I remember seeing this as a kid holding my breath as the sword fell as if it were real life just thinking this guy is literally insane 😂. Definitely a pivotal moment in me becoming a permanent fan 🔥
That’s how you should go about watching one piece, starting from the beginning how they played it and forwards. Same with other anime series, movies, etc
I like the 2023 one, it highlights how close it was. 1999 one just happened, it’s not impactful it’s not slowed it just happened. Not saying I love effects but this time it had a purpose and is clean.
For the people, thinking its only nostalgia. You are very wrong here. In terms of animation and weight, the old versions were much more advanced. The details, the shadows, the propotions are much more realistic in the old version. Animations have really gone worse over the time. The best animated anime films untill today are still the old Cuphead cartoons, Akira and Ghost in the Shell. They are all made before 2000. The Animators were much more skilled, cause they had to animate every minor detail. Todays a animes are much more focused on simplicity and speed.
You've gotta factor in the fact that nowadays anime is rushed out to meet consumer demand weekly, with each animator taking up multiple projects, which is partially why nowadays studios use so much 3d models for background chars (which is, for example, especially sloppy in Blue Lock 2nd cour); still or slightly moving frames; and also in general not having the same level of detail as the anime in 1999
@@seadenfreude indeed there was demand, but it's the producer that's pushing that demand. No one really complain about anime getting released too slow, only when they are suddenly paused in between episodes or when the studio fall behind on their announced date line by months and years later. Generally it's always like "I can't wait for this to be release. "I can't wait for season x to be release. Never like "fk it's taking to long to release" "holy moly season two took over xxx, it's so damn long" and more like "it's finally here, worth the wait". Anime don't get drawn and put together on the spot on the week to week basis. They usually did the main part first, then it take years before it was release. When the studio announced that the series in the making they probably already had roughly 50% done. Then few months or years later it gets released. There were literally tens of thousands of anime out there, no one is going to lose money(ie TV program) for not airing the series sooner, they only lose the chance to make profit, considering the little expenses, the see it as a loss and rubbish excuses to make money. Of course I am talking about heavy action anime like JKK etc. not those 12 ep trash series with only mouth moving and a handful movement. Of course this varies in art work. Some like yakuza as househusband. Limited frame but high quality art work, great voice over and scripting. The demand is there but no one really pushes the demand except for the producer, because all they see is money. Bunch of co** s**ker.
You can cleary see here that the animation, detail and shadows are more advanced and better. What makes it objectively better other than the fact your wrong
@@stephenwu1524tbh i liked the old one better bc i just love the art style (especially water 7 & enies lobby art style) and its not because of nostalgua since i started one piece like 6 month ago
The 99's feels more alive,it have more details in the face,muscles,it's much more satisfying to watch in this scene,but in the new episodes,the new art style is definitely rocking
I like the original version cause it had more tension in how the blade missed his arm, also I see the natural increase in animation as a parallel to how the straw hats evolved and became stronger over time.
@notghost2759 it's not nostalgia. The styles are literally different. 23 does look cleaner and more colorful but the details in facial expressions in 99 breaks 4th wall. The veins in the eyes and forward. The frowning of the face.
In 2023 i feel that skills are unmatchable but in 1999 i feel an old man wants to tell me something with his passion and his art...it hits me different and thats my personal opinion
For me, it’s kinda weird that Zoro already have that big muscle body before time-skip, because if it’s continue and then reach time-skip, we cant see Zoro getting upgrade, like its no difference. So I prefer 1999.
Well it’s not like he’s really muscular in this one compared to him in wano, I feel it’s just the attention to details it’s just better quality so we see more than the older version
@@luckedout2131 honestly thats so true. some people are disatisfied with the show now and its bc of nostalgia. They miss the simplicity and those types of people are the ones that neglect change the most. Realistically if One Piece stayed with its old animation and remained a silly pirate story it wouldve sunk long ago. People dont know what they want out of the show bc they are chasing that nostalgia the feeling of when they first sat down and watched it instead of appreciating the direction the story took which in my opinion is amazing.
