StarTalk Podcast: Neil deGrasse Tyson on Avengers: Endgame
Vložit
- čas přidán 1. 06. 2024
- Screen Rant made a video that features Neil's thoughts on Captain Marvel in Avengers: Endgame. Watch it here - • Why Captain Marvel Mad...
Avengers, assemble! On this episode of StarTalk, Neil deGrasse Tyson and Chuck Nice answer fan questions about Marvel’s latest film, Avengers: Endgame. Rae Wynn-Grant, PhD, conservation scientist and National Geographic Society fellow, joins to talk about the ecological impact of Thanos’ snap. There will be plenty of spoilers - so don’t listen to this until you watch the movie! You have been warned.
What effect would Thanos’ snap have on Earth’s ecosystem? How does Endgame's time travel compare to Back To The Future? What’s up with Captain Marvel in the movie? What is a Möbius strip? All that and more… tune in and enjoy!
Support us on Patreon: / startalkradio
Subscribe to StarTalk: czcams.com/users/startalk...
Follow StarTalk:
Twitter: / startalkradio
Facebook: / startalk
Instagram: / startalkradio
About StarTalk:
Science meets pop culture on StarTalk! Astrophysicist & Hayden Planetarium director Neil deGrasse Tyson, his comic co-hosts, guest celebrities & scientists discuss astronomy, physics, and everything else about life in the universe. Keep Looking Up!
#Avengers #Marvel #CaptainMarvel - Věda a technologie
![Eminem - Houdini [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/22tVWwmTie8/mqdefault.jpg)
Great episode as always! Thanks so much for collaborating on our video Why Captain Marvel Should Have Dominated Avengers: Endgame! czcams.com/video/iUJ4qcdvQb0/video.html
I want to learn your time traveling abilities
Screen Rant The problem is in the MCU Quantum Entanglement isn’t apart of her powers and it isn’t official.
Like there’s some issues, It’s debatable if she is even stronger than Thanos if you don’t go off random science that isn’t officially used for the character and never were apart of her powers.
If you go off feats, scaling, lore, and such it’s a close fight but she isn’t FAR stronger that’s factually wrong.
Captain Marvel’s Powers came from the Space Stone vía the Light Speed Engine which is why she can go faster than light even her Photon blasts are light speed, the reason she was overpowering Thanos is more likely to do with the fact she can absorb energy and her powers came from the Space Stone canonical which made it so she could hold Thanos down and take a headbutt since before he could grab her and throw her aside, not to mention this is after Thanos fought Iron Man, Thor, Worthy Cap, And Scarlet Witch who damaged him, broke his armor, and knocked away his sword so he wasn’t at his best.
But she would still be very even with him and could possibly overpower him especially if she can Amp herself by absorbing energy.
Yet honestly Scarlet Witch was more impressive, with her powers she can destroy the Mind Stone and she can completely overpower Thanos breaking his sword and armor almost killing him. She just isn’t physically stronger or more durable.
Just had to point some stuff out from a scaling and feats view which is more concrete than using science which wasn’t used in the movies and isn’t apart of her powers.
@Adeel ahsen slow your roll buddy. I don't like feminazi neither, but that isn't propaganda. Read the comics
The globe, space, evolution, aliens, dinosaurs and the entire heliocentric model are all lies.
Adeel ahsen Well in the comics there’s sjw shit too especially around 2015+ when the shit really got crazy lol
Neil’s true gift is not his intelligence and knowledge but his ability to explain it to the less educated.
yeah he is a great teacher
"If you cannot put it simply, you do not understand it well enough"
Except he doesn’t know what he’s talking about
Can he explain his four sexual assault accusations to me
@@stephenrothrock9731 Have they been proven in court of law?
But what made Thor believable is when Thor loosely said, “Your Magic is our science that for you is not yet understood”.
Gearie Bowman True. Additionally, Thor is not one of these perfectly incorruptible gods (ahem Wonder Woman); he has grown immensely across his character arc. He lives with losing his powers, earns them back, handles loss in an imperfect way (retrieves his hammer from an alternate timeline), and has his shortcomings (Thor Lebowski).
@Matthew Woods
So true on WW!
That's just lazy writing though.
@@mob_abominator1868 It isn't though, not everything has to be explained in detail.
Also, Thor could be killed. He wasn't eternal. He loses his eye as well.
The most accurate was Thor when he said:
"All words are made up."
Nivadellier
I love that line.
