The Isle Vs Path of Titans | Which is worth it? | Which should you play? Pros and Cons of each!
Vložit
- čas přidán 8. 04. 2021
- Hello everyone! Today we take a deep look at the differences between The Isle Evrima Beta branch and Path of Titans demo launch. Both of these games a extremely fun, but I'm here to help you decided which one you should spend your time playing. So join me as I explain what each one has, and compare them to the best of my abilities!
- Hry
Lots of people are arguing about which is better, bit my reaction is just: “ Oh my God. *TWO* dinosaur survival games???!! Amazing!!!
This is me with every new game I see. The competition makes them better, but usually they each have their own differences that set them apart and make both worth playing.
@@deaconng ah yes the third one
In my opinion I like path if Titans because pot care about there players but the isle like oh here’s a humanoid dinosaur that will never come but if these games are in early access but I don’t hate the isle but I like path of Titans more (in my opinion) and pot Titans will add each ability like the spin-off can sit in the sun and get heat or maybe they might add more damage like if attack the spinosaurus in the spine might reduce there heat ability or maybe when u attacks can feel the weight!
Actualy, there is a *LOT* of more mobile survivel dinossaur game, but they suck
If you like dino games you may like bob as well so you have three pretty cool yeah
To me, it seems like Path of Titans is a good long term investment.
Indeed!
Monke
At the end of the day its we as the players who win.
Truth.
The real dinosaur survival game was the friends we made along the way
The Isle is for players who want to have an immersive survival experience, where as PoT is for players who want to have more of a RPG/MMO experience. I like them both, but The Isle is my personal choice.
I agree
Not always... there are roleplaying servers.
I respect your opinion but for me, path of titans has a more immersive atmosphere.
Yes, i am saying this after playing the isle.
Its just my opinion tho
Isle can be better for you
I personaly love both games so i play both
@@Just-Ignore-It_88 between legacy and evirma I haven't seen one rp server .. I could be mistaken .
@@BucketBoyz401
Hellfire is a roleplay server extreme realism there's not even a global chat
Saurian: I used to rule the world
Wtf happened to that game
@@euronico7949 Nobody knows ;-;
@@euronico7949 they made plants, everyone left, and then they finally released trike
@@lizardzilla Trike?
@@sarban1653 triceratops
Path of titan is adding a nesting system and is planned to have the Amargasaurus. They are also adding in filter feeders later on as well as flyers.
That's so cool!
Amargssaurus is a pretty sick looking sauropod. I’m excited to see that I’m game.
@@J72Gaming im sad the isle chose magy. F***ing magy
@@Michael-bm3rt Magy: *Why won’t you LOVE me?* ( ; - ;)
Because magy is a useless dwarf dino
The thing about the isle is that…uh, certain members of the dev team are…temperamental. PoT has lots of transparency with their regular updates and although the isle has a few features more than then (flying, sniffing, etc) PoT has a VERY good chance of being the better game in a year or two.
Yep i definitely agree on this statement
Path of titans is already a big enough game to be compared to the isle which is way older
Imagine how good path of titans will be after 1 or 2 years
@@lazarus8074 Techically the isle, actually evrima is also about 2 years old only, since it has nothing to do with legacy.
nah, POT balance is for noobs. Its about how many you are, not how good. I have no fear of dying if im in a group and i dont care if i die. The isle i actually care about my dino, one mistake can end you.
@@n1ak There are servers with rules and hardcore, where if you die you loose all your grow and there is a limit of packs, for me PoT it's better in my opinion thanks to the community servers
Path of titans will be adding something called scars and corpse dragging. And what I mean by scars is a Dino could look different when fully grown like the albetaceratops can be missing a horn or have battle scars.
Scarring is a cool system.
so will the isle
Isle already has dragging
@@oceanwater1246 you think? how many times did they promise and never deliver they never ever finished they always start over with some excuse
@@bionic3500 the thing is, scarring is already ingame along with dragging. destroyed
POT dev team is amazing, I love The Isle but they gotta get their game together, literally.
They are just slowly but I can't really play pot since it's to lagy for me so I can't say which is badder
@@pilot_bruh576
So it's not just me? The lag makes hunting other players almost impossible because they just rub a band all over the place. Envirma is also pretty bad with the lag but legacy isle I have no issues with
@@dragonwatch2907 The Isle is SUPER laggy because of... let's say a bad code it has. But, that's some you cannot just skip for a game, which is what they are doing, it is HELLA laggy compared to POT, you can even see it at yt videos, it's getting worse and worse while POT did that code WAY bettee and it's updating it more and more (I mean that The Isle is not optimized, making it super laggy while fighting or just playing normally while POT have a better optimization and doesn't have that masive lag The Isle has).
This is objective, I like The Isle, but sadly they aren't really caring about the game like how pot devs show and do
I as a paleontologist, I say Path of Titans is more realistic in terms of dinosaurs and relates to them with an environment, The isle is something more cinematographic, reminding a lot of Jurassic Park it goes with the taste of each one I prefer realism.
L
I usually prefer realism too, but god damn I love the beibiaosaurus' duck like concept. I hope it will be implemented right. Also I will probably graduate from high school, college and have a family with 3 kids before it becomes playable
The isle doesn't go for realistic ness if it's cool then they go for it
Yep i agree with you
The isle does give serious Jurassic park vibes
There you have it ladies and gentleman, right out of the horses mouth, PoT is more realistic in terms of actual Dinosaurs. The Isle and The Isle Evrima is realistic in terms of Jurassic Park.
