Henri Zwols i guess your right on that one, but in that case the topic wouldn't be about the homwork itself, it'd be about weather that particular student did it or not, because if he didn't have it, the homework would be still in progress in his home
Everything is complicated we just simplify it. Everything is simple we are just looking at too much. We make the simple seem complicated and the complicated seem simple.
Taking a picture of the cat is *the same* as observing it. Also, the title claims the riddle has been solved; however, at the end of the video, it says it has only been *partially solved* So could we then conclude that this video is both legit and *clickbait* at the same time? 🤔🤔 It's clearly in more than one box (computer/smartphone)...
You didn't pay attention. The camera they use, deliberately doesn't take in all of the information. It's not the same as observing it with your eyeball or other equipment, because that stuff would record ALL of the image/information. But the kind of camera they are talking about is blurred enough that you cannot actually say whether the cat is dead or alive just by looking at it. It's a greyed blob, so it could be dead or it could be laying down? Or whatever? By blurring the image, as far as Quantum Physics is concerned, you have only recorded enough information that would be in either state. A blurred photo of a living cat and blurred photo of a dead cat, is merely identical from an information perspective. If you could see the cat was laying in a stiff and ragdoll way, that's how you would know it was dead. If it looked like how a cat lays when it sleeps, or it just was cleaning itself or something but the vague shape of the blur made it look too vague for you to know exactly what was going on, then it could be a dead cat for all you know in some pose which in a blur looks identical. Then, as the dude in the video explained, by taking 2 pictures like this. You actually can eliminate the information associated with the probability that the cat is dead or dying. Thus going beyond observation, by observing the vague grey information inbetween the 2 states, and eliminating 1 half of the information, you actually just FORCE the observation to be that the cat is alive. You are manipulating and dictating what you observe, rather than observing to determine... you determine TO observe.
I totally get both sides to what you guys are saying, but I believe Quantum Physics is much deeper than that, and that even a blurry photo is the same as observing it...
@@terraminelightvoid5467 but how does it change the true state of it being dead or alive by being blurry? blur is just a malfunction of observation and it won't change true state of being alive or dead imagine we take a picture while we have a heart rate equipment attached to the cat maybe your observation with photo malfunction but heart rate will tell it's alive or dead. and see it this way that the fallacy in observation or mistakes won't change reality of that and basically a blur photo is not an observation by the definition of the word and purpose, cause we don't want to observe whether cat exist in there or not cause we already know, we define observation in order to check if it's alive or not. if you say that a photo is blur it's same as saying making a camera to show opposite of what actually happened inside a box, which is called false observation.
Very interesting. It is actually impressive that a thing can be at two states at the same time. Obviously when looked at it, it has to manifest in a way (either alive or dead in the case of the cat), but the fact that science can actually find ways to look at it in its suppositional state is incredible. Great video!
It's so hard to understand. I'm still learning about the theory of relativity and can't even comprehend it already. Seeing some quantum physics videos makes me just wanna back out. Science is so hard to understand. I haven't understand people who says it's hard but seeing deepeer into it makes me think it's just as hard as my most hated subject bc of its complexity, math. I just wanna understand the world that's actually why I'm learning it and trying to still understand it excluding all these equations you will encounter in these theories bc it's hard for me to understand equations but these concepts is just too hard, to visualize it is hard, to make it make sense is hard.
You got it my freind thats what it is At the very last instant when you are about to see it , it cracks or remains same But for iPhone its is always cracked.
No that's not how it works. Things on a large scale, larger than an atom are not all things at once before being observed. He is talking about the quantum level where physics acts differently. It's common sense that you, your phone, or a real cat cannot be in tow places or two states at once. That's not how matter behaves. But at the quantum level things are in different states at the same time, and only enter one state when observed.
@@x1v160 yeah but what he is sayin is that until you look at the open the box, the cat could be dead or alive. Just like the phone until you lift the phone up, it could be cracked or not cracked
Not a single word I'm able to connect and get a picture about this concept. It is like a dream in sleep appears to be clear but after waking up nothing i could remember
At 4:00. Pause the video and observe the play button within the atom while tilting your phone horizontally. That will explain you all the dynamics of Quantum Physics.
I am impressed and confused at the same time on why scientists in 2023 couldn't even put a modern camera instead of an old one where the photo is blurry. Still an amazing video!
@@tr0ller774 i put my mask correctly when i work with patients, this was when i was taking a break.And you are aboslutely correct , there is no use if its under my nose.
I’ve literally just finished a nuclear physics exam and I’ve got my quantum mechanics exam in two days and rn I’m just taking a break from revision and this appears in my subscription. I feel attacked
Could it be that you are observing your future exam and now (no exam) at the same time? Maybe you have both passed and have not taken the exam as you read this?
