The END of an Era | First Time Playing Red Dead Redemption | Part 16
Vložit
- čas přidán 8. 08. 2023
- Thanks for subscribing & liking the video!
Shoutout to the Patreon Contributors: Aaron Chandler, Anna DiLiberto, Callum Whalley, Eric, OrangeLion, Johnathan Mahaffey, Ridge_runner, Denis Rivas, Ido Gordin, james flack, John Mayon, Micheal Stebbins, Mikko inc, Simon Pickard, Whitney Fishback
And thank you to all the channel members! (There are now so many of you, I don’t have enough room in video descriptions to name you alll, this is crazy!)
Thank you all for making these videos possible!
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Support only if you WANT to... CZcams content will always be free!
Throne Gifts: thronegifts.com/u/themirandal...
Meme-berships: czcams.com/users/themirandalor...
MERCH STORE: themirandalorian.myspreadshop...
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Follow my socials for updates!
Twitter: / mirandalorians
Instagram: / mirandalorians
Discord: / discord
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Looking for a deal on games? Check out this affiliate link:
Humble Bundle Partner: www.humblebundle.com/?partner...
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
FOR BUSINESS ONLY:
themirandalorian@nevaly.com
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Thanks for tuning in for your daily dose of GOOD VIBES & VIDEO GAMES :)
#reddeadredemption #johnmarston #gameplay #playthrough #walkthrough #gameplaywalkthrough #gaming - Hry
John didn’t run with Abigail and Jack because he wanted them to live a free life, he sacrificed himself for his family so that Ross can be satisfied with the Marston family. Jack is such a tragic character, RDR is the only gaming franchise that has genuinely made me cry.
Wouldn’t be shocked if Red dead redemption 3 or a Red dead Revelations is about Jack. “Revenge is a fools game” and as shown in this franchise actions do have consequences. People always claim for whatever reason that a Jack game would *need* to be mafia or ww1. I mean sure you could do that. Or just follow the Example of the 1914 Wild West styled Epilogue in Rdr1 and make a full game. As long as the game is designed to still feel like a Wild West game nobody’s gonna care about the year. If they did people would’ve been complaining all the way back since 2010 about the unrealistic, inaccurate nature of the 1914 Epilogue section. The Mafia’s prime years didn’t even start until 1920. America didn’t even get involved in WW1 until April 1917 and we don’t start drafting until May. So we got a few years to work with for Jack without overlapping anything else as long as we keep the story within 1914, 1915, 1916 and the early part of 1917.
And none of the theories about Jack’s life after this game are 100% confirmed canon by Rockstar. So he could’ve died a Outlaw, a Soldier, just an average Joe, or a successful old man as far as we know. Personally, if his game ever does happen, I hope rockstar chooses the latter.
@@redt8311 if we ever get a RDR3, I think it should take place before the blackwater massacre. The Protagonist should be Mac Callendar, I imagine the last cutscene is him getting murdered by agent Milton during the blackwater massacre. If I’m being honest though, RDR3 wouldn’t work like RDR1 & 2. I feel like an epilogue to Jack would be just stretching it, he’s only 19 in 1914, we see him for 1 duel, they’d have to go into the future for Jack to be as good as John or Arthur and that wouldn’t really be about the Wild West.
The reason the prequel idea wouldn't work is because who are we gonna play as after the blackwater massacre if we know everything that happens already, after finishing the story of RDR3 you’d just play as Arthur and the camp will be in colter 24/7 lol. I just don’t know what they can do for this idea to be possible.
The next ‘Red Dead’ should be about the prime times of the Wild West with brand new characters and a whole different story imo.
@@frank1313instead of a red dead redemption 3 I would be better if they make red dead revolver 2 or something, something different from the main story line and not ruin it.
@@frank1313 Why you people want another game about the same gang?? RDR3 should be about completely new characters. If they wanted to show the blackwater massacre, they would've done it in rdr2
@@lepersonnage371 did you even read my comment? I literally said the next Red Dead should have brand new characters, story, time, place etc… but I was saying that IF they were to make a 3rd game about Dutch’s gang, then I think it should be a prequel to RDR2, it sounds like a cool idea, but later on I wrote that it wouldn’t work at all.