I just now noticed in the 1999 version when he hold the new sword his old one isnt drawn on his belt xD but when the shot switches then its back again^^
Saw this first time at age of 7, awesome. 99 version seem a different anime, miss the old fight too without so many light and power up effects, it was simple but still perfect at same time
NO. the old fights looked very bad. I watched One Piece for the first time at the age of 26 and these fights were not even comparable to Naruto, which was released at the same time. you look through the prism of nostalgia
@@snintendog If you look at the names of modern one piece staff outside the webgen additions post-wano, you'll find a decent chunk of OP's staff list filled with Dragon Ball veterans. DB Super was the same way - most of the staff on Super were Z-era staff.
The art in 1999 gives the scene a much better tone. The shop owner's eyes with his veins popping out provides a genuine concerned look. The angle of Zoro's eyes provides a more serious facial expression. The height of the blade to which it was thrown, looks more realistic, how you only see the blade while it's spinning and how close it got to Zoro's arm just makes the scene a lot more epic.
For that time being that was expensive but if the 1999 version was made today, it would be low budget and if the 2023 version was made in 1999 it would be way more expensive. That is what he means I believe
The sword in the 1999 version looks more dynamic because we see the sword heading right for Zoro's arm. In the new version we see a close up of the spinning sword but in the end we see how it barely passes. The key difference is that the old shot builds up more anticipation than the new one because they show us earlier where the sword is heading. In addition to that showing the sword barely missing the arm from different angles also acts as a prove for the viewer to reassure how close the situation was. That's why I like the angles and composition of the old animation way more. I don't mind the differences between the art styles like colour grading and shadows. Both are fine
They both did nearly the exact same thing. Having the cutting edge nearly miss first then pass by the back of the blade. The New show highlighting and more emphasized. Though I still feel the 99 version highlighting the back of the sword instead if this intense moment otherwise conveys the picture I said above. I do get how it makes it a bit more daring for the kids. But the adults who are now adults, would perfere a more realistic show.
![Zoro vs Mihawk. Mihawk admitted how strong Zoro is - One Piece English Sub [4K UHD]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/_qtYAKa7P50/mqdefault.jpg)
The 1999 version feels like what actually happened, and the 2023 one feels like how you'd remember it happening after the fact
Well said
For real
Ain’t that the point for the 2023 version?
That’s literally the point lmfao what is this dumbass comment
@@player223i was also like, well it is a flashback..
why does 1999 just look and feel better
Вложена душа художника, вот почему.
Mixture of nostalga and personal taste
Doesn't look better. The detail and clarity is much better In 2023. The feeling is just nostalgia.
Its the nostalgia bud. 1999 looks shitty if your only seeing this today
@@lukagoblinmodelol fr Zoro looks clean
I remember seeing this as a kid holding my breath as the sword fell as if it were real life just thinking this guy is literally insane 😂. Definitely a pivotal moment in me becoming a permanent fan 🔥
yeah, that's when i believed zoro could do it all
I watched the 1999 version because I was able to see how much the art style slowly improved throughout the series
That’s how you should go about watching one piece, starting from the beginning how they played it and forwards. Same with other anime series, movies, etc
I like the 1999 sword falling. It doesn't slow down as much, which makes the animation look way smoother.
I like the 2023 one, it highlights how close it was. 1999 one just happened, it’s not impactful it’s not slowed it just happened. Not saying I love effects but this time it had a purpose and is clean.
1999
Tbh it just looks goofy, and the replay really makes it goofy, yk it just falls no intense effect showing how close it was.
it more static and less dramatic- kinds boring
Nl 9loQ
The 1999 visual of the sword going around Zoro’s arm is way more satisfying.
