Why Genghis Khan Refused To Invade India
Vložit
- čas přidán 4. 05. 2024
- See this article for detailed references:
00:00 Intro
00:11 The Battle of the Indus: Genghis Khan at India’s Doorstep
01:08 Background
03:05 Genghis Khan Turns Back
04:28 Theories: Not Quite Right
05:32 Cultural Affinity with India?
06:39 The Key to Understanding the Conqueror and His Motivations
07:48 The Old Enemy: China
08:59 Temujin: Genghis Khan’s Early Life and Struggle
10:56 Genghis Khan’s Career as a Conqueror
14:24 Genghis Khan’s Invasions: The Hidden Pattern
15:33 Genghis Khan’s Reasons for not Invading India
18:06 Genghis Khan’s Reasons for not Invading India, Summarized
19:04 Genghis Khan: A Misunderstood and Misportrayed Historical Figure
21:28 Recap
21:55 Conclusion
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
SUPPORT THE CHANNEL
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
►UPI (G-Pay/PhonePe/Paytm): abhijitchavda@icici
►PayPal: paypal.me/AbhijitChavda
►Become A Member on CZcams: / @abhijitchavda
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
JOIN #AbhijitChavda
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
★Twitter: / abhijitchavda
★Instagram: / theabhijitchavda
★Facebook: / theabhijitchavda
★Website:
★Email Inquiries: inquiries.chavda@gmail.com
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
#AbhijitChavdaPodcast
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
★Spotify: open.spotify.com/show/1WmKYRI...
★Apple Podcasts: podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast...
★Google Podcasts: podcasts.google.com/feed/aHR0...
★Stitcher: www.stitcher.com/show/the-abh...
★Amazon Music: music.amazon.in/podcasts/c879...
★Soundcloud: / abhijitchavda
★Audible: www.audible.com/pd/item_name-...
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
#AskAbhijitChavda #Abhijit #Chavda #AskAbhijitShow
Thank you for watching!
Please share the video and spread the message. 🙏
This is the BEST biographical and historical account Of Genghis Khan and the period. It is the standard by which Western Historians should be measured and compared. Outstanding Academic Excellence. Thank You
Thank you, Chris.
I agree with you 100%. Chavda is a genius.
Agree.
Completely agree
Agreed
My grandmother here in Mongolia refers India as the land of gods and has deep respect.
Wow!! Our grandparents really hold vast wisdom. That we should consume
Do you believe Ghenghiz Khan was a practicing Buddhist?
@@mtarkes oh i dont have any experience in history but i generally get the immpression that he started out as a shamanist tengrist and perhaps became an agnostic athiest eventually. He was tolerant towards all religion equally and sought after and invited many scholars at the end of his life. Common teachings of buddhism however has always been the spoken and folk wisdom spread among Mongolians for many many years.
We love mangolians as they love Indian's.
As the video said the secret history of Mongolia gives detailed insight into his campaigns and reasons behind it. Also I heard from an inner Mongolian actor that the CCP bans at least half the episodes from any historical series depicting Chinggis khans or the Mongols. History can be so fragile and influential. Hope the future holds better history for all of us.
I am from Myanmar and our ancestors were Mongols. We love *Hindu-India*
We indian also love budhist mayanmar
May Myanmar return to normalcy and the people live in peace. India must help the Myanmar people during this military crisis. (mohd iqbal).
Love from India
I like Mahasi Sayadaw, Ledi Sayadaw, and Pa Auk Sayadaw
@@luvsuneja Thanks how u know all these Monks?
Bro, i am a Nigerian and never thought I will be interested in the history of India, I just stumbled on the video accidentally, and with the excellent way you are delivering your knowledge, I watched the video till the end, unbelievable. Kudos.
My assessment of Genghis Khan will certainly change after goin through this video.
Hi. Fellow Nigerian here! You and me are in the same boat😂 I stumbled on this video and I couldn't stop watching.
Hello My Nigerian brother I'm a History student And I can Confirm that This whole Video is made On an agenda and this contains half truths and lies to profit the current government of india.
I’m Nigerian too and just wanted to say hi lol
I’m Nigerian too 🙏🏿 knowledge has no race
My history teacher (Egypt) explained the same reasons for not invading India. Emphasising the ruling Mamluk did not provoke nor pose any threat to the Mongols and that the great Khan had no greed for wealth but was driven by a deep desire for righteousness and revenge…
But the mongols did later invade india it was just when they were called mughals not mongols.
@@freneticness6927 mongols invaded in 1290s
@@freneticness6927 Mughals were not mongols but muslims of Turkish origin
@@freneticness6927They were abrahamic then
The mongols did invade into egypt and the mamluks defeated them.
You had me at "The less we say about our Indian historians the better, their attitude is like, why should we talk about someone who didn't harm India, why should we glorify someone who didn't hurt India".
You summed up all of Indian "eminent historians" in one sentence. 🙏
weird thing is mughals have genghis khan ancestry
U forget to say " let's Stick to glorifying the mughals"..🤣🤣
Serene . Hard to tell .. it's all claimed. They are described as uzbeks but the barlas were Turkic who originally didn't look like Uzbek at all
@@sereneevening400 Mughals also have Rajput ancestry.... didn't make aurganzeb any less evil.
Sad but Facts!!!
As a Mongolian 13year old teenager, I highly and proudly appreciate your effort for your research and the video!
Lots of love 🥰from Bharatvarash ( India )
Genhis khan grandson had a Good Relationship with Tamil's Chola Dynasty. He built Lord Shiva Temple in China with a Advise of Chola for the recovered from his illness.
intresting
This was a beautiful video, and you are a fabulous history teacher. I'm going to study deeper into this subject. As a 70 year old American, I've come to realize how modest and weak our history instruction of the countries behind the Iron Curtain, and the East in general, were. It was almost as if they didn't exist. And unless you were a history major in college, it might be a rare elective course that brought you into contact with that history. Thank you for this, Teacher.
All people from north and South America are Americans, not just United States citizens.
@@elpacho....9254 Thanks for your reply. I'm aware of the fact, and meant no offense. I was speaking from the POV of a member of the Western Hemisphere, as opposed to Eastern. What's your nationality - was your history education different in substance from what I described? I'm just interested in knowing. Thanks again! 🙏😊
Indian is brilliant, resonant and unforgettable.
I’ve always believed that Indian was the center of civilization 10-20000 years hence. To trace humanities steps out of Africa heading north as determined, then the route was either western or an eastern path.
I find it hard to believe that 100,000 years ago mankind would continue through expedition, that easterly flow snd eventually onto North America. Yet so it continues.
