Amber Heard lawyer claims expert is biased because she had dinner with Depp once
Vložit
- čas přidán 24. 05. 2022
- Amber Heard's attorneys questioned Johnny Depp's expert Dr. Shannon Curry about a dinner she had with Depp and his legal team before the trial. Heard's attorneys have tried to show Curry is biased towards Depp and was not qualified to make the opinions that she made in the case.
Subscribe to LiveNOW from FOX! czcams.com/users/livenowfox?su...
Where to watch LiveNOW from FOX: www.livenowfox.com/
Follow us @LiveNOWFOX on Twitter: / livenowfox
Raw and unfiltered. Watch a non-stop stream of breaking news, live events and stories across the nation. Limited commentary. No opinion. Experience LiveNOW from FOX.
Trying to beat a psychologist in their own field is kind of a terrible strategy.
Yet the best they got.
We'll let that speak for itself.
funny TOO.
Trying to do it twice is even more terrible.
Agreed especially when they are well spoken and intelligent.
I agree. A psychologist knows how to use dark psychology and reverse psychology. Psychologists are always analyzing what people are saying to them. So, yes, you are absolutely right.
It's fascinating how the most unlikeable person in the world would hire the most unlikeable lawyer in the world.
birds of the same feather hang together
@@Bg-Daisy *turds
oh yeah, and don't forget the rest of her all-star unlikable team:
'Dr' Hughes and her 'men are always the abusers' argument
Dr Spiegel and his 'remote' psychiatric evaluation based on JD's behavior in pirates and his risk factors
The irrelevant physician who somehow could affirm with certainty that JD's injury was definitely not caused by a bottle
The 'agent' doing damages calculation for AH comparing her to Gal Gadot and Jason Momoa that didn't know the names of 99% of hollywood actors
The guy counting hashtags in Twitter
Oh, and let's not forget the amazing Mr Rottenburger and his self objections
Exactly!!!!!😭
i mean, it's not her lawyer fault that this case is impossible to defend. she get paid by amber heard to be her lawyer. she would take every possible way for her client to win the case. including hiring maybe "biased" witnesses. that's why cross examination is required as bringing biased witness like this is pretty common in court room. i fully blaming amber at this point as her lawyer just do what a lawyers do.
As a lawyer, when the truth is NOT on your side...this is the only line of questioning you have.
I think without Amber being Amber and her terrible cross exam fiasco they could have gone with a much better result. Overall the defense did a good job transforming this case into a circus. but Amber cross exam, and her attitude overall did the job for Depp's team
@@Jean-jw4hw You can’t polish a poop. - mythbusters
I know attorneys are supposed to poke holes in witness credibility, but this was grasping at straws.
oh really?
how about the gay guy at the trailer that was tweeting about Amber and cursing at Elon Musk he was falsley testifying how come he was a credible witness to JD team?
@@christophercolumbus8944 what does that have to do with my comment? No, seriously, what possible relevance was that? First of all, I was specifically referring to THIS WITNESS. This witness was being bombarded with questions about eating fast food with the legal team as though that somehow takes away from her credibility. The attorney also kept asking how much she was getting paid even though the witness said “I don’t know” every single time. So…yeah. Secondly, I need a link or something because I don’t know who you’re talking about- what does the guy’s sexuality even have to do with anything anyway?
@@ShatnerLover they all do that
they all ask how much they're getting paid it's very relevant they also asked the surgeon who testified johnny didn't cut off his finger with the bottle
but this broad is clearly lying
she is clearly intimate with the JD team and somehow she forgets how much money she has pockets thus far?
probably $300000 by the end of the trial
i would lie too if i was offered that kind of money
@@christophercolumbus8944 you don’t know what you’re talking about.
@@ShatnerLover i just finished watching Dr Hughes testimony
the JD lawyer asked the same exact question "how much is your annual ..."income?" how much per testimony" he kept on persisting he put emphasis on the word "per testimony" so on and so forth
listen you peace f
if you're egoing to be judgemental don't be hypocritical
Her professionalism and demeanor has won the heart of millions. What a woman.
I can be str8 for her
Can’t F with this smart Dr who knows her stuff!
And her looks.
Speak for yourself. she doesn't know how much she is getting paid and not even approximately?? LIARRRR. She chats on a chat but nothing is reliable
@@IC24233 if you claim the ‘doesn’t know how much she is paid exaclty’ is a lie, you have to provide evidence for that. Can you?
The lawyer is worried about the witness wasting court time while the lawyer is wasting court time by asking questions that have previously been answered. 🤦♀️
Exactly
Well said.
Probably because they think they help their case and want the jury to hear again.
right !? they’re the ones who chewed through an entire day of their own time on ridiculous witnesses who did nothing but discredit their own side lol
Because she's trying to misdirect the jury, it's all team turd have left.
Elaine's attempts to discredit Dr. Curry for not "reporting" a zoom call or eating takeout during a 4 hour interview are quite disgusting.
rewatching this to remind myself why it's laughable that people feel sorry for Ambers lawyer crying in the womans bathroom after the trial. She's been so disrespectful I am glad the witnesses didn't back down once.
Did this happen, really? Damn how pathetic. May be the only law firm that needed the money despite the bad press.
Amber probably lied to her lawyers as well. Even though I think some of the questions seem comical, I really feel that the lawyer was just trying to do her job. It's not like the lawyer and Amber are friends. Amber will blame her lawyer for losing, because Amber is never going to admit that she's wrong. She would be the type of person, that would throw her lawyers under the bus. Her lawyers towards the end didn't seem like they were convinced that she was innocent. I think Amber has already lost.
To be fair, this kinda is her job. Since Dr Curry has a very strong testimony, it is on her as Amber's lawyer to imply she had a bias towards Mr Depp.
A scummy move, but one all lawyers do.