@@stevetait8878 OK - Not even kidding, but a study was done re: time-space, & people who studied after an exam vs. not, actually did better on their exam!! So indirectly? You're humour has a hint of bizarre truthiness!🤣😊👍🏼❤
I'm sorry @Jennifer Silva - I'm just starting year 2 of my free online Creditless MIT courses (provided to spread knowledge & studied by nerds like me) & I kinda felt nervous too!! Congrats on your studies BTW!😊👍🏼❤☮
Elektric Skeptic thank you! I’m also on my second year of my physics and astrophysics degree and barely hanging on but quantum is definitely my favourite topic 😂💖
@@eyesyt7571 thats exactly what i was thinking this kind of scientits are so confused that they ask stupids questions there is no question this life is a test based up on you what gos has given you a sertan test that he knows you can just handle if you want but its up on us tho choose
@@eyesyt7571 sure but this thought experiment was just the start to many others on the state of consciousness like the multi verse theory . Its not about the cat directly but the state of consciousness in ourselves and it's impact on the cat itself so it it both because some of us believe it's alive and others believe it's dead
Schrodinger's Cat was an analogy to explain the Copenhagen interpretation of quantum mechanics, i.e., duality of light being a particle or a wave. But the double slit experiment showed that there is no such thing as a particle of light. The state of the energy when traveling at c is always a wave, not a particle or a photon, but instead light is a potential particle in space and time. This is important because when we dig deeper into the experiments using Maxwell's field equations the results imply that when the energy is in the form of a wave and the measuring device is inside the field that is measuring the particle of light it does not even travel through space or time. So time actually has to be removed from the equation else the information appears to travel faster than light. Spooky action beyond what general relativity is able to explain. That interpretation was solidified with quantum entanglement. The entire confusion comes when using general relativity's interpretation claiming that nothing can travel faster than light so the further away we look into space the younger the light becomes. There is a good reason why Einstein called quantum entanglement "spooky action at a distance." All the confusion comes from general relativity assuming that light particles take time to travel. Light particles don't really travel through space or time. The only part of the energy that travels at c is the front of the wave. But the information when it is measured happens in the now so we are able to see the distant object as it looks now. Example. If a galaxy is born 10 billion light years away it doesn't take 10 billion years for it's information to reach us because we are already inside the distant galaxy's field of energy. All the information pertaining to that galaxy, color, distance, temperature, size, brightness, mass, gravity, movement, etc., is seen in the now, not how it looked in the past when the light left the distant galaxy. So when we look at a galaxy 10 billion light years away it could be any age. Thus, if I'm right, and I know I am then the new James Webb Space Telescope, JWST will be able to view old galaxies, much larger than our own Milky Way, but further than 14 billion light years away. The distant galaxies on one side of the universe should appear to be bigger and produce more light than the galaxies near us. And on the other side of the universe the galaxies should appear to be smaller and smaller, younger and younger the further away they are. Some galaxies will appear to have been born and be larger than our galaxy. This hypothesis would even explain why quasars emit so much light. Because they are actually much older and contain more stars than the galaxies near us. We see their light in the now. By measuring massive galaxies instead of the first light at a distance of 14 billion light years away would be empirical evidence to support this wild hypothesis. It would also be empirical evidence that the universe did not begin from a single event (big bang) but instead has taken time to grow to the size and mass the universe is today. More predictions can be made as well, too wild and lengthy to discuss at this time. Conclusion; Believing you can use a telescope to look into the past is as silly as believing you can use a microscope to look into the future. Light information happens in a quantum instant when the measuring device is inside the EM field. It does not take time for the information to travel because the information pertaining to the distant object is potential (see Copenhagen Interpretation and Schrodinger's cat). The information doesn't exist in space or time until the information is measured or observed (see double slit experiment). This has nothing to do with the wave collapsing into a particle. Because in reality the information never really existed as a particle if it travels at c (see superposition). When traveling at c time is zero (see Maxwell's field equation). Time has to be removed from the equation (see quantum entanglement)! All these experiments can only have one commonality that describes them all. The information inside the energy field traveling at c becomes potential and exists outside of space and time. Note this interpretation does not agree with general relativity, but neither does quantum entanglement.
Only 2 likes? The only part of all that I don't like was the statement "I know I'm right" I love that hypothesis. But you can't call it a hypothesis (which it is) and say I know I'm right. You could potentially be though. It makes logical sense. Wow never thought I'd say that to an explanation of quantum physics.
Drawing conclusions from quantum theory to general relativity is the biggest problem of our time, and has been for 100 years. While I disagree with your theory for various reasons, there’s always a chance that our entire view of physics is wrong and those results would be astonishing and quite useful. If we could see far off stars as they are now there goes our communication problems over long distances. Also we already see stars that are further than the age of the universe in light years (they appear older and different) and this happens because of the expansion of the universe due to dark energy makes those distances swell by the time light gets to us, we only catch glimpses of this due to getting lucky with a black hole or galaxy gravitationally lensing and stretching space and time to give us a closer look into the distance of our abyss.
@@AlejandroCab98 Where can I learn more about the relationship between dark energy and expansion? Are you saying they think dark energy swells space-time? Honestly don't know
Tres Patterson it absolutely does that’s what they call the effect that causes the universe expanding faster and faster rather than the slow down that they expected after billions of years the big bang happened. They believe due to the immense power this demonstrates that dark energy makes up most of the universe. Dark matter seems to keep galaxies together and energy makes the large scale structures grow further apart. Dark Matter and the Dinosaurs: The Astounding Interconnectedness of the Universe” is a great book that explains dark energy and matter very simply, where I learned about it. Pretty entertaining too if i find any good videos on the subject here on YT i’ll post them here.