I agree with you 100%, the first one was EXTREMELY SATISFYING.😊❤😊
That newer one doesn't do it justice at all.😅
Agree 👍💯
Look at zoro's arm which is stronger in 1999
so true
Yeah
For the people, thinking its only nostalgia. You are very wrong here. In terms of animation and weight, the old versions were much more advanced. The details, the shadows, the propotions are much more realistic in the old version. Animations have really gone worse over the time. The best animated anime films untill today are still the old Cuphead cartoons, Akira and Ghost in the Shell. They are all made before 2000. The Animators were much more skilled, cause they had to animate every minor detail. Todays a animes are much more focused on simplicity and speed.
You've gotta factor in the fact that nowadays anime is rushed out to meet consumer demand weekly, with each animator taking up multiple projects, which is partially why nowadays studios use so much 3d models for background chars (which is, for example, especially sloppy in Blue Lock 2nd cour); still or slightly moving frames; and also in general not having the same level of detail as the anime in 1999
@@seadenfreudeYes! I totally agree! Animes are mass produced these days, back then it was art and lots off hard work.
yeah, the old version had less and animation, but more dramatical to watch
@@seadenfreude indeed there was demand, but it's the producer that's pushing that demand. No one really complain about anime getting released too slow, only when they are suddenly paused in between episodes or when the studio fall behind on their announced date line by months and years later. Generally it's always like "I can't wait for this to be release. "I can't wait for season x to be release. Never like "fk it's taking to long to release" "holy moly season two took over xxx, it's so damn long" and more like "it's finally here, worth the wait". Anime don't get drawn and put together on the spot on the week to week basis. They usually did the main part first, then it take years before it was release. When the studio announced that the series in the making they probably already had roughly 50% done. Then few months or years later it gets released. There were literally tens of thousands of anime out there, no one is going to lose money(ie TV program) for not airing the series sooner, they only lose the chance to make profit, considering the little expenses, the see it as a loss and rubbish excuses to make money. Of course I am talking about heavy action anime like JKK etc. not those 12 ep trash series with only mouth moving and a handful movement. Of course this varies in art work. Some like yakuza as househusband. Limited frame but high quality art work, great voice over and scripting. The demand is there but no one really pushes the demand except for the producer, because all they see is money. Bunch of co** s**ker.
You can cleary see here that the animation, detail and shadows are more advanced and better. What makes it objectively better other than the fact your wrong
Bro almost became shanks 💀
I prefer the 1999 version
The 1999 one had way more footage and the clips couldn’t be sync lol
There is one thing I didn't like about that version was the sound effect of the sword spining
No you don’t 💀
@@stephenwu1524tbh i liked the old one better bc i just love the art style (especially water 7 & enies lobby art style)
and its not because of nostalgua since i started one piece like 6 month ago
Me too
The Sword: Why slice just one arm when there are thousands I can slice with him? 💀
exactly
💀
Damn
what?@@ItzSatoru.
@@brooklyn8745 I think I meant to write that for another vid or it was auto correct sorry
The 99's feels more alive,it have more details in the face,muscles,it's much more satisfying to watch in this scene,but in the new episodes,the new art style is definitely rocking
That store's ceiling is quite high
I like the original version cause it had more tension in how the blade missed his arm, also I see the natural increase in animation as a parallel to how the straw hats evolved and became stronger over time.
I share the same sentiment
Why would a flashback of something we already saw need tension
Blinded by nostalgia
No be that did it fast and stuff
@notghost2759 it's not nostalgia. The styles are literally different. 23 does look cleaner and more colorful but the details in facial expressions in 99 breaks 4th wall. The veins in the eyes and forward. The frowning of the face.
1999 looks more like he’s 19 than 2023 which makes him look 21
Ye
Ye
Agreed but also 1999 is simmer than 2023 if u see the face
The 1999 looks way better with the odl modoles
I feel like the 1999 ver had more character as the animation and shading is more on the simplistic side.
In 2023 i feel that skills are unmatchable but in 1999 i feel an old man wants to tell me something with his passion and his art...it hits me different and thats my personal opinion
1999 parece que a cena era real, ja a de 2023 parece mais uma cena de anime msm
I just like how they drew the faces back in the day more
Ngl those looked more like a funny joke more than a serious moment that could look rlly amazing compared to the old ones
Yes it was more cartoonish and had more of a vibe. Now the animation is just more clearer and smoother.
