Figure Drawing Critiques 6 - Mannequinization

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 19. 10. 2013
  • Full Access to Figure Drawing Videos - www.proko.com/figure
    Marshall's Website: www.marshallart.com
    Marshall Vandruff and Stan Prokopenko critique students' drawings based on the Mannequinization video:
    • Mannequinization - Str...
    And some questions answered:
    How to hold a pencil
    How to control line weight
    Students: Don Le, Kenny Vo, Remar, Delia Tee, Peter Yoo
    Follow Proko:
    Facebook - / prokotv
    Twitter - / stanprokopenko
    Instagram - / stanprokopenko
    Tumblr - / stanprokopenko
    Google+ - bit.ly/stangplus
    Email Newsletter- www.proko.com/subscribe
    Follow Marshall:
    www.marshallart.com
    ---
    Music used with permission
    Music Intro - www.freakfandango.es/
    #ArtCritique #DrawingCritique #StudentArtwork

Komentáře • 78

  • @breezysd
    @breezysd Před 4 lety +229

    I feel like I could disarm a bomb if I had Marshall talking me through it

  • @TheJahn1
    @TheJahn1 Před 10 lety +129

    I'm really disappointed that I haven't seen any comments on Marshall's cylinders-as-boxes explanation. It was amazingly explained, and contributed something of tremendous value. Thanks so much!

  • @IwanAcleverUtubeName
    @IwanAcleverUtubeName Před 10 lety +164

    Controlling your cylinders by creating boxes to define planes . . . something so simple yet so mind-blowing at the same time! You guys are amazing!

  • @MalkathiusRecord
    @MalkathiusRecord Před 10 lety +50

    Damn, Marshall's pretty slick.

  • @mediapajaoy
    @mediapajaoy Před 10 lety +21

    Marshalls cylinder-box relationship explanation is fantastic. Thank you! Oh and the accents were fun!

  • @sky44david
    @sky44david Před 10 lety +34

    The best of any figure drawing instruction anywhere on you tube. The detail of explanation is so instructive.

  • @hgsupertramp
    @hgsupertramp Před 10 lety +22

    What an awesome explanation about the benefits of making box forms. Marshall is a great teacher besides an great artist. Thanks Stan!

  • @Vinterdragen
    @Vinterdragen Před 10 lety +15

    Marshall! you are such a good voice actor!
    Awsome critiques Stan and Marshall, thanks!

  • @mobiusloop339
    @mobiusloop339 Před 5 lety +99

    Me: *sees first one* Damn those are perfect!
    Them: "These aren't structural yet"
    Me: oh

    • @IamALeaf
      @IamALeaf Před 5 lety +7

      it was almost just contours no construction or gesture stuff (well there was gesture actually)
      and that makes it look like you traced that drawing or just look at the reference picture you had and drew the lines one by one which improves you very slowly drawing

    • @mobiusloop339
      @mobiusloop339 Před 5 lety +10

      It's been 6 months since this comment and now I DEFINITELY see what they were trying to say.

  • @khuzang
    @khuzang Před 10 lety +4

    These critiques are very helpful! I'm even more grateful you guys put videos every week.
    I really appreciate the work you guys are doing.

  • @mattecrash
    @mattecrash Před 10 lety +3

    Stan and Marshall, I can't thank you enough for your video explanations and critiques now I draw every day with pleasure and understanding.

  • @yuuza
    @yuuza Před 2 lety +1

    omg the voices are everything!! made my day

  • @nathanielwhidbee1310
    @nathanielwhidbee1310 Před 10 lety +25

    Lmfao The way he switched Accents!

  • @AMBIPOZE
    @AMBIPOZE Před 10 lety +2

    One of the best episode! Thank You very much!

  • @Socrates...
    @Socrates... Před 10 lety +17

    I bought the perspective stuff from Marshall. Please do more videos with him and Glen Vilppu.

  • @yogeshwarjaimangal3251
    @yogeshwarjaimangal3251 Před 10 lety +1

    Love all your videos! This one in particular has been very helpful.

  • @KoniWorx
    @KoniWorx Před 10 lety +1

    Thank you a lot for this video! Please keep doing crits. Doing crits for others and for us to see helps everyone!

