Inside the Mossad: Ronen Bergman in Conversation with David Sanger

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 31. 01. 2018
  • Since the founding of Israel in 1948, the nation has relied on its intelligence community and armed services to defend against those who would do it harm.
    And in Rise and Kill First: The Secret History of Israel’s Targeted Assassinations, veteran journalist Ronen Bergman - “arguably Israel’s best investigative reporter,” in the words of David Remnick - pulls back the curtain on the country’s most effective secret weapon. Hear gripping accounts of the dangerous missions undertaken by the Mossad, Shin Bet and the IDF to root out Israel’s enemies before they could attack the Jewish state. And explore the thorny ethical questions that Israeli forces have grappled with as they protected their homeland.
    Recorded on January 30th, 2018 at 92nd Street Y.
    Subscribe for more videos like this: bit.ly/1GpwawV
    Your support helps us keep our content free for all. Donate now: www.92y.org/donatenow?...
    Facebook: / 92ndstreety
    Instagram: / 92ndstreety
    Twitter: / 92y
    Tumblr: / 92y
    On Demand: www.92yondemand.org

Komentáře • 191

  • @KITO1966
    @KITO1966 Před 2 lety +35

    I'm reading this book and now seeing this interview was even better to understand a lot of what goes on with Israel. I respect and admire that country.

  • @hlysnan6418
    @hlysnan6418 Před 6 měsíci +3

    It's a remarkable book, and an extraordinary achievement of research and investigation.

  • @econometrics469
    @econometrics469 Před rokem +9

    13:36
    "You know there's an advantage to being hit by a mine in your spine; you get a certificate from a physician that you have a spine."
    -Meir Dagan

  • @puunersjabski6487
    @puunersjabski6487 Před 2 lety +6

    Totally trustworthy fellas here. No reason to lie

  • @jeremielendo1131
    @jeremielendo1131 Před 2 lety +8

    Several crucial times, Israel was left alone. That is a very good lesson to learn. At the end, the onlyone Israel´s allieds are Jewish People world. May Adonai be and remain over His chosen Land and chosen people. Blessed is His Name.

  • @rocketman48
    @rocketman48 Před 5 lety +32

    Bergman is excellent in this interview ,cant wait to read the book.

    • @davj471
      @davj471 Před 4 lety

      👍🏼👍🏼

    • @srfotog
      @srfotog Před 3 lety +1

      The book is fascinating, which is good because it's around 700 pages. I read it way into the night every night.

  • @tobiasgoldman
    @tobiasgoldman Před 2 lety +16

    What a great interview about some of the biggest heroes in Jewish history. G-d bless them.

  • @cesaradvincula2751
    @cesaradvincula2751 Před 3 lety +7

    Are they talking to themselves? I can barely hear the topic of the their discussions

  • @lepisrbenda
    @lepisrbenda Před 3 lety +9

    you can only say what you are allowed to say when it comes to intelligence and the secret service

    • @GiladGur
      @GiladGur Před 3 lety +4

      You are right. Bergman is a well informed journalist, and not a Mossad agend, so his knowledge is limited as well. Even Mossad agents don't have the big picture because of a notation called compartmentalisation. I believe He doesn't know much secrets.

    • @josephadler5663
      @josephadler5663 Před rokem

      Certain things HAVE to be compartmentalized . It saves the team like that, and BIG PICTURE can not be compromised .

  • @rogerswambua4053
    @rogerswambua4053 Před rokem

    Can someone tell me what's the title of the book??

  • @shaezmina
    @shaezmina Před 2 lety +4

    People will do whatever is needed to survive. It is wired into our gene structure from time immemorial. The ones that survive will replicate further due to their fit for the environment they must survive in whilst others will be obliterated because they could not cope. I am not an Israeli but I suspect I understand this survival mentality that by and large the whole Israeli society has engendered post WW II. It tends to be a self perpetuating mindset that will further hone their skill in a very narrow set of talents since they exercise them so often with a disproportionate allocation of resources; whether that be time, people, money etc. There is however nothing remarkable to this tendency. Any society, group of people or even an individual can on average develop specialized skills at anything should there be enough allocation of time and effort and repetition. The one thing to observe though is that such a high degree of commitment to any goal does not last in perpetuity. Infact, it fades away when the perceptual or actual need (in this case external threats to Israel) moves more distant in space and time. One can see this phenomena playing itself out in the American Jewry which by and large has been shielded from any anti-semitism and have done rather well economically. The commitment to a survivalist cause within this community is dwindling rapidly and one might argue that over the course of another 50 years, it will be a distant memory unless of course a local or global event transpires to re-jog that zeal. Such are the cycles of human psychology which requires constant prodding in any case. Nevertheless, the interview is interesting as is the book. One can clearly see the impish glee in the body language, facial expressions and tone of voice of the author. I suspect there is something to his suggestion that "Israelis like to talk". Evidently, he does not share the view that his revelations might at any rate present a threat to the security of the state he is writing about.

