Let Ireland send asylum seekers back to the UK? Feat. Lizzie Cundy & Marvyn Harrison | Storm Huntley
Vložit
- čas přidán 30. 04. 2024
- The UK has said that it will not take back asylum seekers who cross the border from Northern Ireland into the Republic of Ireland.
That's unless the EU accepts that the UK can send asylum seekers back to France.
Dublin and Westminster are now in a row over the Irish government's plans for legislation. It would mean any asylum seekers who cross the border from Northern Ireland can be set to the UK.
Asylum seekers have pitched tents near the International Protection Office in Dublin. These tents are reportedly being used by some 1,700 homeless asylum-seekers
Irish Prime Minister Simon Harris said his country would: "not provide a loophole for anybody else's migration challenges". And that people are crossing from Northern Ireland because they are scared of being sent to Rwanda.
Jeremy Vine on 5 is on television every weekday at 9:15am until 1:30pm on Channel 5.
Subscribe to the channel for more celebrity interviews, hot topics and debates: bit.ly/34DvAv4
Twitter: / jeremyvineon5
Facebook: / jeremyvineon5
Instagram: / jeremyvineon5
#stormhuntley #ireland #rwanda
That black guy is talking rubbish. He cant even see how hypocritical his views are !!!
Send him as well..
If France owes us nothing attitude, because of brexit, then the UK owes the EU nothing.
Marvin needs removing send him to Rwanda first
Sorry but even if we had remained in the EU it would not have stopped all these illegal immigrants
They aren’t illegal. No asylum seekers aren’t ever illegal.
But you could send them back to the first safe country.
Ireland could take 100,O00 migrants, it's big enough.
@@gambrydew2059hello new account bot 😂zzz 💤
@@gambrydew2059😂what do you think has been happening every year we have been inundated with migrants with years now. Every corner of the country has them. And we have a housing crisis.
Marvyn what a uninformed individual
he's hilarious and accurate
You would know
He is a biased migrant.
@@leelobee6552 He's clueless about international law.
@@bobbailey7024 He had plenty of clues YOU just don't understand
The French are escorting the boats into British waters, that is not stopping them from coming, that is aiding and abetting them to get here.
RNLI is picking them up off the french coast and bringing them to the uk.
Correct!
Ecxactly
@@bornslippy2614 no they pick them up as soon as the French escort them to British waters
Tell that to the French. If Ireland can send the migrants back to the UK, then we should be able to send them back to France.
If they claimed asylum in France as opposed to the UK then sure. Never forget, it was ye gobshites who helped write those asylum laws.
💯
History repeats. This is the plantation 2.0 for Ireland. This time there will be no forgiveness for what our neighbours have done AGAIN !!!
send them home.
@@davidoconnor7694 we’re not sending them to you, these migrants are choosing to go to Ireland. Ireland chose to stay in the EU , all migrants welcome, that is Irelands policy. I don’t want migrants in Ireland either, I don’t want them in Europe full stop.
That man is both ignorant and arrogant! He constantly interrupted Lizzie when she had the courtesy to sit quietly and listen to him...
One ignorant man.
No manners.
Has to talk over people.
Then talks a load of crap.
The problem with the Republic is it's always GBs fault.
Sort your own problem out.😂
Guy is talking nonsense what planet is he on......UK is a very small country...UK & Ireland are both small countries.......France is a much larger country..
That's probably why they accept far more asylum seekers than the UK does
They are NOT Asylum Seekers!
Why give that man a stage when he has no logic within his head, you can't debate with a person who has the logic of a three year old. I wouldn't even bother talking to him.
That black guy isn't very bright. DEI perhaps
He doesnt sound like he is very happy in Britain himself
@@andyjota8906 People like him are the problem. The woke left have propogated this mess and will leave our children without a home. Until we challenge the commies things will get worse. Sadly we could be steam rollering down a civil conflict path.
Interesting the black guy when referring to money sent to France said " You've been robbed " and also referred to England and not we. Where has he been living all these years? Is he not British? He said he is Brittish so then why doesn't he include himself in referring to the place he lives. If an illegal moves somewhere else then what right does Britain or any country to impose a return if they left to go somewhere else. Ireland and France is in the EU. Any deal with the EU must be done as a whole not individual countries. So if the Irish part of the EU want to send them back here then Britain can send them back to the French bit of the EU. The EU block negotiates as one.
