Unpopular Starkid Opinions
Vložit
- čas přidán 6. 09. 2024
- Which opinions did you agree with? Which did you hate? Let me know below!
-
This is not what I usually post, but I thought it would be fun. Let me know if you all like it.
-
Check out Starkid - they make some amazing shows: / starkidpotter
-
Check me out elsewhere if you’d like:
Insta: (follow me here for sneak peaks of my video edits): / allofthefan. .
tumblr: findingfandomwi......
--
Made with:
iMovie
Documents 6
--
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use.
The Night Belongs To Snarl is criminally underrated
Some noob with a channel THANK YOU
You’re welcome, fellow Night Belongs To Snarl stan
@@happymilk7433 definitely!
Think the most underrated song
it’s the best song in Firebringer and my favorite
Adding to 11, I always feel like fans seem to care more about the vocal performance than the quality of the songwriting and musical arrangement.
i feel thats just because most people don't understand like music composition and everything. i know at the start i didnt, and even now that im getting into the more technical elements of the show, a lot of people watching just want to enjoy some great singing. but i still totally agree, i wish the musical arrangement and songwriting were appreciated more
Ashley Rio I don’t rly know anything about song arrangements or like ANYTHING technical but I get what u mean Yh it should still be appreciated more
I agree that AVPM isn't their best show, its just the nostalgia kicking in. Maybe if they had more time and a bigger budget it would have been better.
It was also technically one of their first ish shows that jad a big big following they were still in college and had much to learn so seeing them improve later with AVPS is good cause it just shows how they are learning from their past and developing a style
Darren being a part of it is one of the reasons its so loved, damn that G.L.E.E
Although I do mostly agree with 12 I think that tgwdlm defintly does a better job of balancing the two and by what we've heard Black Friday looks even more promising!
Elizabeth klaers tgwdlm is really my one exception to this opinion. I found the musical interesting, thrilling, unexpected and hilarious. I think revitalizing the cast and using a new musical format, the horror musical, really allowed that show to thrive so much!
@@perfectlyinept4062 I defintly agree! I hope all the other hatchetfeild musicials in the future follow in similar but new steps and succeed just as well!
As somebody who used to be uninterested and maybe even dislike musicals, my opinion completely changed when my boyfriend introduced me to Starkid through tgwdlm.
I absolutely *adore* it and have fallen in love with Starkid, and I'm so glad I was introduced to them through it because I probably wouldn't have watched any of their musicals otherwise. So far I've only watched tgwdlm and twisted, but I can't wait to watch Black Friday (as soon as it comes out!!) as well as Firebringer and Trail To Oregon (when I have the time).
In my opinion, I feel that Black Friday has the opposite effect for 12. It can be funny at times, but a solid 75% of the jokes are references, to the point where you wouldn’t really understand it if you hadn’t seen tgwdlm
Finally, someone agrees that AVPS is better than the others!
Litterally same
I thought that was the general consensus but i guess not
@@val8869 I also thought it was the consensus
I think it’s the best of the Potter trilogy too!!
Heck ya!
Tiffany's voice in The Night Belongs To Snarl is so beautiful
I know! She is so underrated, but her voice is absolutely stunning! I need her to be in more starkid shows
@@ash-fz3tw yes!
For 12, I would like to argue The Guy Who Didn’t Like Musicals is an exception
Miya Valdehuesa also Black Friday now
I’ve BEEN saying that Starship and Twisted are the best! They have it set up where they have characters that are both really funny and well-written. I feel like other shows tend to make their characters too simple because “it’s a comedy!” Also, they both have Dylan and Meredith as a romantic duo and they just work so well together, especially vocally. Their voices mesh so well.
Disneyfanatic THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU
I definitely agree that they’re the best shows but I wouldn’t say they’re my favourite shows
My only problem with starships is that it's 3 hours and half and only has 10 songs (all of them are so so good, but the musical feels too long because of the lack of songs)
I so agree
I don't really think Emberly's painting should be very beautiful, because Grunt literally just invented painting, and thus does not know shit about techniques or anything
He may not know shit about painting techniques, but he sure does know about shit painting techniques amirite?
