Video není dostupné.
Omlouváme se.
Aadujeevitham review | This is a masterpiece!
Vložit
- čas přidán 15. 08. 2024
- Movie Name: Aadujeevitham: The Goat Life (2024)
Director: Blessy
Writer: Blessy
Story: Benyamin
Cast: Prithviraj Sukumaran, Amala Paul, Shobha Mohan, Jimmy Jean-Louis
-----
Aadujeevitham, the movie we have all been waiting for is here, and it did not disappoint. Join me for me a detailed review of Aadujeevitham: The Goat Life. Let me know your thoughts in the comments section, and help me with some questions I had regarding some of the plot points!
#malayalammovie #mollywood #aadujeevitham #thegoatlifereview
---
No copyright infringement intended
Original video rightfully belongs to the owner
The video is for entertainment purposes only
COPYRIGHT DISCLAIMER:
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use.
To give you more context on how manual labourers were recruited and how the job visa was granted in places like Saidi Arabia:
1. The system is very repressive and old school unlike the merit based immigration quotas in the west. In places like saudi there will be a sponsor (also known as "Kafeel" which means owner i guess) for a work visa. The system strips off many basic human rights of the worker and many of the legal formalities in the country including extension of visa can only be fullfilled through the sponsor. There are lots of cases i heared the sponsor keeps all the documents of the workers including the passports to keep the complete authority over the workers to essentially make them work under them like slaves. Remmber the sponsor can be a saudi citizen or it can be a company/business.
Coming to the movie: in many cases Indian labourers go to middle east on temporary tourist visa, and visit the sponsor first, and later convert tourist visa in to a sponsored job visa. najeeb and hakim could have come under such visa on a promise of sponsor arranging the pickup at the airport, which didnt happen ( could be the real sponsor backed off, or may be there was no actual sponsor to begin witth meaning the person who sold the visa to najeeb in kerala was a fraud agent). I know many such instances from stories from distant relatives were the visa promised in a saudi company was fake, and they had to come back once the tourist visa period got over, some people also find alternative jobs while they are in the tourist visa period, where they convert the visa to work visa in within the timeline)😮
Omg.. mate.. thank you for this awesome information. Seriously it's the kind of information which I wish was told a little better in this movie (but perhaps it's explained in the book?). I'm so sorry that you're relatives had to go through that as well.
Honestly this movie showed the hideous behaviour of humans. The actions were inhumane.
Continued: the actual story happened in early 2000s or late 1990 (im not entirely sure) where there was limited connectivity between kerala and gulf in terms of travel. People heavily relied on hubs like mumbai to travel to first then fly from there to different parts of the world. Once upon their arrival at the airport in gulf, they were waiting for their sponsor to showup with their name called out or in a sign bord ( this was a widely used system in the pre internet boom era).
To answer ur question, Since Nobody showed up and they waited until it is very late (probably they were conned) and they wanted to make that call back home otherwise family gets stressed and no one had mobile phones and people litererally anticipate "safely landed" call with in 1-2 hour of the schedule arrival. People also relies on landlines in neghbour's homes in kerala since landlines were also rare. The arab villain also came searching for a guy (his actual sponsoree) and couldnt find him, so he saw these 2 indians which he consider as low class humans suitable for the job he had in mind. So he conned najeeb and hakim asking them to come with him, and najeeb and hakim thought this could be their actual sponsor and they blindly hopped on the vehicle..they must have thought, the worst that could happen would be taking them to a different part of the town were there will be a telephone to make the call they wanted to make so desperate, and also may be some food and place to sleep for the night if they are lucky. Also hoping on the back of the truck is not a socially and legelly looked down thing in many parts of India (but its changing these days). This is what i think happened, and rest is history.
@@D54pod its my pleasure mate..i love your work. This movie is so emotional for me because the way i can connect to the struggles of many manual labourers who went to the gulf to build a life. im from malabar, a region where i have seen the struggle of many najeebs. I am a post graduate having a decent job in one of the flashy cities in India thanks to the struggles of my father who had to come through some of the experiences like najeeb (not bad as najeeb's , i mean it a whole different extreme). My father had to be in jail for couple of months in saudi due to complications happened in his visa, and he was deported to India along with many people like him like Goats in a transport truck. This was years ago, and i remember being helpless sitting in India. He was deported to a random airport in india (his case, it was to lucknow) where he arrived with just his passport and just the cloths he was wearing, and not even having money to buy food or to book a ticket to kerala (lukcnow is 2500 km+ far from kerala). Now he is home, happily living in his home town in kerala running a shop. Im sharing this with you, to tell u the gravity of emotions a movie like this could create to many people in kerala
Wow.. I mean just wow. Thank you so much for taking the time out and writing all this up. I really appreciate it, and it's honestly the reason I love doing this. I've gained so much more of an understanding of the situation and then implications involved with this.
