Can tell these comments are full of LG fanboys - there's a severe lack of originality on display here 1. We don't need to be able to display that we can "do better" in order to criticise art, in the same way we wouldn't ask you to point out things that are worse in order to justify you liking something - it should stand on its own merits (which not a single one of you have put forward) 2. We all live in our own homes like the adult people that we are 3. It's just facial hair 4. Ed Sheeran has way more talent in songwriting than Liam Gallagher Now, let's all try and say something actually interesting moving forward please
First time I've seen CZcamsrs quipping at people commenting on their video. You're allowed to have a view but anyone who disagrees isn't? You'll be blocking people next. There were people writing this album off 20 minutes after it was released. It's a forty odd minute album and they cast judgement in 20 minutes. Gone are the days when people paid 10 hard earned quid for the album. When you paid for the album you listened to it and it usually grew on you. I've had many albums I disliked on the first few listens only for it to become a go to favourite with time. Today's digital throwaway society has made people's listening habits lazy with them cooing over the latest three chord saccharin fix throwaway tune by some over hyped flake of an artist.
Why does that matter? They are reviewing an album made recently. And they are spot on, it's shite. Oasis were incredible. There's no argument there. But that was then and this is now and Liam is a car crash these days. Only the tragic oasis fanboys keep making excuses for him
Who are these 3 end pieces I’ve stumbled across ffs, 20 somethings weren’t even about when the 90s were great and buzzing with great bands and musicians
Tragic to hear so many oasis fanboys trying to suggest they because someone didn't hear oasis at their best means they can't call out Liam making a terrible song and this is bad. Being the front man of a band in the 90s means absolutely nothing today. Embarrassing to see so many people getting a semi at everything Liam does and then thinking "Where were you in the 90s" is a credible argument when someone has a negative opinion
Liam lost his Rock n Roll credibility when he got songwriters in ! He just like a pop idol Simon Cowel act , the ones he used to slag for not writing their own tunes ! And saying what I’ve just wrote ! How times have changed!
Ironically, the best stuff he put out during his solo career are the tunes he penned alone. Most of the co-written stuff has a veneer of naffness to it.
This album is very underrated and WILL grown on you. You You haven’t given it enough time yet…. Never heard so much negativity this online this. Must be infectious
Probably the most ridiculous review I've ever witnessed. I get that it's not going to be everyone's cup of tea but the level of hatred you all display towards it isn't really natural so I'm guessing there's an agenda somewhere.
Entertain me for a moment. Your arguments evoke memories of the inspectors in the 1995 film "The Usual Suspects" - recall how Keyser Soze outsmarted them all? I understand; you remind me of my friends from English literature who studied at Oxford and Trinity, while I was the "dumb" business student. You draw inspiration from the likes of James Joyce, David Byrne, Thom Yorke, or perhaps some obscure Johnny Cale or Nick Cave cover. But hear me out, let's rewind 30 years ago (okay, you weren't born then, but let's pretend). Two brothers boldly declare on TV that they will become the biggest band in England and that their records will stand the test of time. Their first single, "Supersonic," sung in front of a crowd of 20, with lyrics echoing, "you can have it all but how much do you want it." Their debut album isn't just an ode; it's meticulously crafted, taking the best parts of music that came before it. In fact the entire first two albums were created this way. "Rock 'n' Roll Star" borrows from The Jam's "In the City," transitioning seamlessly to The Who's "My Generation," leading into "Shakermaker" with nods to Coca-Cola's jingle. "Live Forever" echoes The Rolling Stones' "Shine a Light," while "Up in the Sky" channels "Paperback Writer" by The Beatles, and "Columbia" pays homage to Axe Corner's "Torgua." (seriously check it out). Each track on their debut album, from "Supersonic" to "Bring It On Down," has its roots in the rich history of music. Even the title "Wonderwall" nods to a George Harrison album (with the outro of course The Cure's 'Lullaby'. However, despite this, they add a positive spin, responding to Nirvana's "I hate myself and wanna die" with "Live Forever," (having been thru a worse childhood than Cobain) and infuse the energy of the Sex Pistols singing the Beatles. Fast forward 30 years, their albums have indeed stood the test of time, with "Wonderwall" arguably being the anthem of a generation. Leaders like Macron and Merkel have even stood to its tunes, as if it were a national anthem. And now, this 51-year-old with average grades, I celebrate the Gallagher brothers' 18th number 1 album. To me, this narrative is more compelling than the movie Rocky; I cheer for the underdog. All I ask is, don't dismiss this too quickly. Half of art is the story! Most of us are inspired by this story. I wonder if you share that same spark with your favorites.