We deserve a "You Gotta go" official version without farts!
YES
*yes*
Absolutely.
And your wagon’s on fire without the random “mud on your dick”
Yes i think i would enjoy the songs more
Don't mind me~~~
- Granger Danger is a wonderful song, but it's overrated.
- The Dragon Lullaby is super sweet, and it gives us a little insight of Harry and how he feels about being a famous boy.
- They handled JJ's suicide attempt in ANI super well.
- Work To Do is VERY overrated, and gets annoying after a while.
- Holy Musical B@man and ANI have the best music in terms of underrated-ness.
- Molag is the best character in Firebringer.
- The foreshadowing in the Independence song is tremendous.
- Mariah's voice is beautiful, but Not Your Seed isn't a great song.
- Holy Musical B@man is the best musical in terms of costumes and creativity.
- Twisted is the second best Starkid villain song (first one is Kick It Up A Notch because nobody can beat Dylan and his badassery of holding his hands up in puppet mouths for over ten minutes while singing)
Twisted isn't a villain song
@@theimplications635 It has a bunch of the Disney villains singing, so...
Abby Ray Newth yeah, but it’s about how they aren’t villains and the main singer is Ja’far, who isn’t the villain of the story
JJ's attempted suicide in ANI is the second best acting performance Starkid has done (second to Dylan's whole performance in Twisted). It's both funny and heartwrenching at the same time, something nearly impossible to do.
The dragon lullaby makes me feel so many things I love it
i think im the only one who loved the entirety of the tto fart joke, probably because i see joey in the corner and cant forget that face
When it kind of starts to bother me, I remember it’s actually just Joey blowing raspberries off stage and having the time of his life. Makes me crack up every time
No one ever seems to talk about Starship it makes me so sad
Fred Pertrench Its such a good musical and most people ignore it. Starship is a beauty, and my personal favorite.
probably bc there’s not as many songs and only a few of them REALLY slap, but i still love it and it’s one of my favorites
Same here. It's my favorite StarKid musical.
Ikr?! It has some wonderful character arcs and I adore it
Yeah, I'd say Starship is definitely the most underrated SK show by far.
'HMB is the most underrated show'. two seconds later: 'Starship and Twisted are the best shows'
Loes just because it’s underrated doesn’t mean it’s the best
Not necessarily an unpopular opinion but an uncommon one ig. I feel that Robert Manion definitely deserves all the love that he gets but it's mostly for the wrong reasons. Lots of people love him because he plays funny characters and not because he's genuinely a fantastic actor and singer and dancer. He has a more clear and dynamic voice than some of those on Broadway. I think he honestly stands out because he puts so much effort into character *and you can tell.* The reason people love his characters is because of all the love he puts into playing them and he deserves more recognition for his technique and talent rather than just the people he's playing *In this essay I will*
To be honest, I think that Robert Manion is too much overrated in the Starkid fandom lol.
this aged... interestingly
I think Joe Walker is the best Character actor in Starkid
He just becomes his role and a lot of the time I don't see Joe I just see the character
Like there have been times I didn't even realize it was him until it was pointed out to me
I totally agree with 6. Dylan made me cry in Twisted and has such an incredible range, and Jaime is hilarious in every role she plays and needs to be a lead soon
And nobody but like 10 people say it and it always gets me. I love Jaime sm and she doesnt get the love she deserves even if shes one of the funniest actresses in starkid
About the firebringer romance, i've always read firebringer as being very poly positive. And tbh i feel like jamila having all those husbands and wives, while still loving zazzalill really supports this.
My point is, jamila and zazzalill are wives and keeri and zazzalill are girlfriends
Yeah, Ani had a pretty unfortunate set up. The show is funny of course but:
1. The style (both structurally and musically) is so incredibly different from any other Starkid show. It was bound to alienate some fans. The whole idea is interesting but very strange, even for Starkid: Star Wars in the style of a 90's Chris Farley movie. It's not much of a surprise that some Starkid fans didn't really latch on to it.