Path Of Titans boutta commit growth in their stretch goal, but instead of normal growth, its growth that is fun and isnt stressfull.
a survival game that isnt stressful? sounds kinda boring doesnt it?
@@yaboyroi25 indeed it does
I mean, if the focus is more on unlocking skins and abilities through unique and interesting ways WHILE surviving, then that’s a unique and fun niche.
@@J72Gaming true true i agree a video game at the end of the day should be enjoyable, but a survival game should be hard and reaching adulthood should be extremely gratifying in the process, idk just my take. cant make it too easy ya know?
But, like 5 hours for a T. rex? Like I think it should be at most 2-3 hours
PoT is more laid back, the isle is more hardcore
its like cod v tarkov lol
@@dapper3322 except...they are dinosaur survival games lmao
@@venth6 I appreciated the metaphor
Hardcore in dying in game
New sub for you. Finally, a comparison that is not based off of opinion or drama! I am glad you are comparing them off of how the games will end up and how you don’t give an actual winner. I wish more people made videos like this!
Glad you liked it! And thank you for the kind words, I try to be as fair as possible with my comparisons. Welcome to the Sauropod Squad! 😎🦕
Yes
“Not based off of opinion” meanwhile the guy is hearting all pro isle comments and not pOt
That’s just straight false. I play both games. Don’t assume, it just makes an ass outta you and me.
He doesn't rant like oh magy the isles gonna die I mean why laggy he doesn't do that he's perfecto
The Isle: "What is a tutorial? We won't teach you basics, you'll just drop in and get spawn killed or starve, because you have no idea what to do."
But they do have tips that pop up for new players
@@Eggnog88 Not when i played.
@@VaciliNikoMavich that's only you it pop up for me
@@conehead_mark1853 Very weird...
Minecraft in a nutshell
LOVED this video. The new Deino and Ptera in The Isle shot that game up to a new level with its new map Spiro. However i STILL feel like Path of Titans map design is unmatched and much less stressful to play. The Isle is for hardcore survival players whereas Path of Titans is FAR more forgiving. Love both and cant wait to see what the future holds for these games. New sub for your channel! Please make more of these videos if possible :) Maybe direct dino comparisons?
Thanks for the fantastic comment! And welcome to the Sauropod Squad. 😎🦕.
I totally agree with you!
Really? Do you play on any certain servers because for me as soon as I got out of the tutorial I was killed on path of Titans. I was sitting next to an AI body and was killed. I was being chasing by herbivores for existing and was killed. Not to mention people camping the home cave. I'm not sure if it's because I choose multiplayer so if you know any good service please let me know because I just want to grow man. I have never made it past the halfway tik for Juvie. For me it's complete opposite, the isle a lot less stressful for me there are some game mechanics I really hope that the isle does that path of Titans have like the scarring mechanic would be really sick to have. I can't wait for envirma to get the Troodon I'm really excited to play as that creepy little shit XD
It’s a good video, but some things that should be mentioned is that Path of Titans also has collision and the regional damage thing that Evrima does. Also that Metri’s bite has poison that drains stamina, and the Alberta has a charge that increases speed.
Perhaps add something about what the final product will be? Like all the things with humans in the Isle, and the attributes and abilities in Path of Titans (for example)
Anyway, other than those small things, the video is pretty informative
Good comment! Thanks for adding that information. Yes those could have been added for sure.
I am amazed you didn't mention that path of titans is also on android. Play on pc when home but jump on the tablet when at the parents lol
Lol. Very good point, I really should have. I only ever play it on PC, and would never on mobile. But that’s just me as a gamer, I stay away from mobile games.
@@J72Gaming also theres a possibility of it coming to console tho thats way down the line
path of titans dosent work on the mobile i have :'(
@@adamc_vp77 i hope it does, my PC isn’t very good lol but it would be great to have in on my fancy new console lol
Are you the person who writes the script for the part of a video where the content creator talks about his mobile game sponsor?
I've never watched such an indepth explanation of two games I really am conflicted on and got so much good info that I still can't decide...great video! I'm more stuck between the two than before now!
Thanks haha glad you enjoyed.
I’m a big fan of both of these games, but I’m interested if you have a preference. Let me know down below, and thanks for checking out my video! 😎🦕
J72 do you have a discord server 😭 I wanna join and talk to you more then just youtube
Haha I do not, it takes a lot of effort to run a discord and I’m just a one man show xD. Maybe someday I’ll get one up
@@J72Gaming what if I told you I could help 😌
Haha. I appreciate that! I’ll think about it. 😎🦕
personally im not a big fan of the mmo questing system and i think the isles graphics are much better so i always play the isle. When i can be an elder imma main spino and become the most powerful largest carnivore
Great video! I think theres a few things about PoT's future you could have gone deeper into, or just didn't touch on, like the modding capabilities on PoT as well as AI dinoasurs, music, more maps, more dinosaurs, game modes, single player, etc, but overall I loved the video. I'll have to put more time into exploring Envirma, even though "coming soon" in the Isle feels a bit more like "your grand kids will get to see the release of this game."