😂
Did Neil just explains quantum tunneling without any visual aid and still make it easy to understand?
That's like peak education there
His real superpower is his ability to dumb things down for us mere mortals
The fact that Neil is talking about ENDGAME! That's enough for me!
Wasn’t he in one of the avengers?
yeah for me too👍🏻
Lol Yup!
Was watching something else this was in my recommended. I forgot what ibwas watching.
@@sithlordbeerus503 Batman v superman
Never realized " I am Groot" was such a deep quote.
pfffff
I am Groot ¯\_(シ)_/¯
with a deep realization behind it
The time machine in endgame sends you back in time, creating a different timeline but it returns you to your own original timeline, and not the future of the timeline you created. That's why you can interact with yourself without causing a paradox.
But Captain America went back in time to his own timeline at the end of Endgame. Because he never turned back like you said.
@@tasarasforever In my opinion, that could have been a parallel, close to the same, but not quite the same, Captain America from a different, very similar, timeline.
If Neil was my science teacher, I would've loved my science classes even more and maybe pursue a different career path.
If you were my gf, i would never let you go
After watching every video, I think the same thing. Science is genuinely fun, but our professors could not do pop culture reference.
@@johnrog4775 kiss?
The fact you're watching this probably means your teacher was quite good
@@A.jmmmm04 lol
45:10 Gravity generator was actually referenced in the first Guardians movie. They used it to escape prison.
Omg, I read this the moment they spoke about it 🤣
True
"The strongest metal on earth and the humans make a frisbee"
interesting little fact: Vibranium is NOT the strongest metal earth. it may very well be the most "powerful" in terms of practical applications (as we've seen in Black Panther - the stuff is in everything they use from clothes to eating utensils) But there is one metal that is far more durable AND "physically" resistant. I believe the reason it's never been mentioned is due to Marvel Not owning the rights to X Men until now. Can y'all guess what metal I'm talking about?? Yep Adamantium. Adamntium is far heavier and denser than Vibranium and in the origins of Captain America ( the true comic origins) his shield is truly unique because it is the ONLY ONE of it's kind. an alloy of Vibranium AND Adamantium. So it has the properties of absorbing kinetic energy and the added bonus of beinf far more durable than ANY other object made from Vibranium. Fun Fact: if Cap's shield had been Adamantium, Thanos would NOT have been able to tear it apart.
Typical of humans
@@pattheman3686 I thought they already cleared that adamantium is an alloy
@@pattheman3686 Actually, considering how it acted, it's quite probable that Thanos' blade was a Vibranium-Adamantium alloy, and thus would have been able to destroy an Adamantium shield
@@jemal999 That "could" be a possibility; we KNOW that Vibranium is not native to Earth, but so far no mention has been made of Adamantium "EXCEPT" in X Men Origins, but I do NOT count that as MCU official history. Besides in Origins They nd up going to Africa for the Adamantium; which is where the Vibranium meteor hit. But then there ARE metals in the cosmos that are just as strong, if not stronger than both Adamantium and Vibranium. Uru for example is stronger by the very fact that it's made from Dwarf Star material, which is Extremely heavy a simple house key made from Uru can weight up to hundreds of pounds. So in effect Mjiolnyr wasn't just unmovable because of the enchantment Odin paced on it, but it was heavy because it was made from Pure Uru metal.
Bruce Banner was what is known in Marvel Comics as a "mutate". In short, he had a genetic propensity to respond to the gamma radiation bombardment in a way which unlocked latent powers rather than killing him. It is similar to how Peter Parker got powers from the radioactive spider, which a radioactive spider bite is not known to confer such properties in the real world. There's a whole backstory for prehistoric Earth which explains why some people are prone to having these kinds of power awakening.
To just have a conversation with Neil would be the most interesting and educational thing I can think of doing
"Einstein is Einstein"
Dr. Tyson is also a detective trained by Batman and Sherlock Holmes.
If Rob from ComicsExplained was here he couldve filled in gaps of what happened in movies vs the comics and the reasoning why something happened
Minutes
That would be a great crossover for Rob to be in this conversation.
Yes, we need this. Also Robcorp represent.
He is Robert
He is a cop
He is RobertCop.
Minutes if they did a sit down like this with Rob and Dr. Tyson, it would be the greatest video (maybe) on all of CZcams!
Rob woul
51 minutes well spent. Never left the episode from start to finish. Thank you such a very informative episode.
