Basically, James Labrie used your vocal melody on most of this song then modified some parts to fit it to his range. To me, your singing sounds the same way how James sang it on I&W recording. Great effort Charlie. You’re still one of those ppl. who helped built this band as to where they are now. Without you and others who left, DT is not that famous as today. Respect.
It wasn't intended as an apology more an eye opener for the guys that were judging my performance compared to JLB. I'm very proud of the fact that for over 25 years, James has sung pretty much the exact melody i wrote back in 1989 and JP has only suggested one or two notes that changed to showcase JLBs high range. \m/
I feel like Charlie's take on the song is more operatic, theatrical whereas James's is a more forwards rock style for Metro. Two entirely different feelings in my opinion. With James, it feels like a rock song. With Charlie, it feels personal and somewhat saddening. Really amazing stuff
Dominici has a unique tone and beautiful emotional voice in general. That said he’s a High baritone, and on good well rested days can sing these DT songs, not without effort though. That takes a lot of strain on a singers voice if you constantly push your range abilities(he does have a impressionable range for s baritone though), but he could never have toured with DT full scale without sounding shit like on this recording. LaBrie was a true vocal beast blessed with an amazing vocal range for men and power as well which made him so versatile and practically a vocal virtuoso until he got sick. Anyone who questions LaBrie, listen to the live at the Marquee album. He shines on it. That said, Dominici’s voice suited the first album.
Very perceptive and musically knowledgable comment. I've often said that I joined this band and took on the vocal job for the first album for The same reason why people climb mountains- because it was there. I knew the melodies I was writing were out of my comfort range but I wasn't looking to be comfortable I was looking to be great. Aim for the stars and you might at least get the moon. It took a lot of work and preparation to perform every night singing 2 whole steps above my natural range and there were those typical rock and roll situations where too much partying made that goal line a bit farther then it needed to be and the results can be heard on bootleg live tapes occasionally. A friend used to say " I pulled a carrot" lol. A very adequate analogy! That said In not making excuses just putting some truth out there among all the speculation. For my 4 CD trilogy I tended to stay in a semi- Comfortable range on the high end anyway but I took myself out of that easy chair for the low stuff. There are many that had no idea I could sing low notes as low as a natural E. Of course that's not the reason why I did it that way I did it for the same reason (you guessed it) as The reason why people climb mountains.
Charlie Dominici Honored to interact with you Charlie and thank you for your response! I totally understand what you are saying and I applaud you for your effort and honestly love to enjoy listening to your voice. It is very special to me and for many years I preferred yours, but I have stopped judging great singers because it’s like apple’s and oranges and if you know singing there is nothing but pure respect for vocalists. Many singers get to much unjustified critique from idiots that knows nothing about singing. I just love impressive singing techniques! and appreciate different styles. I really am impressed with your tone clear high notes, which many non-tenors tend to put more uncontrolled distortion and strain into that further fatigues the voice(big mistake). So your ability to keep the tone clear and bright even when you struggle a bit amazes me! As a baritone myself and amateur singer I understand the challenge you took on, I worked much on my high pitch range but it’s just such a marathon to improve it and takes a lot of practice and bad habits to break to get it right. I believe your voice brought an amazingly unique style to the band! I haven’t looked in the album sleeve in a long time, but did you also contribute to the lyrics?
@@djglammetal9666 I did co-write lyrics with JP on "Status Seeker" and in the early days MP and JP asked me to re-write the lyrics to a song that Chris Collins had written lyrics for. I chose to not listen to his version and wrote the lyric with no influence from that version. The result was what is arguabl
Oops. To continue: arguably one of the best songs on the album. 8 also happened to be what solidified my entrance to the band. That song was Afterlife. I don't know if I'm actually a baritone or possibly a high tenor but if you've listened to any of the part 2 and part 3 of O3 a Trilogy you'll notice that I do have a deep voice in me as well as a high voice but yeah once you get up to that be note with talking OK face, mask, stay off the throat, watch the diaphragm etc. and all that vocal training from the 6 lessons I took back in 1980.
