The Mandalorian Luke Skywalker Deepfake
Vložit
- čas přidán 20. 12. 2020
- ► Paperspace is the computing cloud platform built for the future to power a wide range of next-generation applications. Learn more at: www.paperspace.com
Get $10 free credit using this link: bit.ly/3sgZeQF
Special thanks to Jarkan.
Be sure to check out his channel for some great deep fake videos:
/ jarkancio
♦ Twitter: / sham00k
♦ Instagram: / sham.00k
♦ Discord: / discord
♦ Contact: shamookdeepfakes@gmail.com
► Deepfakes are synthetic media in which a person in an existing image or video is replaced with someone else's likeness leveraging powerful techniques from machine learning and artificial intelligence.
► Created using DeepFaceLabs
github.com/iperov/DeepFaceLab
github.com/MachineEditor/Mach...
#Deepfake #TheMandalorian #Skywalker - Krátké a kreslené filmy
Unfortunately there isn't much I can do to improve the animation/mouth syncing, if I had acess to the body double footage before they applied the CGI, deep fake would be a definite improvement.
Hopefully they release some behind the scenes footage eventually so I can give that a try.
Also, I only had 4 days spare to do this deepfake before the holidays, I'm not 100% happy with the quality but here it is anyway.
Enjoy!
Knowing how quick you put out the deepfake (relative to when episode came out), Disney should hire you to work on the deaging process in films, especially since they've done it in other media before.
This is phenomenal! I was waiting for you to do this - already a huge improvement! I keep thinking Disney will learn and quit making this weak mistake.
If I may ask, roughly how much money did you spend to make this happen?
Why doesn't disney use the same technology?
@@hidir3532 I think it has to do with using in-house technology and not wanting to use better alternatives. ILM probably designed and implemented the tech used to de-age characters for Star Wars. They probably know of the deepfakes but most likely stick with the deaging cgi because they are most familiar with it (rather than learning how to do deepfakes).
@@hidir3532 Yeah, i'm also having a hard time trying to understrand that...
Absolutely nailed Luke's CGI in Boba Fett tonight. Well done sir.
Yeah shamook bro well done , loved it
This!
I was about to say. He did a very fantastic job.
came to see this comment
For real!!!
The fact you were hired by lucusfilm after making this makes this so much better
Was he actually hired? I highly doubt such thing, could you show sources if you believe he was? Companies don't do things like this often, so I was really wondering.
@@qe9573 yes he was, he confirmed it in the comments of his last video (Pattison/Batman deepfake)
@@shoemakerluis That's really cool
yup watched this cause i saw that dude got hired by ILM. thats awesome
There r good and not as good people at all companies. I guess not all CZcamsrs r ticks lol
*Great job on episode 6. It's like they built a time machine and brought 80s Mark Hammil to the present. Thank you.*
Now if only they had someone to fix the voice so he doesn't sound like a robot. But great work visually! I was really excited to see your work Shamook!
@@laserbeamlightning It's Mark Hamill doing his best to sound like his old self
Came here to make this exact comment! I didn't check the episode credits, but I really want to hope you worked on this episode, because the difference in quality in Luke's appearance from the Mandalorian, and his appearance in Episode 6 of BoBF is night and day. Wow! Excellent work!
@@JTMaster Why not just hire the guy the cast as him in Battlefront 2? Would've been cool to just have Sebastian Stan play the role at this point
@@JTMaster In the behind-the-scenes of The Mandalorian S2, they explained that the voice was all AI, not Mark Hamill. I don't know if they used the same approach for BOBF, but if it sounds robotic as well it must be.
Congrats on the hire. The force is strong w/ CZcamsrs!
Shut up
@@micromacaroni2477stfu
Yall stfu
A surprise to be sure but a welcome one! To see you here
Thanks Swoozie very cool
Skin tone is a lot better. Deep fake also seems to add more textures to the face. The original just seems like it's airbrushed to the max lol.
Yeah but the expressiveness is still better in the original. The deepfake just looks dead.
Yeah it's better when you have a decent base.
The skin tone, the lips, the mouth shape, the moles, the scars, the eyes, even his fighting style was completely off and I just got done watching the OT movies as well as playing hundreds of hours of Battlefront 2 in which they completely NAILED Lukes fighting style (and pretty much each Jedi/Siths). This last scene was such a let down. Hell I still believe they did CGI Leia and Tarkin WAY more justice in the movies.
Well the old Star Wars movies are a bit more "textured" since they are older and we are used to see Mark Hamill that way so yeah, I prefer the deep fake one.