  • @imnooneh
    @imnooneh Před rokem

    Thanks proko for all lessons

  • @CaCriGuz
    @CaCriGuz Před 8 lety +1

    Thank you so much guys !!!
    You cant even imagine how much you are helping me :)
    please, keep it up
    Cheers from Colombia :D

  • @supermariosunshine64
    @supermariosunshine64 Před 5 lety +4

    More videos with Marshall please~!

  • @rronbajri
    @rronbajri Před 7 lety +1

    You guys are great! Just saved my life.

  • @Argadeux
    @Argadeux Před 10 lety +1

    Very nice, I always watch your videos, they r great!

  • @jangzterrizer9405
    @jangzterrizer9405 Před 10 lety

    amazing episode !

  • @MrBurgerphone1014
    @MrBurgerphone1014 Před 7 lety +4

    Marshall's the best

  • @JacksonTaylorandTheSinners

    Y’all really great at this.

  • @Annabells117
    @Annabells117 Před 10 lety +2

    Marshall's cylinder-to-box explanation was helpful. I learned figure construction this way but illustrators get lazy & just draw contour bc it's faster & fine for small works. But in my larger fine art (paintings & charcoal) my figures look better when constructed Marshall + Proko way

  • @TheRajatfx
    @TheRajatfx Před 10 lety

    Helped a lot. Thanks for Great videos.

  • @kzakaria91
    @kzakaria91 Před 10 lety

    hey proko thanks for your videos and great effort that u put in these videos , am wondering if you're going to make a figure drawing demo like how do u approach it from start to finish btw the Critiques are super cool

  • @Neverendingsmile85
    @Neverendingsmile85 Před 10 lety

    I'm an italian "amateur", and I truly like these lessons. Thank you very much. :)

  • @CopperPudding
    @CopperPudding Před 5 lety +3

    I laughed so much when the screen flipped for the left-handed pencil hold question!! HAHAHA

  • @madlade98
    @madlade98 Před 2 lety +1

    Marshall, I am adopting u XD god do I wish more of us had access to an amazing teacher in person. I can only imagine how cool it would be to either one of their students

  • @patrickerz
    @patrickerz Před 9 lety +9

    Maestros!!

  • @maracuja55
    @maracuja55 Před 4 lety +1

    Very useful !

  • @kanachiaki
    @kanachiaki Před 10 lety +1

    Marshal's voice is so fun to listen to XD

  • @bijoythewimp2854
    @bijoythewimp2854 Před 3 lety +2

    Vandruff and proko are like the Breaking Bad of Art

  • @CerridwenVids
    @CerridwenVids Před 5 lety +1

    Following on the question on how holding the pencil affects your lines, how does that follow through when you're doing digital stuff?

  • @MrBKuv
    @MrBKuv Před 6 lety +3

    Marshall is one smart guy. Think box first to avoid sloppiness. Then use angles for cylinders and cross contours. I've never heard anyone talk like that.

  • @firrycel
    @firrycel Před 2 lety +1

    i cant stop thinking of the funny moment when stan says "marshall art thats like a " :)) thats what i was thinking

  • @GolgoX3
    @GolgoX3 Před 10 lety

    Очень круто! Большое спасибо.

  • @andersdenkend
    @andersdenkend Před 4 lety +4

    Damn, is Marshall a part time voice actor, too???

  • @robinlinh
    @robinlinh Před 9 lety +7

    hi, I'm big fan of your channel, I love it so much, but I have 2 questions I want to ask you:
    The first thing I notice is that gesture is very important, so the first must do thing is capturing the gesture. But after that, I'm really confuse between manequinization, landmark adding and robo bean. I mean I don't know which is necessary and which is not, and the use case of those 3. Should I use all of those 3 in every drawing or some time use this one, some time not? I hope you can clear this part for me so we will know how to put all your lesson together in one drawing.
    Also, the second one I would like to ask is could you do a full time laps of your drawing for a full body model? In this way we can see how it is started and how it is finished in complete. I know this will be too much for most of us to learn but I just really want to see the big picture, that how we can combine everything we learn from your channel to one. Maybe now we can't see it all but time by time, with your channel, we can look back and clear things more and more and I think that is an very effective way to learn.
    Thank you for reading this and your hard work

    • @MuddyRawwr
      @MuddyRawwr Před 9 lety +1

      I have the same doubt. I mean, how are we supposed to use them? Should I start with gesture or not? That's confusing :z

    • @robinlinh
      @robinlinh Před 9 lety +1

      the gesture part is clear for me, you must always do the gesture, it tells the story. It is the "getting to detail" that gets me confused

    • @MuddyRawwr
      @MuddyRawwr Před 9 lety +2

      So gesture is used as a draft?