2. The decision to have the songs performed offstage by the band didn't do the score any favors. The music is actually pretty good, but it just doesn't have much of an impact. It's much more effective to hear the characters sing the songs, rather than hearing them come from disembodied offstage voices. If you look at the amount of plays Starkid songs have had on Spotify, pretty much the entirety of Ani's (very solid) score is sitting at the bottom of the list. That's a real shame honestly.
3. The show was presented in rep with Trail to Oregon, with the inevitable result being that fans would compare the two shows and one would end up being much more popular than the other. Obviously, Trail to Oregon (which is one of my favorites) ended up taking off as a Starkid favorite while poor Ani was left in the dust. For example, the videos for both musicals came out about 4-5 years ago. Currently, Ani has about 708,000 views. By comparison, Trail to Oregon has almost 2 million.
4. As the video pointed out, Oregon also had the benefit of having several fan favorites in it like Jeff, Jamie, Joey, and (of course) Lauren, the darling of the Starkid fandom. Ani had a larger cast that consisted of some lesser well known Starkid members, so people might have been more drawn to the cast of Trail to Oregon.
5. TTO also had a more traditional structure, a fun interactive element that encouraged repeat viewing, etc. Etc. Notice that since the summer of 2014, Starkid hasn't done any more shows in rep. This is probably because they want to avoid what happened with Ani.
Having the band sing instead of the actors really was a risky thing to do, but I actually love it because we get to hear Clark sing and he has such a great voice, I can listen to Long Ago And Far Away forever. But I totally agree with your points and and it's really sad to see how few people can deal with change (as in like a show that is very different from the others).
I definetly agree but I also think it's why it has a special place in my heart, for the originality, I personally think it's really good and it's very underrated
I totally agree. Ani is one of my favourite shows, and it makes me kinda sad that people dislike it that much because is different(? (I mean, I get it if you dislike it for different reasons lmao). I think it's a good show overall, not the best, but is not the worst.
I think we should appreciate more the effort and originality of this show. We are introduced to some awesome voices that are different and new (Clark, Pierce, Meredith in the background. Talkfine does a great job in the show).
Some comedy-puns that we are kinda familiar with (HMB) but that it doesn't feel rushed since is part of the character (and the comedy is not only that).
Since Talkfine is the one doing the music, we can appreciate more on the acting and dancing of the actors, which is brilliant.
Idk why I did this but ok
I wanted to write something in the comments like “I agree, but...”.
Then I saw everyone else’s comments above me and all I can say is:
-Ani is one of my favorite Starkid shows.
- and I agree.
😂
YES! "The night belongs to snarl" is SO slept on and it is a God - tier song!
I KNOW RIGHT?
also I want to see more Tiffany. Tiblin was one of my favorite characters in fb.
I pretty much agree with everything in this video. I will add: although Firebringer is definitely not the best starkid show, the soundtrack is the most listen-able to me and has some of starkid's best songs (HMB close second)
Firebringer I think is hands down the most beautiful soundtrack starkid has. The harmonies are so perfect! My personal favorite soundtrack overall is TGWDLM ... I sing the damn songs all the time Jeff Blim is prob one of my fav lyricist because TTTO is my second!
The composition on Firebringer is better than any other Starkid show. Meredith and Mark truly understood how to use the female voices in the cast, and they also understood that harmonies can completely MAKE a song. It's just a beautiful soundtrack with real musical education behind it.
Twisted has BY FAR the best lyrics of any Starkid show. The songs are catchy as hell, and there are so many layered jokes/references in them that it never gets old listening to the soundtrack. There's always something new to pick up on.
Unpopular opinion: Black Friday wasn’t particularly strong in terms of writing, and the songs weren’t as memorable as previous shows. Also the way it was filmed didn’t really sit well with me. I still enjoyed myself, but as a fan from day dot it was a little disappointing.
Jamie's acting, singing and comedy is the best of all Starkid actresses, but Lauren gets the most praises, because she gets bigger and more relatable roles.
i absolutely love jaime, shes so talented and she definitely deserves more lead roles. however, lauren doesn't just get praised bc she gets big roles, she gets praised bc shes plays them well.
Lauren gets more praise because she is the best comedic actor of the entire troupe. Jamie's vocals are better and she's a great actress, but Lauren is definitely funnier.
