A huge thank you for reviewing this product! Taking the extra step to compare them to the Kaleidos products is what makes your channel stand out for me.
I saw that cp was putting out multichrome liners so I dug out my kaleidos liners, and holy moly, they were hard to remove…my favorite is still tourmaline, which I would re buy…
So glad Colourpop is branching out into multichrome but this seems a little late to the party. Love my Moira ones. I was a die hard Colourpop girl but I have bought anything from them in ages! How cool would a true multichrome SSS collection be? Thank you for reviewing.
Moira multi chrome liners are amazing! The formula is super smooth and creamy, the multi chrome effect is potent and they last all day! The price is also so inexpensive, it was easy to buy more than one! If Colourpop isn’t careful, Moira is going to surpass them!
@@sugerless20 get all of them!! Lol depends on if you prefer dark or lighter shades but half are lighter which I prefer. 2 of the 10 are kinda just high sparkle (ones gold the others purpley), but they're all great. I don't use the dark blue to purple one much, and tend to go with the bright green most often. If I have time ill use the lighter color near my inner eye and the darker one toward the outer for each color. They are fantastic though!!
I ordered the Colourpop ones and also a couple of the Moira ones because I want to compare the formulas because the price point is similar. Can't wait to try them both out. I have been using multichrome liquid shadows and pigments as liners up until now so this is a whole new avenue for me. Excited!
I have a couple of the Moira ones and they’re pretty nice. The one critique I have in products like this is Amanda gave us a nice thick swatch, but in the waterline, it doesn’t scream multichrome.
I absolutely love the Moira ones! I grabbed the full set and found...I tend to use the lighter ones more than the darker ones, but they're almost perfectly set to use as gradients of the lighter inner eye with matching dark outer eye. And if you don't remove them cleanly you have a fantastic sparkle left behind lol
Am I crazy or did these used to be those thin sticks that snap off easily before? I love how thick they are now! I might get one of these once the Twilight collection drops 😅
Thank you for the comparison. I already have all the kaleidoscope liners and I had planned on getting all the CP but after seeing swatches and comps I will only get 2. You saved me money!
Thanks so much for these comparisons! I really appreciate your swatch completionist nature ;) You answered all my questions and helped me decide on which ones I’ll be picking up! I’m also now regretting not completing my kaleidos collection. I think I need to double back for Solaris!
I appreciate that you did the comparison swatches on the kaleidos vs CP. That was what I was curious about. I will stick to the kaleidos as CP liners tend to be super fragile for me and that is frustrating. However I am glad that these are available as it means more of these types of products give people options!
Thank you! I bought them yesterday morning without thinking twice! I do already have the Kaleidos liners, but aside from the one exact dupe I think they make a great collection all together!! Cool cool cool.
The minute I received the email that these were in stock I jumped on them! Duo chrome are my favorite and I’ve purchased them from Sugar Drizzle and Moira too…can’t wait to try them! Merry Christmas and Happy New Year to me!!!xoxoxo
Happy new year. Thanks for the comparisons. Think I'm good with the Kaleidos and Moira multichrome liners. These Colorpop ones seem to need going over a couple of times to see the shift. The black base (apart from the orange one) is very apparent, so they appear a little...dull 😕
I enjoy the kaleidos liners but they are super fragile and a little pricey but my biggest complaint is that the containers are too similar. I will be ordering these. Thanks!
This was so helpful! I have also been looking for a replacement for the hocus pocus liners from a few years ago, and some of these look close in your video 🤞 I’ll be sure to use your code when I pick them up. Thank you!!
I ordered them, but I haven't seen anyone try them in the waterline!!! That's where I use a gel liner most. Very rarely am I using it on the lid or under the lower lash line.
I'll be able to use them in a tutorial soon! That's how I like to use the BFF creme gel liners too as you often see in my eye looks, but unfortunately I'm unexpectedly traveling right now so I had to film + edit this one on the go... not my fave way to work but I still wanted to get some swatches + comps out 😅
muuchas gracias por la reseña..., lamentablemente Kaleidos ya no despacha a donde vivo, así que estos delineadores son una buena opción y bastante similares.
Yes all day for these! Colourpop makes the only waterline liners that work! Yes, plus love that they are made in the USA. So tired of the toxic things found in makeup coming out of the PRC!