Charlie Dominici When I was younger I didn’t really appreciate complex rock as much as I do now, so Afterlife and Status Seeker was actually my fave songs on the album funnily enough! I love the whole album today though. It’s a timeless gem! There is nothing like it, and you had an influence on that which no one can ever take away! Thank you so much for the stories behind the lyrics to the album. The lyrics on Afterlife has so many perspectives and seems deeply philosophical! Pleasure to know that you wrote them! About the vocal ranges, I could imagine that as a naturally gifted all round singer it is hard to determine one’s singing stereotype, I guess it’s just where you feel most comfortable. And I am sure you can sing everything - but what a I hinting at was that with constant performances, the “true” range/stereotype, that you feel most comfortable in, would show by where you have the best stamina over a longer time frame of daily singing, if you know what I mean? Anyway, it’s not important - you can sing everything on normal days, I am sure(growling, screamo etc not taking into account haha)... I have not heard your own albums I must admit - did not know they existed!(But I have played your DT album a 1000 times perhaps) I will check out your own ones ASAP! Hope you are doing well in general🤘🏼🎤
When Dream and Day Unite is a masterpiece, I love this album, your voice was perfect, the members of DT were idiots to have taken you out of the band because you were much better than JLB
@@feralkitty9378 each go their own but Kevin Moore was a much tasteful player in DT than JR. KM didnt overplay and knew when to lay in and lay off. He’s also a great songwriter and has great feel in his compositions.
@@feralkitty9378absolutely not lol. Rudess can play way more notes way more perfectly, but Moore was their best songwriter during their most important years.
@@radicalstanza3614 overall rudess contributed melodically more so than moore because he just overall was a better writer than moore. And in my opinion the melodies he writes are far more beautiful and effective than kevin moores. For example, anything of the six degrees of inner turbulence song, specifically goodnight kiss. or dissapear, or the count of tuscany, ministry of lost souls, sacrificed sons. the list does not end.
As a child, I thought I could live without pain. Without sorrow. As a man.....I discovered this video and now I'm living in pain and sorrow because I CAN'T TAKE THIS GUY'S SINGING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
@@tidalcliff2202 That's because it obviously does, and after 30 years, it's not like you have anything to compare it to other than a single album and a handful of demos.
Nem tudom, hogy ki hogy van vele, de én nagyon szeretem Charlie hangját! Szerintem egyedi, ezer közül is azonnal ráismerni. Charlie, köszönöm az első Dream Theater albumot!
Dominici's voice isn't bad from what I've heard of it. But it doesn't sound quite right for Metropolis. But then that might just be from knowing it so well with Labrie.
I'm spanish. Excuse me for my english. Charlie was the perfect choice for a band like DT. For a band in his first steps, this man pushed his style to a netx level. I don't know was happened to make the change, (business probably} also the majestic of his voice are forever in the history of DT. Saludos desde Cartagena, España.
The great thing about a band that goes back 26 years is that you can see how they've evolved over the years, what trials and tribulations they've gone through.
when Charlie sings its like I feel 80 but he have a beautiful voice that is good for theater, however the new vocalist have a very thin voice and a high pitch voice which connected to rock, they are both better thats why dream theater decided to change the vocalist to connect with the new era now a days and they succeed, It would be the same with Angra this is more instrumental and a little bit vocals like your in a game or a vortex or whatsoever 😅
He just.. says everything so dramatically.. like a william shatner cover of it. I'm sorry, Labrie owns this song. Especially the live at the marquee version.
@MyMytalMajesty Even though Myung starting contributing again recently, I don't think his role in the band is big enough to the point where DT would end if he left. Petrucci's the only one whose departure could actually lead to the band's end.
