No, he came back to the Giants in 2008 but didn’t play that season due to an offseason injury, he then played for the Ravens in 2009 and played in 10 games but had no catches, so this wasn’t his last game it was just his last catch
I would say yes, but I’m salty that he betrayed the Dirty Birds just to chase a ring (he complained that Atlanta wasn’t winning WHEN HE WAS INJURED HALF OF THE FUCKING TIME) and turned into a total diva, not no silent HOFer.
@@justus4423 Talked shit about losing games and putting the spotlight saying he “Wants to be traded ASAP” while he was *constantly injured and had previously mentioned that he was gonna be a Falcon forever*
@@ethandegge3127yea and if he showed the other angles, the defenders hand was within an inch of the ball and just barely missed it. The throw was just as impressive as the catch
Honestly there’s a few that I don’t think deserve to be on this list or where they are on the list. Jermaine kearse should be there, as well as Julio Jones in 51, immaculate reception, and (hot take) Mario Manningham in 46 as honorable mention
I agree, but this op is obviously biased to put Edelman's on here. Doesn't belong in the top 50 "catches" of all time. Manningham was under intense pressure by 2 DB's and the toe tap was unmatched in this clip
Santonios catch happened in 2009, Tyrees catch was in 2008, and the first catch was in the late 90's. Lynn Swanns juggling catch in the super bowl is the only "old" catch id consider
he didn’t even get both feet down. there’s a zoomed picture where his one foot is on top of the other and never hits the ground. another all time fixing by the nfl
@@dabear7822😂😂😂😂😂...watch it again then... dumbest comment I've heard..u have to be a browns.. Ravens..bengals.. Patriots..or Cardinals fan ...am i right? 😢
Tbf all these are Super Bowl winners and much more impressive. Immaculate reception was cool, but sorta lucky. And the Steelers didn’t even win it all that year
Justin jeffersons catch against the bills is the greatest catch I've ever seen 3 defenders one hand and rips the ball out of a defenders hand without it touching the ground and it was on a 4th down
It was impressive but Grimes catch wasn't on OBJ's level. You could pull up hundreds of one handed catches that look similar over the years but OBJ caught the ball with 3 fingers, behind his head. Grimes looked the ball in and needed 2 hands to complete the catch
I know it’s not on here and a lot of people think it’s overrated but I think the Hopkins game winning catch against the bills was definitely worthy of the conversation
David Tyree's catch was the greatest catch I've ever seen. I still can't figure out how he held on to the ball. The 18 and 0 Patriots ended up 18 wins in a row and one GIANT loss.
I know it’s NFL history but theres that one highschool play where the Guy is like getting hit in the air and catches it one handed on the way down and that’s without a doubt the best catch or all time
The Holmes catch is the greatest catch of all time. Pass, catch, big time play made in the big game to seal it up. Eldelman’s catch is a clutch play but Holmes’ catch is the catch.
That Julio Jones catch in the Superbowl was better than the Santonio Holmes catch in his Superbowl. Maybe not as far as the moment but as far as difficulty.
You could actually argue with you Eli could have a third, that pass/catch by Manningham in the second giant patriots Super Bowl might be one of the greatest passes and catches of all time
I agree. I made that argument but the OP keeps deleting my post. 😅. A total 🤡. Edelman's tip drill catch is same as many hail Mary catches every year. Nothing special and not difficult.
I was low-key about to be heated because no one talks about Edelman's catch and I thought it was going to get left off again here, but this guy gets it.
Yeah, probably gets left out bc it's just a boring tip drill like hundreds of other Hail Mary passes.😅 These are supposed to be about incredible technique and concentration
I’ve actually met David Tyree in New Jersey at a private Christian school where is son was. I didn’t really get so say anything to him but I knew I recognized him.
It is so weird that not a lot of people talk about eldman 's catch
Or you prob just live in Atlanta so no one wants to talk about it
bc its not that insain
He was down
Bc it was not that good
@@1andonlygabewhat does that have to do with anything?
Fun fact: David Tyree never played in the NFL again after that game.