@@outlawzqc Same opinion. And edit was a little bit off. The color of the blade should remain a mystery till the elevator opened (we all knew who he was, but the suspense was there as well, but they showed the green too soon IMO). And that piruette with Force Push looked weird. Swooshing effect of the blade is very weak and was better even in Original Trilogy, here it lacks post-production.
Got no complains about Luke's presence, I was touched nonetheless, still love the scene, but from experienced filmmakers we should expect more than just good ideas.
Came here bc I found out you were hired by Lucasfilm/ILM
That is amazing and gives me hope for the future of the star Wars universe, congrats Shamook
but Lucasfilm released the original...so now this guy works under the same umbrella of too many cooks in the kitchen. he wasnt hired to run the department.
perspective folks, perspective
@@I_Shit_on_your_shit_point the cream rises to the top
@@bend5911 sycophantic simpletons cream themselves
im worry about this guy, he’s got a job
but what if disney fire him
and take shamook’s secret skill
and share with others
im still worry
@@joshuagraham2843 that should be the least of your worries
Dude, do you realize what you did? You opened up a whole new door in movie/tv making. You're an absolute legend. Luke in Ep. 6 of Boba Fett looked amazing. Like unbelievably good. I can see all the major film companies coming to hire you in the future if they haven't already. Great job man, absolutely great job.
They probably already are.
Disney hired him.
Dude just watched episode 6 of Boba and all I can say is you have made so many star wars fans happy. You killed it on Luke man. Had my eyes playing tricks on me. I couldn't believe what I was looking at. Out of this world. Please never leave Lucasfilm. Convince them to do a Luke show based on the feedback you are getting on all your videos right now!!!
If only they got a real impressionist to dub for Luke instead of their AI voice and then it would be perfect
Making videos on CZcams doesn't get you a job.
Shamook: Hold my lightsaber.
*lightsaber
*Grogu
Actually it did Juan Marin. So YOU hold his lightsaber little prick!
"Hold my lightsaber?"... Lets have a chat down at HQ son.
@@martinbrancato5390 Read his whole comment before you get aggressive. I´m assuming english is not your first language.
You did such an amazing job! Very smart move by Lucasfilm to enlist your awesome talent!
**SPOILERS**
The Luke in tonight’s episode was perfect… thank you and everyone who worked on it! I absolutely love it!
It was genuinely the best they will ever do. I was close to tears. This all but confirms they should do a Luke tv series like holy hell that would be disgustingly amazing. That’s how you make everyone sign up to Disney +
@@haydenpettit3392 dude that would be the coolest show in the world. There is so much about Luke I want to know about
@@Kaaos_ yeah sorry, added a few more lines so it should be good now
The eyes have so much more life , didn’t realise how dead the original ones look , nice work!
If you didn't notice how death the first one was before this video I don't know what to say
@@amvchannels3458 nah, neither did i
well but they move less naturally with deepfake.
It was the first thing I noticed in the original, the eyes look terrifying
@@Szellah7 the originals are of a guy in his late 60s, vs a fake one of course.
I am proud that You are hired at lucasfilm because of this deepfake.
Are you his dad?
proud is the way to the dark side...
Why?
I look forward to the retro update!
A surprise to be sure, but a welcome one.
Congratulations!! Episode 6 was a freaking seamless!! So happy they hired you!! Hopefully they will ask you to redo this sequence in the Mandalorian ala “special edition” and then the circle will be complete…
Just saw chapter 6 of Book of Boba Fett and if you were behind the Luke's deepfake... You sir are a genius. That looked unbelievable
He was the person behind it looking so good!!!!!
Haha, upon instant viewing of that episode; I knew you were gonna deepfake it! And it looks spectacular! The eyes in particular are a massive improvement, so much more life in them. Kudos.
Looks much better
As you would say, fuckin’ A! 😁
The mouth still looks weird but not knowing anything about making deepfakes im guessing they're really hard to get right
I said myself the same thing
Yeah, Luke doesn't look like a PS3 game character anymore! The only thing that needs improvement is the mouth, but there's not much to be done with that.
When I first watched the episode, I said “they should’ve used deepfake technology instead. It would’ve looked more realistic.”
Yeah just they ran out of budget (or at least thats what was speculated)
@TGDS well they used Mark's face and de-aged him while this video used his face when he was younger and applied it to Luke. You can still see that it isn't perfect but it looks better than the original. Honestly though I think the editors were just lazy or something cause it could've been better even at their budget
@TGDS nah it was that CGI face tech they used in Rogue One.
