THE BIG COMPARISON | GTA IV vs. GTA V vs. Mafia II vs. Mafia III | ULTRA
Vložit
- čas přidán 12. 03. 2020
- I made this BIG GTA IV vs. GTA V vs. Mafia II vs. Mafia III comparison to show the differences! Which one is the best?
Buy Mafia II: Definitive Edition with the link below to support PlayGround! :)
www.greenmangaming.com/games/...
Thank you!
If you like my video, please SHARE it with your friends!
I hope you enjoy the content I made!
Welcome to the PlayGround!
Go to chrono.gg/PlayGround - for TODAY's deal!
Many thanks for everyone who support PlayGround through this!
Thank you so much for watching!
► Subscribe for more high quality videos! :) czcams.com/users/PlayGroundFH...
/////////////////////////////////////////////
My PC:
CPU: i7 8700K 4.7 GHz
RAM: 32 GB DDR4 3200 MHz
VGA: RTX 2070 8 GB
/////////////////////////////////////////////
Music:
Production Music courtesy of Epidemic Sound: www.epidemicsound.com
The More You Make - Aesyme
Dirty Cash - Aesyme
Some of That Gold - Aesyme
Cruisin' - Aesyme
Facebook - / finalhopegameplays
Twitter - / fh_gameplays
Support PlayGround on Patreon!
/ playground
Donation:
www.paypal.com/cgi-bin/webscr... - Hry
GTA4 + Mafia2 = perfect game
what about gta5+gtaiv
and good story like in gta san
and combine red dead.. map with gta san map+gtav map and another maps(vice city)
and get some ideas from mafia2 (and other games)
i think it would be a good game to play
Why not combine all of them?
@@Synthwavu yeaaah😈😈
Yes
RDR2 Story + GTA 4 & Mafia 2 Details + GTA VI Graphics = Perfection
Also in gta IV when you press the F button he keeps the car running and gets out of the car and if you hold the F button he pulls the handbrake and turns off the car.
Same with the Y button on Xbox.
@sucka la mink nah, people don't feature it in games beacuse it takes some more time to script, and much people don't care abaout it. Why spend time making something only 50 people out of thousands players will use, if you can spend time on something else that everyone will use. Doing it for many big devs seems like a waste of time. They just do new map, new story and sometimes new mechanic without spending time for details, so they can earn money at the least cost possible
same thing in gta v btw
@@Ursusowanie why does it take time to script when the script is already there in the previous game and they have to optimize for the new game that's it
The point is because people CARE about the small details.. weather it’s food you can eat . Every building going inside and out.. having to refill your gas I LOVED that about mafia !
Just to remember that Mafia II was a medium budget game that wasn’t fully completed because they didn’t had the money to do it. Even though, it had THAT amount of details.
imagine the complete version of mafia 2
@@suicidaltendenciezzz damn
@@suicidaltendenciezzz unfortunately,the company who made this game was disbanded
fr
@@idsfxtm5759 wrong
you cant compare when there isnt even the feature in the game!!!!
I liked your point actually
True gamers never compare games
Ikr? This video is b.s.
He compares the games, not the features
He is a fool
I genuinely wonder, why these games do not accumulate their own features from previous to new ones.
@Purple Guy cool. but whag about rockstar then? why didn't they have previous features like picking stuff up, better parkour, and better combat?
@Purple Guy You call people dumb yet you're the dumbest one here. You have no fucking clue what you're talking about.
Optimization i guess
Senator Chadrick .A reasonable thought, by the way. It makes sense
@Purple Guy 2k Czech was merged in Hanger 13, but yes Mafia 2 and 3 were made by different studios. GTA on the other hand is the same studio, thus the question stands.
MAFIA 2 the tyres (tires(USA)) react to what the vehicle is doing which most other games don't have that level of detail
Wdym by React to the what the vehicle is doing?
*12*
in mafia 3 the tyres also deform, though its more subtle
Mafia 2 also has better weight, so you can almost feel potholes in the road, but gta 4 does have that, just not so as much. The body roll is amazing, just a bit too fast though.
Mafia 2 also has vibration on turns
Ujjwal Nigam because RDR2 “DEFINITELY” has tyres
PlayGround's Nexus Store is now OPEN! You can find GREAT GAMES! (for example: Mafia: Definitive Edition)
www.nexus.gg/PlayGround
Many thanks for everyone who buy from my store and this way support my channel! :)
@CREEPY SKIPPY Yes, it will work! And if you buy the game through that link, I will get about 4% of the money. :)
I have that game already, there are 30 GB more to download than the classic Mafia II and I don´t see a big difference (there are still some more details), but I got the game for free, because I already have the classic game.