Knowing that she cried in the woman's bathroom does make me feel extremely bad for her. She might have been a bit nasty but she was also kind of given a shitty stick to work for. I feel like she's actually a good lawyer; there's just not much to be done when your client is AH. I sincerely hope for the best for AH's lawyer team because, at the end of the day, they're just trying to do their job. Giving them a hard time for struggling with this case is, honestly, like giving a cashier a hard time because their management makes them enforce bad rules. Its not the cashier's fault that the manager has hoops to jump through; its not really the lawyer's fault that their client was terrible.
I feel awful for her lawyers... I hate that their careers are also kind of battered now for having associated with AH.
@@otterlylost2029 But she also chose to make a statement after the trial further saying that she believed amber heard and that the verdict was a setback for women and victims of domestic abuse. Do you still feel as bad for her?
This woman is obsessed with trying to use food as a gotcha. First the muffins, now the dinner. Unbelievable. She's just making herself look bad. It's coming off as sad and rude at this point
I explain the reason....
Because she was not invited and she wanted to go to a dinner with JD let's be honest who doesn't want to 😅
It's probably Amber who is pushing the dinner like a date because she is jealous of this very professional and beautiful Michelle Pfeiffer looking lady Amber probably has all kinds of thoughts in her head about this woman being at Johnny Depp's house for that long even though they have already been divorced for awhile and it was only for professional reasons
"How dare they have food at anytime for any reason! Your honor this is an outrage!"
and Johnny's candy
Actually i feel sorry 4 them . They took a case for a lier and abuser.
This attorney is ridiculous. How dare someone have dinner at dinner time.
Conflict of interest. Would your doctor have a meal with you?
@@aimeej4045 she had a meal with his entire legal team. At Depp’s house because he is mega celebrity and is basically home bound. Again, she did not have dinner with Depp like you are trying to insinuate. She was having an interview over dinner time, so she and the whole team ate food toget
@@aimeej4045 She isn't JDs doctor lol!!
Yep she threw away her entire career for some noodles or sushi in take out containers. That checks out 🙄
I really died at this lmfaooo 🤣
People want to hate on this trial because it involves celebrities but this is representative of much greater issues that have nothing to do with being famous or not.
EXACTLY!!!! 🙌🙌🙌soo many of us have been involved or hurt by a narcissist or other hurtful people and so many have survived insidious violence, so we understand and finally people are seeing what we have gone through
Dr Curry's testimony is perfection. Elaine attacked her ethics and knowledge of the intricate datasets used to rule out PTSD especially in a patient faking PTSD. She proves Heard is a histrionic carrying two borderline personality disorders. I have such respect for Dr Curry's intellect and strong ethical professionalism. She's a beautiful role model for young women.
borderline personality disorder is a single disorder you can't have two of them
histrionic is histrionic personality disorder
both borderline personality disorder and histrionic personality disorder are cluster b personality disorders
just because someone has a cluster b personality disorder doesn't mean they're a bad person but also having a cluster b personality disorder does not excuse abusive behaviors including but not limited to the ones AH has exhibited
she is nothing but a w
$300000
how much did you make, sharon?
are you working at some convenience store at $20 an hour? she made $300000 conducting observation of some ex wife of some hollywood celebrity
she is not even board certified i might add
@@christophercolumbus8944 don’t lie Christopher she didn’t say she made that amount
@@marthaindiana she implied
and that's enough
still a lot
she doesn't know????????
She's straightforward, outspoken and totally unflinching...
Now I know the meaning of the quote, "it's easy when you're not lying."
and she's not going out of her way to overexplain things that really doesn't need an explanation for every single question.... like the other expert
That’s the very thing that’s been going through my mind.
Meanwhile, it’s quite difficult to behold such straw-grasping on the part of Ms Pettyhoff here… much less trying to comprehend how she sleeps at night…
Well said!
YES!!!
Damn right!!!!
She is the best, most unflappable, professional witness I've ever seen in my life, and every attempt to make her look bad, misinformed or biased just makes the lawyer look dumb. Love watching her testify.
She's good, but I think the lawyer managed to make it clear that she received a lot of money from Johnny Depp. It's hard to believe she has no idea how much she got paid by Johnny Depp. And answering "I don't know" when asked "200000?" implies that 200000 is plausible.
@@brinckau all the expert witnesses are paid including the lithe psychologist on Amber's side. The amount is irrelevant when the data is represented. Not to mention the clear bias of AH's psychologist. I'm not even a Depp fan but this is evident. If you have ever felt with anyone with narcissistic personality traits and Historionic personality disorder you can see that in AH's reactions to questions and he constant flip of "modes" from defensive to aggressive. I get it that she is stressed and in a trial but the extremes she reaches for are evident in her body language and verbiage.
@@r.palmer Yes. I don't know why you're talking to me about AH, but I agree. I was just saying that Dr Curry, as unflappable as she is, couldn't really avoid answering the question about how much she's been paid.
@@brinckau When you mention the money there's an insinuation there that she would breach her professional ethics, AND lie under oath in order to paint a negative picture of AH.
@@cheekypiper512 Yes, I know the lawyer wasn't asking out of curiosity, but to discredit the testimony.
I kind of respect the lawyer for willing to push boundaries of utter stupidity for this case. I mean, just imagine having to come to the decision with your team that you'd be discrediting someone on the grounds of having dinner for lack of anything better to nitpick on. It ought to suck at least a year's worth of life out of you.
Either that, or Elaine hates both takeout and muffins. But AH's team certainly did their best to influence the jury by any means or thread they could, its indeed been a good effort on their part.
If the psychologist was seeing depp or his ex professionally it goes against the psychology ethics guidelines to have dinner with clients because it promotes the spread of transference and countertransference
@@ericmiller9688 they were being interviewed, and that is standard procedure as said in the video. She said she was hungry and they ordered take out. Literally was just them eating while being interviewed and Johnny depp didn’t even say anything
@@ericmiller9688
She was being interviewed by depps legal team and dinner was served. Huge difference.