@@epicvoiceguy Nope. It's deepfake.
@@epicvoiceguy no it’s been confirmed they used deep fake, but the best and most convincing deep fakes need a good movement mesh underneath to work with, and instead of just applying the deep fake to the face of the actor they used, there was a cgi layer in between, which is why he comes off so weird especially when speaking. They didn’t use mark hamil or Sebastian Stan as the body double for this Luke, so they had to try and fake a cgi face structure underneath to match some of Luke’s features so the deep fake wouldn’t come off misshapen.
Guessing it’s your work in Book Of Boba Fett Episode 6, Luke looked absolutely incredible. It is indeed a glorious time right now to be a Star Wars fan. Congratulations on getting the dream job.
I don't think so
@@danieldeleon1270 actually your wrong. This guys name is literally in the shows credits. He is now working for ILM and Lucas Arts. Google it.
@@danieldeleon1270 he works for them now
You worked on The Book of Boba episode right??? It looked incredible!
If Disney don't officially fix the episode, I'm going to edit this in to my own copy for all future viewing.
Even your CGI face looks more realistic than Disney's one! (also, Hi Amy! Love your videos!) ❤️
It is because it's a studio so they cannot use "programs" that he used. Lucasfilms made it like that for specific purposes.
@@user-mp3eh1vb9w Even if they can't use the same DF tools, there are still various other techniques that can be used to produce a much better job than they did. They really have no excuse. His eyes don't even have highlights! So dry.
Ditto
Do it!!!!
I was waiting on someone to do it better than Disney and I was not disappointed
Someone always does it better than Disney when it comes to the new Star Wars space junky.
@@rejuvinatez347 facts
🤔🤔
Bro how is this remotely better? It looks a little worse if you ask me
Doesn't disney believe in deep fake tech?
Well done on TBOBF Luke! Looking forward to more. I hope they let you officially redo Mando 2 at some point.
I know it was you who we have to thank for that ridiculously realistic young Mark Hamill on the latest episode of The Book Of Boba Fett. I cannot believe how real he looks!!
Please Disney, go back and re-edit this scene with Shamook, the scene is like 98% perfect and the episode is a masterpiece. Just give us that 100% and update the episode.
Yup, the original was a bit underwhelming
@@Ocker3 the fuck it was? It was absolutely mind blowing lol
@@PiperAtTheGatesOfYourMom see what happened to me was the title of a online article spoiled that Luke was going to show up, and then the CG just looked strange.
Same for Leia please !! 😍 And Tarkin !! That would be SO damn awesome !! I'm still pretty glad they did what they did, but being improved will surely make the impact of the moment so much better!! it's distracting when you realize it's artificial. With this technology you might stay in the moment as he/she was really there! 😍
@@alfanovanta Absolutely!! Definitely have him redo the Leia and Tarkin CGI! I would actually watch the movie again just to see that improvement. The original Mandalorian Luke was good, but watching fake Leia and Tarkin just made me regret people have to die.
Just for fun, you should deep fake Sebastian Stan's face onto Luke, see how he would have looked in the role.
Sebastian Stan looks so much like the original that it would make no difference! 😆
there was a reason why they didn't cast him though
@@lag00n54 yea because they wanted to pay tribute to Mark for his debut. They're not gonna do this all the time. Lol
It would be great!
or Anakin’s! oooo😮
what a superb cg in boba Fett episode 6
Hats off to you
Just watched the latest episode of book of boba. Bro! You SMASHED it. There are no words! Huge respect and admiration goes your way!!!
The marvelous deepfake that landed him a job at Lucasfilm.
*Industrial Light and Magic.
@@rickylovesyou which is part of it... So you're point? Jeeze
@@rickylovesyou 🤡
This is wayyyy better. The original face the eyes don't have focus.
Yeah like a blind person speaking....
"This isnt my best work" - Shamook
"Hold that thought" - Lucas Films
Fantastic work on book of boba man! The team delivered.
If Disney could remove Jeans Guy, I hope this scene will get fixed too.
Whats jeans guy?
I hope they can fix his mouth. I know the deep fake didn’t have much to go on but both sides he looked so stiff when talking
@@gold333 a regular guy working on the set in a t-shirt and jeans was briefly standing in a hallway in a shot during an episode and a couple days later they digitally removed him.
Edit: similar in scope to when a Starbucks cup was left in a shot for an episode of Game of Thrones. HBO had it removed after it was noticed.