Oi
Will this link work pls tell
@@PlayGroundComparisons we want 100% off
If we combine gta 4's logics and gta 5's graphics
We can get the best open world game
@@SKYAzuraX
Example for physics .. ragdoll
Example for logic ..
In gta 4 the peds will run for shelter while raining
There are difference man
😂😂😂😂
Mafia 3 clearly has the better graphics out of all four.
And a story like GTA sa
@@dariozivanic4948 meh, how about story about coronavirus Getting gang turfs from other gangs
after five years on being covid-18 it was time to go covid-19
@@Phelps-1247 mafia 3 is the worst game ever........DAMN this is SHIT
Grand Theft Auto IV.
yes.
V
@@FilipinoFurry shut the fuck up 9 year old
@@pulanjuri1 what did he do?
@@ohnono3931 he thinks that gta v is the best bruhhhhh its gta iv
The big GTA games VS the big Mafia games! Vote for the best at the top right corner! ;)
Mafia games
Could you someday create a video of what is beyond the peninsula of the map of gta 3 in an argumentative way based on the space time of the gta universes? It looks interesting
Gta 4
7:53/what feature is that
@@lolathomas1965 9:30 Look at the car's wheel! If you get out of the car it stays turned or not. In Mafia II and III it stays the way you leave! :)
9:37 in gta 5 you can able to turn wheel while standing.
You can do that in others as well
You can use the gas station and park the car with turned wheel in Mafia 1 too
7:59 "О чём я и говорю!"
what I'm talking about!
Mafia is so underrated
No it's known by many but not as much as gta
@@rameshbabusumathi Not really.
Just cause too is underrated deverving games are not getting what they deserve in this generation
@@ricorodriguez8350 yeah just cause is underrated it's very good btw
@@rameshbabusumathi yeah
Mafia II is great in physics.. I haven't played mafia III yet only Mafia II, GTA IV and V.. In mafia II we have to break the lock before we access to the car.. That's damn realistic😘
You Can also break the window
@@super-gamer.2006 yeah and it's so realistic
4 different ways to steal a car in Mafia 2:
-pick locking
-smash the window
-shoot the window
-shoot the door handle
That's damn impressive
in Mafia III you can break the window or use picklocks. picklocks will be available as you progress through the game. of all Mafia 3 has the best physics and graphics. driving is almost realistic. if you are playing on a console, the vehicle acceleration and shift points vary based on how far you have pressed the accel button. that is still missing in GTA V
Yeh mafia 2's fall physics are really realistic. The character majes a stupid pose and doesnt even react to the fall and doesnt move at all.
Yeah, soo realistic.
Combining all of that= awesome graphics
Awesome game
Game is not all about graphics
@@shilpisirvaiya1299 Nevertheless
@@shilpisirvaiya1299 stop being nostalgic
I have no idea why they remove some of those details in games, it annoys me because it makes it more fun, imagine fleeing from the cops in Mafia 3 and then you suddenly run out of gas. Same goes for GTA, there was way more interaction in that game, including places you could go to.
It makes the game feel the same feature wise, because they remove features from the game and add none, or others, keeping features though would enhance game experience, definitely.
I like how in Mafia 2 you can change driving mode to be easier to drive or more realistic. GTA should take notes.
gta iv and v driving is fine no notes needed
@@bartman26 5's driving is way too simple and dumbed down for the kids. Drifting around corners slows down cars way too much without mods. It's like the game sees you having fun and takes it away.
4's is like everything is a 1974 Cadillac Deville with varying acceleration speeds.
But yes, let's not have any options that would make the game more fun for more people
@@jeiku5041 I remember when I used to play GTA IV I changed handling on 10 most used car by me. There are many great community modded car handlings for GTA IV. Actually with community handlings GTA IV driving is way more realistic than GTA V. What I really hate about GTA V is that if you roll a car on the roof you can simply use steering to roll it back on the wheels. It doesn't make any sense.
@@Romif_SK I mean I'd be pretty angry if I rolled an expensive car and couldn't flip it back over.
Gta driving is far better than mafia 😂
Combine all these games together to get...Grand Theft Mafia. The best open world game in the century.
i think gta4 + mafia 2 definitive edition is enough
good story
mafia 3 like graphics which at times make gta5 look like average
best physics
if you do wanna add something then removing gta 4 and adding red dead redemption is much better as it contributes to both physics and graphics much more than gta series (even thogh i think gta 3 story + rdr 2 is better)
0:32 Johnny from GTA 4
Yes trevor killed him
Wow! Good attention to detail
Wow didnt notice
You have hawk eyes man wtf
7:50 in this test if it is "can you leave the car with engine on" in GTA 4 you can.