And now both India and China have similar populations, but how different is their societal foresight, edification and spiritual connectivity??
As a Mongolian it is nice to know there are people who actually know the real facts.
I respect Genghis khan and Kublai khan. They are historical heroes.
@S K there is no proof that Tamerlane was a decadent of the Great Kahn
We all are looking for our real history and some people like him are going beyond what it actually takes... thanks to him 🙏
@S K why not
The entire world history has been distorted, manipulated and twisted by Westerners/Europeans/Whites to push white supremacy and Eurocentrism.
No shitty music, no fancy editing effects, just pure content by someone who's an actual historian. One of the best videos I've ever seen period.
RE "fancy editing effects", less face time and more map time would be an improvement.
Also, to fully counter the "reductionist view", information and archeology that examines the daily lives of the people pre and post Genghis (and his general) in the conquered lands is needed. How was trade affected? Were there successful administrations of the laws; what form and relative load were taxes? What cultural load was imposed by Genghis outside of his affinity for Hindu Buddhist traditions? What prevented him from establishing succession to maintain the empire? And finally the backbone of the "reductionist" narrative -- his psychological terror tactics prior to or after invasion -- must be addressed.
No game of throne scenes.
Totally agree
Agree. No "woke" rewriting history to suit their vile middle class hypocrite selves, just factual history.
Exactly
Genghis Khan was the the manliest man to ever walk this earth. And not because he was extremely powerful. But because he knew when and where to use that strength.
Fr it’s soo awesome I wanna stay alive to find out more even tho it’s useless But he let no one cross him and did thins not out of anger but reason
He was also know for fathering an crazy amount of children!
Dude was insanely impressive
Reminds me of male rana mongoliana.
He was a rapist and murderer. Stop glorifying this evil man.
Literally every single Mongolian person I know is one of the hardesr working, physically strong, mentally strong, beautiful, and yet simultaneously peaceable people I have EVER met.
Literally.
Can see their faces and recall specific moments that we studied or worked together.
Awesome people.
As a Mongolian, I must admit that I am amazed by your outstanding and coherent explanation. I am proud that our ancestors were men of principals and respected different cultures. Cheers!
Mongols were Hindus, that is why Genghis Khan refused to invade India.
Exactly. Coupled even with few army, any territory can easily be captured by their raging army. But dat is a mystery for India. Buddhism is one of the reason.
Gengis Khan clearly believed in KARMA,
cornerstone of Hinduism & Buddhism.
Greetings from Indian in Canada 🙏
No one cared about Hinduism outside India for most parts but Buddhism ☸️ had won the hearts of millions all around the subcontinent, anyone with basic knowledge of Buddhism knows how it spread like wildfire as it resonated with the traders & merchants, who were often rational & hardworking, as opposed to Hinduism was crippled by cast system empires by the Brahmins that time. Hinduism also has a long history of greed & rivalry, lot that have been wiped from history similar to western historian, which is never seen under Buddhist national. The great emperor of India - Ashoka is a great example who was one of India’s most ferocious conquerer but took refuge in Buddhism in later parts & is also the reason we have come to learn about Buddhism today. The Hindu & Mughal rulers and ensured to wipe off Buddhism from the face of India as it empowered every being.
Regardless, fascinating narration.
Please keep up, people seeking truth would always appreciate this perspective.
@@justiceempire1170 not Buddhism, Mongols were Hindus.
@@abro99 your comment reeks of anti Hindu hatred, keep ur anti Hindu fake history with u. No one cared about Hinduism outside India? There was a time when Hinduism was followed all over this planet, anyone who knows real history knows that Buddhism never spread anywhere like a "wild fire" at all except in places like Srilanka, Tibet and Thailand, these countries too were Hindu Before, Hindus never had a caste system but a Varna system, the caste system was started by UK, Varna system Never discriminated, you will never understand Varna system. Buddhism never resonated with any merchants because these merchants were hardworking and rational hence didn't agree with the teachings of Buddhism, Buddhism never spread in India or the rest of the planet except the countries I mentioned because no one agreed with the nonsensical illogical teachings of Buddhism that is why people all over the planet are leaving Buddhism and converting to Hinduism. Hinduism was never "crippled" ever, it was flourish more and more. Buddhism has hate, rivalry and greed always, Hinduism never had all this, Hinduism on the other always taught peace, harmony, tolerance unlike Buddhism. Buddhism taught to spread hate towards other religions, Your anti Hindu comment is an example, that is why Buddhists have always persecuted people of other religions everywhere, that is why Buddhists annihilated countless rohingyas Muslims and Rohingya Hindus. Buddhists annihilated And persecuted Hindus in Bhutan. Srilankan Buddhists annihilated and persecuted Hindus and Muslims in Sri Lanka. Hinduism is the most tolerant Religion. Buddhism teaches intolerance and violence against others. King Ashoka never converted to Buddhism nor did he preach Buddhism, that's another lie started by communists and Buddhist Historians. Hindus or Muugals never eradicated Buddhism, the fact is no one in India accepted Buddhism because Buddhism is full of nonsense and nonsensical teachings with no logic or spirituality.
Here in India un educated muslims proudly claim Zengis Kahn (=Khan)
was a muslim 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Kahn meant leader of the clan
@@mohammedzubair3151 😂😂😂😂 nice joke
Lol even muslim.have stolen this name of khan lol. He is kahn
I've never seen a single muslim claiming that he was a muslim.
@@subratabhattacharya7983 because religion is all about ideology not about birth.
islam came after so many religion thats why all are converts
@@ravindra869 yes
The ancient history of Asia is insane.
The world's culture and religions are based in Asia.
If you look carefully, ancient wars are mostly done to invade India. But Why?😮
@@user-fl6qp4jm2j because india was the richest country by far, just ask vasco da gama
I’m Irish. Great to hear a great story. True History. Keep up the good work
I’m an isiZulu speaking African from Africa, this just brought tears to my eyes. Thank you for this. Every source of information about Ghengis Khan portrays him as a blood thirsty warlord, something they never do to Alexander
A interesting perspective. Worthy of serious consideration.
Well done!
Brother, Africa is a continent. If you are Zulu be precise about your country of origin, instead of claiming the entire continent...
No wonder non-Africans still referr to Africa as one big country, when Africans do the same.
@@Exxperiment626 I am an African and I am from Africa, that’s how I describe myself. If this doesn’t sit well with you. Just ignore it, pretend like you didn’t see it. Nothing bad will happen to you. Peace!!!
I'm African( Zulu of the Mthetwa tribe) and Indian and .....