I love how in the first question he basically kind of explains some of the concepts that were talked about in loki
In the first Gaurdians film, they established that artificial gravity is a technology that exists, and the spacecraft were using this tech!
Back To The Future had one major error. They had a Gibson guitar from 1957 in a film taking place in 1955.
@Cancel Ok I'm pretty sure she says "Rodent" not "Ronan".
I think a two year anachronism is pretty unnoticeable to anyone but the most die hard guitar collectors out there. The 1955 model can't be that much different can it?
@Cancel Ok She says: "Rodent we are ready for you plan." There is a "T" sound at the end of the first word. Rodent and Ronan could be easily confused for each other if said fast enough.
Or did they? Maybe another time traveler from the future brought back a guitar?
And also - Chuck Berry didn't hear the intro riff that Marty played - he just heard the usual 12-bar blues progression that was already common in his milieu, so how did he compose Johnny B. Goode with that jump intro?
27:30 🎁
I’m slightly happier because Neil exists today 😌
His explanation of quantum teleportation in its simplest form is amazing.
It's like Marvel hired him to explain the actually in their work!
I'm starting to think that this guy works for the MCU!😅
You love Black Widow because marital arts? Very smooth mister Tyson veryyy smooth.. :)
@nikhil nair You spelled "spelled" wrong.
@nikhil nair You’re wrong about so many things.
1. I’m Canadian.
2. I knew you spelled “spelt” correctly.
Okay, so you’re only wrong about two things, and the second thing is probably because I forgot to put a smiley after my stupid comment.
Don’t think that I’m going to apologize for any of this. Just because I’m one of those polite Canadians doesn’t mean I’m sorry … so … yeah, sorry about that.
cheers
‘Black Widow’ serial killers are typically women known for killings multiple husbands.
Deadly ‘marital’ arts
@nikhil nair Hah! We totally would! … er, shit … sorry about that.
Recursive Apologetic Impulse Disorder is a real thing in Moosejaw, Saskatoon, several locations in Hamilton, and pretty much anywhere else in Canada that sounds so much better than it could ever (EVER) actually be - uh huh, I'm looking at you, Winnipeg! Get rid of the polar bears, you're farther south than Calgary!
@nikhil nair "people like you" … whoa! People like me?
You're the one intentionally using non-American spelling, grammar, and diction all while simultaneously assuming your audience is American unless otherwise further clarified. In my neighbourhood of Canada (heh!) that sort of thing would be generally considered a "dick move"!
Shit, I should have started with that argument.
You can't be Indian AND Asian, if that were possible I'm pretty sure the UN would just be a cricket league by now, all highway off ramps would have drift lanes, and white people like me would be your slaves!! (honestly, if this happens, someone should really re-use that #timesup hashtag)
That wasn't my white guilt talking, it was the white guilt of the rest of you simply incriminating me with the group. 😂
Sometimes I think life would be easier if I was actually as dumb as some of the shit I say online. 😈
I laughed at “three of them were named Chris!”
This is honestly one of the best podcast episodes I’ve ever seen.
22:49, when Neil said there is a part of the movie where they say the absence of humans made the air and rivers cleaner.
reminds me of absence of people during lockdowns during the pandemic
Yea sure i watched Black Widow because of her "martial arts" too. Yea yea yea totally relatable.
lol.....sure fam....lol
wow, what nunchuks.
BadS we say that cause we’re married lol 🤫
BadS 😂
simp
"That thing (the shield) doesn't obey the laws physics at all."
Spider-Man (in Captain America : Civil War)
Captain America: **nods in agreement**
There’s a lot of things going on that you don’t understand.
Neil doesn't remember cap has missed before and it didn't hit nothing...but still came back. Spiderman>NDT
Captain America was only gone (from his time line) for 5 seconds.
Nothing changes in his original time line except that he now has come back as an old man after 5 seconds.
That's why he gives his shield to his buddies to do the captain America job.
Neil's comment about timeline aged well for Loki season 1
for reals! it just makes you think how much does marvel studious actually think about the way they do stuff
@@spicydubu none at all anymore, apparently. They just want to have everything, not caring at all if it makes sense in accordance with the other movies
32:35 when Neil cracks up laughing at Chuck’s jokes, I feel like the world is a better place 🥳
38:21 this one was my favorite lol
The rare times it happens. Chuck belongs in the 90’s. His part painful to watch
Then you open Twitter...and cry.