@OBQM Yes....but then there's The killing hand, which labrie does absolute wonders with. Dominici does sound alright on this version, but there's also the version with him and sherinian (from late 90's) where he sounds hideous...even worse when labrie's performing part of the song with him. Now, if you'll excuse me, I think i'll click on the live at the marguee metropolis link to the right now ;P
Interesting to hear how much the song changed from this to studio version. The first half feels empty without JP's guitar fills. Also is it me or is the keyboard super loud and guitar super quiet here?
This is why CZcams's new "first name, last name" policy is horrible. For a split second, I thought the real Dominici was commenting here. Fuckshitassdamnhell
@ScrotumCancer2 SO TRUE!! No Petrucci, No DT!! Probably i can think of Jordan's departure as a "serious injury" or something, but without Petrucci, it's just a headshot. Gotta love my analogy!!
People should take into account this is a live recording. However, this is pushing Dominici's range outside of what he's good at, at least for live performance. Still interesting to watch, though. What's the story behind the, uh, unusual channel name?
Just came across this video. I like Charlie's vocal chops but it seems to me that his voice is definitely struggling to hit the high notes; besides, he is showing too many emotions while singing this and thereby modulates the song too much. James has a more smoother approach to this, IMHO.
@dmdollinar08 i prefer dominici because he doesn't screw up his singing wiht growls or trying to alter his tone for every song. i prefer dominici vocals to labrie on the early songs and labrie might have been a good singer for 2 years until he had his accident
@@CharlieDominiciTheSinger hi Charlie, big fan of your wdadu album. It gets 100% review score from me and it's always cool to drive at night while this is playing on my cd player. Thanks for your service!
It's no secret that the bulk of DT's repertoire is in a higher range than my natural ability to perform night after night and especially under any kind of duress. Anyone that performs vocally knows that there are many things that can affect the human voice which is much more susceptible to obstacles such as environment ( thick cigarette smoke, heat or air conditioning, humidity,too little sleep, inaudible stage monitors while the band behind you is pushing a level of decibels similar to a 747 taking off (120-130 db), too much parting, and list goes on. The truth is I probably shouldn't have even gone to the audition that fateful night when the band that hates being compared to Rush played an hour of Rush songs as I sat there thinking 'Oh I'll just sing high like Geddy and nail this gig. Of course the rest is history but in closing let me say that noticing my difficulty for any one or more of the reasons mentioned earlier is no sign of musical intuition but rather as redundant as saying James wasn't hitting the notes because he had food poisoning. When you hear me pulling a carrot on any one of these recordings it's not so much for the reasons I mentioned but more that the songs are out of my range. But getting up on stage in front of thousands of people and making them scream and jump around flashing metal horns at you is such a f*king rush that I'll tolerate any unflattering criticism however minor and from any self proclaimed music critic regardless of their knowledge of the subject. After all with the advent of the internet it seems that any 12 year old with a keyboard and mouse is a credible source on the subject. I only hope they feel the kind of rush criticizing we performers that we feel when we throw ourselves to those little lions! Rrrroar!!! Lol
@ScrotumCancer2 Eh, it depends on the music. Overall, LaBrie is better, but make no mistake, this song is NOT a Dominici-range song. He does well on this version, but the LaBrie high-pitched vocals version is obviously the best. A lot of WDaDU's material is far more Dominici-suited than LaBrie, as was evident in the 2004 reunion show.
What's the point of recording an intro that you'll never play again in the future? Since I&W, intro to this song is played from the studio recording for performances. Maiden did the same with Aces High.
The great thing about a band that goes back 26 years is that you can see how they've evolved over the years, what trials and tribulations they've gone through. Nevertheless, Dominici's vocals still hurt my ears here.
Hearing this along with stuff from his self titled band honestly makes me wish he never left. His voice was always better, and still is better than Labrie's imo Original lineup was the best in terms of how they sound Though at the same time, without Labrie we might not have songs like Disappear...