@@fazelabdulla9845 Myambose
As a Mongolian i really respect your knowledge of our history, thank you
I even don't know this. I think need to share more and more
@Hello Biro Buddhist
@Hello Biro he was shamanist , later he killed big shaman as who was gaining more influence and power
@Hello Biro yeah its still practiced in many countries, there are lot videos
@@Beyonder1987 No, Genghis Khan could until that Khilji would not stop him.
I had an amazing spiritual experience in Pune, India a few years ago. It’s been hard trying to explain it here in the west without getting weird looks. This is a great video man. It was nothing to do with a yogi or guru. It happened while visiting a community of people with learning disabilities as we were trading stories and songs about Indian and Scots cultures. Thanks for your hard work and a big hello from Scotland. 👋🏴
Namaste🙏🏻 and thanku for your kind words brother ❤
@@tuhin2839Any time at all. 😁
Why were you in Pune?
@@mangopudding5979 It was part of a study trip
@@MartyMcK for how many days?
I'm from Himachal Pradesh from spiti valley we are taught we carry blood of Genghis khan spiti is a region rural area where we are all Buddhist u should visit Spiti valley
Are you Tibetan
im coming to hp ,i want to marry any local girl from spiti valley or nearby areas ,i want that dna ,im from southern india .
@@1ne7evNi am an rajput if you agree we can marry
@@Kshatriya288 😳🤯🙏
@@1ne7evN wtf
This is the first intelligent commentary about Genghis Khan I've ever seen or heard, and I'm not young.
@@ladusingh2141 You must have a lot of time to copy paste the same thing every where . I am willing to give to Typography job for $5 per hour .
@@ladusingh2141 khalistani spotted
@@ladusingh2141 hey jeehawdi, your madrasa knowledge doesn't work anywhere outside of your 7th century medieval world. So, place an ice pack on the burnt area.
@@narutohenaruto that was funny not saying i agree with your comment
@@aryanchakraborty5175 what did he said ? I think he deleted his comment
"Let's just stick to glorifying Mughals"- The entire careers of the so called top tier Historians of India summarised in one single line. RESPECT SIR 🙏🏻
@@Klaus-cl3hr nope ,only in delhi the revolters proclaimed bahadur shah zafar as the emperor of India,the revolt of 1857 were scattered,and each of the leaders were leading rebellion own their own,nana saheb and rani laxmi bai fought against the law if doctrine of lapse ,whereas the soldiers fought due to the reason of animal fat in the gun cadriges and the low wages and inhumane treatment
@Abhinav damn bro each of your answers just shut up anyone having wrong info 😂😂... truly this NCERT has fucked the history...it is like they are writing fairy tales 😂😂😂...jo mn me aya likh do
@SAFFRON BOY are u mad under the mughals India United if not for the Mughals India would still be divided the brits just made us suffer not unite us but under the Mughals, under Shah Jahan especially India was in a state of peace
@INDIAN भारतीयYou know that the whole of Middle East is Muslim so unless u want to remove India from the world map and you want to make the Hindus a minority then go on remove us from India but if you want a United India then u need not think about this
@Abhinav Anglo Mughal War hua tha 1686-1690 and it was a Mughal Victory ofc it will be Aurangzeb was ruling India at that time
I didn't know any of this, thank you very much for this insight. I'm learning a lot about Indian history because India is such a fascinating country. Unfortunately I only know the "official" version of the story so far. So I'm very happy to have found you in CZcams. Thank you 🙏 for your great research and Insights.
❤ Greetings from Germany
I'm argentinian, from European descent, still I cannot but agree with you in terms of european history being studies much more than the rest. Your points do make a lot of sense and I presume there is a good chance some are valid. It would be interesting for me to know more about Gengis Khan, still I would love for people talking about these guys to emphasize the horrible things they did. All of them from Gengis, via Cesar, the sultans and all the way to Stalin, Bush or Putin have donde so much wrong
Just like Mohammad, Temmujin created many things in society that are part of the foundations of Western societies to this day. There are many professors who dispute how vicious he was, saying he did a lot of conquering just by letting cities know he was coming. If they submitted, he did nothing to them.
Bloodthirsty belongs to all men. The killing of sport teams after they lost a game? Nuff said.
Thats because historiography comes from europe. Basically all university diciplines come from europe.
As a Mongolian, I have to say that he made an awesome research about the greatest strategist of all time Chinggis Khan!
chinggis khan?
@@striker1711 that's how it is pronounced
Wow.. thankyou so much for this verification 🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼
Temujin (Genghis Khan) was not Mongolia. Fudan University nankai University many universities genetic engineering 🧬 research. Tiemuzhen gene is the Han gene of Yellow River and Yangtze River. Han =Khan was completely different from other Mongol tribes. In the 13th century, the Han and Tang dynasties were in chaos. Genghis Khan's family went into exile in Mobei. After Temuzhen was born and grew up, he conquered all the small tribes in Mobei in the name of the Han people and named it --Mongolia…
mera naam hai amara phirta hu main mara mara.... hello amara from koga clan ...ding ding
I grew up learning history with a western narrative and perspective. Even a majority of our Indian history taught was on Mughals. Its quite a revelation and refreshing to hear from an Indian historian. Thank you.
I agree
I agree thondup bro 👍
As a child I use to admire almost all 'the greats' - for 1 quality I thought was possessed by all - How to manage mass? Today I got much better insight abt Chengis Khan. Much better human than some of "The Greats"..... Evn the Doc abt Chengis in NG also didn't quite highlighted the Good side of Chengis.
Agreed Thondup brother
This was definitely true in the past. However, in Western universities, there is now increasing guilt over European colonialism. Scholars here are starting to present alternative points of view, and not just stick with a Judeo-Christian bias. As a Buddhist, I am fully aware that Buddhism cannot be properly understood from a Christian or Muslim perspective. Right or wrong, English is the dominant scholarly language on Earth, and I can only access English language information. Fortunately, scholars (like The Indian Interest) from around the world are presenting their non-Western perspectives in English. I already know my culture's perspective, I want to understand other perspectives.
wow.. didnt even know how the 20 mins flied...
what a smooth and inspiring explanation.. respect for genghis khan rose to all time high
Turns out the terrible Khan might have been a better guy than most of his "civilized" enemies. I shall listen to Mongolian throat singing all day, to cherish new-found wisdom :)
Excellent video! I have ADHD & your history lesson is keeping my attention mostly and I subscribed to you too now. I’m 51 years old first generation Iranian/American and feel the need for learning more about my background so watching you talk helps me with that.