This is NOT meant as a criticism, just a question/suggestion. Would the swatches be easier to apply and gentler on the skin and liner going side to side the long way rather than up and down? (you are the queen of swatching, so you may very well know best! 😊) These are so cool! I’m excited to own them! Plus, they are all vegan! 😁 Yay!
The removal is really the only thing that’s rough on my skin 😅 because these liners are quite soft, longer swatch strokes are more likely to break them so shorter motions keep them in tact and give us a nice big juicy swatch to be able to really see the colors!
@@MakeupJustForFun See, I KNEW you were the swatch queen! Should have kept my big mouth shut! 😂 It just looked so uncomfortable to me…but I’m glad that was just a me problem! And of course, liners don’t get used that way normally, and it was just so we could best see the colors, and they served that purpose beautifully! 😊 I’m excited at how good most of these look even next to the Kalaidos liners. Those are out of my budget, but these I can swing! 😁 Thank you for all of your hard work covering Colourpop. I use your videos to make purchasing decisions all the time! (and your code whenever there isn’t a sale!) ❤️
Great comparison! Thabk you. My eyes hurt from some of the dried liners, imagine to have to press that much in a sensitive part. Not your fault of course
Wow, I had really high hopes for these liners, since the regular creme gel liners for my go to for any liner, I have almost every color, except some of the newer shades, but I was really bummed when I saw that most of the liners didn't have a flip or much of a flip to them, and how easily they wiped off. I think I'll wait to buy them, until I see comparisons with the Moira multi chrome liners.
Have you done a wear test on these? Multichrome pigments are known for fading in most formulas, especially their shine. Do these stay looking good after a few hours?
Is it just me or did she say she removed the kaleidos before colourpop but it was the other way around? Kaleidos quality is way better than colourpop, no way kaleidos wiped off before colourpop.
A huge thank you for reviewing this product! Taking the extra step to compare them to the Kaleidos products is what makes your channel stand out for me.
Hi. The dry wipe wipes the Colorpop ones off well before the Kaleidos ones from your arm. :)
Yes. I came on here to say the same thing!
I saw that cp was putting out multichrome liners so I dug out my kaleidos liners, and holy moly, they were hard to remove…my favorite is still tourmaline, which I would re buy…
It’s the opposite i guess
So glad Colourpop is branching out into multichrome but this seems a little late to the party. Love my Moira ones. I was a die hard Colourpop girl but I have bought anything from them in ages! How cool would a true multichrome SSS collection be? Thank you for reviewing.
What moira multichrome shades are your favourite? I'm thinking of getting some. Atlas is must on my list.
Moira multi chrome liners are amazing! The formula is super smooth and creamy, the multi chrome effect is potent and they last all day! The price is also so inexpensive, it was easy to buy more than one! If Colourpop isn’t careful, Moira is going to surpass them!
@@kam0406 Price is a major reason why I want to try Moira first. What shades would you recommend? When are their best sales?
@@sugerless20 get all of them!! Lol depends on if you prefer dark or lighter shades but half are lighter which I prefer. 2 of the 10 are kinda just high sparkle (ones gold the others purpley), but they're all great. I don't use the dark blue to purple one much, and tend to go with the bright green most often. If I have time ill use the lighter color near my inner eye and the darker one toward the outer for each color. They are fantastic though!!
I ordered the Colourpop ones and also a couple of the Moira ones because I want to compare the formulas because the price point is similar. Can't wait to try them both out. I have been using multichrome liquid shadows and pigments as liners up until now so this is a whole new avenue for me. Excited!
I have a couple of the Moira ones and they’re pretty nice. The one critique I have in products like this is Amanda gave us a nice thick swatch, but in the waterline, it doesn’t scream multichrome.
I absolutely love the Moira ones! I grabbed the full set and found...I tend to use the lighter ones more than the darker ones, but they're almost perfectly set to use as gradients of the lighter inner eye with matching dark outer eye. And if you don't remove them cleanly you have a fantastic sparkle left behind lol
@@Lawnmidget I've been very impressed with the Moira brand products that I've purchased so far. Great Brand!
How did you like them?
I LOVE the way you filmed this video!! 😍 Swatching from this vantage point and with different lighting was really helpful and lovely to watch 💯
The live swatches are so very helpful as was the wiping off test. Thanks for taking so much time to test them!