And there we go, Neil has increased happiness without use of the Infinity Gauntlet. 😁
Then Neil's wish to make the world a happier place is working.
I appreciate that you lead into your breaks like they do on TV. It's less jarring that just letting the ad interrupt
This a video recording of a radio show that has commercials. CZcams has an algorithm that recognizes points in a video where ads can be placed so when he stops the conversation flow for where there was a commercial on the radio show the algorithm places an ad. It's probably based on the same algorithm when CDs were still fairly new. Back then you could record an entire concert as one mp3 file and most CD burning programs could break it up into tracks based on a lull in the music or a beat change. The problem with ads in most videos is the video doesn't have a big enough lull for the algorithm to find so it uses the length of the video. The flaw in the old algorithm was if a song had a beat break the program inserted a track change that you would have manually remove before you burned the cd and it's probably the same issue that you run across on CZcams where a thirty minute video has fifteen ads because it had fifteen lulls and no one manually remove the extra ads
😂
@@DTG_LOCKETT youtubers can manually place add breaks on there videos. Its pretty likely that whoever manages this channel for them just put in the time to place the adds there.
I literally had to watch the entire series of Marvel movies all the way through to Endgame, just to watch this video. Thanks, guys.
After watching this and listening to Neil talking about Endgame,the fact he's 62 makes me feel not so bad about watching and enjoying this and the other marvel movies, at 56 I'd always thought myself maybe too old,that they were a guilty pleasure.
27:30 "I try to make sure there's somebody out there that's slightly happier because I exist in this world today." - Neil DeGrasse Tyson That's my new favorite quote.
Its very weird that I came across this comment while strolling through the comments when I was exactly at this point in the video 😳
When Captain America interacts with himself, the latter thinks he is Loki transformed into him, so it's OK.
Plus cap goes back and undos all the timelines they created
Sahil Dalvi yeah, just cause they say that’s how time travel would work that doesn’t mean in theory it would work, by going back theyve already made branches, when he goes back again there are some more branches,
As soon as they interacted with that world, it already got branched off and also they stated that going back in time doesn’t change what has already happened, so as he’s went back in time to fix the problems, that still doesn’t fix the branched off time lines as ‘fixing’ something cannot work as they’ve stated that going back does not change the future, so as them futures are already in affect as they’ve changed it, they cannot be undone
The future where Loki escapes with the stone, the future where Tony talks with his dad in the past, every action would change something, it would just create more branches. Unless they don’t want to use the butterfly effect to which with regards to time travel is impossible as simply going back changes things straight away, even from the hulk smashing the taxi up, that would then branch things off as things change
@@craigo5030 exactly the very presence in other time leads to another branch.
PARADOX EXACTLY... I don’t understand why nobody realises that! If I were to go back in time to a younger me, take my game console and have a conversation with my dad, that’s created a future where I have no games console and my dad has talked to someone when he would originally be doing something else, even if it’s by the second, it still counts...
Now if a second later it got put back there would still be a future where it branched off that I didn’t have one and my dad spoke to me
@@craigo5030 Even after breaking so many rules avengers still lost by 1 to 14,000,605 😂
One of me favorite episodes, awesome job guys!!!!
"They also have unobtanium, from Avatar".
The Core: "AM I JOKE TO YOU"?
The scientist there said the name of the element had like 13 syllables so to make it easy they just call it unubtanium ao technically the word is in the movie but it is nit the ifficial name of the element
Hold on now. The captain america who stayed in the past ALREADY did all that saving from the previous stories. So during those events, there was captain america doing all the saving, and another captain america living out his life with his girl.
So everything that he did previously was still done.
Yea but his girl would have done all different things that impact the other captain
@@mailmarca Wrong. The girl did exactly what she did in the previous movies. Keep in mind, during the previous movies, there was already a second Captain America living with her.
As the former director of shield, she would have known the importance of, and been perfectly capable of making sure the younger Cap didn't know about his older counterpart. Hell, they probably had many discussions about what to do if/when younger Cap shows up.
@@KurNorock exactly what i was about to say. love Neil, but he really needs Endgame explained to him before he talks about plot elements that might be confusing to him and to other casual MCU fans.
🤯
I think going back in time let him do all the things the comic book version of him did, from WW2 to the day that his younger version was defrosted, and then he either retires, or helps Young Cap until he's ready to meet up with Falcon to pass on the shield.