Your surname is Indian 🤨 ??? Maybe you should get a DNA test it may hold some great mysteries, your ancestors maybe from the sindh region of India as "ani" in the last name is most used in that region , Sindhi people are trader group of people in Hinduism sindh and Iran was directly connected in the past as Baluchistan was a part of sindh.
@@Your_spanish_el_amigoMore like the iranians invaded into india loads of time and the pashtuns are culturally persian. And the dehli sultinate came from iran.
@@freneticness6927 that has nothing to do with what he said.
@@freneticness6927Delhi sultanate is turkic , Persians never invaded deep into India and Persia shares history with India.
As I a Mongol from Mongolia, I would like thank you for explaining the history of our founding father, Chingis Khaan based on more authentic historical accounts and objective judgements than ideological. Yes, he is the most misunderstood historical figure in the world.
Chinggis' sons are worse than him, they deserve the title of being bloodthirsty and barbarous.
As a Indian I have respect for Mongolian for teaching lessons to muslim world and make them feel the same pain they give to non muslims nations. Jai genghis baba
@@singhbritishindian1849 this just shows your hate towards muslims
Do you think he was a buddist? Just wondering
@@missourimongoose8858 Chinggis Khaan was not committed to any organized religion but used to practise Shamanism, which was the spiritual belief of Mongols before Tibetan Buddhism was introduced. But many of the ancient Mongols’ spiritual beliefs had similar elements of Tibetan Buddhism.
I’ve said this for a decade. GK was misunderstood. I’ve read so many historical texts where this ridiculous reductionist view is propagated. GK was far less barbaric than most conquerors. He was also far more tolerant and organised. Great video 🙏🏻 you’ve got yourself a new fan.
Bruh! Arjun bhai? BHAISAHAB YE KIS LINE MEIN AAGYE AAP?
@@adityakumarsingh4844 😂
@Arjun Kanugo two main things I learn when I read about Genghis Khan history was meritocracy and diplomacy. He choose his men well regardless of their backgrounds and practices diplomacy better than most kings in history of mankind.
Yeah there were definitely some good points about him buy you can't just ignore all the bad stuff he did. He was still a rutheless and brutal ruler who caused millions of unnecessary deaths to innocent people simply to further his own cause
True, western reductionist perspective did changed the narrative to suir them. 👍
I dare to add that, this chapter also teaches "Why shouldn't we trust blindly our fellow human beings". I wish we had a concept of visiting faculties like you, Abhijit Sir, during our school days. But I know now why not: politicians and opportunists don't want rebels. Rebellion originates only from true narratives. Kudos
Great arguments, great video, and finally someone who pronounces the name correctly! I really can't see how the "civilized Westerners" could describe India as savage, it's a civilization so rich, so profound, so magnificent. Respect from Serbia!
true, india had civilization when their ancestors were eating raw meat, inside a cave
It’s possible that it was in part propaganda. You need to dehumanize an enemy if you’re going to loot and raid them. You can also unify the Christian’s against it simply because it is different enough to do so.
@@Noumenon4Idolatry on point. 👌👍
They show Trishul and Swastik in Tengriism, and then Buddhism. As an Indian, these are clearly a brother people. Respect. 🙏 🇮🇳🇲🇳
@TALIB KHAN and where did you find all these?
@TALIB KHAN I'm definite that you're not being rational, you're just being carried away by your affinity towards your bloody Islamic sires.
C'mon just bcz we have some things in come doesn't mean we are always brothers it's just like the world adopting yoga they adopted some things from our culture.
This means we had a trade relation or something like that back then.
😂😂😂This is the most epic shit i have heard about. Indiand be like anywhere in the world if they find anyone relatable ....oh man thats my brother
@@husdffnarefbbdumbbks just like Ummah :-)
As a Mongolian I very much appreciate your content, so far you are one of the only few people to talk real facts about the histories and same time not being biased!
much love
@@peace719 Ulaanbaatar is the coldest capital city in the world and half the population lives there.
Ulaanbaatar’s average annual temperature is -1.3C while the second coldest capital city’s annual average temperate is +3.5C
It's biased history. lol this man even calling Afghanistan as India. He's just a fundamentalist Hindu, spreading his fake propaganda
@@Saif-gt9id Afghan now is nothing but then Taksashila ... HINDU propaganda you say,that land was flourished of Hindus and Buddhists, check your facts.
@@Saif-gt9id There is a mountain range in today's Afghanistan called "Hindukush". In Mahabharata, there is an imp character of mother of Kauravas called "Gandhari" who belonged to today's Kandahar. There are a lot of such mentions in the history that reveal Indians ruling Afghanistan from Ancient times.....Now don't say Hindu Fundamentalists wrote that History to save your dignity..
Love from india ❤️❤️❤️❤️
I'm so glad I found this opportunity to learn about history from an Eastern perspective ❤
well you can never fully trust history, but the way we protrayed him and the way we portrayed Alexander the Great just shows how superficial and stupid we are. The cause of this is the unbelieveble stupid thought that everything you dont know has to be somehow inferior to you and driven by low motives. I hate that a lot about us, because its wrong and dumb. I would even say that its an inherent superiority complex of the west as a whole which will be our downfall, or already is. But dont make the mistake to believe its only the west, China and parts of Arabia have the same problem.
My first real understanding of the man Genghis Khan and the Mongols is this 22-minute video I just watched. More power to you and your channel!
"The less we say about Indian historians, the better."
Best line ever.
Exactly, all these darbari historians are actually a distorians.
I liked "he didn't conquer us, so why should we pay any attention?"
An extremely stupid remark, that displays no knowledge whatsoever of Indian history or of Indian historians. I wish there was a way to flush the Internet clean of drive-by students who come to find five minutes of chewing gum for the eyes.
@@indrajitgupta3280 yeah let me guess you believe aryans were native to India despite DNA and linguistics
@@marcomartins3563 The exact opposite.
I suppose you get straight 'A's in your post-graduate classes?
As a Mongol i am astonished with your explanation. So much more researched into his character than everyone i know and heard of
Mongols were Hindus.
@@southernlights1890 chagiz khan... Mongol.. 🤔
@@sulakshanaranade6270 Hindu is a religion.
@@southernlights1890 The Mongols weren't Hindus. Mongols mostly followed Tengrism. Some Mongols converted to Buddhism, Christian, and Islam. Buddhism is based off of Hinduism but it is still a separate religion in the sense Islam and Christianity are derived from but still separate from Judaism.
Don't be carried away by false, motivated propaganda. this clip is an attempt to appropriate a Mangol legend.
After watching your video, I have developed a high degree of respect for Chengiz Khan and Mongolia
I live in America. My history teacher tried teaching us that the Roman Empire was the largest empire the world has ever seen.
