "Fame" and "Born this way" albums. Lady Gaga Just don't subliminaly sell us to those in power.
Who’s listening to art pop in 2020?
only those with TASTE 😌
Core fans the real fans
It’s her best album imho. I love all her songs and all her eras, but something about ARTPOP just feels right and futuristic. It’s timeless 🥺💜
@@endlessgalaxy2675 OMG I was just writing the same comment!!! %100 true 👌🏼
Murat Soysal 😭💜 we just appreciate art, pop and ARTPOP. It’s nice to see I am not the only one 🥺💞
I love how she never performs the same version of a song
FACT
Na poker face
*Lovegame would like a word
I believe it's her philosophy. "When you do live, you perform. Not replaying the ones you can hear on the album"
Learned from Bennett and Winehouse
People just keep ignore the fact that she’s also a serious pianist 💀
That's where she started her music nd Never forgets that
she played pianp by foot.and heel sometimes
...and singer, writer, composer, producer, entertainer, etc.
@Edgar Maidana hay una performance de poker face en la era the fameque lo hace... en verda, en muchas presentaciones lo hizo
@Edgar Maidana aquí lo hace más al final czcams.com/video/EtmPCuOTYMg/video.html
7 years later, this album is #1 on iTunes in 19 countries....
The album was ahead of his time
dvdd melhor álbum, amo demais
When did it hit #1 in 19 countries
@@Djeff82 in this year 2021
@@RyuziBeats had no clue. Wow
26*😍
This performance is timeless. It captures the magic of "ARTPOP"
I totally agree.
♥️♥️♥️🙌🏻
I agree,love it
Yess
I agree...
She's so tiny and adorable. I love her and always will, no matter if her songs are on the charts or not. She helped me a lot. I hope to meet her one day and thank her for everything.
she's not tiny she is FAT! Seen her lately?
anthony oz The only fat thing around here is your ego amore.
Alex Manuel thanks hun! but she still is faaaaat!
***** Omg you know it's a disease right? That's really rude
***** Just because they're skinny themselves it doesn't mean they think a chubby person is ugly, my skinny friends always tells me that I'm beautiful and I'm chubby, although they think that they are too fat.. It's all in their head. It's about low self esteem, everyone can't help it. Some people have a hard time gaining weight, I thought it was mean to say you hate skinny people like.. overall (that's what it sounded like at least). So, like, ''wtf?'' to you too.
Artpop was ahead of it's time and that's on PERIODT. No one can look at this and say they don't see someone being absolutely authentic with authentic music
True
Totally agree
Exactly....my friend told mw about this song ..like rn ...nd I am obsessed
MAKE SURE TO SIGN THE PETITION!!!!
it went to number 1 in dozens of countries?
i seriously cannot believe people did not appreciate artpop when it came out. the lack of taste
She always ahead of her time...
Maybe a lot of people just not ready with this masterpiece
Agreed she was so ahead of us
agreed. this song is a masterpiece and it got paid dust by everyone including the fans
@@charlotteaitchison2922 I always be here for her since day 1
I always love and support her
Fans who betrayed this ARTPOP is absolutely FOOLS
Yeah even some of her fans were lashing out on her it was a ridiculous time. I'm glad I enjoyed it.. my fave part was SWINE FEST. The deluxe version of Artpop came with the entire performance I love rewatching it. My Botticelli Punk Girl ♡
"I try to sell myself but I am really laughing because I just love the music not the bling" - Lady Gaga 2013
Honestly, I don't think she or anyone will ever beat that verse.
I have to agree with you. That line is awesome. It makes me think of people who are only in it for the money, or the bling. Not the music. Gaga is in it for "the music not the bling."