(The combat system in PoT as of right now is also a placeholder. We don't have any clues to what their plans are, aside from body dragging, kill animations, latching and grabbing, and effects like bleed, poison, and ... bone break... )
Yes 100%. I went into PoT as much as I’m aware, like I mentioned I’m still relatively new to Path of Titans so there’s plenty still for me to learn. I’m sure I missed little things here and there. I’m very excited to see where the future of the game leads. Thanks for the comment! 😎🦕
Evrima also plans to add all that. I like both games. I feel like PoT is easily worthy of being the isle legacy but better as it has legacy feel with a splish splash of what makes Evrima super fun to play.
But same goes for Evrima, all those things you mentioned were also talked about by The Isle’s devs. And also please keep in mind that Update 3 only took so long because they worked on two almost completely new playstyles one of which they have worked on the last time 4 years ago and the other they have never even worked on (or at least not in the Isle). And you might say that I don’t have proof that those updates will take less time but I actually have. Update 2 took less time than Update 3 did since they already hade the core ‘walking on land mechanic’ and had already fixed most bugs so that also implies to the future updates!
Brilliant video ! Well done on hitting over 300 as well !
Half way through and enjoying it !
Thanks dude!! 😎🦕. 1000 subs feels closer every day.
Correct. It’s the next big milestone besides 500 subs.
man i just wanna say thanks for the great video. I really enjoyed you were to the point and clear in the comparisons. Really delivered on the video title, which i can't say for most other dino youtubers. Well done man
Glad you enjoyed!
The Video is really well edited in my opinion, makes it a lot more fun to watch than just people talking about it the whole video without showing anything.
Glad you liked it thanks! 😎🦕
Thanks for this very video, it's very informative and in depth. Some information might become irrelevant in the future but I'd hope on an updated video when a lot of progress has been made in both games. Keep it up!
Thanks dude glad you enjoyed it! I will likely update it in the future once decent progress has been made on both games.
Evrima Pros:
-growth
-balanced combat
-amazing light engine and graphics in general
-better dive and flight mechanic (now with update3)
-spawn zones
-very smooth animations
Evrima cons:
-essentially only 6 dinosaurs playable
-map looks good at first glance but is really very generic and lacks unique spots
-game is almost 5 years old now without being finished and updates take forever, so rarely any new content is added
-humans will be added to the game ruining the immersion
-some dinosaur models are inaccurate (scaly Utah, Hypsi with primary feathers etc.)
-no skins yet
PoT pros:
-already almost 20 playable dinos after only about a year in development
-new updates released often several times a month
-much more realistic and scientifically accurate dinosaur models
-map is much better designed with different biomes, small streams, ponds, ravines and caves/burrows
-there will be maps/servers with only contemporary dinosaurs playable, adding much more realism
-no humans will be added
-different food iteams for different dinosaurs added last patch
-water quality system
-multiplatfrom crossplay
-interspecies groups between for herbies and carnies respectively (e.g. Stego can group with a campto but not with a cerato)
-custom skins, unlockable through quests
-quests give you something to do
PoT cons:
-No growth yet
-combat is very unbalanced yet, herbies being generally to op and fast (e.g. Styraco being faster and having more stamina than Cerato)
-map is almost to big for 100 players (even tho larger servers are planned)
-graphics are slightly worse (most likely due to the mobile compability)
-No spawn regions, you'll spawn anywhere on the map
-almost immidiate death after food/water runs out
-animations aren't as smooth
Nice job compiling all the pros and cons dude
Except 2 things...
First, growth is added after 7 months!
Yes..i am from the future
And second, the pc graphics is very nice now! And animations are smooth.
Eh the whole humans thing is kind of subjective as are the dinosaur designs but asides from that I agree with you
the devs for the isle have already stated that on unofficial servers, humans are toggleable, so if you want a dino sim without humans, u can have it, i personally cant wait for humans tho!
@@jasonberryman1035 the dinosaur designs being more accurate is not subjective. You can try to argue that we don't really know what they looked like, but one game is following more current science and one isn't.
@@Va11idus I wasn’t implying that I meant that the fact that the Evrima designs being not as accurate isn’t necessarily a con because what people enjoy in a dinosaur design is subjective
Thanks for establishing the different points of each game. This gives me a better idea to consider getting PoT.
Glad I could help! 😎🦕
NEW Follower here....I feel like your review was honest and straight forward...Need more of that.
The fact you didnt pick a winner is fantastic.
Good stuff man
Glad you enjoyed!
Your videos are great quality and you explain things very well which is why im subscribing
I appreciate it! Glad you like the content 😎🦕
This was an amazing review, not biased. That’s why I subbed
I really dig your style. Very practical and entertaining, unlike most other dino-game channels (which are just entertaining...sometimes). Looking forward to enjoying your channel.
Thanks dude! Glad your enjoying it.
Great video man! You definitely deserve more recognition!
Appreciate it! 😎🦕
13:00 I think they should call the guilds "herds" and or "packs".
As someone who strictly plays isle. Play both, who cares. They’re amazing games. I just prefer isle.
Excellent video. Exactly what I was looking for!
Thanks! Glad you enjoyed it.
Excellent summary of the games. Thank you for making this.
Glad you enjoyed!
excellent video!!! very well thought out opinions/pros and cons. while I lean toward the isle as my favorite dino game, path of titans looks very promising. I will probably pick it up some time in the future.