However the Mongols ruled over 100,000,000 people and over 33 million square km of land.
The Romans only ruled 76,000,000 people and only 5.9 Million square km of land.
Someone needs to teach the teachers here 😂😅
One lesson I learnt from history :
If you want to know real history, ask the hunted - not the hunters.
history is written by victors, so not all the history is accurate
Raiding and demanding tribute is different than conquering and encorporating
@@joelhungerford8388 talking to people and offering protection for them to join you doesn’t seem like conquering.. taxing and Roman trade routes doesn’t seem like conquering… now real conquering requires a siege. The mongols toss a few dead bodies flown over your protective border to start the biological warfare protocols before the mongols come in and torch your town. After that force your women to have their offspring is just fundamental protocol used to assimilate you into the Mongol empire. When it comes to conquering the Mongols will have you fucked. Literally 🤣😂
Do u believed also the peanut size land of Macedonia, with enemies within and without, can travel 6000km to take on India 2500 years ago?😆
I'd never be hostile to India‼️all those fabulous meals - and good remedies ‼️
"Genghis Khan is the greatest conqueror in RECORDED history"
I appreciate that he doesn't deal in absolutes... Subscribed
@L yes
@L he even conquered china
Yes I noticed that subtlety too
Everything is NOT fair in love and war! War must have principles and love must have sacrifice!
Thank you Abhijit Chavda Sir for deciphering history as it is for the coming Generation. Your contributions to History will remain forever.
my friend i applaud you that was some great stuff.....and again it shows how the world order decides how is good who is bad....one of the best short documentaries that is based on truth not favouring what is theirs....FANTASTIC....BIG UP MY BROTHER
He explained more in 22 mins, than my history teacher could ever do in her lifetime
Facts 😂
School ki padhai bilkul bakwas hoti hai trust me mai history ke bare mae bahut padha hai and schools ki padhai mae bahut data wrong or partially right hota hai.
@@user-me6fj4ob4d yes bro NCERT me sara wrong hai Mughals/British ko glorify kia gya hai pura chapter dedicated hai
apne Bhartiya maratha, rajput inka zyada kuch nahi hai.
@@infinixgaming1791 Yes India had very great empires and all cannot be summarised but atleast they need to mention some of the names of great kingdoms who contributed towards India's glory. Like Chola, Maratha, Kushan Empire, Mauryan Empire, and many other empires and kings. One of the most underrated is Ahom Empire , one of the most powerful empires of India but sadly there are no mention of such empires in our textbooks.
@@user-me6fj4ob4d Yup I know and that's bcz Our first govt was congress and 1st education minister was Abdul azad. You know where I am going...
Our Education system Needs a big change. We are praising Mughals is like Jews Praising Hitler for his acts..
you were so correct in saying (on the Ranveer allahbadia's podcast) that Indian history textbooks only talk about who ruled over India and do not instill any sense of pride in us Indians. It gives us a loser mentality. That is also probably why we Indians immigrate to other countries because we don't have any hope left.
Learned so much from this video on Genghis Khan. I WISH and HOPE that you soon make more videos like this. I am in 12th right now and I never felt more interested in history. Thank you very much.
Seriously,???? You move out of the country because of better quality of life, obviously we dont move to poor countries
@@abdulqabeerjasim6521 Feeling of inferiority complex instilled in our system by our books?
@@casablanka208 that dude is rebuked 100 times, he has uncredible and fake, if you believe one to be trur and most authentic post it it here i will rebuke it for you
Obsolutely correct.
@@whocares3132 all these are debunked too😂 go get a life
Good story telling, but for sure, Genghis Khan is a great leader and a great soldier. Although I am a Chinese American, I dislike how the Chinese historians treat Mongols. They refer Mongols as foreigners, but when it comes to Genghis Khan's glory, they call him "our great king of China".
Genghis Khan massacred cities by cities. There was a historian who fled to India and wrote a book about conversations between the mass murderer and a Central Asia general. The general said if the Mongols killed everybody, then nobody would live to tell the stories of the Mongols. Genghis Khan did not give a damn about it, and said people who heard about the slaughter of the cities would spread the word of fear. I thought about telling this video's creator that he was mistaken that the Mongols did not attack India. I finally decided to give him the correct history. Mongol history in Central Asia was written 20-30 years after, and hence carried errors. Genghis Khan sent two generals across Indus and they fought two years. Genghis himself wanted to pass India to go back to Asia. He changed mind after dissuasion by followers using the rhino in Indus as some omen. This Indus river thing was already two years after the two generals fought in India. The Mongols in the 1250s attacked India numerous times, and from Iran, the Mongols attacked India almost every 10 to 20 years.
Wat een fascinerend verhaal en geweldig uitgelegd wat een kennis en wijsheid. Dank voor de uitleg deze kennis is nodig om dingen in perspectief te zien. Vriendelijke groet uit Nederland
Those 4k dislikes are by jalaluddin's descendants 🤣😂
You even got 💓
@Naruto Six kuch 'bhi' comment kar deta hain
@Naruto Six Look destroying mosques and his anti Islam activities doesn't mean he was the same to every religion. Also I think he hated Islam cuz they killed his grand-son, also humiliated his officials. Do you think a man of that calibre of any fucking ethnicity (Hindu, Islam, European, East Asian etc.) would tolerate that? The shah of Iran deserved that. Also Delhi sultanate became independent so you shouldn't be worrying about it.
😄😄😄😄
@Naruto Six India par mongols ke commanders ne attack kiya tha genghis khan ne nahi .
Attack jammu , punjab , delhi and nothern region mei kiye gye the
Delhi mei allauddin khilji .
Best part of the content : " History is lies that everyone agrees upon"
“Conquering is easy. Ruling is hard.” Genghis Kahn
I learned more about Genghis Khan in this video than I learned in any US history class. Thank you for the enlightenment into a part of history that been washed over in my formal education.
Same .... And I am Indian and have have parents one history major and other Fine Arts major .... And I should have known🙂
World history in the USA has been and remains sadly terrible.
@@sharonhoerr6523 l
*drt rKjhl
L
It's biased history. lol this man even calling Afghanistan as India. He's just a fundamentalist Hindu, spreading his fake propaganda
Half of what this fool said isn't the truth. This idiot's facts based on indian's fake history books
i am from Nigeria. We've suffered from fault-lines of disunity for decades; fault-lines engineered by the British colonial power when the empire was putting together for economic purposes, the pieces that make up Nigeria today. Hearing about a similar divide and rule strategy against the Mongol tribes by China just brings it home for me. today there are deep divisions in Nigeria motivated politically at home and controlled by foreign interests. But I also see Nigerians fighting on to stay together under the new organically grown brand "Naija". However we are sorely in need of a powerful unifying figure (male or female) who can create for us what GK created for his people, uniting and forge them into a single national entity. Thank you so much for this presentation, Abhijit. Most informative and inspiring.