It would be better if she said "THEY try to sell myself but I am really laughing" wow iconic
Daniel fucking right bro
Even in GUY GYPSY AURA NO ONE COULD
nicholas bert I feel she wouldn’t have been allowed to say that. She pushed the boat as far as she could, and went for self depreciation😔 absolute living legend
this world doesn’t deserve Lady Gaga, they let ARTPOP down
Rip off of Madonna's Bedtime Story live at the Brit Awards 1995 czcams.com/video/BUW-UxpsWmw/video.html
@@ginasousabranco5637 just shut up
I love Madonna so much but Gaga absolutely more creative than her and btw she is great VOCALIST that Madonna could never ...!!!both are not the same at all
@@ginasousabranco5637 Madonna couldn't even stay in tune for like 3 seconds lmao. She barely could push her voice out her lungs. Don't get me wrong, Madonna is a legend but calling Gaga a Madonna ripoff is really a wrong statement. This performace was better in any way, shape or form than the one you linked.
@@Skrapes FACT
Đồng ý
I'm convinced this lady is the artist of the century - I can't think of someone more creative and talented.
I agree. I was never a big fan, but I literally slept on her genius. She is pure talent.
that’s on you tbh
Coming back 7 years later and realizing this album was one of the most advanced points of psychedelic and interpersonal artistry that my generation didn't nor could comprehend at the time of it's release. I will have a family one day and show my children her performances and say, I was young then and I experienced this. For that I'm grateful.
Trueeeeee
spill
PERIOD
literally!!! I am mindblown
I'll have children only so i can talk to them about artpop
imagine if this gets performed at the Chromatica ball I’d cry
I would literally die. 😭😭😭😭
Same ...I can't wait
Artpop 😍
a cultural reset tbh
So...your thoughts on the album?
To me ARTPOP is an amazing album, no idea why so much hate on it.
davidgeorgiev the problems
Kristin Farquhar F With?
davidgeorgiev mainly because she sang with r kelly
davidgeorgiev its the best of hrr for me.
davidgeorgiev because the best music is underrated
I feel bad for anyone who missed out on the ARTPOP/ArtRAVE era. I remember BEGGING my parents at 15 to let me see the concert for this album live, and then I arrvied at the venue at 8:00AM to be the (second) person in line with a GA pit ticket. It was without at doubt it was most wild, enthralling, and beautiful show I've ever been to.
Very jealous ! I was too young at the time and never would have been able to go financially, I saw her finally at the chromatica ball and that was amazing, so sad I will never be able to experience the artrave but glad I have seen someone I look up to so much live finally.
Everything that went wrong during this era for her that we know and don't know included is really a huge shame, it is an incredible body of work and deserved so much more, even though it was ahead of its time, if only things had been slightly different like DWUW staying solo or having a different feature, Vocal and instrumental productions not having been diluted e.t.c.
At least it has been celebrated more than ever these past couple years, Gaga herself tweeted about the artpop petition and how it means a lot to her that finally it is getting some flowers, a truly iconic album that deserves the title of legendary.
I was 16 during Artpop, I never had the money so couldn't go to Artrave. 🥲 But Yes I'm glad I was old enough to experience this era.
Yesssss i was 15 as well and I was hurt
@@eenver941same
I missed this concert
7 years later... This MasterPiece called ARTPOP (ahead of her time) is number one on iTunes in 28 countries! Unbelievable!
41 now
Omg how is that possible tho??? No shade, i fucking love our Goddess Gaga, but like 7 years? thats incredible
@@Justlilmonster The fans trended it in honour of its anniversary
This was so perfect. If you don't like this you're wrong.
CaliforniaLuv84 queen of stanning her 3 years ago!
I didn't realize this Lady was so petite in statue! Thank you God for blessing us with this TALENTED iconic genious🙌
this album had so much potential! Too bad people didn't like it. I think it has great songs.
I will just add, this is my favourite lady gaga album
I think she did promote it but her management was in turmoil and didn't do their part and also her detractors were so adamant at bringing her down and they were already talking trash about her and the album before she even released it. I think she was fighting against a lot of forces at the time but I liked the album myself and this song is one of the highlights of the album for me, in fact this version is better than the album version IMO.
its actually way way better than BTW . ppl are dumb honey so dumb
When u think in ARTPOP, which music you have in mind? ... Nothing!
i have ARTPOP i hav applause ... exx dreams ... gypsy ..... MJH ..... guy ... venus
Artpop was ahead of her time
this song has to be one of the greatest, most timeless songs i have ever heard. it just has to be heard by the right people.