Thank you for being a swatch completionist!!❤
I was waiting for your review and swatches before buying anything. This is perfect!
Glad I could help!
Am I crazy or did these used to be those thin sticks that snap off easily before? I love how thick they are now! I might get one of these once the Twilight collection drops 😅
Thank you for the comparison. I already have all the kaleidoscope liners and I had planned on getting all the CP but after seeing swatches and comps I will only get 2. You saved me money!
I was wondering about these because online photos don't do them justice. Great review, thanks!!
Thanks so much for these comparisons! I really appreciate your swatch completionist nature ;) You answered all my questions and helped me decide on which ones I’ll be picking up! I’m also now regretting not completing my kaleidos collection. I think I need to double back for Solaris!
moira has some pretty nice multichrome liners for like $6 which is crazy. thanks for the comparisons!
I appreciate that you did the comparison swatches on the kaleidos vs CP. That was what I was curious about. I will stick to the kaleidos as CP liners tend to be super fragile for me and that is frustrating. However I am glad that these are available as it means more of these types of products give people options!
Good morning Amanda! Happy Friday! I've been patiently waiting to hear hour thoughts before purchasing. I hope you have an amazing day😊🩷🩵💜🤎💚💛🧡
Thanks Amanda! Just picked up 4 during 30% off CPop sale. Just love the brand. Ventura Blvd my fave
Lovely swatching thank you so much!
I wish they did a brown with yellow shift
Or a black and teal or turquoise
Happy New Year!!! ❤️ Thank you Amanda for the very thorough review and swatches. I am definitely going to purchase these based on your review.
Happy new year!!
Thank you! I bought them yesterday morning without thinking twice! I do already have the Kaleidos liners, but aside from the one exact dupe I think they make a great collection all together!! Cool cool cool.
The minute I received the email that these were in stock I jumped on them! Duo chrome are my favorite and I’ve purchased them from Sugar Drizzle and Moira too…can’t wait to try them! Merry Christmas and Happy New Year to me!!!xoxoxo
Happy new year. Thanks for the comparisons. Think I'm good with the Kaleidos and Moira multichrome liners. These Colorpop ones seem to need going over a couple of times to see the shift. The black base (apart from the orange one) is very apparent, so they appear a little...dull 😕
Oh baby, this is such an exciting release!! 😻💙✨💜✨
I enjoy the kaleidos liners but they are super fragile and a little pricey but my biggest complaint is that the containers are too similar. I will be ordering these. Thanks!
This was so helpful! I have also been looking for a replacement for the hocus pocus liners from a few years ago, and some of these look close in your video 🤞 I’ll be sure to use your code when I pick them up. Thank you!!
That 1st Hocus Pocus release that broke colourpop's website😂 but it was legit
I ordered them, but I haven't seen anyone try them in the waterline!!! That's where I use a gel liner most. Very rarely am I using it on the lid or under the lower lash line.
I'll be able to use them in a tutorial soon! That's how I like to use the BFF creme gel liners too as you often see in my eye looks, but unfortunately I'm unexpectedly traveling right now so I had to film + edit this one on the go... not my fave way to work but I still wanted to get some swatches + comps out 😅
@MakeupJustForFun that makes sense!!!! It is very appreciated that you did this for everyone!!
Theresa is Dead has you covered ❤🎉
muuchas gracias por la reseña..., lamentablemente Kaleidos ya no despacha a donde vivo, así que estos delineadores son una buena opción y bastante similares.
I like the green and peach one. I love their regular liners so I have high hopes for these.
I’m excited to try these. I love anything Colourpop!!
So good to see the comparison!!
Looking forward to seeing what you do with these. Thank you for sharing 💜
Thank you for doing this thorough review. Your swatches always rock!
I got 3 of the colors. Excited to try them out
🌸🌸🌸Thank you Amanda for another great video!!🌸🌸🌸
I ordered these yesterday as soon as they dropped. Can't wait to get them!!
I just picked up a few from ulta! I can’t wait to try them out!
Yes all day for these! Colourpop makes the only waterline liners that work! Yes, plus love that they are made in the USA. So tired of the toxic things found in makeup coming out of the PRC!
omg i was just about to buy the colourpop ones and this vid popped up in my recommended
Thank you for the comparisson. It's really useful.