@@MYKIEONG gear 5 is just luffy bringing that cartoonish vibe back
Zoro was black at that time lol
それは日本人でも思ってる
昔の方はスローモーションになってない分リアルさがあって好き
Слава богу! Что я не один так думаю.
인정
Agree
重心がおかしなことになってるけどな。
Agree!
Bro was so close to being shanks 😂😂
Bro I watched that clip in 2024 it hasn't changed
For me, it’s kinda weird that Zoro already have that big muscle body before time-skip, because if it’s continue and then reach time-skip, we cant see Zoro getting upgrade, like its no difference. So I prefer 1999.
Well it’s not like he’s really muscular in this one compared to him in wano, I feel it’s just the attention to details it’s just better quality so we see more than the older version
Finally someone with a reason
Bro... zoro was swinging 200 pounds+ like a sword pre-timeskip.
Zoro is absolutely jacked when we first meet him
In the early episodes we could see he lifted well guys and trained
1999のあのあっさりしてるけどやってることの怖さや凄さがわかる立ち絵が好きだった
Nah
あと店長の絵柄が1999の方が好きや
刀がひどい
新しい方は作った画像にエフェクトいれてごまかして回してます！っていうのがわかる
1999 noanoaa sarishiteru wa gyooteru goto no (kanji) sayu(kanji) sagawa garufjfnsbgdodktlwps
今のはわざとらしいですよねえ。
Esta escena fue la que me convenció de ver one piece, ahora no puedo dejar de verlo
You can see how the creator of one piece really went into it since 1999
こうして見ると当時の作画は少ない予算でよくこのクオリティーだせたな
今のアニメーターへのプレッシャーは計り知れない
Я так рад, что это мнение не только моё!
I agree with u there is more beautiful
ここで腕飛ばして二度とやらねぇからぁ！のコラ画像好き
安いもんだ。腕の一本くらい…
( 圧 倒 的 手 遅 れ )
それは流石に剣士の恥
2023 looks like wano zoro
2023 look like Zoro now but with both eyes open
やっぱ昔のワンピース好きすぎる。
Does anyone else like Zoro's hair better in the 1999 version? LIke how how his hair was more blueish green instead of full green now?
Me
It's mosshead anyway
teal
Yes 1999 is the true moss head
Tbh it’s fine both ways. I never really cared
Bro knew physics better than my sir😂
2023 looks like timeskip zoro for some reason
I like the ‘99 version cause Zoro looked younger like he would’ve been at the time and the editing wasn’t overdone with the sword missing his arm.
Bro what they played it back like 7 times-
@@malevolentghost5734 bro frr he saying that like if 1999 version didnt have an ESPN replay of the blade missing his arm💀
Yeah, nostalgia is a big factor. Even when people try to deny it, it's definitely there.@@KingKrystoff
@@luckedout2131 honestly thats so true. some people are disatisfied with the show now and its bc of nostalgia. They miss the simplicity and those types of people are the ones that neglect change the most. Realistically if One Piece stayed with its old animation and remained a silly pirate story it wouldve sunk long ago. People dont know what they want out of the show bc they are chasing that nostalgia the feeling of when they first sat down and watched it instead of appreciating the direction the story took which in my opinion is amazing.
@@KingKrystoffNew animation lacks soul
1999 she is the best
It*
Minor spelling mistake
No.
@@joyguillermo-sabado2012 No he
me too
I just kinda noticed zoro had bicep veins all along...