You should try it! Both are fun. Thanks for the kind comment! 😎🦕
very informative and detailed. remember me when your channel is big one day haha
😎🦕
VERY helpful video, thankyou! x
1, path of titans got everything you mentioned in the deeper dive exept sniff. path of titans also got water drainage and water pollution path of titans gets updated every 4 to 1 week, and is gonna have modes, and 2 maps.path of titans is also gunna have progressive growth, And path of titans is gunna have more than 17 tipes of food for herbivores, and 5 types of carnivorous food. in my opinion path of titans is better.(this is only my opinion because of these reasons, i suggest you try out evrima too.)
Но в тажэ в римя в нек скучно ИГРАТЬ
I'm mostly exited for modding in Path of titans right now.
This makes me happy.😁
I disagree but you got some good points.
Yeah
Excellent comparison! I'll probably end up playing both also
Thanks glad you enjoyed!
PoT is also planning on bringing more abilities, and i’m sure those who want a challenging game can probably get that later once the game is fully released and more players play, and PoT also does have locational damage, necks do more damage than tails, PoT is also gonna add new quests- i prefer PoT but The isle is good atm for hardcore players :>
i think strafing adds a lil more to combat in PoT, but you really have to find a community server focused on realism role play, so it’s not just running around biting, but more strategical and more engaging, the isle has better combat tho
Same does ervima .
Congrats on 1k 🎉
Thanks Dude! 😎🦕
Great unbiased review! Can wait for update 4 in a decade! 😅
Great video!
(I never realized that Isle never actually “released” until this video)
(POT has localized/body part damage, I think it came out with the Alio update +- 1)
Evrima had localized body damage too though like tail, body and head damage if not more regions and the body part damage will be expanded in the fractures snd the gore update!
@@xeno07_max20 I know, because he said that in the video. He did not say that POT had it but it does. That's why I commented that.
More regions? that sounds cool, have they given info on it?
@@dtgamerk9670 I believe punch (one of the Isles devs) confirmed more variety of damage times (dependent on where you get hit and by what) in the the Isle discussion channel on the official discord channel.
@@xeno07_max20 Cool, thanks
@@dtgamerk9670 Yeah can’t wait to see both game progress into (hopefully) the Dinosaur games we’ve been wanting for so long! Fingers crossed 🤞
nice job on hitting 300 subs and the thing with the isle is it is a sleeping giant if they had more people and if people give them time they will beat any dino game out PoT is good and is a different game in general but if you want a good dino survival the isle wins it will dominate when it is done but until then it still slaps (I like the isle if you couldnt tell)
I agree the isle slaps xD
Your account blew up ! Congratulations
Thanks!
Path of titans has been in out for 2years so far and the isle has been out since 2015. I think path of titans is good for the time its been out compared to the isle. The reason I picked path of titans over the isle is because the future features they are gonna add and path of titans get updates faster so it was hard to pick but I chose.
But you need to keep in mind that we are comparing EVRIMA and PoT and Evrima has been in development for around the same amount of time.
@@xeno07_max20 But it also has had legacy to build of off to that is hell of a starting point to.
@@lights_utopia1130 No it didn’t Evrima was made from scratch. Evrima and Legacy aren’t even on the same Engine!
@@xeno07_max20 Really? That's crazy
@@crowspears3265 Yeah
This video helped me alot thanks mate lemme sub real quick
Glad to help, and cheers! Welcome to the Sauropod Squad. 😎🦕
@@J72Gaming
Thank u again, keep up the good work bro 🍺
really comprehensive, super helpful!
Glad you found it useful!
I adore both, The Isle is for sure my preferred choose but both games certainly bring something to the table for all players to enjoy
Since you're a big saurapod fan (saurapod gang 😎👍) Amargasarus is coming soon as a stretch goal dino in PoT and a modder by the name of KTO Sergi will be adding Giraffatitan and Camarasaurus as mod dinos
Awesome!
nice video bro def disserves more views
Thanks dude! 😎🦕
This video deserves more views
Appreciate it!
I feel like for once there's a fair question in a PoT/Isle comparison. "Which is worth it?" Both can be worth it, but it's such a more fair question compared to "which is better." One game is much cheaper, the other is way more expensive, and they both have very different types of communities/developers. "Is it worth it" is such a better question, since it's not comparing which game is better, it's comparing if a person would find either or both games worth the money and time.
While I love Path of Titans more, I do enjoy the environment of The Isle and do play it on occasion. Path if Titans just has more updates, more dinosaurs that come out every month alongside persistent bug fixes. Whereas the Isle fixes those bugs there and then and you don't have many issues. But in honesty, I like the Path of Titans Devs more as they are more interactive with their community and their game may not have the sniffing idea that The Isle there but it is primarily a survival game. Sniffing takes away surviving for me, it makes me find food too easy. Path of Titans you have to ambush your prey and forage like a Dinosaur should do.
I'm in the middle between both games. But I think the games shouldn't be put in contest to each other. They fill different niches and both side of players can enjoy qualities of both. The problem is comparing the games and going into either with the expectations of the other game is just not the way to go about it.
Also, Path of Titans updated their combat abilities for their dinosaurs.