Yeah that was my exact thought
As soon as I saw CGI Luke I said "can't wait for the better version Deep Fake on YT."
Same, I thought damn even on CZcams deepfakes are better done, and even longer!
It’s not better though! It’s just brighter with a dot of light in his eyes
@@TheTruth-13 yeah but it changes everything, the scene is more alive
@@schtemeul yeah right you mean brighter😂😂
@@TheTruth-13 Stop spamming your copium everywhere dude. lol
Luke in Book of Boba Fett looks incredible. It is indistinguishable to me from reality. I'm assuming that's because of you. So glad they hired you, instead of suing you for making them look bad!
CONGRATS for todays episode :O
The deep fake does better with Luke's eyes.
Does Luke blink?
but does a worst job with the lips , unfortunately
😯😯
Agreed. Great work with the eyes. Lips not so much.
Yup. Has highlights and life.
It's the cloudiness in the eyes of the original that really takes me out. That and the lack of mouth movement when he speaks. I know you said mouth movement cant be helped and I understand that, just fixing the clarity of the eyes goes a long way to improving this.
Just need to use the eyes from this footage and the lips from the original.
For me, it's the skin. His skin looks way too perfect. The deepfake looks superior not just cuz he adds that spark back into the eyes, but the subtle imperfections into the skin that add so much character.
@@WobblesandBean yes you're right, it looks way to smooth.
Takes you out? Glad to know I didn’t ruin my own experience like you did
@@TheTruth-13 The experience is godly and I personally wasn't taken out of the moment. The CG is still pretty good! It just can be a bit frustating if you know about deepfakes and how it easily could have been even better.
Incredible job with the recent BOBF episode 🙌🏻
Hey, I don't know if you were repsonsible for a certain character's CGI in BOBF, but either way I just want to say well done, you are rekindling the star wars magic in our hearts.
Again they used the wrong technique...Use Bucky from Winter Soldier as the stand-in, already looks 90% like Mark Hamill...you then add minimal Deep Fake CGI to the nose and mouth distances etc, not even touching eyes and mouth much.....
Now that is an excellent idea
Honestly I wouldn’t have been upset at all if they just had Bucky play Luke!
Or just pass the mantle to bucky and accept that hes the new luke
It wouldn't be the same.. This had Mark Hamill.. And was De aged... Mark deserves this
Lol but they would’ve had to spend a ridiculous amount of money to get Sebastian, especially if he’s just a stand in.
His face looks loads better, the animation is still off but that's based on the original animation so not a lot you can do... amazing work
Exactly right. People don't seem to understand how deepfakes work in it being a nearly completely automated process once the images are uploaded. No or very little manual animation is done after that.
So the only reason some of the mouth and head movements are still off is because the underlying animation of them was poorly executed. Had the deepfake been done over better animation or better yet, a live actor, the mouth and other animation would've been seamless.
Carrie Fisher deepfaked in Rogue One had the same issue for the identical reason. Whereas Harrison Ford deepfaked in Solo looked incredible (aside from Alden's square jaw/head which still bled through) because it was done over a live actor.
That being said, Hamill's deepfake here still looks infinitely better than what we had before.
@@boomieboo is it bad that I don’t see anything wrong with Luke’s face?
CGI biggest problem are the Eyes 👀, this version got the better ones so it looks more natural!
@@jonnieleewalker5164 for this particular case though it's not only the eyes .. which do feel dead yes.. but it's also mouth movement that looks here like luke had a stroke and the lips just don't move right anymore.. and also the editing cuts were off, around the neck and around the hood and around everything really .. Personally it just took me off the moment , but other than that i liked what they did with the scene and Luke.
@@alejandromate4071 I agree. For me its a problem with the top lip not moving. It's just completely stiff, and that's not how human mouths work. Sure, the upper lip doesn't move as much as the lower, but they definitely take on shape when forming sounds. Not enough cgi art gets this right, and that accounts for a lot of the uncanny Valley imo.
Awesome work on the latest BOBF episode. Thanks man! To you and everyone who worked on it.
The Luke that appeared today was goddamn fire, hats off to you and the team
Congratulations on being hired by Disney. I hope you go to Marvel too.
Then we can have T'Challa back, atleast for a little bit
@Crimson The Thunder Knight Such great philosophy. We only CGI shit actors. Or is it the other way around? 🧐
Corporate wants you to find the difference.