I'm really sorry to hear about your father mate. That's just devastating. I hope you and your family have recovered from such an incident. But I'm so glad this movie was made for the likes of Najeeb and your father who have also faced these terrible situations. I hope something is done to stop these atrocities. I now empathise even more than I already had after had seen the movie.
@@D54pod I dont think the visa agent was fraud. Because in the interview his wife said their relatives came late and by the time arab guy took them.
This is real story. Najeeb is still alive in Kerala
Yes, he sure is.
World class film from Malayalam..❤
This film deserves nothing less than an OSCAR AWARD..❤
you're right
No. Oscar deserves this movie. Not the other way around.
1:45 Actually atleast 90% of the population of Kerala would've been read the book..it's a really I mean REALLY famous novel in Kerala..!
Yes I remember hearing this when I did some reactions! Really glad it got turned into a movie!
Bro, Actually we learned this novel in our school education. It's a part of our school education syllabus. It's a real incident of a man named najeeb in abroad 2.5 years
Yep I had heard this was the case! I'm sure this will be a monster hit considering this.
Wow...❤ prithvraj's Best performance... ❤ Amazing movie...
I mean he was just on another level.. wow!
Malayalam cinema💎
Thank you for this review, particularly the heartfelt intro!
So I did see it this past weekend…I was so filled with joy to be able to see it in the theater . . . and then the film began.
Oh boy. Immediately I knew what was coming…and I felt my stomach tighten. I completely understood why these 2 went with that man. They were low wage laborers (his job before was diving for river sand!)…it’s implied that they did not have a higher education and were (I’m certain) the first time out of India. They were naive and, sadly, trusting of these “kaleefs” so took whatever they were told at face value.
It sickened me how easy it was to abduct both of them. Yes Najee probably could have taken him out but I also think a cultural deference for the “boss” came into play that eventually morphed into a classic case of Stockholm Syndrome.
So yes…almost from the first scene there was a deep feeling of dread of the fate of these two.
I do have to say that while I was astounded by Prithviraj’s physical and emotional performance…there were things that kept knocking me out of the film.
First and foremost off…I wasn’t that sold on the soundtrack & score. It seemed to pervasive, underlining/highlighting the tragedy unfolding that was quite evident with the need for (what I found) melodramatic music. There are times when I just wanted to hear his breathing and the vast unyielding drone of the desert wind. The score kept prodding me to feel a certain way in a way that became annoying over time.
The second issue I had is more difficult to admit to. Since 9/11 here in the US, Islamic and in particular Arabian culture have been portrayed in a narrow spectrum from inhumane terrorists to intolerant fanatics to uncivilized brutes. I hate these stereotypes but I, as a gay man, also do see a rather extremist component fixated on stamping out all not aligned with their beliefs. Hence I felt uneasy with how all (solely male) Arabian culture was portrayed, from sadistic to heartless. Even the one man who picks him up just plops him out on the streets then drives off.
I did enjoy this whole coda section as it allowed the audience along with the the character of Najeeb to ease back into civility. Though I was confused with the ultimate fate of the African Khadiri’s fate. He seemed the most robust and well equipment and pure of heart that it was just a shock that he would either (a) wander off to save himself or (b) succumb to the desert. I’m wondering if the book illuminates more on that.
Other than some pacing issue (as you and Kathy both mentioned) and some slightly wonky CGI, I agree that Blessy did a knockout job. And wholly agree that Prithviraj should definitely be up in the running for the National award as he fully committed…not just in his physical transformations but in his nuanced behavior, facial ticks and tears that flowed from deep within when he would encounter tiny moments of relief.
More to say…but will refrain :)
I am so glad you got to watch a Malayalam movie in cinema, and what a way to start! That's awesome. And of course, thanks so much for listening and giving me your input! Always a pleasure to get your perspective.
it's a good point on Najeebs education, I think the book actually goes into more detail as to why he was captured so easily and also why he doesn't attack his "kaleefs". It's still frightening how quickly and easily they were captured though. Part of it is also to do with respect for another man of Islamic faith, and also Najeeb accepting that this is the path chosen for him. As I mentioned, I wish the movie did a better job of making that make sense a little better.