Really ?
Probably because he got his payday after that superbowl win
@@EsliLover911💀
No, he came back to the Giants in 2008 but didn’t play that season due to an offseason injury, he then played for the Ravens in 2009 and played in 10 games but had no catches, so this wasn’t his last game it was just his last catch
@@phillyeaglesforlife5127 Thank you for the correction!
OBJ’s catch is so iconic it’s craxy
Julio Jones just left the chat
Tbh julios superbowl catch is more impressive than most of these
I would say yes, but I’m salty that he betrayed the Dirty Birds just to chase a ring (he complained that Atlanta wasn’t winning WHEN HE WAS INJURED HALF OF THE FUCKING TIME) and turned into a total diva, not no silent HOFer.
@@rhettrozbicki3127 Yo what diva stuff did he do i missed that part
@@justus4423 Talked shit about losing games and putting the spotlight saying he “Wants to be traded ASAP” while he was *constantly injured and had previously mentioned that he was gonna be a Falcon forever*
Fax 🔥
Bro gave the Edelman catch like two seconds of screen time but took a third of the video to remind pats fans of 18-1 😭😭
OBJ’s is by far #1. I think you rated the catches by its impact on the game.
FR😮
Nah
Odells was extremely impressive, but Santonios catch was just so perfect, he had ZERO room for error, and had to stretch completely out for that one
@@ethandegge3127bro stop
@@ethandegge3127yea and if he showed the other angles, the defenders hand was within an inch of the ball and just barely missed it. The throw was just as impressive as the catch
JERMAINE KEARSEEEEEEEEEEEEEE!!!!! The absolute greatest catch to never be remembered. Such a shame it was overshadowed 😢
Honestly there’s a few that I don’t think deserve to be on this list or where they are on the list. Jermaine kearse should be there, as well as Julio Jones in 51, immaculate reception, and (hot take) Mario Manningham in 46 as honorable mention
I agree, but I think it’s more about who won. Like Tyree and Edelman’s catches won them super bowls, but yeah.
Odell should be number 1 that’s the toughest catch ever made list is a lil shaky
Jefferson was tougher
Yeah, Edlemans catch was nice but not that difficult. Def changed the game, but you and me can make that catch.
its crazy because Eli could've been on here a 3rd time with the 3rd and long pass to Mario Mannigham.
I agree, but this op is obviously biased to put Edelman's on here. Doesn't belong in the top 50 "catches" of all time. Manningham was under intense pressure by 2 DB's and the toe tap was unmatched in this clip
@@tcurr0309 This guy said Holmes had the greatest toe tap of all time. He must not know Tony Toe Tap himself, Chad Johnson. lmao
Damn football didn’t exist before 2010
Santonios catch happened in 2009, Tyrees catch was in 2008, and the first catch was in the late 90's. Lynn Swanns juggling catch in the super bowl is the only "old" catch id consider
I was about to say the same damn thing. Recency bias as a MF.
That Santonio catch is by far the most impressive i have ever seen, just the sheer amount of body control needed to be able to complete that catch
he didn’t even get both feet down. there’s a zoomed picture where his one foot is on top of the other and never hits the ground. another all time fixing by the nfl
@@dabear7822😂😂😂😂😂...watch it again then... dumbest comment I've heard..u have to be a browns.. Ravens..bengals.. Patriots..or Cardinals fan ...am i right? 😢
The throw was probably more impressive despite it being a great catch.
@@user-mf9wg6jq5f the ball had to be perfect and it was
@@user-mf9wg6jq5f the throw and catch were both impressive..it was an impressive play for sure...an impressive drive for them both too
Obj is #1 no question
Cap Justin’s is
No.? Aint even that crazy of a 1 hander? Its a normal sc. 😊
@@user-vx8fr8tz2bnah obj was better
immaculate reception not even making top 5 is CRAZY
It should be 1
No
Tbf all these are Super Bowl winners and much more impressive. Immaculate reception was cool, but sorta lucky. And the Steelers didn’t even win it all that year
@@anonymouswhitecircle5236 exactly it’s the most overrated overhyped catch of all time
@@jmoney1884 ight def not overrated bro, it’s still one of the best plays of all time, just not as athletic as these other catches 😂
Objs catch at 4 is crazy
That Edelman was insane 💪🏾
That first one is to clean
Odell's catch vs Washington was also incredible when he horizontal 1ft off the ground. Same season he caught the TD vs Dallas.