@@KNG-fm1kj Or just recast him the guy was playing a character not the character is him. Happened with dumbledore, been waiting 14 years for black panther since I was a child.
*ILM, not Disney
Bro. Send this as your resume to Disney or Corridor Crew
2021 Edit: Congratulations buddy! You did it! (:
Shout out to Corridor Crew for being the reason I know what’s wrong with Luke’s face in this scene
@@carterfriske4516 haha I thought the same damn thing
Funny you say this, I commented about this guy on one of their latest uploads. Hopefully they’ll read it.
Bruh deepfaking is not hard hahahaha
@@badassgaming01 Creating a decent deep fake is relatively easy, yes. But creating a near perfect one is unbelievably difficult. Considering the best VFX company in the world, ILM, still struggles with this, I respectfully disagree with you.
Episode 6 of BoBF absolutely BLEW me away. You did a fantastic job. There was only one shot where his face was turned to the left where it looked a little off to me, but overall, I was mesmerized by your work! I hope they can continue to work on Luke's voice though, it still sounds a little robotic at times
Lucasfilm made the right decision hiring you! That newest episode of Boba Fett was mind blowing
The fact you got overall a much better quality in such a small time frame is nothing short of absolutely amazing work. Well done.
I think the one on the the left is supposed to look like Sebastian Stan mixed with Hamill. So when Stan takes the role it's a lot smoother for the audience
@@BadluckTribe I heard they used up all the money for their budget for the other episodes and the finale was where they had to cut corners. I’m not sure tho
Makes since. People seem to forget this is a TV series budget not a movie budget. This is one of the most perfect seasons for a TV series I've seen they did amazing and the fact the only thing people dislike out of the whole season is just a kinda crappy luke is great
I get that this looks good. But adding a deep fake luke onto a cgi luke is not impressive. Adding a deep face luke onto someone else is difficult. This deep fake is good but you have to remember the original artists were working on someone that didn't look like luke or at least had to de-age mark hamil
@@rosswilkes7817 Are you sure?
I suspect deepfaking a lookalike actor yields better results than deepfaking a CGI attempt.
I just love how Mando without helmet just looks confused the whole time
No he looks sad
BROOOOOO THAT NEW EPISODE HE LOOKS SO GOOD
Incredible work. Can’t stop thinking about how good that episode was and it’s all thanks to you!
The deepfake makes the original look like a PS3 cutscene.
I'd say PS4 at least... but yeah, the deepfake looks way better, especially the eyes.
@@TheMorbidOtaku That's fair.
@@TheMorbidOtaku The eyes look better in a still image, they are both still lifeless looking however
The original is deepfake too by the way...
Lol it already looks like a PS3 cutscene
But a really epic one
Much better than billion dollar company
Als ob ich dich hier finde 😀
Moin
I think the time wasn't in their side
Just to let you know as a professional 3D artist. It is extremely easier to apply a deepfake on top of a face that looks already similar to the target image, rather than a face that is entirely different. So them applying a deepfake on top of the already CGI-ed face made it not only way easier, less time consuming but also made it look way better. However, if you were to add deepfake on top of the original actor it wouldn't have worked, and there are millions of examples of how bad it looks online, when the face shape doesnt match. Also shows work on very tight schedules, and even deepfakes require a lot of time and you do not have much control over the outcome, making it almost worthless in production as it is right now.
@@farrex0 this guy did it shortly after, yes disney made it from scratch but why did they not apply the deepfake after?
Amazing Work on today's episode!!
You worked on this recent episode! Bravo! 👏👏👏 Thank you for bringing *him* back lol
How to make any CGI character look better:
Brighten the eye color and give them twinkles.
Glad I'm not the only one saying this. It's such a common missing detail, that's easily fixed.
Yeah. The lack of eye glint is what makes him look dead. Video game company Valve realised this in 2004, so they wrote code specifically to make sure character eyeballs always had a glint on them. The deep fake fixes that, and even though it makes the rest of the face look overly painterly, it's still enough of an improvement.
the glint/twinkle is specifically called a "catch light" in photography.
Amazing job with the lack of facial movement from the original replacement. Looked more like the Luke I watched growing up and I spent less time in that uncanny valley. Why don't the big studios use this technology when it seems to provide so much more? Thanks for doing this. Seasons Greetings!
I think they don't want deep fake to become popular so we can't put our favorite 13 year old disney princesses on...stuff.
Because they go to people who have been specialising in CGI for years. Doing it via CGI requires a lot of skill and can only be done by a few people in the world. Many times that number could use deep fake. It ceases to be something that is rare and can be charged at a premium rate. Consequently, they have a financial motive not to change.
