Hi was doing some research the rapid IPS is together with the QD to achieve the faster response time. If I am correct. Thanks for the heads up though. Cheers !
@@Nwhproductions You may have misunderstood your research material. The Quantum Dot layer doesn't contribute at all to the pixel response time of the display. The display's response time would be the same regardless if Quantum Dot is used or not. The response time boost for the MSI monitor comes entirely from the Rapid IPS technology.
@@perdana5786 You are wrong and I think you may misunderstood your research material, since Quantum Dot is used here to produce the Rapid IPS... The first layer is LED display. Quantum Dot is what makes the pixel (wavelenght) orientation in the IPS layer. There is no way that you would have IPS layer splitting the light and over that you would have Quantum Dot doing the same, that is really not how it works. Quantum Dot and Rapid IPS in this case is the same layer and the same thing. Here is what wikipedia says: IPS: "The liquid crystal molecules are aligned parallel to those surfaces in predetermined directions (in-plane). The molecules are reoriented by an applied electric field, whilst remaining essentially parallel to the surfaces to produce an image." In QD displays, this layer is created by using quantum dots, while the background is usually lit with LEDs
Actually there is a panel technology that uses quantum dot emitters, however, there are only a few experimental versions of it. The qd’s are electroluminescent rather than photoluminescent. It may be the holy grail of display technology alongside, or rather than microled. But I know u meant the standard lcd quantum dot displays we all are familiar with.
I had that MSI monitor. It's a good monitor but colors are WAY oversaturated and no sRGB to prevent that ruins it. Also the display port is 1.2a and not 1.4. I was disappointed when I found that issue because you can't activate 10 bits at 165hz.
Waiting on a Spyder X Pro as yeah it really needs full calibration to look accurate. And this monitor is not 10bit, it is 8bit+FRC. And no casual app or game is using 10bit color space so it is useless marketing.. unless you use professional GPU and true 10bit monitor with special pro software.
Good video, although factually wrong. As you said yourself, the QD is just a layer on the IPS panel, therefore making the comparison name "QD vs IPS" doesn't make sense. Also the response times have nothing to do with Quantum Dot, that's just the different IPS panels used in those 2 monitors. Quantum Dot is sorely to provide a wider color gamut.
Either get an IPS or OLED panel for color calibration. VA panels are good only for contrast, but OLED is the best of both worlds, its only downsides are: 1 Burn-in 2 Much more expensive per pixel/inch
Hi I answer the questions I had reset the monitors to their default settings. I also tried to make the whites as close as possible to make it as fair as possible Cheers!
@@julian006_3 the most affordable and cheap way of doing it is using a white pice of paper and abit of eyeballing. I will suggest using the gaming osd app to do the tuning. Cheers
Seeing that you use two different monitors I bet the difference in brightness and colour has more to do with the default calibration. If you didn't calibrate both monitors, then your colour comparison is useless. QD panels are IPS panels as QD only relates to the backlight used. I'm lucky to have a Asus ROG PG32UQ (QD IPS panel) at home and use a ProartPA329c (IPS) for work. Both have the same colour specs on paper and once calibrated they are 99.9% the same; although the Proart monitor edges it because the backlight is more uniform and the anit-glare finish seam finer to me. The ROG also took longer to calibrate. TBH I just think the ROG is just the Proart with QD backlight and hdmi 2.1 as it is a newer model. Theres no real difference between QD-IPS and IPS in terms of image quality IMO. QD just allows for faster response times and uses slightly less energy apparently. QD is ultimately marketing.
@@baotapss7 If english isnt your first language noone cares how you feel so how about you not even comment mister saved videos of how english sounds because you dont know it. Everyone else who isnt incompetent and doesnt have a monkey brain can understand their own language pretty well. Gtfo of here
you're very irritating how about you go back to the drawing board and try learning english again if you cant understand people. Everyone else who actually knows english doesnt have a problem except for incompetent people like you who need people to tell them how verbs sound, go back to school and try harder@@baotapss7 🤣
It's Rapid IPS that is 4x faster. Not Quantum Dot. The only thing Quantum Dot does is makes colors more intense.
Hi was doing some research the rapid IPS is together with the QD to achieve the faster response time. If I am correct. Thanks for the heads up though. Cheers !
@@Nwhproductions You may have misunderstood your research material. The Quantum Dot layer doesn't contribute at all to the pixel response time of the display. The display's response time would be the same regardless if Quantum Dot is used or not. The response time boost for the MSI monitor comes entirely from the Rapid IPS technology.
Thanks I'm going to buy MAG274QRF (no QD) , it's almost 150 dollars less in my country
@@perdana5786 You are wrong and I think you may misunderstood your research material, since Quantum Dot is used here to produce the Rapid IPS... The first layer is LED display. Quantum Dot is what makes the pixel (wavelenght) orientation in the IPS layer. There is no way that you would have IPS layer splitting the light and over that you would have Quantum Dot doing the same, that is really not how it works. Quantum Dot and Rapid IPS in this case is the same layer and the same thing.
Here is what wikipedia says: IPS: "The liquid crystal molecules are aligned parallel to those surfaces in predetermined directions (in-plane). The molecules are reoriented by an applied electric field, whilst remaining essentially parallel to the surfaces to produce an image."