Lads... I hope you realise that these guy were involved in the creation in two of the greatest albums in the history of UK music, right? You three are sat in your bedroom making a podcast. You look pretty silly. Like positioning yourself as restaurant reviewers when all you've eaten is beans on toast
@@ARyan-nf5my I like the seahorses record, but I honestly think John's best work is the first stone roses record, might not be his most technical but it's just creatively beautiful and so tasteful, serves the songs, not himself
I think this album is actually great , there's 10 tracks on this album and I'd 6 are really good the other 4 are okay if you just wanna listen to something. I do think people were thinking they were gonna write someone unreal as they both legends in there own right but I think it's great they did some songs together and people shouldn't judge to harshly on it. I'm thankful we got a collaboration and I also think mother nature song is actually an amazing song x
Liam Gallagher is still popular with the new generation of music fans mainly because of his attitude imo. He’s over 50 and still acts like a young man or teenager who doesn’t give a f about anything apart from rock n roll. That appeals to kids who’s parents are probably the same age as him. He’s still got the same spirit that connects with young people.
Is true its his act, that's why the general public aka non music people buy into him but his greatest moment was defo squaring up to the pap that day. Dale Winton's drawers!
I feel like you guys are the only people out there who also believe the album is not good at all. Apart from 'Mother Nature's Song', which I really like by the way, all the songs are very same-y and don't offer anything inventive or interesting or novel. Even before the first single 'Just Another Rainbow' came out, people online had already pre-ordered the album before even listening to THAT single, which is just bizarre to me. Why would you pre-order an album without hearing it??? I'm glad you made this video because it's important to call out an artists' shit music, in your own opinion, despite being a fan. Oasis are my favourite band ever but I can openly say there's albums I don't like, even from Liam or Noel's. I feel like there's gonna be loads of hard-as-fuck fan boys who will defend anything Liam makes to the grave if you dare criticise it.
I do love 90's indie music which obviously this record will appeal to, but would probably rank the new albums by Shed Seven and Cast above this record but Liam's voice does make so of the tracks sound massive
Sort of feel sorry for them really, they think music is these 30sec nonsense tiktok videos these days, you dont need an ounce of talent to make music now, so glad me and. Lot of you grew up with real music be thankful 😊
Out of Liam's 4 solo albums under his own name including this, I would probably rank this a clear 4, but that's still not a knock I enjoyed the album and collaboration and look forward to their next record together, gives Liam 2 careers now his solo stuff and his stuff with John, this album was always going to appeal to someone like me I enjoyed some of Beady Eyes stuff to like Soul love
You already went into this album with a negative mindset expecting it to be "shit" so doesn't even sound like you're giving it a chance. If you go into something already hating it then your brain is naturally going to perceive it in the worst way possible, especially if you're surrounded by an echo chamber of the same opinions & mindsets. Would have been more interesting if at least one of you liked it or had a different perception. Still, you're entitled to your opinion, but not sure if i see the point of reviewing an album you're just going to collectively shit all over, doesn't really achieve much in my opinion. Spread love
Cost of living crisis is hitting these guys. I remember seeing John Squire on a show talking about his art and a question was put to him about music, he said music is a young mans game. Like the Rolling Stones should stop. I always thought that was rough given what great talent he had. But I respected it.
Mother Natures Song is a really smooth and chilling song. I'm coming from the guitarist point of view. There's been a couple of people uploading covers of it but they're all playing the basic chords. It's pumped full of interesting melodies, and has a much more complicated structure than what it initially seems. Personally I'm just happy to see these two legends collaborating and giving Joe Public a summer album to get back into that vibe of the pure band vibes. Cash grab? I don't think so. I've never seen Squire bop around before, but he does when playing these songs. It's nice to see him in that kind of groove. But anyway, it's all opinion based I guess.
I love Liam and John but apart from Mars to Liverpool and You're Not The Only One I thought the album was dreadful. I'm going to see them play the album through in Paris next month. 50 quid ticket. Wish me luck.
You see that CD that comes in a packet of Washing Powder plastic cover? Well, they should see who can fck this album into the washing machine first and don't forget to rinse the shite out of it. This is the type of album I'd expect from Forest Gump himself, it's that bad but at least I could say that Forest tried his best. And it just goes to show how the media and certain bands are all in each others pockets.