*waves* Hello from FPV world :-)
@@jamesfx2 bro, there are apps on your phone for free which can "deepfake" better than disney did for this episode. It's AI doing it not some tech wizard
I think they did use a deep fake for the original but they rushed it. You have to train these things
I came here specifically to congratulate you on Boba Episode 6- it looks vastly improved, especially around the sharper jawline in some scenes, his eyebrows doing some of the talking for him, some of the cheek movements from the teeth clamping together- and some of the lip movements from where I think Hamill used to- maybe it's called swallowing words? Something I remember also about his speech is he tends to also kinda smile/leave his mouth open when he speaks on something he is certain about/ has made peace with. I hope you continue to build on it !
Came after the latest episode and I think this guy worked on it , Luke Skywalker looks amazing
dude I was searching for his name in the credits lmao, Luke looks SO much better!
@@TheChiptuner You find him?
@@justaname1345 No, but I was looking for their username, I don’t know their real name
Where can I learn this power?
Shamook: "Not from Disney"
Hahahahhaha
?
😁👍👍
"not from a mouse" would have been better but ok
jajaja!!! muy bueno.,,., (cuando leo "no de disney", ya me vino la cara de palpatine en el teatro..)
It’s all about they eyes, the key to the soul. Improvement compared to the original, hope they consider this deepfake.
Exactly. The eyes are so key.
And subtle mouth movement .
Right?? And the skin is too perfect, it's actually distracting. The deepfake looks much more real, because it adds back in those subtle imperfections. It still looks uncanny, but that's because the deepfake is simply overlaid on an already flawed template. Whoever did the original really did a poor job. The mouth movement is just straight up awful, and the eyes are lifeless. Jedi are stoic, but they're not completely devoid of emotion.
It's too bad there's no mock awards show for the Emmys, like The Razzies are to the Oscars, cuz this would definitely win most poorly animated 😂 Which is a shame, cuz they absolutely nailed it for lil' Grogu. Did Mark Hamill even perform for the template? Or is Luke entirely CG? I know they used a body double, but it doesn't specify in what capacity. I don't know if what we're looking at is Mark Hamill standing there with CG elements blocked over it, or if it's the nameless body double with Mark's facial performance.
It doesn't help that CGI Luke barely blinks. I think he only blinked 1x through the entire thing -when he bent down to pick up Grogu
Similar in the movie King Kong (2005) they would always have a fake highlight in the eyes of Kong. In its death scene the highlight disappears. As if the life and soul leaves the body. It's super subtle, but genius.
Reminder: The Book of Boba Fett Chapter 6 would be impossible without this man.
Love you boss
Was that your work in EP6 of Boba Feet? Yooo, congrats! And nice job!
Disney Exec.: "Some kid... on the internet... was able to make this in a cave! With a box of scraps!!!"
Disney Engineer: "Well im sorry... im not some kid on the internet..."
I understood that reference!
@@tsunamifoxy SMH
@@tsunamifoxy I understand that reference to understanding that reference
Lmao 🤣
@@hoffmanmoore7630 I understand that reference to understand that reference to "I understand that reference to understand that reference"!
The thing that bothers me the most is that when he says “permission” his lips don’t even touch
In the original or the new one?
@@The_Gallowglass both I think
Both. Lips hardly move. Like a ventriloquist.
@@OwenGebhard Yeah, but in some frames, it looks like the one on the right is worse. Still overall the texturing and Mark Hamil look is far more realistic in the new one.
That's alright. Go back and watch Empire in the swamp scene. When Luke says "If he even exists" - he didn't move his mouth at all. ;)
Good job on the latest episode!
Thank you for everything book of boba fett episode 6 cgi and voice amazing
Deep fake doesn’t fix the core issue of the original. The face is simply not expressive enough. There is zero emotion or expression in anything. His eyebrows hardly move his lips move only when absolutely necessary. It looked like Disney just tried to play it super safe by not messing up the face model too much but the end result looks so bad in motion. The deep fake did fix a lot of the details on the skin which many already mentioned but it’s still in the uncannny valley for me.
exactly
The results are def better when deepfakes are used on an actual actors face
It's because Tarkin in Rogue One was too expressive to the point where his movements looked way too fluid and not realistic. Like you said, I think they tried to minimize the risk of that and completely over shot this time. Luke is kind of like a walking corpse. He makes no sudden movements or facial expressions, and he's got "dead eyes" :/
They need the original take without the deep fake
Well, other than the expression part, I can vouch that the deepfake one looks more surreal especially with the eyes being right, nevertheless. Its still a better part compared to the Disney 💩
The deepfake definitely looks better, but only when Luke is NOT talking. When he talks, the lips don't sync with the audio. If there's a way to fix that, then the deepfake would win hands down.