His African
He is British but hates the country like a lot of left wingers.
I’ve never heard such incoherent drivel than what that black guy came out with.
Black people think there should be open borders. Maybe we should do a swop.
Why have they give this idiot air time
Ireland should help out.
@@gambrydew2059 What do you suggest they do.
Has he been drinking?
If we open our doors and allow who ever wants to come to Britain in, where will we put them, we can't take care of those we already have.
There's enough space here.
@@gambrydew2059good evening new account bot 😂😂
There's no one to take of your grandma _because_ they left. No one to pick your fruit or clean your toilets etc.
@@2020_Visi0n
🙄😜🤪😂🤣
@@2020_Visi0n So you think migrants are little more than slaves? Low skilled workers?
What utter nonsense Mr Harrison is speaking. Attitudes like his are the problem.
Immigrants are legally obliged to seek asylum in the first safe country they reach and France is a safe country and France has broken international law
Is this guy for real
I hope he doesn't
Believe what he says
Both countries don’t want them & just passing their problems back n fourth . We’re a small country as well lady, but I understand they should be ALL be sent back and BOTH countries need to buckle down on their borders.
Who is this guy? Trying to say we are not a small island? Has he looked at a map?
She obviously meant in size not status.
Also if we severed ties with France for leaving the eu so can't send them back. Ireland have ties and are in the eu, so they can send them back to France where they came from and France will have an obligation to take them.
So ireland and France. Have it out between yourselves. Leave us out of it!
So he thinks the UK is responsible for Ireland's migrants AND we are responsible for France's migrants as well? Err you can't have it both ways . . . what a Britain hater!
Is he English?? Really shame on him
Of course he isn't English. @@marilenawestcott4223
I saw a video of those migrants tents in Ireland months ago, Ireland are just trying to get rid of their migrants that EU allow into their country!
@@marilenawestcott4223 He is African not English!
@@careytitan9097 Just looked now, he was brought up in England by his Jamaican mother.
Could we have hoped for a little "I have done great here in England, I am a successful man and my colour has not held me back"?
Predictably the answer to that is a definite no, this person will grab any chance he can to disparage Britain. He will side against Britain with anyone no matter who they are or where they are from.
This seems to be the running theme with very many of those whose roots are elsewhere. They have no loyalty to this country and give no acknowledgement about the advantage that growing up in Britain has given them.
Is it cost im BLACK 🤣🤣🤣🤣 and i bet 100% that he lives in the UK
Rather than fall out with Ireland is to work together for the same goal all country's want , stand together,send them all on their way, France have been very disappointing
No let the EU loving Ireland have and keep them.
Follow me: EU(France) vs 🥊 UK vs 🥊 EU (Ireland)
1) Migrants ran away from their undeveloped countries to come to Europe which are the European Union countries the first states to receive them. 2) then already in safety the illegal immigrants leave France (European Union Country) to enter the United Kingdom. We British cannot send them back to France. I don't understand why because "we" Europeans have the European Convention on Human Rights court, and the Dublin Regulation responsible for asylum applicants.
3) Now the migrants in the UK are fleeing to Ireland (another European Union country) and the Irish government is already working on immigration policies to deport them back to the UK. So why cannot the United Kingdom deport them back to France (EU), If Ireland (EU) can deport them to the UK? Can you see what is happening here?
These illegal immigrants are already in the European Union which is a safe and prosperous political and economic block, why do they still need to go to the UK seek for protection? If they are already safe within the EU, the United Kingdom should have the power of law to send them back to the EU. That's why the Rwanda plan shouldn't even exist at first instance. It's expensive and we are just wasting our money to solve an European Union awfully-managed problem. The British government shouldn't spend billions to solve this humanitarian human crisis caused by the EU but instead to deport them back to the EU and invest the money in our own internal problems. It will be much cheaper and more in accordance with the international humanitarian laws and human rights.
