Escobar's Bear Hug Leads to PK, Bouanga's PK: Dive or Contact? Cucho Hernández Red Card Correct?
Vložit
- čas přidán 7. 04. 2024
- Andrew Wiebe is back for another edition of Instant Replay to break down the most controversial plays from the weekend.
📺 Watch every match with MLS Season Pass on Apple TV: apple.co/MLS
The 🐐 plays here. Join The Messi Insider for insider news, early access to Messi promotions and more: www.mlssoccer.com/messi/
➡️ Subscribe Now: / mls
➡️ Follow us on:
- TikTok: www.tiktok.com/@mls?lang=en
- Instagram: / mls
- Twitter: / mls
- Like us on Facebook: / mls
➡️ Para Español:
- Instagram: / mlses
- Twitter: / mlses
- Facebook: espanol.mls
For more information about MLS, go to the league's official website: www.MLSsoccer.com
#mls #highlights #mlsseasonpass - Sport
The first call is EXACTLY why VAR should exist, shocking for the ref to still get it wrong.
VAR makes the game better most of the time imho. Big mistake by the ref it seems like.
The ref should be sidelined as he was not willing to correct his mistake.
It should but it shouldn’t be be run by blind people
And Buonga should get a game misconduct for the simulation applied the next time LAFC plays the Galaxy. Neutral here, but dives like that have no place in the sport.
@@DukeTrout So true, Duke.
Glad we LA Galaxy fans are not "crazy"
Frustrated, pissed, a bit sad, but not crazy.
In this instance, 100% agree. Carson shouldn’t have gotten a penalty.
@@1Dylan1 it's how it goes sometimes. Might be nice for the Galaxy to lose a game. Takes some of the pressure off in my opinion. Now, back to work!
It was not just LAG fans. Pretty sure most fans were annoyed with that call. We have VAR to overturn these accidental calls and this ref decided to double-down on his bad call.
Looks like Freeman might turn out to be MLS's next Ricardo Salazar. Ego too big to be challenged even by other refs and video evidence.
Just want to say how embarrassing it is for these forwards to go down so easy looking for a call. Some of these dudes werent even touched. In my personal opinion refs should be more strict about simulation
100% agree. I think Kevin Cabral should have seen yellow, and I'm a Rapids supporter.
If a team is playing Vancouver, there will be bodies flying to the ground on every play. Source: watching any team play against Vancouver.
LAFC gets all the calls. Trust me as a Whitecaps fan I know..
Ditto Miami.
Freeze frames an angle where you cant see both shoulders. "Its shoulder to shoulder"
😂 One second later elbow to the back 😂
@@baxtronx5972 right? Who gets hit from the side and gets launched forward
Unless he has a shoulder growing out of his back...
It looks like it's his knee and thigh pushing his hip from behind that actually took him down. Definite PK for me.
Shoulder to shoulder perhaps, but there was also knee to butt. The defender's left leg was in between Gil's legs
What about all those Yoshida drops on corner kicks? ):
That galaxy pen is absurd
Shoulder to shoulder? Malanda's torso twist might have created one of those "what color is the dress?" illusions.
The rev that managed the El traffico derby is dumb
Missed the Sang Bin non-call. The Minnesota-RSL game was well officiated.
I didn't think that the contact in the box was a PK, but Sang Bin was clearly fouled as the pass came in, he just fought through it. It's the reason why players fall down the they feel any contact cause the ref doesn't call fouls unless you do. The ref should have pulled that play back for a free kick outside the box and given a yellow for DOGSO.
@@mattripley3717 Can't do that - a free kick for a DOGSO foul outside the Penalty Area requires a red.
Respect to MLS for giving us a video about controversial calls, most sports leagues hardly do that! Also, props to them for letting one of their users give their opinion about calls.
I mean, they aren’t really critical of the refs though and they’re usually wrong about the most controversial plays. It’s really just them covering their asses for some of the controversial plays.
@@1123Steveo true...
@1123Steveo And besides, even though we sports fans criticize refs a lot, we have to remember that refs are like us, mistakes are so common even refs make them! However, criticizing a ref can be a good idea, especially for some of these penalty calls in this video. (This is just an opinion, please do not take this seriously)
@@bentheswitchsportsfan06 you’re right, I think that most of the fair criticism comes from mistakes that are happening over and over again that the refs should be learning from but the MLS and other leagues like the premier league just excuse. If the refs were held to a certain standard then I feel like players and fans would be happier with most calls going either way
@@1123Steveo Very true statement. ☺
Andrew....how can you have the video paused (3:18) and then state something that is clearly not true. That's clearly NOT shoulder to shoulder. The defender is clearly behind the attacker making the challenge. I don't get where you're coming from here.
Completely agree with you on the NYC PK. That wasn't a clear and obvious error. VAR overstepped and got shut down.
Missed the Sang Bin non call that should've been either a free kick or pen
I wish I could see that replay. I didn't pay for MLS this season.
What minute was that?
RSL fan hear abd that should not have been a second yellow at the end of the game.
Still crazy that the center ref went to the VAR screens and doubled down on his wrong call.