🔥👊🏽🔵
I fucking love this album so much omfg her best era she served Looks, Visuals, Performances, ART, and mostly Pop it was truly ahead of it's time
u look hot btw
your tweets are iconic oops
skskksks i know u from twitter legend
What is you twitter
so agree! A masterpiece!
When everyone left her and didn’t believe in her I stood by and believed in ARTPOP and now everyone else notice how magical this era was.
Same here omg
That's a BADDASS comments
Just WOW
I always did and I always will love ARTPOP
I've always love ARTPOP and think it is her most interesting album. The farther along the album goes, the more that this strange aura starts to take over. Can't quite explain it.
Yeah! because they missed out hahaha I have so much merch, a ManiCure shirt, and magazines from that time. Even the v.i.p book from ArtRave.. my Artpop cd is deluxe with the Swine Fest performance ♡
This song has aged very well. Here enjoying it in 2023.
One of her most beautiful pianos ever.
This performance deserves soooooooooooo very much credit it's a masterpiece! the hair the outfit the stage the melodies the way she plays at the piano how she manages to get down on those stairs where she couldn't see a single fucking step...
and she does it barefoot
+utopiachild71 The safest way to do it is barefoot as she can feel the stairs with her feet as she goes down them.. With shoes on she would have probably fell and broke her neck..
MsKerryanne oh good point
MsKerryanne Gaga runs in Armadillos, the McQueen shoes... trust me she can walk on air if she wants to.
Gaga doesn'r need Air Max to walk on air :D
I hope someday she will make a museum with all the pianos (the paw, the burning piano, the heel, the bubble piano, the super tall piano...) and clothes, it would be so epic!
Rion I don't think she kept all of those.
Lucent Lux Yes she does
Rion some of her items are already in museums and some she has kept :) some of her items such as an outfit from Bad Romance, her Grammy outfit from 2010,and her meat dress are all in "The Rock and Roll hall of Fame and Museum"
the piano with heads in born this way .
+Rion YAS!!! Imagine all the different disco sticks lighting the way to a stairway of high heels: like the armadillo ones by McQueen, the pumps with lucite penis stilettos, the meat boots, the knee-high black patent leather studded BTW era tour boots. And rooms full of clothing & props themed for each album, like the Fame, etc. That's such a great idea! Oh, & of course, the purple pyramid studded keytar!
The album version it's beautiful as it is but when she sits on the piano and performs a few seconds of the song stripped from all the other sounds, she gives you a glimpse, like a gift, of how she concieved the song, how it was born. Just her voice and a piano. And it's simply magical
The lone survivor of planet Artpop. Even if nothing else had worked, this song will still be enough for me to appreciate Lady Gaga.
this generation doesn’t deserve her intelligence and artistry.
Gina Sousa Branco do you have an issue this Madonna performance is literally nothing like this??
@@ginasousabranco5637 it can't be a rip off. If it would be a rip off of one of madonnas performances, it would be shitty, too.
Gina Sousa Branco Ripoff how? Just because she’s wearing white while having stage presence doesn’t make it a rip off. Please stop being bitter.
@@ginasousabranco5637 hahaha girl you are so obsessed
@@ginasousabranco5637 youre obsessed look at you commenting in a gaga performance video with this😍😍😍😍welcome in the fandom hun
And just to let u know even if its a rip off gaga outdid madonna's performance 😍your fave has to be ashamed after gaga performed this
This is my favorite performance. Her voice is perfection. ARTPOP is my favorite song of ARTPOP!
***** Mine too. This is my fave performance and i dont usually have one. When i saw this the first time i immediately fell in love ♥ its just really beautiful and always makes me want to get up and dance and sing with her :D.
Bloodmoonlilmonster6
Bloodmoonlilmonster6
this is so iconic.