Those are beautiful I will definitely buy some of them❤
This is NOT meant as a criticism, just a question/suggestion. Would the swatches be easier to apply and gentler on the skin and liner going side to side the long way rather than up and down? (you are the queen of swatching, so you may very well know best! 😊)
These are so cool! I’m excited to own them! Plus, they are all vegan! 😁 Yay!
The removal is really the only thing that’s rough on my skin 😅 because these liners are quite soft, longer swatch strokes are more likely to break them so shorter motions keep them in tact and give us a nice big juicy swatch to be able to really see the colors!
@@MakeupJustForFun See, I KNEW you were the swatch queen! Should have kept my big mouth shut! 😂 It just looked so uncomfortable to me…but I’m glad that was just a me problem! And of course, liners don’t get used that way normally, and it was just so we could best see the colors, and they served that purpose beautifully! 😊 I’m excited at how good most of these look even next to the Kalaidos liners. Those are out of my budget, but these I can swing! 😁 Thank you for all of your hard work covering Colourpop. I use your videos to make purchasing decisions all the time! (and your code whenever there isn’t a sale!) ❤️
Would love to see what your thoughts are with Moira and Nikkia Joy Cosmetics' multichrome products ❤
You sold me. 😅😮💨 I will definitely be picking them up. 😍
Moira Beauty also has a set of multi-chrome liners and is also worth a comparison video. 😃
Me: I NEED THESE!
Also me. Never wears eyeliner. 😂
Right? It is lovely to look at and know you still have them to swatch on your hand IF AND WHEN you get around to it lol
Happy new year!
Great comparison! Thabk you. My eyes hurt from some of the dried liners, imagine to have to press that much in a sensitive part. Not your fault of course
Are you going to review their new Golden Hour palette?
Great video as always! And you are inspiring me to layer my multichrome powder shadows over my gel liners to get the same effect! ;)
Wow, I had really high hopes for these liners, since the regular creme gel liners for my go to for any liner, I have almost every color, except some of the newer shades, but I was really bummed when I saw that most of the liners didn't have a flip or much of a flip to them, and how easily they wiped off. I think I'll wait to buy them, until I see comparisons with the Moira multi chrome liners.
Colourpop came off first! Almost completely gone with one dry wipe!!!
I thought it was the other one?
Thanks for sharing. I just wanted 3 of them and yeah, your code didn’t work for 3 of different colors. ☹️ But thanks for sharing the swatches.
I have the kaleidos so was really only interested possibly in power trip. Your video did not help dissuade me from that pull to purchase. 😂
Have you done a wear test on these? Multichrome pigments are known for fading in most formulas, especially their shine. Do these stay looking good after a few hours?
Not yet but I’ll use them in a tutorial next week!
Moira has multi chrome liners (I think)
do the colourpop creme gel liners last all day in the waterline?
Wait. From the thumbnail I thought the comparison liners were the Moira ones.
Hi Amanda, Have you tried these in lower waterline yet, and is the shift visible?
You can see one of these in action in this video czcams.com/video/-0nlY9Z55mo/video.html 🤩
could you theoretically use this as a shadow stick of sorts instead of just liner?
I don't see how anyone can stop us!
I'm curious to how the Colourpop stand up against the Moira liners since they are in the same/closer in price and demographic
I don't have any of those so I don't have any insight on that 😅
@@MakeupJustForFun makes sense. There really is no reason to get duplicate shades of the same shift in liners once you have a set.
I tried to use your code, but it kept telling me it was invalid 😮 Other codes worked, so I don't know what happened.
I'm trying to use your code but it doesn't work! 😢
I know 😭 I’m trying to get it fixed! Not a great thing to have happen on a weekend
Is it just me or did she say she removed the kaleidos before colourpop but it was the other way around? Kaleidos quality is way better than colourpop, no way kaleidos wiped off before colourpop.
Is it just me or are elf and ColourPop behind in the game and actually crying Moira a lot?
These are gorgeous. It hurts to see you waste so much of the product doing the swatch 😢.
Thousands of people get to see the swatches so it’s definitely not a waste!
Kaleidos was horrible. I was so disappointed in them.