  • @rpk5250
    @rpk5250 Před 2 lety +4

    Terrorism strikes at average people so why shouldn’t they be targeted when they’re doing typical things?

  • @CALISUPERSPORT
    @CALISUPERSPORT Před rokem

    There are way too many ads on this video...

  • @marysullivan3326
    @marysullivan3326 Před 2 lety +1

    What's the title of the damn book???!!!!!

  • @christineschmidt9846
    @christineschmidt9846 Před 4 lety +2

    Would have stop them

  • @jatwangismyname900
    @jatwangismyname900 Před 9 měsíci

    Low volume

  • @johnsutherland168
    @johnsutherland168 Před 4 lety +28

    By way of deception, thou shalt make war.

    • @mendoza4789
      @mendoza4789 Před 3 dny +1

      Booted from 109 countries with that mindset

  • @naoufal450
    @naoufal450 Před rokem +4

    Sounds like a mafia with good use of words

    • @TheHeavensFellen
      @TheHeavensFellen Před rokem

      well in fact Jews were the driving force in the American Mob syndicate, look for an article on this from Segula magazine out of Israel

  • @joevictor6815
    @joevictor6815 Před 3 lety +11

    Love for Israel from India - CUFI

    • @TheHeavensFellen
      @TheHeavensFellen Před rokem

      Wait, a christian, and in India? Gandhi saw a Jewish state in Palestine as a furtherance of the British- western meddling blueprint. Bang Bang, problem solved.

  • @mosesmusekiwa4842
    @mosesmusekiwa4842 Před 3 lety +17

    love Israel

  • @michaell8002
    @michaell8002 Před 9 měsíci

    Its a really good book but I don't see it as a celebration like a greatest hits album.

  • @CraigTalbert
    @CraigTalbert Před 5 měsíci

    49:39 woah

  • @billybelk1831
    @billybelk1831 Před 4 lety +8

    I read his book. It is just a rehash of other previous books on the subject. I didn;t learn anything.

    • @martinmartinmartin2996
      @martinmartinmartin2996 Před 3 lety +2

      In the USA there are 3or (8?) intel agencies . TRUE, look it UP : how an FBI agent reported WEEKS BEFORE 9/11 that non-citizen Arabs were taking a course in Florida "How to take off a complex Boeing 747 " but not learning how to land A Boeing 747 !

  • @georgialynnjones3955
    @georgialynnjones3955 Před 4 lety +1

    inside mossad see other lettter. max grandmother,me.

  • @user-cg7uv3mh9f
    @user-cg7uv3mh9f Před rokem

    Fantastic book. Shame about the crap volume, so I didn't bother listening to the whole thing.

  • @georgefere8452
    @georgefere8452 Před rokem +3

    I love Mosad and Jewish people.

  • @radikowalski1553
    @radikowalski1553 Před rokem +2

    The fact that these men are even attempting to write about information that IS classified and could harm a nation is unacceptable and insane. These people should be jailed for interfering in the nation’s security.

    • @ladybug5859
      @ladybug5859 Před rokem +1

      FREEDOM of speech trumps that🗽

    • @user-bo8nb2mi
      @user-bo8nb2mi Před rokem

      @@ladybug5859 shouting fire in a crowded cinema is criminal not free speech

    • @purdy9170
      @purdy9170 Před rokem

      @@ladybug5859
      There's no absolute freedom of speech .in any country . especially where National Security is concerned .

  • @yuglesstube
    @yuglesstube Před rokem +1

    Seems they killed Arafat in the end.

  • @dirkjanwubbolts798
    @dirkjanwubbolts798 Před 4 lety +12

    I have just finished the book for the seventh time in about 4 years. It keeps fascinating me. And I learned a thing or two, three from this report. It strengthens my opinion that the Israelis, or Jews if you will, are the most humane and wise creatures on this planet. And I have read Einstein, Velikovsky and Spinoza, to name a few.