Lol!!
Watching Heard's lawyer is like watching an SNL skit.
I believe Elaine's annoying and aggressive nature is doing nothing but further damaging Amber's case.
I know huh
What case lol
And her own future reputation & career too
At this point I don't think Turds case could get any worse lol
I'm over her same stupid questions
I love how she's concerned with wasting the courts time, yet is asking all these questions a 2nd time
She was concerned about time because they wasted so much of their time putting those wackos like Dr. Spiegel on the stand 🙄
an the amount of time they take with finding evidence while in court..
I know! She asked exactly the same questions as the first time!
::deep breath:: "[She's] trying."
Elaine has obviously memory problems. I would never ever have any contact with such a disgusting lying unprofessional lawyer as she is. Waste of both money & time.
She has the brain of a genius, the temperament of a saint, and the face of an angel.
My favourite clip has to be 13:40
"Objection, hearsay"
"I haven't even asked the question yet"
"Well are you going to read her notes?" 😂😂😂
She is a class act and sooooo impressive. She doesn't get rattled despite Elaine trying to put words in her mouth. She has her facts straight.
Never play with a psy! Lol
They know more another the human nature!.👍😅
-I proved this case was over the first week on The Amber Heard Playlist!!
Amber could also take some lessons in hair style from the good Dr.
That’s because she understands human nature and behavior and she has control of her lizard brain that most don’t when in conversations like this- she’s able to think before she acts-
The Truth is always easy to remember than lies, The Lawyer messed with the wrong Witness, Big Mistake
The lawyer was borderline rude. But she wasn't borderline stupid; she manifested an excessive symptoms of stupidity
LOL
She was running out of time(defence time limit is at its end in this video) in a case where she needs to grasp at straws as she doesn’t have much of a case, while the world is watching. I think everyone can give her a break. She has to try and fight whatever the situation.
@@korvish111 We could, but she lectured the witness for wasting time after asking the same question three times knowing the answer, so we won't.
Borderline bull OUT RIGHT RUDE!
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Apparently, the attorney has no idea what “I don’t know” means.
If Elaine’s strategy here is to discredit the psychologist then she’s doing a terrible job 😂
She's an excellent witness. No matter how much she charges, Depp should be happy to pay it because her testimony alone should win him the lawsuit.
Amber and her entourage of lying-freeloading friends are despicable human beings.
But it doesn’t because it’s unprofessional for someone as such.
@@davidsilver323 That sentence doesn't make sense...she's hardly unprofessional, as such...lmao
She literally might be his most trash witness… yall fall for a pretty face.
@@davidsilver323 There are some truly dumb people out there, whom even with this video out there and hearing from the own Dr’s mouth, cannot and or refuse to believe when someone is not only not qualified to do such psychological evaluations but being “paid” to be biased and put forth a narrative towards the defendant and even admitting it live in court 😂
This woman Dr Curry is seriously putting her reputation on the line and has been caught multiple times lying. She’s Very unprofessional but I guess she must be getting paid a lot by the plaintiffs attorneys (DEPP)
Elaine:
"We are on very, very strict time limitations..."
Also Elaine:
*makes a joke about a mule that nobody laughed at*
But i laughed so much, thinking back to all those irrelevant and non-professional deposition and testimony that they presented, and they wasted time for.
I think Johnny & Ben had a quick 😏
@@10CentGambler Let's bring back the Disney rep
@@jassewalton1768 Objection, hearsay, lack of evidence :)
“We are on very very strict time limitations” yet let me ask you about dinner again and let me fumble thru papers and make it confusing so you appear biased
Dr Curry: that’s not correct...but okayyyy Elaine, do your best, I do my job and follow procedures
Funny how they can always pressure the witness with replying with short answers but they can take 5-15 minutes looking for the paperwork they need to question the witness! I hope they never get another case again!!
I cannot believe I am watching a multimillion dollar trial and a lawyer doesn't have copies of documents to hand for the other party, witness and judge
I don't think it's appropriate for the lawyers to ask experts how much they've been paid.
I agree, very inappropriate.
imagine saying "we're on strict time limits" and then asking her all the same exact questions she already testified to LMFAO
“How much money has Mr. Depp’s legal team paid you to be here?”
“I don’t know.”
“Over 100K?”
“I don’t know, I don’t do my own books.”
“Over 200K?”
“I don’t know.”
“Over 300K?
“I really don’t know.”
“Over 400K?”
“…”
“Okay, 500, that’s gotta be it, right?”
@@mikeschmidt4624 Yea ikr like CAN YOU REALLY NOT UNDERSTAND THIS? 🤣
@@mikeschmidt4624 That was a good move from the lawyer. She knew she wouldn't get a response like "I was paid $125,000". So she mentioned increasingly big amounts, to see when it would stop being plausible to someone who "doesn't know".
If you don't know how much you paid for a bag of chips, and I ask you "was it 100,000?", your answer won't be "I don't know". Because you know that you didn't pay $100,000 for chips. Even if you don't know the actual price. You will only answer "I don't know" when the price is plausible to you. Like "was it 2 dollars?" - "I don't know".
200,000 seemed plausible to Dr Curry, and she started saying "that would be way too much" only at 300,000. That would indicate that the price is likely to be 6 figures.
@@brinckau good point
@@mikeschmidt4624 c
It's not like she was wined and dined, she was offered take-out during a professional meeting that clearly went overtime. Big difference.
Unfortunately for their whole team lol…. They do not have much going their way in this case lololol. So they Gota grasp at straws
Was offered "take out"....lol....well that's entirely different to luring her to his house with the promise of a planned meal AND......heaven forbid....A DRINK......possibly a Moscow Mule no less. What!!!! did they do a Vulcan mind meld while she was under the influence of gluten and alcohol?
She’s probably jealous Amber doesn’t buy them dinner
They sent a limo to pick her up, Tyrese was in it to rub her feet the entire way to Depp's compound. On arrival she was given a milk bath at which point Depp fed her strawberries and eventually cunninlingus.