Yep
I totally agree with you dude
If you waited a few more days and you wouldve had the new isle update adding pterodon, dienosuchus and an entirely revised envirma map to compare with POT
This
More like waiting two months for the next update.
I love your videos!
Thanks! 😎🦕
I may already own and play both The Isle and Path of Titans, but this is still a nice video. Although I do play Path of Titans more than The Isle for one main reason. *cough cough* my laptop is a piece of junk *cough cough*. It’s nice to know how both games are doing. And while I do prefer Path of Titans more because I can actually play the mobile version, if I ever get the chance to properly play The Isle, I’d surely play more of Evrima. Also I decided to sub.
Thanks for the comment, glad you enjoyed the video. Welcome to the Sauropod Squad! 😎🦕
I don’t really know much about the isle evrima, but I do know quite a bit about PoT and I noticed there were a few things that were not mentioned when talking about PoT’s development and future. Firstly and most importantly (imo) combat. I saw that you mentioned that everything in evrima had something unique about it and did not say this about PoT, however while this might not be the case now, PoT has plans to make each dinosaur very unique and different from eachother; for example, lambeosaurus is confirmed to be able to heal allies, sarcosuchus will have a lunge ability, raptors will get the ability to pounce, allosaurus will (when it comes out) have tho ability to latch on to targets and hold them in place and that’s just to name a few + the fact that the lead developer has stated that each animal will have up to 10 abilities it can use at any time along with more that can be switched out. Also PoT’s combat is very placeholder, things like collision and locational damage (both of which are already implemented in the game btw) are still a heavy wip. PoT also had plans for more food items and more in depth diets, a second map, fully aquatic animals and flyers and that’s just to name a few.
But seriously though, great video, most people in the dinosaur game genre are usually very biased towards one game or another for some reason, it’s nice to see someone who can keep an open mind and see the pros and cons of both games without letting emotions get in the way. You’ve earned a sub and a like from me
Great comment! Thanks for enjoying the video. I did state in the beginning that I'm still very new to the PoT world, and that the quests coins will eventually unlock abilities, but yea I didn't go into much detail of what those could be. All of those you just told me are news to me! Sounds very cool, I like the idea of a healing herbivore as it would be a very unique playstyle. Stoked for the future of PoT!
Блин, лечить своих союзников? А это не слишком?
Some of that wasnt true. Raps didnt get pounce and allo cant latch on. >=(
Good vid, good points towards each game!
Makes me wonder though, have you ever checked out Beasts of Bermuda?
It remains largely overlooked in the dino gaming community, but it does improve in gameplay and looks with each update (the most recent update looks really nice actually and added freaking forest fires!) and has gameplay loop that stretches into Infinity. Pretty unique take on dinosaur games that is worth a shot imo.
I have a high interest in BoB, just haven’t check it out yet. I will eventually for sure!
@@J72Gaming Sweet! Then I hope you'll make a video on it too. :)
Something that would help PoT with the emptiness in their map, is AI
PoT is supposed to be adding AI real soon. In the meantime, they've shrunken their map down until they add them.
What a good review 👍🏻
Thanks dude!
Amazing video! Just sucks you did the comparison just a few days before update 3 went public
For me the Best goal in a dinosaur game is just growing up the dinosaur and surviving, not doing quests to win skins. POT does not have point on that from my part but i know some players like that and i respect. Like it just does not feel the purpose of a survival dinosaur game and combating it feels more like a competition of skins game. That's not what i am looking for. Evrima does have what i am looking for. Immersion. Every dinosaur has their own mechanics like ptera can fish or deinosuchus can drown other dinos, Evrima does got my point on that. Also so much better animations and graphics than POT.
Path of titans will get everything you are looking for. They simply have a different development way. And the graphics aren't much better. Maybe a bit.
POT is definitely not a skins competition, you use the points you get to unlock abilities and maybe when your full grown you buy a skin and even so players are impressed by size not what color you are
First time I saw your intro I thought your logo was a thicc dinosaur with pasties.
On Panjura everyone hangs out at corpse cove, and on Gondwa everyone either goes to Big Quill Lake or Crater Impact Pond, and they all just swarm the place.
I hope the isle adds a system where if you’re constantly filling your hunger and food (with player dinos) you’ll get a growth boost, eating babies would be .5x, juvies 1x and adults 2x this’ll 100% make the game more fun for aggressive players. It’ll make the game feel even more like a survival game knowing you’re prey no matter what size you are. And for herbies there can be special bushes that look different from normal but are a little more harder to find and are smaller so groups can’t all snack on it. The affect at which your growth speed will be increased is only for a set amount of time meaning you’ll need to keep yourself fed and quenched as much as possible. I hope some one looks at this as something really fun.
I believe the diet system will work more or less like this, letting you grow up faster if you eat your correct food. Let’s hope it brings in the content you wanna see!
Wow I kinda wanna work on the Isle Evrima. The game just seems like it has a lot of potential on improving the multiplayer aspect of the game.
It’s got a lot of promise!
I agree. The isle can honestly be one of the greatest games of all time if they really put their time and money into it. Fingers crossed they keep it going
Don’t get your hopes up, the devs are slow and there’s ALWAYS drama
@@gamingreacts8787 them sluggish is part of the reason I wanna join. And the drama just seems like it’s more fun 🤩
Seeing that the lead developer is an absolutely shitty human being (there wasn't even a proper _investigation_ into fucking *sexual abuse* accusations, possibly of minors, can't remember, on one of his employees) that can't take criticism at all and throws nervous tantrums at his community Discord members, with his team being hardly any better in the meantime...