In QD displays, this layer is created by using quantum dots, while the background is usually lit with LEDs
Quantom Dot is not a panel type its a colour filter and enhancer. There are VA and IPS Quantum dot panels possible. Even QD OLED (Samsung)
Actually there is a panel technology that uses quantum dot emitters, however, there are only a few experimental versions of it. The qd’s are electroluminescent rather than photoluminescent. It may be the holy grail of display technology alongside, or rather than microled. But I know u meant the standard lcd quantum dot displays we all are familiar with.
Pre-Trip: bought the MSI Mag274qrf-qd
IPS Quantum Dot 1440p 165hz monitor.
I love it!
how it now?
@@Criptooooo it's great, I bought a second one for my daughter.
you still rocking it 8 months later and loving it? play any FPS on it? going to pick up a new monitor today and thinking that this could be the one.
I had that MSI monitor. It's a good monitor but colors are WAY oversaturated and no sRGB to prevent that ruins it. Also the display port is 1.2a and not 1.4. I was disappointed when I found that issue because you can't activate 10 bits at 165hz.
Just needs to be calibrated, but I agree it should have an sRGB mode and be more accurate out the box.
Can you watch youtube videos without calibrating the monitor? Do the colors still look good or not?
I feel its alright to do so. The color on any monitor would be different depending on the color of your room also. Cheers!
Waiting on a Spyder X Pro as yeah it really needs full calibration to look accurate. And this monitor is not 10bit, it is 8bit+FRC. And no casual app or game is using 10bit color space so it is useless marketing.. unless you use professional GPU and true 10bit monitor with special pro software.
10 bit isn't even necessary
Hey dude, can you please compare them in a longer video with each other ?
Good video, although factually wrong. As you said yourself, the QD is just a layer on the IPS panel, therefore making the comparison name "QD vs IPS" doesn't make sense. Also the response times have nothing to do with Quantum Dot, that's just the different IPS panels used in those 2 monitors. Quantum Dot is sorely to provide a wider color gamut.
Noted! Thanks for pointing that out!
@@Nwhproductions Appreciate you taking the feedback. Great production quality otherwise, keep up the work!
@@cook1e0 Thanks Man! We are all learning and I do appreciate people teaching me new things too. Have a great New Year!
so would u say the QD version of the MSI is worth it?
@@zyback Yep If you are getting one of the best display technologies out there other than OLED that is really ex. Cheers!
hey can you compare it with the msi mag274qrf the non qd one
Good afternoon, Sure I will ask them if its possible. Cheers!
Colors are more vivid? From this footage, is seems the QD display has too much magenta in it. The fire doesn't look right at all.
you really do not understand nothing in monitors...
Can u recommend this monitor ? 27" MSI Optix MAG274QRF-QD
or other one? looking for 1400p 27 ones thanks
Do you use it for content creation or just gaming?
Cheers!
@@Nwhproductions if I use 2
samsung g7 vs lg ultragear nano ips vs quantum dot? color accuracy editing + gaming? cheers
*cries in using a non existent historical ancient Toshiba 40av700e tv cause i cant afford a monitor*
my current monitor is a $15 one from the thrift store i also cry with you
Is va monitor good for colors calibration ?
And what is your opinion about Samsung G9 for colors calibration ?
Either get an IPS or OLED panel for color calibration. VA panels are good only for contrast, but OLED is the best of both worlds, its only downsides are:
1 Burn-in
2 Much more expensive per pixel/inch
my ears exploded with that intro
Good video, thank you
Thank you!
is quantum dot IPS panel same as QLED?
Did you calibrat the msi-QD?
I am also interested in this. Hardware Unboxed sayed that he had to calibrate the monitor because it is to oversaturrated
Hi I answer the questions I had reset the monitors to their default settings. I also tried to make the whites as close as possible to make it as fair as possible Cheers!
@@Nwhproductions Which Software do you use ?
@@julian006_3 the most affordable and cheap way of doing it is using a white pice of paper and abit of eyeballing. I will suggest using the gaming osd app to do the tuning. Cheers
@@Nwhproductions Ok thanks :)
Sticking with my 5$ Tn panel.
25 % wrong pronunciation. Impossible to watch. Because keywords are important.
Seeing that you use two different monitors I bet the difference in brightness and colour has more to do with the default calibration. If you didn't calibrate both monitors, then your colour comparison is useless. QD panels are IPS panels as QD only relates to the backlight used. I'm lucky to have a Asus ROG PG32UQ (QD IPS panel) at home and use a ProartPA329c (IPS) for work. Both have the same colour specs on paper and once calibrated they are 99.9% the same; although the Proart monitor edges it because the backlight is more uniform and the anit-glare finish seam finer to me. The ROG also took longer to calibrate. TBH I just think the ROG is just the Proart with QD backlight and hdmi 2.1 as it is a newer model. Theres no real difference between QD-IPS and IPS in terms of image quality IMO. QD just allows for faster response times and uses slightly less energy apparently.
QD is ultimately marketing.
Compersion? Do you mean comparison?
Say what??
Slurring of speech!!
Watching the video is very irritating because it's impossible to understand.
@@baotapss7 If english isnt your first language noone cares how you feel so how about you not even comment mister saved videos of how english sounds because you dont know it. Everyone else who isnt incompetent and doesnt have a monkey brain can understand their own language pretty well. Gtfo of here
you're very irritating how about you go back to the drawing board and try learning english again if you cant understand people. Everyone else who actually knows english doesnt have a problem except for incompetent people like you who need people to tell them how verbs sound, go back to school and try harder@@baotapss7 🤣