@@CharlieDominiciTheSinger estimado no importa si cantaste bien o mal , lo importante es que estuviste en la formacion original de la banda progresiva de metal mas grande de la historia y cuantos cantantes pueden decir lo mismo¡? Un abrazo
Man... I'm So Sorry To Say... But I Have To Say: The Instrumental Sounds Amazing Here, But 2004 Dominici's Voice Fits This Song More Better Than This One... 🙂 Rest In Peace, Mr. Charlie Dominici...
Charlie just can't match pitch all that well live. Even james is off sometimes but this is inexcusable. Not to mention the melodrama of the delivery of the lyrics (aside from the melody obviously)
I apologize for the timing on this. I'm not making excuses but I was still writing the melody when this was recorded. =)
charlie dominici commenting in person? damn epic, I think your voice in When Dream and Day Unite was great! btw an honor!
Basically, James Labrie used your vocal melody on most of this song then modified some parts to fit it to his range.
To me, your singing sounds the same way how James sang it on I&W recording.
Great effort Charlie. You’re still one of those ppl. who helped built this band as to where they are now. Without you and others who left, DT is not that famous as today. Respect.
+Charlie Dominici On the 15th anniversary there is a good lesson about how to sing this song, and it not given by Labrie.
+Charlie Dominici Dude you were amazing singing this don't apologize
It wasn't intended as an apology more an eye opener for the guys that were judging my performance compared to JLB. I'm very proud of the fact that for over 25 years, James has sung pretty much the exact melody i wrote back in 1989 and JP has only suggested one or two notes that changed to showcase JLBs high range. \m/
Rest in peace Charlie💔💔
I feel like Charlie's take on the song is more operatic, theatrical whereas James's is a more forwards rock style for Metro. Two entirely different feelings in my opinion. With James, it feels like a rock song. With Charlie, it feels personal and somewhat saddening. Really amazing stuff
Dominici has a unique tone and beautiful emotional voice in general. That said he’s a High baritone, and on good well rested days can sing these DT songs, not without effort though. That takes a lot of strain on a singers voice if you constantly push your range abilities(he does have a impressionable range for s baritone though), but he could never have toured with DT full scale without sounding shit like on this recording. LaBrie was a true vocal beast blessed with an amazing vocal range for men and power as well which made him so versatile and practically a vocal virtuoso until he got sick. Anyone who questions LaBrie, listen to the live at the Marquee album. He shines on it. That said, Dominici’s voice suited the first album.
Very perceptive and musically knowledgable comment. I've often said that I joined this band and took on the vocal job for the first album for The same reason why people climb mountains- because it was there. I knew the melodies I was writing were out of my comfort range but I wasn't looking to be comfortable I was looking to be great. Aim for the stars and you might at least get the moon. It took a lot of work and preparation to perform every night singing 2 whole steps above my natural range and there were those typical rock and roll situations where too much partying made that goal line a bit farther then it needed to be and the results can be heard on bootleg live tapes occasionally. A friend used to say " I pulled a carrot" lol. A very adequate analogy! That said In not making excuses just putting some truth out there among all the speculation. For my 4 CD trilogy I tended to stay in a semi- Comfortable range on the high end anyway but I took myself out of that easy chair for the low stuff. There are many that had no idea I could sing low notes as low as a natural E. Of course that's not the reason why I did it that way I did it for the same reason (you guessed it) as The reason why people climb mountains.
Charlie Dominici Honored to interact with you Charlie and thank you for your response! I totally understand what you are saying and I applaud you for your effort and honestly love to enjoy listening to your voice. It is very special to me and for many years I preferred yours, but I have stopped judging great singers because it’s like apple’s and oranges and if you know singing there is nothing but pure respect for vocalists. Many singers get to much unjustified critique from idiots that knows nothing about singing. I just love impressive singing techniques! and appreciate different styles. I really am impressed with your tone clear high notes, which many non-tenors tend to put more uncontrolled distortion and strain into that further fatigues the voice(big mistake). So your ability to keep the tone clear and bright even when you struggle a bit amazes me! As a baritone myself and amateur singer I understand the challenge you took on, I worked much on my high pitch range but it’s just such a marathon to improve it and takes a lot of practice and bad habits to break to get it right. I believe your voice brought an amazingly unique style to the band! I haven’t looked in the album sleeve in a long time, but did you also contribute to the lyrics?