Yeah, no, I wouldn't really wanna work for this kind of people.
They are planning to add a growth system, and they currently can support every pc device. It’s also free on mobile?
I’m in on path of titans
I think pot is actually kinda more realistic than the isle since it’s going for realism models like with the feathers and scales but it’s just my opinion, I also like how different species of dinosaurs have different stats(I’m talking about like the sub species of a specific dino) and for different sub species you can have different play styles. This is just my opinion and how I feel about both games
I can understand it from that point of view. As far as how the dinosaurs look, yea PoT is being pretty true to form, and the Isle is having fun with designs. But as far as the experience the player has, The Isle is very realistic and immersive. PoT will likely get more immersive as time goes on with new abilities and sound design upgrades, but its main aspect is going to be questing to get coins and that will always be a priority over Evrima's goal to gain perks by being realistic. (Eat from the correct diet ect.) Thanks for the comment Rawr Xd haha
Thx for the feed back !
I duno, The Isle has been in early development since 2015 and then had that big reset. It's still not done.
Yet Path of Titans indiegogo uploaded on Jul. 15, 2019. It feels like the Isle has a lot more time to be something and yet development wise it feels like Path of Titans is doing more actively.
I agree with you somewhat. Evrima alone however has been really well made, and update 3 has proven each update is solid. So both are doing things well imo.
Cool video, I think its good that there are two games, because this pushes both to get better and better, since theres somewhat of a competition, thats good for the players. Like let's be honest, if POT never existed, The Isle probably never would have even bothered reworking the game.
I’m not sure they would never have bothered to rework the game, as Evrima answers a lot of the problems they were having with legacy, but yea competition is good for both of the games.
10:00 Correction (Even if you have gotten comments about it already which I assume 100%)
Elder system to devs words.
"Grow and develop until you reach the grand age of elder and die with a PERMANENT perk/bonus, The more you age the weaker you get. OR Stave off the Reaper for awhile and become something Far more Terrifying."
I think The Isle is much more better graphic-wise gameplay-wise and etc, it also has better mechanics and Evrima has tons of room to grow.
Yeah I feel like PoT’s Dinos have less, I don’t wanna be rude, but, love put into these creatures. Although some creatures have some abilities most are just reskined and reanimated creatures with different stats, while Evrima has a different ability that isn’t just more or less damage for every creature!
@@xeno07_max20 it’s gonna be the other way around when they implement the combat system don’t you think?
@@Aziruf It ended up being not the other way around
I personally play both ... which I love cause I love dinosaurs my entire life ... but I been play PoT more than Isle lately cause I been having trouble running Evrima after an update
pls do an updated version of this!
Really great video, thanks for posting. Do you think the graphics of Path of Titans will improve their graphics till they're at the level of The Isle eventually or stay as they are?
Also, the "colorful" texture designs in Path of Titans looks really bad to me, I want them to all be "boring" colors like they are in Saurian and The Isle. Is there anything in the settings you can do to change this? Like make them all default colors or whatever?
I hope they make some graphical upgrades to Path of Titans, right now its solid but not amazing. And I agree that some of the crazy textures of Path of Titan's skins are a bit much - I'm not sure if there is a way to change this as a lot of the focus and goals in PoT right now is to obtain these skins and show them off.
@@J72Gaming Ah, damn. I really dislike them. If there's a tiny bit of variety in color, it's okay for me, but I don't like all the patterns and stuff.
Also, I really like The Isle and see the gameplay to be a bit better than POT, but one huge flaw with it is that they're planning to have humans in it. That's too sci-fi for my taste and I don't think I can get it if they have humans, looking for a purely dinosaur game.
So I was wondering, do you think they'll have a third installation of the game (so far they have two - Legacy & Evrima) that has humans and the people that don't want humans will stick to Legacy and Evrima? I'm not sure how popular my "anti-human" opinion is in The Isle circles, so I dunno if there are discussions regarding anything like that.
When humans release servers will have the option to include them or not. Many rules will be available for customization by the server admins so is as players will just have to find the servers that fit our desires for the games. The devs mentioned all this in a dev blog awhile ago and it gave me hope for the future of the game. Whether you like the idea of Savages Vs dinos vs mercenaries, or if you just want only dinosaurs there will be a place for that.
@@J72Gaming Thanks for the great news and the interaction so far. Just subbed to your channel. One more question, do you have any videos or anything regarding Beasts of Bermuda? Alongside POT and The Isle, it seems to make up the "big 3" of dinosaur survival games. So I was curious how BOB would compare to POT and TI.
Thanks for the sub! Welcome to the Sauropod Squad. 😎🦕.
As for Beast of Burmuda, I do have an interest in covering it. I will eventually get it and check it out, likely making another VS video. I like to be informed on the games I cover so I’d like to play BoB for awhile before comparing it with these other two options.
Path of titans looks cool to those who used to play the isle always before . But to be honest The Isle is the king of dinosaur games for now
When I realized you had an updated review.
Also you forgot one of the pros of P.o.T is that when you die you don’t loose ALL your progress, only some of it. On the isle you loose everything when you die.