Let's see what the EU is doing, follow me:
Currently Russia is instrumentalising illegal immigrants and pulling them into Finland and the Baltic states borders on threatening the internal EU security. The EU is accusing Russia of committing humanitarian crimes against human rights and provocation the sovereignty of member states nearby. However the EU is also doing the exact same thing by instrumentalising migrants in north of France and pulling them towards the UK, threatening our internal security borders. It sounds to be a hatred movement of punishment after the withdrawal of the United Kingdom from the EU (Brexit). Is that okay? There is only one name to be called: hypocrisy.
In my opinion the UK needs a much more powerful conservative government and a fierce leadership to start impose their voice and take attitude towards EU. Cancel the Rwanda bill and deport people back to the EU because they came initially from the EU anyway which is considered to be a safe and prosperous political & economic union.
For decades the United Kingdom was paying millions for its EU membership and then was used, abused, bullied, imposed and told what to do by the EU and very much hated by many central European states such that British people no longer feel to be Europeans. That's why Britain left the EU because of the EU shameful attitude towards to the UK for many and many decades. You may not understand because you may be from outside of the UK, but your country will be soon destroyed and then will be too late to bring it back. It will come a day when you will understand what I am saying. Let's together collapse the European Union and take total control of our nations, identities and our own people. That's what matters to us!
If the migrants intentions to come to Europe are primarily economic, then they need to come legally by applying for a permit visa and residence as everyone else that endures the migration procedures. The world works the same for everyone and not for the privilege of a few, and this calls equality rights which we must fight for. If people can come illegal and make their life as such; so why do we even have passports or Border Checking Controls?
Not underdeveloped countries, war torn countries.
Your spot on 👍
Funny that there's no coach loads of women and kids that are fleeing these so called war torn countries 🤔
Fleeing to Ireland ? They were invited to come with the promise of accommodation - as did Wales with school girls in short skirts!! We are being replaced !!
@@johncummins3860I'm English 🏴 and feel absolutely awful for what's happening to Ireland 🇮🇪. But this has been happening in England 🏴 for absolute years and when it was part of the EU 🇪🇺. All the Irish 🇮🇪 that are in England 🏴 I hope they stay here, because I dread to think how they would feel going home to see what's happened to there motherland.
@gambrydew2059 war isn't a qualifier for asylum btw. As shocking as that is. It's oppression based on 5 categories based on things like religious, political, social and lgbt status and there is a systemic government lead oppression of such classes. Not a single Ukrainian is an asylum seeker, they are in Britain on humanitarian grounds which is completely voluntary. Too many people are unaware of social policy.
UK & Ireland are both small countries.......France is a much larger country..
Irelands population is 5 million, GB is 66 million....big difference
@@Deehir UK is full, France has been paid millions to stop the boats, they are to blame....
@@DeehirEnglands towns are bigger than our cities and we have a housing crisis most of our land is for agriculture. If britain was worried about its poulation size they should have thought about that years ago. Im irish i have english neighbours and best friends here. We should work together not be divided or both our cultures will not last into the future.
@@bornslippy2614 I 100% agree . A joint effort from both countries to reduce the numbers
@@bornslippy2614We did think about it years ago, but we were always told we were racist and to keep quiet. Our population kept growing yet no one asked the English 🏴 if they wanted it? People took it upon themselves to just come here uninvited seeking job opportunities. I'm glad Ireland 🇮🇪 and England 🏴 are both speaking out now, the people of the country should be listened to.
No! They are not our responsibility those that came from France should have been looked after there.
Marvin is rude, ignorant and has an agenda.
Send the Black guy to Rowanda he is not Irish am I right?
We don't want them we don't want the one's we got.
Why aren't they in four star hotels just shows how stupid our country is
It's being done on purpose this is the great replacement
This man is a joke why did Jeremy vine have people like that in his Show that's why sometimes I not watch his Show
Because it's his show and is trying to offer different perspectives?
I read the Daily Mail and the Guardian to get both ends of the spectrum.
Brexit has nothing to do with it, this was happening well before Brexit.
France has twice the land mass of Britain . Britain is a small country and is the most densely populated country in Europe
And Ireland is even smaller it's a tiny country compared to England...
This one’s an absolute air head
Sadly we have a lot of them. That’s why we get the governments we have because these idiots vote them in
typical. expects people to listen but just tallks over her when she speaks.