I think that at the quantum level it's SO sensitive that once it's observed, which is a path of least resistance since the act of observation is at a quantum level an adsorption of a tiny amount of energy which collapses the wave function into one of the possibilities.
(Shrodinger's parents were killed by cats) Shrodinger: (Creates whole theory to get cats killed) The rest of the world: Great person! Extremely intelligent! THIS IS A MEME (if you are dumb enough to take seriously this is a joke)
That glorious moment when my brain just refuses to process anything mathematically-related, and so this video left me with more questions than answers. I mean, hey, I still enjoyed it.
Another way to look at it is to measure the temperature of the inside of the box somehow after a certain amount of time, or just when you haven’t heard the cat meow for a while also if you put specific pressure platings on the entire bottom inside of the box you can see how often the cat moves and after it hasn’t moved in a while it’s likely it’s dead
This is really well explained. Great vid. Tried explaining this to my parents when the article was originally brought out. I think I'll just show them this vid.
i think i remember thinking about something similar to this when i was a kid, and i think it was about if things exist when we arent observing it in any way, or if a mirror reflects when we observe it, even if we take videos or photos of it, since that is observing it, it can be seen
1 it makes nois because it's heavy and the tree is made up of wood and have leaves so it will surely make noise 2 no one hear it maybe because they are far
@@kzuna8585 Well you are mostly correct. I too thought I had it figured out for many years. Until I realised that it all depends on what kind of tree, what kind of ground it is landing on, and the distance of the sounds waves that equates to noise. The other part is that what accounts for the noise if no one or anything hears it? You can argue that it does make a sound simply because of size and weight, but no, its only really because many organisms have ears that pick up the sounds. Many other types of organinsms will only feel vibrations, because they have no ears. Thus if an organism has no ears nor central nervous system, then it may not even feel the vibrations. It may only have the primitive version of sight.
This is so cool . I got a little lost but the coin flip metaphor really helped and this video really helped me understand something else I'm currently working on ❤️
"How can we learn its fate without opening the box?" Well, you could put a stethoscope up to the box and listen. (Or sensitive microphone.) Is the cat breathing? Is its heart beating? Is it maybe even walking around within the box? These things will make sounds. If they are detectable even in principle, there is no superposition.
@Is S Yes. I think the answer to the Schrodinger's Cat paradox is that it simply is not possible to completely isolate a complex system like a living animal from interaction with its environment. Therefore, it cannot be in a superposition of states, which requires complete isolation and lack of interaction. No simple box can cause that.
@@fredcarson2667 Pretty much, its the idea of conditional statistics iirc. Given more information, the probability can change at basically any variation.
I'll give it a try. We are talking about particle physics. The cat was the observer and measured movement in the box constantly. Spoiler, the cat lives.
I think it's fascinating. The idea that the cat can be both alive and dead at the same time until observed is mind blowing. It's a way to highlight the strange nature of quantum theory and the role of observation in determining reality.
Black Phillip i like how it seems to sit on perhaps a fence. Clearly there’s a psychics answer to it and there’s also a major philosophical impact the paradox carries.
This video is really amazing and explicative of the scrodinger cat theory and it also serves as a brief introduction of quenatum mechanics and fisics, It is also very interesting on how something can be alive and death at the same time depending on the observation of atoms and the influence on probability.
"schrodinger's cat is most famous cat in history. "
Tom : Am i a joke to you?
Who is Tom?
bruh
@@Pastidellia U CaN't SeE ThE JoKe JeRrY
Hahaha hilarious.. Preety sure Jerry will b sad.
Which Tom?🤔😺
Teacher: "Where's your homework?"
Student: Ma'am, It's in its superposition...
Lmao
Well it was in a superposition until your teacher asked about it. Now you have to present it.
Henri Zwols well actually it wasn't even in superposition, it would be if there would be 50% chance that his homework is finished or not
@@Reino_X From the teacher's perspective it was.
Henri Zwols i guess your right on that one, but in that case the topic wouldn't be about the homwork itself, it'd be about weather that particular student did it or not, because if he didn't have it, the homework would be still in progress in his home
Schrödinger's smiley:
: ) :
HA
HA
Praneel Pathak LOL
: ( :
@Claire Choi thanks 😁
Girl: “guys can’t take hints”
The hint:
Lmfao
So girls are kids got it
Lel
Video went over my head. Was hoping the jokes about the video wouldn't.
@@unfazedo no the joke is that the hint is as hard as solving the Schrödinger's cat riddle.
If the cat is in two different boxes at the same time it is dead for sure.
Just one half the cat is in each box. Funding for this experiment ran short.
Lol
Yea lol
Two different boxes in the cat🤔
quantum physics is best understood when under extreme effects of alcohol.
This is the simplest and most complicated thing i've heard
In a quantum world opposite, uncertain things happen in the same time
You never know until you look in your brain although you would not
@Erlend I believe that's the entire point.
..and...simultaneously, this is the most complex and yet simplest thing you've heard.