There is a way to fix that, using a real person as Luke and using deep fake on top. It would be awesome.
It is my understanding that you are working now for Disney / Star Wars right?
So I was wondering if it was you that worked at the Deepfake Luke Skywalker that was in The Book Of Boba Fett S1E6? :D
the fact that grogu is currently mastering the force is a masterpeice AND I CANT WAIT FOR IT man i hope next season takes as long as they want just make sure its perfect
All the resources at Disney are outdone by a guy on his laptop.
More like a guy with two 2080Ti's in NVLink. Deep fakes need A LOT of processing power. But I know you're just joking :)
@@MrFahrenheit2k I use a single Quadro P6000
@@Shamook I could pull it off with a Geforce 256 and Paint! :P
@@Shamook boom, roasted.
heu... deepfake has been make on the original who was already retouch, so its not "one guy"... and only apply on front face, all the side, and looking bot are very bad with deepfake... so here they just dont do.
Someone, Disney, holywood, whoever - hire this guy already!
Doesn’t eve. Look better! Look at his nose. All he did was get rid of the facial hair, and made him a bit brighter with a dot in his eyes lmao
@@TheTruth-13
What are you talking about lmao it looks much better, if you think you can do it better, good for you
@@Detective_Deadblue 1:21 yeah this looks much better😂😂
Man... Yo... Right!
@@TheTruth-13
You should consider going to an eye doctor
Congratulations for getting hired for Luke in Boba Fett! Awesome, and SOOOO much better!
I saw the new episode of The Book of Boba Fett, with Luke on it, and I assume that is your work. I just can say that it's incredible.
It definitely could have been better if he had the original actor footage. You can't make the middle of the face look better if it wasn't moving much, to begin with in the source material (the version we have now). I'm so surprised they didn't go with the deepfake route because it would have looked so much better than what we got.
nothing is perfect its about the feeling and story of seeing luke not about the eyes ore mouth its about luke
@@Zap319 yeah, the bad CGI took me out of the feeling.
When I first saw this scene I thought they hired a Luke lookalike. This deep fake is so much better and it's actually is recognizable as Luke. The CG is actually really amazing and realistic, but the main problem is that it just looks like a different person.
@undy - a Luke-alike
@@Zap319 maybe if they didnt toss Boba Fett into the series. It feels like they are just cramming nostalgia into it because they can.
The fact that Lucasfilm has hired him makes me hope they’ll update the scene to this version.
better than that, Book of Boba Fett ep 6 with soooo much more screen time and so much better!
the fact that this isn’t even the best you could do excites me for the future of star wars
After watching BOBF chapter 5 I Can’t wait to see this work on screen next episode 🙏
This looks so much better, even the eyes look alive.
Yo fr that’s what I’m saying
It's especially better in the eyes. The rest is a slight improvement that makes it even more accurate, but the eyes is what it makes the big difference here.
Except the mouth movement looks worse
Impressive.
Most impressive.
A surprise to be sure, but a welcome one.
You've controlled your fear. Now release your anger!
This is where the fun begins!
My boy Holden!! Love your videos man!!
Nice
Fucking amazing work on bobf ep 6. It’s literally insane
Coming back here after watching latest episode or Boba Fett and hoping that the improvements in the CGI were all your doing cause if so outstanding job!
The biggest problem with the original is the lip movement, it's almost non-existent and doesn't affect the rest of the face, it's like he's had a ton of botox. The words don't match the mouth shape at all. E.G. The 'Nothing' in "Talent without training is nothing" line doesn't match at all. That's what the real problem is. And that same problem remains with the deepfake. Fixing the mouth alone would improve this more than anything.
Yeah, deepfake can’t fix bad animation.
That and the lack of facial expression, yeah he's a Jedi and they're supposed to be emotionless but he's basically a robot lol.
I’m not sure why they didn’t use Deepfake at this point. That was my first thought when I originally saw this scene.
Totally agree
I'm not saying that I necessarily disagree with you I just want you to do me a quick favor and say the word nothing out loud while looking in a mirror.
I mean the internet is full of deep fakes. Why hasn’t anyone at Disney figured out this is better? Are they too old or something?