I did overall like the soundtrack / score... but your points are very valid. I found that the case especially in the second half, through his journey in the desert. If I'm remembering correctly, it actually felt like a typical thriller, which didn't use the elements of nature as well as it could from a sound perspective. Not a major criticism for me, but I get your point for sure.
Yeah that point is a difficult one to balance. Admittedly I found myself hating the Arabs, and I think this movie was even banned in Arab countries (but that might have been a rumour). I didn't feel great about that, as I do think this grossly exaggerates how especially Men of Islamic faith are. I can understand for sure how uncomfortable that would be for others like yourself as well. I do know this was based very closely on the book, so I have to assume the book also does this. In fact I've heard that the actual kaleefs were much worse than what they showed in the movie!
I guess they just didn't know what happened to Khadiri’s. His role was so important, and watching him was just amazing.
Thanks for taking the time to respond!
@@D54pod …and thank you for both the video and your response as well!
Once I get settled in, I am looking into starting my own review channel… so I may be pinging you with some newbie start up questions 🙃
Hey! I'm sorry to only be getting back to you on this now! For some reason I don't get notified on responses. That's amazing, it would be awesome if you started a channel! When you do, hit me up on d54.podcast@gmail.com.. happy to help in anyway I can.
Looking forward to viewing your analysis!…will watch this after I watch it IN THE THEATER (finally am in a city with Indian cinema viewing options)
Yesss!! I can't wait! Glad to hear 👏
Prithvi said in an interview that there is a director's cut they plan to release when the movie comes out on ott and the duration is 3h 30m. I think the bond between Najeeb and the goats and many hard hitting incidents that is present in the novel would be explored more in that version. It's always a pleasure to hear your thoughts and analysis in such great detail man. Appreciate your love for Malayalam cinema. So much excited to see the film on the big screen tomorrow.
Wow.. honestly I cannot wait for that. It'll be hard to watch this again, but those extra details will just add so much. Thanks for the information as always mate.
Thanks for the kind words as well! Looking forward to your thoughts after you've seen it.
Watching this later tonight.. will drive back listening to this!
Can't wait bro!
They were informed that someone will come and pick them up. Waited for sometime and then they thought that was the person.
Very unfortunate.. it was literally a kidnapping
So glad you like the slow burn pacing of the movie, lot of people dont get that movies like these need that kind of screenplay
The slow burn of the first half perfectly compliments everything that happens in the second half. Perfectly balanced. Without all the set up and context in the first half, it would just be an typical survival thriller. It ended up being so much more.
Thanks for taking the time to comment!
Ayaalum njanum thammil is my favorite Prithviraj film. But Goat life is his career best performance. Resul Pookutty is an Oscar winning (Slumdog millionaire)sound designer.
I've seen very little of Pritviraj, but I this performance was just sensational. Looking forward to checking out more!
Rasool Pookutty is also an Oscar winner. He did the environment and ambient sound in the movie and ARR did the musical scores and songs...
Oh perfect, thanks for the info. I get the difference between the two now. Sound design is such an underrated part in the film making process!
Rasool Pookutty got Oscar Award for sound design in film Slumdog Millionaire in 2008
That's awesome! Thanks for the info mate.
Glad to know you loved it but bit sad it trumped Bhramayugam as your top film😊. Thank you for the mention mate. Ya indeed a great performance.
The book nd movie still haunting to me. I think thats enough to express. Great review as usual bro❤.
Yeah mate, it sure is haunting. Thanks as always for all the insights mate, much appreciated.
Andhar se koi baahar na ja sake ❤️
Novel writer is Bennyamin he met Najeeb in Bahrain ( Najeeb return to Gulf Bahrain after some years) from Bahrain Najeeb met friend of Bennyamin in American military camp were Najeeb , Bennyamin and common friend were working. Najeeb first told his story to common friend he introduce Najeeb to Bennyamin he was looking for Expat worker story.
Oh that's fascinating! Thanks for sharing!
Plz watch 'Ennu Ninte Moideen' film of Prithviraj and Parvathy....❤
Oh nice, I'll be covering another Pritviraj movie after those sensation as well!
Watch AYYAPANUM KOSHEEM - it is a prithvi raj movie that you should watch 🔥🔥🔥 it is about male ego
Yes I've heard a lot about this one. I'll have to put up a poll or something. There are quite a few good Pritviraj movies to check it out seems!