18-1 Patriots. Thanks for coming to my Ted talk.
thank you
No Lombardi. All for naught.
Justin jeffersons catch against the bills is the greatest catch I've ever seen 3 defenders one hand and rips the ball out of a defenders hand without it touching the ground and it was on a 4th down
4th and 18 I think and yeah I got your point
i agree and that catch definitely should be top 5
If the defender wasn’t there Jefferson wasn’t catching that the defender kind of stoped the ball
Definitely
I think that d-hops one handed catch where he put it under his legs should be here even though it didn’t count. Or at least a mention
nah
The Jermaine Kearse Super Bowl has to be on here
Brent Grimes made the same catch as OBJ on the same weekend.
Chris Chambers used to make that toe tap catch 4 times a game.
It was impressive but Grimes catch wasn't on OBJ's level. You could pull up hundreds of one handed catches that look similar over the years but OBJ caught the ball with 3 fingers, behind his head. Grimes looked the ball in and needed 2 hands to complete the catch
I know it’s not on here and a lot of people think it’s overrated but I think the Hopkins game winning catch against the bills was definitely worthy of the conversation
As a Dolphins fan, Orange Gadsden made several catches like that. Dude was a beast. He just never had a QB that could make him famous.
THE CATCH has left the chat
Marty booker catch against the lions was insane.
Everyone sleeps on Brent Grimes insane one handed interception on megaton when he jumps 3 feet in the air
Rice running full speed on the sideline with an extended one handed catch should be #1. This list is lacking at best.
Great list, not sure why JD’s catch from TB often gets forgotten
Fax bro Edelman had the best catch of all time by far.
I want what you’re smoking.
@@rhettrozbicki3127it was for the Super Bowl, in the greatest comeback ever on turf, cmon now
@@Jackson54321 It hit the ground and he bobbled it and you know it.
@@rhettrozbicki3127 BRO LOOK AT IT NEVER TOUCHED THE GROUND
OBJ was pass interfering the defense on his catch 😂
On defesne
David Tyree's catch was the greatest catch I've ever seen. I still can't figure out how he held on to the ball. The 18 and 0 Patriots ended up 18 wins in a row and one GIANT loss.
The first two were the beat catches
Greatest catch gotta be “The Catch” but only cuz I’m a Niner fan 😂
I know it’s NFL history but theres that one highschool play where the Guy is like getting hit in the air and catches it one handed on the way down and that’s without a doubt the best catch or all time
Not having OBJs catch at #1 is just disrespectful
Ok Giants fan
@@kgcool literally not a giants fan but okay
@@bush3510 then dont say thing like a Giants fan
Notice how every single other one is in the super bowl
Super Bowl 42&51 catches are wayyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy better
The Holmes catch is the greatest catch of all time. Pass, catch, big time play made in the big game to seal it up. Eldelman’s catch is a clutch play but Holmes’ catch is the catch.
If we bring OBJ in this list then you would have to bring george Pickens catch in this too. That catch was incredible why does nobody talk about it
Lynn Swann in Super Bowl X diving catch belongs.
I remember watching the Edelman catch on my couch with my parents before they passed
Julie Jones and DeAndre Hopkins have left the chat
That was Edelmans luckiest catch ever and having it happen during one of the craziest superbowls ever is what makes it insane
Dwight Clark's catch is a all time top top 5 catch to send 49ers to their first super bowl
That Seahawks catch against the Patriots on that final drive was crazy
That Julio Jones catch in the Superbowl was better than the Santonio Holmes catch in his Superbowl. Maybe not as far as the moment but as far as difficulty.