Interesting to hear that your host didn't know what was going on in Ireland. I've known for years and the reason why is because the
Irish Government, Police Force and most important the media were all in on it. They did not inform the Irish people that the migrants who were coming into Ireland at night by bus loads, most of them young black men. Our crime has gone through the roof. The local families are not happy with their children coming home from
Schools because the migrants stand around the streets. Crime has gone up, the streets are not safe, I could go on and on. I think of my parents and their parents how hard they have worked and to see their country lost forever. They are saying give it another ten years and we will be a minority in our country!
I hate this government and will never forgive them and the Police Force who saw what was happening, never did anything for their people.
It's about time these true stories are broadcast to the outside world because the media and the so called Irish Government keeps it a secret. Just like Russia does to their people. Yes, we are on a par with Russia regarding the news being censored from getting out to the outside world!
We had the murder of a lovely young teacher who was on her bicycle early afternoon in a Park. Two gay men murdered in their home; I won't mention what went on there, too graphic! Women murdered and children going missing, a 12 years old boy raped in a public toilet. No the media don't tell you about these horrible things. All the above were victims of foreigners let into our countries without being vetted!
That is what is happening to Ireland and I would like the world to know!!!
Marvyn is clearly not that smart , the fact he’s referring to England and not the UK says a lot , also he’s not looking at France and the EUs lack of actions , the EU technically is a country in all but name
We send them to France, France send them to Spain etc 🤦
They probably arrive in Spain.
And Italy mostly
@@underground9560 most definitely Italy and have been doing for years! They're the scourge of society, mostly delinquents, who are causing nothing but trouble wherever they go.
I know full well as I work in the immigration office here in Milan.
EU open border policies have lot to answer for.
Proud Irish woman,your fellow Irish people didn't ask for this,
People have to realise that whoever arrives in the UK, actually want too stay in the UK.
When they left their home nation,they had a destination already planned out. Be it the UK, France, Italy, Sweden etc.
They're not ALL heading to England and those on the French coast aren't even registered in France and never had any intention of being.
I work in the immigration office in Milan, Italy & I can assure you, things are out of control here. I'd say easily 10 fold.
We're quite literally at the point of an invasion.The entire infrastructure of Europe (as a continent, not the EU)is unable to take anymore. So what are we going to do? Lots of bla bla,yet no solution.
It's most certainly an invasion and we have the EU & WEF to blame for the mess!
The boats coming across the Mediterranean originally when this crap started should have been stopped unfortunately the EU who are in control decided no borders allowed anywhere in the west, the USA is exactly the same!
Dragging the boats back across the Mediterranean would be a good start.
Marvyn needs to read up on the 1922 Common travel agreement his thinking is incorrect As for sending illegal immigrants back to the UK that has to be agreed between the UK and the EU Ireland is not allowed to negotiate with the UK according to the EU
Marvin makes no sense. If Ireland can send people back then so can UK! Is it true Ireland sent those invitations to foreign lands? If so, then what are they complaining about?
Rhat’s guys opinions are all flawed. Why is he even there… migraintspass through countries to get to the UK. So what about the responsibilities
For all the countries they pass through
The uks answer is to send them to Rwanda.. migraints don’t want to do they’ve gone else where. C’est la vie
They employ an anti-british panelist like Marvyn to wind us up not for his intellect.
Open borders in EU are the issue.
The only person who has any true knowledge of the situation is the gentleman on the panel. The migrants who have come to Ireland via NI are already registered in the UK! Most of them have British or Scottish accents because they have lived in the UK for years!!
The Irish lady in Kent is correct. It was a gay, woke minister Roderic O'Gorman
Minister for Children, Equality, Disability, Integration and Youth of Ireland, who put out that invitation tweet and is largely responsible for the entire mess. He also managed to lose 20 children somewhere in the system. One young girl was later found in a NI brothel!
There is evil afoot and we the people of Ireland, NI, England, Wales and Scotland need to unite to fight this evil for the future of our children and grandchildren! 🙏
Eu should make rules as US. Anyone gets in EU illegally will never be a legal resident
Ireland and the eu insisted on an open border re the good friday agreement and the belfast accord
Don't worry, if this keeps up the next thing we'll be hearing is they have decided to suspend the common travel area and crossings from NI into Ireland. That will be a massive double standard but you can't put anything past them to get what they want.