The darkest Lady's Gaga album. Masterpiece.
No, Born This Way is darkest Lady Gaga’s album.
She hits every single note live just like on the recording... Many times even better then the original recording.
Yet other artists like Selena Gomez get praised more
Artpop It's sad. I pray to God she can make a comeback and get The Fame Monster type of sales. She deserves it. The next single release is gonna be so critical for her career. It's either make or break!
...that's definitely not true a single can not break an artist of her caliber. Even if she is not as big a force as she was when she premiered, she is incredibly talented and has made a permanent influence in pop culture--she will always have a great number of fans, more than a lot of artist in America.
Doubleyouexwhyamzed... So.. make or break?
Lysol Disinfectant Wipes shallow lol. She’s on top again
The piano and voice is about to give me tears....
The best from Lady Gaga.... This song and album is brilliant... This song brings me to tears...
Same
NUMBER ONE ON 24 COUNTRIES !! JUSTICE FOR THIS MASTERPIECE !!!
"Money can run out,but talent is forever." -Lady Gaga
My Queen you're so fucking talented.
I will always love you
I honestly don't understand how people say she can't sing. Her voice is amazing
Just jealous
Anyone who says she can't sing is wrong and have no idea what good singing sounds like. I'm a singer/songwriter and am in awe of her talents and skill.
9 years since ARTPOP and I still believe and advocate in the meaning of ARTPOP.
What message was that? I'm struggling to get it 😫
@@legendsrule8968 If Gaga and her fans can belong together then her art and pop culture can belong together. "We could, we could belong together ARTPOP" She's screaming out to not stick to the status quo of pop culture in 2012/13.
Lot's of people didn't get the album or understand it upon it's release however if she released this album post 2018 it'd would of been incredibly succesful
ARTPOP was truly ahead of its Time. Just like she said It's *FUTURISTIC*.
THIS is the definition of ART + POP! The beginning is so ART, & the end is so POP! She blows me away every time!
I think Lady Gaga is only Artist that her live performances sounds better than Album version of songs 😐😀😀😀😀 Queen
Also amy winehouse they sounds so good in live vocals
lana del rey too
@@sebastianignacio9998 lana? no. ahhahahaha
Ariana
Whitney houston from early '80s to late '90s.
“Could try to sell you out or I could show you all the reasons why” 😭💓🔮
ARTPOP 🔵 WILL ALWAYS HAVE A SPECIAL PLACE IN MY HEART
This performance shows how artpop would sound if she had followed her instincts instead of trying to unite her complex message with her label desire for radio friendly songs. artpop is a very intellectual album dressed as generic music, that's why some people love it and others hate it
It's polarizing but I think that's what makes it so interesting. I think it would've definitely been more interesting had her vision completely pulled through.
I do hope that gaga will realize that she can actually launch her own label and release anything she has on mind. i am even disappointed that obviously, LG6 (as what her fans are naming her next album) is being delayed (and delay) all over again because of her label. gaga's Adele tweet (and the popstar tweet) are the hint of it. Sad that we (as fans) are being hindered from seeing and hearing the potential and all of her ideas because she is being caged by her label.
Well, she needed the fame and experience she earned with "the Fame" and "the Fame Monster" to get the collabs and skills used on Artpop.
Xiao Buddz “Lg6” is not a name that we call it- it’s what we call an album we don’t know the name of. LG- lady gaga 6- sixth studio album. Simple as that
You're gonna tell me Swine and Dope have generic pop sounds?
I don't care what others say, Artpop is my fave album from her. The lyrics are so deep and trippy.
But production is terrible ;(
+Taylor production is really good,it just didn't sell much that's why if it was selling big people wouldn't be saying this shit!
Actually I liked artpop. More than Btw. It's so fresh (trap, urban, and many things) but I get it since it's experimental not everyone get it
+Taylor how so? The best producers were on it, David Guetta (Fashion!), Zedd (Aura, Donatella, G.U.Y), Madeon (Mary Jane Holland, etc.) and the list goes on.