"When I'm gone, they'll just find another monster." Dutch was right. It's one of those things that you never see in the moment but when you look back, it was all pointing in that direction. Ross was never gonna let John live, he was part of the gang, and he wanted the gang wiped out. Ross used John to take out all the gang members, made him do all the hard, dangerous work while he stayed in his office, and then ambushed him like a coward.
Well said
It was so dirty how they had John do all that work just to stab him in the back like that. I was so pressed when I got to that part where John walks out of the barn I literally only targeted Ross when I went into deadeye mode for the last time. I was like please just let me hit this guy with one shot, I just wanted to at least take a ear or leave a scar lol.
Might be cowardly yeah, but it is the smarter way to go about wiping out the Van Der Linde gang.
If I got a beef with a quick draw expert, I'm not dueling him on the street... I'm gonna shoot him in the back.
So of all the fighting members of the gang who would have been known to the agents, only Charles managed to get away. From a story perspective I’m guessing it’s because he went so far away they couldn’t get to him even if they knew where he was, or they just simply couldn’t find him because he went away and lived a quiet life not attracting attention. Or for all anyone knows he could have died by this point too.
@@terminallumbago6465Sadie and Pearson and Mary Beth etc
Also, they called back to this moment in RD2. When Jack first meets Ross, he is fishing with Arthur when Ross comes up to them with Milton. In fact, the only on-screen dialogue Ross has in RD2 is when he tells Jack to enjoy the fishing. Fifteen years later, Jack hunts him down in the same way and both times Ross is carrying a shotgun.
Lol Ross tells Jack to enjoy fishing, and then many years later Jack kills Ross while Ross is fishing.
@@arcticfirefly5777 Technically, Ross was duck hunting but they did both interrupt each other on their trips.
@@Miller_Boxx Ah shoot, you're right. That's a rifle/shotgun, not a fishing rod 🤣
He talks in the Red Dead Redemption mission, too
@@gachastem6522 You hear him shouting but you never actually see him. The scene fishing is the only time you see and hear him at the same time.
The part where Jack and Arthur go fishing in RDR2 still gives me chills. That little boy is the one who finally killed Ross!
By the river for being mean to Uncle Arthur too. Revenge is a dessert best served cold.
@@stevemccann4166 "Revenge is a fool's game" (c) Arthur Morgan
When you complete the epilogue in RDR2, John and Abigail are standing in the exact same spot where they will be buried, years later.
I'M CRYING NOW THANKS A LOT!
@@TheMirandalorianyou can find Uncle sleeping in *that* spot on the porch during the epilogue too
It's also the same spot Strange Man says is a "good spot." Also the same place they got married at.
Even though Arthur was tragic some of us were already traumatized by John and it didn't quite hurt as much (still extremely painful though)
“May contain too much awesomeness”
John: 💀
RIP
“he saw things no boy should see” true, jack had front row seats to seeing kieran ride in with his head off …
I always wondered where Jack got that brown jacket from when you play as him.
After playing Red Dead 2 though, now I get the feeling that it's Arthur's jacket he wears alongside his father's hat.
Rather fitting honestly.
He is also wearing a scarf similar to the one Dutch wears in RDR 2.
It's not the same jacket, not the same color, not the same material/textile
It would have been fun, but it's just a different jacket
Three shots by john at the strange man, three members dead, one alive. Gotta love the tiny details
@@L4ftyOne ik thats why i said "one alive"
That final scene with the Strange man is where John, Abigail and Uncle are buried too.
@@stevemccann4166 Yep sure is
Ross first words to Jack:
"Enjoy your fishing, kid... while you still can"
*How ironic, Mr. Ross c:*
and the cycle of violence continues the work john and abigail did and try to steer jack away from that life he ends up falling in the same place becomes exactly what they feared he’d become
Little Jack did say he wanted to be a gunslinger.
@@stevemccann4166 a self fulfilling prophecy
@@chrisbergsten1429 I also whacked the wife and brother to get rid of any lose ends. However, Pinkerton guy at station might have put two and two together. It was quid pro quo for Jack too as Ross, his wife, and brother for pa, ma and uncle.
i personally think johns death is sadder than arthurs
@@SiR_ES7EVESI found Arthurs to be more sad as he did not get to live the life he wanted. Seeing him slowy die was awful. Plus i had him built like a tank at the start and by the end he was reallly skinny also seeing him with High honour try to make things right was really powerful. Johns death hits hard as well but both games are only games that have made me tear up.