Nah it's that the wheel will remain turned when leaving the car in mafia games
Nah it's that the wheel will remain turned when leaving the car in mafia games
I like how in mafia 2 when you open the hydrant and drive into it, the water which is already propelled will fall down, not an entire animation in a pause.
Did you know? MAFIA II IS CZECH GAME FROM BRNO
well yea, I'm from czech :)
Hell yeah
Czech making great games.remember hidden n dangerous 2.mafia
5:03 I didn’t know that air came out the tire when you shot the tire, it’s those little details which makes a game good
And slow ...
In real life you will not see the air that comes out of the tire after you have shot it
*12*
@@95regShamil Lmao
Have you even use a tire before? 😂😂
Your just embarrassing yourself
I like how the dude holds his brake to flash the reverse lights as if you’re shifting the car into park to make it more realistic. It’s the little things, man.
9:30 even that is smoother in gta 4 than gta 5
Gta 4 💯👌
Pd: thanks for 20 likes💯 and playground heart💯💯
𝘼𝙣𝙙 𝙬𝙝𝙤 𝙩𝙝𝙚 𝙛𝙪𝙘𝙠 𝙘𝙖𝙧𝙚𝙨 𝙖𝙗𝙤𝙪𝙩 𝙡𝙞𝙠𝙚𝙨
@Maldonado approve this crash Lol
Xd
@@goldplayergameplays.3543 OOF
Edited comments always gets fucked now stfu
Gta iv was a revolutionary game for these games
Same with Mafia 2. Remember mafia 2 was also 2010. Gta 4 and mafia 2 are from the same era, the last era of amazing gaming. (About 2012 it ended, but watchdogs was 2014, but that was still realistic.)
Mafia 2 Is 2010 but gta 4 is 2008. Gta 4 is the one who brought out the HD Open world games
Well mafia II is a great game.. I need a game with a story line like gta San Andreas, graphics like GTA V, Physics like GTA IV and Mafia II❤
That would be an amazing game
Mafia 2 has a great story too
@@chethanprabhu4475 I know that. But no any game can touch our hearts like San Andreas.. Especially it's story line.. Carl Johnson, big smoke, Cesar vilapandado, sweet, Ryder etc..living characters.. They won't die❤
@@connor4689 I feel Mafia 2 story is better than San Andreas, it's also had better emotions. But as u told San Andreas is close to my heart as well since it's my childhood game.
@@chethanprabhu4475 it depends on you. As I guess San Andrea's story line is legendary. It's long and really interesting till the last mission. Mafia II Is short and interesting. But Vito can't replace Carl in our hearts
Мафия 2 это произведение искусства
Я сначала в первую играл, но так как не было опыта знакомства с такими играми, я вообще не понял, как играть))
Думал, что всю игру придётся на машине ездить, так как первая миссия погоня. Не особо любил гонки и поэтому бросал её раз 5, никак не понимая, что делать.
Когда до меня дошло, после прохождения нескольких миссий, что это за игра, то я влюбился в неё))
Просто шедевр для своего времени, что по деталям к игровому миру (не считая одинаковых на лицо персонажей 😂), что по сюжету.
0:34 Johnny photo on the flour
Gonna bake a cake?
Mafia 2 was way ahead of its time and STILL doing better at realism vs a lot of games today. If you've not played it, You're missing out. It's better than 3, And heaps better than any and i mean ANY GTA if you're into story and some wildly awesome physics too.
I agree. played the game lime 4 times over
Do you ever saw the story of GTA IV?
@@r.3752 ahem* GTA San Andreas
@@Constipation397 for me, the 4 one it's better than SA
@@JJMDthelilypod ok, its your opinion
Gta4 Physical +gta 5 Graphics+Gta san andreas missions=SUPER PERFECT GAME😎💥
+Mafia theft auto
0:23 Niko:
I'm best
3:00 "sorry for gas prices" price: 3.05$ for full tank
today: 758$ for 1 ml
Nice vid
Also
BOSS SOUNDTRACK
*12*
GTA 4 physics + GTA 5 graphics + MAFIA's details= Best Game
And i say: Mafia 2!!! Because i love that game. That game is my childhood. Who is with me? Like.