@@djglammetal9666 I did co-write lyrics with JP on "Status Seeker" and in the early days MP and JP asked me to re-write the lyrics to a song that Chris Collins had written lyrics for. I chose to not listen to his version and wrote the lyric with no influence from that version. The result was what is arguabl
Oops. To continue: arguably one of the best songs on the album. 8 also happened to be what solidified my entrance to the band. That song was Afterlife. I don't know if I'm actually a baritone or possibly a high tenor but if you've listened to any of the part 2 and part 3 of O3 a Trilogy you'll notice that I do have a deep voice in me as well as a high voice but yeah once you get up to that be note with talking OK face, mask, stay off the throat, watch the diaphragm etc. and all that vocal training from the 6 lessons I took back in 1980.
Charlie Dominici When I was younger I didn’t really appreciate complex rock as much as I do now, so Afterlife and Status Seeker was actually my fave songs on the album funnily enough! I love the whole album today though. It’s a timeless gem! There is nothing like it, and you had an influence on that which no one can ever take away! Thank you so much for the stories behind the lyrics to the album. The lyrics on Afterlife has so many perspectives and seems deeply philosophical! Pleasure to know that you wrote them! About the vocal ranges, I could imagine that as a naturally gifted all round singer it is hard to determine one’s singing stereotype, I guess it’s just where you feel most comfortable. And I am sure you can sing everything - but what a I hinting at was that with constant performances, the “true” range/stereotype, that you feel most comfortable in, would show by where you have the best stamina over a longer time frame of daily singing, if you know what I mean? Anyway, it’s not important - you can sing everything on normal days, I am sure(growling, screamo etc not taking into account haha)... I have not heard your own albums I must admit - did not know they existed!(But I have played your DT album a 1000 times perhaps) I will check out your own ones ASAP! Hope you are doing well in general🤘🏼🎤
oh yea and btw. Try singing this song your self sometime! \m/ lol haters gonna hate, right mikeportnoying?
Your work in your solo band was amazing!
I wanted you to have recorded at least one more album with the DT ... because you had to leave the Dream Theater? ...... T_T
"mikeportnoying"?
I couldn't even do it 1/100000th as good and I'm not going to pretend I could.
@@jetstream454 he threw Charlie out of the band, and Derek... and then left...
His tone has so much character
This might be the best DT's live drum equalization ever. I love the sound of the snare.
Daniel Sandoval Drums sounds great, perhaps Portnoy is using Ian Mosley's setup?
I like James better! \m/
No I'm Mick Jagger but I wanted to pretend to be a singer that people might know. Silly, right?
+Charlie Dominici ha ha haaaaa
+Jacob Wallingford I like both singers, but Charlie - this is so amazing, I'd love to have this in a top quality. You're expression is wonderful.
When Dream and Day Unite is a masterpiece, I love this album, your voice was perfect, the members of DT were idiots to have taken you out of the band because you were much better than JLB
Well...you know...bootleg recording of a performance AFTER you'd been kicked out versus a studio recording isn't exactly a contest. LOL
I love every person in this band, current and past member.. for me they are truly great artist
Kind of refreshing, hearing another voice's take on this song.
RIP Charlie Dominici
and I'm hot!
Personally, I think Charlie Dominici is a great singer. So is LaBrie. I like them both equally on this song.
The Labrie version is a cover.
Прощай, Чарли, нам будет тебя очень не хватать. Земля пухом.
Charlie was also in Frankie and the knockouts. He played guitar and background singer.
Kevin Moore and Mike Portnoy were clearly the two most important members.
I like rudess ,,,but sorry moore make dream a THEATER
rudess was way more important than kevin moore, kevin moore contributed way less to dt than rudess did, and rudess had better melodies.