100% Johns hits harder for me and I played 2 before I played 1, I just like John as a character more, at least RDR1 John.
I was more invested in Arthur and thiought the writing got even better and they were able to create way more depth to the characters with the background they already had with this game going into that one. Arthur hit me harder than any character in any game ever.
There was solace in that Arthur got to die the death he always wanted. Johns death was not peacful, it was brutal and gory. Both were noble, Arthur deciding to help John as his last act of goodness and John not running away and condeming his family to a life on the run . I cant decide for myself. Johns death was more unexpected to me but as a result less melancholic and in a way less beautiful than Arthurs final redemption. @@John-996
John's death was very cruel. I really liked Arthur, he's a great character, but John is my favorite character. And every time I listen to Dead Man's Gun I feel very sad for John and others.
56:54 "The day John Marston stopped shooting" so sad... great playthrough!
Jack is officially an outlaw now. The cycle continues.
@@fakeninja4447 Killing a retired government agent isn't legal. So.... outlaw.
He killed him in a duel, that was legal at that time
He's an outlaw, but never will be hunted for that (happens in mexico, no one know it's jack marston who killed ross, probably authorities wouldn't care even if it happened in usa)
"the day john marston stopped shooting."
- jack marston
Literally my favorite game. I love watching people play it for the first time. Watched countless play throughs before 2 came out, and countless since.
23:10 It's both so sad and so cute the way Bonnie kicks at the dirt and sadly stares down at the ground, like a shy or embarrassed little girl.
I know you probably won’t hear them but , like all of jacks voice lines in the post game are the most depressing thing ever. If I remember correctly if he gets in a gun fight he can say “ come on I don’t have anything to live for anyway”😢
Unlike Arthur's death, you didn't know John was going to die, it was sudden. John was the first protagonist I ever cried over. He's written so well
Also I'm pretty sure you meant to say 1914 when reading Abigail's grave, not 1714
When you played 2, how long did it take you to make the connection that Milton's go-fer when you went fishing with Jack would be John's killer?
@@MilesjDoyle Man can you shut the hell up
@@MilesjDoylebro nobody fucking cares
I disagree. The first thime i played this game i knew from the start John would have to die, subconciously, but when Dutch died and the game didnt end i knew. I felt dread while playing this game. Honestly it was very creepy, like i was on borrowed time. Whats funny is that i didnt feel that way about rdr2 even though i knew the gang would fall apart.
Though, to some of us I guess, the "first protagonist we cried over" was Emile Chaillon. (Valiant Hearts).
1:09:16 the death of John was so shocking that she even misread the age of their death and the gap between their death
the shock knocked me back a couple centuries LMAO!
I love how they handled the concept of revenge throughout this series and how perfectly they illustrate how it’s just not worth it.
John was found by the Bureau of Investigation (formerly the Pinkertons) because he chose to hunt down Micah for revenge. Abigail tried to stop him, even screaming to him that he was risking everything they had. But he was blinded by his need for payback.
Jack ultimately follows the same blunder as his father, choosing to hunt and kill the man that wronged his family. And honestly, who could blame him? If someone murdered my father, I don’t think I’d be able to walk away from the chance to murder them right back.
But in choosing revenge, Jack rendered his father’s sacrifice meaningless. John gave his life so the Bureau would have no further reason to chase Abigail and Jack, and so they could live normal lives free of John’s outlaw past. He gave everything for Jack to be able to escape the sins of his father.
But now Jack has become the very thing his parents tried so hard to prevent him from being: a gunslinging outlaw. As far as anyone knows, he murdered a highly decorated retired federal agent; few probably know anything about who Ross really was, and even those who do probably are those who helped cover it up. So Jack will now have to sleep with an eye open for agents that might come for him, and that will probably eventually lead to him going on the run and resorting to crime to survive.
i don't care about the consequences
that was for my boy john
and yeah they will try and hunt jack down cause the guy he asked to find ross will be onto him now
Not necessarily. Jack never told them his name, so they would only be able to go off a description of him, plus they were in Mexico at the time. Apparently, Jack lived all the way up to around the 1980’s and wrote a book.
john: he aint gonna be no frontier gunslinger
Jack: im looking for edgar ross
Arthur (1899): "When the time comes, you gotta run and *don't look back* ...this is over"
Some years later John comes to Micah for revenge.
1:04:29 John (1911): “You keep riding and *don’t look back* .”