They did the same with India
Your society is not alone bro. They did the same in India too. However the long past history and the continuous Civilisation that goes thousands of years in the BCE era certainly helped India.
Honestly India is a name given by Greek scholars in BCE. The Persians called us Hindus.
What we call ourselves the name of the land from thousands of years is Bharata. And the people are called Bharatiyas.
Nigeria never existed until the British created the nation of Nigeria. There are thousands of languages in Nigeria, with hundreds of different tribes.
@@moefinesse9878 first of all, we do not have thousands of languages in Nigeria. Secondly, does the existence of multiple languages in a country make it less of a country? I think not. Thirdly, the same Britian was cobbled together from different ethnic groups. That's the way it is for a lot of countries. Having said that, what exactly is the point you are making?
You're most welcome, Toba. Best wishes to you and Nigeria.
8:50 the reason for the Chinese aggression was what happened with the Turks a few hundred years prior. They basically learned their lesson to never let the Steppe horse tribes unite.
China had Turkic rulers, (for a time, before being assimilated), Indian sub-continent did from the Mamlukes, Trans-oxiania (Iran/Afghansitan as you say but it covers a wider area), then Asia Minor and old Byzantine and Roman lands.
And even before, the Kipchaks, Pecheneks, Bulgars (all nomadic Turkic), or the related but not Turkic Magyars (modern day Hungary). They were fleeing and managed to conquer and defeat empires along the way and basically shifted the balance of power for hundreds of years to come.
So the Chinese dynasties, being a literate society, learned its lessons and meddled even more heavily in the steppes. Stopping any such threat from ever bursting forth again.
But, as history teaches us, this sort of repression always blows back harder. And it loosed the Mongols upon the world. The most fearsome and capable conquerors and warriors we have ever seen assembled in history.
Blowing back China, Central Asia, and the Middle East back into their own dark ages, akin to the one in Europe experienced by Western Rome (and now denied by Western historians because apparently dark ages had a bad connotation..) anyway. I think it’s important to understand the history behind why the Chinese dynasties were treating the mongols in this way (and how it eventually shaped them into the very weapon they feared.)
This is a very good analysis on the character of Jhinghis Khan. I have for many years admired this man reading anything I came across about this interesting and extremely powerful man. So much so, that I named my son Temujin after him. My experience is also that very many Indian people have very deep understanding of things as they really are.
Feeling sorry for those who thought genghes khan was a muslim 😂
yeah islam was adopted by his later great-grandchildren only
@@avvishi8003 Many idiots from the Hindu right think that Khan = Muslim.
😂😂
Yes Genghis. Was not muslim but grandson became muslim sooner or later
@@sajidkadri2623 OK. And...?
So 'Khan' is actually a mongolian name originating from tengrism? The South asian muslims have claimed it now.
South Asian Muslims don't know their history or they reject the truth and facts.
@@pz2818 As someone from Bangladesh, I agree. Most people here have zero idea what their history is and mostly believe in made up bs.
@Sjrikk 😂 yea
It was more like Qha'an not Khan
@@GianHainAap. Wow, didn't know that. Thanks!
Just today I completed reading the book "Genghis Khan & the Mongol conquests 1190-1400" by Stephen Turnbull, 2003, Publisher OSPREY Publishing (Essential of Histories), and wondered why the Mongols circumvented India and continued their exploits in the direction of Iran, Middle East and Europe on Western side of Mongolia and also towards China, Russia, Burma, Siam, Vietnam, Korea, Japan, Java, Combodia and Japan on their East. Then by chance I came across this video by Abhijit explaining the reasons I was looking for. Thank you Abhijit ❤
I thought about telling this video's creator that he was mistaken that the Mongols did not attack India. I finally decided to give him the correct history. Mongol history in Central Asia was written 20-30 years after, and hence carried errors. Genghis Khan sent two generals across Indus and they fought two years. Genghis himself wanted to pass India to go back to Asia. He changed mind after dissuasion by followers using the rhino in Indus as some omen. This Indus river thing was already two years after the two generals fought in India. The Mongols in the 1250s attacked India numerous times, and from Iran, the Mongols attacked India almost every 10 to 20 years.
This was a random recommendation on my youtube, and somehow I learned way more than i expected. Thanks, and great stuff.
We want a webseries on Mongols just like Vikings.
Netflix has Marco Polo tho. It lasted for 2 seasons maybe due to lack of support.
Excuses me.. How about ATTILA THE HUNS..
@@kilosiera western audience?
It feels weird as a norwegian to watch HBO's Vikings, careful what you wish for. Seeing Ghengis Khan speak english might not do the trick
@@sirkkusalomaa4644 probably have him in full plate armor too
As a mongol i respect your knowledge of time
This was fascinating. Thank you for a new and informative perspective on a historical figure that went from being a more likely unknown man to a powerful and long remembered man.
Excellent presentation! I taught about Genghis Kahn years ago ... of how wherever he went he spread innovation ... in one Chinese region someone had invented glasses, in another they encountered ground beef and trousers which were elsewhere unknown. Genghis Kahn was a really cool dude.
I am from Vietnam who now live in America and a student of history, I have to say this is brilliant from many angles. Thx for your work.
I have a degree from the State University of New York in History. But it seems I was indeed misinformed about Genghis Khan, in what very little I was taught about him. Thank you very much for the very thorough and insightful treatment of the subject of history's greatest conqueror.
Hey Martin, why doesn't you tell your brother Sheldon Pollack to just shut up. Why he destroying indology department in American universities. Why he is hell bent to destroy our civilization study?
@@prakashtiwari8003 +1
U look like mick Foley😳
Temujin (Genghis Khan) was not Mongolia. Fudan University nankai University many universities genetic engineering 🧬 research. Tiemuzhen gene is the Han gene of Yellow River and Yangtze River. Han =Khan was completely different from other Mongol tribes. In the 13th century, the Han and Tang dynasties were in chaos. Genghis Khan's family went into exile in Mobei. After Temuzhen was born and grew up, he conquered all the small tribes in Mobei in the name of the Han people and named it --Mongol
This is an evergreen video. :)
Anyone who has an open mind and wants to see sequence of events as is should easily spend several hours watching and rewatching this video.