It’s funny, as a 42 year old, I’ve never met someone smart enough to claim them as dumb. One can listen to Keith Jarret, The Smile, Peter Gabriel and still get a buzz of this - you guys just missing it
Man this comment section goes so hard. I wouldn't agree to such an extent on ur take but its definitely a very underwhelming work, not that i was expecting a lot anyway lol
Ha ha ha , love your comments and opinions lads , I quite like the album but I think it’s more nostalgic than anything , and music is all subjective so respect your views , ps - some of the lyrics on this album I think are wrote in fucking crayon 🖍️ there that bad …. 😂
After reading all of the many glowing, fawning reviews from 50 year old blokes in baggy coats, I’m glad I’ve stumbled upon this and feel I am not alone in my huge bored indifference to this album. Totally predictable, plodding structures and REALLY poor lyrics. I like some of Liam’s solo stuff and was a huge Oasis fan back in the day but my reaction to this was a jaw breaking fucking yawn.
It’s one of the best Albums These days..yes oasis is gone..time past by…these Giants Rock together..They Go on…defenitly maybe these fellas sing wonderwall 😢
this is an awful take. I listened to the album and it’s very well written and recorded despite not knowing much about squire or gallagher or the UK 90’s scene. I’m canadian. judging by the other comments, most agree with me. also cash grab claim isn’t really based on reality, i’m assuming both of these artist are already loaded.
'I think everyone should grow out of Oasis/Stone Roses at our age' jesus, seriously? Come on lads, get off your high horse & let people enjoy the music. I know the fanbase can be full of old haircuts but takes like those make it hard to take your reviews seriously.. again just clearly wasn't an album meant to be reviewed by people who go into it with preconceptions. but like i said before, u can do whatever u want. at least you got me commenting lol
F N SQUIRE.. SIT THERE LAD AND DO WHAT I SAY.. says ( the one trick voice, and the only influence he could muster on "Jools" were the "Rose's".. tit. Scotland has spoken but I'll be at the gig giving esquire pelters! I've done more with my life since they came on the scene.. which is never what I hoped for,aye Squire is an inventive guitarist.. just not here..oh man I and my poor poor "Rose's Troglodytes".. are like fk sq and Lm..we are all thinking that they are two faced back stabbing desperado's..who have forgotten their band roots!.. no worries boys I'll be there with some veryyy old eggs!!!
For guys in their 20's you are disappointingly dismissive. Interested to know if you have any artists or music which you deem as timeless? (And who that is?) Alot of Squire and Gallagher fans independently will deem both to be able to do no wrong. Not saying the album is amazing btw but you are a harsh reflection of youth reviews.
Liam and John need to go back to copying nursery rhymes in order to get a few hits. One decent song for me which is Rainbows, in fact it blows anything else away on this what can be deemed only a "cash grab." album. The lyrics could have stolen from a five year but Liam and John will still take all the credit. 4/10 and i'm being very kind.
Yes I agree, more of a pink floyd fan, I like well researched lyrics, and plenty of insights. Fairly boring album. I Couldn't even listen to all the songs.
Hahaha BS. This shit is next level. Just watch the live performances. Hendrix and the Beatles would have been watching from the crowd if this came out in the sixties.
good review lads. looking fwd to seeing the avalanch of Adidads and Pretty Weans screaming abuse at you in these comments - already started. agreed w Cal, the chorus of M2L is actually ok. Biggest enduring disappointment is that the man who created an entire album around the concept of situationism (Paris '68) and who wrote tunes like Love Spreads and Standing Here virtually with his eyes closed, is now churning out shite like this. such is life i guess.
Solid meat and potatoes indie rock album, Liam's voice full of swagger and personality, lyrics might not be up to much but who cares, I guess you guys would pan Lennon's I am the egg man lyrics to as being meaningless word soup, if you enjoy Liam you will enjoy this album, is it high art with political deep lyrics, no and nor is it attempting to be
Get a grip, it’s better than anything in the charts by a mile music is dead in this country, it’s only existing artists than can do great music because millennials haven’t got a clue what good music is
Well said. I think these dumbheads don't know sh*t about good music. They can suck on it! Liam is one of the last Rockstars on this planet, and he is doing pretty well these days, coming from one of the greatest band ever - Fuk'n OASIS! 😎
@@FoolsHQ nothing on there worth listening too tbh the fact this video already has far more views than any video`s you have put out about modern music artists says it all although i do agree some what, im not the biggest fan of this album
Well it's nothing new but that's isn't the decider on whether it's good. It's a simple rock n roll record, basic tunes embellished by Gallagher and Squires brilliance. And yes, everyone is free to critique art. I'd argue that few do it with such awful smugness as yourselves.