Everything is complicated we just simplify it.
Everything is simple we are just looking at too much.
We make the simple seem complicated and the complicated seem simple.
Your crush actually likes you and doesn't like you at the same time, until your curiosity makes you approach her
Im ugly
@@dallas218 lol
Dope
But then we actually realize all of us here won't ever get a girlfriend
Nice thinking
When you open the box and the cat is dead, curiosity literally killed the cat
@Celert so this where that saying comes from?
That was genious :D
Yes but what if the
Cat only used one life.
Oh that's why! 👏😮
I searched the keywords "sub atomic particle & law of attraction" that's how I remembered to watch this video
99th like
I am still confused but on a higher level
But you are confused and not confused at the same time
I am confused in superposition
Lol
It's the stupidity what confuses
If you didn’t study a little bit of quantum physics...it will be difficult to understand the meaning of our reality’s nature...
Kick the box, an angry cat is a good sign that its alive.
Finally solved
FitnessONI you’d kick over the poison flask so you’d kill it
@@PrinceBallytv Or maybe not, simultaneously 😂
Go ahead, kick a steel box. I dare you
Good luck kicking a steel box
Physicists: Did You Die?
Schrödinger's Cat: I Died, But I LIVED!
‘Sadly yes, but I lived!’
“Tell schrodinger im alive
"I live, I die, I live again!"
~Warcat
Lol
My mind is like shrödinger now
I both understand it and not at the same time
Best. 😂
Lol😅
Brilliant 👏
Ridddle: Schrödinger’s cat is the most famous cat in history!
Garfield: Am I a joke to you?
Yes.
Nyan cat: allow me to introduce myself
This would make a fantastic ERBH video.
Yes
Tom: Who the hell is garfield!?
Science the more you understand the less you understand something like this.
I must be a professor doctor in quantum mechanics for I didn't get any of this.
Science, the more you understand, the more you realize how much don't understand.
@@ryanqube9132 Exactly my point.
More u know in the science more u discover the unknown
quantum science is best understood when undergoing extreme effects of alcohol.
Philosophers: "To be or not to be?"
Schrödinger: Yes
Teacher: How to make a thing complicated??
Me: Add quantum to it...SIMPLE!!!
Lol
I love quantum social science
My life is more complicated than this..
Literally every movie that tries to sound sciency
Literally this guy saying "quantum magic"
So, before I open that bag in the drive-through of McDonald's, my fries could both be there and not there. 🤪
yes, but actually no :)
@@megazaspal8537
😂🤣
They say that ....
No, the person who put/didn't put the fries in the bag knows about it, so this theory doesn't apply in this case.
@@chiggen_wings5703
Some days later, the fries could be expired or not until you open the bag
Me: sees video
Me 10min later: “ Puts aluminum in microwave “
Lol
Don't be dumb!
You have to wet the aluminium first!
Then microwave it :)
Nice
Why didnt you season it first
I find it interesting that the most famous allegory for superposition, a complicated quantum physics phenomena, is a cat in a box.
I'm dumb af when it comes to science, but this guy make me want to learn everything.
Neighbor : can have my cat back now...?
Me : i aa aa ,
well yes but Actually no!
😂
Best comment I've seen in a while.
Just say ppssppsps
@@g1ntok147 kskskskksks
The correct answer is: Yo
Taking a picture of the cat is *the same* as observing it.
Also, the title claims the riddle has been solved; however, at the end of the video, it says it has only been *partially solved*
So could we then conclude that this video is both legit and *clickbait* at the same time? 🤔🤔
It's clearly in more than one box (computer/smartphone)...
You didn't pay attention. The camera they use, deliberately doesn't take in all of the information. It's not the same as observing it with your eyeball or other equipment, because that stuff would record ALL of the image/information. But the kind of camera they are talking about is blurred enough that you cannot actually say whether the cat is dead or alive just by looking at it. It's a greyed blob, so it could be dead or it could be laying down? Or whatever?
By blurring the image, as far as Quantum Physics is concerned, you have only recorded enough information that would be in either state. A blurred photo of a living cat and blurred photo of a dead cat, is merely identical from an information perspective. If you could see the cat was laying in a stiff and ragdoll way, that's how you would know it was dead. If it looked like how a cat lays when it sleeps, or it just was cleaning itself or something but the vague shape of the blur made it look too vague for you to know exactly what was going on, then it could be a dead cat for all you know in some pose which in a blur looks identical.
Then, as the dude in the video explained, by taking 2 pictures like this. You actually can eliminate the information associated with the probability that the cat is dead or dying. Thus going beyond observation, by observing the vague grey information inbetween the 2 states, and eliminating 1 half of the information, you actually just FORCE the observation to be that the cat is alive. You are manipulating and dictating what you observe, rather than observing to determine... you determine TO observe.
I totally get both sides to what you guys are saying, but I believe Quantum Physics is much deeper than that, and that even a blurry photo is the same as observing it...