Video is old my dude. Came out before growth.
The isle can run in a 16gb ram pc, ryzen 5 2400g with vega 11 with no graphic card?
Cool ,like alway
I currently own The Isle and was looking at Path of Titans with a "Grass is greener" mentality, so I came to this video trying to see if it was justified. Ironically, my main problem with Evrima is the whole "grass is greener". I love that PoT seems to have more brown, a dusty "red dirt" kind of muddyness in some locations, you can see the pebbles and rocks on the shores. Whereas with Evrima... it's pretty much just that same saturated green for grass, the few open plains areas where there aren't trees and bushes so thick you can't enjoy seeing anything (and so many players have been complaining about the thick vegetation causing them to fall off cliffs.) The map doesn't look as enjoyable to play on... on top of how the devs refuse to give us an in-game map, whereas PoT looks like you get an MMOesque style minimap, quests, and all in a nicer UI.
I actually kindof hate The Isle's silly glowy particle system for Scenting, right now, worse than the glows from Legacy.
But, your review implying that The Isle's combat and "dinosaur weightyness" feels better is giving me pause, I like what I see about PoT, but is the handling and combat truly worse?
And honestly, I like the look of the PoT dinosaurs better. The Isle is simply going abysmally slow in adding new species, who knows how many years it would take them to get around to adding various colored textures per species.
But... the fact that PoT isn't on Steam is a QoL convenience problem for me, I prefer to purchase on Steam. Ugh. Why couldn't they just have combined into one good game sooner.
And that bit about The Isle's Elder system... not excited for it at all. I certainly won't use it. I prefer maining a dinosaur and not having my time wasted (in a game where you already die so much and have so many growth hours wasting your time)... so why screw yourself becoming an Elder? Not worth, imo.
Lol comment ignored because the video maker is bias
Or perhaps it was because it was a comment that happened a few months after the video came out and I missed it? Your comments are sour AF my dude.
Can you do a video of evrima vs Beasts of Bermuda when we get more updates?
I would love to make that video, although I like to be informed and know the game well enough so I’d like to play the game first and haven’t yet. On my idea board tho!
I just wish The Isle is available on MacOS too, as that’s the only thing I have to play on for the time being but really want to play both and only PoT is playable on MacOS
I definetely have a soft spot for The isle ( The game, not the devs. ). I am sure that POT is a good game for many people but recently I have only been finding more reasons to support why I do not want to play the game. Personally I like a more realistic approach, the quest system has therefore really put a sour taste on my tongue. For me it is more of eating to survive just so that I can eat more and survive a little bit longer. The quest system really does need to approve though, not because I would want to play it either way but for the people who actually want to use it. From what i've seen it only allows you drinking/eating quests, location finders, picking up objects and etc. Not only that but the slot system allows you to rage kill a person that has previously killed your other dino ( I do not understand the system but I know that there are slots for your dinos )
The fighting style is a big factor in my enjoyment, which from what i've seen is quite choppy for path of titans. The isle has a more smoother and a more enjoyable playstyle when it comes to fighting. I hear a lot of people discussing whether or not these games take skill when it comes to combat, and to this I say both. The isle has started focusing on a playstyle that makes it more difficult for example utahraptors (or whatever they are called now, I honestly don't really care ) to kill large dinosaurs. It is still possible, however you can't simply ride anyone to death. In path of titans they have sort of a similar playstyle in which it takes a bit of skill. Something I have noticed (mostly an assumption) is that smaller dinos can kill like really big targets. For example the Metri that can drain stamina. Not only that but the sluggish turns allow for much easier ''tail riding'' despite the tail smack being an option. The isle has smooth alt turns that almost allow dinos to turn on the spot, while dinosaurs like the stegosaurus have the natural advantage of having a spiked tail.
The isle definetely looks the best, despite the whacky lighting sometimes being a bother. Right now the map kinda feels a bit boring with not much variety in the different locations but the graphics are by far the best I have seen in dinosaur games. The water is also much better than path of titans water in my opinion, not to mention that even more details will be put into it in the future. There are different ai spawns in the isle and path of titans water sources, however I must say that The isle still takes the cake on that one. Not only do they have fish but they also have frogs and sea turtles, I believe crabs will be added in the future as well. I know that a lot of people will disagree but in my opinion I find the path of titans maps and models to be sort of dull and not very exciting to look at. The map has generic lighting with an added day and night cycle. The foliage is quite bland and the trees seem to go forever. I personally feel like the water needs a bit more work put into it and the foliage especially. Grasslands basically do not exist. The models of the dinosaur are fine, but they look a bit smooth to me. I want to see them wrinkles!
Many people argue that path of titans have more dinosaur than the isle but I do feel like their playstyles blend together way too much. Some creatures even look like they are younger versions of another species! They need a lot more variety in body movements and combat tactics.
In conclusion, the isle is more of a hardcore survival game while I feel like path of titans is more of a relaxing game to hop onto after work. It does not seem like you'd really be afraid of losing your dino, especially since it is so easy to grow them. Not only that but path of titans players seem more forgiving than what the isle players seem to be. I do believe that path of titans has a better community and better devs than the isle does ( Not in skill ). The isle seems to have a bit more ''skilled'' developers in the sense that the graphis look better despite having been run in UE4 while path of titans has been run in UE5 ( The isle evrima is now being run in UE5 as well ) and the models, animations and concept art is just amazing. Both games are good depending on who you are, these are just my thoughts on the games.