John Squire made a half decent album 35 years ago and has done nothing of note since. Oasis made music for people that don’t like music. Why would anyone think that this album would be any good?
These 3 guys look like they lay flowers every year for Viola Beach, it's not a great album but it certainly isn't as bad as you lot make out, 5 really good tracks on it to be fair
Dreadful album. Rehash of old crap, but done more badly. The guitar riffs, the vocals, the lyrics, the songs, absolutely bollocks. Liam now sings like Mr Punch and John Squires is irrelevant. I can't believe I spent money on actually buying this shiiiiiiiiittttee. It's taking the ****.
As a 50 year old i can 100% say Liam Gallaghers biggest talent was convincing people he had talent. Absolutely loved definitely maybe when it was released and still do now but the albums got progressively worse unfortunately. John squire was always a talented guitarist so here we are in 2024, oasis and the roses long gone, and left with this lazy sheeeeeeeiiiiiiiittttttte. It certainly wont be the worst album of the year though just not a very good one.
Can tell these comments are full of LG fanboys - there's a severe lack of originality on display here
1. We don't need to be able to display that we can "do better" in order to criticise art, in the same way we wouldn't ask you to point out things that are worse in order to justify you liking something - it should stand on its own merits (which not a single one of you have put forward)
2. We all live in our own homes like the adult people that we are
3. It's just facial hair
4. Ed Sheeran has way more talent in songwriting than Liam Gallagher
Now, let's all try and say something actually interesting moving forward please
It would be nice if you did !
What you're saying is horse shit so why should everyone else refrain from talking the same shite?
First time I've seen CZcamsrs quipping at people commenting on their video. You're allowed to have a view but anyone who disagrees isn't? You'll be blocking people next.
There were people writing this album off 20 minutes after it was released. It's a forty odd minute album and they cast judgement in 20 minutes. Gone are the days when people paid 10 hard earned quid for the album. When you paid for the album you listened to it and it usually grew on you. I've had many albums I disliked on the first few listens only for it to become a go to favourite with time.
Today's digital throwaway society has made people's listening habits lazy with them cooing over the latest three chord saccharin fix throwaway tune by some over hyped flake of an artist.
@@justinwiggy Notice you're not dealing with the music on this album. You're complaining about the social zeitgeist.
@@MoonwalkerWorshiper I wouldn't be commenting what I commented if I thought the album was shit.
You 3 bell ends serious? Let yer mums back into her room ffs! #TACHEBALLBAGS
This one got a laugh in the group chat, mate. Thanks for that
A telt thir mam 'Daint be scairt to gi me baws a wee knock aboot'.
how old were these three bell ends in the 90s
Why does that matter? They are reviewing an album made recently. And they are spot on, it's shite.
Oasis were incredible. There's no argument there. But that was then and this is now and Liam is a car crash these days. Only the tragic oasis fanboys keep making excuses for him
Two😅
@@dazzag I'm intrigued what your definition of a car crash is?
They weren't born. I bet their music taste is Kings of Leon and all type shit like that.
@@cinemar 🤣🤣🤣🤣I bet that 'Chelsea Dagger' song is their anthem Oh, no...the would be 8.
3 gays who probably spunk over their justin Bieber albums
The Three Stooges
Who are these 3 end pieces I’ve stumbled across ffs, 20 somethings weren’t even about when the 90s were great and buzzing with great bands and musicians
Sadly it is 2024 and this is pretty cack
Times have changed. I grew up loving oasis but get a grip mate. This is just terrible
lol agreed I’m a fan and its Gash ! , seriously trying to like it , but ain’t happening !
I can't really get passed the 3 burglar tashes....
Worst album of 2024 or worst review?
Worst album!
And review.
Tragic to hear so many oasis fanboys trying to suggest they because someone didn't hear oasis at their best means they can't call out Liam making a terrible song and this is bad.