Some years later Jack comes to Ross for revenge.
John will always be the heart of Red Dead for me. He was my first hero. I'll never get over his death but I understood why it happened to redemption is more important than living. By the way, this is why everyone was so excited to play and see John in Red Dead 2, because we never thought we'd see him again.
Jacks first time meeting Agent Ross was fishing with Arthur, so the ending was fitting.
Yup, that was an awesome call back.
I wouldn’t mind if this is the ending of the whole story. But I also wouldn’t be shocked if it isn’t. like Arther said “revenge is a fools game” and actions have consequences in this franchise. Jack literally did the same thing his dad did by choosing revenge and that’s what caused this whole game to happen.
@@Z777TON3R.Kno, it was fishing, you won't be getting very many likes
Arthur's death is So sad but John's death is so tragic and brutal and unfair.
You're right at the end having a different experience if you played rdr1 before 2, at the beginning when Arthur and Javier find John in the mountains I fanboyed so hard when we see John the first time and the rdr1 theme is heard faintly in the background when he's getting carried by Arthur. I also spent the first few hours wishing I was playing as John instead of Arthur before he eventually warmed up to me lol, hell I'm probably one of the rare humans in this world that had mixed feelings at the epilogue, still devasted about Arthur but lowkey happy I was playing as John again
“When I’m gone, they’ll just find another monster. They have to, to justify their wages.”
Dutch
"Enjoy your fishing kid, while you still can" - Edgar Ross to young Jack, standing by a river, 1899. As somebody who played this game first, the realization of that blew my mind. For them it started by a river, and it ENDED by a river. What a wild ride.
And in the end the tragedy is that Arthur AND John's sacrifice was for nothing. Jack ended up a well read and educated outlaw with a problem with authority... just like Dutch.
Im pretty certain rdr3 will be another prequel. It cant be with jack because the wild west years are over in his time. There are plenty of stories in rdr2 we never got to see. In rdr3 we'll probably have everyone back in their young years robbing blackwater, then the story will be told and finished.
Remember the "I know you" stranger mission?
The mysterious man is believed to be either Death, or the Devil, and his final meeting with John ends with him saying "This is a beautiful spot", while standing right where John and Abigail end up getting buried.
When you did the strange man missions, John shoots 3 times at him. When he shoots a fourth time his gun jams. The three gunshots foreshadowed John, Abigial, and Uncle's deaths. The fourth shot got james because it foreshadowed Jack, who survived. And when he says "This is a fine spot." During the final talk, he says that because he's standing where John and Abigail are buried.
@@keithcole8536 Definitely. When you do more research and discover that you did encounter the Strange Man in RDR2 and witnessed some of his works, it's a total mind=blown moment.
"I'm an accountant of sorts." Still chilling every time I watch/play it.
In the end Arthur's sacrifice only bought John 10 years
I wasn't ready. I knew it was coming and I still wasn't ready. Rockstar's doing a really good job at making you care deeply about these characters and then, in the end, killing them all. Damn them.
I can't be the only one who thought "Okay I was meant to do something here, restart and this try this again.... Wait why am I playing as Jack!!! Oh shit." This was up there with my first experience with Fallout New Vegas. I shoot a named character and expected a game over but the game continued and that was when I realised that person wasn't coming back. Funny enough both games came out the same year.
I LOVE FALLOUT NEW VEGAS!!!
@@TheMirandalorianyeah you and everybody else.
I didn't like how you see the end from the start.
Step one, go to Vegas
Step two, prepare for battle of Hoover dam.
Step three, Hoover dam.
They could have added some twists and turns.
"this is a fine spot."
- mystery man
The Strange Man was right when he said ‘This is a fine spot’. 😉😉
Fun fact: The location of the graves is where the 'strange man' said: "This is a fine spot".
Had so much fun watching you experience this for the first time!!! I remember playing this back in 2010 when it came out. Rdr2 was the right call to be a prequel. It bleeds into rdr1 so perfectly
Amazing playthrough! But for someone who loved reading the newspapers in the game, you probably missed the most important one which was the the last one you can buy as Jack! Gives closure to some of the characters John met through his journey!
In the end, both Arthur and John's efforts failed. Arthur wanted John's family to live the life he wanted, and John wanted the same for Jack. But, John choosing to get revenge on Micah led Ross straight to him, and led to the events that brought John to his demise. Jack, too, decided to choose revenge and killed Ross, becoming the one thing both Arthur and John worked so hard to try to prevent: A gunslinger.