Right, she wasn’t invited to have dinner. She was scheduled for the meeting, not bc she wanted to have dinner. Huge distinction.
Man Elaine is not a good attorney. She should be an attorney for parking tickets or something
Playing mind games with an expert psychologist is like trying to explain to a chess master on how to arrange the chess pieces. 😂
She’s really hostile and combative whilst Doctor Curry is chilled AF
Facts
She was running out of time(defence time limit is at its end in this video) in a case where she needs to grasp at straws as she doesn’t have much of a case, while the world is watching. I think everyone can give her a break. She has to try and fight whatever the situation.
@@korvish111 how much time do both the defence and plaintiffs have left? I have been watching the trial but can’t remember this.
@@MelinaJamiee plantif has 15 hours heard has 4 hours
@@MelinaJamiee but defence rested their case. There isn’t much left now except closing statements on Friday. Depps team is just doing some rebuttals today. My guess is depp is the last witness. Cross examination to begin soon.
Elaine was so rude to her, wouldn’t even let her read whatever paper she brought up to show her- just yanked it then stomped away. Such an angry and desperate woman now, she’s down to the wire trying to save this case, but it’s impossible. I almost feel bad for heard’s legal team. I hope they were all planning on retiring anyways…
She’s so intimidated by her, it’s honestly hilarious. She seems to think by being rude that she’ll break her in some way and catch her in a lie or something, but it’s obvious that Dr. Curry is incredibly professional, honest, and confident in her testimony.
Lmao 💀😭
@@shrimplythebest honestly If someone were to act that way towards me rather than break I would have to calm myself from being angry and from potentially throwing spite and shades whenever I talk to whoever I dislike.
With the money Amber pledged to pay them they should be able to retire after this case 😂
lmao
I cannot believe that - this lawyer demands a complete obedience from Dr.Curry in regards to timeline and "yes/no" answers. Amber Heard have never complied to those sort of demands coming from Johnny Depp's lawyers and even if she did - it took a long time to get there !!
03:10 love how ambers attorney is trying to stop the witness from explaining her actions due to time limit but when Amber did it when she was being questioned by depps attorney, you dont see any interruptions
How is this even real? This has to be a joke, no way that Amber’s lawyer truly acts that unprofessional and immature. Wow, the Shannon Curry is a freaking Queen though
She's trying to be like Camille at this point. Problem is, she don't have the same class or competence as Camille.
@@tonityndall4532 wow thats crazy anyways i liked the weather today nice and sunny
@@tonityndall4532 she'll never be like Camile. For starters, Camille is hot. Heard should have chosen a different lawyer.
@@dannnsss8034 can’t you applaud Camille without bringing up physical appearance? she’s incredible at what she does. keep your thirst out of it
The Dr that starts every sentence with So. Ask her any question and more often than not she will say So....
One thing this trial has shown me is the amount of people who probably lose their cases because they can’t afford great experts like these.
Yes I think the same. JD is millonaire . And if being a millionaire it is costing him all these days and resources to prove that AH is lying! and with the privilege of being a public figure and the case is broadcast, he can reverse the opinion created by the media. But what about innocent people without resources? when on the other side the lawyers are so miserable?
This is so true.
Makes you wonder how many people are actually innocent and sitting in prisons because they didn’t have the funds to be proven so and those who are guilty but had the money to hire enough people to make them seem innocent.
@@IbleedPnk great point! But i want to add that it's not a one side relationship. the prison owners & companies benefit from filling prison quotas & selling prison's labour. It truly is disgusting.
At the end of the day, Johnny built a good team and Amber didn’t. There are many good lawyers and even more bad ones. You don’t always have to drop millions but you should always scout for a good team.
Thats why JD’s legal team interviewed her before they hired her…They wanted to make sure she’d be unflappable in court..and she could clearly and convincingly explain her diagnosis of Ms Heard.
„I did not write that in my notes. Do you have my notes so we can look at them?“ 😄 I love this woman so much.
This is probably the best witness I've seen. Not only is she super professional, she's also not afraid to call out misrepresentation.
She's very good, but I still prefer the amusing one's, like their psychiatrist
@@lesley9989 👄👅⤴↪⤵ do I have to answer that question your honour?? 👁👄👁
@@clovermx1472 that's the point, they ask questions and you have to answer
@@lesley9989 You have to answer questions, yessir. 👩⚖😤
@@clovermx1472 I know. Hilarious
“We’re on a strict time limit.” Proceeds to go into a lengthy explanation of why dr curry can’t finish her answer.
And talks about dinner again.
Lol. Exactly what I thought!
Plus she’s asking the same pointless questions that she’d already asked Dr Curry several times when she was on the stand before lol
That’s a generic dumb redirect to get the witness to shut up
"we're on very strict timelines so I'm going to repeat your original cross exam word for word while we run down our clock so we can't cross exam other rebuttal witnesses"
7:35 when the lawyer just walks away while she is still reading then just laughs about it. Classy lady.
While team Depp always provided copies for the judge , team Amber AND her witnesses.
There are some days when I can’t even what I had for dinner the night before. There’s no way that I’d be able to remember 200+ cases and exact components of each of them. There’s a massive difference between intentionally committing perjury and genuinely forgetting something until a later point. And when lawyers try forcing you into only answering with “Yes” or “No” responses, you don’t always have the luxury of being able to say, “Not that I recall” or something along those lines. I’m impressed with how Dr. Curry has consistently handled herself during this case.