Causation sequence that led an individual became a principled leader, ruler.
See change in life after having seen your uncle brutally killed by Chinese for forming a coalition to stop internal conflicts caused by Chinese (sounds like today, no?). Then to see father brutally killed by Turks. Thanks Abhijit for rendering this journey in a digestible interesting fashioon. Would love to see more from "Bravehearts of Bharat"
"Indian Historians: Let's just stick to glorifying mughals"
Accuracy 100
🤣🤣🤣
Dont worry. Now historian+govt they are changing/editing history and pleasing their vote banks.
@@saifkhan-dz3oz Wrong, there is an effort to remove the wrong history and reality of mughals(turkic invaders) is being shown who committed mass genocide of Indians/Hindus
@@saifkhan-dz3oz really they changed really you peoples are enemy of world 😂 every country was good but then Islam invaded 😂 even you people don't accept and whatis changing history really 😂 destroyed thousand of temples and that was not only temples like you justa some idiotic prayer and talk about invading that temples have scriptures history idiots destroyed them even we be e thebiggest history yeah becauseits world history connect everyone don't know how many cultures you people destroyed even your ancestors also got beaten they fight but loose and nowyou are Muslim and saying shits and huh what change now we are learning from scriptures CZcamsrs proofs so you are jealous and angry but you can't do anything so jealous I am angry but ok world will be free oneday we will keep knowing our ancestors history and ancestors friends
Indian Historians were all Commies
As an ethnic Chinese in U.S. I found your lecture very informative. Your brilliant analytical mind makes your theory believable.
Thank you.
shamed of Chinese like you,this guy is talking bullshit,he knows little about real history
No one likes you go back to china
This answers some questions I've wondered about for years. Thank you!
Thanks for sharing such historical views base on the personal account and it's motivation to excel life treat. More power to the channel.
RIP for those who think Chengis Khan is Muslim.
He self declare butcher of muslim
But Great Khan is certainly big daddy of Muslims.
I thought he was muslim for years just because of that "khan"
Who thought he was Muslim you tool?
Mongolia has no religion. It believed in Shamanism, it is Nature worship. You idiots keep thinking Muhammed or Jesus is great? Lol, I suggest you idiots read Buddhism nd Hinduism. Just read without any thought of it being religious book. Koran and Bible is for morons
i"m a teacher by profession and it really pains me to know how wrongly we were informed and taught. but I sincerely feel the coming generation should know the real history of India and then take it across to the world. Thank you for a lovely eye opener information.
@Ranjit Tyagi tell me one lie....
Tell me one wrong information...
@Ranjit Tyagi It's western propaganda my friend, this is what happens when Europe and westerners dictate history, do you know Genghis Khan is seen as a barbarian and ruthless conquerer in the west? That's becuase his commanders fought some wars in Poland, Europe and when you're an enemy of someone who can dictate your history, you will painted as a ruthless barbarian and conquerer.
@@zorozoro2495 There's one famous lie that Alexandre lost at the battle of hydaspus river by Porus, which is not true.
@@BatCostumeGuy who said porus won the battle .. he lost but alexander gave back his kingdom to him because of his bravery.. that's what I came across in ancient India history...
I am from north east india ,my father race is mongoloid and my mother is sikh ❤,proud to be hindu 🕉
I'm proud to be Buddhists
@@Anant84257 we are same bro....root is same.....
@@kunaldutta3949 mangoliod mostly follow Buddhism and Sikh follow Sikh religion then how you are hindu
@@Anant84257 fool I am from India not Mongolia,,,,india have different race ,,,,,in north east India mongoloid race is dominant, in Assam mongoloid races were Hindu in majority...
@@kunaldutta3949 why you follow hindu, you should follow Buddhism
This is a fantastic video, thanks for making it. I learned a lot!
It's not often my mind is completely changed about something, but this is one of those times.
Also, it's ridiculous to compare Alexander to Genghis, given that Alexander started off as a king (after probably murdering his father) with the best army in the world his father had built and trained, while Genghis started with nothing.
One of them was also educated by Aristotle
@@j.d.1856 The other likely studied the art of war by Sun Tzu, which likely trumps anything Aristotle could teach about war and military strategy.
Jedi, the Lyvsavor
It's a good thing you added "Likely " . Doubting the abilities of one of the greatest minds in antiquity seems a little brash, even when comparing him to the great Sun Tzu.
@@arkmennis1 Aristotle was not known for military strategy. As brilliant as he was, that's not his expertise.
I had always wondered how Mongols who were tolerant and accepting of all religions (which shows compassion) would ever be genocidal. Your analysis makes me finally understand their core motive for expansion and conquering. Little is also understood about discipline in those time, fear was a major ingredient in discipline.
I think it's that they wanted to avoid uprisings while they expanded so they wouldn't have to waste troops on quelling internal affairs.
That and they didn't really care about pushing a theocracy.
@@zakariamattu8613 ohh yeah you are superior and truthful 😂😁
what a coincidence , first a Hindu killed millions of muslims and destroyed their mosques ,
later their decedent converted to muslims , and after 200 years their decedent done same with hindus that
changez khan done with muslims .
@@zakariamattu8613 ooo poor historian speaking
@@freeman6190 cry harder
Fantastic video! I've always wanted to learn more of the cultural side of this part of the world!
Absolutely excellent summary of the history of Genghis Khan. At 75, I learned a great deal about the man and his times that is motivating me to learn more. The interface of the different religions is also fascinating given their importance to the peoples of the world. The interpretation of Genghis Khan as a principled man who only attacked in retaliation for wrongs done to his people is very interesting. Thank you for this well produced lecture.
As a retired university professor I must complement you on your presentation and knowledge of the Mongols and Genghis Khan. I’v always had a fascination for ancient cultures..you have sparked that interest..we never stop learning...thank you,
I am not a mongolian neither Indian but your analysis on this is fascinating and really learned a lot.why Ginghis Khan did not invade india shows that he has God in his heart.
@True light no, they were turks who invaded india, and previously have been kicked by mongols
@True light no, turks have not originated from mongols. They do have some commonality in origin but so does the every human being on earth. But through medieval ages, both were different, turks were somewhere turkmenistan and kazakhastan, and mongols around mongolia and southern Russia. They have different languages and culture. And it was the mongols only, who kicked the ass of turks and forced large number of them to today's turkey. And mughal king babur claimed to have his mother from mongols but there is no proof and it was a trend among turkic and other rulers to associate themselves to mongols and genghis khan. Even if some had mongol mothers, does it make them half or full mongol??? 😏absurd
@True light What you said is Kinda true but kinda wrong we can't say like the turks originated from The mongols yes essentially the turks and the mongols had the same culture but afterwards the turks started following Islam and the turko mongols that you are talking about are the ones that followed the Islamic culture. Yes one of their parents was mongol but yet they followed the culture which their Turkic parent followed not the one that mongols followed. So they are the for springs of Genghis khan is just for the sake of saying. The Religious , Cultural , ethical value that they followed were totally different from that what Genghis khan followed. So comparing them with Genghis khan is just baseless.