    • @ladybug5859
      @ladybug5859 Před rokem

      Perhaps true if u include a projected genocude on an innocent people because as gabor mate says-- youve never healed from your original wound, trauma

    • @ladybug5859
      @ladybug5859 Před rokem +1

      Perhaps true if u include a projected genocude on an innocent people because as gabor mate says-- youve never healed from your original wound, trauma

    • @ladybug5859
      @ladybug5859 Před rokem

      PS
      The giveaway is when the Israelis asked a Known World War II criminal to devise their security in order to keep down and to eliminate the people in whose land they now had declared their nation state. IN this way they ensured that they would perpetuate genocide, this time, not on them, but on another people. It's as clear as day.
      The Israelis and the Zionists are doomed people and they have written their obituary already. As long as there is breath in their body, they can change their obituary. IT'S up to them.

  • @ap-ig8dr
    @ap-ig8dr Před 4 lety +6

    Seems like this guy is really biased against Netanyahu and somewhat against trump also for some reason. 🤔😏

    • @srfotog
      @srfotog Před 3 lety +5

      Any intelligent person would be against Trump.

    • @leveraged6694
      @leveraged6694 Před 3 lety +1

      Trump is a sociopath. Take psych 101.

    • @AN-cy7xm
      @AN-cy7xm Před rokem

      Anyone with 3 or more brain cells is biased against Trump.

  • @elasteroidedepapel
    @elasteroidedepapel Před 2 lety +1

    35:00

  • @abhishekpatras2891
    @abhishekpatras2891 Před 3 lety +11

    God bless Mossad. God bless IDF. God bless Israel.

  • @tibebubekele8751
    @tibebubekele8751 Před rokem +1

    Israelis degree of secrecy is purely manifested on their freedom and strength amid their eternal enemis.

    • @bobross5079
      @bobross5079 Před 3 měsíci

      They will tell you that they are persecuted ,.
      But they will never tell you why

  • @richardbishop8666
    @richardbishop8666 Před 4 lety +9

    Much love for lsreal from USA

  • @lortea
    @lortea Před 5 lety +2

    pure jerk he is

    • @martalevin4829
      @martalevin4829 Před 3 lety +3

      Because they killed a terrorist who's a relative of yours?

  • @federicokspitz7879
    @federicokspitz7879 Před 4 lety +3

    Mossad and Shin Bet shields and swords of Israel 🇮🇱.

  • @rocketman48
    @rocketman48 Před 5 lety

    skorzeny was in dublin for many years,

    • @purdy9170
      @purdy9170 Před rokem

      Several ex Nazis were welcomed in lreland .The lrish Governments turned a blind eye .

  • @sayanmalik2409
    @sayanmalik2409 Před 3 lety +9

    love u israel..god bless u

  • @mariebeatricesophiepicardh8051

    Your interview as ring my 🔔, because the most important work in the Torah and godly intervention as been written by me for 15 years , my writing as been conterfeiting , so the law was desobey.
    Their way to obtain real justice with the archive of proper morale media.
    Finding the peoples who take credits for my god gift credits , it the way to set harmonies in the whole world.
    Honor your Jewishness and my inter generational heritage.
    Your peace Ambasssdrice Marie Beatrice Sophie Picard Hopkins
    Picard pico PICARER
    Pi 🕵️‍♀️ car 🚙 ring 💍 tone
    Of bless memories

  • @dipladonic
    @dipladonic Před rokem

    This is ruined by far too many adverts.

  • @grantd.conroy447
    @grantd.conroy447 Před 4 lety

    Smooth gent! Scripted show! But Will by the book. Military chain of command very tight obviously!

  • @josephadler5663
    @josephadler5663 Před rokem +1

    What an excellent book !! Good job to all the people involved with that book , I like to read and re-read certain books over and over again 👍🏽 💯🫡

  • @prakashpatel-so4bh
    @prakashpatel-so4bh Před 6 lety +23

    We all Indian LOVE
    Jewish people and Israel

    • @peterpham2473
      @peterpham2473 Před 6 lety +2

      no not all i have met indians who hate israel

    • @peterpham2473
      @peterpham2473 Před 6 lety +1

      Even though they are Hindus? Are you in India or UK?

    • @peterpham2473
      @peterpham2473 Před 6 lety

      What other countries do Indian people love?

