Burke Lecture: John Shelby Spong

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 20. 08. 2024
  • A pre-eminent voice for liberal Christianity, John Shelby Spong was the Bishop of the Episcopal Diocese of Newark for 24 years before his retirement in 2000. His admirers acclaim his making contemporary theology accessible to the ordinary lay person-he's considered a champion of an inclusive faith by many both inside and outside the Christian church. His challenges to the church have also made him a target of hostility, fear, and death threats. Calling himself "a joyful, passionate, convinced believer in the reality of God," he seeks not to create a new religion, but to reform the church he loves. [1/2005] [Show ID: 9117]
    More from: Burke Lectureship on Religion and Society
    (www.uctv.tv/burke)
    Explore More Humanities on UCTV
    (www.uctv.tv/hu...)
    The humanities encourage us to think creatively and explore questions about our world. UCTV explores human culture through literature, history, ethics, philosophy, cinema and religion so we can better understand the human experience.
    UCTV is the broadcast and online media platform of the University of California, featuring programming from its ten campuses, three national labs and affiliated research institutions. UCTV explores a broad spectrum of subjects for a general audience, including science, health and medicine, public affairs, humanities, arts and music, business, education, and agriculture. Launched in January 2000, UCTV embraces the core missions of the University of California -- teaching, research, and public service - by providing quality, in-depth television far beyond the campus borders to inquisitive viewers around the world.
    (www.uctv.tv)

Komentáře • 612

  • @CyeOutsider
    @CyeOutsider Před 10 lety +58

    Its amazing to hear a man of faith be so honest and unflinching in his account of the dark side of religion. Too many Christians want to pretend it doesn't exist.
    The world desparately needs more of this kind of honesty.

  • @sequencerman5
    @sequencerman5 Před 10 lety +57

    Just a quick message ...John Shelby Spong has renewed my faith in Christianity. I SO admire this man!

  • @joebob1012
    @joebob1012 Před 3 lety +9

    “Scripture is a human creation by people who was seeking God but their humanity constantly got in the way.” - Bishop John Spong

  • @dpevjen
    @dpevjen Před 9 lety +37

    After spending a lifetime listening to hundreds of church sermons explaining how to live life based on some specific Bible verse along with a fair amount of sophistry, it's nice to get a breath of fresh air and hear a speaker who can clarify things into undeniable wisdom. That man is Bishop John Spong.

    • @johne6081
      @johne6081 Před 9 lety +7

      Daniel Evjen -- Spong appeals to listeners who are not afraid to think for themselves -- what a concept!

    • @scapegoatiscariot2767
      @scapegoatiscariot2767 Před 3 lety

      👍

    • @conradbulos6164
      @conradbulos6164 Před 5 měsíci

      Yes, Bishop Spong is indeed a rare jewel and stand out among his peers of todays's clergy, and a great voice for humanity too soon claimed and silenced by death.

  • @praveenpande4786
    @praveenpande4786 Před 9 lety +25

    I am not a christian but I can easy relate to Mr Spong's lecture, greatly appreciate his commonsense approach, makes one THINK

    • @Dishodiwaba
      @Dishodiwaba Před 4 lety +2

      Yes, and you share something in common: neither of you is Christian.

    • @scapegoatiscariot2767
      @scapegoatiscariot2767 Před 3 lety +4

      @@Dishodiwaba .
      I don't know what he would say to you about that but I agree with him on everything except God in Jesus being a good thing so, I would take what you said as a compliment.
      You stay with the bigots and the racists and The godly people. We will love them and help them when they flee from you. And they are - in droves.

    • @conradbulos6164
      @conradbulos6164 Před 5 měsíci

      Not being a Christian

    • @conradbulos6164
      @conradbulos6164 Před 5 měsíci

      How then do you manage to live and get along in a largely Christian world and among Christian friends or are you a Mus!im, Allah, be praised!? Living among Muslim brothers in Arabia or India?

  • @conradbulos6164
    @conradbulos6164 Před 9 měsíci +2

    Dear Bishop Spong, wherever you are, please know that you will be missed. You gave us the real meaning of Christianity and made us see Jesus in a new light and that we owe Judaism
    a deep sense of gratitude for being the spritual Mother of Christianity

  • @irvinmulholland697
    @irvinmulholland697 Před 10 lety +29

    Hey Chip, your statement is exactly the same thing I said about Jerry Falwell over 40 years ago. The irony is that as a teenager I had the extraordinary experience of living in a place and time where I had personal interaction with both Mr. Falwell (my mother was a charter member of his church) and Mr.Spong (I became a member of his parish) and I can tell you with complete certainty that John Spong is a fully realized spirit that speaks the truth. Nothing dangerous about it unless you are fearful of discovering the magnificent spirit that you are in essence. Should you prefer to continue living in fear (of ideas and/or everything) then the life denying legacy of Mr. Falwell's ideas would be the way to go.