FYI in the MCU, Titan is a fictional planet in a fictional solar system. It's not the Moon of Saturn (unlike the comics).
that’s true otherwise it would have only taken 73 min to reach Earth from Saturn traveling at the speed of light
@@Hikingalliance although, it doesn't really matter since it looked like Benatar couldn't do space jumps (as was shown later in the movie, when the gang jumped to Gardens-planet, or before in any vol. of Gurdians)
And yet again that reminds us about Quill's stupidity. They ran out of fuel, how's that possible? What was he thinking about routing for Titan? That they could fill up tanks there?
Andrew Vanelli you have to love Quill though he is funny Af
@@andrewvanelli5317 it's possible that the ship was damaged in the battle and they lost their fuel reserves. Or maybe it's fairly common/easy to refuel on a planet like Titan (perhaps by siphoning fuel from another spacecraft) - we simply don't know the answer as to whether Quill knowingly went to Titan without enough fuel to leave.
Dr.Tyson: Why do I need anyone else when I have Captain Marvel
Wanda Maximoff (post Wandavision): Hold my beer
also marvel stating that she could've killed thanos by herself
Nah
I like to go with one of the comic explanations for Cap's shield. Cap is such a master strategist that he is able to calculate the angle and force needed to get his shield where he wants it. This is also why he is such a natural leader, capable of immediately coming up with a plan and dishing out orders.
Just quick fact, the shoutout of gravity generators came way back in Guardians 1, in the Klin prison. 45:21
Very nice, well spotted.
Now explain why every habited planet in the galaxy has the same gravity? So why did the gravity generator seem to be set to exactly 1G of Earth gravity?
Guess there is a Goldilocks zone for habitable planets of mass vs rotational speed vs atmosphere density vs other solar system bodies and their gravity. And we on earth thought it was all about liquid water and atmospheric oxygen.
9 months later, I came and didn't expect to watch the entire video. But I did.
Awesome video!
Just an FYI Unobtanium as a metal was mentioned long before Avatar. If you watch the 2003 movie The Core, the vehicle they use to navigate to the core is made of what the character Brass calls Unobtanium. Check it out.
Having Mr Tyson as your Dad or Uncle, must be very cool. He's a cool Dad/Uncle
49:40 is the deepest thing I've ever heard. Everyone should respect Groot
"I love watching Black Widow"
Me: same
"Cause who doesn't love watching martial arts"
Me: .... wait wat
Exactly, Martial Arts is not on my mind when it comes to black widow/Scarlett Johansson
Unless you consider the things that I wanna do to her Martial Arts😂😂😂
I just heard that part and paused to look for the comment that said this...didn't have to look for very long and that makes me happy
Martial arts, yyyeeesss, that is absolutely why I like watching Black widow, really, no other reason AT ALL, definitely. Just the great.... martial arts, yup, that's it.
I came to the comments specifically to post this comment LOL! I never realized she even did martial arts till just now...
😏😏
Simply put. I LOVE THIS :) Please do many more.
Best wishes and thank you.
True
Thank you as always. Very cool to listen to and think about.
I hope you end up watching the Expanse TV series. I would love to hear your thoughts on how they portray the science behind a lot of what's going on in the series.
Thank you
World breaker Hulk and professor Hulk are different versions of the Hulk😂
NewGodFlow89 exactly they take bits of story’s of comics to movie
This is what happens when Neil tries to do this
NewGodFlow89 facts I’m cringing at them get all the basics wrong😂
Right?! Ragnarok was more of the planet hulk story line, but yeah. Also a bit of Gorr the God Butcher.
They did not anything of the Worldbreaker Hulk story. They just had him as a Gladiator. The WBH story was MUCH more than a few minutes of Thor Ragnarok.
"3 of them was named Chris, whats up with that?"
Well, one Chris is funny, one Chris is handsome, one Chris is charming.
Together they form the chrisforce capable of swooning any lady
The chris stones
They will make a CCU (Chris Cinematic Universe)
Well, all three are funny,handsome and charming
@@worsethanyouthink And more than a few men.
Would removing “Hatred” instead of increasing “Happiness” work out better?
Idk.
This is nice too.
No...well it would work out if you're willing to become a single minded robot along with everyone else.
One of my favs out of many!! Great job guys. ✌🏼🤙🏼👍🏼😎💯😍👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
I don't think the Titan Tony and Nebula were returning from was supposed to be the Saturn's moon one, was it? I was under the impression it was across the galaxy somewhere and just shared the name
No it’s not Titan in the solar system.