My issue with ani lies in the costumes, while nearly everything else is great, the fact that people are waking around in onesies and Halloween costumes is legitimately distracting and put me off the show for the longest time
Number 8 - what are you talking about that painting was God-tier
someone who understands why AVPS is so good
I nearly threw my phone in agreement on number 13. Starship and Twisted are the best starkid musicals.
I like how no one mentions TGWDLM here because for some reason almost everyone has the same opinions about it
I think I agree with all of these, except I'm not so sure that Jaime is even in my top five Starkid singers. I think it's because everything she sings is very dramatic and over-done, because she obviously has some serious vocal chops (Join Us and Die, like woah) but in songs like The Night Belongs to Snarl, you can hear that she's not really singing with her real voice. She tends to sing in her throat and let the vibrato take control; which works when she's trying to be silly, but it's not the most pleasant vocal tone to me. I really hope we get some more vocals from her in Black Friday like we did in TGWDLM, because I think she has the talent and is probably a very good singer; they just give her really crappy characters to show off her "serious" voice. She really is one of the best actors in Starkid though, I definitely agree on that one.
and I should say that this is all personal opinion; singers like Cher, Celine Dion and Shakira are all very popular and have super throaty tones to their voices, so some obviously people must really like that tone. It's just not my individual "flavor", and that's why Jaime isn't at the top of my own list; not because she's a bad singer
That's how I feel about Jeff too, he has a good voice but he does the over the top inflections as part of the characters and it's just too much for me.
@@sarahkinsey5434 Honestly that's how I feel about Joe Walker too. Dude has a good voice but it often just gets lost under the character he's playing. Spies are Forever actually let him sing nearly straight and it was great.
It seems like Jaime either sings really deep, even for her range, or really girly and high like when she was Candy in HMB or during some parts of Join Us And Die. She really shone in Starship though, especially in Kick it Up a Notch
Esther Schick we get to hear their natural voices in Jim and the Povolos, and I love it! I just listened to them again, and I fell in love all over again!
Thank you!! Finally someone who thinks that a Very Potter Sequel is better than AVPM!
Bruh the entire fandom thinks this.
I've just gotten into Ani all these years later. Chris Allen is a gold mine who I really which had done more work with the company not to mention Nick Lang. The songs are good, but on a deeper level not on a comedy level. I'm probably responsible for 1/2 the listens to Back on Top on Spotify because of how much I love that song.
Unpopular opinion: Jeff Blim's voice is not super good. Idk I just dont like his vibrato (I'm sorry)
Fr his chest voice is so much better, i didnt really lije his voice in tgwdlm bc of it
I don't really like his voice at all :(
I personally love it because it works so well for comedic or bouncy scenes. What Do You Want Paul and TGWDLM opening wouldn't have been anywhere near as good without the crazy falsetto. And when he sings in his chest voice it's beautiful, like in When the World's at Stake and America Is Great Again
@@CantDraw-bq6pj i can see your point and i agree but that one part in tgwdlm opening when he uses it its just not it but i can see in some instances it would be funny
I'll do you one worse... I don't think he's funny. And since his voice sucks and I think he's not funny, it's a double whammy.
“Starship and twisted are the best starkid shows” isn’t even an unpopular opinion, it’s just facts.
Tbh, Starship just has a great story structure and amazing concept that's why it worked out really well and is my all time favorite musical Starkid did. All of the songs keep replaying in my head especially Kick It Up A Notch and its reprise. It's something you see on a Broadway show that wins like 3 Tony's. And also because of the concept and the story structure, it can be presented in different mediums of entertainment too like animation (like the animatics Mak did here on youtube), comics, novels, etc. just fine and it will still turn into a masterpiece (it just depends how directors and writers execute it). And also, how could I forget the worldbuilding established beforehand? You can explore it more too like Junior's family relationship, how Megagirl was created, Taz and Commander Up's backstory, the robot war, the farm planet Tootsie grew up in, and so many more. Ughhh I can't stop gushing about how great it is!!!