+Taylor The album was mediocre because of the poor writing, not the actual production. Zedd, Madeon etc did a fantastic job with the production and the album was praised for its production
I think this is one of her most underrated live performances. It came after the horrendous fall out with Troy Carter and all the evil people who literally tried to ruin her. To me, this is very much a phoenix rising from the ashes moment.
YES!! Agree completely.
7½ years later, #1 in 41 countries. See when you're a legend.
Fucking love this performance
+Fahad Ahmed = Farthard Ahdouche. I can rhyme & mock too, point is, it's ignorant. Whether you have something positive or negative to add, form a concise thought. What you say matters to others; if you sound stupid, people will assume you are. On a side note, insulting someone in a public forum only makes you look bad, not the person you're attacking.
+Fahad Ahmed you must have a lot of time to go on a singer's videos and write your shitty opinions that no one wants to hear. Write comments like that and of course the Little Monsters are going to retaliate. Fucking hell just get off Gaga's back and leave her alone. ARTPOP was an amazing album that people have not realised changed the course of the music industry because she introduced a new and fresh genre that people are now using to produce music.
then why the fuck would you comment on my comment, when i and obviously the rest of the people on here to watch this performance, don't want to hear your opinion? You make no sense, move along.
+CaptainEnigma Avenged God, I love this performance too, I love too how she bounced back with grace from the over opinionated haters. This is real talent.
it's just perfection❤
This song is highly underrated
Bish I'm crying because I supported ArtPop era all the way when everyone turned their back to her 😭
It's not artpop, it's ARTPOP
Wow....did she EVER did a bad song??
I never heard this song before. I only became a little monster about three weeks ago, by pure accident. I never took Lady Gaga that serious...thinking she was just another plastic autotune pop idol. How wrong I was!
Since about three weeks - when I got the time - I've been binge watching Gaga video's, interviews and performances and I'm stunned. Stunned by her talent and stunned I didn't notice her before. She's a TRUE artist, in every meaning of the word and this performance is....just wow. I cannot find the words. Fantastic. Awesome. Pure art in it's finest form.
I've always been a Bowie fan and the biggest Queen fan around since 1986, forever mourning the loss of both Freddie and David. But I cannot express how happy I am now having discovered Lady Gaga. To me she's the new Mercury, the new Bowie of this century and the new Kate Bush as well. But: a true original, just like Mercury, Bowie and Kate Bush. Of course true artists cannot be compared, there will never be another Freddie Mercury and there will never be another David Bowie. But I'm pretty damn sure there won't ever be another Lady Gaga as well.
I could go on like forever, but let's keep it to this. Thank you Stefani for your music, for your performance, your charisma, your personality and...your ART! Please stay around for the coming 50 years!! :-)
Pascalsmit1971 OMG I am her fan from 2011 but you described my thoughts about her)
I'm glad I did! ;) I'm somehow jealous you discovered her years before I did. I didn't follow pop music since my late twenties and I was born in 1971. I was 20 when Freddie died and I remember the day as yesterday. I also remember exactly where I was and what I was doing when I heard the sad news about David Bowie.
Anyhow...I've been listening to my own personal oldies since the beginning of this century. But I'm glad that I have now found a new incredibly talented true artist that is still alive! ;-)
And still I'm wondering...why didn't I notice earlier?? :-\
I feel the same way. I never really cared for pop music. But I became a fan a few months ago. She is really amazing. Im also sad I've been missing out on her these past 10 or so years. But I'm here for the rest of the ride.
Im his fan from 2012 and i love her so much
She has a pure heart but people judge gaga before they see who really is gaga
So they dont know how much talent and pure heart gaga have ❤️
@@DARQAURA hell yea thats hot. I love my idol
Such an underrated vocalist. One of the best voices among the pop divas in my opinion.
I agree - not many people can sound this good with only a piano - no auto tune a she’s awesome. This reminds me a little of Tori Amos - she sounds best just playing a piano (sometimes two) and singing.