Yeah titan had moons. So it was a planet. Thanos threw one at Tony
Backstory is that when Thanos was created in comics - his planet was originally the moon off of Saturn, but that has long since been retconned. This Titan is just a planet, which may or may not even be in this galaxy.
Correct. Titan is a planet elsewhere in the universe.. Not Titan the moon ..
It should have been named "tightened".😅
2:52 Neil DeGrasse Tyson : "And I love watching Black Widow, who doesn't love some good.....martial arts" hahahaha Genius
I could think of some Martial Arts I'd like to try with black widow
I enjoyed this commentary on theoretical time travel. The Pim Particles that deal in quantum mechanics leaves the scientific plausibility to time manipulation, but leaves a lot of questions which I heard Neil briefly address about dimensional paradigms and butterfly effects.
Inspirational thanks. I love listening to your books as u read them yourself.
Really loved the way Rae explained the science. So cheerful and clear with her explanations. Hope to see more of her in future episodes. Just a wonderful personality.
Plus she is HOT
Id love to have a chat with Mr Tyson. You could be 100% sure that no matter what you'd say the conversation would still be amazingly interesting. Amazing human being.
Doctor, NDT has a Phd in Astrophysics
Chuck's Doc Brown impression is perfect.
I thought so as well. Lol
Thank you so much for this video , for enlightening us , for humoring all us fan boys & all the science nerds & most of all for having that super-hot guest scientist Dr. Rey on this episode !!! You guys should have her on more often !!! Thanks again , love you !!!
Neil: marvel movies are based on science.
Doctor strange : am i a joke to you?
Actually according to the MCU What Doctor Strange mastered is the quick rewriting of psysical equations.
@@toniodotcom and according to Thor and asgardians magic is just another form of science that humans have yet to understand
Point is that marvel for the most part tries to incorporate more science than D.C lol. Simply compare the justice league to the avengers character's and you'll see that with the exception of batman the D.C universe has so many things so far from reality it makes marvel heroes look pretty grounded when it comes to powers.
@@h3llboyyy407 I think that's cause most of marvel is based on our actual world alot of the names in marvel are stuff that actually exist but don't do as crazy stuff
"That thing (the shield) doesn't obey the laws physics at all."
Spider-Man (in Captain America : Civil War)
Around 50 minutes long video of scientists talking about science, yet most of the comments are basically "you got the fictional 'facts' wrong!".
One of them isn't a scientist, but what's your point?
@@Anti-HyperLink wow, you didn't get the point? *facepalm
I mean they're talking about how accurate the fictional facts are so yes, it's kind of important that they have those facts straight before comparing them to real life.
Yeah in a different episode they said how interact with past events would become your future and your future can't change your past and he did that it created an alternate timeline where what happened in the past happened differently
Lol
One important point to mention would be, there are different series for many of the characters, and they are written by different writers. Like how any other sentient lifeform would consider us the same. They also explain A LOT more in the comics than in the movies. It's been simplified(too much?). Interesting point to note, DC also has a crossover series that came out in 1994 on paperback.
Hope you can react to the physics and chemistry in Dr. Stone!
I think Neil de Gresse Tyson would love Cowboy Bebop
The "oops I tripped! I should have tunneled to the van" killed me
This was actually as interesting and entertaining as the movie itself 😁👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👌🏻this two are the best 😄👌🏻
Great episode. My favorite scientist talking about my favorite move. Lots o love to both Neil and Chuck. :)
They : Thanos is right
Also they : Thanos is idiot
lmao yeah
He's correct, but he went about it wrong.
you can be an idiot and right at the same time tho. for example, you are right that today is raining and you are an idiot because you don't bring an umbrella knowing it is raining today.
It's the methods, not the result, that ended up as the problem. Thanos' end goal would have positive effects, but at the cost of exterminating half of all life. :)
Thanos is right, but Thanos' plan is idiotic. Look at how fast our population is growing, how effective will removing half really be in the long run?
Hawkeye is all geometry and physics. He may not be a genius like Tony but it takes skill for that level of bow accuracy. Ok, nerd hat off now...
Bless your heart! It pisses me off to have him talked down at all the time like this, as if almost perfect hand-eye coordination is a common talent to have.
Do you also called very talented gymnasts or the top people in their sport knowledgable in geometry or physics? Hell no, its called talent. Its all instinct. Computation is automatic, but doesnt mean they know geometrical equations.