"This IS a fine spot. See ya around, Cowboy." The Strange Man
I love your energy. Your videos brighten my day.
good! i'm very glad! have a wonderful day!
I'm surprised she managed avoiding someone leaking the fate of John Marsten as much as she loved the first game but both were amazing, they rarely make em' this good anymore. :)
This IS the first game little kid. And shes played it before. Its a fake reaction.
@@MisterDevos She played RD2 first as in the first rd game she played. Of course I know this is the first game. 🥴🙄
@@MisterDevosShe said she watched her brother playing it before, she didn't know the whole story. And i'm pretty sure he knows this is the first game, little kid.
im honestly shocked too... i tend to avoid spoilers by any means necessary!
@@carl_consumer.of.realityNo she said she spent hours watching him play that story and was familiar with John as a character. It’s a fake blind reaction because “blind reactions” are popular as hell when it comes to this game, there’s several small youtubers that built their career off this franchise
"The day John Marston stooped shooting"
25:35 when you started to pick up on what was comming, that was how i felt the entire game when i first played it.Rdr is so depressing after rdr2. Everything that happened so that Jack would not become an outlaw, all for nothing, all because John killed Micah and thats how the Pinkertonss found John when Arthur wanted John to not look back and Jack to live not as an outlaw. But Jack has to take revenge, repeating the cycle. Also some awesome details:
-1 Jack meets edgar Ross on a river with Arthur while fishing and then Jack kills Ross in a river while he hunts
-2 In a dialogue in the second game little Jack says: I dont wanna read, i wanna be a gunslinger. And Abigail says: over my dead body! Which is exactly what happens
-3 the 3rd part of the Stranger mission "I know you" ,where you meet the strange man, he says to John TWO times that the place they are standing on "is a real fine spot". That spot is where Johns grave is located.
I hope you see this. Your playthrough was amazing and you picked up on a lot of subtle things
the spot he is buried is where the strange man said "this is a nice spot"
What an amazing series Miranda!! Thank you so much for it! 👍🏽🙂
50:08 Jack probably wanted to prove to John he could hunt on his own.
"Your father killed himself with the life he lived"
Such a great line that gets easily forgotten about. The life that John lived was going to get him killed eventually. John knew that the odds were that Ross wasn't going to let John walk away completely after all the terrible things John had done over the years. Ultimately I don't believe Jack will get his own game if only because the way of the outlaw by this point in the timeline is gone for good.
If you think about it Jack ends the game as a murderer on the run which is exactly what John and Abigail wanted Jack to avoid doing, Jack's entire family has been destroyed by the government but the main cause of that destruction was the fact that his family (John and Abigail) were outlaws themselves who did many terrible things to get to where they were and those terrible things eventually caught up to them in the form of the government agents catching them and forcing John to turn against his former gang.
I don't think the story of Jack can really be continued in a Red Dead game given that the West has essentially been civilized at this point and Jack himself realizes that the outlaw gang lifestyle doesn't work anymore in a civilized world. He also realizes that in a more civilized world, his own sins are much more likely to catch up with him and that he is not going to be able to run away from them. So I think that Jack does settle down and attempts to live a quiet life elsewhere, becoming an author. After all given the sort of person he killed in Ross I doubt very much that the government will really be all that interested in wanting to track Jack down for Ross's death especially if Jack doesn't do anything else to draw attention to himself.
Enjoyed your playthrough of RD. Look forward to your next adventure.
1:11:39 How badly Jack treats his horses and "Work you damn nag" became a meme.
Watching this series was epic and i got a bit sad at the end as i thought it was all over but then you reminded me of undead nightmare, cant wait for this 🙂
i'm just warning you now! my version is super buggy for some reason, but it leads to some really funny moments!
I have watched every episode of this. Thank you Miranda! Great fun.
RDR and RDR2 are my favorite games of all time. Glad you played them in the order you did. I think RDR2 gave more emotional attachment to all the characters in the long run. Love your content.
One think I should mention is that Jack and Ross' first and last time they met all ended up next to a river! The 1st time is when Arthur takes him to fishing, they are confronted by the Pinkertons, which included Ross. And now the story came this far.
my favourite part of these games are the themes and context they tackle, especially the dying of the west and cycle of violence being so inveitable, and jack becoming the thing his father fought to prevent.