Agreed
@@wendyfrench8042fact dear
The love and power this performance holds in my heart. She is a poet 100%
The way she says “cruelty” definitely does something to me
its 2016 and i still dont get it why artpop dont get grammys
this literally EVERYTHING
Trust me award shows are just stupid. History shows how bloody fucked up they are with all the snubs theyd done.
Just like how Till It Happens To You didn't win the Tony
Because it was trash :v
+Mauri Ramos do you like trash bitch
Yohanes Daniagi 90% of the best albums and songs that once won a Grammy are not remembered nowdays😂
She's should do a piano and voice album it would sell. Her melodies are amazing. Her lyrics are extremely poetic. She'll be around a very long time.
I only Understand the album now that it’s years later THIS WUZ AHEAD OF ITZ TIME ‼️‼️
One of the best live performances she’s ever done
This song's melody is just so right! Takes me to utopian places
AGREED
Exactly!!! Perfectly worded!!
"MY HEART CAN BEAT WITH BRICKS AND STRINGS
MY ARTPOP COULD MEAN ANYTHING" - MY FAVORITE VERSE
this was a LATE NIGHT TALK SHOW. the way she ate. i can't.
Let’s back this album #1 worldwide!
She always sounds way better on live performances
ALWAYS !
She always gives everything in her everytime she performs it's just beautiful to watch you can truly feel how into it she is. Rockstar behavior! Or just an artist :)
such an unexpected title track. didn't sound like what I thought it would, I was pleasantly surprised. probably one of the best title track songs I've heard
G.U.Y is better
JezusDayz lol no it’s not
Me rewatching artpop performances in the first few weeks of 2024 .. an era that was beyond its time and foolishly waysided
Who’s here after ARTPOP came #1 on iTunes WW in 2021? 🎨🎶
The Queen .
yasss
Goddess*
Sounds alternate. Sounds pop.
Sounds old.
Sounds modern.
And risky. And the face of Lady Gaga.
I was very critical of previous work in this pop artist.
But now she's really showing what he can do.
Sound different and alternative relative to other current pop artists.
My congratulation Lady gaga great job.
yes
I'm so happy somebody (for example you) noticed it. This song is really different. It reminds me different songs but no one. And the sound is so good. Thank you for giving her a chance to show you her best.
Where did heavy criticism and negative with respect to the work that Stefani Joanne Angelina Germanotta was producing in his previous albums.
Never liked what she was doing at the beginning of his career as Lady Gaga.
I always thought she was more limiting your talent with pop songs midianas.
But with this her new job, she did something very different! A sound and my personality in pop and electronic music today as produtor.Se one day I can do something with it or have a very happy to produce an entirely different that has touched the world of current pop music sound oportunidade.Ficaria. I make electronic music and very different from the alternate path atuas compositores.Sigo pop. And Lady Gaga loves this alternate world.
excuse me, risky?
I'm not trying to be mean, but it's really hard to understand what you say in English because you make very essential grammar mistakes or you use a terrible translator. Like this part: "...one day I can do something with it or have a very happy to produce an entirely different that has touched the world of current pop music sound oportunidade..." what???? I'm not a native English speaker, but please, use a better translator or something.
this is literally the meaning of ART
April 14th of 2021 and i listening this performance on repeat! ARTPOP is number 1 all over the world, after 8 years!!! Let's celebrate Little Monsters and make justice for ARTPOP!
If you do not like her, that is fine. However, that is your opinion. Gaga has changed my life with the album ARTPOP. It defiantly 'freed my mind'. Helped me fined my artistic side, and thanks to this album I am doing piano lessons, drawing, painting, and after listening to her interviews I started losing weight after I found out she also struggled with an eating disorder. I was very obese (16.5 stone) and now I am 9 stone. And I am 16 years old. So all I can say is thank you Gaga! :)
Congratulations 😊😊😊😊😊
monachairlines totally agree!! Thanks to Gaga I started to see life in a different way, a better way, with a smile on my face, accepting myself as I am, I stared bass lessons, dancing lessons, caring about myself, my body, my mind. I don't care what people say, I am me, thank u Gaga. I love music but I love this artist.