So you’re saying you might have had dinner with Mr Depp _last night?_
Oh come on. Yep we might not remember dinner last night if it was a cheese sandwich watching a football game, but if you had dinner with a Hollywood celebrity last month try telling me you wouldn't remember it. This woman Dr Currie did not impress me at all. Her first answer that she had "no idea" how much she was earning out of this is implausible. She is a professional with a charge out rate and she would know what she charges per hour or per day. In the eyes of the judge she would have come across immediately as evasive. And to then say she "couldn't remember" if she had a drink, and "couldn't remember" if Johnny Depp spoke directly to her, is just as implausible. Depp didn't win the case because of this witness, Amber Heard lost the case with her own behavior in the box.
She couldn't really challenge Dr. Curry on her professional knowledge in research, so she attacked her personally by insinuating that she is biased and unqualified in the IPV area when the task was NOT to determine whether there was IPV or not towards Amber but rather whether there is psychological distress. Elaine and her team are desperate and disgusting. They have obviously been studying how the other team asks questions and objects, but they just come off as extremely rude and disrespectful, not professional and precise like Depp's team. Sad.
For sure they have been copying the other team. It’s so obvious. Unfortunately it’s to late as they already have a bad reputation because of their own actions.
Exactly!
"they just come off as extremely rude and disrespectful, not professional and precise like Depp's team." My thoughts exactly, especially Elaine and Rottenborn - especially Rottenborn, he is downright nasty, childish and rude in my opinion.
Birds of a Feather
Amber identities with them because……
Precisely.
I smell desperation!
And this isn’t a waste of the courts and jury’s time? “Did you eat dinner?!”
She was about to ask about the muffins again. Jesus christ 😩
We’ve already talk about this dude, weeks ago!!
May be she dislikes muffins.
She’s a fan of pancakes by the looks of it
of course she's gonna go for the muffin route. she had nothing else.
That smile she had at the beginning was her thinking “here we go again. Lol”
😂😂🤣🤣🤣
It’s honestly sad seeing her lawyers now, from a separate interview with someone who knew and worked with Amber I feel like she charmed and bamboozled her team into thinking they had an open and shut case. Then when faced with all the evidence that their client has been bold faced lying to them and the public now they’re scrambling. Elaine was here trying to catch Dr. Curry in a lie or trip her up because it’s been so easy for JD’s team to do that exact thing to Amber and the rest of their witnesses. She’s just getting out what she wants to say and doesn’t care if it helps the case at all, at one point she just skips over her own incoherent question when Dr. Curry asks for clarification of what she means because she can’t trap Curry into the answer she wants. Just asking broad ass questions overall hoping that the witness will just answer and she can flip it later on. The tremble in her voice is very telling
Amber has one point in her favour, which is the fact that she has never mentioned Johnny in her article on the Washington Post. He is accusing her now of intentionnally ruining his career, but I'm not really sure she can be made guilty of that : All of the fuss about her toxic behaviour is just noise.
Her lawyers are not stupid. Especially Elaine, she's well experienced.
They were after their 15 minutes of fame
@@YNYNYNYNYNYN oh I agree they aren’t straight up stupid and that made them cocky. Again I think they thought this was gonna be a breeze and didn’t prepare for Johnnys team to have as much as they did and breakdown every lie she has told. Also because Amber never expected Johnny to ever say that she abused him she didn’t tell her lawyers this information so they could come up with a strong defense against that. I think she’s making her lawyers look dumb so she can use them as a scapegoat if she loses which is messed up and I kind of pity them because of that
@@floatingsara yea that’s the one thing that might get her through because the final published version didn’t have his name. Now what might slip her up is that she’s unintentionally admitted that she wrote it about him, it directly referenced their relationship and, I’ll have double check which one, either the ACLU or the Post came out and said that her original drafts did include his name. Guess we’ll have the final outcome soon enough
@@karadancer17 wow
never thought about the scapegoat idea
I can't comprehend twisted ideologies
Amber‘s lawyer is so on organized, papers everywhere constantly looking for a specific paper very unlike Johnny’s attorneys who have everything that they need right there at their fingertips… Where in the world did she drag up this attorney? She seems like a flustered mess. I’d love to see what her office looks like
This Doctor is very smart, and very sane. Amber's legal team will never be successful in making a fool out of her.
and jesus is she attractive...
@@sean3587 distractingly so
Being sane is a required qualification to be a psychiatrist
Edit: That being said, I dunno how ambers Dr. got his license
you mean like the "experts" THEY called to the stand, who made fools of themselves? lol
She's obviously trying to make her look unethical. Sorry, that was that Smegol.
I love how she smiles instead of rolling her eyes when AH lawyer is being beyond ridiculous.
Yes, I laugh every time I see Heard now - she is SUCH AN OBVIOUS LIAR and FAKE! But she's writing reams of rubbish to try to convince everyone she's intelligent! Typical narcissistic 'mirroring'. I think she believes she's convincing everyone she's truly on the same academic level as her lawyers and understands all that's going on. Truly pitiable, actually.
Yup.. it’s what she does with her borderline pt too
I can't remember but smth like that I already said to another comment.the gueen😊😊😊😊
Rolling your eyes is overrated. I would smile and tell them they are just amazing 😂
Like when a 3 year old says it was the magic flying unicorn who ate all the cookies.
Dr. Curry exudes warmth, professionalism, compassion, and while being asked all these questions, which are softly spoken amusing, remained in charge having her facts straight and being unfazed by the things which tried to be put in her mouth. Smiling gently even though as someone works in the same field as her, knows how alienated she must´ve felt. Grand applause for a grand person!
Claims they are short on time, asks the same question three times. 🤷♂️
She speaks like somebody telling the Truth. Not trying to hide a thing.
She lied her butt off , she’s a lightweight
@@alexkane84 yeah ok 🤦🤣😊
@@alexkane84 imbred
@@alexkane84 if that’s lying then what is Amber Heard doing when SHE talks??
@@alexkane84 lol you're obviously a nut
All those questions and she didn't ask the most important one: where did they order food from and was it good?
😆😆😆😆😆😆
This comment made my day. Lol
Most importantly - did they tip the driver?
If so...how much?
What kind of car did he drive?