(1) The person who went through all this ( Najeeb ) said, at the airport the people who trapped him look for people like him who had no clue where to go, he was waiting for a person to pick him up for the job he was waiting for, so he went with them. (2) Najeeb could not move out from that place that place because the sound woke them up and their was another person who was keeping an eye on him on a vehicle at a certain distance. (3) Wherever he looked he could not find a road to move towards the nearest city. Check out the book Aadujeevitham in english , Najeeb has not even disclosed all he went through.
Yeah I was meaning to actually check out the book, unfortunately life got in the way :/... If I can find it, I'll check it out for sure!
Thanks for all the info! That's some great details which help fill in some of the blanks for sure!
@@D54podEnglish version of the book is called "The Goat Days".
I agree that he felt passive when he first arrived at the camp and that did feel frustrating. But by the time the broken glass scene plays out, he's already experiencing Stockholm syndrome. This is more thoroughly explored in the novel but thats whats happening where he's already empathazing with his captor. A glimpse of this can also be seen when Hakkim tells him that they can escape and Najeeb's first response is "Escape? Its too far, too difficult" or something to that effect.
i read this book (i live in california btw) and i have NO ONE to talk about the book with. so, imma see this movie in a couple of hours and get back to this comment because i don't think he empathizes with his captor but accept that this is a trial that Allah has laid out for him. Najeeb's faith is what he clings to while he is going through this hell. i wonder if the movie will show this.
@@shelly_lee perhaps empathises is the wrong word to use. But I don't know which word to use to describe what happens when someone experiences Stockholm syndrome. Its a feeling of helplessness. It's a hopeless feeling that you have towards your abuser. This is what I meant.
But also, yes his faith is an integral part of who he is. It's one of the core themes of the novel. He goes through a period of time where he even questions if he should continue to have faith.
I'm not gonna ruin it by saying how the movie tackles that. But definitely watch it! A visual treat that deserves a theatre watch. And do return to this comment to share what you thought!
I'll also not say too much as I don't want to ruin the movie, but I can definitely say you're both onto something! Would love your opinion @shelly_lee especially around the spiritual aspect.
@@D54pod ok i am back from the movie and first of all HOLY CRAP!!!!! the dude who played Najeeb was AMAZING! at the start of the movie he protrayed vulnerablity, sweetness, and big brother energy. i wanted to protect him from everything evil in the world. i liked that the movie focused on his struggle. it touched on everything else that was said in the book but the main focus was on Najeeb and the actor understood the freaking assignment. Najeeb's spirituality was expressed through song and what an amazing score. Allah sent Ibrahim to Najeeb (my take on that) as well as those who helped him along his journey. i knew what was going to happen and i STILL cried! hats off to the director for that cause those tears of mine were earned. the thing that sold me most on this this film was the performance of Prithviraj Sukumaran. i would love it if hollywood snatched him up for tons of leading roles but then India would get all mad and then wars would break out and that would be bad.....so how about a loan?☺favorite of movie of 2024 so far.
Hey @shelly_lee thanks so much for getting back to this comment! I'm so glad to enjoyed it, and looks like it held closely to the book. Yeah like I said in my breakdown, I think Pritvirajs performance was one of the best I've seen and it's exactly for what you mentioned. He showed vulnerability perfectly.
The character of Ibrahim, he was just amazing and such a great performance as well. For a lot of movie I actually was debating with myself whether he was real or not. To show that level of mental and emotional fortitude in such distress was just remarkable.
I think Pritviraj is doing more movies in India, but yeah it would be awesome if he got a good opportunity in Hollywood as well!
Oscar loading to 🇮🇳 ❤
🌹
I believed he was jailed for 3 months and not 3 years
Yeah I think you're right... I'll have to relisten to what I said but if I was wrong thanks for correcting!
movie was dissatisfying for me pls read the novel expecting a review of novel available in english also you will get why the movie lacks detail and will never connect to foreigners who don't have context to indian immigrant workers in gulf. film could've surpassed film cast away easily. what a waste of all efforts. its like ponniyin selvan were you only enjoy it fully if u read the book.
I think many people are afraid to say it out openly thinking they will insult the real life Najeeb. you will understand only if you read novel after watching film. to judge each separately
Interesting.. I haven't read the book, if I can get a physical copy I can check it out for sure. I understand the frustration however as books, especially ones like this one where not a lot happens, are particularly hard to translate to movies.
I do agree however that there could have been background information about the migrant crisis, especially considering the international / pan-Indian marketing approach of the release.
❤❤❤
❤️