    • @peterpham2473
      @peterpham2473 Před 6 lety +1

      You do not represent all of Indian people so just speak for yourself

    • @prakashpatel-so4bh
      @prakashpatel-so4bh Před 6 lety

      Whole world is family
      In the Indian religious book

  • @le3b
    @le3b Před rokem

    is this not terrorism?

  • @JohnSmith-xq6cv
    @JohnSmith-xq6cv Před 5 lety +1

    Skorzeny didnt kil for Mossad

    • @JohnSmith-xq6cv
      @JohnSmith-xq6cv Před 3 lety

      ROBERT DEAN mossad lies. Disinformatzia

    • @stinkeye460
      @stinkeye460 Před 3 lety

      He warned German scientist to not support Egypt obtaining a bomb in exchange for him not being tracked down by Wiesenthal. Which was a lie ha ha.

    • @JohnSmith-xq6cv
      @JohnSmith-xq6cv Před 3 lety

      @@stinkeye460 three different accounts claiming he killed for mossad, all different stories in different years. It’s a myth

    • @stinkeye460
      @stinkeye460 Před 3 lety

      @@JohnSmith-xq6cv The MOSSAD bull shitted him.

  • @GlobalPrivateTruthWarrior

    A powerful God that needs humans to hurt people who have other ideas, and critiques? Got it! Maybe the God should be called VIOLENCEYHWH

  • @SpainHighlander
    @SpainHighlander Před rokem

    I wonder how many of his 'interviewees' ..... he'll never buy that ? But let's see just how gullible he is. Each Katsa trying to outdo the other with a crazier story. Ho Hum.

  • @gups1982
    @gups1982 Před 2 lety +6

    Go Israel 🇮🇱

  • @ashwiniragupathy5978
    @ashwiniragupathy5978 Před 4 lety +9

    Long live Israel 🇮🇱
    Love from India 🇮🇳

    • @srfotog
      @srfotog Před 3 lety

      @iccabobb creed WTF?

  • @Son.of.Saturn
    @Son.of.Saturn Před 4 lety +3

    Is Bergman an especially Jewish surname?

    • @charleskristiansson1296
      @charleskristiansson1296 Před 3 lety

      I don't think so. This spelling can be found in Scandinavia. I think the names are borrowed.

    • @bjolie78
      @bjolie78 Před 3 lety

      In german it means miner

    • @noprivacyanymore
      @noprivacyanymore Před 3 lety

      @@bjolie78 der Bergmann, literally "mountain person" is one of many words that can mean miner.

    • @noprivacyanymore
      @noprivacyanymore Před 3 lety +4

      @@charleskristiansson1296 borrowed? There are plenty of Jews who got their first surnames in German speaking countries.

    • @makinen06
      @makinen06 Před 3 lety

      it's a yiddish name, a language used by some european jews. it's a mix of german and hebrew. the germans would say bergmann, for jews the name is bergman (on "n" for jewish names, 2 "n"s for germans). bergman, goldman, schwarzman ... jewish names.

  • @user-cn2fn1dr4h
    @user-cn2fn1dr4h Před 5 lety +2

    ככותרת ספרו של רונן ברגמן: "רונן ברגמן יעשה הכל"

    • @christineschmidt9846
      @christineschmidt9846 Před 4 lety

      Saaaabes que .carajo .porque noooooo hicieron caso gente que vean .shalom

  • @whatabouttheearth
    @whatabouttheearth Před 3 lety

    But the whole time Skorzeny was building The Fascist International. Living in Franco's fascist Spain

    • @danielt.3152
      @danielt.3152 Před 3 lety +1

      James Lee and a Mossad operative

    • @dmk124
      @dmk124 Před 2 lety +1

      Skorzeny was a duplicitous character. Building a Fascist international while sending names and locations of his "comrades" to Mossad hit teams.
      He had another condition Ronen doesn't mention, it was getting a promise that his book about special operations will be translated to Hebrew and published in Israel. This condition was met.

    • @TheHeavensFellen
      @TheHeavensFellen Před rokem

      @@dmk124 fascists and the israeli pre state underground were aligned and operated openly by late '1970's when menachem begin became PM of Israel.

  • @aaronrobertson8022
    @aaronrobertson8022 Před 4 lety +4

    🇮🇱

  • @edwarddypify
    @edwarddypify Před 6 lety +10

    Mr Bergman. Have you already established the REAL story of your own Mother ??