That's the most heartwarming thing I have seen today.Im happy for you 😄
I'm just wondering, how you are doing right now :) Hope you're doing okay!
The greatest album I’ve ever heard and SO UNDERRATED
FACTS
#1 on itunes go check💖💖💖💖
This album was meant to push the boundaries and merge ART & POP two things that don't really go well together, because one is deep and the other is shallow, she wanted to make them belong together, through her (the way she's been doing since her 1st album, making Pop Music in a very Theatrical way, very Artsy, very dramatic, putting on fashion to expand the performance Art out of the stage into real life (like you see Paparazzi taking photos of her artistic fashion instead of her drunk at a club or with boyfriends) because she wanted to control the argument of her own fame, for them to focus on her artistry instead of her celebrity, she had such a master degree on Fame culture like you cannot believe, even experimented on it, took a purple teacup with flowers print everywhere she went doing interviews and the teacup became famous, proving what a powerful imagery that can be, using her own fame as a vehicle for even an object ☕ to make the news, it did make the news. 😅
She was just 23 years old, 22 when she started. Genius!
So going further on that, she wanted ARTPOP to be a "reverse Warholian expedition" in which instead of the Pop Icon like Marilyn Monroe going into the canvas, becoming Art, in Pop Art, she wanted to reverse it now with ART or "the canvas" going into the POP Icon, her: Lady Gaga. Into Pop Culture. ARTPOP.
When she had avant-garde fashion on, theater makeup on, very creative wigs, headpieces, crazy shoes, she's making Art out of herself, with powerful imagery, as a "Pop Star" who makes Pop Music but also experimented on the music (she did that too on all her previous albums bringing what's next in music, but pushed it further on this album) to bring technology, the future (that's why this album is so ahead of it's time, it came out in 2013 and just now it's getting more recognition) it's experimental in the sounds and entire production of the music and vocals, nobody got it then, it wasn't commercial because commercial meant to be basic for it to be catchy and POPular, for the radio, instead, this was very out there, very ARTsy, not for everyone. At first she thought about making two parts, one more Pop the other more Art experimental, but then it would go against the concept idea of them belonging together so I believe she put the most experimental songs on the 1st half and the most Pop songs on the 2nd half, the song ARTPOP is in the middle of the album as a bridge that merges both Worlds together and the song is self explanatory in the lyrics, "we could belong together ARTPOP".
Let's talk about how this song in particular "ARTPOP" gives me underwater vibes, totally on purpose because if you close your eyes and imagine Botticelli's Aphrodite or Venus how she was born in the sea from a giant oyster, I can almost feel the bubbles surrounding the Venus on her seashell under the sea, is crazy but it gets you there! Or if you like mermaids, that could be too, half reality, half fantasy, it's so brilliant!!! 🎶🐚♀️💖🎨👌🏻
But nobody talks about that, seems like only I noticed it. :/
I can totally see where you're going with the underwater vibes, I see it that way too. It also sets the mood for watching art pieces in a submarine.
I loved reading your comment, it helped me understand more of Gaga's intent to express herself in the album
Justice for #ARTPOP. ARTPOP has returned to the Top 5 on US iTunes, 7 and a half years since release. It's never a bad idea to show Lady Gaga's diverse catalog some love and appreciation. #BuyARTPOPoniTunes.
fell in love with this song from the very first time I heard it.
+Jesus Carbajal Ditto. Love at first sound. *
She is always so ahead of her time... It's almost as if she traveled from the future and is blessing all of us peasants with her Godly transcendental vocals YAASSSS
She is
Yassss we're peasants af gahhgaggga
Tonight my mom, and I were watching Jimmy’s show with a musical guest. I told her about how Jimmy gives room to artists when they perform. The biggest one I could remember was this performance. I showed her how stunning this was and she was blown away by it all. Little did I know it’s going to be 10 years since Gaga gave us this album. I bought this album when it first came out, and it is one of the best that I own. Lady Gaga, you are a true artist. ❤
Happy 10 years of ARTPOP 🔵✨
👊🏽👊🏽👊🏽🔵
I think ARTPOP is her most personal album
Joanne is 😉
she's been saying that since the fame lol
Vinícius Valles Alves pls, Joanne.