@@TwentyTwoThirtyThree I understand
Terramine Lightvoid you just typed an entire story my guy
@@terraminelightvoid5467 but how does it change the true state of it being dead or alive by being blurry? blur is just a malfunction of observation and it won't change true state of being alive or dead imagine we take a picture while we have a heart rate equipment attached to the cat maybe your observation with photo malfunction but heart rate will tell it's alive or dead.
and see it this way that the fallacy in observation or mistakes won't change reality of that and basically a blur photo is not an observation by the definition of the word and purpose, cause we don't want to observe whether cat exist in there or not cause we already know, we define observation in order to check if it's alive or not. if you say that a photo is blur it's same as saying making a camera to show opposite of what actually happened inside a box, which is called false observation.
Title: Schrodinger's Cat is finally solved.
The end of the video: "This riddle is only partially solved."
Me: "Is this clickbait?"
Schrodinger's clickbait
Yes and no
Lmao.. that was the Longest run-on sentence ever lolFor the whole 10 minutes the narrator didn't pause at all 😂😂😅
I've solved this riddle. I'm dead inside and I'm still breathing 👌✌
R u a cat
@Pablu mijare diaz don't be hard on yourself. Hug someone.
R u a cat
@@syphoss3621 R u a cat
@Y O J I M B O 用心棒 R u a cat?
Physics is like cartoon cheese with holes. The more we know, the more we don't know
Title: “The biggest mystery finally solved”
Watched till the end: “while this mystery is only partially solved...”
me: “eat a d”
Very interesting. It is actually impressive that a thing can be at two states at the same time. Obviously when looked at it, it has to manifest in a way (either alive or dead in the case of the cat), but the fact that science can actually find ways to look at it in its suppositional state is incredible. Great video!
An object cannot exist in two states simultaneously, we lack the technology to disprove that. All of this is speculation and not factual.
I remember someone said
"Whoever claims to understand quantum physics, they don't"
He's right.
Niels Bhor
I understand that I can't understand it
It was Feynman who said it
It's so hard to understand. I'm still learning about the theory of relativity and can't even comprehend it already. Seeing some quantum physics videos makes me just wanna back out. Science is so hard to understand. I haven't understand people who says it's hard but seeing deepeer into it makes me think it's just as hard as my most hated subject bc of its complexity, math. I just wanna understand the world that's actually why I'm learning it and trying to still understand it excluding all these equations you will encounter in these theories bc it's hard for me to understand equations but these concepts is just too hard, to visualize it is hard, to make it make sense is hard.
@@er404music same I get the gist but meh too
So its like when you drop an IPhone on the ground. Until you lift it up, it could be cracked or not cracked😂
You got it my freind thats what it is
At the very last instant when you are about to see it , it cracks or remains same
But for iPhone its is always cracked.
No that's not how it works. Things on a large scale, larger than an atom are not all things at once before being observed. He is talking about the quantum level where physics acts differently. It's common sense that you, your phone, or a real cat cannot be in tow places or two states at once. That's not how matter behaves. But at the quantum level things are in different states at the same time, and only enter one state when observed.
@@x1v160 yeah but what he is sayin is that until you look at the open the box, the cat could be dead or alive. Just like the phone until you lift the phone up, it could be cracked or not cracked
@@x1v160 yup
I am in highschool
Thanks for clarifying my concepts
Thanks sir
@Bogdan778 Hahahaha!!!
Everyone for a century: THIS TRULY IS A MYSTERY
Two guys: can't we just use a camera?
Everyone: give these guys a medal
Plot twist cat lays on camera lens and is silent next
But isn't it observing, even through a camera? Therefore invalid?
I see,you don’t know what observing means
@@anti_nyx they weren't observing through a camera really
But observer effect could change things
Not a single word I'm able to connect and get a picture about this concept. It is like a dream in sleep appears to be clear but after waking up nothing i could remember
Imagine having this dude in a physics lecture. It would sound like a movie trailer
What I learn from school: 10%
What I learn from CZcams: 90%
In conclusion: School is Useless
I learned from books
If u didn't learn the 10% from school,u wouldn't understand the other 90% from youtube
@@arnawlfightsuh8531 I think she is a teacher working in the school
Wait until neural link 20-30 year from now . school system might get isolate
let's defund schools let's stop sending kids to schools let's see how it goes
At 4:00. Pause the video and observe the play button within the atom while tilting your phone horizontally. That will explain you all the dynamics of Quantum Physics.
I am impressed and confused at the same time on why scientists in 2023 couldn't even put a modern camera instead of an old one where the photo is blurry. Still an amazing video!
Lesson learned today:
Keep your cats away from a box with a poison bottle.
Cat is like : stupid humans finally they got this
There is no use of ur mask
Fax
Lol
@@tr0ller774 i put my mask correctly when i work with patients, this was when i was taking a break.And you are aboslutely correct , there is no use if its under my nose.
@@hris02 👍
...you make a noise, if the cat reacts, it's alive, if it doesn't react, it's dead.
This video managed to confuze me more than i was before
I’ve literally just finished a nuclear physics exam and I’ve got my quantum mechanics exam in two days and rn I’m just taking a break from revision and this appears in my subscription. I feel attacked
Could it be that you are observing your future exam and now (no exam) at the same time? Maybe you have both passed and have not taken the exam as you read this?