Your profile pic says otherwise
Abdulla Alaqili My nigga your pfp is a Fortnite skin stfu
Shucayb Bashir so what?, he says his favorite game out of the 4 games is mafia 2 but his profile pic is gta 5
Abdulla Alaqili FIRST of all he didn’t say fav 2nd of all you’re watching these PG games you’re prolly one of em 9 yr old sweats
Shucayb Bashir fam yea he did, you really need to learn to read, and I said out of the 4 games, and I’m not 9 years old and I don’t play Fortnite anymore I just find this profile pic cool
Awesome Comparison Bro
Nice comparison👍👍👍
*GTA IV was revolutionary game on that time*
man the music is great
Awesome bro
Still for GTA 4 game 2008 it's impressive this game doesn't get old 😮
I just noticed that the wheel of the cars in Mafia 2 and 3 really have realism. Wow.
They had to do research, because tires of that era, bias plys, were distinct and different..and unlike the massacre of GTA 5, the tire actually feels like a tire, not a thick black block from the front view and a circle void with a badly painted on texture from the side view. They have depth, and shape to them as older tires did, with really pretty designs.
Still gta -5 have 100 of details which magia doesn't have😂
Would it be cool if they made a GTA game set in the 1930s?
it would, but it would be called mafia clone
Everyone watching the perfect detail of the game, i love detailed game like a real life 😀😀😀😍😍
U can eat pork bun in sleeping dogs. Non of these games in the video can't.
I mean you can eat a hot dog in mafia 2.
You can eat in GTA IV.
@@rubenito9921 cux "A man who never eats pork buns is never a whole man."
U can eat pizza, hamburger, fried chicken, salad, hot dog and ice cream in San Andreas. And u can also use the vending machine.
@@lshkr6133 Mafia II....
I like both two games GTA IV and Mafia II
Gta 6 might watching this video and saying just Hold on bitches I'm coming Hahahh
7:58
Девушка на заднем фоне: "О чем я и говорю!")))
The best of mafia is the sound engine . Manual shift and simulation
7:58 Женщина по русски сказала:-"О чём я и говорю".
GTA 4 + Mafia II + GTA V graphics + GTA San Andreas story, the game is powerful.
but how much gb it would be imagine I think it would be like 200+ gbs soo its alot
mafia 2 was the most realistic of them all, it had a lot of features, you could actually run out of gas and cops will chase you for speeding, but you can bribe them
Gta IV also is very realistic
@@paulghencea9037 But Mafia 2 is better.
I like in IV that when you tap the exit button he leaves the car running, and if you hold it, he pulls the handbrake and turns the car off. Same if you get in a car or on a bike and drive immediately he doesn't put on helmet or seatbelt so if you crash he flies out the window, but if you wait a second he puts helmet or seatbelt on and never flies out the window if you crash. little details..
0:39 he's like I'm not about to break my back in an attempt to pick this up.
Did you know that mafia is Czech🇨🇿 game.
Thank you creating this video I know now what would I downlaod Mafia 2
No GTA 4 is fun and more realistic than mafia two you can even have free roam
@@butter_akbar2688 the guy wants to play mafia 2 he didn't say what was better, butthurt much lol.
*12*
Spuddywesker why would I be butthurt tho?
@@butter_akbar2688 they are both good
Thank you bro 👍👍👍👍👍😊🙏🏿🙏🏿🙏🏿🙏🏿
Maja aa gya
are you playing and recording these games on pc.BY the way love your videos
Thanks! And yes, it's on PC! :)
@BORN TO KILL Nvidia's built in.
*12*
The motorcycles in gta 5 were the only ones that could have turned wheels when parked
Which do you recommend with best phisics? Ty
I like tour vídeos👍👍👍:-)
*12*
no one can beat the details of mafia 1 classic & gta IV
I like how the dude parks REALLY illegaly
Be honest. Besides bull in a China shop, who actually frequently used the picking up an item and throwing it feature in GTA IV? Not being critical, just genuinely curious.
i liked throwing then at cars
Best background music
Credit where it’s due, Mafia 3 makes hitting the a hydrant look and feel the most real. I’d assume they don’t just fall over that easily like most games show
Queputas
Rockstar is KiNG in LOGICS from the time of creation of GTA IV.
Logics? You mean physics?
No man, Logics too !💖😊
@@samzony When did logics become a video game term? Never heard of it in nearly 30 years of playing games. Physics, game mechanics, level design, systems. Sure. Never heard of "logics". I really don't think it's a thing. I even tried googling "video game logics" to see if I was missing something. Nope, nothing in game design suggests "logics" is a thing.
There ain't no logics in GTA
@@lexgamer6495 Are there "logics" in any game? Are these people referring to A.I.? What is this term?!?!?
Gta 4+mafia 2
Old is gold
😁
7:59 o tchem ja i govory (о чём я и говорю).)))))
Neither game can beat up GTA IV completely till now. Nor will do in the future.