Being the front man of a band in the 90s means absolutely nothing today. Embarrassing to see so many people getting a semi at everything Liam does and then thinking "Where were you in the 90s" is a credible argument when someone has a negative opinion
Thought it was a fun listen and look forward to the live tour
Glad you enjoyed it, even if we didn’t. Thanks for the comment👍🏼
There playing small gigs then Fests in summer , with second album half done, so wake up it's the summer of Liam and John ,
Bells . Who gives a fxxk what they think
Thank you for taking the time to comment despite clearly not giving a fxxk
I quite like this album. Hope to see you boys on the comedy circuit soon.. Bloody hilarious 😜
Liam lost his Rock n Roll credibility when he got songwriters in ! He just like a pop idol Simon Cowel act , the ones he used to slag for not writing their own tunes ! And saying what I’ve just wrote ! How times have changed!
Ironically, the best stuff he put out during his solo career are the tunes he penned alone. Most of the co-written stuff has a veneer of naffness to it.
This album is very underrated and WILL grown on you. You
You haven’t given it enough time yet…. Never heard so much negativity this online this. Must be infectious
Probably the most ridiculous review I've ever witnessed. I get that it's not going to be everyone's cup of tea but the level of hatred you all display towards it isn't really natural so I'm guessing there's an agenda somewhere.
man you guys gonna be old too one day. don’t get too cocky. great album - best Gallagher output from either. I’m 42 - think the audience is 40-50 .
I'm 43, this album is amazing, and these three twats 😡
Entertain me for a moment. Your arguments evoke memories of the inspectors in the 1995 film "The Usual Suspects" - recall how Keyser Soze outsmarted them all? I understand; you remind me of my friends from English literature who studied at Oxford and Trinity, while I was the "dumb" business student. You draw inspiration from the likes of James Joyce, David Byrne, Thom Yorke, or perhaps some obscure Johnny Cale or Nick Cave cover.
But hear me out, let's rewind 30 years ago (okay, you weren't born then, but let's pretend). Two brothers boldly declare on TV that they will become the biggest band in England and that their records will stand the test of time. Their first single, "Supersonic," sung in front of a crowd of 20, with lyrics echoing, "you can have it all but how much do you want it."
Their debut album isn't just an ode; it's meticulously crafted, taking the best parts of music that came before it. In fact the entire first two albums were created this way. "Rock 'n' Roll Star" borrows from The Jam's "In the City," transitioning seamlessly to The Who's "My Generation," leading into "Shakermaker" with nods to Coca-Cola's jingle. "Live Forever" echoes The Rolling Stones' "Shine a Light," while "Up in the Sky" channels "Paperback Writer" by The Beatles, and "Columbia" pays homage to Axe Corner's "Torgua." (seriously check it out).
Each track on their debut album, from "Supersonic" to "Bring It On Down," has its roots in the rich history of music. Even the title "Wonderwall" nods to a George Harrison album (with the outro of course The Cure's 'Lullaby'. However, despite this, they add a positive spin, responding to Nirvana's "I hate myself and wanna die" with "Live Forever," (having been thru a worse childhood than Cobain) and infuse the energy of the Sex Pistols singing the Beatles.
Fast forward 30 years, their albums have indeed stood the test of time, with "Wonderwall" arguably being the anthem of a generation. Leaders like Macron and Merkel have even stood to its tunes, as if it were a national anthem. And now, this 51-year-old with average grades, I celebrate the Gallagher brothers' 18th number 1 album. To me, this narrative is more compelling than the movie Rocky; I cheer for the underdog.
All I ask is, don't dismiss this too quickly. Half of art is the story! Most of us are inspired by this story. I wonder if you share that same spark with your favorites.
What three very strange young chaps. You have to worry for people like this.Nearly the oddest thing ive seen on youtube.
Lads... I hope you realise that these guy were involved in the creation in two of the greatest albums in the history of UK music, right? You three are sat in your bedroom making a podcast.
You look pretty silly.
Like positioning yourself as restaurant reviewers when all you've eaten is beans on toast
Grow out of Oasis?,
By the time your 36 you'll grow back into them, everyone does,
Seems like we’ve still got a few years of good sense left thankfully
Yep, so enjoy it while you can,
I agree with the review, as a guitarist who loves John's playing, think he's a bit over the top on this
@@stephenwolverson1056thank you for watching and commenting🤝🏼
@@stephenwolverson1056they said that about seahorses record yet its his best work.
- and Tony visconti's but this is far removed from 1997 .....