Plays like THIS are exactly what VAR was for, and he CHOSE to not accept video evidence or reality. Upside-down world. Freeman needs to be removed from MLS reffing until he gets better.
MLS knows exactly who to suspend this weekend, and his name is Jon Freemon
He's on the Atlanta-Philly game this week. And "MLS" has no say in these things. It's all PRO.
Cant wait to hear the mental gymnastics Pro will be spitting about that obvious simulation call that wasnt called against LAFC
"PRO would have preferred to not send any LAFC penalty to VAR under any circumstances."
PRO is a joke. It was better when they went in strike.
I am surprised that Miami's Ruiz taking down Milhailovic in the box (with 7:03 on the game clock) didn't make the cut.
Me too! I tagged Instant Replay on twitter on that very play, yet they totally ignored it...
Thanks Apple TV for the low-quality streaming video.
Inside Video Review will be interesting this week. I'd be surprised if we didn't hear at least one "PRO would have preferred...." comments.
LAFC needed a bogus PK just to beat us. What a bunch of cowards.
Not really what 'coward' means, but sure.....
I'd be ok with the SBJ non-call in St.Paul if it weren't for the softest calls known to man in the games in LA and New York. Both of those also had VAR checks which MN never got one, though idk if you can review a foul outside the box without dogso (which there defo was even if you don't see a penalty
VAR cannot send down for review a foul which would not be a red card offense (like DOGSO) or a penalty.
Extremely disappointed to see that you don't look at Sang Bin being mugged by three defenders in the Minnesota game, especially considering the mentions on Twitter were FULL of tweets suggesting that you take a look at it.
out of all the calls with austin/san jose .. Stuver's tackle or hand ball they chose the Rubio call???..
From a Austin fan, no matter if you are either a Austin or San Jose fan , the ref’s decisions were absurd.
That Austin FC player dived. That was not a penalty.
El traffico no pen. That ref is on drugs
“Does Rafa Czichos smell good”
hmm.. looks like the upcoming eclipse drags the performance of the referees down a bit this weekend.
From an Atlanta United fan, can we have the replacement refs back? Anyone who thinks what Muyumba did was a foul shouldn’t be allowed near a match as a spectator, much less a referee.
Yet another instance that proves all VAR decisions should be made by the 4th official. Take the decision out of the ref's hands so there is not issue of ego. That PK call on LAG/LAFC was as clear of a simulation call as can be and yet the ref that originally called for a PK overrides the "clear and obvious error" call from VAR.
It will be interesting to hear the audio during Inside Video Review. The angles shown to the referee may have been lacking compared to what was shown to us. They have all the angles, but we do see VAR failing in their job to present it correctly.
Ditto for the Atlanta United NYCFC penalty. Ref made an ego call, no way that’s a pen
I would be embarrassed of that LAFC “win” if I was a fan.
I see it too often where instead of looking for a clear and obvious error the VAR looks at it as “it’s a foul but I wouldn’t have called it” so they send it down. I hope that changes soon
Softest PK I’ve ever seen in ATL-NYCFC. It’s not a penalty for me. I don’t know hardly any refs who call that.
The slightest grab and pull will throw anyone off balance going fast, a pen for me.
It's still a PK in my mind. If you see the other angle from behind that was shown live. He reaches out to grab him when there was no need to. The ball was directly in front of him and he grabbed him anyways
While it is soft, these get called about 10 times a year in each league. Still not sure why defenders even do it, the attacking player did not really have much of a play with 3 defenders and a goalie in front of him. Just a dumb play to even put it is in the hands of the ref.
Should definitely be a PK. What are you doing grabbing a player and spin them.
I’ve been waiting so long for this!🎉
1:50 might be the best call of the week. He clearly puts his hands up into his shoulders and gives him a huge shove. That is always going to be called a red card, and I am happy that the ref saw it and gave him a red.
Yellow got the red for the kick out into the player that pushed him down. THAT is always a red. The push, IMO, wasn't that bad. It only looked like it because the guy in yellow made the most of it. Give a yellow, but there's no world where that's a red.
@@MrCho14 You are truly correct.
Cabral was clearly brought down lol by the trailing knee. How do you miss something like that
I agree. It looks like Ruiz's knee bumps Cabral's foot just as it's lifting off the ground. It doesn't take much to throw a runner off when they are at a full sprint. Ruiz had an even more obvious foul on Mihailovic in the box a few minutes earlier that MLS seems keen on pretending never happened.
The LA Galaxy got robbed
Maybe, but it's the Galaxy so does anyone really care?
Insane to not have any calls from the SKC-POR game. Not saying the ref made us choke, we're more than comfortable doing that on our own, but the ref definitely didn't help things at all.
Not sure why I watch Instant Replay.... Dwiebe knows nothing about refereeing. Malanda shoves his knee into the back of Gil. Shoulder to shoulder??? I mean yeah Malanda's shoulder is making contact with Gil's shoulder but do you discount the rest of the contact?
Clear and obvious dive.
4:31 HE'S STILL EMPLOYED!?
Would love a review of the handball or lack thereof in the revolution vs club America game the other night. Didn't matter to the result at all really, but man that was an annoying call and 5 minute VAR look to get it wrong IMO.