  • @rockyj74426
    @rockyj74426 Před 12 lety +2

    How wonderfully comfortting it must be to have a mind so small that it doesn't have room to recognize that it is possible to "believe" while at the same time questioning and examining those beliefs. The N.T. was written in an attempt to make god understandable to First Century people who, because they knew nothing of germs, decided that if one was a leper it was because god was punishing him.
    Bishop Spongs new interpretations of the Bible in light of modern science are refreshing and spot on.

    • @conradbulos6164
      @conradbulos6164 Před 5 měsíci

      Why do you have the letter G in small letter of your god like He was not the God you believe in but others believe in?

  • @serbangheorghe
    @serbangheorghe Před 12 lety +3

    I enjoyed learning from Bishop Spong that after we get rid of the Terrrible Texts of the Bible, the ones used along history to justify so much cruelty, injustice and oppression, we can focus on the texts that reflect the Love of God.He `s an eloquent, dynamic, informed and persuasive speaker.

  • @jcpent12
    @jcpent12 Před 12 lety +1

    John Shelby Spong has given me the words, the confidence, the clarity, to finally articulate what I have truly come to believe these past 4 years of questioning. I am at peace with my existence, I am overflowing with love and appreciation of the depth of humanity, and I accept the gift of logic and reason and rationality that my creator has given me. I can finally live a genuine, rich life. Thank you Bishop Spong.

  • @inquiry10
    @inquiry10 Před 14 lety +3

    If more preached sermons like this there would be less hate in this world.

  • @gumpinwheeliebin
    @gumpinwheeliebin Před 16 lety +12

    Incredible! This man talks so much sense. I wish the whole world thought like he does!

  • @ilovemymum777
    @ilovemymum777 Před 12 lety +5

    If the Church was like this I would gladly go back :) This man is an honest True God faring Man and I could listen to him all day. Thank you John Shelby Spong

  • @paulducharme60oo
    @paulducharme60oo Před 7 lety +6

    If religion has caused such strife worldwide for so long,does it not behoove us to see that it is not the true way of love, nor the true way of God? Can we not witness His own truths?

  • @lukeism2
    @lukeism2 Před 14 lety +3

    i actually really like this guy - he isn't like most evangelists/apologists like bill craig and frank turek - basically politicians or defence attorneys for christianity - this guy is real.

  • @vanman724
    @vanman724 Před 2 lety +3

    RIP John. It was always apparent to me that you spoke the truth. Hope to meet you someday...

  • @robway888
    @robway888 Před 8 lety +16

    This is worth watching several times. Great truth. thank you

  • @pedrogonzalez7611
    @pedrogonzalez7611 Před 10 lety +6

    Beautiful, this is a calling to change christianity and make it more like Jesus.

  • @willowstarfeather
    @willowstarfeather Před rokem +1

    I’m watching this from Australia and I can tell you the climate here has changed since this was recorded. We are currently suffering from the cold and rain and not the heat. Last three years the La Niña has been bringing the rains. We have just had crops wrecked by rain.

    • @conradbulos6164
      @conradbulos6164 Před 9 měsíci

      Uh, Bro. Willow, in spite of the natural calamities your land has been suffering under, dont let yourself become a weeping willow
      But instead be steadfast in your faith and accept that what is happening is part of natural law
      and you just have to ride with it.

    • @conradbulos6164
      @conradbulos6164 Před 5 měsíci +1

      Sorry to hear of your climatic problems down there. My son is visiting there as a tourist. I hope he doesnt get sick because of your weather.

    • @willowstarfeather
      @willowstarfeather Před 5 měsíci

      @@conradbulos6164 four years la Nina now although the BOM is still saying it's a freaky el Nino. Probably too scared to say it's gotten colder not hotter. Only trouble is we haven't had many bushfires 🤣. It must be so frustrating for them. They have been hunting fires. There is one in VIC but the conspiracy theorist in me thinks it's deliberate because it's near farming land and I know those places burn off a lot and it can get out of hand etc. just do happens to be in a socialist state🤣. But houses have been lost which is always sad. I'm sick of the rain here though. The tropics are getting hammered by rain. Hope you son's not gone up there. Cairns and Tully area in Qld. But hey it happens up there.

    • @willowstarfeather
      @willowstarfeather Před 5 měsíci

      @@conradbulos6164 where is he. No I haven't heard of people getting sick in the rain. Flooding is another matter. Lots of germs in the soil and they get moved around. Best to stay away. I'm near Sydney. It's not too bad flood wise here just wet.