@@missionpupa k
Thank you! People make fun of him as if shooting a bow and arrow is a piece of cake, but it takes years of training and slapping water to master it.
And most of the people who make fun of him are probably fat-asses who can barely move let alone use a bow.
Simple geometry.
Capt Marvel explains why we need more than just her. She tells the Avengers that she’s been helping lots of other planets who don’t have Avengers.
I'm happier knowing that you are with us. You are a hero and role model to me.
Hawkeye did state in "Captain America Civil War" that he tried to play golf. He played 18 holes and shot 18. "What's the point?" he said.
Man. I want to meet Neil at least once before I die. If only I had 1% of his genius.
The philosophical conversation ab happiness was fantastic. Agree w the 1st idea, love the question proposed ab how to create happiness, and respect the thought of needing sadness to appreciate it fully. Well done. And Thanos could have just created an infinite food source and well of unlimited resources I'm each country on every planet. He could literally change reality so.....yeah. but marvel did an absolutely AMAZING job with what they accomplished
This video was suggested to me today. At 18:00, something about their discussion became interesting because of the current covid context, and especially because of the carnivore theory they explained... i saw this movie for the first time in January 2020, and the story sat with me for weeks. By the Summer of 2020 i decided to become Vegan for a lot of reasons, mainly health reasons to survive the pandemic. This is an interesting discussion.
I wanted to see Cap return the Soul Stone, they missed an opportunity with that one. Him seeing Red Skull.
Who knows there might be a movie on it!! 😀
I want to see an entire movie of Cap returning all the stones, including the Soul Stone...which would also make me curious how this would effect all the various timelines (to include the potential revival of Gamora and Black Widow). The lists and possibilities are endless.
William Randolph there is no coming back from the Soul Stone, technically that’s the only stone he doesn’t have to return. I think it just regenerates every time someone dies.
Really don't know what they would've done though just have a convo?
One of the 'LOKI' episodes is supposed to follow cap shortly during his mission to return the stones.
Thank you guys for doing this show. It is helping my younger brother catch up on his science concepts understanding.
You guys should do another one of these with a diff movie !!!! Every week or month pick a sci-fi movie of some kind and answer some questions pertaining to the true or false science involved
Keep up the awesome job you two !!!
Love re watching star talk vids
Because the 2012 Captain America thought present day Cap was Loki🤷🏾♂️
James Osborne exactly
And he erased his mind with Lokis staff.. Everyone seems to forget that part
Exactly! 2012 Cap had no idea it was himself. Also, when he goes back to live with Peggy Carter, Frozen Cap is still frozen and becomes unfrozen in 2011, and as long as Future Cap never gets involves and tells everyone he's back (which he wouldn't), then nothing changes the Past Cap from saving people like he originally did.
David Meade then past cap should've been near that bench where future cap sits if he did not alter that timeline, and he would be with falcon and winter soldier too
But he still interact with himself, that's the point. He doesn't matter Cap believed it was an impostor using his identity, they freaking interact
I always assumed Titan in the comics was not Saturn's Titan...
The comics Titan was the moon of Saturn actually, the films made it it's own planet not related to Saturn.
@@alexanderthegreat5649 I didn't get that.
At the time that Jim Starling wrote the original stories, the idea that Saturn's moon was so Earth-like was very much part of popular culture. All the nerds were very excited about this, so Starling capitalized on that. Remember these guys weren't trying to build a legacy at the time. They were just trying to write stories that would be impelling to their audiences at the time.
It is not Saturns moon, just because it`s called Titan, it doesn`t mean it`s our Titan.
@@NorB0316 it is in the comics but as for the MCU you're right...but to be fair there's no reason why it couldn't be because titan is desolate probably far before humanity had the technology to know that
At about 12:53, Neil mentions the fictional element "unobtainium" as being from the movie Avatar. However, I was mildly disappointed that he didn't mention that unobtainium appeared first in the movie The Core. (By the way, unobtainium is an old in-joke in engineering school that refers to a material that has properties that are far beyond those of any known material, such as being an infinite heat-sink or a perfect insulator or having zero electrical resistance at room temperature.)
Love this!! Love the Marvel movies, do all you can with Marvel concepts please!
39:17 WOW. Getting so trippy - if you see space from a different perspective, it will change who you are.
I've just found the star talk.