@@feralkitty9378 each go their own but Kevin Moore was a much tasteful player in DT than JR. KM didnt overplay and knew when to lay in and lay off. He’s also a great songwriter and has great feel in his compositions.
@@feralkitty9378absolutely not lol. Rudess can play way more notes way more perfectly, but Moore was their best songwriter during their most important years.
@@radicalstanza3614 overall rudess contributed melodically more so than moore because he just overall was a better writer than moore. And in my opinion the melodies he writes are far more beautiful and effective than kevin moores. For example, anything of the six degrees of inner turbulence song, specifically goodnight kiss. or dissapear, or the count of tuscany, ministry of lost souls, sacrificed sons. the list does not end.
As a child, I thought I could live without pain. Without sorrow.
As a man.....I discovered this video and now I'm living in pain and sorrow because I CAN'T TAKE THIS GUY'S SINGING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Holy Hell.... My ears... Oh my ears...... That is all...
+Michael StJames lol
Intro here is better than the original
Sounds like Karaoke night at the local bar..
Rest in peace Charlie❤️
Dominici is a good, stable, constant singer. But his style dont fit with DT sound, i think.
You act like Labrie's style does fit.
@@tidalcliff2202 it does.
@@tidalcliff2202 That's because it obviously does, and after 30 years, it's not like you have anything to compare it to other than a single album and a handful of demos.
@@tidalcliff2202 it does
I love that this exists. Thank you.
🔥🔥🔥
Crying while singing
You've done great work during the foundation of this band. You are still a part of the Dream Theater family. 🤘 🎵
Nem tudom, hogy ki hogy van vele, de én nagyon szeretem Charlie hangját! Szerintem egyedi, ezer közül is azonnal ráismerni. Charlie, köszönöm az első Dream Theater albumot!
Go home, Charlie. You’re drunk.
One of the best voices ever, imho.
Dominici's voice isn't bad from what I've heard of it. But it doesn't sound quite right for Metropolis. But then that might just be from knowing it so well with Labrie.
I like the intro here better than the studio version on I&W. Got more of an eighties feel to it!
But I love John myungs hair though...
This has got to be like the only time they actually played the intro live, as opposed to having the album version intro played.
Love the spacy intro (
The intro is certainly better in this than the original
I'm spanish. Excuse me for my english. Charlie was the perfect choice for a band like DT. For a band in his first steps, this man pushed his style to a netx level. I don't know was happened to make the change, (business probably} also the majestic of his voice are forever in the history of DT.
Saludos desde Cartagena, España.
FINALLY I get to hear just you singing this song. Something I heard about, but could never find it. Thanks man!
The great thing about a band that goes back 26 years is that you can see how they've evolved over the years, what trials and tribulations they've gone through.
with those keys the sound of the band is completely different.
yea all james labrie hate thing...... james had a vocal rupture , before that he was a beast....
ew cant imagine an album with this voice XD
Just listen to when dream and day unite hahahaha. Good songs on that album but dominici ruins it for me
when Charlie sings its like I feel 80 but he have a beautiful voice that is good for theater, however the new vocalist have a very thin voice and a high pitch voice which connected to rock, they are both better thats why dream theater decided to change the vocalist to connect with the new era now a days and they succeed, It would be the same with Angra this is more instrumental and a little bit vocals like your in a game or a vortex or whatsoever 😅
Now i am so happy that they kicked out Dominici and had LaBrie. What a awful live performance. This is like he is crying.
Funny how the three guys in the middle are all gone now, and the only remaining members from this lineup are the dudes on the far left and right.
He just.. says everything so dramatically.. like a william shatner cover of it. I'm sorry, Labrie owns this song. Especially the live at the marquee version.
@MyMytalMajesty Even though Myung starting contributing again recently, I don't think his role in the band is big enough to the point where DT would end if he left. Petrucci's the only one whose departure could actually lead to the band's end.
totally agree with the diss.to that guy..Labrie is one the best voices in metal
@OBQM Yes....but then there's The killing hand, which labrie does absolute wonders with.