My opinion: obj catch should be number one, it was the most impressive catch by far.
Can’t wait for top 10 kickers 🔥
Never let bro cook🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
As a falcons fan, I cried 28273 differ t times that day
Those Jermaine Kearse catches were pretty ridiculous too
The 18-0 pats that played 17 games got to love them
I’m just wondering where Jermaine Kearse SB catch is at! Lol
The kearse catch in the superbowl shouldve been on the list too
My greatest catch is a 1v3 burn which i caught outside of bounds and dived into the td zone
I thought one of best catches was Lynn Swan from Terry Bradshaw against Dallas Cowboys in one of the Superbowls!JET UP!
Right after he said Holmes catch was immaculate i though i Knew what would be 1
UUUHHH LYNN SWAN.......
OBJ catch should be number 1
You could actually argue with you Eli could have a third, that pass/catch by Manningham in the second giant patriots Super Bowl might be one of the greatest passes and catches of all time
I agree. I made that argument but the OP keeps deleting my post. 😅. A total 🤡. Edelman's tip drill catch is same as many hail Mary catches every year. Nothing special and not difficult.
Julian’s catch was so easy bro
I think he isn’t as much talking about the catch he’s more talking about the circumstances and how it effected the game
It’s not just ranked by catches,it’s the situation that helps too
Great list
We found Gus Fring’s new partner.
I was low-key about to be heated because no one talks about Edelman's catch and I thought it was going to get left off again here, but this guy gets it.
Yeah, probably gets left out bc it's just a boring tip drill like hundreds of other Hail Mary passes.😅 These are supposed to be about incredible technique and concentration
Jules saved all us pats fans by surpassing David Tyree. He's our goat WR
that is crazy
I’ve actually met David Tyree in New Jersey at a private Christian school where is son was. I didn’t really get so say anything to him but I knew I recognized him.
Justin Jefferson’s catch was that but he grabbed it out of the defenders hands with 1 hand
Bro that was crazy
naw.. tyree was number 1 can’t argue it. hardest of them all & most meaningful..
this guy is definitely a patriots fan
The George Pickens catch was good
Beckham ⬆️1
I remember just being in elementary school and everyone was talking about Odell’s catch
Welp guess the immaculate reception died this should be titled iconic catches
Lynn Swann’s superbowl…y’all know what I’m talking about!
Imaculate reception
I notice it's amazing the 2 best ever moss and rice not even on the list amazing they made the position look so easy there never was a difficult catch
Youd think jjjetas is on here but dude has something against him
I'm a steelers fan I was shocked when San tonio homes just head toped 3 people
#5 could have been a crazy head top
You probably forgot about that one Deandre Hopkins catch 🫢🏈
Justin Jefferson and George Pickens left the chat
They were in the bottom 5
They were in the first part of this
but still Justin Jeffersons catch was better than #2
@@hr_wiffleball_6509cap the db held the ball in place for him to catch it
These are definitely some catches of all time
Odell’s is one no questions asked
I mean, the top three were good catches in the situation, but Odell Beckham had overall the best catch
Feel like you looked at the stakes more than the catch.
Mario manningham catch in the sb should be up their to
As a cardinals fan we're not allowed to talk about that in my house, ..you will be grounded for 43 days..
Justin Jefferson left the chat
He stated he wasn’t going to include Justin Jefferson because he said that the dolphins receivers catch was way harder
Immaculate reception left the chat
OBJ deserves to be higher, that’s the most iconic catch I’ve seen in my life
Immaculate reception is feeling a bit left out.
I feel like the giants have the most miracle catches because it's just like their season it's a miracle if they win 7 games
I would put julian edelman's super bowl catch at 4 and move everything up, this isn't about the circumstance, it's about the catch.
the catch left the chat
It’s crazy how shops catch against 3 ppl isn’t on here
LETS GO THE GIANTS GOT TWO OF THE BEST CATCHES
The fact that JJs catch is not on this list proves that that this list isn’t valid. That obj catch is great, but no where in the same hall part as JJs