That's clean 😊
旧版の実際のスピード感から出る周りの反応の迫真感とかリアルで好き
新版のドキドキする感じも好き
こうした比較動画は昔のアニメの良さを再認識させてくれるな…
Да, старая версия ощущается лучше
2023 looks more intense
La sensación que da la de 1999 es puna la de 2023 se siente como vacio como si fuera un recuerdo
I love how they draw Zoro’s shoes in 1999
普通に腕が真っ二つに切れて「二度とやらねえから！！」って泣いてたコラ画像好き
Mis ojos:⬆️⬇️⬆️⬇️⬆️⬇️⬆️⬇️⬆️⬇️⬆️⬇️⬆️
I just now noticed in the 1999 version when he hold the new sword his old one isnt drawn on his belt xD but when the shot switches then its back again^^
Saw this first time at age of 7, awesome. 99 version seem a different anime, miss the old fight too without so many light and power up effects, it was simple but still perfect at same time
NO. the old fights looked very bad. I watched One Piece for the first time at the age of 26 and these fights were not even comparable to Naruto, which was released at the same time. you look through the prism of nostalgia
I think the same the fights now are better but the new animation in the memories etc. Take away the aging and growing of the character.
Bro what the new fights are way better
@@swagquality8935the old fights were amazing, tf you on? Your just speaking through personal opinion.
@@swagquality8935that’s just your opinion bro 😂
Fun fact: he holds the sandai kitetsu like how he hold henma
henma?
u mean enma?
@@myMm2playzno he meant yoru OFC IS EMNA
Kitetsu III
Old zoro feels younger than reanimated
i agree
1999 has more expession, 2023 has quality
昔の方がヒヤヒヤ感上手く表現出来てて好き。
何かリアルな生々しさがあるよね。最新版はアニメ過ぎると言うか
演出過多やなケバいおばはんみたいや
@@user-um8pk7xe3f
そうそう。シンプルでいいんですよね。
勿体ぶってスローなんて入れる場面じゃない(笑)
Some things look better new, but the most important part, the sword spinning and going around his arm, looked better in 1999.
I love the fact that they had different ideas over time but still showed the same thing
2023 Zoro looks like time skip zoro
1999 is smooth and good 👍
2023 looks just like what a fan animation look like
No surely you dont know what modern animation is, bro fan animations has bigger line weights if u don't know what that is then don't talk
@@kaider_renzo 1999 just Looks better. THE OG Dragon ball duo were involved its also why no one like how Super looks compared to Z or even GT.
@@snintendogtrue
@@snintendog If you look at the names of modern one piece staff outside the webgen additions post-wano, you'll find a decent chunk of OP's staff list filled with Dragon Ball veterans. DB Super was the same way - most of the staff on Super were Z-era staff.
@@Ruldolphmaker nope they are all new hires not z vets.
この頃には昔の若々しいデザインが合ってる
Bro i love how in the 2023 they kinda recreated the old animating style
The 1999 Zoro was more fierce looking and hot
これで腕切れるの好き
もう二度と！やらねぇからッ！！
安いもんだ 腕の一本くらい😂
存在しない記憶で草
みんなコメント上手いなw
HxH worked but one piece is a journey through time. Those old episodes are liquid gold. 1999❤
2023 makes him look like he is in wano
old but gold
The art in 1999 gives the scene a much better tone. The shop owner's eyes with his veins popping out provides a genuine concerned look. The angle of Zoro's eyes provides a more serious facial expression. The height of the blade to which it was thrown, looks more realistic, how you only see the blade while it's spinning and how close it got to Zoro's arm just makes the scene a lot more epic.
どちらも良いと思いました！
ただ、綺麗な画になれば良い訳ではないと言うのもよくわかりました！
Zoro almost became shanks.
i want 1999 version since zoro always laugh and smiling.. while 2023 version is always serious face...
1999 zoro hair was peak 👌🏻
In time skip
Zoro has always been this serious.
@@zWaderWolfno he hasn't Zoro is only serious in post time skip
Sii
1999 version, does anyone think the kitetsu killed someone in the basement instead of zoro
Never thought of that
It's not a modern time building or an apartment complex. It's the owner guy shop with only him and his wife, no one was injured except the floor
Yea but how do you know there is no basement ? Unless you are a Japanese architect also its only a what if
2023 is better
U mean did that soward jabbed someone when it penetrate through the flooring?