  • @TheWolfgangfritz
    @TheWolfgangfritz Před 4 lety +3

    Ronan Bergman might have made quite an achievement in investigative journalism but as a Jew he didn't help Israel's reputation. Even more people now will hate Jews. Personally I applaud Israel and Ronan's skill but it's too delicate a subject to be exposing it the way he did. A "true Patriot" would never do such a thing, yet it probably was a temptation Ronan couldn't overcome, his fame, the adulation, etc,. I equate the Mossad with the 1600 Century Japanese Ninjas, at least in their proficiency; something like this must be kept secret. The Islamic world and maybe even the rest will be even more vigilant in looking out for Mossad.

    • @MOTIVATIONBYDAR
      @MOTIVATIONBYDAR Před 4 lety +3

      The whole point is that the incident in Dubai proves Mossad can no longer operate using outdated tactics in a surveillance world. This book does nothing too hurt Israel as every single country is involved in doing the same too various degrees. If anything this was very patriotic as it shows the Israelis to what lengths Mossad was willing to go to protect Israel their homeland.

    • @josephadler5663
      @josephadler5663 Před rokem

      👆🏽

    • @TheHeavensFellen
      @TheHeavensFellen Před rokem

      He seems like a fair minded journalist from the times ive seen him elaborate on t he Vannunu affair

  • @alexdrosos9122
    @alexdrosos9122 Před 6 lety +11

    People like this weaken Israel

    • @aryehfinklestein9041
      @aryehfinklestein9041 Před 6 lety +4

      Very silly statement. Like any other country, Israel's first obligation is to defend its citizens and to ensure its security. People like you would prefer Israel to commit suicide - sorry, that won't happen. Grow up.

    • @alexdrosos9122
      @alexdrosos9122 Před 6 lety +1

      Aryeh Finklestein What are you talking about I support Israel hundred percent other than my home country the United States of America I love Israel with all my heart I think this guy is a tool I don’t know why you’re calling me names I’ve poured more of my own money into Israel than you could possibly imagine

    • @aryehfinklestein9041
      @aryehfinklestein9041 Před 6 lety +2

      Then I sincerely apologize. I read your previous statement to mean that anyone writing honestly about Mossad's activities is somehow giving the anti-Israel propagandists an advantage. So please explain what you meant by saying that the author or his book "weakens Israel".

    • @aryehfinklestein9041
      @aryehfinklestein9041 Před 6 lety

      Alex, I just watched this interview more attentively, and agree with you entirely. So again, please accept my apologies. You were right.

    • @alexdrosos9122
      @alexdrosos9122 Před 6 lety

      Aryeh Finklestein Believe me me and you are insane side 🇺🇸🇮🇱

  • @ukaszs1037
    @ukaszs1037 Před 6 lety +8

    Mr. Bergman tells lies and every time he says another story. Once he claims his mother was at least 7-year-old before WWII but in another version he claims his mother buried her father during the war having only 5 years. Also he says his mother claimed Polish people were worst than Germans Nazis during the war but she didn't know any Germans. How could she compare it if she didn't know or see any Germans? It means that she wasn't in Poland during WWII at all.

    • @jamshedshaikh4619
      @jamshedshaikh4619 Před rokem

      Zionists of all shapes and forms thrive on lies. These people have not learned anything from Auschwitz’s or holocaust. The host an American does not ask him tough questions.

  • @barriesmith3489
    @barriesmith3489 Před 6 lety +3

    What a boring program

    • @MartinAracon
      @MartinAracon Před 5 lety +1

      Why? Are you not interest of historical impressions?

  • @danamarta7803
    @danamarta7803 Před 4 lety +4

    Read Talmud. That is all you need to know about " judaism".

    • @ligiu9724
      @ligiu9724 Před 3 lety +4

      Probably you never saw a copy of Talmud in your life...

    • @ligiu9724
      @ligiu9724 Před 3 lety

      @Tal Benavraham who?

    • @stinkeye460
      @stinkeye460 Před 3 lety +1

      Stupid prick. The Talmud is a collection of commentaries on the Torah and Law. Keep worshipping your pagan god and savior.

  • @spiroskoulouberis5898
    @spiroskoulouberis5898 Před 4 lety +5

    Sick culture, evil minds.

  • @judydavis2379
    @judydavis2379 Před rokem

    this author is mediocre

  • @YutoHirata
    @YutoHirata Před 2 lety

    was right side turbo negger synth
    HISTORICAL MISBELIEFS.
    Was heavy listner of Hirata Yutos room surveillance wrote this along his cyber ops.
    kaboom gated.