  • @badadebooper8922
    @badadebooper8922 Před 9 lety +3

    I removed my comment because to many people could not grasp the understanding of this situation. So rather than bring nonbelievers into the conflicts within the body, I decided to stop trying to explain things to those who do not have the common foundational understanding of Scripture. I apologize if I have offended anyone; however, I stand my my beliefs.

  • @GODTHESOOTHSAYER1
    @GODTHESOOTHSAYER1 Před 11 lety +2

    Mr. Spong has articulated the truthfulness of the immorality of faith belief in a way that has never been told ever before. His speech was amazingly forthcoming and enlightening. He's a great thinker and a tremendous human being.

  • @billydebianchi2046
    @billydebianchi2046 Před 9 lety +17

    This man makes Christianity come alive for me

    • @jehovahuponyou
      @jehovahuponyou Před 8 lety +3

      +Billy de bianchi THAT IS BECAUSE YOU ARE A REPROBATE.

    • @billydebianchi2046
      @billydebianchi2046 Před 8 lety +1

      ah ok. and you are who, god himself??

    • @jehovahuponyou
      @jehovahuponyou Před 8 lety +2

      +Billy de bianchi OH, NOT HARDLY, GOD HIMSELF HATES YOU AND SPONG.

    • @billydebianchi2046
      @billydebianchi2046 Před 8 lety +1

      Lol taking this from a guy who calls god jehova. Its yahweh idiot

    • @jehovahuponyou
      @jehovahuponyou Před 8 lety

      +Billy de bianchi HAR, HAR, HAR, HAR - WERE YOU ALSO DROOLING WHEN YOU WROTE YOUR POST?
      TELL ME SHITLOCK HOLMES, WHY DO YOU THINK I CALL THE LORD GOD JEHOVAH?
      WHERE DID YOU GET YAHWOWMAWPOWZOW FROM, GRAFFI FROM THE WALLS OF THE PROJECT YOU LIVE IN?

  • @blackiebori
    @blackiebori Před 16 lety +2

    "The Sins of Scripture challenges Christians to look beyond the myths of their faith into the heart of the matter. To some the book will be heresy, to others revelation. But above all it will make people think, which is just what Bishop Spong means to achieve." -Bill O'Reilly

  • @cjunk351
    @cjunk351 Před 15 lety +2

    I wish I had this guys literature when I was a christian. It may have helped rescue me from a lot of waisted time and effort. how much support does this guy get amongst christians nowadays?

    • @conradbulos6164
      @conradbulos6164 Před 5 měsíci

      Why is it important to you that Bishop Spong have the support of many? Do you appreciate quantity more than quality of content? Do you go by popularity as your gauge of faith?

  • @Lisarata
    @Lisarata Před 13 lety +3

    At MrMohjong What I've read of Spong is that he advocates for ending theocracy. He does not mean we have to give up Christ or God, but that we have to take our egos out of the picture.

  • @claudecasalini913
    @claudecasalini913 Před rokem +1

    Bishop John Shelby Spong
    I salute you❤

  • @larry2524
    @larry2524 Před 10 lety +6

    I believe he spoke very well without getting into mystical teachings on the inner esoteric meaning of Yahushua (Jesus) message. Very thought provoking!

  • @blackiebori
    @blackiebori Před 16 lety +2

    This man serves God by trying to make a world in which everyone can be loved, even those who don't seem deserving of it (Luke 6:27-29). I don't think one has to believe in a hell to get saved, that just produces more negativity in our developement as human beings. Rather, one must believe in the Kingdom of Heaven which our Lord said is within us (Luke 17:20-21). We must work very hard to produce the Kingdom from within us to a Kingdom around us (Matt. 13:33).

    • @conradbulos6164
      @conradbulos6164 Před 9 měsíci

      You are right, bro. Hell is what create for ourselves and no out side place of torment nor do we need to be saved for we were never lost as if God would allow that for his children.

  • @claudecasalini913
    @claudecasalini913 Před rokem +1

    What a great man Bishop Shelby is❤❤❤

  • @rockyj74426
    @rockyj74426 Před 12 lety +7

    THE GOSPEL OF JESUS CHRIST . . . "Love God with all your heart and all your mind; love your neighbor as yourself." This is EXACTLY what Spong is preaching.

    • @conradbulos6164
      @conradbulos6164 Před 9 měsíci

      Uh, Rocky, any command is abhorrent and repulsive to human nature even the command to love and even coming from Jesus. Maybe we should start saying instead.....It would be wiser to love
      God ........