@@stevetait8878 OK - Not even kidding, but a study was done re: time-space, & people who studied after an exam vs. not, actually did better on their exam!! So indirectly? You're humour has a hint of bizarre truthiness!🤣😊👍🏼❤
I'm sorry @Jennifer Silva - I'm just starting year 2 of my free online Creditless MIT courses (provided to spread knowledge & studied by nerds like me) & I kinda felt nervous too!! Congrats on your studies BTW!😊👍🏼❤☮
Elektric Skeptic thank you! I’m also on my second year of my physics and astrophysics degree and barely hanging on but quantum is definitely my favourite topic 😂💖
@@jennifersilva3448 Awesome - My fav. too!! So much love to you•I'm Verrry Impressed & I *KNOW* you can do it! ❤❤
Me: seeing a video on YT that seems interesting
Me 10mins later: how is it solved if it is not solved yet ?
the answer is in a super position!
The multiverse my friend, the multiverse
It is solved and not solved at the same time.
The cat: “HEY, IM DEAD, PLEASE HELP ME, OPEN THE DAMN BOX!!”
Schrodinger's cat is basically explaining an alive and not-alive mystery, I do find it interesting, yet too confusing.
Everyone:
Cats* hmm, cute........
Schrödinger: Let's put em in a box.
Why am I even watching this? I don’t even understand..
Because you do understand that you dont understand ?
Because you evidently do not suffer from Dunning Kruger and therefore you understand the value of curiosity
The whole thing is a hoax, whether we look at the cat or not doesn't matter, it is either dead or alive.
@@eyesyt7571 thats exactly what i was thinking this kind of scientits are so confused that they ask stupids questions there is no question this life is a test based up on you what gos has given you a sertan test that he knows you can just handle if you want but its up on us tho choose
@@eyesyt7571 sure but this thought experiment was just the start to many others on the state of consciousness like the multi verse theory . Its not about the cat directly but the state of consciousness in ourselves and it's impact on the cat itself so it it both because some of us believe it's alive and others believe it's dead
I always find quantum physics so fascinating so nothing exists till we look at it
Narrator: this cat because the most popular cat in the history
Tom: am I joked to you??
yeah it's in top comments already
Schrodinger's Cat was an analogy to explain the Copenhagen interpretation of quantum mechanics, i.e., duality of light being a particle or a wave. But the double slit experiment showed that there is no such thing as a particle of light. The state of the energy when traveling at c is always a wave, not a particle or a photon, but instead light is a potential particle in space and time. This is important because when we dig deeper into the experiments using Maxwell's field equations the results imply that when the energy is in the form of a wave and the measuring device is inside the field that is measuring the particle of light it does not even travel through space or time. So time actually has to be removed from the equation else the information appears to travel faster than light. Spooky action beyond what general relativity is able to explain. That interpretation was solidified with quantum entanglement.
The entire confusion comes when using general relativity's interpretation claiming that nothing can travel faster than light so the further away we look into space the younger the light becomes. There is a good reason why Einstein called quantum entanglement "spooky action at a distance." All the confusion comes from general relativity assuming that light particles take time to travel.
Light particles don't really travel through space or time. The only part of the energy that travels at c is the front of the wave. But the information when it is measured happens in the now so we are able to see the distant object as it looks now. Example. If a galaxy is born 10 billion light years away it doesn't take 10 billion years for it's information to reach us because we are already inside the distant galaxy's field of energy. All the information pertaining to that galaxy, color, distance, temperature, size, brightness, mass, gravity, movement, etc., is seen in the now, not how it looked in the past when the light left the distant galaxy. So when we look at a galaxy 10 billion light years away it could be any age.
Thus, if I'm right, and I know I am then the new James Webb Space Telescope, JWST will be able to view old galaxies, much larger than our own Milky Way, but further than 14 billion light years away. The distant galaxies on one side of the universe should appear to be bigger and produce more light than the galaxies near us. And on the other side of the universe the galaxies should appear to be smaller and smaller, younger and younger the further away they are. Some galaxies will appear to have been born and be larger than our galaxy. This hypothesis would even explain why quasars emit so much light. Because they are actually much older and contain more stars than the galaxies near us. We see their light in the now.
By measuring massive galaxies instead of the first light at a distance of 14 billion light years away would be empirical evidence to support this wild hypothesis. It would also be empirical evidence that the universe did not begin from a single event (big bang) but instead has taken time to grow to the size and mass the universe is today. More predictions can be made as well, too wild and lengthy to discuss at this time.
Conclusion; Believing you can use a telescope to look into the past is as silly as believing you can use a microscope to look into the future. Light information happens in a quantum instant when the measuring device is inside the EM field. It does not take time for the information to travel because the information pertaining to the distant object is potential (see Copenhagen Interpretation and Schrodinger's cat). The information doesn't exist in space or time until the information is measured or observed (see double slit experiment). This has nothing to do with the wave collapsing into a particle. Because in reality the information never really existed as a particle if it travels at c (see superposition). When traveling at c time is zero (see Maxwell's field equation). Time has to be removed from the equation (see quantum entanglement)! All these experiments can only have one commonality that describes them all. The information inside the energy field traveling at c becomes potential and exists outside of space and time. Note this interpretation does not agree with general relativity, but neither does quantum entanglement.