Zoro has that unspoken rizz
Ah memories..... Oh wait, for Zoro it was only two to three years ago, meanwhile it's been over ten years with evolving art designs.
This reminds me how much I like the old style of one piece especially around episodes 200 when it changes just a little bit
Me who still in episode 5 and just watched one piece yesterday 😂
Nah but the sword just going into the ground was so satisfying
the only thing better about 2023 is probably tashigis reaction and the dude across the counter reaching out
The legend says that Shanks tried the same experiment but that it turned out badly 🤣
what
@@zenIsfrbruh
@@DarkNinja-bf6hk wot
@@zenIsfrit’s a joke cuz he lost his arm
XD
Even this cursed sword went "Oh, this a bad bitch."
Zoro is like let the sword cook
the 2023 one make him like a grass block
目を閉じるカットが新しい方は顔が正面ちょい上向きで胆力があるように見えて、昔の方は俯きで腕が落ちても上等って覚悟があるように見える。比較のお陰で完成したいまのゾロと成長中のゾロの2つを感じられて面白い！
確かに
新しい方はもし当たっても平気そうに見えてハラハラ感を感じなかったけど、それが理由かも
身体の線も太くなってるし
なんか、作画が今のワンピに近すぎて
冒険クリア後の一部データ引き継ぎの
二周目ルートにしか見えない
それだ
2023's ceiling is higher than mt.everest💀💀💀
2023: way to extra and way more detail with a higher budget
1999: an iconic low budget masterpiece
Not how budget works
For a 1999 anime, that's not low budget. You must be new to anime.
For 1999 that’s consider really great animation with high budget bro 😂
For that time being that was expensive but if the 1999 version was made today, it would be low budget and if the 2023 version was made in 1999 it would be way more expensive. That is what he means I believe
You're a rookie it's ok we've all all been There 😅
ちゃんと絵や演出の良し悪しをわかる人が多くて安心した。
1999 - actually happened
2023 - for climactic reasons
Old is gold 😂😂❤❤❤❤
なんだかんだ頂上決戦あたりまでの作画が好き
OLD IS GOLD 😎💫
🤓
new is domanod
@@Dizzman_Dchill
This helps me a lot
You do not mess with perfection.
Yeah as good as the updated version looks, the retro 90s look just feels nostalgic and more sentimental.
The sword in the 1999 version looks more dynamic because we see the sword heading right for Zoro's arm.
In the new version we see a close up of the spinning sword but in the end we see how it barely passes. The key difference is that the old shot builds up more anticipation than the new one because they show us earlier where the sword is heading. In addition to that showing the sword barely missing the arm from different angles also acts as a prove for the viewer to reassure how close the situation was. That's why I like the angles and composition of the old animation way more. I don't mind the differences between the art styles like colour grading and shadows. Both are fine
In the old animation we are not sure of the end of the scene till it comes, more suspens
@@juanbodenghien7510 Exactly
Thats the amount of trust he's got.
They have exhausted themselves restoring the old series in a new look. Many say the old is a diamond
Shanks if the sword hit zoro: welcome to the club
Ikr
The team who actually saw the 1999 version
👇
Old is Gold
He wasn't scared of the blade, the blade was scared of him😂
I like the old artstyle when everyone literally look goofy even tho they kinda serious, while the current artstyle makes everyone looks badass
Goofy=loofy
Yes, they definitely looked more unique back then, didn't they? I feel the same way!
1999 is a masterpiece❤🔥
the sword said
F*ck You Zoro Now You will lose your sense of direction
Bro 2021 looks like zero with his eye cut off
The 3 different angles in 1999s scene just hit different
The origonal one shows the swords respect. By turning its back it accepts it wants this fate, not a near miss to show dominance.
They both did nearly the exact same thing. Having the cutting edge nearly miss first then pass by the back of the blade. The New show highlighting and more emphasized.
Though I still feel the 99 version highlighting the back of the sword instead if this intense moment otherwise conveys the picture I said above.
I do get how it makes it a bit more daring for the kids. But the adults who are now adults, would perfere a more realistic show.