@@ARyan-nf5my I like the seahorses record, but I honestly think John's best work is the first stone roses record, might not be his most technical but it's just creatively beautiful and so tasteful, serves the songs, not himself
I think this album is actually great , there's 10 tracks on this album and I'd 6 are really good the other 4 are okay if you just wanna listen to something. I do think people were thinking they were gonna write someone unreal as they both legends in there own right but I think it's great they did some songs together and people shouldn't judge to harshly on it. I'm thankful we got a collaboration and I also think mother nature song is actually an amazing song x
Liam Gallagher is still popular with the new generation of music fans mainly because of his attitude imo. He’s over 50 and still acts like a young man or teenager who doesn’t give a f about anything apart from rock n roll. That appeals to kids who’s parents are probably the same age as him. He’s still got the same spirit that connects with young people.
Is true its his act, that's why the general public aka non music people buy into him but his greatest moment was defo squaring up to the pap that day. Dale Winton's drawers!
Genuine question - name me one good tune released in the past 2 years?
I could name plenty of outstanding albums ..yes whole albums but as you prolly are so out of touch it would go right over your head .
@@ceannairereibiliunach8133 why don’t you name these outstanding albums?
Anything by the blossoms. All of Noel Gallaghers stuff
@@stephenowen6862hilarious
@@stephenowen6862😂
I feel like you guys are the only people out there who also believe the album is not good at all. Apart from 'Mother Nature's Song', which I really like by the way, all the songs are very same-y and don't offer anything inventive or interesting or novel. Even before the first single 'Just Another Rainbow' came out, people online had already pre-ordered the album before even listening to THAT single, which is just bizarre to me. Why would you pre-order an album without hearing it??? I'm glad you made this video because it's important to call out an artists' shit music, in your own opinion, despite being a fan. Oasis are my favourite band ever but I can openly say there's albums I don't like, even from Liam or Noel's. I feel like there's gonna be loads of hard-as-fuck fan boys who will defend anything Liam makes to the grave if you dare criticise it.
🤝
The most punk rock review of this album on the internet. Well done, guys. I've subbed.
You guys likely play zero instruments. Worst insight ever.
Bro they're all musicians XD
Three Fuds talking absolute bollicks!!!!!
I do love 90's indie music which obviously this record will appeal to, but would probably rank the new albums by Shed Seven and Cast above this record but Liam's voice does make so of the tracks sound massive
Agreed 👍
Nice click bait by 3 Druid looking boys 😅
Exactly have a look at their other video stats, quite embarrassing
That's what Ed Sheeran fans look like!
Sort of feel sorry for them really, they think music is these 30sec nonsense tiktok videos these days, you dont need an ounce of talent to make music now, so glad me and. Lot of you grew up with real music be thankful 😊
Out of Liam's 4 solo albums under his own name including this, I would probably rank this a clear 4, but that's still not a knock I enjoyed the album and collaboration and look forward to their next record together, gives Liam 2 careers now his solo stuff and his stuff with John, this album was always going to appeal to someone like me I enjoyed some of Beady Eyes stuff to like Soul love
You already went into this album with a negative mindset expecting it to be "shit" so doesn't even sound like you're giving it a chance. If you go into something already hating it then your brain is naturally going to perceive it in the worst way possible, especially if you're surrounded by an echo chamber of the same opinions & mindsets. Would have been more interesting if at least one of you liked it or had a different perception. Still, you're entitled to your opinion, but not sure if i see the point of reviewing an album you're just going to collectively shit all over, doesn't really achieve much in my opinion. Spread love
Worst music review of 2024 😂
Cost of living crisis is hitting these guys. I remember seeing John Squire on a show talking about his art and a question was put to him about music, he said music is a young mans game. Like the Rolling Stones should stop. I always thought that was rough given what great talent he had. But I respected it.
And now he’s up on stage again doin Rolling Stones covers. They sign off with sympathy for the weevil
Mother Natures Song is a really smooth and chilling song. I'm coming from the guitarist point of view. There's been a couple of people uploading covers of it but they're all playing the basic chords. It's pumped full of interesting melodies, and has a much more complicated structure than what it initially seems. Personally I'm just happy to see these two legends collaborating and giving Joe Public a summer album to get back into that vibe of the pure band vibes. Cash grab? I don't think so. I've never seen Squire bop around before, but he does when playing these songs. It's nice to see him in that kind of groove. But anyway, it's all opinion based I guess.
I love Liam and John but apart from Mars to Liverpool and You're Not The Only One I thought the album was dreadful. I'm going to see them play the album through in Paris next month. 50 quid ticket. Wish me luck.