  • @kbeldenkb
    @kbeldenkb Před 10 lety +9

    A beautiful sermon.

  • @louismartin4078
    @louismartin4078 Před 3 lety +2

    Bishop Spong takes us from the ground floor to the Love Level.

  • @mattmew28
    @mattmew28 Před 11 lety +2

    I think Spong is right on...and I think he gives a good point towards the end that it's really not productive to try to have a "conversation" with a fundamentalist that already has decided that their point of view is correct and therefore in line with God. By the comments/debates I see here, I think he is right. I'm giving up having "conversations" with such people. I wasted too many hours of my life. I'd rather spend my time learning how in my faith I can help improve the world around me.

    • @conradbulos6164
      @conradbulos6164 Před 9 měsíci

      Uh, Matt, that's why they are called fundamentalists cuz they are not thinking with their brains but with their fundaments aka butts.

  • @simonbattle0001
    @simonbattle0001 Před rokem +1

    Thank you John Shelby Spong.

  • @StephanieSoressi
    @StephanieSoressi Před rokem +1

    As usual, I agree with the late Reverend Spong; it must surely be the unforgiveable sin, to claim to be the Chosen, for it denies the Sacred Spirit in all.

  • @jodiewhittaker9700
    @jodiewhittaker9700 Před 5 lety +3

    Great Lecture.

  • @wilstarmbel
    @wilstarmbel Před 16 lety +1

    The main thing is that Jesus Christ is our saviour and i know and love him with all my heart and i thank God for revealing Jesus to me.
    God Bless
    had a bible study tonight with my close friends and my bro we read Mark 5:1-43.. Amazing.

    • @conradbulos6164
      @conradbulos6164 Před 9 měsíci

      Uh, Sister Wils, you,ve not been listning to Bishop Spong. He's been saying that Jesus did not come to save us from original sin
      cuz he doesnt believe in the Fall.
      He quotes Jesus as saying, "I have come that you may have life and have it abundantly"

  • @Jaybird196
    @Jaybird196 Před 11 lety +2

    I would not go back, BUT I certainly would've stayed far longer :) . Mr. Spong strikes me as a very good man, exemplary even. I think lots of people, religious or not, could learn much from someone like him.

  • @sgrannel
    @sgrannel Před 7 lety +2

    Thank you for acknowledging and addressing some of the points that atheists and other critics have rightly leveled at religion and more particularly the Bible. Human capacity for reason may be used for deducing that some ideas cannot possibly be true, and the hope is offered that religion might be moderated or improved. However, the burden of proof still rests on one who asserts that some sort of god actually exists.

    • @conradbulos6164
      @conradbulos6164 Před 9 měsíci

      Yes, Sgrannel, A God exists but who is outside the bible and not one who intervenes in human history out of respect for his gift of Freewill to mankind. He is the God of Christianity who speaks of love and compassion and mercy not the God of Christianity who advocates violence and revenge
      and cruelty.

    • @conradbulos6164
      @conradbulos6164 Před 9 měsíci

      Yes, God exists because you exist as his image and likeness. You are proof itself that God Is.

    • @conradbulos6164
      @conradbulos6164 Před 9 měsíci

      There are none so blind as those who have eyes but do not see nor minds so closed that refuse to understand.......

  • @colloredbrothers
    @colloredbrothers Před 14 lety +5

    I can feel truth when i hear it, this man talks it.

    • @Faltor895
      @Faltor895 Před 4 měsíci

      You've been deceived.

  • @blackiebori
    @blackiebori Před 16 lety +4

    I love the part in Mark 5:9-13, when Jesus was ready to have a conversation with Legion. It's funny how Jesus doesn't send the demons straight to hell, but he takes compassion on them and grants their request to go into pigs. Most exorcists, like John Constantine, are ready to have a brawl with their demon apponent, but Jesus did no such thing, he's one of a kind!!
    God Bless!!!

    • @conradbulos6164
      @conradbulos6164 Před 9 měsíci

      Now why would demons be afraid to go to hell since that's where they belong? And what did the pigs do to deserve such evil burden?

  • @Jexka007
    @Jexka007 Před 16 lety +2

    Spong is offering a suggestion of what the coming of Christ was about. Jesus didn't represent any of the destructive scriptures in the bible. His message was to be able to walk with your neighbor with love and acceptance no matter what race, religion, or sexual orientation they are. Spong is explaining how complex the bible is and the way that it is transcending through time. You experience god when you experience a source of love. I LOVE Spong!

    • @conradbulos6164
      @conradbulos6164 Před 9 měsíci

      Uh, Jexka, Shouldnt you have G in capital letter in God out of simple reverence for Him/Her as we would treat our parent out of simple respect?