I remained without words when i was scrolling the youtube's bar and i saw that.
I'll listen the podcast on spotify when i 'll drive to reach the work or somewhere else.
Glad to listen things concern about the space and the physics.
This video actually induced me to rewatch the whole movie. Thanks to neil.
Same😀😀
When discussing the effects of the “Great Blip,” I was interested in hearing more about how the disappearance of 50% of species would affect genetic variation? What genetic characteristics would likely emerge in certain species? With more resources and less competition (for resources and mates) how would this impact genetic diversity?
It would have no effect on genetic variation. North- and South-America was settled with not more than 12 families creating all the native tribes. Something N.d.G.T. told in a talkshow with Colbert.
@@Teskal africans asians and Vikings was in the Americas
@@janiecekeys4765 I wrote about what happend before the europeans found this continent. The first humans who arrived america.
@@Teskal i as well, smh
The Artificial Gravitation was an Upgrade, they did in the "Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D".
The only Parts, they showed of that Technology was Gravitonium floating through a glass-pipe.
5 minutes and Chuck brings up World Breaker Hulk....My Man!!!!
And gets it wrong!
@@DapoOlasiyan and get everything completely wrong
@@DapoOlasiyan lmfao I was thinking the same thing
I know this is really old by now, but when Neil was talking about making people happy I couldn't stop thinking About Takuto Maruki, the main "antagonist" of Persona 5 Royal. Maybe Neil should read about that character, it really raises some heavy questions about existence, freedom and happiness.
Freaking LOVE these Q&A episodes, especially when they’re about my favorite nerdy fictional universe!!
No science in Hawkeye??!! You gotta know the crazy math that goes on in his head to be able to always hit a shot!!
I thought his power was "one shot" or "bull's eyes". No math involved. He just sees his target then he hits it, baring any obstacle that happens after his shot. He just likes the bow for the added challenge. With a sniper gun or even a plasma gun, he would just be too deadly.
@@DaxSassIt's well established in the MCU that he doesn't have "powers" so he has to do the math to nail a shot
@@vendettarules1 yes, that is his power, the crazy physic math that goes thru his mind to get the one perfect shot. He can calculate path, vector, velocity, acceleration, environmental obstacle and other stuffs in the blink of an eye. He just cant talk science or boil water for a living.
@@DaxSassI agree he does seem to have that ability passively and not something he actively is trying to do. i think the bow allows for a style and different ammo types like hacker attachements, mini bombs, and the like. Bullets are probably too boring and limiting for him. in civil war when he says "played 18, shot 18 just can't seem to miss" seems to me that implies it is not something he actively does through insane mental math skills but just something he is gifted with and comes naturally. He can't seem to miss anything unless interrupted mid shooting process. So I feel clint does actually have powers in a sense.
Simple geometry
He's confusing Professer Hulk with Worldbreaker Hulk. Endgame's Hulk is supposed to be Professer Hulk.
But ragnarok hulk is 'meant' to be world breaker
@@reedog1016 It is an allusion to worldbreaker hulk in ragnarok yes, but they were talking about endgame hulk as worldbreaker hulk and endgame hulk is professor hulk.
@@DarkCurow no they werent.. they said that they pulled from the story of world breaker Hulk in Ragnarok and in the comics soon after the series of world breaker Hulk comes the professor Hulk series and all he meant was in Ragnarok they portrayed story of world breaker Hulk and an endgame they followed up with Professor Hulk just similar to the comics
@@3rdfloor751 Except he didnt even mention Professor Hulk.
@@DarkCurow he said smart Hulk and for those that are into the comics knows that he meant Professor Hulk. Actually he said brulk because he didn't know the correct term
The Infinity Gauntlet actually makes it so you can do anything anyone can conceive of. The Mind Stone allows the user to read and control every mind in the universe. 👀
29:42 Chuck : Thanos goal to help u all
well technically he is,i mean he try to delay the birth of celestial
Man these science chanells of youtube nowdays ... i wish i could have my memories erased so i could watch it all over again and be amazed and mesmerized as the first time!
My interest in science is skyrocketing because of you all.
Thank you
Got to love NDT. I could listen to this man all day.
He couldn’t because it would have took to much energy to create than to destroy… I love these guys
Its the infinity gauntlet we are talking about,,, the most powerful instrument in the entire universe and multiverse. There wouldn't be any difficulty in it doing anything, whether creating or destroying. Ibelieve it would all be the same.