Don't talk rubbish are you for bloody real pal
Can we send Marvyn to Rwanda?
Southern Irish here, Im for hard border at BRITISH terminals, e.g. Heathrow airport to Belfast or Dublin, no EU passport, no go. No asylum applicants. Same extra checks for Americans, Chinese etc, traveling Europe, proof of intention to stay only temporarily on holiday. Irish passports whizzed on through. Terminus change is A LOT cheaper and Belfast agreement isnt challenged.
Ireland can't send back them back, as the Irish deemed the UK as an unsafe Country
So ireland thinks the uk is responsible for france letting them across our channels
The French obviously not wanting them
Irish here. This problem been here for since 2016-17 Brexit panic. However ,yes. If you keep pushing buttons, we too. Can push buttons.
Diplomatic disputes are not good for our two nations.but, if ye want we can keep doing it...
People may bring up the border ,however . Any checks on that would cause issues for the UK.
This isn't to do with Brexit....wake up!
This is to do with Europe, Schengen and free movement of people. Unless Europe shuts down its borders then welcome to Africa, parts of the ME and Asia emptying into Europe destroying what we have built in the last Centuries. Don't think using the UK as the 'last stop' on the journey is going to save Ireland and the rest of Europe. Borders are required if we value our way of life, if not crack on and see what this amazing life we have all enjoyed looks like in 25 years.
No, it's not an English idea. Look at Australia. Methinks, there's a bit of negative non-conscious bias being exbibited here. Or maybe just performance for the show.
Well said . UK dismisses their responsability. They should have dealth with this with France and not direct them to the Irish boarder. Step up UK, take responsability !
When talking about migration between the EU and the UK, someone who does not know the difference between England and the UK, is hardly a useful choice. He also seemed to have a big problem just with the English in general. Odd it was not challenged.
They came across many countries even before France. The fact they can arrive in Greece, let's say, then travel across many EU open borders,(an EU POLICY) then its actually an EU problem . Why does the EU stupid idea of open borders become our problem?
This host is completely uninformed
The NHS employs 1.5 million people,220 thousand are foreign born.
Sam is clueless.
But not illegal foreigners
@@Henry-ve3ye Which is why I said Sam is clueless.
People fleeing war can go to any country they want to even if they pass through Italy greece etc its law that uk signed up to in the 1950s same for other European nations did. Theses people do not go to Belarus, Russia they will not have any rights in places like Belarus. Also uk has paid many £ millions to Rwanda to send a MAXIMUM of 300 people and if the uk wants to send more to Rwanda will need more millons. In the republic of Ireland they have bad housing issue's in Dublin due to prices being more expensive then London, Paris, Milan. And in areas in ireland that are more west area's have issues about the government not helping the locals first with housing, public services etc.
The uk should just set up a processing in france and an agreement it would stop alot and lower costs and Rwanda is laughing at the uk getting tax payers money for something that will not work. Some local british people might want to be given £3000 to start a new life in Rwanda and live like a king the uk cost of living is turning the uk into a 3rd world nation with everyone getting more poor. The torys are a joke.
UK not England
It’s only recently that they started coming from ENGLAND the Irish government is trying to get out of what a mess they have made of this country they have been coming in bus loads well before this happened all men
Why don't the British empire just get out of Ireland 🇮🇪 and then Ireland can sort out Ireland
💯
I don't believe that the British empire as you call it , is in Ireland, it's the Irish who are in Ireland. And I do believe that the majority of Northern Ireland is happy with the current situation.
@@sparkesman1980 Ireland UNFREE will never be at peace BRITISH out of Ireland is the only way
@@derry1423
Get a job. Get a life.
The British Empire dissolved decades ago. The United Kingdom is in the Island of Ireland because the Northern Irish people want to stay in the UK. And if you ask people from the Irish Republic if they want reunification at any cost, the vast majority don't want it.