Haha 16 has been my unpopular opinion for a long time I'm so glad to know someone else agrees with me. Along with the higher production quality for me I think it comes down to the way they blend the plots of the first, third, and fifth books so well. Replacing the troll on Halloween with Lupin in the shrieking shack. Discovering the mirror of Erised and meeting Sirius at the same time. The blending of the stories is just done so well. Like umbridge being the one who sentences Sirius to death makes so much sense to me I often forget it isn't actual potter canon.
When you compare AVPM to AVPS in this aspect, AVPM seems like it is sort of just a thrown together/ hap hazard mixture of books 4 and 7 (with maybe some 6).
Wow. I’ve never agreed with a starkid related video this much.
I think Twisted was the first musical where they truly balanced the comedy and drama really well. There were still parts where the jokes seemed forced, but it truly is a professional level show as far as the writing goes, and Dylan is absolutely PHENOMENAL
Honestly, 14 - 16, 100% true cause every time I say to myself "I feel like watching AVPM" I watch the sequel 🤷♀️
JUNE 👏 SAITO 👏 APPRECIATION 👏
My unpopular opinions:
*I found Firebringer boring
*I love the song Inevitable but I was kinda disappointed with TGWDLM's ending
*Jamie's a great singer but a lot of the characters she does really annoy me
*Commissioner Gordon in Holy Musical B@tman annoyed me too
Oh, I have some unpopular opinions
• TGWDLM is extremely overrated. It has great songs and a storyline sure, but it pales in comparison to Twisted, Starship, and even a very Potter Sequel
•AVPSY deserves more love, but since they didn't have a lot of time to rehearse it's considered rather low in people's rankings. It has a really beautiful ending and all of its songs are phenomenal.
•Work to do is now that song people like ironically. Unlike Show Stoppin' number which is truly overrated. Don't get me wrong, I love it. But it overshadows songs like "what do you want Paul?" And "Join us and Die". And that's just in TGWDLM
•Firebringer's songs are great but get the lower end of the stick due to its mediocre comedy. It has better songs than the TTTO (mostly) but its story is just rushed after act 1
•Merideth is a better Hermione than Bonnie. Avpsy doesn't count because that was literally her first time even playing that role. With the small amount of time she was given to rehearse it's no wonder why she'd be mediocre in that sense. She does a much better job in the Starkid Reunion.
•(Not really unpopular) but A.J Holmes needs to be in another Starkid show. He was in MAMD and AVPSY. Plus he did the Twisted Demo but that was it.
I disagree a lot with the Hermione one, Bonnie was epitome of Hermione and I believe that she’s actually Hermione a lot more than I do with Meredith. Don’t get me wrong I adore Meredith, I just prefer her so much more as Jemilla, Megagirl and Scheherazade
THE LAST ONE!!! I dont see much opinions on A.j., but bRO HE IS SUCH AN AMAZING SINGER AND ACTOR. I hope we'll be able to see him in future shows, even a small part would be ok!! Also, Jamie 1000000% needs a main part.
Dude, I showed the very potter triology recently to my dad and he liked Meredith's Hermione better, I was shocked bc thats usually the other way around lol
AVPM deserves some credit it was their first musical and their budget was 150
I've watched firebringer three times probably. I find it to be more charming than funny or dramatic. Like there are so many good things about it, but also many bad things, and they don't balance each other out, so I'm just left a bit indifferent. But I like it, and Climate Change is criminally underrated.
However, I think the one thing that really kills Firebringer is the timing of the jokes. Some of them just kept going on forever, making me groan at times.
1. Agreed, and I don't think that's unpopular, I've heard that before.
2. I don't really ship Zazzalil and Keeri enough to want them to be a main couple, but I definitely agree that there should have been more Jazzalil build up. I mean, as funny as it is, Zazzalil's "Wait you're gonna hold me to that? ... Okay, I'm into it." is the least romantic way to start a relationship.
3. I'm gonna (politely) stop you right there, and remind you that Ani exists.
4. That's correct.
5. Yeah, and you're not alone on that.
6. I don't know, man, sometimes I feel like every Starkid actor is the best Starkid actor, you know?
7. I've honestly never thought about it in that way, but it checks out.
8. Haha, you're right.
9. Yeah, I think everyone felt that.
10. Okay but I still feel like it's good enough to deserve more regonition than it gets. I mean the acting is great, Clark fucking delivers, and it has that trademark Starkid humor mixed in with super touching moments (they handled suicide better than 13 Reasons Why, in a comedy).