Dominici does sound alright on this version, but there's also the version with him and sherinian (from late 90's) where he sounds hideous...even worse when labrie's performing part of the song with him.
Now, if you'll excuse me, I think i'll click on the live at the marguee metropolis link to the right now ;P
Dude, that's his channel. I'm friends with him on Facebook, and he has linked to that channel in the past.
@paskajuzzy I think everyone's hair is pretty styling here! But the Johns do take the cake!
When you drink one too many and decide you can do karaoke
Interesting to hear how much the song changed from this to studio version. The first half feels empty without JP's guitar fills. Also is it me or is the keyboard super loud and guitar super quiet here?
This is why CZcams's new "first name, last name" policy is horrible. For a split second, I thought the real Dominici was commenting here.
Fuckshitassdamnhell
@Rovelius39X7 Hes a fantastic singer
@ScrotumCancer2
SO TRUE!! No Petrucci, No DT!!
Probably i can think of Jordan's departure as a "serious injury" or something, but without Petrucci, it's just a headshot. Gotta love my analogy!!
People should take into account this is a live recording. However, this is pushing Dominici's range outside of what he's good at, at least for live performance. Still interesting to watch, though.
What's the story behind the, uh, unusual channel name?
Charlie like an opera singer I think.
Just came across this video. I like Charlie's vocal chops but it seems to me that his voice is definitely struggling to hit the high notes; besides, he is showing too many emotions while singing this and thereby modulates the song too much. James has a more smoother approach to this, IMHO.
Sorry but I have to do this: Thumbs up for Myung's hair
..... I like the bass solo xD
@Rovelius39X7 He was a lot better than James during the When Dream and Day Reunite reunion show, and his solo stuff is great.
JP is so quiet how unfortunate
@richyn2 Actually he did attempt sounding like a girl in Metropolis pt 2 for the parts of Victoria. Just a random fact.
Of all the comments that aren't my own, this is the best.
This isn't a demo. It's a live recording from some club that DT released as a bootleg.
@dmdollinar08 i prefer dominici because he doesn't screw up his singing wiht growls or trying to alter his tone for every song. i prefer dominici vocals to labrie on the early songs and labrie might have been a good singer for 2 years until he had his accident
Is that bad lighting or does Charlie have a terrible sunburn on his chest?
@RaidonSama CHRIS FRIGGIN COLLINS was better than Dominici?!?!?!?! Really?!?!? Are you serious?
dude the fact that your user name is porntoy and you mention charlie dominatrix just made my day! LOL
He hits the notes, but I can tell he's struggling at many points. I personally don't really like this at all. I much prefer James
Ok, they'll keep James then. Doh!
@@CharlieDominiciTheSinger hi Charlie, big fan of your wdadu album. It gets 100% review score from me and it's always cool to drive at night while this is playing on my cd player. Thanks for your service!
It's no secret that the bulk of DT's repertoire is in a higher range than my natural ability to perform night after night and especially under any kind of duress. Anyone that performs vocally knows that there are many things that can affect the human voice which is much more susceptible to obstacles such as environment ( thick cigarette smoke, heat or air conditioning, humidity,too little sleep, inaudible stage monitors while the band behind you is pushing a level of decibels similar to a 747 taking off (120-130 db), too much parting, and list goes on. The truth is I probably shouldn't have even gone to the audition that fateful night when the band that hates being compared to Rush played an hour of Rush songs as I sat there thinking 'Oh I'll just sing high like Geddy and nail this gig. Of course the rest is history but in closing let me say that noticing my difficulty for any one or more of the reasons mentioned earlier is no sign of musical intuition but rather as redundant as saying James wasn't hitting the notes because he had food poisoning. When you hear me pulling a carrot on any one of these recordings it's not so much for the reasons I mentioned but more that the songs are out of my range. But getting up on stage in front of thousands of people and making them scream and jump around flashing metal horns at you is such a f*king rush that I'll tolerate any unflattering criticism however minor and from any self proclaimed music critic regardless of their knowledge of the subject. After all with the advent of the internet it seems that any 12 year old with a keyboard and mouse is a credible source on the subject. I only hope they feel the kind of rush criticizing we performers that we feel when we throw ourselves to those little lions! Rrrroar!!! Lol
inascoltabile
e c'è gente nei commenti che sostiene che dominici sia meglio di labrie, e ne sono anche convinti
@sexypadri My guess is he was too old, when WDADU was recorded, he was 37..the others were 18-19
DT Rules!