Ps: I am aware that The isle devs are somewhat mean and annoying per say, or at least they seem like it to me. I get all itchy whenever I have to hear them complain about something. This however does not spoil my enjoyment of the game. Something can still be enjoyed despite being made by someone you disagree with.
Haven’t tried Path of Titans yet. And maybe I’m just not enough of a gamer, esp on the multiplayer side of things, but I could not for the life of me figure out how to play the Isle.
I wish I knew all of this ahead if time.
I didn’t have any friends to play with to help guide me through it, but I went into a random server, control instructions popped up for a minute before they disappeared and I didn’t know how to get them back, realized you had to go to another website to download a map to figure out where u were, saw no one around, and the chat basically ignored any of my questions.
So the few times I played chalked up to following the scent of water or plants to eat (always seemed super far away) and would stuck near the water source and hide in a bush because I was too skeptical about venturing too far out and losing where I was before and dying of thirst lol.
So I’d either die of starvation/thirst pretty quickly, or the one player I would find would be hostile and kill me immediately…and I didn’t know how to defend myself. 💀
I sound like such a noob, I know it, but my god-makes me afraid to buy and try another if it ends up being the same experience. Idk how you dino gamers do it lol
Practice makes perfect. It wouldn’t be called a creature survival game if survival was guaranteed xD. I have a few videos on how to play each creature, where are good spots, ect. They may help. Either way, good luck if you choose to continue playing!
Abilities are now in Path of Titans as of recent updates!
I absolutely love Sauropods. By far my favorite type of dinosaurs. We should start a Sauropod herd!
Subscribe to join the Sauropod Squad. It’s our first step at making a giant Sauropod herd 😎🦕😋
@@J72Gaming already did by the time the video was over
Two questions for those who played both games: which one do you think gives you the most "realistic" life of a dinosaur experience ? Which is the best done technically (movements, animations, AI) ?
Evrima will give you that feeling imo
so far i noticed i can run PoT on max settings with 1440p and 60fps and basicly have 0 lag in online servers compared wen i play the isle .. its like rubberband here and there time to time the biting is often unlogical.. i cant max out my settings cause i get some weird black shaders.. but hey i love PoT now because you can actually swim and get your bodies from the bottom of the lake.. in the isle people cry for body deniing tons of kicks and reports in every server.. for that bullcrap
Nice video
Thanks glad you like it.
Hello I’m interested in getting a new laptop to play the isle on. Do you play on a laptop or a pc? Btw great content really enjoyed the video :)
I play on a PC. I always recommend a PC over a laptop as your able to customize it and upgrade it through time easier.
@@J72Gaming ok I’ll look at them :)
i play path of titans on my ipad it’s fun and i plan on buying the isle as soon as i buy a pc
Both are worth it.
Both are equally as good.
Yes and I don’t appreciate people directly comparing these games with each other. This video did it much better comparing pros and cons since I feel like PoT is a semi Rp/semi Survival game (because of the quest/group quest system and because most people don’t think ‘I must survive!’ but ‘welp Imma chill out with that carnivore at a lake without needing to worry about being eaten’) and The Isle/Evrima is a Horror Survival game (since they will add tribals, hypers, a darker night, gore ect. and you (especially in the future will) need to be scared about drinking, walking through the jungle, walking through tall grass, pretty much anything). And as you said both games are good in what they are doing.
Humans and tribals will add so much to the Isle and SPINO but its so much waiting sadly.
@@randomname5646 but the waiting will be worth it!
@@xeno07_max20 yep, just like the waiting for PoT’s prerelease will 😄
@@Aziruf That is true I am really excited for both game’s future
I can't help but wonder and speculate if "path of titans" has copywrited off of "THE ISLE", they're a lot of dinos that are strikingly similiar, like that of the theri they're wanting to release eventually. What is your opinion on this?
thanks man
😎🦕
I'm wondering, is Evrima planning on bringing back the hypos, the buildings and that unanswered mystery of the island, or is abandoned?
I’m unsure! The lore has always been a bit of a hidden mystery for us players.
I worry that the mobile crossplay might be holding PoT back, some content has been cut due to it and it is also the reason combat and movement have a tendency to be clunky as they are, i.e going up and down in water requires you to use two separate buttons, or the removal of directional attacks, as a system where looking into the direction of a hit (like in the Isle, Ark, etc) is not possible for mobile players.
I love PoT, I just wish it would decide to live up to it's full potential, not being held down by mobile restrictions.
Not that mobile support should be dropped, but to separate mobile and console/pc.
I agree with the concerns towards limiting PoT's potential due to the requirement of mobile controls. As a PC gamer, I will never mess with it on mobile so its easy for me to wish it wouldn't interfere with the development, however I know there are a lot of people who don't own a PC but do own a mobile device, so for them this game is perfect.
@@J72Gaming release it on console and a lot of the mobile players would leave, main reason there are mobile players is because they can’t afford a pc and have console but no support for consoles exists, but make the app and main game run differently so it isn’t held back still
Not sure I would like the idea of questing, the elder system seems so cool tho!
Both are fun in their own right! Stoked for both.