Yes!!! 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
I was wondering the same, must’ve been bomb 💣
This therapist is so far ahead of the lawyer it's almost embarrassing to watch...
Cmon, she's asking Dr Curry if she has charged hundred of thousand in fees and then insinuate she's biased over a dinner?
Dinners are priceless 😂
I’m currently studying my master’s in psychology and I’d just like to make this clear: psychologists do not need to be board certified and rarely are. This is a requirement for a psychiatrist, as they are considered doctors. So a psychologist being board certified or not means absolutely nothing in regards to their legitimacy or knowledge.
Yes, it is true. Psychiatrists absolutelty need to be board certicfied as they study MBBS (Medicine) and then do pyschiatry as residents. So they are Physicans (doctors). Whereas, Pyschologist mostly don't need a board certification because one can be pyschologist by studying psychology as bachleor and masters and attain a doctrate (DO NOT need to study MBBS/Medicine).
Thank you for clarifying that, Crazy-A's attorney/team is down right scandalous!!
I too, have an MS in Psychology and you are correct. This woman is highly knowledgeable and professional. Can't say the same for the attorney questioning her.
@@Anirita holy wow, you're gorgeous
Especially considering that the "board certified" psychologist is so painfully biased as men being the aggressor in relationships lmao
The fact that she burned so much of their remaining time on this when the doctor made her look silly the first time shows Elaine had nothing. It is so embarrassing. She would have never asked a male doctor these questions.
Elaine is sexist. She suggests that a take away might corrupt a woman's mind and professionalism.
@@hiphiphoogray Elaine didn't worry about the take aways Johny bought for any of the male experts hired by Johny's legal team.
Excellent point - she wouldn’t ask any of those questions to a man!
What has a male doctor got to do with anything?
Right? She would never ask a male doctor that and it’s pathetic.
These were the most unprofessional players in any court case I have ever seen. What an unbelievable joke.
Elaine: "We're on a strict time limit"
Also Elaine: "But what about the muffiiiiiins!??"
Elaine Again: "You had dinner at JD's? How warm was your dinner? Was it room temperature? If it was too warm did that not suggest that you have ulterior motives for appearing in this trial? And you still haven't answered me about the muffins!"
God she's an embarrassment...
JD's lawyer : asking forensic questions. Rebutting the false opinions of Dr Hughes and possibility she was biased.
AH's lawyer : dinner!! You had dinner!! You're biased!
Fox is fake news, grasping at straws
🤣😂🤣
😁😁😁
She is being paid maybe 2,00,000 USD and they are thinking whether she is being bribed with Dinner. LOL .... Fncking Clowns.
The desperation from Heard's lawyer is palpable
Idk what that word means, but I agree
And the "nah, I'm not even gonna ask that" 😂 Toast.
She’s not doing half bad today
@@AztecRay “ you can feel it in the air” :)
They are desperate because they haven't a chance in hell of winning...or getting paid.
Kindness can a woman beautiful, but Dr. Curry surpasses even kindness.
She’s on a strict time table but half the time is spent on correcting simple facts this attorney can’t get right.
Elaine ... she doesn't realize, this literally just comes off as "lawyer tricks" that are so obviously a contrived twisting of events. I LOVE how Camille and Johnny's team stick to straight facts, clear relevant science... and Elaine just jumps up there and doesnt even try to challenge that, she goes to muffins and trying so hard to make food into a romantic dinner date. Clearly a sign Elaine is so out of her depth because her client is indefensible!
Ugh it’s so annoying I don’t even understand why they have to let them cross lol
Expert accepts that JD suggested her that Amber has personality disorder, she spends few hours wining an dinning with JD and his team, never been expert in such diagnosis and still diagnoses Amber suffering from. forget who is right or wrong, these so called expert breached professional protocol. They should be struck off. Amber was able to expose her but other poor sould will have financial clout to do that.
I mean I’m pretty sure Amber’s team knows she lied. They’re basically in a position where they are trying to argue that water isn’t wet.
@@edwardduda4222 lawyers are paid to defend you even you are tried for murdrt
@@VijayaBjoshi she was interviewed. Elaine is warping events to make it look like Dr curry is conspiring with JD against amber heard. This is straight desperation from Ambers team at this point
Dr Currey is a knockout compared to Heard. She should have been cast for the movie instead of her.
Someone in your house for a length of time says they are hungry - feed them. Universal human decency.
The funny part about all this is that we saw Dr.Curry's explanation of Amber's behavior played out live for us every day in that court room. Nothing she said was ever a lie about her. She literally described her behavior word per word. So even if The beautiful Dr. Curry chugged beer and smoked bongs with JD's whole legal team...she'd still be 10,000,000% percent accurate about Amber the Turd.
love this comment😆🤣
Facts
Correct!
I'm sorry Shidori.. but you dropped this
🎤
Such a W statement lmao
I can’t believe this woman passed the bar. She is simply an awful attorney. After this I highly doubt ANYONE will hire her again.
I've never seen such incompetent representation in my life - and I've worked in courts and with lawyers over many years.
Her credentials say otherwise. She’s a top attorney in several states. I just think she was dealt a terrible hand by a lying Amber Heard that brought out the worst in her.
I agree. I was wondering if this woman was a real lawyer? because her line of questioning is absurd and silly.
@@jessicalee9120 😂
She kept asking question after question and getting bad answer after bad answer and she just moved on like she didn’t just ask the worst question possible. She just goes, “alright”, and asks the next question 🤣 😂 🤣
I think Amber picked this team because she felt she could tell them how to run the case. She kept making notes throughout the trial acting like she knew what to do next.
Johnny just sat down and let the experts do the work.
It’s funny she has an issue with her having dinner at Johnny’s house while she was being interviewed but not an issue with Amber having dinner with the judges wife in the UK 🤔
This!!!
The judge needs to get a medal of honour to listen to the stuff.