Only 2 likes? The only part of all that I don't like was the statement "I know I'm right" I love that hypothesis. But you can't call it a hypothesis (which it is) and say I know I'm right. You could potentially be though. It makes logical sense. Wow never thought I'd say that to an explanation of quantum physics.
Yes
Drawing conclusions from quantum theory to general relativity is the biggest problem of our time, and has been for 100 years. While I disagree with your theory for various reasons, there’s always a chance that our entire view of physics is wrong and those results would be astonishing and quite useful. If we could see far off stars as they are now there goes our communication problems over long distances. Also we already see stars that are further than the age of the universe in light years (they appear older and different) and this happens because of the expansion of the universe due to dark energy makes those distances swell by the time light gets to us, we only catch glimpses of this due to getting lucky with a black hole or galaxy gravitationally lensing and stretching space and time to give us a closer look into the distance of our abyss.
@@AlejandroCab98 Where can I learn more about the relationship between dark energy and expansion? Are you saying they think dark energy swells space-time? Honestly don't know
Tres Patterson it absolutely does that’s what they call the effect that causes the universe expanding faster and faster rather than the slow down that they expected after billions of years the big bang happened. They believe due to the immense power this demonstrates that dark energy makes up most of the universe. Dark matter seems to keep galaxies together and energy makes the large scale structures grow further apart. Dark Matter and the Dinosaurs: The Astounding Interconnectedness of the Universe” is a great book that explains dark energy and matter very simply, where I learned about it. Pretty entertaining too if i find any good videos on the subject here on YT i’ll post them here.
The cat has 7 lives, it will be alive until the 7th try
Are you a Hindu?😂😂
Its actually 9 lives
@the god of cringe the stonks guy
Where is it written?
The joke is that it lost two lives
I think that at the quantum level it's SO sensitive that once it's observed, which is a path of least resistance since the act of observation is at a quantum level an adsorption of a tiny amount of energy which collapses the wave function into one of the possibilities.
Scientists to cat :- are you dead ?
Cat:- well yes but actually no
New discovery: cats have 18 lives
chaseanader nah, 21
@@erlendslette5599 nah 24
nah just 1 (opinion)
It's 69 lives
Click bait, this solves nothing at all.
No it doesn't solves because it was already solved by scientist, its just a news video
the amount of sensationalism in this channel gets me triggered so hard
That's the point.
There are no sources anywhere either.
@@emanuelbalaban4089 Sorry but you are wrong, this has not been solved. And really the point of it is that it can never really be solved.
(Shrodinger's parents were killed by cats)
Shrodinger: (Creates whole theory to get cats killed)
The rest of the world: Great person! Extremely intelligent! THIS IS A MEME (if you are dumb enough to take seriously this is a joke)
The last line “Quantum computer capable of Digitizing human consciousness and endless sources of energy” really got me.
Riddle: Schrödinger's cat is the most famous cat in history!
Salad cat with yelling lady: Am i a joke to you?
Haha 😂😂😂😂
What about Pavlov's dog?
AAAAAHHH!!!!A TALKING CAT!
@@Dexter-rv3nt it's a dog.... Idiot
Yes, that cat is literally a joke..
Wow Sheldon cooper is gonna be so mad he didn’t solve it himself
That glorious moment when my brain just refuses to process anything mathematically-related, and so this video left me with more questions than answers. I mean, hey, I still enjoyed it.
Another way to look at it is to measure the temperature of the inside of the box somehow after a certain amount of time, or just when you haven’t heard the cat meow for a while also if you put specific pressure platings on the entire bottom inside of the box you can see how often the cat moves and after it hasn’t moved in a while it’s likely it’s dead
You don’t seem to understand. Its the observation that determines the collapsing function. Sight isn’t the only method of observation.
There is only one way to solve this .... I'm getting the neighbours cat ..
no you savage
@@TheLabDragon No buts get into the box now ....
@@parthasarathyvenkatadri never I cant
@@TheLabDragon Here follow this fur ball ... Come on ... There it goes into the box ....
@@parthasarathyvenkatadri lol your a savage
This is really well explained. Great vid. Tried explaining this to my parents when the article was originally brought out. I think I'll just show them this vid.
i think i remember thinking about something similar to this when i was a kid, and i think it was about if things exist when we arent observing it in any way, or if a mirror reflects when we observe it, even if we take videos or photos of it, since that is observing it, it can be seen
The thing that gets me is HOW DOES THE UNIVERSE DEFINE AN OBSERVER?!?!
Consciousness.
Fun fact:
The cat solved the thingy
When the box is opened, The cat cannot be in both states at once
Me: *coughs* people of science, please allow me to present to you... ZOMBIE CAT!
Same as if you're in your house and a friend outside without knocking wondering if you're there inside or gone
I feel like getting everything and not understand everything at the same time.
So I am at superposition
Its like that old saying..."if a tree falls and no one is around to hear it, does it make a noise?" LOL. Im just playing.........or am I?