JP's look could be mistaken for Criss Oliva here.
@ScrotumCancer2 Eh, it depends on the music. Overall, LaBrie is better, but make no mistake, this song is NOT a Dominici-range song. He does well on this version, but the LaBrie high-pitched vocals version is obviously the best.
A lot of WDaDU's material is far more Dominici-suited than LaBrie, as was evident in the 2004 reunion show.
what might have been..
Whoever voted down one of my previous posts has a lot of nerve! I provide you with this entertaining video and you repay me by silencing me?
x).. sure.. but, i prefer called, "early creativity".. cause, he didnt have to change to much!.. but.. youre right.. its lack of creativity too...
Of the billions of videos on youtube, THIS is the one in which you choose to barge in and tell people to stop arguing?
What's the point of recording an intro that you'll never play again in the future? Since I&W, intro to this song is played from the studio recording for performances. Maiden did the same with Aces High.
Try to stare into petruccis eyes in the pic.
@IReallyAmIronMan Yes, very Shatneresque!
The great thing about a band that goes back 26 years is that you can see how they've evolved over the years, what trials and tribulations they've gone through. Nevertheless, Dominici's vocals still hurt my ears here.
@evolutionmb Because it's not possible for singers to improve over time, right?
On WDADU he had a very unique and operatic voice in my opinion, but his range and ability is not enough to sing anything from images and words
Parece o Ney Matogrosso no vocal...
I stand corrected then, though I suppose I can't be blamed for being skeptical about that sort of thing.
@KyleJPie10 And the LaBrie blowers aren't?
But you are in every Dream Theater video?shut up and enjoy them!
funny how james can sing charlie DT songs better, but charlie cant even touch JLB's stuff
Hearing this along with stuff from his self titled band honestly makes me wish he never left. His voice was always better, and still is better than Labrie's imo
Original lineup was the best in terms of how they sound
Though at the same time, without Labrie we might not have songs like Disappear...
Missing out on Disappear wouldn't have been a bad thing.
How is dominici better in any way than James la brie, are you deaf???
@@davidescristofaros2241 have you heard James anytime past 2008? He was great but the touring hasn't worked well for his voice
sounds like he's crying, probably a bad day in his life lol
How did you know? Damn internet no privacy anymore!
@@CharlieDominiciTheSinger estimado no importa si cantaste bien o mal , lo importante es que estuviste en la formacion original de la banda progresiva de metal mas grande de la historia y cuantos cantantes pueden decir lo mismo¡? Un abrazo
Man...
I'm So Sorry To Say...
But I Have To Say: The Instrumental Sounds Amazing Here, But 2004 Dominici's Voice Fits This Song More Better Than This One... 🙂
Rest In Peace, Mr. Charlie Dominici...
LtR: Petrucci, Portnoy, Dominici, Moore, Myung
omg
@ScrotumCancer2
"He was a lot better than James during the When Dream and Day Reunite reunion show" my friend
@chrisbDTM Funny as in....a joke? Are you saying your comment is a joke? Because I would agree with that.
@richyn2 My comment got two thumbs up. How many did yours get?
@seroxturk It's better that he cries than the fans who have to listen to Labrie.
Are you fucking kidding us ???
huh charlies struggling. also they changed the key. still interesting to listen to
Charlie just can't match pitch all that well live. Even james is off sometimes but this is inexcusable. Not to mention the melodrama of the delivery of the lyrics (aside from the melody obviously)