Both Irish peoples would have to overwhelming agree to reunification for any chance of it to work. It can't be 51% from each side, it would have to be 65% AT LEAST, probably 75% to be on the safe side...
I totally agree with the last caller Barbara. Britain and France should not put this burden on 26 small counties. And they wouldn't be coming from Britain into Northern Ireland and down into the Republic. If Britain did not come out of brexit. And I hate to say it bring the border back bring the army back. Maybe the English army and the Irish army can coincide and work well together so the Republic of Ireland is not going to be invaded in the same way the British people were. 😢
What a nerve! The very fact that the EU refuses to take people back from Britain but yet they expect Britain to play by different rules. This is now an EU problem started by France which had ended up in Ireland. If France hadn’t been so difficult neither Britain nir Ireland would be having problems
Same here in England, publish the crime figures!!!
It's a definite NO ! Ireland is with EfU.
The people going from the UK to Ireland did not come with the small boats. They have stayed in the UK without being processed.
Same as when they entered France so I don’t get your point
Omg 😮if any illegal immigrant that’s in our country is our responsibility WTF 😳
The Irish government could send the illegals to a country of their choice like somewhere in Africa I am sure that they know a country like Rwanda they could do this, why don't they?
He's says he is an English citizen. There is no such think!
If this would force the pathetic UK to take proper actions then OK. Anything to get the UK from dithering more.
This guy is just a complete fool
You can have them now blame the EU good luck
Its never going to stop if you have doo gooders in the way
@4:20
Tony is talking through his hat
1 million people 20% of Ireland's population are newly arrived legal migrants, that have arrived here in the past 10-15 years
We are well used to it
The big bosses are trying to pit Ireland and Britain against each other, we shouldn’t destroy our good relations between our two countries. Britain is a small island, Ireland is even smaller. 20% of the Irish population were not born in Ireland, it’s not sustainable. Ireland is full. Ireland was never a coloniser we don’t owe those countries, at this stage neither does Britain.
You can't you signed the EU papers live with it and have you forgotten about the IRA.
Correct me if I am wrong but this argument is a waste of oxygen because the Republic of Ireland is an EU member state.
Mr Macron insisted that individual members states cannot negotiate returns policies to another country, only Brussels can negotiate returns policies.
Cundy on Vine last week said she doesn`t feel safe in London but Rwanda is a nice safe country , problem solved lizzie girl off you go to Kigali
if being in the EU and having good relations with fance would help the problem as marvyn says then why cant ireland send them back to france.
He says "We" - and then he says "You." Which is it, please?
Showed himself for what he really is…
The Law is on the side of The UK.
Harrison the UK DID NOT CREATE THIS PROBLEM IT WAs the EU and France in particular because the law states that anyone seeking asylum should be granted that status in the first safe country. These people have come to the UK via Spain, Portugal, Italy and France.
Ireland is Smaller than the UK lady😉
It takes 6 months to see a doctor in Ireland now. Hospitals are full to emergency levels. Tourism is gone as hotels have hopped on the gravy train. What a mess.
Same as the uk all because of illegals who we spend billions on that could pay for the nhs etc
As for the first Man caller why should Ireland foot Britains bill to send their refugees anywhere. Tje Man on your Panel is the only one with sense.
The eu should start doing the right thing instead of passing them all away from them ,all the immigrants need to know an island cant take the whole world,
why not just stop them at the border halfway between england and france.
Because the rnli just go out and pick them up
No they are in the EU now
Demography is destiny, remember that. Africa has the highest birth rate in the world. In fact, the African population is going to double.
The only solution is the " Down Under " solution. Kudos to them.
No. We have the CTA. Eire should send them back to the France, the last EU country to house them.
Answer - No, now is there an other question.
Question to the Muppet saying we should, why is it England and not the United Kingdom?
Its like a bunch of 9 year old talking
The hosts not the callers
Its nice to hear that most of the public realise that there is a plantation going on again ireland ..and our population is getting back to prefamine levels while once again 80 % of our farm produce is being exported ..this time in the form of the dominant irish dairy sector .history may not repeat but it always ryms .
We need to just say no and not pay any money at all
Dont give France a penny and keep Rwanda policy in place so that migrants continue to go to Ireland. That guy hasnt a clue.