11. True.
12. Never thought about it, but I think that may just apply to TTO and Firebringer, TGWDLM is certainly one of Starkid's darker shows.
13. Twisted is definitely in the top two if not best, but while I love Starship to pieces, even Nick Lang has said it's their worst show (which I disagree with but still, what a hot take on your part).
14. Re-fucking-tweet.
15. Yup, and it makes sense, it was their first show (I mean unless you count the Lord of the Rings parody or whatever).
16. I agree, though I feel like AVPSY gets more hate than it deserves.
adding to 2, keeri heavily mimicks zazz throughout the show, which is something people with crushes can sometimes do so 😳😳😳
I think A Very Potter Senior Year is criminally underrated and doesn't get enough love because it's a staged reading. I think they handled having scripts and a voice over for most set extremely well. Even playing off of it. It takes true talent to take those situations and still make a spectacular show! Also, the songs are still ridiculously amazing. "When I Was" from that show is arguably one of their most beautiful and heart wrenching songs. Joe Walker is right up there with Dylan in my opinion. Probably even better than Darren Chris.
My most unpopular opinion: tgwdlm has a great plot, but overall has the worst songs out of all of them. Half of them I forgot existed, others are very simple or very repeating. Some (like show me your hands or showstopping number) are fun, but I would overall never play the soundtrack on its own
unpopular opinion: avpsy is underrated. personally it’s my favorite from the potter series, but maybe that’s just me. it was rushed and was used just as a final goodbye to the series, for closure, but the acting of many of the scenes and the singing in it shines through. it made me cry multiple times unlike avpm and avps and tied up loose ends and some of the characters’ flaws, at least bringing them to light
okay like, i agree with about 99% of these, but may i say: 13 IS SO RIGHT. JOEY IN STARSHIP MADE ME A TRUE FAN OF STARKID HONESTLY AND TWISTED MADE ME CRY AND I NEVER CRY.
finally an intellectual who realizes how great starship is
1. I get what you mean, I wish it had been slightly more of a dramedy, but I think the comedy it goes for is solid, just not fantastic or anything
2. I feel like that wouldn't make sense for the overall philosophical arc, and that a relationship with Keeri would have a power imbalance due to her willingness to do what everyone tells her to - she'd have to undergo a character arc about learning to be her own person before even being in the running. Plus, the combo of Zazz and Jemilla reflects the leadership styles they learn to use.
3. yes, wizard god, yes
4. MAMD comedy is highly underrated and fucking spectacular but for me nothing will ever beat the AVP series in comedy
5. yes. it's really funny, especially once you realize it's a parody of the whole ancient aliens thing, but it is so out of left field. I heard once in an interview that Nick Lang was worried it would be "too obvious" and I was like WHY
6. fair and valid. I have a bias here bc of my long-standing crushes on Lauren Lopez and Joey Richter.
7. Y E S
8. bold of you to assume it wasn't a good painting (jk I get what you're saying but the artist jokes are so quality)
9. absolutely. 10/10
10. I mean yeah, it was never going to be a more popular musical, but I wouldn't say it failed. It just didn't get as popular as the rest - it's still a fantastic musical.
11. yessssss
12. fair. I feel like this balance is what made the AVP series so good. Firebringer was sort of the last one with that good good balance - it's hard to take TTO seriously with the imbalance between drama and comedy
13. Yes to twisted, I don't particularly care for starship but I understand why you would
14. fair.
15. yes - they're close, but yes
16. yes. i fucking love AVPS
A million years later and Guys Like Potter is still my favorite song...
p-please,,,, just one keerilil content,,, we're starving,,,,
HufflepuffPrinxietyPhan do you have any songs you associate with them?
@@perfectlyinept4062 oh god,,, not that i can think of??
HufflepuffPrinxietyPhan well I’ll see if any pop up to me. Firebringer was not my favorite of their shows so I haven’t watched it many times, but I like Zaz and Keeri and would be down to put together an edit for them, more similar to my cmvs, if inspiration hit!