Maybe
1 it makes nois because it's heavy and the tree is made up of wood and have leaves so it will surely make noise
2 no one hear it maybe because they are far
BNIBCD Creative Media (vsauce theme kicks in)
@@kzuna8585 Well you are mostly correct. I too thought I had it figured out for many years. Until I realised that it all depends on what kind of tree, what kind of ground it is landing on, and the distance of the sounds waves that equates to noise. The other part is that what accounts for the noise if no one or anything hears it? You can argue that it does make a sound simply because of size and weight, but no, its only really because many organisms have ears that pick up the sounds. Many other types of organinsms will only feel vibrations, because they have no ears. Thus if an organism has no ears nor central nervous system, then it may not even feel the vibrations. It may only have the primitive version of sight.
Its does it make sound not noise 😂
This may be a 2 year old video but watching this right as I was starting Rascal Does Not Dream of Bunny Girl Senpai made me understand so much more
Now I undestood superposition, and didn't, at the same time.
Now I'm confused whether am dead or alive when I fell asleep lol.
ERROR ME IS CONFUZZLED
This is so cool . I got a little lost but the coin flip metaphor really helped and this video really helped me understand something else I'm currently working on ❤️
Instruction Unclear, Accidentally Invented Immortality.
"How can we learn its fate without opening the box?"
Well, you could put a stethoscope up to the box and listen. (Or sensitive microphone.) Is the cat breathing? Is its heart beating? Is it maybe even walking around within the box? These things will make sounds. If they are detectable even in principle, there is no superposition.
@Is S Yes. I think the answer to the Schrodinger's Cat paradox is that it simply is not possible to completely isolate a complex system like a living animal from interaction with its environment. Therefore, it cannot be in a superposition of states, which requires complete isolation and lack of interaction. No simple box can cause that.
No not the cat!
The cat is technically an observer too.
Monsai Bodonsai yeah for the cat you might have died from a heart attack as well but it will never know until somebody opens the box
But isnt the cat the event?
This is like seeing something that u can’t see at the same time
9:50
That cute smile of the 🐈
When you're on your last of your 9 lives and you gotta activate a cheat to stay alive
The Cat's consciousness affects the outcome !!!
Nothing Personal Kid So before the box is opened the cat knows whether it's dead or alive but we don't.
@@fredcarson2667 Pretty much, its the idea of conditional statistics iirc. Given more information, the probability can change at basically any variation.
@@fredcarson2667 is it possible for a dead cat to know if he is dead?
Why am i seeing this right after watching Bunny Girl?
Bunny girl senpai!!
Because she is a bunny and a girl at the same time
@@senbonkzakura7991 huh?
I'll give it a try. We are talking about particle physics. The cat was the observer and measured movement in the box constantly. Spoiler, the cat lives.
Me: are you dead or alive?
Cat: Y E S .
this is just the theory of probability explained with difficulty to confuse viewers
4:14 there were scientists from hiroshima and bombay.
I hope you get it
Bomb ayy
Hiroshima bomb
Bomb bay
You have bigger brain than the scientists
Savage....
Even tho the city is called Mumbai now
This video explains how bizzare are quantum physics, this also shows that quantum physics are full of surprises. Nice video!
I think it's fascinating. The idea that the cat can be both alive and dead at the same time until observed is mind blowing. It's a way to highlight the strange nature of quantum theory and the role of observation in determining reality.
"Imagine that you..."
here we go again...
*gets comfortable*
I always thought Schrodinger's Cat was a meta-physical question
Krohl the Slain many thanks 🤍 good to see another fan on the internet !
Black Phillip i like how it seems to sit on perhaps a fence. Clearly there’s a psychics answer to it and there’s also a major philosophical impact the paradox carries.
in my opinion I find that the experiment sparks discussions about the nature of reality and the strange behavior of particles at the quantum level
How u doing mate??
quantum physicist: Good question..
So, you’re telling me that the dilemma of Schrödinger’s cat is potentially solvable using elementary cat pictures?
Endless sources of energy and Quantum computers with better AI?! That's phenomenal!! It's historical! That could change the world pretty soon!!
We all know what they will be used for. Controlling the hoi polloi.
And who will control those supplies of energy? The rich and powerful.
@@anonb4632 What does that have to do with the price of tea in China?
@@NetTubeUser Our freedom.
@@anonb4632 You're not only paranoid, but you also develop an inferiority complex, which is intriguing and fascinating to me, really.
Every second of this video just confuses me on a higher level each time
This video is really amazing and explicative of the scrodinger cat theory and it also serves as a brief introduction of quenatum mechanics and fisics, It is also very interesting on how something can be alive and death at the same time depending on the observation of atoms and the influence on probability.
Narrator: IMAGINE...
Me: that scared the shit out of me
well damn ive never been THIS early. literally says "no views" xD
You've achieved everything a person can now. Nothing to do but sit back and enjoy the fame.
@@jaybones8457 my life is truly complete. It said it was posted 20 seconds ago when I clicked it
wow what an achievement
Congratulations! You've avoided saying "first!" And being cancer!
this sounds very simple but it gets more complicated the more you think about it
Just say the cat one word and you will know without opening the box "treat!" 😂😂
Well....that was clear as mud. Thanks.