In this essay I will:
I feel like there are definitely different perspectives based on which order you played the games in. Speaking as someone who played the first game first, I didn’t really have a chance to see characters like Bill, Dutch, and Javier as anything but villains who stood in the way of John getting back to his family. It wasn’t until the second game where those gaps are filled in and you get to see the background and the relationships between the characters. So if you played the second game first, you already went into RDR1 with that backstory in mind.
On the flip side though, there are moments and callbacks in RDR2 that possibly resonated more with those of us who played RDR1 first. It was nice to finally know how John got his scars, and see Beecher’s Hope built from the ground up, and learn how Uncle became part of the Marston family, and other smaller moments like John coming out of the cabin wearing his RDR1 iutfit, or posing in the same way as the RDR1 cover. Or exploring New Austin (especially Armadillo and Tumbleweed) in the second game, or hearing certain characters mentioned like Bonnie MacFarlane, Landon Ricketts, and Professor MacDougal. Or hearing certain lines used in the second game that were also in RDR1 (most notably the speech Dutch gives to John on the cliff) and certain comments foreshadowing the events of RDR1.
So really both games add emotional weight and significance to different parts of the games that they wouldn’t otherwise have, but I do feel like you get a better experience if you play RDR2 first because it gives the events of RDR1 and the relationships between the characters more significance that makes for a more compelling story.
RDR2: Ross: Enjoy your fishing Kid while you still can
RDR: Jack: Enjoy your fishing Old Man while you still can.
It really is so cool all the ways they connected the two stories from either perspective. You can play them in any order and it will still be special and connect dots in satisfying ways. Makes me wonder how much of RDR2 was already written and how much they filled in.
You never disappoint with your choice of games Miranda! I have enjoyed this journey with you. Good gaming and good vibes always!
awww good! i'm glad!!
@@TheMirandalorian I can’t wait to watch you play the Undead version!
This was an awesome playthrough! Can't wait to see what the Undead part is about as I've never played it.
In the beginning Ross found Jack by the river, but by the end, Jack found Ross by the river
I love how when jack kills Ross he look at his gun and reflects on what he just did
Then on the credits song it starts whit "your hands upon a dead man's gun"
I just finished watching this whole playthrough! This was such a fun and hilarious ride watching the game through your eyes!
There would have been a newspaper before the final mission as Jack that had the fates of most of the NPCs in the game.
Bonnie eventually got married, though it isn’t stated who her husband is.
Marshal Johnson stepped down as marshal and went as far away from Armadillo as possible.
Seth eventually found his treasure and returned to his family.
Irish died after his gun discharged in an outhouse.
Abraham Reyes eventually became the president of Mexico but he became just as much of a tyrant as Allende.
Professor MacDougal got kicked out of Yale again after he attacked another professor with a croquet mallet and climbed onto a rooftop naked.
And Landon Ricketts died peacefully in his sleep of natural causes at an old age, having moved back to the US after that last mission with John.
I always see you play my favorite games to see if you feel like me in the history of videogames, and the truth is that you transmit very good vibes. I love your videos and how you enjoy videogames like me, new subscription!! (PS: you Will play DLC of zombies?) translated with Google translate, I'm Spanish
I remember the first time playing was shocked saying the main chracter die in game really hit hard. I feel like great with jack killing Ross by a river something Arthur would have done years ago had jack not been with him. Made so pissed seeing Ross point a shotgun at Arthur and knowing i could not kill him in 2. Its funny jack first meeting him and later killing by river. After RDR2 the ending with jack feels like depressing with jack being alone on ranch. "People Don't forget, nothing is forgiving".
Such a great series I’ll miss this! I’m very excited for the next game though!!
i'm sure i will have many more playthroughs to come!
@@TheMirandalorian I’m hyped for the GTAV series
Always a good day when a new video is out keep it up 🙌
Another fun watch-along! Thanks Mirandalorian! Who had a worse death: Marston or Morgan?
Oh man.... John was more shocking, but Arthur you kinda saw it coming!! But I would say Arthur hurt more 😭😭😭
And thank you!!
Edgar Ross and jack Marston first met when jack was a little boy by a lake, how ironic it ends with their final meeting is also by a lake
Arthur to John; I want you... To not look back
John to Jack: Just keep riding and don't look back
Ross lighting that cigar like "John Marston, our debt is settled!"