@True light turks are NOT mongols, mongolian belongs to tungusic languages of korean japanese and siberian, turks are tartars who were servants of mongols
@@denvergamingzone9766 No NO commonality between Mongols are turks, Mongols are steppe people, turks are farmers who migrated from munczhuria region in northern chi 0na
Loved the chapter.. It has definitely changed my perspective.. Thank you so much Sir😊
Absolutely brilliant description of a Great Man
Having done Martial Arts for over 50 years my mentors have been Sun Tzu, Lao Tzu and Genghis Khan and have always believed that they were not only strength but Integrity
A quality unfortunately confused with morality by most people
It is the quality that truly defines who you are
Thank you for enlightening the public to what a true hero is
Most loved quote: “Do you know what this is called ? “PRINCIPALS”.
Do you mean "principles?" O tempora, o mores!
Please give the time stamp buddy.
@@cygnus2693 19:00
I was first introduced to the greatness of GK by one Buddhist taxi driver in Manali , India. Now this lecture has reconfirmed what he had told me. Before this we were only told as kids that GK was only a barbarian, plunderer.
@HEY HEY HEY what the CZcamsr said in this video
What greatness? He was a mass killer and slaughtered millions of ordinary people who had nothing to do with war
He was very smart.
@@sappudusappudu4329 Did he not defend himself according to this video GK?
Thank you sir for your wonderful narration on the life of Chengis Khan and the reasons of not invading India. Although there is no historical written evidence on that but the reasons yyou have provided are most accurate, true and logical.
Thank you for your time in research. You have enlightened me to facts I have never known.
Ranveer's Podcast Brings me here 🙏🚩😎
Ranveer?
@@prakharprabhat585 ranveer allahbadia (now as prayagraji)
Me too
Yes me too bro
+1
As a Westerner this is refreshing. We live in our own bubbles and it makes us spiritual and academically soft. Recently I have become a Nomad and I want to travel and meet people throughout the world. I think we as a species need to reinvent ourselves and find meaning in our own lives.
I will be returning to your wonderful channel. Thank you.
Westerners should not be allowed to dominate this world again, the world has suffered enough because of y'all, y'all cannot think nor can y'all understand cultures around this planet, y'all cannot understand world intrigue or history, y'all have distorted this planet's history to portray Europeans as su perior to others, y'all have written world history according to the west's perspective. You westerners are fit to be followers and not leaders.
@@mangopudding5979You sound very much like a Westerner trying to stir the kettle.
In india sanyasis (monks) do kind of nomadic travel across India to reinvent themselves towards their journey of enlightenment
Great point more people should be principled like that. Thank you for shedding light on this
Thank you Sir, I have read about Genghiz Khan during my shool days about 50years ago however you gave a very clear and honest explaination of this Great Man and I really Respect and admire him even more now that you have given a very astounding History of this once Great Leader who showed the world Who and What he really is but mistook by racist bigots who painted a negative picture of this Amazing Iconic Human Being Who will never ever comeback to this Planet Again, Thanks Once Again for this brief lesson of past history
I learned more about Genghis Khan in 22 minutes than I ever learned in high school or college combined! Thank you!
Exactly! 😂
Thank you so much!! Brilliant and I definitely hope it goes viral if it hasn't already 😃. My PhD is in philosophy I am no indianologist although I do teach seminars in Hinduism Buddhism and some of the Chinese traditions at my university (Mississippi State University). I wholeheartedly agree that Mongolian culture is very much underrepresented for the historiographical reasons that you most succinctly and eloquently expressed. I knew of Genghis Khan's sense of modesty and honor, Not to mention his organizational and military genius, combined of course with the unsurpassed equestrian might of Mongolian archers (basically born on horseback) but some of the details you described about his reasons for declaring war are quite an eye-opener. In short you might say that he adopted in practice much of what is described by scholars of war as just war theory. Thank you so much again!! I will definitely share this with my students.
Please write an unbiased paper on Hindu history. The west terribly needs it 🙏🏽🥺
Wow! This is History. This is the way to narrate it! 🎉
Excellent!
Most informative and truly enlightening.
Your delivery was also superb.
Lot of ground work done.
Keep it up.
Hats off to you.
Please give references to some books or material for us to read more on Genghis Khan.
I m an Indian tamang . We are originated from Mongolia it’s nice to know about our ancestors !!!
great to know
Wow
Tamang people are not mongolian, they are not from Mongolia, You don't even know the difference between Mongoloid and Mongolian, Tamang people are Mongoloid not Mongolian.
@@sadanandkumbhar9960 she is wrong.
@@jeerudra Tamang people are mongoloid and not Mongolian. She is wrong.
NCERT books are inferiority building blocks of Indian life. These needs to be rewriting .
They were designed by prof Nurul Hasan and approved by Mrs Indira Gandhi.....
It depends on how you see it. The history needs to be unbiased. If we as Indians have a history of being defeated, let it be so. No point in vainglorious whitewashing. But let us take lessons from it. The key lesson is that we were not United. We should remember this and never let it happen again. The Chinese have realised this. We have not.
@@pradman81There is great difference between India and China.China has got only one race i.e Han and one language for more than 3000 years .In India there is vast diversity in language, race and religion.China has been fortunate in having great dynasties of emperors ruling over it for more than 2500 years and has been able to withstand foreign invasions except that of Mangols.
@@sureshpandey9485 True. Ethnic bonds alone do not define unity. If not, then the entire ME and the Islamic Maghreb would be one country. The Chinese are real leaners of history. They look at things like the warring states period, Taiping rebellion even the last Chinese CCP-Koumintang war and realize that their only way to avoid chaos is unity. They value social order over freedom. We never try to learn from history. Perhaps the policy makers might but it is not inked into our psyche like it has been for the Chinese.
@@sureshpandey9485 China actually has many ethnic groups and languages too. It's just that the Han are dominant.
Thank you sharing this video ! 🙏🌷
Thank you for this insight into history! Very much appreciated and enjoyed! 💖
This is the standard that all must follow when discussing history, and learning about amazing people like Genghis Khan. I consider this a privilege to have been able to listen you and your presentation. Thank you!