  • @scapegoatiscariot2767
    @scapegoatiscariot2767 Před 3 lety +3

    Had my first pastor at the age of 21 been like this man, I would not have had the troubles I had in religion for four decades. He is confessing what hundreds of people in my past so desperately denied and tried to explain away instead of just simply and honestly confessing it. this leads me to believe that most religious people including the clergy are dishonest.
    "Thank you Mr. Spong."

    • @mzdejavu3419
      @mzdejavu3419 Před 2 lety

      He was truly a gem! I just discovered his wisdom and knowledge 2 days ago and he saved my thoughts regarding Christians and spirituality.

    • @conradbulos6164
      @conradbulos6164 Před 9 měsíci

      Maybe, not dishonest but simply misguided and needed a Bishop Spong to set them straight.

    • @scapegoatiscariot2767
      @scapegoatiscariot2767 Před 6 měsíci

      ​@@conradbulos6164no, I'm convinced it's dishonesty. I knew the first time I read Genesis when I was 21 that God or the god of the Old Testament was evil. I did the "God is always right dance for years", not realizing what I was doing to my family end my own dignity. I always question within myself, how God could be right when he's so wrong about so many things. I don't wonder anymore. Those books were written by men, not women, not minorities, men in power. Religion is how they kept power.

  • @ItsAnaThatsMe
    @ItsAnaThatsMe Před 12 lety +1

    I wish I lived closer to him. I would go see him as often as I could!
    He definitely restored my faith in the reason of the Bible...
    His desire is bring common sense back to the Christian arena... but as he says its been in short supply for quite some time.

  • @bonaccordmusic
    @bonaccordmusic Před 9 lety +6

    I like Spong's point that the bible can be seen to move from one conception of reality/God/humanity to another (I think it starts about minute 47). If we see our holy scripture as a static set of rules then we might just turn out to be that kind of Christian. However, if we view the whole of scripture as dynamic, a living, growing tradition, then we may open our own hearts and minds to such growth. The Spirit moves.

  • @AtamMardes
    @AtamMardes Před 6 lety +2

    Finally someone to help people understand the fact that religion is a scam.

    • @conradbulos6164
      @conradbulos6164 Před 9 měsíci

      Uh, no, Atam(?)not Adam? Religion is not a scam but the interpretation of it by people who have their own self serving personal agenda. Get it?

  • @Andante931
    @Andante931 Před 11 lety +1

    I just noticed your reply, thank you. The orthodox teaching is that God predestines those for salvation, gives them faith to believe, regenerates them to salvation, seals them with the Holy Spirit, all because of the work of Christ. Liberal Christianity bypasses all of this and states by being good one may have a type of salvation from evil by their own will, but does not consider we are born dead to God and children of wrath with no good in us. We need Christ for salvation.

    • @conradbulos6164
      @conradbulos6164 Před 9 měsíci

      Uh, Andante, your name reminds me of a joke about a girl giving in to seduction tells her !over as she takes off her panties, she cries, No Andantes, I want it allegro con brio! That said, what Bishop Spong is saying is Christ did not come to "save" us but that we may life and have it abundantly. It's a new and different kind of life Jesus was talking about. It's a transcendent life beyond the ordinary physical life but a life more fully lived and experienced abundantly!

    • @conradbulos6164
      @conradbulos6164 Před 5 měsíci +1

      Predination is not in God's vocabulary. Tha's why (He) gave us Freewill, the complete, absolute, unlimited and unconditional freedom to do as we wish without negative consequences except the operation of natural law which he set in place to govern the universe
      (He) created out of nothing.

    • @conradbulos6164
      @conradbulos6164 Před 5 měsíci

      Should be.. Predestination not predination.

    • @conradbulos6164
      @conradbulos6164 Před 5 měsíci

      Furthermore, as God's children begotten in His image and like ness( not created from clay as Genesis teaches) we never lost our place in heaven so salvation is not necessary and Christ is there to remind us who we are not to "save" us but to awaken us.

  • @erpthompsonqueen9130
    @erpthompsonqueen9130 Před rokem +2

    Thank you.
    Interesting to recall that a book that was available to me as a child was Fox's Book of Martyrs.

  • @chipfitzpatrick5082
    @chipfitzpatrick5082 Před 11 lety

    Like most Mainline churches..have watered down the Gospel,allowed detestable things to enter and serve as ministers......so much has changed from the first century...listening to this guy.......He is Lukewarm at best and Jesus will spue him out of His mouth....

  • @fisterklister
    @fisterklister Před 4 lety

    I aggree with Spong on almost everything, but he's christianity is very original, and only for him.