Maybe they’ll go back and deep fake it who knows
They should adapt to it already
I think they need to hire this guy to do it. I hope they become aware of his talents here!
They're stubborn. That's my guess.
What they did was deepfakes. Atleast part of it maybe like the mouth and eyes.
I have never seen deep fake so good in tbobf ep6! Ever. I tought they hired a new actor. Good job!
Wow, your work in TBoBF episode 6 is so believable. What talented skill! Thank you!
Holy shit, I don't understand why Hollywood doesn't implement this technology, it looks way better
The reason behind it might be that it is a controversial issue because some people use deepfake to put Hollywood actresses' faces on porn stars. It can be that Hollywood is afraid to use deepfake in their official materials because it could be interpreted that they legitimise that aspect as well.
A deepfake on CZcams only needs to be at 1080p resolution, but a professional effects company working on TV and feature films needs a neural net that can be trained on faces and generate them at 4K or even 8K. That's going to take a lot of time and computing power. This deepfake is pretty good, but at 1:05, the deepfake doesn't have the amused expression Luke is supposed to get from seeing R2 interact with Grogu.
@@Prosaicus
With brutal render farms (can't imagine how gigantic is the one used by pixar)... it's a question of hours, even in 8K
@@Prosaicus Well, take into account that this deepfake had the shitty cgi Luke as a reference. If we would have access to the mocap footage, I'm pretty sure the deepfake would turn out much better.
DEEPFAKE: skin tone is better. Eyes are better. Shadows are better. ORIGINAL ILM: details movements are better. Im stunned for this!!!
It would be more perfect if they were not using CG, using a random real person to be as Luke and using deepfake to change his face.
if the person who did the deep fake had the mocap/original actor data if would be almost perfect and 10x better than the weird cg they decided to do
Lighting is much better on original.
The deepfake is better in details, but moves like a rubber mask. All deepfakes look like that to me, so I don't think I'd blame it all on the source being a processed (de-aged) image. Rubber mask face is a characteristic of deep fakes.
The eyes are unnaturally lit up on the deep fake and the mouth is worse off. Prefer the cheeks
Thanks for episode 6. Amazing work!
DUUUUUDE SHAMOOK , the new cgi deepfake on episode 6 of book of boba.... OMG thank you! What a work of art.. i was speechless
I cant wait to show my dad!
Luke: "Talent without training is nothing"
Rey: 🖕
Talent without training leads to matte Luke face.
Wasn't she trained with Luke and Leia in the trilogy?
If the issue that she was using the force in the first film before she was training, remember how easily/quickly using the force came to Luke in New Hope, before he had any real training with Yoda.
Bro din djarin beat gideon with no training, guess hes a mary sue too then?
@@squarehead3336 No training? Every Mandalorian trains/prepares for battle on a daily basis
@@squarehead3336 Din was trained in the Fighting Corps by the Children of the Watch. We don't know whether Gideon had any kind of advanced combat training.
It's the eyes chico, they never lie.
I love you.
Exactly. It's all in the eyes. The originals are lifeless
Completely
Who here actually knows which movie the OP is quoting?
@@mikesgotniceice scarface
Good work on this week's episode
Luke looked F’ing amazing I was shocked. I thought he looked good the first time but my god. Amazing job on this Ep.
I'm grateful that we got Luke, but he looks like a deepfake of a deepfake.
This needs more likes
The original was a deepfake. You can see it glitching between images in the original. The show used a deepfake with bad reference material. The A.I. couldn't use it correctly. It must not have had enough time to render before the episode was set to air. They may update it later since it's a streaming show.
We need to go deep(fake)er...
Deepfake is purely data driven, which makes it unbiased. The problem with modern CGI "realism" is that animators go in with the preconceived notion that CGI is "stiff and robotic" and they overcompensate in the opposite direction. The result is something that looks TOO animated, TOO smooth, TOO subtle.
I think luke was supposed to look more like Sebastian Stan than Hamill
Disney CGI specialists: It's impossible.
Disney: Shamook made this in a cave! WITH A BOX OF SCRAPS!
Clearly he is not a Shamook
Tony Stark
Oh yes. i love this post
Disney CGI specialists: "Well, I'm sorry...I'm not Shamook"
I’m high right now and this made me laugh maybe more than it should have but either way I love you for that. That’s one of my favorite quotes ever even tho it’s pretty random
Came back to this video because of the newest episode! Amazing work!
Finally we can get a young Luke that doesn't look like crap