I really want to do Keerilil fanart now. I wish that they were the couple in the musical because what if is so gay and amazing and uHg
@@perfectlyinept4062 I associate a thousand years with them, however I do ship Jazzalil (don't kill me)
MAMD is soo underrated. Met AJ Holmes at the Edinburgh fringe this year. I was flyering and he past me and I GASPED. It’s Joey’s Heart!
It's such a great musical that gets slept on because it has starkid old cast
Mamd is my favorite
SO GLAD FOR ONCE SOMEONE SEES STARSHIP AND TWISTED AS THE GODS THEY ARE!!!
Also, in regards to Zazzalil, Keeri, and Jemella...After reading the comments, I have to disagree with everyone. Zazz and Jemella shouldn't end up together, and neither should Zazz and Keeri. From a writer's perspective, the show already had a love subplot between Grant and Emberly, so any other romance between other characters is redundant.
With Number 15, understand it was their first show, give them some credit. It could’ve been a total flop but when you think about it, it was well done especially for their first
DYLAN AND JAIME ARE THE BEST ACTORS I HAVE BEEN THINKING THIS FOR AGES
How did I never realise that paint how you see me has choreo inspired by famous paintings
I agreed with every single thing you had to say abt firebringer
All of this is so freaking true. The AVPS bit, the part about The Night Belongs to Snarl, the Twisted being one of the best shows, EVERYTHING!
13 made me so happy bc almost everyone says twisted is the best show, and i agree it’s amazing, but starship is my all time favorite and so many people look over it.
Yes! Twisted has always been my favorite show! It does such a good job of being laugh out loud funny but also having a great story with good drama. And I mean... Dylan.
Anyone else going through this just saying, "Yeah I agree" to everything?
I SO agree with 8! It would definitely be strange if Grunt was suddenly good at painting considering he had just invented it and didn't know any techniques, but can you imagine how sweet it would be that his love for Emberly made that one painting beautiful? Like, the one good painting of his is of the woman he loves?
4:55 EXACTLY! They're all great but the 2nd one is definitely my favorite
AVPM is definitely not the best show, but it's like reading old books (Like Harry Potter ;)) or listening to Michael Jackson. Sure, it has its flaws, but it feels nostalgic. It's a feeling people look for when trying to escape the newer and admittedly less popular plays.
1. I agree. Nothing else to say.
2. I don’t really agree with this one , but I’m not really good with pointing out developed relationships anyways.
3. Agreed.
4. I haven’t seen it, so I wouldn’t know, but from the clips I’ve seen it’s pretty funny.
5. I disagree, but I see where you’re coming from.
6. Completely agree.
7. Yep. When I first listened to it, I didn’t really like it, but I’ve realized it’s way better than I though before.
8. Agree, all the way.
9. I disagree, only because I have the humour of a six-year-old.
10. I wouldn’t know, I’ve never watched it.
11. Agreed.
12. I don’t really agree because I watched the newer one’s first, so I’m biased. (And I suck at picking out good comedy.)
13. I agree with the Starship part, but not Twisted. On my opinion, Twisted is really, really good, but not the best.
14. Totally agree.
15. Yep.
16. Mhmm. Definitely.
I completely agree with 13. Starship and Twisted have great stories, costumes, props, songs, and vocals. Plus Dylan...
I absolutely loved Twisted. The acting was phenomenal and the props, costumes and singing was equally as great!
Starship was truly a game changer, the improved quality was crazy and it really made me realize how legit their talent and productions are. Also I think it’s criminal how little people acknowledge Me and My Dick, I was dying laughing the first time I watched it.
The plot twust at the end of firebringer was so pushed. But jamies voice really saved it
Im watching avps right now and i can agree that it’s better than avpm, but i still love voldemort and quirrel’s storyline from the first one
YES Holy Musical B@man appreciation I love it so much
MAMD is the funniest starkid musical and that’s one perry’s hat
Yes, Twisted has some of the most powerful and beautiful songs but FIREBRINGER!!! I was amazed at how consistently good the arrangements, harmonies, and vocal performances of Firebringer’s songs turned out.