  • @CaitieLou
    @CaitieLou Před 12 lety +3

    I'm in the exact same position today, just ordered one of his books on Amazon. This guy is pretty major.

  • @Lukieloo
    @Lukieloo Před 12 lety +2

    A breath of fresh air.

  • @griss2984
    @griss2984 Před 11 lety +1

    Women were treated that way long before the Jewish faith came about. Slavery was also a different animal back then. Spartacus, an escaped slave from Rome, also owned slaves. What the Bible does is show individuals and the whole of humanity, warts and all. It's an honest portrayal of us. Polygomy is one example of that. No where in Scripture does it say that's fine. It presents it as a reality of the time. Same with slavery, just giving guidance for Christians on either side of that life.

  • @larryparker8677
    @larryparker8677 Před 7 lety +3

    A wonderful talk.

  • @pgtrue
    @pgtrue Před 13 lety +1

    love is the answer

  • @SiberianTiger51
    @SiberianTiger51 Před 11 lety

    I person, Bishop John Shelby Spong is not a kindly person. However, I agree with his theology. He is brilliant.

  • @fklein23
    @fklein23 Před 3 lety +3

    A truly brilliant lecture!

  • @qwertyqart
    @qwertyqart Před 11 lety +1

    without a doubt, great talk! even for the person who studied 10 years in eastern orthodox gymnasium, it is a fascinating lecture, with lots of humor and precious words

  • @onecuponeway
    @onecuponeway Před 15 lety

    i think that you have a point. and yet it is unquestionable that this is a very learned man. He is picking at the bible very intelligently and comparing it to our modern day secular beliefs. I think that he's right about many many things that he speaks of. God gave us a brain to reason with and his word to think about. Don't take anything to be true from first hearing.

  • @shaygahweh
    @shaygahweh Před 12 lety +1

    I'm an agnostic and I love this guy.

  • @MyReluctantTheology
    @MyReluctantTheology Před 11 lety +1

    I haven't read Sam Harris' book, but I've seen some of his interviews and lectures. I've also seen a lot of films of Christopher Hitchens. They are pretty harsh, but Spong isn't any bit more gentle than they are.

  • @manouchehr7
    @manouchehr7 Před 15 lety +1

    What bishop Spong is talking about is not new, what is quite new is realization and awareness of a Christian bishop.

  • @StacyTood
    @StacyTood Před 14 lety

    Life can be influenced by many things but our heart will accept and reflect things that it truly desires and that would not change regardless if we believe that God exists or not.
    In other words we are a reflection of our heart.

    • @conradbulos6164
      @conradbulos6164 Před 9 měsíci

      Uh, Stacy i take heart in what you're saying cuz I find it very heartening to realize that the heart is wiser than the mind in what really counts in our existence.

  • @ClumsyRoot
    @ClumsyRoot Před 12 lety

    A form of the Golden Rule can be found in nearly all religions, and most of these faiths predate Christianity.

  • @ruthamyallan1
    @ruthamyallan1 Před 13 lety +1

    @tumbleweeeeeed I couldn't agree more. Whenever I hear Spong speaking he always reminds me of the snakey charcter in the garden of Eden story, and conversely, when I read that very true story, I can always see the 'bishop''s face with the mouth opening and the darting tongue slithering out, 'Yea, hath God said?.....

  • @Revjonscott
    @Revjonscott Před 14 lety +1

    This is so true.... Thank you for making since!!

  • @Andante931
    @Andante931 Před 11 lety

    Thank you sir for your reply. Yes, I believe that liberal christianity finds no need for the sacrfice of Christ, so we may save ourselves. It is a system whereby mankind is autonomous and makes his own rules as he sees fit. I on the otherhand consider Christ my Lord over me, and my creator in whom is all authority. This means I hold the bible as the sole provider for the teachings of salvation.

  • @griss2984
    @griss2984 Před 11 lety

    Also, in that verse, submit does not mean what it has come to mean in our western society. It in no way means subserviant. We all must submit to some authority. My boss is younger than me and has less experience in actual practice than I do, but I submit to him as he is in authority over me and I like getting a paycheck, but that does not mean that in life I'm not his equal. In marriage, a wife and husband are partners, but the husband has the final vote. He should take his wife's council, tho.

  • @TadJohnson
    @TadJohnson Před 16 lety +1

    No, we can't recieve new insights about God. Jesus has made Him fully known to us.

  • @TorianTammas
    @TorianTammas Před 11 lety +1

    Well usualy religions do not tell us how to keep slaves. In the roman or greek or other religions it is not taught how to beat slaves and how to keep slaves but "god" seem to see it as important to do so.