Lol, this lawyer is ridiculous. She asks the same question about pay three times, then rambles about time limitations.
Exactly!
And she asks questions she asked her last time as well. So stupid
Yep, that about made my head explode.
Frustrated nothing to defend
I found it unbelievable as well, that she has no idea of how much she's getting paid considering the probable amount. But yeah, asking the same question in a different ways can be objected and is ultimately a waste of time.
It's amazing how literally every person on Amber's side is either rude or dumb. Like where does she find these people? Is there a club specifically for obnoxious people?
Most rich folk are very rarely are they kind
@@cathal3666 the people representing or testifying for Depp aren't exactly broke, are they? But look how impeccably behaved they have been so far!
@@cathal3666 Heh, it seems like you are jealous of rich people
Birds of the same feathers
I think that's just because that's the only type of person that's willing to testify to what Amber wants without going "I can't say that, it's unethical"
Very rarely see a beautiful woman being very very smart, composed, grounded, wise. The psychologist is amazing, knows her job and has got such a deep insight regarding psychology, the way she’s explaining her understanding to the level where everyone can get a glimpse it’s amazing.
How many times does this lawyer try to put words in her mouth? "You wrote that in your notes, didn't you?"
"I did not. Do you have my notes so we can-"
"SO this next thing..."
"I actually don't know"
"I truly don't know..."
"I DON'T KNOW!"
"I DO NOT KNOW!"
Lady....she does not know!
Also............I love how Elaine tried copy Camille Vasquez in her technique of questioning..."Please answer my question" hahahahahah girl please don't..just don't it ain't working for you.
The lawyer doesnt care about her answer. A lawyer's question is sometimes enough to plant a seed into jury's mind. Just like Camille asking AH rhetorically that she was the abuser, she wasnt expecting Amber to say yea! She was just planting that seed. Same with Elaine and the muffins and the dinner and the fees. She's rude and aggressive and unprepared, but she's still doing some sort of damage, even if it's subliminal.
I thought I was the only person who Noticed how she’s now imitating Vasquez! Wow!
Food drinks muffins are you hungry or stupid Elaine
You're right! I just also noticed she's now mimicking some of JDs other, male attorney style too!! Wow! Gutsy (not in a good way).
Yeah I noticed. I was like nice try Elaine hahaha
Just tell the lawyer. She wants to know if you brought the muffins to the dinner at Johnny's place. And if so, was it store bought or homemade. AND if it was homemade, pass that recipe.
😅😅😅
😂😂
*Objection speculation*
@@wordotexe can we uhhh approach?
😄😄🙌🏽
12:04 "Yes, it's fine". After that line when Dr. Curry smiles because she knows the attorney just wants her to use the parts that fit her narrative is terrifying and hilarious at the same time.
Love it how it’s legal in a “justice” system to try to advert the truth so much like this lawyer.
She tries to make Dr. Curry look bad but Dr. Curry just disagrees and makes her look so bad for lying. It's in a deposition and you can't even get that correct Elaine 😂🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️
I saw Dr shannon curry as a very clever woman....i was very impressed
I was surprised Dr. Curry allowed herself to get even a little flustered.
Amber’s lawyer not only trying to emphasize on how dr curry had dinner at johnny’s house but also trying to copy camille’s way of examining is beyond pathetic and hilarious
I’ve also noticed that Amber is more engaged with her lawyers like JD has been. Amber’s PR team is on high alert to copy what they think is working on Johnny’s team.
But only Truth wins.
@@folkfooted I hope her PR team ends up with a whole bunch of lawsuits over the blatant censorship bulshit they've been pulling on CZcams channels
🤣
I didnt see this at all
Hopefully the jury can see through this and on the whole it just hurts the Turd even more.
So they don't expect to interview or meet with expert witnesses that will testify for them before trial? If so then that would explain David Spiegel.
👌😅😂 .
How is this woman a LAWYER?!!!!! I mean how?!!! Horrible 😒
It’s so obvious how intimidated Elaine is by Dr. Curry, it’s incredibly embarrassing. She interrupts her because she says the court is on a strict time schedule but then is wasting time by asking the exact same questions from last time 🙄
She did that because Amber thinks it was good. I can't imagine a seasoned lawyer wanting to go back there. It sort of sounds nuts. So I think it came from Amber.
Elaine's once the jury to believe opor Hammer she doesn't have the best lawyers like Johnny this is the play on the jury for sympathy
They’ve only got 4 hours, Jonny’s team has 16… desperate times, desperate measures. 🫣
The court isn’t on a scheduled, AH team are as they’ve got less than 4 hours remaining. She’s probably wanting to push through so they have more time. But I agree it’s embarrassing and Elaine is an absolute fool
Elaine: "We're about to run out of time so PLZ!"
"Okay"
Elaine: "So did you get paid $100 thousand? How about $200 thousand? Over $300 thousand? Can't be $400 thousand? How about $500 thousand? Maybe $600 thousand? Surely $700 thousand!”"
🤣🤣🤣😆😆😆
When does she take I don’t know is a I don’t know - if I was the juror I would be so annoyed - irrelevant
😀😀😂😂🤣🤣🔨
She definitely watched the office before questioning.
"343 days...344 days ..okay 345 days."
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
What's wrong with offering a guest in ur. home something to eat.
FGS !!
From Camille to Dr Shannon Curry, Johnny really has an eye for strong, intelligent and serious women, pretty strange how he fooled himself to being involved with Amber who is the complete opposite 😂😂😂
Agreed. His time with amber trained him to see who the winners are... you don't know what winning feels like without losing a few times.
I hope he will apply this lesson to his personal life. Camilla and Dr Curry are class acts.
Most likely because of what DR curry said about Amber basically she over play herself and does her best to seem like she's something she's not.
That's the thing about engaging a person who has BPD and cluster B personality traits. They at first seem to be amazing partners and people, but the switch will flip as the relationship continues. AH most likely made JD feel seen and special at first but that all started to change as soon as she had her hooks in.