I believe this is MLS games only. They don't touch Open Cup or any other competition involving non-MLS teams.
@@MrCho14 I know, it's worth a shot tho...
You circled the shoulder contact but did you see the knee to butt contact? That’s why he went down. Watch again and you will see why the penalty should have been called.
3:20 if you want a time stamp.
crazy
on the gil shoulder to shoulder.....that isn't shoulder to shoulder. Also CTL's player's knee drives into Gil from behind. Easy PK
On the first foul on Cabral. Thats dogso. you can see he gets his right foot hit by the inter miami's player on his right shin when Cabral is pulling his right foot away. its light but its there
Not seeing it with Cabral. I paused it through the close up view and I don't see any contact.
When have we seen ANY simulation calls?!?!? If it’s not a penalty it’s simulation, once the refs start calling them we will stop seeing them simple as that…
embarassing from bouanga
the one austin fc call you mention and its the one they get obviously *RIGHT*
just say you dont like us, go back to playing the villian, and move on.
That challenge on Gil was a definite penalty. You can challenge with the side of your shoulder to their side. You can't put the front of your shoulder into the back of someone else's
I tagged Instant Replay with the time (7th minute) of a clear penalty no-call on the Rapids vs. Miami, and you completely ignored that play in your analysis of the game. Why?
So far I'm not seeing any difference from the scab refs.
Thus is just awful to watch the wrong choices being made even with VAR.
I'll expect an ESPN documentary about it in 20 years.
💛💚🌲💚💛
cabral has the top of his foot hit by a knee. i agree it's not a missed call. but you can see the contact.
Football is a bugging of bodies. Pause.
Your consistency is as good as PRO..... terrible.
When people who have never refereed, never gone to clinics, never passed any tests critique those who have and have reffed for years, then they just don’t know. Please.
Most blatant dive I've seen in a long time in MLS. PRO is a clown show.
All the refs are garbage!! Gave up watching a long time ago because it’s all fix!!
*_SEE YA NEXT TIME!..._* hopefully, with the old "replacement refs", because imo they were significantly better. 😞
LAFC 🇺🇸💛🖤 el mejor de EEUU
these refs omg
MLS might have the worst refs of any sport anywhere in the world. Divers are rewarded and fouls are not called when someone is clattered into and run over. Also, I kind of feel bad for Hernandez. He gets bumped, pushed, and then the guy looks like he is trying to jump right onto Hernandez's torso for no reason.
Nothing about the FC Cincinnati game? Really? That ref was by far the worst non scab ref all year
Deni got kicked in the head against Colorado. No call, it wasnt even featured on here last week. Moral of the story, all refs make mistakes. Its game 7, move on or keep crying.
Doesn’t matter, that dive was a disgrace to the sport
I don’t know how Kucho Hernandez got a red card. The other player should’ve been sent off to.
You might need to explain yourself here. There was a common foul by the opponent. Hernandez then kicks out making contact with his cleats. That's 100% a red every time. The referee doesn't really have an option there.
@@MrCho14to add, even if he misses it is still a red as it is attempting to strike an opponent
This is known type of Bad acted Dive, when player start falling before touch 😂😂!!
Jon Freemon should not be a professional referee. The job requires confidence in decision making and humility to admit when an on-field call was wrong. This is the most obvious simulation I ever seen in ages, what is the point of running over to VAR to confirm the wrong decision. In a derby match, seems like he lacked the courage to make a call that would upset the home fans
I'm leaving full judgment until I see Inside Video Review this week. From what I understand, the angles and speed it was shown to him were not the best potentially making this a VAR failure more than anything else. We'll see what comes out.
Regardless, I don't believe in any world that his decision was based on upsetting anyone. That's just ridiculous.
Well, Inside Video Review puts this entirely on Freemon. VAR did a good job. Not sure what he was looking at.
You are but this isn’t
I don't care for any of these teams, but Galaxy got screwed on that PK, and Colorado got Unkle'd, no surprise he's back and looking to make an impact. The strike should have gotten rid of him. Bring back replacement refs.
Cabral's foot is hit by the defender's knee. Not simulation. Should have been a foul.
Weibe! Are you blind? That is a thigh thrust to the back of Gil's hip. Definitely should have been a PK. Yeah there is shoulder to shoulder but that's not what takes him down. The contact from the thigh thrust pushes him forward. Clear PK. Huge mistake.
Surprised nothing from the Timbers game. Skcs third goal definitely didn’t seem onside
It looks very close. So close that there was no clear and obvious error and therefore VAR rightfully did not get involved. It's actually a great camera angle on this one. I'm leaning towards the right shoulder of the player who played the ball being kept onside by the backside of the defender in the center.
Putting aside that it wasn't 'definitely' anything, I've said here before that I'd much rather look at other calls on this segment rather than arguing over inches in potential offside decisions.
@@MrCho14 Fair enough. I also wouldn’t have minded looking at the tackle made on Evander with the cleats up to the ankle. It seemed like dangerous play and maybe warranted a red and there were a couple others I had questions about.