Rather you than us mate! Enjoy🤝🏼
Cash grab really I don't think these 2 are hurting for cash
It’s the Millennial Nick Kent, Tony Parsons and Julie Birchill folks!
You have 6 thumbs up whilst the album sold 36k albums.. I hope you enjoyed the Britts, as I’m sure that’s more your thang 🎉
These guys wanked over the Glastonbury lineup
You see that CD that comes in a packet of Washing Powder plastic cover? Well, they should see who can fck this album into the washing machine first and don't forget to rinse the shite out of it. This is the type of album I'd expect from Forest Gump himself, it's that bad but at least I could say that Forest tried his best. And it just goes to show how the media and certain bands are all in each others pockets.
John Squire knew what he was doing using Laim Gallagher to open the door for him to cash in
What do you mean noel brought liam along liam asked noel to be in oasis 🖕
One word to describe your panel Is hummel
Could’ve been so great.. he needs to get Andrew Wyatt back on songwriting duties
It’s funny, as a 42 year old, I’ve never met someone smart enough to claim them as dumb. One can listen to Keith Jarret, The Smile, Peter Gabriel and still get a buzz of this - you guys just missing it
Basically these 3 don't know music cos been brought up with souless drivvle pre program shit
Glasto 94, Maine Road 95, Earls Court, Clapham Grand and never became a fan. Gave up in the end when I discovered Interpol.
Man this comment section goes so hard.
I wouldn't agree to such an extent on ur take but its definitely a very underwhelming work, not that i was expecting a lot anyway lol
Ha ha ha , love your comments and opinions lads , I quite like the album but I think it’s more nostalgic than anything , and music is all subjective so respect your views , ps - some of the lyrics on this album I think are wrote in fucking crayon 🖍️ there that bad …. 😂
Just another rainbow is my fave so far ,the new mgmt lp isn't good enough but hopefully a grower
Holy shit guys you riled these Oasis stans up, got them out here calling you names! Keep winning Fools u the goats!
After reading all of the many glowing, fawning reviews from 50 year old blokes in baggy coats, I’m glad I’ve stumbled upon this and feel I am not alone in my huge bored indifference to this album.
Totally predictable, plodding structures and REALLY poor lyrics. I like some of Liam’s solo stuff and was a huge Oasis fan back in the day but my reaction to this was a jaw breaking fucking yawn.
Glad to see at least one person has some sense in these comments
It’s one of the best Albums These days..yes oasis is gone..time past by…these Giants Rock together..They Go on…defenitly maybe these fellas sing wonderwall 😢
Wasted my time listening to these nobodies .
What a totally rubbish podcast.
Definitely liked it more than these guys. I don't care about formulaic, creativity is overrated for me
this is an awful take. I listened to the album and it’s very well written and recorded despite not knowing much about squire or gallagher or the UK 90’s scene. I’m canadian. judging by the other comments, most agree with me.
also cash grab claim isn’t really based on reality, i’m assuming both of these artist are already loaded.
I still like the Voice of LG. It is his own Style. On a meta level this means trust yourself and develop your opinion. This is the meaning for me.
Nice Nickelodeon and SpongeBob font on display.
'I think everyone should grow out of Oasis/Stone Roses at our age' jesus, seriously? Come on lads, get off your high horse & let people enjoy the music. I know the fanbase can be full of old haircuts but takes like those make it hard to take your reviews seriously.. again just clearly wasn't an album meant to be reviewed by people who go into it with preconceptions. but like i said before, u can do whatever u want. at least you got me commenting lol
F N SQUIRE.. SIT THERE LAD AND DO WHAT I SAY.. says ( the one trick voice, and the only influence he could muster on "Jools" were the "Rose's".. tit. Scotland has spoken but I'll be at the gig giving esquire pelters! I've done more with my life since they came on the scene.. which is never what I hoped for,aye Squire is an inventive guitarist.. just not here..oh man I and my poor poor "Rose's Troglodytes".. are like fk sq and Lm..we are all thinking that they are two faced back stabbing desperado's..who have forgotten their band roots!.. no worries boys I'll be there with some veryyy old eggs!!!
I didn't like it at first but listened to it loads cos I was going to watch them. Now I think it's good
i think the album is dull. I was so looking forward to it. Formulaic is exactly how it feels. No real attitude
Few giggling kids
For guys in their 20's you are disappointingly dismissive. Interested to know if you have any artists or music which you deem as timeless? (And who that is?)