Honestly, the nostalgia is why AVPM is so loved. I don’t know what invokes the nostalgia, because I didn’t watch the trilogy until I was about halfway through the Starkid collection, starting with TGWDLM, but the nostalgia is really strong and the show could have been near on par with - dare I say - Twisted *gasp* if it had been made a little later in their careers with better production quality.
This is a list of painful but true Starkid facts.
I agree with 15 but I think that’s because of how new to it they all were. It was their first musical as Starkid, and it was also probably due to the filming as well
I think that Jemilla and Zazzalil both learned from each other how to be a really good leader. In my opinion, they should rule together, but not as a couple. They had chemistry several times, but not very much. Although I think that, Jazzalil isn't so bad to me. I have never thought about Keeri and Zazzalil, but you're right, they would be cute.
How are the Ani actors lesser known? Joe Walker, Nick Lang, Brian Holden, Meredith, Denise, Joe Moses, and Chris Allen had been in several of their previous ones, I know Eric was usually behind the scenes before but I loved him in it.
Úna Parkinson All had been in shows before but never really leads - Joey richter, Dylan Saunders, Lauren Lopez, Jamie Lynn Betty etc. Along with that there are only two (three w/ nick) original actors, actors that were in the first Very Potter. Not saying any of them are less talented, just potential less recognized.
@@perfectlyinept4062 Joe Walker has definitely been a lead and a fan favourite, but I see what you're saying. I think I sometimes leap to defend Ani a lot because it's one of my favourites and I hate how much hate it gets
IM MANY MONTHS LATE BUT THIS IS THE FIRST UNPOPULAR OPINION VIDEO ABT STARKID WHERE I AGREE WITH EVERY SINGLE POINT THIS IS SO VALID
Definitely agree with 13. No question about it. TGWDLM and Trail are the second tier to me
i think i agree with all of these opinions except for the fact that i actually like the humor in firebringer, and i think that the fart joke in trail to oregon got old very fast only because we watched it for like. five times in a row. if the character death had been the same in every show we probably wouldn't mind, so it must've been a lot funnier for the live audience
I agree with number one whole-heartedly, I often think about how amazing it would've been if they embraced ot as a drama
As an avid gbth fan, I have to agree. Quite frankly the reason we all love it is probably just the breakdowns at the end
1 i disagree with, just because it wouldn't have worked as a drama. it just wasn't funny. it should have been better written. 2 is completely true.
I totally agree with 11. The props and outfits are so well made and the backgrounds always look good. I think the people who helped create them deserve as much love as the actors😊
THANK YOU!!! the night belongs to snarl is sooo underated and it's one of my favorite songs
here a year later with my unwelcomed unpopular opinions
- firebringer does have some funny moments, but i wouldn't put it in the comedy category
- sands of time is *underrated*, it's short but it's so beautiful
- i find mamd uncomfortable to watch
- while i would've loved to see what mariah would've done with lex, angela was made for the role. if they did black friday again when everyone wasn't sick, i'm sure it would be even better
I completely agree with number nine, Jeff kinda saved it and made it funny again with the breakdancing joke but then it got old again. But at the same time it wouldn’t make sense for the farts to just stop after a little bit
I just thought of this and I want to document it before I forget. Rachael, Jeff, Jaime, Corey, and Lauren should do a 5 person version of You Gotta Go and maybe speed it up at parts and harmonize. In fact, I may try to write this lmao because I have nothing better to do with my life.
omg i thought i was the only one who thought #2 they literally hint so much to them having a relationship and then they throw it away at the end
I hva actually thought about 1 6 7 8 9 11 14 15 and 16 before and semi agree with a number of other ones, makes me happy that im not the only one that thinks these
YES YES YES STARSHIP AND TWISTED ARE THE BEST STARKID MUSICALS THANK YOU THANK YOU YES
The Night Belongs To Snarl is the only song from Firebringer I have on my "I probably won't skip this" playlist :)
13 is absolutely correct and no one can convince me otherwise
I think most people agree with most of these in their heart of hearts but don’t want to admit it
#6 is totally not unpopular! Been saying that from the beginning!
I ADORE AVPS above the entire trilogy and I’m glad I’m not the only one