Pakitos Monster Joanne was not out when I said that
Vinícius Valles Alves it was artpop was like the 2nd Importand album to gaga the first was joanne the third ks cheek to cheek then the fame
I truly believe people didn't understand this album. She doesn't care about sales, she just celebrated artpops birthday this year that's how you know she actually cares about what she produces. This album in my mind was too artistic for people to truly understand.
Sounds 1000 times better than the album version.
Artpop was fucking majestic and the world was not ready for its beauty.
I am not the biggest fan of Lady Gaga but, damn this album was underrated. People didn't want her to change/evolve so they underappreciated such a great album.
Thank you! ArTPoP is fantastic. I love love love this album. Good Stuff!!!
You're a true artist if you sound better live than on your studio album
A.M.E.N. She always sounds so much better live!
The Artrave changed my life. a must see concert
Patrick Reed
no..you are a LEGEND if you do it...Lady Gaga is a POP LEGEND...she will be bigger than Madonna in the future...just wait...shes doings very smart...she just realased a Jazz album with TONY BENET...a Jazz legend ♥
Federico Pedemonte yeah right!!! We're witnessing one of the greatest artist ever!!!
This is the best performance I've seen of this song. It really is so good, the lightning, the outfits, the stage, the opening in the piano. It really is high quality thing!
This, and the iTunes London show are my 2 favourites. Both magical in different ways.
This her best work, in my opinion.
What a star, our generation will not appreciate her until she is gone. We live in a world where everything is disposable. Remember when you decide to throw something in the trash that gaga is recyclable and can be used forever, a true artist that can be moulded into countless things. I love you!
Hey, just because ARTPOP didn't have the chart count doesn't mean her new 2016 album won't top all of it
robert patuson some time this year, we don't know yet but all we know is its being recorded as we speak and its called LG5 or something and that it will sound a lot like her older stuff
robert patuson people that have already heard it says it sounds a lot like the fame and the fame monster and that its not like ARTPOP
You're right: Lady Gaga is often misunderstood because she's too much genius and innovative. Anyway she will remain in the music world for far in the future
marco brenni agreed shes gone so far in her own career that she can never not be famous
she is like the best live performance on earth. next to cher.
What about Beyonce, Aguilera, Carey?
they are great, but i have never seen them in concert before so i did not want to put my opinion on them.
Gaga writes her own songs and is the best live performer around
Who is here on the day that artpop is rising on the itunes charts again?
We didn’t deserve ARTPOP back then, a true cultural reset
One of the best performances of her career. PERFECTION !
I personally thing ARTPOP album is her most personal album, it was a celebration of her pain, its very raw and primal, from songs like dope, swine, artpop and do what u want, and we Little Monsters share that with her, something the rest of the world missed to see. I love ARTPOP and its always in my consciousness.
right on ♡
This is it!
I loved ARTPOP better then Born This Way and people crucify me for it but oh well.
+Doubleyouexwhyamzed OMFG samee, the only songs from AP i didnt listen to much were jewels and drugs and mary jane holland. I loved it. I have NO idea why people thought it was different. It was better than anything she had done by then.
est omne tempus BUT JEWELS AND DRUGS & MJH ARE REALLY GOOD! give it a try
Lady Gaga is a Genius! Her music is in tune with human consciousness. I didn't understand this album at the time. I was stuck on the "Fame" and "Born this way" albums. Lady Gaga Just don't subliminaly sell us to those in power.
Art pop is one of the greatest albums of our time
She looks different and mature, and amazing performance like always
Her voice and presence on stage, wow, simply, Extraordinary!!!
***** yep, sure am, buddy.
***** tf is your problem
#1 WORLDWIDE ITUNES ALBUM CHART GODDESSSSSSSSSSSS
Best version of this music