When I first played this game back in 2010 i played the last mission with my brother and when John got killed he got angry and said I killed John cause I didn’t kill all of them in dead eye. So I replayed the whole mission and both of us were heartbroken that John dies no matter what.
Jack meets Ross for the first time by a river and kills him by a river...karma is a bitch.
The ending of rdr2 is even more sad when you know that arthur simply just extended johns life for a bit
I don't really see people mentioning this, but I can't imagine I'm the only one who gets chills playing RDD2 whenever someone mentions death to John even casually, like Arthur saying, "Don't die just yet, cowboy." But the line that tops them all is Abigail's: "How many times do I gotta bury you, John Marston?" and John reply of "Never." Sends shivers down my spine...
If you read the newspaper now as Jack you'll find out what happened to the other characters. This game was my first love and it really does hit different now knowing the second game and how that plays out. I had no idea how Dutch saying I have a plan was such a big thing when i played this one first years ago but now it does give you chills knowing why playing the second.
Undead Nightmare is so good, and you get another go round with John 👍👍
watched every episode love your channel straight up😇💯
ps red dead redemption is my favourite game always play it
both 1 and 2 are amazing games!
Watched every second of this play through. Yelled at the screen a few times. Trying to say don't do that last mission with Jack stop at the grizzly bear and after that everybody is just chilling out at at the ranch
There is a book in Michael’s house in GTA5 titled Red dead redemption by J.marston. I like to think you are playing the story Jack wrote.
Run and don't look back...heard that someplace before
i cant believe you held it together Miranda. i played this game, watched many people play it. yet here i sit bawling my eyes out and you're not
i was sooooo mad looooool!!!!
I was literally the same way like when I saw John’s death I was angry and shocked rather than sad and crying
Red Dead 2 dialogue:
Abigail:How many times do i have to bury you John Marston?
John:Never,you ain't never burying me
Here's a morbid but legitimate question: what happened to the bodies of all those soldiers?
Like, did the army have to come back and collect them?
When Jack and Abigail are up in the hillside sobbing and the music is all "Don't bury me no-oooooooooow..." are there army guys just awkwardly out of frame loading bodies onto a carriage like "Ah, Jesus, just don't make eye contact, just focus on the job..."
Johns end is even more devestating after Rdr2.
Amazing video John Marston and aruther are both in heaven, I guess Jack Marston will be the main character in red dead redemption 3,
Yknow I feel like ik what Jack Feels now, lost my father back in August 27 I'd honestly never will watch a death scene without thinking of my father now, I'll miss him
When John met Abigail that was a beautiful friendship I loved every single episode of this walkthrough we love u Miranda ❤ x
thank you for watching, and even more for enjoying it!
I too played RDR2 first. So glad you shared this playthrough. Now, I don't have to. I was shocked at Johns death. He was always my second favorite character, Sadie was #1.
SADIEEEE! i would NOT turn down a rdr game all about her!
This was exactly my sentiment when I first played this game so many years ago. It was at the time my favorite all time game, and it was never supplanted until the release of RDR2. Sure GTA is rockstar’s money maker, but the single player focused franchises like RDR and Max Payne are absolute BANGERS.
It's even more tragic that Jack became exactly what John and Abigail didn't want him to become.
my theory is the strange man is the grim reaper, that saying when death touches you, he takes you away. he put his hand on johns shoulder the first time they met. "this is a fine spot" where john gets buried ☠
God, I love this game 😭 I'm currently replaying it on the Series X, and it looks beautiful 😍
Such a masterpiece of a game. I was fortunate enough to play it back when it came out. Cannot wait for you to play UN.
Btw, you should totally look into starting the GTA games, especially gta 4 and san andreas.
I played the first RDR1 first, so I've always wondered what it would be like playing RDR2 first, having so much history of story and playtime with John and to see it end like the way it did. It hit hard just only playing RDR1, I'm bettin it hit a lot harder having played the prequel first. All of that effort John put into getting the life he wanted and to have it end like that, truly tragic.
Lesson: When Arthur tells you to walk away and don't look back. Walk away and don't look back. He should have never went back for Micah. That's how the Pinkertons found him.
John filled with holes like swish cheese
Miranda: Maybe we can revive him?
Even Lazarus would have been a big ask after that.