  • @tajohnsonma
    @tajohnsonma Před 16 lety

    This world is seriously lacking sensible voices like Bishop Spong. I think the church has destroyed itself long enough. It is time to begin a movement of healing. If more of us would speak up then we could probably have avoided the meaningless war we are in.

  • @blackiebori
    @blackiebori Před 16 lety

    I'm glad you brought up 1 Cor 2:6-16. Although it is partly Pauline in theology, it also goes into perfect accordance with Jesus' teachings in the Gospels also. St. Paul speaks of a hidden wisdom that is revealed not by the spirit of this age, but by the Holy Spirit. The Pauline epistles were written before the Gospels, so there was obviously a young oral "tradition" that had remained untouched by redactors until the second century (right after the time John was written).

    • @conradbulos6164
      @conradbulos6164 Před 5 měsíci

      Until the tenth decade when John qrote his Gospel. Yes, Paul wrote his epistles from the young oral tradition later earlier than the Gospel writers by decades and should have been placed first ahead of the gospels in the printed bible for proper chronology and better religious perspective.

  • @TadJohnson
    @TadJohnson Před 16 lety

    Your god and my God are obviously different. The main difference being that your god is one created by you. You give life to your god, but when you die, so will he and so he is not able to save. The Holy Spirit says that my God is mighty to save bc He forever lives to make intercession for us. His existence can be traced back from everlasting to everlasting. When I'm dead and gone He and His Word will remain. You choose which man-made deity you will follow. As for me, I will serve the Lord.

  • @MikeJunior94
    @MikeJunior94 Před 11 lety

    If you are going to quote romans 1:23 at least remember to who Paul is writing and what he says in 1:21 "For although they knew God, they neither glorified him as God nor gave thanks to him, but their thinking became futile and their foolish hearts were darkened." 1:23 is clearly talking about those described in 1:21. This means you have to claim that people who see God as loving, don't worship and don't give thanks. You can quote mine all you want, but it isn't working without context.

  • @salamace7
    @salamace7 Před 11 lety +1

    The real irony there is that, if you read Genesis all the way through the expulsion from Eden, you find that the snake was telling the truth, and that god himself confirms it.

  • @me25422
    @me25422 Před 12 lety +1

    This man restores my faith in Christianity. Thank God! (even though I have trouble believing lol)

  • @AlanLow
    @AlanLow Před 2 lety

    Fortunately, religiosity is on the decline worldwide but has a long way to go yet.

  • @MyReluctantTheology
    @MyReluctantTheology Před 11 lety

    I spent Lent reading books like The God Delusion by Richard Dawkins, Why I Am Not A Christian and other essays on religion and related subjects by Bertrand Russell, and Some Mistakes of Moses by Robert Ingersoll. However, I'm now reading The Sins of Scripture, and Spong is about as harsh as Dawkins, Russell, and Ingersoll.

  • @veggieblues
    @veggieblues Před 3 lety +4

    hi mga ka sir raj :) HAHHAHS

  • @blackiebori
    @blackiebori Před 16 lety

    It would have been even more cataclysmic for Jesus' ministry than it already was if he had said Moses hadn't written the Torah. This was universally accepted in the Jewish world at the time.

  • @Meldola07
    @Meldola07 Před 11 lety +2

    Thank you for the answers. It's nice to see someone reasonable and intelligent on these kind of videos. I also disagree with Spong on some of his points, but I do appreciate different opinions as long as they are backed up by reasonable arguments.

  • @SirKickz
    @SirKickz Před 13 lety

    It's wonderful how getting death threats is listed as one of his credentials.

  • @phoenixtimes2
    @phoenixtimes2 Před 15 lety

    Now is the time for all people to not be necessarily "Christian" but be Christlike. I have a news flash: God is not a Christian. Nor a Hindu, Buddhist, etc. We, as believers, have the opportunity to give birth to a new Christianity. One that is inclusive, accepting and honors the great traditions of the church through the ages. Our time is at hand. We can't fear fundamentalism. Our world is crying out for what we as believers in a loving God can give. Let's be true to God and His love for ALL.

  • @andrewknake
    @andrewknake Před 8 lety

    He talks about a new consciousness always winning against an old definition.
    What guarantees that this new consciousness is correct or that it is something that God desires?

  • @blackiebori
    @blackiebori Před 16 lety +1

    I definitely agree!! That's why there has to be another reformation cuz the Protestant reformation didn't make things any better.

  • @rockyj74426
    @rockyj74426 Před 12 lety +1

    I heard him in person 10 days ago. He said, "My job is not to preserve 'the church' . . ." but to make God's love accessible to people. [the last part is paraphrased because I cannot remember it exactly].