@@caddiePiece
I agree. My sister is probably worse than Amber. My sister has been married 6 times and is looking for her 7th.
She pretends to be exactly what each man is looking for, but she can't fake who she actually is for too long. After she gets married, (and she convinces the men to get married quickly) she becomes a psycho. She has physically and emotionally abused men, and she rages like no other person I have ever seen.
It's really sad because she has married some fine men.
I'm really surprised that she hasn't murdered one yet...truly.
"Yes, because I never had a client that was essentially homebound because of their celebrity status."
BOOM. Way to just completely obliterate Elaine's pathetic attempt to discredit your analysis in one fell swoop, Dr. Curry. Well done.
Elaine's response is even better..
*starts nodding before the Dr even finishes*
"Allllright, touche. Good answer."
🤦♀️it’s after 3 to 4 hours later, she’s hungry then Johnny Depp decided to order takeouts for everyone 🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️NOT dinner for 3 to 4 hours 🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️
@Johnny Depp u r most welcome, from Singapore 🇸🇬😅👍
This lady and Camille are honestly my role models. So professional and elegant.
So professional and credible. I love that there are two very strong women who have emerged from this trial that have set an amazing example to young girls today. They both exude compassion, professionalism and competency in their chosen careers. To all young impressionable girls out there, be a Dr Curry or a Camille, please don't be an Amber.
Yes , I thought the same.👍
yes sure they had rich family who helped before what they are now . also ms elaine is the same as them
@@meralEdwtDawlatly she is on the wrong side in my eyes. However i must respect her for defending a client who actually blamed her own lawyers for not presenting evidence
@@meralEdwtDawlatly omg always an excuse to discredit people's accomplishments. MONEY does not make you who you are as a person. Don't make shallow comments it's unbecoming
3 women, Kate Moss
How in the world did this woman get a license to be a lawyer? I'm sorry, but she infuriates me so much lol. Dr. Curry, on the other hand, is an absolute queen i love her!
edit: THAT being said it's just an opinion so please don't take it seriously. I am sure Elaine is a great attorney, she just took on a bad case with a bad liar. God bless everyone.
50+ years ago times weee different in the library
She's good for intimidating and manipulating weak opposition witnesses. Her tactics will never work against someone high-profile like Johnny Depp.
very rude just like her client
well what can she do, its hard to defend a liar
She's probably an okay attorney, but Amber is a guilty client. Not much to work with.
It's hard to fluster someone who is just being impartial.
I'm unclear on how eating while in Depp's home makes Dr. Curry more biased than sharing muffins with Amber Heard, lol.
AH Lawyer: "You did not disclose that you ate breakfast this morning, isn't that correct?"
Psychologist: "That is correct."
AH Lawyer team: "We got her!"
She had no reason too as well. Since that was just the interview.
ba ha ha ha , my sentiments exactly. More men who are victims of domestic violence should legally fight for their rights! Equality is equality after all.
@@zanynurse All people should fight for it. But the police don’t even take assault seriously. So, it has to be classified and changed within the law.
😂😂
not taking heads side but the meal dose bring up some red flags 1) it took place at his home usually a meeting like this would be at a office 2) there were drinks involved that makes it come across more social 3)Depp was present as to make sure that the other lawyer cant say that he didn't win her over or influence her
The bottom line is that everything she said about Amber Heard's personality was there for EVERYONE to see when Amber took the stand.
She LITERALLY proved everything she said she was.
That's about it too. Everyone who has dealt with people with BPD, HPD, or narcissistic personality disorder sees all the signs from beginning to end. It wasn't that bad in the beginning just seemed like over acting but at then Vasquez came into play and rattled her. That's when Amber really came out. Then the second time she lost it. She became the "monster". The narcissism showed hard as did the sudden mood shifts. She couldn't hide it because she was focused on the lies. Mrs. Vasquez was rapid firing questions and the lies were becoming jumbled and she slipped up letting the real Amber show.
It was so sweet to see her lies exposed,and by herself.
Either this woman is a complete fraud or she's incompetent! A checklist is not a test and giving the client a cheatsheet is no way to get to the truth of the who, when and why of the abuse a pathological liar like AH alleges. It is wrong on so many levels because with the standardized Danger Assessment, she actually wrote Johnny's name down on the form as abusing AH in 2019 when he hadn't even talked to her since 2016. This woman needs to be investigated! What if someone else she's had a relationship with since Johnny abused her?
I know it was so ridiculous and odd...like she comes across as not that bright
It's not having dinner when you have a business interview and then grabbing a bite to eat. Or must you die from hunger. Even if it is a dinner oit must be addressed as "business diner" or "business lunch" !!!
When you have an important appointment with some others, that takes couple of hours, isn't it normal to give your guests something to eat and drink? And because this was in the evening they make it 'dinner with Johnny'? That's insane! Some lawyers are not so smart.
elaine is a disaster and her performance and contribution during this saga will not help her business in fact it could do a lot of damage she's probably lost a lot of credibility if she had any
"we're on a strict timeline here", loses documents again! Amber Heard's team is a joke😂
Omg!!!! Elaine wastes more time on stupid crap, she ask over and over about the dinner. Now that's a waste time
Totally.
@@redds7777 . You mean Elaine - i can't find my notes - Bredehoft 🤭
Wait...
I'm thinking, I'm thinking.. lol
She's trying to use Camille's style and failed miserably. She's just rude, pathetic, and desperate at this point. She wasn't ready for any of the answers the witness gave. Short on time, but asking 2 minute long questions that were previously answered and reciting procedures. SMH
I just made the same comment. It’s so obvious. She’s making fool out of herself 😂
"We need to be vigilant of the time, we want to be sensitive of the jury’s time, so PLEASE just tell me what you ate two years ago in MR. DEPP'S HOME. This is REALLY important to the jury."
@@laporziuncula 🤣🤣