    • @keithrowsell6847
      @keithrowsell6847 Před 8 lety +6

      +Le tuan linh I can answer that, what they are teaching you here are tools to use for solving problems within you drawings, you don't have to use all of them in every one of your drawings, but once you learn how to use them they can help you with perspective or the structure of a person within the drawing etc. You may even draw all of the body correctly, but you're having some troubles with the foreshortening of the arm, so then it's a handy trick to use the simplified structure technique to conquer the issue. There are artist that know anatomy so well the needn't use any of these techniques, not even the gesture drawing (though these artists are few and far between).

    • @robinlinh
      @robinlinh Před 8 lety +2

      Keith Rowsell thank you for your reply. I figured it out after a lot of practicing.

  • @jsnlu369
    @jsnlu369 Před 10 lety +1

    yaaaaaaaaaaaar another thumbs up!

  • @sebagonzalez4874
    @sebagonzalez4874 Před 6 lety +8

    11:00 Best accent ever

  • @mrnekron7042
    @mrnekron7042 Před rokem

    The right and left hand difference he showed was AWESOME XD lol. Love from India

  • @ahmedaly5213
    @ahmedaly5213 Před 10 lety

    very good

  • @Amarp123456
    @Amarp123456 Před 10 lety +1

    Thanks proko can u plz teach how to make fashion figures plz plz

  • @DUDECUSzxc
    @DUDECUSzxc Před 8 lety +1

    What was that black thing on stans hand?

    • @samfortunato
      @samfortunato Před 8 lety +2

      pretty sure it's a smudge guard. they're drawing on a giant touch screen, so the smudge guard can prevent handprints and such on the screen.

  • @rosar.4293
    @rosar.4293 Před 10 lety

    Cool.

  • @Moebius007
    @Moebius007 Před 10 lety

    Funny Teaching..Thanks~!

  • @Carbon2861996
    @Carbon2861996 Před 10 lety +2

    Hey, Stan, with the pencil holding thing....what if my hand shakes horribly?

    • @tyvonable
      @tyvonable Před 10 lety +1

      Carbon2861996 i think you should relax your hands more.

    • @sondersays3320
      @sondersays3320 Před 10 lety +5

      Have a chicken sandwich, have a nap, do some stretches, take a deep breath.
      Then focus and try again :)

  • @Uhcip
    @Uhcip Před 10 lety +2

    is...that cintiq the size of a table? wow

  • @qrayn
    @qrayn Před 10 lety +2

    Wait wait wait is he also reading the narrator of "The Stanley Parable"? XD

  • @tiagocandeias6553
    @tiagocandeias6553 Před 4 lety +1

    WHAT AN ACCENT XD

  • @artwhat..
    @artwhat.. Před rokem

    Proko.. I'm using a .05 mechanical pencil, when I lay it down on it's side I get the same thickness line,ba da bing..

  • @pottergeist
    @pottergeist Před 7 lety

    the guy is the stanley parable narrator

  • @beestonpalani07
    @beestonpalani07 Před 8 lety +1

    kind of looks like decaprio.

  • @stikosstikos5131
    @stikosstikos5131 Před 3 lety +1

    Their so mentally strong

  • @natalitseitlin2344
    @natalitseitlin2344 Před 10 lety

    Чудесные уроки. И как жаль, что их нет на русском....

  • @roman2024pc
    @roman2024pc Před 9 lety +1

    Is this uncle Vessemir??

  • @sirflatfoot6720
    @sirflatfoot6720 Před 10 lety

    MartialArt

  • @Thestripper1
    @Thestripper1 Před 4 lety

    Yo Stan! It is difficult to see your black pen demonstration while you are wearing a black glove and a black shirt. Think values Stan.

  • @general_iroh_
    @general_iroh_ Před 8 lety +1

    My Gesture looks great, but the details look shit

  • @Krisjennewein
    @Krisjennewein Před 4 lety

    Being left handed didn't bother...DuhflippinVincheee!!!! (clutches pearls). However; don't be too quick to patronize the slog through existence that is the plight of the left handed. Especially when you consider the creative edge, not thinking like y'all has for us. (in most circumstances, and under encouraging conditions, some assembly required.)

  • @jorgepuente6242
    @jorgepuente6242 Před 10 lety

    to much critiques.