  • @Andante931
    @Andante931 Před 11 lety

    I understand your hatred for Christians, but before you throw away your own salvation, remember, sinner, you have by your nature sinned against God and are a child of wrath, but you may escape this fate. Dont worry about the world, its passing away, worry about your soul and your standing with God. If you are not able to believe, ask God to help you. He wishes none to perish. I will pray for you today. Remember you do not choose Him, He chooses us, we depend on God for our salvation and faith.

  • @blackiebori
    @blackiebori Před 16 lety

    Christianity today has to be perfected. From itself to Christhood

  • @blackiebori
    @blackiebori Před 16 lety

    You also stated, "Joshua was also given authority to write Scripture, and most likely wrote Joshua and the end of Deuteronomy (Joshua 24:26)"
    Exactly!! This proves my point that Moses didn't write the WHOLE of the Torah, the Five Books (The Pentateuch).

  • @brentduanefoster
    @brentduanefoster Před 16 lety

    What is quite interesting to me is how those who believe in Inclusion or Universalism when someone does not agree with them, they do not condemn those that disagree with them.
    However, if you disagree with someone who believes in fundamentalism, they DO NOT HESITATE to let you know that you are hellbound unless you repent and embrace their doctrine.
    Wouldn't that pose some concerns to those of us who call ourselves "Christians"?

  • @chipfitzpatrick5082
    @chipfitzpatrick5082 Před 11 lety

    God is Love,God is also Holy.......He said be thou Holy for I am Holy.....I used to be a Episcoplalian....after listening to this guy....I know why I left the church...He doesnt have a clue of who God is , or HIs character....He cant stand sin..thats the deal. Read your bible..God will give you understanding all you have to do is ask.

  • @TadJohnson
    @TadJohnson Před 16 lety

    And, btw, the "evil" mentioned in Isa 45 is speaking of "natural evil" (hurricanes, storms, mighty winds-natural disasters), as the context of the verse explains quite clearly. That is why most translations render the word "calamity" (See ESV, NKJV, NASB, NLT, HCSB, MSG).
    But good though, look for another verse that describes God's lodrship amd mastery over evil and how he uses it to the praise of His glory (they're there).

  • @Lisarata
    @Lisarata Před 13 lety

    At MrMohjong What I've read of Spong is that he advocates for ending theocracy.

  • @MiroBG359
    @MiroBG359 Před 13 lety +2

    brilliant guy!

  • @CaitieLou
    @CaitieLou Před 12 lety

    I think it's funny how we as Christians look at how Paul and Leviticus wrote about how to keep slaves, or that a woman should never hold authority over a man, or that a father can sell his daughter into slavery, or that a child can be stoned to death for being unruly, we simply dismiss it as the ignorance of the age in which they lived. Yet when it comes to homosexuality, suddenly they are the unquestionable authorities on what is moral and just in the eyes of God.

  • @blackiebori
    @blackiebori Před 16 lety

    In this same chapter, St. Matthias was selected to take Judas Iscariot's place, but St. Luke makes no mention of the Apostles' approving of St. James as a "pillar" of the Jerusalem Church. Paul already mentions that St. James was a prominent figure in Galatians 2:9 and 12. 1 Corithians 15:7 also mentions that Jesus appeared to St. James. It's funny how Paul doesn't mention the women that Jesus appeared to, but this is probably his patriarchal standing point already in action.

  • @griss2984
    @griss2984 Před 11 lety

    While I am on the more conservative/fundamentalist side of the spectrum, and would say that what Spong espouses is not Christianity, it's sad that so many (though there are more of us than you'd think) on my side of the spectrum inadvertantly view Christianity as a "check-your-brain-at-the-door" faith. God calls us to love Him with all our heart soul and MIND, and I feel that to do so means actually studying and knowing what we believe.

  • @margaretk.haydon3137
    @margaretk.haydon3137 Před 2 lety

    I wish he was still here to communicate with.

  • @brentduanefoster
    @brentduanefoster Před 16 lety +1

    "the biggest reason why the Roman Catholic Church can't get it's head right about the role is that none of their priests have daughters!"
    WOW!!!!

    • @conradbulos6164
      @conradbulos6164 Před 9 měsíci

      Hey, Brent, now you know why Catholic priests must make a vow of celebacy. The Catholic church hates anything to do with sex and that's why her theology insists that Mary has to remain a virgin mother because the idea of reproduction in biology in sinful.

  • @mysteryperson1976
    @mysteryperson1976 Před 12 lety

    I used to think so low of Bishop Spong, but he has gone from being very low on my list to being my favorite theologian.