@Neo Papa nope 4 is still the better game
Depends What you mean by beating it
lmfao take a load of this guy
Gta IV fanboy detected. lel gta V is still the superior game each game rockstar launches is better than the previous one, just because gta IV is better than Gta V in some things that doesnt means that IV is better lol...
@@sebastiansantos1471 Actually, those fans think it beats 5 in every single thing, meanwhile 5 does have more and better features than 4 does.
Grand Theft Auto IV and Mafia 2 :))
+Gta V awesome games
I love the last part so realistic, mafia fan
didn't even know those games existed
If you are a real gamer you should know mafia 2 is one of the best games in the world
7:59 "О чем я и говорю"
АФИГЕТЬ! ГТА 4 СОЗДАВАЛИ БУДТО БЫ В РОССИИ!
А че тут я так и не понял ыто проверяли?
@@user-hy8sf7tw4t хех) я тоже непонел бро)
To nije ruski,vec srpski jezik☺
@@user-hy8sf7tw4t в мафии, когда выходишь из авто, колеса сохраняют положение
Imagine red dead redemption 2 + all gta games + mafia 2 + cyberpunk without all the bugs
And gta trilogy
In the gta you can turn the wheel, you need to sit in the car, clamp the handle and gas, then with all this get out of the car at the same time turning the wheel of course, and it will be turned
The real problem in all of those games that some small stuff can go completely unnoticed. Like a carwash in mafia II, if there was a mission to take a car there and get back to your boss that would be awesome. In mafia 2 you go straight to shooting, no stuff like "wash your boss' car, and drink a coffee nearby while it is being washed". Or cut a tire to make a gut walk out of the car to capture him.
Most close to it was GTA IV, though I never knew of combos in-game till I read on Wikipedia, in-game guide would be very cool. GTA IV is the best GTA considering the story and the world, but, oh no, kids cried that there were no helicopters and jetpacks, so we have what we have in GTA5.
Mafia 2 was a rushed game, most missions, features and locations were cut entirely or used in DLC.
@@demon8062 All because greedy Take Two wanted fast money, instead of letting 2k Czech do their job.
@@danwordgod2017 indeed
Bro i got interested about gta iv and v but since then i FORGOT MAFIA III AND II exist even tho i know them for a long time🤦🏻♀️🤦🏻♀️🤦🏻♀️
*12*
Ok kid
I have played all of theae but mafia 2 now I have to get that to complete the perfect game collection
In mafia 3 while driving a car some sound is coming like dentist is using drill over teeth
8:06 Russian sound
Хуяша саунд
Раша параша
36 вкусов сисек
You can get speeding ticket in Mafia 2
even mafia 1(the city of lost heaven)
@@huseyinuguralacatli5064 yes indeed
You forgot the best part, bribing the cop lol.
This is why I love Mafia 2. Hate Mafia 3.
Same with GTA. Love some stuff in GTA 4 which I hate in GTA 5.
If you crash your car too much in mafia 2 you can repair it by walking to your hood
Mafia's devs are also in Take 2's ownership like Rockstar games , nice
Wow like
Mafia 2 is the best than all
THATS CORRECT
ITS SOO EMOTIONAL GAME
Johnny is in the newspaper 0:40
I think you hold the car exit botton at 8:04 coz you have option to turn off the car and leave it on
Mafia 2 best game eve......
Best story, verry good graphic..& gamepla...
Lowend pc full Regulation 100%
Till GTA IV, GTA V and RDR2 completely beated it
@@kangration8626 Not GTA V tho.
Mafia 2 had best story
thats true
hey, how did u get that much money in mafia 3. can u tell me the method?
Gta 4 with ultimate textures look seriously gorgeous and on top of that that gameplay, makes it best gta. My opinion.
Aye dude with GTA games yes.. But in mafia II it's more realistic with vehicles.. You have to break the car's lock before you access.. Once you access, you can get in the car easily without breaking the lock again.. That's more realistic bro.. I've also played every games in GTA series but this game is far ahead from GTA games.. But Mafia III ruined the series completely 😒
gta 4 is father of all open world games
Mafia 1 is grandfather
Lol, you speak as if there wasn't open world games before it.
@@erikoo4715 GTA III send his regards.
True mafia is good game but GTA is another level
GTA V, Mafia II, Mafia III: “We all have unique features, all of us... what about you?”
GTA IV: *”......I can pick up objects... it’s pretty cool...”*
In short, IV will pick up V, Mafia II and III and just throw it in the water ;)
Gta sa and Gta 5 story + Gta 4 and mafia 1,2 physics and detail + Gta vc map + rdr graphics= best game of the century