Alot of Squire and Gallagher fans independently will deem both to be able to do no wrong. Not saying the album is amazing btw but you are a harsh reflection of youth reviews.
Liam and John need to go back to copying nursery rhymes in order to get a few hits. One decent song for me which is Rainbows, in fact it blows anything else away on this what can be deemed only a "cash grab." album. The lyrics could have stolen from a five year but Liam and John will still take all the credit. 4/10 and i'm being very kind.
Ain't heard the album but I'm not fond of the artwork.ha
Good input Tony.
As a big fan of liams i have to agree, cmon you know was a lot better imo
Ah 3 idiots...
Raise Your Hands, Mars to Liverpool, Just Another Rainbow and Mother Nature's Song are good tunes. The rest of the tracks are forgettable.
A generous review
Yes I agree, more of a pink floyd fan, I like well researched lyrics, and plenty of insights. Fairly boring album. I Couldn't even listen to all the songs.
Hahaha BS. This shit is next level. Just watch the live performances. Hendrix and the Beatles would have been watching from the crowd if this came out in the sixties.
good review lads. looking fwd to seeing the avalanch of Adidads and Pretty Weans screaming abuse at you in these comments - already started. agreed w Cal, the chorus of M2L is actually ok. Biggest enduring disappointment is that the man who created an entire album around the concept of situationism (Paris '68) and who wrote tunes like Love Spreads and Standing Here virtually with his eyes closed, is now churning out shite like this. such is life i guess.
The easiest thing in the world is to criticise other peoples work. Let's hear or see some of your original ???? work.
Solid meat and potatoes indie rock album, Liam's voice full of swagger and personality, lyrics might not be up to much but who cares, I guess you guys would pan Lennon's I am the egg man lyrics to as being meaningless word soup, if you enjoy Liam you will enjoy this album, is it high art with political deep lyrics, no and nor is it attempting to be
It’s pretty dire
Bellends.
Who are these three 🪖
Fuck stains.
Get a grip, it’s better than anything in the charts by a mile music is dead in this country, it’s only existing artists than can do great music because millennials haven’t got a clue what good music is
Well said. I think these dumbheads don't know sh*t about good music. They can suck on it! Liam is one of the last Rockstars on this planet, and he is doing pretty well these days, coming from one of the greatest band ever - Fuk'n OASIS! 😎
Plenty of great new music out there other than this tired and recycled drivel
Like what??
@@FoolsHQ
@@HarryDeanotake your pick Album Reviews
czcams.com/play/PL2UAfDwAuzRKBhwp-fec7SoJxluo7TTpC.html
@@FoolsHQ nothing on there worth listening too tbh
the fact this video already has far more views than any video`s you have put out about modern music artists says it all
although i do agree some what, im not the biggest fan of this album
Not a good day for positive thinkers
Cal is hilarious.
3 philosophers talking about a life they don't live, ridiculous
Well it's nothing new but that's isn't the decider on whether it's good. It's a simple rock n roll record, basic tunes embellished by Gallagher and Squires brilliance. And yes, everyone is free to critique art. I'd argue that few do it with such awful smugness as yourselves.
Well I love it😂!
John Squire made a half decent album 35 years ago and has done nothing of note since. Oasis made music for people that don’t like music. Why would anyone think that this album would be any good?
Talking some shit
These 3 guys look like they lay flowers every year for Viola Beach, it's not a great album but it certainly isn't as bad as you lot make out, 5 really good tracks on it to be fair
I think its Pretty good!
What a bunch of.
Nonsense it’s a great album
Silly boys
Go play with your one direction mate s
Dreadful album. Rehash of old crap, but done more badly. The guitar riffs, the vocals, the lyrics, the songs, absolutely bollocks. Liam now sings like Mr Punch and John Squires is irrelevant. I can't believe I spent money on actually buying this shiiiiiiiiittttee. It's taking the ****.
It's a pretty bad album & these 3 are grim little nerds - both things can be true.
Agree totally!lol unlistenable
I think it's a great album
I just took a look at the track titles and said yeh these guys are struggling
😂😂😂
Genuinely one of the worst albums i've ever heard.
As a 50 year old i can 100% say Liam Gallaghers biggest talent was convincing people he had talent. Absolutely loved definitely maybe when it was released and still do now but the albums got progressively worse unfortunately. John squire was always a talented guitarist so here we are in 2024, oasis and the roses long gone, and left with this lazy sheeeeeeeiiiiiiiittttttte. It certainly wont be the worst album of the year though just not a very good one.